Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Project On Veganism - by Aryan Raj - From KJ Somaiya Institute of Management
Project On Veganism - by Aryan Raj - From KJ Somaiya Institute of Management
Roll No – 17030120067
By – Aryan Raj
Content
1. What is Veganism
2. Why Does Veganism Interest Me?
What is Veganism?
"Veganism is a philosophy and way of living which seeks to exclude—as far as is possible
and practicable—all forms of exploitation of, and cruelty to, animals for food, clothing or any
other purpose; and by extension, promotes the development and use of animal-free
alternatives for the benefit of animals, humans and the environment. In dietary terms it
denotes the practice of dispensing with all products derived wholly or partly from animals."
Most people get confused and believe that Veganism is Synonymous to Vegetarianism. But
that is not true. A Vegetarian seeks to avoid consumption of Animal Meat and quite often
also of eggs. While Vegans, tries their level best to not consume any animal product. Meat,
dairy, poultry, honey and fish. Not just that, a Vegan also tries to avoid any cosmetics,
clothing material or any item that has either been produced using any animal’s body parts,
for example Leather Items or if it has been tested been on animals. A Vegan chooses to not
support Animal Suffering in any form. So, they also avoid visiting Zoos, Sea World or
Circuses that deploy animals for entertainment.
A. The Sheer Scale – As per estimates done by Population Reference Bureau, since the
inception of human species, approximately 107 billion humans have ever lived on our
planet. While we kill 70 Billion land animals and more than 1 Trillion Marine animals
every year. The sheer scale! We kill 10 times more animals every year then the number
humans ever born on this planet. And sometimes it gets difficult for people to get their head
around these numbers involving Billions and Trillions.
So, just for reference:
1 Billion Seconds = 31.69 Years.
1 Trillion Seconds = 31,709 Years.
B. A Practical Experiment – So let’s take for e.g. Human Trafficking. In this experiment all
one has to do, is go on the street and ask around hundred random people about their
thoughts on Human Trafficking. There are very high chances that all hundreds of them
would say that human trafficking is a moral abomination and government should take strict
actions people who indulge in it. No one would justify it by saying, “Oh! But there is a huge
economy for it and people’s livelihood depends on it.” Point being that at large, there is
consensus amongst majority of people that huma trafficking is wrong.
But now if you ask the same people about exploitation of nonhuman animals, and whether
its Moral or Immoral, you are not going to get the same kind of consensus.
. I don’t intend here to give a base moral principle or an ethical foundation and tell you to
build upon it as to why you should care about animals. Instead I make an argument from
consistency. I take things that I think a rational human would already believe in, just see the
logic that you use to justify those beliefs also that you apply to non-human animals.
Moreover, majority of the people are already animal lovers and care about animals. Most of
us get enraged when we see people abusing stray dogs. We already have that innate
compassion in us for animals. But as soon as a species change from dogs to chickens or
goats, we not only do not intervene or ignore, in fact funnel into the industries that are
causing this to happen. This is a uniquely economical moral emergency.
Racism for example doesn’t go away when we stop paying for it but exploitation of animal
name of food, clothing, and entertainment would vanish the moment we stop funding it.
# Animal Experimentation
Experimentation on animals – If animals are so like us that we can substitute using them
instead of humans, then surely, they have the very same attributes and that means they also
deserve to be protected from harm.
We are a family. Together on one planet. And of the 5 million species on that planet, only
one has the power to determine what level of suffering is acceptable for all other sentient
beings to endure, whether its eating less meat, raising voices for welfare of selective species
(dogs, cats) or speaking up for every voiceless being. It’s the choice that every human being
has to make.
2. The semen is collected and artificially inserted in the vagina of the cow. Hands and sticks
are inserted inside cows’ private parts to semen of the bull inside.
I am not exaggerating. This is how cows are always kept pregnant. After-all Milk has to be
obtained from the cows every day. NOW, injecting hands or anything in private parts of any
animal, for me this is bestiality and Animal cruelty. People use euphemism like Artificial
Insemination to make it sound better. I don’t buy it.
Now when the calf is born, the lifespan depends on the gender of that calf. A male won't give
milk.
3. So he would be sold off after few weeks of his birth for veal. In India, farmers also practice
'Khalbacha' (I have explained it in the last point).
And If the calf born is a female, she would subsequently enter the same cycle as her mother.
That is constantly being impregnated and used for milk.
4. Due to this constant cycle of Impregnation, a cow/buffalo whose lifespan is around 20 yrs.
cannot live beyond 8-10 yrs. Let me explain this in detail in the next point. And
simultaneously I will also address another important question.
5. The million Dollar question, which everyone asks but no one has answer to:
"Despite cows being revered and worshipped here in India, why is India still one of
world's top producers of beef?"
The answer is - Because 80% of dairy cattle in India, when their milk production efficiency
decreases, and they aren't any more profitable, they are sold off to slaughter houses.
If you actually think over it, Beef (and Leather) are nothing but a by-product of the Dairy
Industry.
6. So a cow's milk production efficiency inevitably goes down after 4-5 cycles of pregnancy.
Which is by the age of 8-10 yrs. Then the cow isn't profitable anymore. Her maintenance
costs subsequently exceed the profits one is making from selling her milk.
7. If you were to ask me life dairy cattle is more horrible than those animals who are raised
solely for meat (broiler chickens for example). When an animal is raised for meat, they are
kept in a shelter and killed when they attain a certain age.
But here in dairy industry, you are emotionally and physically exploited to the fullest extent,
then sent to slaughter house. Sounds more horrible to me.
8. Now i Will explain KHALBACCHA- So In order to continue the milking process & keep
mother lactating, a KHALBACCHA-a makeshift calf-is placed next to her. The tail & the head
of the young calf is dismantled from the carcass and is placed at the ends of the stick, while
the remains of calf are sold in market as veal. Now you might say these don't happen often.
But that's true. These do often. I have visited various villages, where I saw many dairy
farmers indulging in KHALBACCHA.
9. In almost every case Cows are kept tied, their calves are kept tied away from them. Many
times, cows’ mouth is blocked with a bottle or mug or small bucket so that they drink their
mother’s milk.
So, that was some information on Dairy Industry. But as I said, towards the end I will iterate
the choices that we have the dominant species of this planet. Our Tastebuds v/s subjugation
of Non-human animal’s life to eternal suffering.
1. - GREENHOUSE GASES -
2. -WATER-
3. -LAND-
4. -WASTE GENERATION-
*This is the equivalent of over 6.611 million lbs. per minute. (This does
not include any animal raised outside of USDA Jurisdiction, backyards or
fish raised for aquaculture)
5. -OCEAN-
6. -FORESTS-
7. -HUMANITY-
Animal Agriculture also has negative impact on Humans.
So, let’s say, that if the arguments surrounding ‘ethical treatment of animals’ doesn’t
convince you. The environmental argument against Animal agriculture should force
any rational human being to contemplate over their food choices and consider
veganism, as it has the anthropological angle to it as well. Can we keep exploiting
our planet like this?
The choice that one here has to make is between – Taste buds/sensory pleasures
v/s Sustainability of our planet and our species.
2. Processed Vegan Food – This category would include all those foods that are being sold
as alternative to Non-Vegan Foods. For e.g., Entire plant-based Milk range which are an
alternative to Cow’s milk, the various mock meats whose taste and texture resemble the
original meat but are made from plant-based sources.
In this essay, I am solely going to discuss and do analysis about the future of those Vegan
Food, which come under the category of “Processed Vegan Food”
In the year 2018, the global vegan food market size was valued at $12.69 Billion and is
expected to grow at a CAGR of 9.6% from 2019 to 2025. One the reasons for the rise in
popularity of vegan alternatives to its meat and dairy counterparts can be attributed to
health benefits that former brings in. North America, Europe, and Asia Pacific, have
witnessed a tremendous surge in percentage of vegan population.
Growing awareness about animal health and animal cruelty in the food industry has
brought in a conscious shift in many people and has been encouraging them to switch to
plant-based food products. Between, 2012 to 2017, the demand for meat-free food grew
by 987%.
Over the past few years, one in three American consumers has either stopped or
reduced meat consumption. Many European countries, USA and Australia have seen a
constant increase in demand for Vegan food over the years.
Rising awareness about various health benefits offered by plant-based food products
has increased the consumer base of this industry. Plant-based products help maintain
blood pressure levels and lower the risk of heart disease, stroke, prostate cancer,
colorectal cancer, cholesterol, and premature death.
Dairy alternatives gained immense popularity in 2018. Since around 65% of the world
population is lactose intolerant and it has been a key factor in increasing the demand for
natives. Hence availability of dairy-based cheese, yoghurt, ice cream and other snacks has
attracted many non-vegetarians and why didn’t the consumer base for this. Plant-based
cheese accounted for the largest share in the dairy alternatives and the fact that The cases
of lactose intolerance is constantly rising, the demand for these dairy alternatives are only
expected to rise.
Offline segment which includes convenience stores, speciality stores, hypermarkets and
supermarkets what is the largest distribution channel and it is projected that they will
continue to maintain their dominance. Moreover, the number of supermarkets and
hypermarkets have only been growing I will continue to grow, and will continue to have an
overall positive effect on the product sales.
That said the online channel is also expected to penetrate the market with rising usage of
internet and smartphone devices. Currently 48% of US consumers buy some or the other
groceries through online platforms and this number will only go up in the future. So in the
future both online platforms and off-line platforms we’ll see a rise in demand for plant-based
products and will propel the segment growth
4. A Convincing Idea
Their products manage to provide its customers a similar experience as that of its
Non-Vegan alternative,
Weakness
1. Health concern –
At the end of the day majority of the products are processed foods. And certainly, there are
negative effects on health associated with processed foods.
3. Pricing –
We also cannot deny that the pricing of such an on the Vegan products is generally more In
comparison, subsidy being one of the reasons. A dairy farmer would get a lot of subsidy
while farmer growing almonds wouldn’t get any, so it is inevitable that the prices of dairy
products be cheaper compared to other plant-based milk products.
4. Supply chain infrastructure -
The production line and supply chain of the organisations indulging in Vegan food business
is not very robust and a lot of work needs to be done here in order to minimise unnecessary
costs that occur because of not having proper supply chains in place.
Opportunities:
Threats:
The Hindu Scriptures and epics, for example the Bhagavad-Gita, Ramayana and
Mahabharat advocate for an ethical treatment of animals at several instances and
how it helps in accumulation of good karma. While vegetarianism and ethical
treatment of animals are the core principles of Jainism and Buddhism. Even as we
come forward great philosophers like Sri Adi Shankaracharya who travelled
extensively across Bharat spreading the message of Advaita Vedanta also spread
the message of vegetarianism to everyone he met. So basically, the idea of
vegetarian has always been a part of India.
But we will look at opinions off two of the tallest personalities of the contemporary
India who undeniably have had paralleled influence on India. The leaders are
Mahatma Gandhi and Rabindranath Tagore.
Mahatma Gandhi -
Is Mahatma Gandhi, a man of action, who won the world wise message of India that
is nonviolence, send it within his body and spirit. He believed in being the change
you wish to see in the world one such Benevolent A change was his who to never
consume meat, milk or milk products.
Gandhis were Vaishnavite and hence followed vegetarianism. But MK Gandhi in his
childhood days came under influence of a notorious friend and started consuming
meat in order to get strong, but he soon gave up on that as his conscious didn’t allow
him to continue eating meat.
Gandhi followed vegetarianism even when he was in England even though he faced
lot of inconveniences, people now, well-wishers reason with him to eat meat but
None could shake his pill of not consuming meat.
You can’t read various books on definition of vegetarianism, and all the writers that
he read about had exactly arrived at the country that bans primacy over lower
animals doesn’t mean that farmers should pray upon later and that the higher should
the lower and that there should be a mutual aid between the two as between man
and man.
One of the definitions that he read vegetarianism suggested abstention wrong all
animal products, discovering eggs and women alike. Also keep across some
literature from Calcutta, describing the torches with cows and buffaloes are
subjected by them was. And this had a go find effect on him. Then at Tolstoy farm in
1912, in a discussion about me with Mr Kallenbach who said to Gandhi “we
constantly talk about harmful effects of milk. Why then do we not give it up? It is
certainly not necessary.” Gandhi warmly welcome recommendation and took a
pledge of giving of dairy products then and there.
Once he was under treatment by Dr Jivraj Mehta and Mr Gokhale, and hot pressed
in very hard to consume to which Gandhi replied, ‘I am willing to eat on all points
except the one about which I beg you do not replace me. I will not take milk, milk
products or meat. If not taking these things should mean my death, I feel I’d rather
face it.’ Subsequently he was given a fat less diet which restored his health.
There is another instance when Mahatma Gandhi was at Matheran, under care of Dr
Dalal. The doctor said, ‘I cannot rebuild your body unless you take milk. If in addition
you take iron and organic injections, I would guarantee fully to renovate your
Constitution.’ To which Gandhi replied, ‘you Can you give me injections buttermilk is
a different question, I have a bow against it.’
However, to combat against the Rowlatt act. It was necessary for Gandhi to rebuild
himself and fight at his full capacity. Since Gandhi was only aware of cows and
buffalo’s ill-treatment, after being pressurised by various doctors he decided to take
goat’s milk. After taking this decision, Gandhi said, ‘I was I fully conscious when I
started taking mother Goldsmith, that the spirit of my who was destroyed.
Consequently, one of the greatest experiments in my life came to a stop.’
So even though Gandhi took a step back on his vow, He was fully conscious of this
and in spirit he maintained his purity which is clearly deflected in his symbolism of
nonviolence. And this inspired millions of people around the world at a time of great
violence and still influences many today.
Rabindranath Tagore -
In sad yet gentle tones, Rabindranath Tagore writes about the morality of consuming
animals. In his letter to his niece Indira Devi come on issues us just off the
humanness of his genius. Clearly possessed a very high degree of empathy for the
nonhuman animals. He makes a conscious choice of going vegetarian. He writes in
his own words in his works – glimpses of Bengal
“As I was sitting at the window of the boat, looking out on the river, I saw, all of a
sudden, and old looking bird making its way through the water to the opposite bank,
followed by a great commotion. I found it was a domestic phone which had managed
to escape impending doom in the galley by jumping overboard and I was trying
frantically to sweep the cross. It had almost gained the bank when the clutches of its
relentless pursuit were closed on it, and it was brought back in triumph, Gripped by
the neck. I told the cook I would not have any meat for dinner.
I really must give up animal food. We managed to swallow flesh only because we do
not think of the cruel and sinful thing we do. There are many crimes which are
creation of man himself, the wrongful loss of which is down to their divergence from
habit, custom, tradition. But cruelty is not one of these. It is a fundamental Singh, and
admits of no argument or nice distinctions. If only we do not allow our heart to grow
callous, its protest against 20 is always clearly heard, and yet we go on perpetrating
cruelties easily, Murali, all of us in fact, anyone who does not join in is dubbed a
crank.
How artificial is our apprehension of sin! I feel that highest commandment is that of
sympathy for all sent in beings. Love is the foundation of all religions. The day I read
in one of English papers that £50,000 of animal carcasses had been sent to some
Army station in Africa but the meat being found to have gone bad on arrival, the
consignment was returned and eventually auctioned off a few pounds at Portsmouth.
What is shocking waste of life! What a callousness to its true worth! How many living
creatures are sacrificed only to Grace dishes at a dinner party, a large proportion of
which will leave the table untouched!
So as long as we are unconscious of our cruelty we may not be to blame. But if, our
pity is aroused, we persist in throttling our feelings simply in order to join others in
their praying upon life, we insult all that is good in us. I have decided to try a
vegetarian diet.”
He wrote this on 28th March 1894. The book glimpses of Bengal is a collection of
letters and the above is one of them which hero to his Niece.
So, we explode in detail opinions of two of the most tallest figures of our country over
the topic of medical treatment of animals and by humans should make conscious
efforts of switching to vegetarian/Vegan lifestyle
To Vegan Brands-
My suggestion to the Vegan brands would be to keep talking about these uncomfortable
facts with respect to animal treatment in factory farms and slaughterhouses or beat the
negative environmental facts of animal agriculture, in a way that is very impactful.
There are many consumers who just eat the animal products for its taste, so These vegan
brands should aggressively tap these consumers, and spread awareness among them that
an alternative to meet is available which would tease as well exactly like it but is made in a
much more ethical and environment friendly manner. Pitching in front of the big corporate
giants in order for them to invest in Vegan brands as a part of their CSR should be another
strategy that should be worked upon and basically so that we can brands and compete with
others in a free market.
References
For all the stats regarding Environmental Destruction caused by Animal Agriculture -
https://www.cowspiracy.com/facts
Rabindranath Tagore -
https://thebengalivegan.wordpress.com/2017/10/15/vegetarianrabindranath/
SWOT - chrome-
extension://ohfgljdgelakfkefopgklcohadegdpjf/https://ruonanmandyzhao.files.wordpress.com/
2020/04/swot-analysis_beyond-meat_ruonan-zhao-1.pdf