Causes and Pathomechanisms of Oesophageal Varices Development
Causes and Pathomechanisms of Oesophageal Varices Development
Department of Surgery and Justice, Medical Service of Lower Saxonia, Hannover, Germany
SUMMARY
Portal hypertension is a common clinical syndrome with chronic liver diseases and is characterised by a patho-
logical increase in portal pressure. Moreover, portal hypertension is associated with increased portal blood flow.
Increased vascular resistance in portal hypertension is because of an increase in both intrahepatic and portosys-
temic collateral resistance. Chronic elevations in systemic and splanchnic blood flow have been documented as
key elements of hyperdynamic circulatory state of hypertensive animals and humans. Peripheral vasodilatation
initiates the development of the classic profile of decreased systemic elevated splanchnic blood flow and elevat-
ed cardia index that characterises this state.
Portosystemic collaterals develop as a result of portal hypertension. This is the central pathophysiological event
that leads to bleeding from oesophagogastric varices and portosystemic encephalopathy. Collateral vessels
respond to various vasoconstrictors and vasodilators.- Varices in the distal 5 cm of the distal oesophagus are
easily identified by endoscopy because of their superficial location in the lamina propria and therefore are must
apt to bleed and why the current practise of endoscopic therapy is likely to be successful in obliterating the
varices. In patients with oesophageal varices the dilated deep intrinsic veins displace the superficial venous
plexus, assume a supepitheal position and are endoscopically visible as teleangiectasia, cherry red spots, red
colour signs, hemocystic spots, red wale markings or varices on varices. As alternative endoscopic way of treat-
ment the paravariceal injection has been propagated by our group thus preserving the pathophysiologic collater-
als and preventing early new formation of collaterals and rebleeding.
Pathophysiologically the concept of erosion has been abandoned and replaced by the explosion theory: bleeding
probably occurs when the expanding force by pressure and flow can no longer be counter-balanced by the
variceal wall tension; at this point the varices rupture and bleed. When the varix distension has increased, the
radius has increased and the wall thickness decreased. Thus early diagnosis of patients with a high tendency to
bleed can easily be made by endoscopy, measuring portal and / or oesophageal-variceal pressure and character-
istising the chronic liver disease according to the Child-Pugh-classification.
Received: 1999.06.01 Correspondence address: Karl-Joseph Paquet, MD FACS FICS, Department of Surgery and Justice, Medical Service of Lower Saxonia,
Accepted: 2000.07.08 Hildesheimer Str. 41, D-30169 Hannover, Germany
915
Clinical Research
Increased resistance
916
Paquet KJ – Causes and pathomechanisms of oesophageal varices…
917
Clinical Research
918
Paquet KJ – Causes and pathomechanisms of oesophageal varices…
919
Clinical Research
920
Paquet KJ – Causes and pathomechanisms of oesophageal varices…
921
Clinical Research
922
Paquet KJ – Causes and pathomechanisms of oesophageal varices…
this point the varices rupture and bleed. (Polio and The finding of oesophageal varices in cirrhotic
Groszman 1986) [44]. The factors regulating the patients carries a grim prognosis [46]. It is estimat-
tension experted by the wall of varices to contain ed that 50% of these patients will bleed from their
the expanding force can be described according to varices at some time in their lifes [47,48]. Factors
the LAPLACE-LAW (Figure 9). that can predict which patient will bleed and when
this event will occur have been partially elucidated.
T = TP x r/w The magnitude of the elevation of portal pressure
appears predictive in that patients, whose portal
in which T is the wall tension, TP the transmural pressure is above 10–12 mmHG, have an
pressure, r the radius and w the wall thickness of increased risk of bleeding compared to those portal
the varices. The transmural pressure is the differ- pressures are below this level [27,49]. This has
ence between intravariceal pressure and the pres- been shown by our group in two controlled ran-
sure in the oesophageal lumen. The entire varix is domised trials [38,52] and by others. However, an
in equilibrium between the outwardly directed elevation in portal pressure does not necessarily
flow (TP x r/w) and the inwardly directed force of mean that the pressure in oesophageal varices is
the wall tension. The inwardly directed force is also high, because individual patients may differ in
augmented by the surrounding tissue structures, the type of collateral circulation [50]. As has been
which provide reinforcement for the vessel wall. demonstrated by our group, too and later by
japanese investigators, teleangiectasia, varices on
The larger variceal size multiplies the deleterious varices, red colour signs (i.e., cherry red spots, red
effect of high intravariceal pressure by increasing wale markings, or hemocystic spots) and blue
the expanding force. When varix distension varices, which may indicate thin overlying mucosa
increases, the radius increases and wall thickness have been associated with a history of variceal
decreases (Figure 9). The wall tension increases in bleeding [38,40]. This relation is still debatable. In
an attempt to contain the expanding force. Since a prospective trial, only 19% of patients with these
venous structures have little musculature, this limits variceal stigmata bled from oesophageal varices
their capacity to develop wall tension. Eventually, over a 2 year period [51]. However, our group was
the expanding force in an enlarging varix exceeds able to identify a higher frequency of bleeding up
the limit of wall tension and variceal rupture to 80% over a period of three years by combining
occurs. the large varices with endoscopic signs of bleeding
and a wedged hepatic pressure gradient over 16
The consequence of events leading to portal mm HG [52]. Thus large varices with endoscopic
variceal bleeding are initiated by increased portal signs are associated with an increased likelihood of
923
Clinical Research
924
Paquet KJ – Causes and pathomechanisms of oesophageal varices…
year survival is 23%. Early rebleeding may be an Benhamou [56]. These varices may be less likely to
overt reflection of the degree of liver failure and rupture because they are found deeper in the gut
has been correlated with death within 30 days. wall than oesophageal varices and the frequency is
counted not more than 10%. Duodenal varices are
Graham and Smith [46] have shown that bleeding- often found in individuals with extrahepatic portal
associated mortality rate is highest in the first days hypertension where the varices serve to bypass the
to weeks after the variceal bleed and returns to obstructed segment. In patients with intrahepatic
baseline by 3 to 5 months. Therefore, therapeutic portal hypertension, duodenal varices form
interventions are likely to have the most influence between the afferent branches of the portal vein,
on survival if introduced in the early period follow- such as the superior mesenteric vein, and the infe-
ing the bleed. rior vena cava [57,58].
Gastric varices may be more difficult to identify at Without doubt, there is a pathogenic correlation
endoscopy because there are generally situated between elevated portal pressure and variceal
deeper than oesophageal varices and may resem- hemorrhage. However, the exact correlation is still
ble rugal folds. In actually bleeding patients, the a matter of controversy.
fundus is frequently obscured by a pool of blood
and small gastric varices may not be easily detect- First of all, certain levels of portal pressure or por-
ed. In these cases the patients should be put in a tohepatic gradient of 10/12 mm HG are required
right site position to be more accurate and sure in for the development of oesophageal varices
detecting the varices and source of bleeding. [59,60]. At levels lower than these, the presence of
varices is unlikely. In patients with liver disease in
In much of the literature, gastric varices are report- an early stage, the presence of varices correlates to
ed together with oesophageal varices rather than as the degree of portal hypertension. However, in
a separate entity. Therefore, the incidence, fre- patients with established portal hypertension the
quency of bleeding, and natural history of gastric relation between variceal hemorrhage and the
varices have not been defined precisely. Incidence level of portal venous pressure is still questioned
rate of 16% to 70% have been reported in patients [61,62]. For this controversy the following reasons
with portal hypertension and cirrhosis [29]. are responsible:
Whether mere presence of gastric varices influ-
ences survival is unknown. However, patients who 1. There are still methodological problems in mea-
bleed from gastric varices present a therapeutic suring portal pressure, even when the method of
challenge because they are part of an extensive occluded wedged hepatic venous pressure is
collateral network, making hemostasis and ultimate used.
obliteration difficult [55].
2. The pressure in the oesophageal varices may be
Duodenal varices more important for the risk of bleeding than the
portal pressure because formation of sponta-
Apart from oesophagogastric varices, duodenal neous shunts can be followed by pressure
varices are one of the more commonly reported reduction, equalisation, compensation or pres-
digestive tract varices in portal hypertension. The sure balance [63].
incidence of these varices is not known, but the
duodenal varices represented one third of the 3. The oesophageal varices are localised quite dis-
bleeding ectopic varices reported by Lebrec and tant from the portal vein, so that the possibility
925
Clinical Research
Table 2. Heinz Kalk-Classification of hepatocellular function - a modi- the hypothesis of explosion as a course of variceal
fied Child-Pugh-Classification (proposed by our group) rupture and abrupt variceal hemorrhage.
Observation Points Points Points Last but not least, other predisposing factors for
variceal hemorrhage like ascites, coagulation disor-
Nutritional status exellent good poor ders, local elevated fibrogenolysis, the last not to
Ascites none moderate marked common in prehepatic block without liver disease,
easily controlled poorly controlled are all included in the Child-Pugh-classification and
Neurological disorder none I-II III-IV their modification by our group (Table 2), responsi-
(encephalopathy) ble as well for the risk of bleeding, liver failure and
Serum bilirubin (mg/100ml) < 2.0 2.0 – 3.0 > 3.0 thus prognosis [48,53,54].
Serum albumin > 3.5 3.5 – 3.5 < 3.0
Prothrombin concentr. > 75% 50% – 75% < 50% Therefore a good clinician or hepatologist should
(Quick - test) be aware of all these variables when he is responsi-
child A = 6-8 point; child B = 9-11 point; child C = 12 or more point ble for a patient with portal hypertension.
REFERENCES:
of vascular resistance in this area can not be com-
pletely excluded. 1. Greenway CV, Stark RD: Hepatic vascular bed. Physiological Review,
1971; 51: 23-65
Rigau et al [59] found that portal pressure in 2. Genecin P, Groszman RJ: Portal Hypertension. In: Schiff E, Schiff L
patients with oesophageal variceal bleeding was (eds): Diseases of the Liver. JB Lippincott Company, Philadelphia
significant higher than in those patients without 1993, pp 935-973
bleeding. Staritz et al [63] compared 14 patients 3. Popper H, Zak FG: Pathological aspects of cirrhosis. Am J Med,
with compensated liver cirrhosis and status post- 1958; 24: 593-625
variceal hemorrhage with 15 similar patients with- 4. Baldus WP, Hoffbauer FW: Vascular changes in the cirrhotic liver as
out bleeding and determined that patients with studied by injection technique. Am J Digest Dis, 1993; 8: 689-692
bleeding had a median intravariceal pressure of 22 5. Bhathal PS, Groszman HJ: Reduction of increased portal vascular
mmHG and patients without bleeding of 15 resistance of the isolated perfused cirrhotic rat liver by vasodilators. J
mmHG. Hepatol, 1985; 1: 325-337
6. Beker S, Valencia-Parparcen J: Portal hypertension syndrome. A com-
Thus, oesophageal pressure of at least 20 mmHG parative analysis of bilharzial fibrosis and hepatic cirrhosis. Am J
represents a high danger of bleeding. Furthermore, Digest Dis, 1968; 13: 1047-1054
a positive correlation between pressure in 7. Van Leeuwen DJ, Howe SC, Scheuer PJ et al: Portal hypertension in
oesophageal varices and their size was found [64]. chronic hepatitis: relationship of morphological changes. Gut, 1991;
In patients with alcoholic cirrhosis this Reynolds- 31: 2339-343
Rector-group measured the portal pressure by 8. Schaffner F, Popper H: Capillarization of the hepatic sinusoids in
means of an indwelling hepatic vein balloon man. Gastroenterology, 1963; 76: 704-709
catheter during and after the bleeding episodes. 9. Reynolds TB, Hidmura R, Mitchell H et al: Portal hypertension with-
Portal pressure was significantly higher than 16 out cirrhosis in alcoholic liver disease. Ann Int Med, 1969; 70: 497-
mmHG in patients who continued to bleed or 506
rebleed compared to patients remaining stable. 10. Lieber CS, Zimmon DS, Kessler RE et al: Portal hypertension in
They stated that continuous monitoring of portal experimental alcoholic liver injury. Clin Res, 1976; 24: 478 (a)
pressure in patients with bleeding oesophageal 11. Brion E, Brenard R, Pariente EA et al: Sinusoidal portal hypertension
varices due to alcoholic cirrhosis is safe and feasi- in hepatic amyloidosis. Gut, 1991; 32: 227-230
ble and permits rapid stratification of the risk of 12. Pinzani M, Failli P, Ruocco C et al: Fat-storing cells as liver-specific
bleeding, continuous bleeding and rebleeding. pericytes-spatial dynamics of agonist-stimulated intracellular calcium
Nearly all authors involved in measuring transients. J Clin Invest, 1992; 90: 642-646
oesophageal variceal pressure by different methods 13. Mc Clure RR, Woodward M: Contractile fibroblasts in chronic alco-
agree in the statement that oesophageal pressure is holic cirrhosis. Gastroenterology, 1979; 76: 704-709
more elevated in large varices than in small one 14. Rubanyi GM: Endothelium-Derived relaxing and contracting factors.
[65–67]. Furthermore, this pressure is influenced J Cell Biochem, 1990; 46: 27-36
by respiration, the Valsalva manoeuvre, vomiting 15. Vane JR, Anggard EE, Botting RM: Regulatory functions of vascular
and pressing the abdomen to a great extent, as endothelium. N Engl J Med, 1990; 323: 27-36
mentioned above [65–67]. All these data underline
926
Paquet KJ – Causes and pathomechanisms of oesophageal varices…
16. Mittal MK, Gupta TK, Lee FY et al: Nitric oxide modulates vascular 37. Beppu K, Inokuchi K, Koyanagi N et al.: Prediction of variceal haem-
tone in normal rat liver. Am J Physiol, 1994; 267: G416-G422 orrhage by oesophageal endoscopy. Gastrointestinal Endoscopy, 1981;
17. Gupta TK, Chung M, Sessa WC et al: Impaired endothelial function 27: 213
in the intrahepatic circulation in cirrhosis. Hepatology, 1995; 22(4): 38. Paquet KJ: Prophylactic endoscopic sclerosing treatment of the
156A oesophageal wall in varices – a prospective controlled randomized
18. Gupta TK, Groszman RJ: Administration of L-arginine, the physio- trial. Endoscopy, 1982; 14: 4
logical precursor of nitric oxide, reduces portal perfusion pressure and 39. Paquet KJ, Fleig W: Sclerotherapy of oesophageal varices. In: Papp
ameliorates hepatic vascular hyperreactivity in experimental cirrhosis. UP (ed): Endoscopic Control of Gastrointestinal Haemorrhage. CRC
Hepatology, 1994; 20(4): 200A Press, Boca Raton 1981, Florida, USA
19. Rockey DC, Weisiger RA: Endothelin induced contractility of stellate 40. Paquet KJ, Kuhn R: Prophylactic endoscopic sclerotherapy in patients
cell from normal and cirrhotic rat liver: implication of regulation of with liver cirrhosis and oesophageal varices. Hepato-Gastroenterology,
portal pressure an resistance. Hepatology, 1996; 24(1): 233-240 1997; 44: 625-636
20. Columbato LA, Albillos A, Groszman RJ: Temporal relationship of 41. Paquet KJ, Raschke E: Experiences in the management of the acute or
peripheral vasodilatation, plasma volume expansion and the hyperdy- impending haemorrhage from oesophageal varices using the oesophago-
namic circulatory state in portal hypertensive rats. Hepatology, 1992; scopic sclerosing method. In: International Symposium on acute gas-
15: 323-328 trointestinal haemorrhage. Prague-Carlsbad, Karger, Basel 1972, pp 184
21. Liebermann FL, Reynolds TB: Plasma volume in cirrhosis of the liver. 42. Paquet KJ, Raschke E: Management of haemorrhage from
J Clin Invest, 1967; 46: 1279-1308 oesophageal varices using the endoscopic sclerosing method. Ann
22. Halvorsen JF, Myking AO: The portosystemic collateral pattern in the Surg, 1973; 117: 99
rat. Eur Surg Res, 1974; 6: 183-195 43. Paquet KJ, Oberhammer E: Sclerotherapy of bleeding oesophageal
23. Sikuler E, Groszman RJ: Haemodynamic studies in long- and short- varices by means of endoscopy. Endoscopy, 1978; 10: 7-12
term portal-hypertensive rats; the relation of systemic glucagon levels. 44. Polio J, Groszman RJ: Haemodynamic factors involved in the devel-
Hepatology, 1996; 6(3): 414-416 opment and rupture of oesophageal varices: a pathophysiological
24. Lee FY, Colombato LA, Albillos A et al: Administration of N-omega- approach to treatment. Sem Liver Dis, 1986; 6: 318-331
nitro-L-arginine ameliorates porto-systemic shunting in portal-hyper- 45. Garcia-Pagan JC, Feu F, Castells A et al.: circadian variations of por-
tensive rats. Gastroenterology, 1993; 105: 1464-1470 tal pressure and variceal haemorrhage in patients with cirrhosis.
25. Lee FY, Colombato La, Albillos A et al. (1993) N-nitro-L-arginine Hepatology, 1994; 5: 595-601
administration corrects vasodilatation and systemic capillary hypoten- 46. Graham DY, Smith JL: The course of patients after variceal haemor-
sion, and ameliorates plasma volume expansion and sodium retention rhage. Gastroenterology, 1981; 80: 800
in portal hypertensive rats. Hepatology, 1993; 17: 84-90 47. Koff RS: Benefit of endoscopy in upper gastrointestinal bleeding in
26. Mosca P, Lee FY, Kaumann AJ et al.: Pharmacology of portal-sys- patients with liver disease. Dig Dis Sci, 1981; 26: 12
temic collaterals in portal hypertensive rats: role of endothelium. Am J 48. Galambos JT: Oesophageal variceal haemorrhage: diagnosis and an
Physiol, 1992; 262: G544-G550 overview of treatment. Semin Liver Dis, 1982; 2: 211
27. Garcia-Tsao G, Groszman RJ, Fisher RL et al.: Portal pressure, pres- 49. Lebrec D, De Fleury, Rueff B et al.: Poral hypertension, size of
ence of gastrooesophageal varices and variceal bleeding. Hepatology, oesophageal varices, and risk of gastrointestinal bleeding in alcoholic
1985; 5: 419 cirrhosis. Gastroenterology, 1980; 79: 1139
28. Butler H: Gastro-oesophageal haemorrhage in hepatic cirrhosis. 50. Rector WG, Reynolds TB: Risk factors for haemorrhage from
Thorax, 1953; 7: 159 oesophageal varices and acute gastric erosions. Clin Gastroenterol,
29. Sarin SK, Schadev G, Nanda R et al: Endoscopic sclerotherapy in the 1985; 14: 139
treatment of gastric varices. Br J Surg, 1998; 75: 747 51. Inokuchi K: Prophylactic portal non-decompressive surgery in patients
30. Butler H: Veins of oesophagus. Thorax, 1951; 6: 276 with oesophageal varices. Ann Surg, 1984; 200: 61
31. Kitano S, Terblanche J, Kahn J et al.: Venous anatomy of the lower 52. Paquet KJ, Kalk JF, Klein CP et al.: Prophylactic sclerotherapy for
oesophagus in portal hypertension: practical implications. Br J Surg, oesophageal varices in high-risk cirrhotic patients selected by endo-
1986; 73: 525 scopic and hemodynamic criteria. Endoscopy, 1994; 26: 734-740
32. Vianna A, Hayes PC, Moscoso G et al. Normal venous circulation of 53. De Franchis R, Primignani M: Why do varices bleed? Gastroenterol
the gastrooesophageal junction. Gastroenterology, 1987; 95: 876 Clin North Am, 1992; 21: 85
33. Spence RAJ, Terblanche J: Venous anatomy of the lower oesophagus: 54. Burroughs A, Mezzanotte G, Philipps A et al.: Cirrhotics with varceal
a new perspective on varicose. Br J Surg, 1987; 74: 659 haemorrhage: the importance of the time interval between admission
34. Hashizume M, Kitano S, Sugimachi K et al: Three-dimensional view and the start of analysis for survival and rebleeding.
of the vascular structure of the lower oesophagus in clinical portal 55. Trudeau W, Prindiville T: Endoscopic injection sclerosis in bleeding
hypertension. Hepatology, 1988; 8: 1482 gastric varices. Gastrointest Endosc, 1986; 32: 264
35. Mc Cormack TT, Rose JD, Smith PM et al: Perforation veins and 56. Lebrec D, Benhamou JP (1985) Ectopic varices in portal hyperten-
blood flow in oesophageal varices. Lancet, 1983; 24: 1442 sion. Clin Gastroenterol, 1985; 14: 105
36. Noda T: Angioarchitectural study of oesophageal varices – with spe- 57. Sauerbruch T, Weinzierl M, Dietrich HP et al.: Sclerotherapy of a
cial reference to variceal rupture. Virchows Archiv, 1984; 404: 381 bleeding duodenal varix. Endoscopy, 1982; 14: 187
927
Clinical Research
58. Paquet KJ, Lazar A, Bickart J: Massive and recurrent gastrointestinal 63. Staritz M, Meyer zum Büschenfelde KH: The endoscopic measure-
haemorrhage due to jejunal varices in afferent loop – diagnosis and ment of intravascular pressure and flow in oesophageal varices. J
management. Hepato-Gastroenterology, 1994; 41: 276-277 Hepatology, 1988; 7: 126-131
59. Rigau J, Bosch J, Bordaz JM et al.: Endoscopic measurement of 64. Bosch J, Bordas JM, Rigau J et al.: Non invasive measurement of the
variceal pressure cirrhosis. Correlation with portal pressure and pressure in oesophageal varices using and endoscopic gauge: compari-
variceal haemorrhage. Gastroenterology, 1989; 96: 873-880 son with the measurements by variceal puncture in patients undergo-
60. Vialett A, Magelau D et al.: Haemodynamic evaluation of patients ing endoscopic sclerotherapy. Hepatology, 1986; 6: 667-672
with intrahepatic portal hypertension. Relationship between bleeding 65. Gersch, P: Endoscopic non-invasive manometry of oesophageal
varices and the portohepatic gradient. Gastroenterology, 1975; 68: varices: prognostic significance. Am J Surg, 1982; 144: 528-530
1297-1300 66. Gross E, Erhard J: Endoskopisch geführte Druckmessung in distalen
61. Koch H, Henning H, Grimm H et al.: Prophylactic endoscopic scle- Ösophagusvarizen. Dtsch Med Wschr, 1987; 112: 125-127
rotherapy of oesophageal varices – results of a prospective controlled 67. Ready JB, Robertson AD, Gow JS et al.: Assessment of the risk of
study. Endoscopy, 1986; 18: 40-43 bleeding from oesophageal varices by continous monitoring of portal
62. Sauerbruch T, Kleber G, Gerdes A et al.: Prophylaxis of first variceal pressure. Gastroenterology, 1991; 100: 1403-1410
haemorrhage in patients with liver cirrhosis. Klein Wschr, 1986; 64:
1267-1275
928
Index Copernicus
Global Scientific Information Systems
for Scientists by Scientists
www. IndexCopernicus.com
IC Grant Awareness
IC Lab & Clinical Trial Register
Need grant assistance?
IC Conferences
Step-by-step information on Provides list of on-going laboratory
Effective search tool for how to apply for a grant. Provides or clinical trials, including
worldwide medical conferences a list of grant institutions and research summaries and calls for
and local meetings. their requirements. co-investigators.