Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Flemish Dutch: 1. Lieke: Dagget Wet (Axl Peleman)
Flemish Dutch: 1. Lieke: Dagget Wet (Axl Peleman)
Language Workshop
RCLT, La Trobe University, Friday 29 May 2009
Rik De Busser
[email protected]
–1–
Language Workshop – Flemish-Dutch
The velars fricatives and the rhotic are usually problematic for foreigners trying to
learn Dutch:
2/47
Rik De Busser, RCLT, 29 May 2009
Syllable-initally
Syllable-finally
3/47
Language Workshop – Flemish-Dutch
The correspondences between vowels in Standard Dutch and in the dialects, though
not isomorphic, are usually quite systematic.
Consonant inventories do not normally vary too much between dialects and the
standard language.
3.1. Text
Jos: A Marie, gûje môrrege. Hoe goaget ermee?
ʔa maˈriː | ˌɣʏjəˈmørəgə || huːˈgɐ(ə)gətərmeː
‘OK, bye.’
3.2. Vocabulary:
gûje môrrege: good morning
hoe goaget ermee: how are you doing (< hoe goa-g-t er-mee ‘how go-LIG-it
LPRO-with)
4/47
Rik De Busser, RCLT, 29 May 2009
3.3. Grammar
Singular Plural
Nom Acc Obl Nom Acc Obl
Free Bound
1 ik, ikke k- mê, me mê welle, we os os
2 gê, ge g- ê ê gelle, ge elle elle
3M hê (hêj-) hem, em hem
3F
3N
zê, ze
et
(zêj-)
t-
ze
et
hoar
―
} zelle, ze ze hun
5/47
Language Workshop – Flemish-Dutch
Marie: Goed hoor, met mij gaat alles goed. En met jou?
4. Introduction
4.1. Geography
The Dutch language is spoken by around 20 million people in the Netherlands and
Flanders, the northern part of Belgium (see Map 2). There are also Dutch-speaking
populations in the ABC Islands, Suriname and Indonesia (all former Dutch colonies)
and in the northern part of French Flanders. Afrikaans is a 17th-century offspring of
Dutch.
6/47
Rik De Busser, RCLT, 29 May 2009
Map 1 – Province of Antwerp (l.) and the Arrondissements of Turnhout (tr.) and Antwerp (br.)
7/47
Language Workshop – Flemish-Dutch
Today, political and linguistic boundaries are fixed (by political agreement) and more
or less coincide. This situation came into existence only recently (the language
boundary in Belgium was fixed in 1932). In the past, both the Dutch language area
and the boundaries of the Low Countries have changed considerably. In general, I’d
dare to say that both political and linguistic boundaries have somewhat contracted
8/47
Rik De Busser, RCLT, 29 May 2009
9/47
Language Workshop – Flemish-Dutch
‘Nederlands’ / ‘Netherlandish’
From neder ‘low-lying’ and land ‘country’, originally used for the country that was
lying below the Rhine.
This part of Belgica, which belongs to the Catholic King, is generally called
Nederland, because it stretches itself low and empty to the wild Sea. By almost
the entire Christian world, it is also called Flanders, taking a part for the
whole.
Kiliaan (1612)
Later it referred to a number of political entities, all of which included parts of the
present-day Low Countries.
The term was first used to refer to the language in the Low Countries in 1482 and has
remained into use till the present day. However, it had to compete with different other
terms and only gained the upper hand around the end of the 19th century. It is
presently the generally accepted term to refer to the Dutch language, in both the
Netherlands and Belgium.
‘Dietsch’ / ‘Dutch’
In much of the Middle Ages, Dutch dialects were often referred to as Dietsch or
Duutsch (cognate the present-day term Deutsch ‘German’).
Willem, die Madocke maecte, Willem, who created Madocke,
Daer hi dicken omme waecte, Could not sleep because
Hem vernoyde so haerde it annoyed him so much
Dat die avonture van Reynaerde that the adventures of Reynaert
In dietsche was onvolmaket bleven had remained unfinished in Dutch
Van den Vos Reynaerde, 13th century, edition de Keyser & van Elsander (1984)
Willem, the writer who had also written the Madocke, now disappeared, was unhappy
because the story of the fox Reynaert had not yet been translated from the French
original, Le Roman de Renard.
10/47
Rik De Busser, RCLT, 29 May 2009
The term Dietsch, which now funnily enough only survives in English and not in
Dutch, was used regularly at least since the 13th century and goes back to Old-Dutch
þiet ‘people, crowd’ (> Middle Dutch diet) and means ‘the language of the people’.
This in turn is related to the proto-Germanic adjective *peudiska- ‘of the people’ (<
*peuda- ‘people’ + *-iska ‘ADJR’).
‘Hollands’ / ‘Hollandish’
Originally referring to the County Holland (see Map 3) and later to the Province of
Holland (Map 2). Probably from Holtlant ‘the land were wood was copious’ (<holt
‘wood’ and lant ‘land’; certainly pre-12th century.
‘Vlaams’ / ‘Flemish’
Adjective of Vlaanderen ‘Flanders’. First attested in 1080 as Old Dutch flamisk, from
flamo (n.) ‘Flemish’ and -isk ‘adjectivizer’. Probably from flandr- ‘inundated area’.
The name ‘Flemish’ has been used to refer to the Dutch spoken in Flanders since at
least the 13th century.
It can now both refer to the Dutch standard language and the collection of Dutch
dialects spoken in Flanders. The term gained popularity during the Flemish
Movement, which in the young Kingdom of Belgium fought for the official
acceptance of Dutch as an official language.
However, although the Standard Dutch as it is spoken in Flanders and Standard Dutch
as it is spoken in the Netherlands are mutually understandable, there are some marked
differences.
11/47
Language Workshop – Flemish-Dutch
It is actually more accurate to say that much dialectal diversity has been – and is
being lost – due to a standardization process that has been going on for centuries but
12/47
Rik De Busser, RCLT, 29 May 2009
gained momentum from the 17th century on, at which time is spread from Holland to
the rest of the Dutch language area.
This is mirrored today in the phonological distance of the different dialects in the
Dutch language area to Standard Dutch.
Although neither Belgian nor Dutch people think of it like that, many Dutch dialects
are presently endangered.
1. selection of a dialect
2. codification of grammatical and lexical preferences
3. extension of the supra-regional variants to functional areas that were formerly
the domain of dialects
4. general acceptance
13/47
Language Workshop – Flemish-Dutch
The first phase of standardization was already present since the Middle Ages.
Codification of grammar and spelling gained momentum in the 17th century in the
Netherlands, but only since the end of the 19th century in Flanders.
At the moment, the official standard for the Dutch spoken in Belgium and the
Netherlands is prescribed by the Dutch Language Union (Nederlandse Taalunie).
However, there are some (phonetic, lexical and grammatical) variations between the
Dutch standard in the Netherlands and that in Flanders.
Standard Dutch
Hoe gaat het met je? Wat ben je van plan deze namiddag te doen?
Dialect (Kempen)
Hoe goatet ermê? Wa zen ê planne veu dieëze noamiddag?
5.1. Text
Jos: Ha Lewie, ik zen de Jos.
haː ləˈwiː | ɪk zɛn də ʒɔs
‘Hi Joseph, my Mary has told me about you. How are you, mate?’
14/47
Rik De Busser, RCLT, 29 May 2009
‘Good.’
5.2. Vocabulary
zen: to be
ik zen de Jos: lit: I am the Jos; in some dialects of Dutch, a definite article can be
used with proper names referring to people if they are identifiable in the context.
os Marie: lit: our Mary; in many Dutch dialects, but not in the Standard language, a
member of one’s family is often preceded by the plural first person possessive
pronoun. E.g. ozze Gerd (masc.), os Uli (fem.)
hee: simple present of hemme ‘have’; here used as an auxiliary to form the present
perfect
vertelle van X: tell about X
hoewist: < hoe is et ‘how is it’; how are you doing
moat: take a guess: comparable to Australian…
engê: and you
tgoawel: ok, reasonably well; < et ‘it’ goa ‘goes’ wel ‘particle’
wel: Dutch discourse particle expressing confirmation; exact meaning hard to define
veu wa: for what?
hie: here
kwildekik: < ik wil-de-k-ik ‘1S.Nom want-PST-1S-1S
vroage of: ask whether; the final /n/ in vroage(n) surfaces because of liaison with of
kunne: can, be able to
hellepe: help
mên: my; here a masculine form mêne + -n ‘liaison’
15/47
Language Workshop – Flemish-Dutch
5.3. Grammar
3F zê hee hee zê
3N et hee heetet
16/47
Rik De Busser, RCLT, 29 May 2009
Louis: Maar jongen toch, ik zal eens kijken wat ik kan doen.
From the 6th century onwards, the High-German Consonant Shift create a rift between
17/47
Language Workshop – Flemish-Dutch
the West-Frankish dialects and what would become the High German language area.
p ff p f
Phase 1: t ss V__ and t s __#
k hh k h
p pf
Phase 2: Alemannish and Bavarian dialects: t ts
k kχ
b p
Phase 3: d t
g k
Interestingly, the present-day boundary between Romance and Germanic languages
already stabilized between the 6th and 9th century, although it would shift somewhat to
the north in the following centuries.
6.1.1. History
The oldest attestation of Dutch is an interlinear translation of Latin psalm texts, the
Wachtendonkse Psalmen, written in the early 10th century (±900) but passed down
to us through a 16th century copy.
1.1 Salig man ther niucht vor in gerede ungenethero, ende in uuege sundigero
ne stunt, inde in stuole suffte ne saz.
1.2 Navo in euun Godes uuille sin: inde in euuin sinro thenken sal dages inde
nachtes.
‘1.1: Blessed is the man that does not sit in the assembly of the ungodly, and in
the path of the sinners does not stand, or in the seat of doom not sits.
1.2: But in the law of God his will is: and about his law will he thing by day
and by night.’
ungenethero: gen. pl. of un-genethe ‘un-grace’ / sundigero: gen. pl. of sundigo ‘sinful’ / suffte:
gen. sg. of fem. suft ‘sigh’ / euun: dat. sg. of ewa ‘law’
A very famous example of Old Dutch – long considered to be the oldest Dutch text –
is the following stretch of text, a probatio pennae written around 1100 by a
West-Flemish monk who was working as a copyist at the monastry of Kent.
18/47
Rik De Busser, RCLT, 29 May 2009
Hebban olla vogala nestas hagunnan hinase hi[c] [e]nda thu uu[at] unbida[n]
[uu]e nu
‘All birds have begun to make nests, except for me and you. What are we
waiting for?’
Old Dutch still retained much of the Old-Germic nominal and adjectival morphology.
There are four vocalic stems (on a, ô, i and u), three consonantal stems (on n, ter and
nt) and so-called root nouns (in which nominal inflection attaches directly to the root).
There are four cases. A fifth, the instrumental case, is only retained in a number of
idiomatic constructions.
Masculine Neuter
Sg Pl Sg Pl
Nom dag daga wort wort
Gen dages / dagis dago wordes, wordis wordo
Dat dage / dagi dagon worde, wordi wordon
Acc dag daga wort wort
Table 7 – Illustration nominal morphology: Old-Dutch a-stems
There is a class of weak verbs and seven classes of strong verbs, which have umlaut
in (a) the simple present singular and/or (b) in the simple past.
Simple present Simple past
Singular Plural Singular plural
1 nimon nemon nam nâmon
2 nimis nemet nâmi nâmet
3 nimit nemunt nam nâmon
Table 8 – Illustration strong verb: nemon ‘take’
19/47
Language Workshop – Flemish-Dutch
6.2.1. History
From the 9th till the 12th century, the Dutch language border slowly moves northward
into the Counties of Holland and Utrecht . At the end of the 12th century, the group of
dialects then spoken in the Low Countries and the North of France is generally called
Middle Dutch. There was no fixed supra-regional standard. The linguistic prestige
dialect was typically that of the political-economical centre of gravity, which shifted
throughout the centuries. From the 13th century onward, the Flemish towns of Bruges,
Ypres and Ghent (in the present-day West-Flemish dialect area) became economic
power houses. Under influence of the French Romantic literature, a Dutch literary
tradition arose based on courtly romance and Christian ideals.
In gods namen ende in sijnen vreden In Gods name and with his protection
Soe beghennen wij deser reden Like this we begin this story
Ende spreken inden beghinne aldus: And we speak in the beginning such:
Sancti spiritus
Assit nobis gracia
Ende bidden gode daer na, And after that we pray to God
Den troester ende den volleyst, For the solace and the help
Dat vanden heilighen gheyst of the Holy Spirit
Die ghenade mit ons sy, … whose mercy is with us
Heinric van Veldeke, Prologue of the Sint Servaes legende (1170-1180), from van Es (1976)
In the 14th century, with writers like Jacob van Maerlant, Jan van Boendale and Jacob
van Ruusbroec, the epic tradition was complemented with contemplative and
descriptive work, for instance Maerlant’s famous Spiegel historiael, a historical
20/47
Rik De Busser, RCLT, 29 May 2009
encyclopedia in five volumes that was only completed after his death.
Picture 2 – A page of Maerlant’s Spiegel Historiael (1325-1335, Royal Library Den Haag)
During the Middle Dutch period, the Dutch dialects went through a series of changes
that resulted into a shape that is more or less recognizable to modern Dutch speakers,
especially those in Flanders.
21/47
Language Workshop – Flemish-Dutch
A number of new diphthongs come into existence. In the 12th century there is already
diphthongization of /uː/ to /ɔu/. After the 13th century /iː/ diphthongizes to /ɛi/. At
some point during the Middle Dutch period, /y:/ shifts to /ʌi/ or /ʌy/.
A major change between Old and Middle Dutch is vowel reduction in unstressed
syllables, which led to the loss of nominal declension and much of the verbal
morphology.
hebban olla vogala nestas hagunnan > hebben alle vogele nesten begonnen
/hɛbɑn ɔlɑ voːgɑlɑ nɛstɑs hɑgunɑn/ /hɛbə ɑlə voːgələ nɛstə bəgɔnə/
Nominal (and adjectival) morphology varies from dialect to dialect, but most
variation can be subsumed under two inflection types.
Type I Type II
Sg Pl Sg Pl
Nom vader vadere cnape cnapen
Gen vader vadere cnapen cnapen
Dat vader vaderen cnape cnapen
Acc vader vadere cnape cnapen
Table 9 – Nominal inflection of Type I (vader ‘father’) and Type II (cnape ‘boy’)
Pl Nom wi ghi si
Gen onser/onses (j)uwer/uwes haer
Dat ons (j)u hun
Acc ons (j)u hun
Table 10 – Middle Dutch pronouns (standard system)
22/47
Rik De Busser, RCLT, 29 May 2009
From a political perspective, this will turn out to be somewhat irrelevant. After his
father was murdered in 1419, the Burgundian Duke Philips the Good inherits Flanders
from his father. In the following years, he will unite almost all of the Dutch-speaking
area under his banner and install a centralized administration for the entire Low
Countries. Under his reign, the arts would flourish . In 1425, the University of Leuven,
the first university in the Low Countries, was founded by Duke John IV of Brabant.
The Dukes of Burgundy were Francophone and in contact with them French was the
language of communication, but the people remained Dutch-speaking and local
administration was normally conducted in Dutch. Because of the economic
importance of Flanders and Brabant, local administrators could even ask for
privileges and Mary of Burgundy even consented that only ‘gheboren vlaminghe,
vlaemsch sprekende ende verstaande’ (born Flemings, speaking and understanding
Flemish) could get official positions.
In 1482, Mary of Burgundy dies and the Netherlands are inherited by her husband, the
Habsburger Maximilian of Austria. His son Charles V, who was born in Ghent in
1500, became the most successful emperor of the Holy Roman Empire. In the
so-called Pramatic Sanction of 1549, he unified the entire Dutch-speaking area of his
empire as the Seventeen Provinces with a separate regional government and declared
them indivisible. This created a feeling of national and cultural unity and the terms
Nederduytsch and Nederlandsch came into general use to refer to the Dutch language.
Gradually, the first treatises on the Dutch language appear, e.g. Joas Lambrecht’s
Néderlandsche Spellijnghe (1550). In 1584, the first Dutch grammar was published in
Amsterdam: Hendrik Laurenszoon Spieghel’s Twe-spraack vande Nederduitsche
Letterkunst (A Dialogue on the Dutch Language), a work with the programmatic goal
to prevent the neglect that the people were showing to their mother tongue. Picture 3 –
23/47
Language Workshop – Flemish-Dutch
The political unity of the Dutch language area was only temporary. In 1555, Charles’
son Philip II, King of Spain, becomes Lord of the Low Countries. In 1566, the
Iconoclastic Fury (Beeldenstorm) broke out in what is now the North of France.
Incited by Calvinist preachers and fueled in the underground Hagenpreken (lit: Hedge
Preachings), adherents of the new Protestant faith attack churches and destroy statues
and Catholic paraphernalia. Philip answers by sending the Duke of Alva to the
Netherlands. Alva’s ruthless behaviour alienated both Protestants and Catholics.
Many Protestants, noblemen and rich traders fled to the North, especially to Holland.
Alva managed to get the Southern Netherlands (present-day Flanders) under control
and in 1585 Spanish troops captures Antwerp. The Dutch rebels answered by
blocking the River Scheldt, hereby effectively shutting down the harbour of Antwerp.
This would be the prelude to the Eighty-Year War, lead by William of Orange, and
the creation of the United Provinces .
6.4.1. History
Politically and religiously, present-day Flanders was now separated from the
Netherlands and the Eighty-Year War brought cultural exchange more or less to a
standstill. Flanders became a part of the Spanish empire and lost its economic and
cultural dominance. The United Provinces, in effect a republic, saw the dawn of their
Golden Age, where culture and literature would blossom in the patrician
Rederijkerskamers (Chambers of Rhetoric).
Drama, poetry and expository literature flourished and conscious efforts were made to
develop a new kind of Dutch that was able to serve as a literary and administrative
standard and was suited for the sophisticated cultural environment created by Dutch
economic prosperity. Amsterdam became the centre of Dutch culture and its ‘Prince
of Dutch Letters’ was Joost van den Vondel.
24/47
Rik De Busser, RCLT, 29 May 2009
Dit 's Grootvaâr, van wiens deugt geen eeuwen zullen zwijgen
Hy deê zijn Rechters zelfs het hair te berge stijgen,
Toen hy ter vierschaer quam al even wel gemoedt.
Zijn vyant dronk de doot aen zijn onschuldig bloedt.
Godt schept den hemel ende de aerde, v[ers] 1, 2. ende het licht, op den eersten
dach, 3. Op de[n] tweeden, het uytspansel, met scheydinge der onderste ende
bovenste wateren, 6. Op den derde[n] scheydt hy het Drooge ende de Wateren,
9. Schept Gras ende vruchtbare Boomen
God creates heaven and earth, v. 1-2, and light, on the first day, 3. On the
second, the firmament, with the separation of the waters below and above, 6.
On the third he separates the Dry and the Water, 9. and creates grass and
fertile trees
Biblia, dat is: De gantsche H. Schrifture (Statenvertaling 1637), Genesis 1:1-10
25/47
Language Workshop – Flemish-Dutch
Interestingly, the back vowel /ɑ/ is fronted and lenghtened to something like /aː/ in
17th century Amsterdam. This ‘clear a’ was associated with civilized speech in the
Golden Age.
26/47
Rik De Busser, RCLT, 29 May 2009
Nominal case was on its way down in the spoken language, but is kept artificially
alive in the literary language of the 17th century (and beyond). The genitive, for
instance, was used profusely. The examples below are from van der Horst (2008:vol.
2, p. 1077-8)
With nouns:
With infinitives:
Another sign of this Renaissance influence is the prolific use of bare participles
(examples from van der Horst (2008:vol. 2, p. 1150ff)).
‘Nevertheless, some drivers got away, leaving behind their horses and
weapons.’
(3) Maar den avond beginnende te vallen, hoorden ik van verre eenige lieden
naderen
‘But when the evening began to fall, I heard from afar some people come near’
“zo agt ik het niet onveilig, dat men het gebouw veste op het meest
doorgaende en eenstemmigste Gebruik, zo in de beschaeftste Spreektael, als in
de schriften der agtbaerste en geleerdste Nederduitsche Schrijvers.”
‘I find it not unsafe [to proclaim], that a building should be built on the
foundations of the most common and consistent use, in the civilized spoken
language, like in the writings of the most honourable and learned
Nether-Dutch writers.’
ten Kate Hz. (1721:14)
In the 19th century, innovative Dutch writers would react against this artificial writing
language that had evolved away from the real language of the people, beginning with
the publication of the anti-colonial novel Max Havelaar by Multatuli in 1860.
Notwithstanding this evolution, the political unity and prosperity of the Netherlands
during the 18th, 19th and 20th century had as a result that a Dutch standard language
gradually developed itself.
dialects of Dutch. French became the language of all administration and of the legal
courts. In this climate standardization of Dutch or the development of a literary
language was impossible.
In 1829, the Belgian revolution broke out and in 1830 the Kingdom of Belgium came
into existence. French became again a French-speaking nation and William’s rather
authoritarian language politics created anti-Dutch feelings, although the government
officially expressed the need to translate official documents in ‘Flemish’. In the eyes
of most of the French-speaking elite, Flemish was a language spoken by the peasantry,
unsophisticated and of no importance. This attitude would survive far into the 20th
century.
The Frenchification and the romantic momentum of the Belgian revolution created a
renewed interest in the Flemish national past, among a small class of Flemish (but
sometimes Francophone) intellectuals. They saw the Frenchification as a threat to the
Dutch language and started to write in Dutch. An example of the first is Hendrik
Conscience, whose novel De Leeuw van Vlaanderen (The Lion of Flanders) is a
mythicised description of the victory of the Flemish armies over the French in the
Battle of the Golden Spurs in 1302.
De roode morgenzon blonk twyfelachtig in het oosten, (2)
en was not met een kleed
van nachtwolken omgeven, (3)
terwyl haer zevenkleurig beeld zich glinsterend in elken
dauwdruppel herhaelde; (4)
de blaewe dampen der aerde hingen als en onvatbaer
weefsel aen de toppen der boomen, (5) en de kelken der ontwelkende bloemen opened
zich met liefde om de jongste strael van het daglicht te ontvangen.
The red morning sun shone hesitantly in the east, (2) and was not shrouded with a robe
of night clouds, (3) while her seven-coloured image was glisteningly repeated in every
drop of dew; (4) the blue vapours of the earth dangled like a insusceptible fabric from
the tops of the trees, (5) and the chalices of the budding flowers opening with love to
receive the young rays of the morning light.
H. Conscience (1838), De Leeuw van Vlaanderen, of de Slag der Gulden Sporen, p.1-2.
One group of writers and language idiologues, the ‘localists’, wanted to return to the
29/47
Language Workshop – Flemish-Dutch
ancient Flemish language the past, free from pernicious foreign (and Protestant)
influences of the Northern Dutch standard language. Its most famous exponent of the
second movement is Guido Gezelle, a Flemish priest who became famous for his
poetry with West-Flemish dialectal influences and gathered a literary movement of
young seminary students around him.
Het Schryverke. The whirligig beetle
(Gyrinus natans.)
Another group, the ‘integrationists’, of which Jan Frans Willems was probably the
most important exponent, saw a solution for the Flemish problem in a cultural
integration with the Netherlands.
The group of people striving for the promotion of Dutch in Flanders is often refered
30/47
Rik De Busser, RCLT, 29 May 2009
to as the Vlaamse Beweging (Flemish Movement) although they were never formally
part of a single group. Initially, they strove for literary and cultural recognition, but in
the last decades of the 19th century the movement increasingly developed a political
and social ideology, especially after it realigned itself with progressive democratic
forces within the Catholic Church.
Demands were put for the restoration of Dutch as an official language of the kingdom,
student protests broke out asking for education in Dutch, and demands were made to
make Dutch the language of the administration in Flanders. Walloon civil servants
saw this as a threat to their position and founded political counter-movements. The
government passed some language equality laws were passed, which were mostly
symbolic and did not change anything in practice.
First, that in the courts of law the defendants should not be tried in French if they did not
understand that language. The law of 1873 gave teh Flemings complete satisfaction in that
respect, and they have hardly made use of it.
Secondly, that civil servants, in their contacts with the public in the Flemish part of the country,
should have a sufficient understanding of the local speech of those who are illiterate with
regard to French. In anticipation of the knowledge of French becoming more general as a
result of compulsory primary education, we can easily satisfy those Flemings ignorant of that
language by sending Flemish civil servants to their part of the country.
However, if this minority should continue to flaunt its ignorance, should then the Walloons
and all educated Flemings be subjected to the tyranny of that ridiculous ‘mother tongue’ that
serves no purpose? Should it be forcibly be introduced in to Parliament, law-making,
education, the army and every sector of public administration, putting to disadvantage the
Walloon race, the more intelligent and enlightened of the two? [...]
From Fredercq (1906), Schets eener geschiedenis der Vlaamsche Beweging, vol. I, p. 197.
While around the turn of the century Dutch was generally accepted to be the standard
language of Flanders (in some places, it was even used in the local administration),
there was no language legislation that recognized this tendency. There was still a
large economic gap between the Francophone upper classes and the Dutch-speaking
middle and lower classes, the educational system was completely French, and the
appointment of Flemish civil servants was deliberately blocked by the Francophone
central administration.
The Flemish movement, who had gained in strength, grew increasingly frustrated
with the lack of political progress and the unwillingness of Wallonia and Francophone
upper class to accept bilingualism in Belgium. In the beginning of the 20th century,
31/47
Language Workshop – Flemish-Dutch
they would radicalize and start to pursue the idea of a monolingual Flanders.
6.7.1. pre-1920s
The First World War intensified the clash between the two language communities in
Belgium. The German empire, which saw the annexation of Belgium and Holland as
of crucial importance, started to pursue a Flamenpolitik (Flemish Policy) in 1914 ,
mainly in order to win over Holland: the Flemish people and the Dutch language got a
preferential treatment; the University of Ghent could teach in Dutch; and cultural
links should be forged between Flanders and the Netherlands.
Flemings made up about 60% of the Belgian army at the Front in West-Flanders, but
the infantry was up to 70% percent Flemish, many of them uneducated and unable to
understand French. The officers, on the other hand were almost exclusively
Francophone and most didn’t speak Dutch. Dissatisfied soldiers held secret meetings
and secretly organized protest. They organized themselves in what was going to be
called the Front Movement (Frontbeweging), which would after the war fight for
Flemish self-rule.
On the Necessity of the Flemish Movement
Q. Surely this is an exaggeration? The Flemish are alive, after all, and notes for their health.
A. The Flemish eat, work, sleep, stand, marry, have their habitations – but any slave does that,
who has no life of his own; and it is a life of our own that is the question here, the Fleming’s
own Flemish life.
Q. What does the Fleming stand to gain from this life of his own?
A. This: that with the whole heritage of his blood and race – that is, his nature, his name and
his language – he enjoys complete freedom, justice and respect in his own country, and when
abroad as much as that nature, name and language entitles him to.
Cyriel Verschaeve (1918), The Flemish Nationalist’s Catechism. From Hermans et al.
(1992:240)
32/47
Rik De Busser, RCLT, 29 May 2009
After the war, constitutional reforms were carried out in 1918 and 1921 which
introduced universal male suffrage but also made Dutch the language of local and
provincial goverments in Flanders and allowed the University of Ghent to offer part
of its courses in Dutch. Further changes were not made and the Flemish Movement
had lost some of its shine immediately after the war because of it being associated
with collaboration with the German enemy. Slowly, however, the Flemish cause
gained impetus, especially after the Catholic Church put its wait behind demands for
social reforms in Flanders.
After the end of the war in 1944, Flemish nationalism was unsurprisingly associated
with collaboration with the Nazis. The Resistance was predominantly
French-speaking and left-wing and they wanted to be repaid for their sacrifices.
Language came to the forefront in politics. Language laws were openly flouted and in
the 1947 sensus there was a drop from 40-50% in the number of Dutch-speakers in
certain municipalities compared to the 1930 census, indicating that many did not wish
to consider themselves as Flemish anymore. The attitude against collaborators and
perceived collaborators was hostile and often violent.
On the night of 15 March 1946, the Yser Tower, a monument to Flemish soldiers who
died in the First World War, was blown up. Its desecration (the monument bore the
inscription ‘All for Flanders – Flanders for Christ’) helped to rekindle pro-Flemish
and anti-Walloon sentiment. Another factor was the so-called Royal Question. King
Leopold III’s ambiguous attitude towards the German occupier led to demands for his
dismissal after the Liberation. The Walloons and anti-Catholic parties were in favour
33/47
Language Workshop – Flemish-Dutch
of his abdication; the pro-Flemish and Catholic parties wanted him to return. In a
referendum held on 16 March 1950, 57% of the population voted for the king’s return:
72% in Flanders and 42% in Wallonia. This led to violent rioting in the industrial
centres of Wallonia and when the protesteres threatened to march to the capital, the
king abdicated in favour of his son Boudewijn. Both Flamingants and Catholics saw
this outcome as a bitter insult to Flanders.
Due to the increasing cultural prestige of Dutch, the Flemish Movement gained mass
support from the 1950s onward. In the 1950s and 1960s the administration of Flemish
companies were gradually converted to Dutch, although in some regions the top
echelons remained predominantly Francophone till well into the 1960s. In 1962, the
language boundary between Flanders and Wallonia was fixed by law and the Ministry
of Culture was split into a Dutch-language and a French language ministry. It was
only in 1973 that it was declared by official decree that the language of Flanders was
‘the Dutch language’.
The Flemish Movement had finally attained all of its original goals, but the problems
between Belgium’s two communities were still not solved. The problem started to
centre more and more around Brussels, which over the years had evolved in an
overwhelmingly Francophone city with a militantly anti-Flemish population and
which now rapidly expanded into the surrounding Flemish countryside. In order to
completely federalize the country, the question of Brussels would have to be solved.
In 1980 Belgium was separated into three regions (Flanders, Wallonia and Brussels)
with extensive local powers. Because of Walloon demands for the expansion of the
territory of Brussels, the actual government, the Brussels Regional Council, was only
instituted in 1989, after another constitutional reform.
34/47
Rik De Busser, RCLT, 29 May 2009
1:
Comines-Warneton (Komen-Waasten) / 2: Mesen (Messines) / 3: Mouscron (Moeskroen) / 4: Spiere-Helkijn
(Espierres-Helchin) / 5: Ronse (Renaix) / 6: Flobecq (Vloesberg) / 7: Bever (Biévène) / 8: Enghien (Edingen) / 9:
Drogenbos / 10: Linkebeek / 11: Sint-Genesius-Rode (Rhode-Saint-Genèse) / 12: Wemmel / 13: Kraainem / 14:
Wezembeek-Oppem / 15: Herstappe / 16: Voeren (Fourons) / 17: Malmédy (Malmund) / 18: Waimes / 19-22:
Lontzen, Raeren, Eupen, Kelmis (La Calamine) / 23-27: Burg-Reuland, Sankt Vith (Saint-Vith), Amel (Amblève),
Bütgenbach, Büllingen (Bullange)
35/47
Language Workshop – Flemish-Dutch
This obsession with spelling is in part a result of the strong normative character of
linguistics in the 19th and 20th century in the Dutch language area. An example from
a historical grammar of Dutch:
Wat ons niet verbaast is dat in dat gesproken Nederlands veel ongrammaticale zinnen
voorkomen; vergissingen, versprekingen, hervattingen zijn niet van de lucht, er
komen herhalingsconstructies voor en bijzinnen krijgen vaak de vorm van een
hoofdzin (Uijlings 1956: 54 e.v.). Een aantal van die constructies komt met grote
regelmaat voor; ze zijn nader beschreven door Frank Jansen (1981) en het is niet
uitgesloten te achten dat sommige daarvan ten slotte aan schrijftaalnormen zullen
gaan voldoen.
What does not surprise us is that spoken Dutch contains many ungrammatical
sentences: mistakes, slips of the tongue, resumptions are frequent, many repetitive
constructions are used and subordinate clauses often get main clause constituent order
[...]. A number of these constructions have a high frequency; they have been
described in detail by [...] and it is not out of the question that some of them will
eventually become part of the written norm.
At the end of the 19th century, it is perceived as important in the Netherlands and in
Flanders to speak Algemeen Beschaafd Nederlands (Standard Civilized Dutch). (This
was later renamed Algemeen Nederlands (Standard Dutch), after people repeatedly
brought up the argument that non-standard variants of Dutch were not necessarily
uncivilized...)
In 1980, Belgium and the Netherlands erect the Nederlandse Taalunie (Dutch
Language Union), an international organization that is responsible for the
development of unified language policies in the Dutch linguistic area. This includes
the publications of periodic reforms of the Dutch spelling in the Green book, but also
things like the promotion of Dutch education overseas and the promotion of Dutch
36/47
Rik De Busser, RCLT, 29 May 2009
literature. In cooperation with the Univeristy of Nijmegen, they also published the
Algemene Nederlandse Spraakkunst, a comprehensive reference grammar of spoken
Dutch (online available on: http://www.let.ru.nl/ans/).
In the Kempen, much of the original gender system has remained intact. We already
saw some of this in 5.3.2. Each noun has an inherent grammatical gender. Attributive
deictics, adjectives and anaphoric personal pronouns agree in gender and number with
their target noun.
37/47
Language Workshop – Flemish-Dutch
spreke ‘speak’
Other class 2 verbs (uə-ø-ø): woëne ‘live, inhabit’, koëpe ‘buy’, stoëte ‘nudge’, toëne
‘show’
Other class 3 verbs (æ-ɛ-eː): rêze ‘travel’, blêve ‘stay’, wêze ‘point’
38/47
Rik De Busser, RCLT, 29 May 2009
In the Kempen dialect (and many other Brabantian dialects) you have six suffixes for
expressing the diminutive.
39/47
Language Workshop – Flemish-Dutch
(6) Hê leest iederen oavend êgelek wel, veu zoever dakkik wet, vanaf dattem
toaskomt tottatem goa sloapen een gazet.
‘Each evening, from the moment he comes home till when he goes to bed, he
actually reads a newspaper, as far as I know.’
Pincers also occur with separable composite verbs, a special subclass of verb
compounds in Dutch whose infinitive consists of an adverb and a verbal root (the
adverb is usually related to a preposition). In inflected forms the adverbial element
functions as a free constituent in the clause. Examples:
In actual clauses, all other constituents except for the subject, will normally occur
between the verbal head and the adverbial element.
40/47
Rik De Busser, RCLT, 29 May 2009
(7) Ik kom zoelang as ik mê herinner elleken oavond zoe ongevêr ronte zellevden
têd oan.
‘As long as I remember, I arrive each evening approximately around the same
time.’
A third type of pincer constructions involves complex verb phrases. In main clauses,
only the inflected member of a complex VP occurs in second position. All other
members will be moved to the end of the clause.
(8) Ik wil da liever veu da zêtkan zien allemaal toch wel schoën afgewerrekt
hemme.
af‹ge›werrek-t hem-e
complete-‹PRF.PRTC› have-INF
‘Before she is able to see it, I’d rather want to have complete everything
beautifully.’
8.1. Text
Jos Lewie, ik denk dakkik is na houës goa gaan se. Tis al loat oant wôrre.
41/47
Language Workshop – Flemish-Dutch
‘I am getting tired.’
8.2. Vocabulary
denke: think
dakkik: da-k-ik ‘that-1S-1S’
noa houës goan: go home
hoas: house
goan: go; here used for expressing the future
tis al loat oant wôre: it’s already getting late
loat: late
wôrre: become
dasgoe: < da is goe ‘that is good’
goat mer: you go
goat: third singular of goan ‘go’
mer: particle
ik goan hie: I will here (note that goan is here again used as a future)
ok: also
bekans: almost
men schup afkôsse: lit: to clean my shovel > to stop working
schup: shovel
afkôsse: wipe off
zen … oant … : progressive construction < zen ‘to be’ oan ‘at’ -t ‘it; 3S.N’; e.g. gê
ze onnoeëzel oant doen ‘you are behaving silly’; hê is oant sloape ‘he is sleeping’
kzennermee weg: I am leaving; lit: I am gone with it <k-zen ermee weg
‘1S-be.1S.PRES with.it gone’
tot môrrege: till tomorrow; see you tomorrow
42/47
Rik De Busser, RCLT, 29 May 2009
8.3. Grammar
43/47
Language Workshop – Flemish-Dutch
2 vanaf dak was geboren was kik al intelligent At birth I was already very intelligent
ik pakte recht ner moeders beust gelak ne grote I immediately took my mother’s breast like a
vengt big boy
t was nie voor mee te spelen, dak pakte ner die It wasn’t just to play that I was grabbing for this
beust breast
oek nie vuurt seksuele, 't was van de groeëten It was also nothing sexually, I just was very
deurst thirsty
3 ik zopekik alles leeg, ons moe wist gieëne road I emptied everything, my mother didn’t know
what to do
ik blette totdak kreeg ne mellekottomoat I cried until I got a milk dispenser
oeëk toen ik al op school zat, beterde het geen When later I went to school, the situation did not
flouët improve
as niemand maai indoeëg had, zoop ik den If nobody kept an eye on me, I emptied out the
inktpot ouët ink pot
(refrein)
4 oep zestieng joar waskik al wêreldkampioeng On my sixteenth I already was a world champion
kzoop z’allemoal onder toafel, aan maai was I drank them all under the table, I was a lost case
niks te doeng
na zêve doage drinke, lag iederieën al plat After seven days of boozing, everybody was
lying flat on their backs
doarnoa gingk oep de lappe want ik waskik nog But I went out to party because I was not drunk
nie zat yet
5 zoeë zattek is in Olland, ‘t was een iejer vur de One day I was sitting in Holland, it was an
Bellege honour for the Belgians
die kezen oanet leren oeda Bellege kunne To learn those cheeseheads how the Belgians can
zwellege guzzle them down
zoeë zopekik in m’n eentje wel twintig voate On my own I emptied twenty barrels
leeg
oemda'k dan zekers wist da'k e vatje groatis Because only then I could be certain that I got
kreeg another one for free
44/47
Rik De Busser, RCLT, 29 May 2009
(refrein)
6 ik ging noar ne genêshieër, dieje mij toen ‘s I went to a doctor who did a check-up
onderzocht
dieje vent beziengkik noeët nie mieër, ik voelde I’ll never have a look at that guy, I felt ripped off
ma bekocht It was only a young chap, he had just finished
et was nog een joenk gasje, hê kwam mer pas school
van tschool He said: mate, you don’t have blood, that’s pure
hê zee: gê hechen bloed moat, das zoaveren alcohol!
alkool!
7 en allist gieën gehêm menieër, toch blevvet And although it’s no secret anymore, sir, I won’t
onder ons tell anyone
ê moag daddis gieën moag nie mieër daddis Your stomach is no stomach, it is a goddamned
begot een spons sponge
ê keelgat is gen keelgat, vengt, al denktegê van Your throat is not a throat, although you might
wel think so
ak vergelijk dannist toch drekt de If I have to compare it: it’s like the Kennedy
Kennedy-tunnel tunnel
(refrein)
da kan-ne-k-ikke blindelings
that can.1S.PRES -LIG-1S-1S blindly
45/47
Language Workshop – Flemish-Dutch
9.3. Vocabulary
zoape: drink excessively, especially alcohol; (v.) to booze
da kannik goe / ik kan da goe: I am very good at it
blindelings: blindfolded, blindly
me m’n ogen toe: with my eyes closed
tegen m’n hoar omoeëg: excessively, boundlessly; lit: up into my hair
10. Bibliography
Camerman, Filip. 2007. Antwerps Schrijven: Spelling and Grammatica van het 21e-eeuwse Antwerps.
Antwerpen: C. De Vries-Brouwers.
Coppen, P.A., W. Haeseryn & F. de Vriend. 2007. Electronische Algemene Nederlandse Spraakkunst
(E-ANS), version 1.2. Available at: http://www.let.ru.nl/ans/e-ans/.
de Keyser, P. & A. van Elsander (Eds.). 1984. Van den Vos Reynaerde (Series Van den Vos
Reynaerde Series. Antwerpen: De Nederlandsche Boekhandel.
Fredericq, Paul. 1906-1909. Schets eener geschiedenis der Vlaamsche Beweging (three volumes).
Gent: J. Vuylsteke.
Goossens, J. 1980. Middelnederlandse Vocaalsystemen (Bijlagen van de Vereniging voor Limburgse
Dialect- en Naamkunde 2). Hasselt: Vereniging voor Limburgse Dialect- en Naamkunde.
Hermans, Theo, Louis Vos & Lode Wils (Eds.). 1992. the Flemish Movement: A Documentary
History 1780-1990 (Series the Flemish Movement: A Documentary History 1780-1990 Series.
London: The Athlone Press.
Hoppenbrouwers, Cor & G. Hoppenbrouwers. 2001. De Indeling van de Nederlandse Streektalen.
Dialecten van 156 steden en dorpen geklasseerd volgens de FFM. Assen: Van Gorcum.
INL. 2007. Geïntegreerde Taaldatabank. De Historische Woordenboeken van het Nederlands op
Internet. Instituut voor Nederlandse Lexicologie. Available at: http://gtb.inl.nl.
Kiliaan, Guicciard. 1612. Beschrijvinghe van alle de Neder-landen; anderszins ghenoemt
Neder-Duytslandt, door M. Lowij Guicciardijn; Overgheset in de Nederduytsche spraecke door
46/47
Rik De Busser, RCLT, 29 May 2009
47/47