Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Full Costing Book - CA Sanjeev Mittal
Full Costing Book - CA Sanjeev Mittal
----PREFACE----
It gives me immense pleasure to present this book “-------”. A best way revises all concepts and
formulas for CA Inter Cost and Management Accounting.
This book is prepared keeping “concept clarity and formulas” is of utmost importance. This will help the
students to grasp the ocean of syllabus in a shorter span of time.
Contents
Chapter 2: Material Costing ............................................................................................................ 3
EOQ Formula:
Annual Requirement of Raw Material
Total Ordering Cost = ∗ 𝑂𝑟𝑑𝑒𝑟𝑖𝑛𝑔 𝐶𝑜𝑠𝑡 𝑝𝑒𝑟 𝑂𝑟𝑑𝑒𝑟
Quantity Ordered Each Time
Concept 3: EOQ in range type-question Range type question are those question in purchase price per
unit decreases as order size is increased from one range to another.
Step 1: Calculate EOQ for each range.
Step 2: If EOQ falls within respective range then it will be valid EOQ otherwise invalid EOQ. (We may find
more than 1 EOQ size)
Annual requirement of raw material (A) will be same in all range.
Ordering cost per order (O) shall also remain same in all range
Carrying cost (C) will change in each range if it will be based on as a % of purchase price.
Lead Time: it is time gap between date of placing the order with supplier and date of receipt of ordered
material.
4 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Concept 6: Minimum Level / Maximum Level / Average Stock Level / Danger Level
Minimum Level: it is that level of stock below which stock in hand of raw material should not be allowed
to fall otherwise stock out.
Formula = Re-order Level – (Avg. Usage X Avg. Lead Time)
Maximum level: it is that level of stock above which stock in hand of raw material should not be allowed
to exceed otherwise high carrying cost.
Danger Level: It is the level at which raw material kept for emergency is used for production of Finished
Goods, (Normal issues of raw material is not possible).
Danger Level = Avg. Usage X Max. Lead Time for emergency purchase
Concept 7: Material Turnover Ratio / Inventory Turnover Ratio for raw material
It is a ratio between raw material consumed during a year and average stock of raw material maintained
during the year
Raw Material Consumed During the year
Formula = Average Stock of Raw Material
5 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Total wages
Effective Wage Rate = Total Actual hours worked
We call flux as ―Ful ‖ just to learn formula Labour turnover under Flux method
Flux 2: (If fresh recruitment due to expansion considered) =
No. of separations in a year+No. of accessions
Average no. of workers on the roll during the period
*100
Chapter 4: Overheads
Concept 1: Concept Overheads meaning and Recovery Rates / Overhead absorption rate: 5 Methods
a) Percentage of direct material cost = ∗ 100
Concept 2:
Allocation of overheads VS apportionment of overheads:
Allocation means charging a full amount of overhead directly to a department for which this amount has
been incurred.
Apportionment of overheads: when separate identification of overhead department-wise is not possible
then we have to divide cost of whole overheads among all departments on logical basis then it is called
apportionment of overheads.
Concept 3:
Treatment of under/over absorption (Recovery) of overheads:
Under absorption of OH means that amount of OH absorbed over products is less than the amount of
actual OH incurred.
Over absorption of OH means that amount of OH absorbed over products is more than the amount of
actual OH incurred
Accounting Treatment:
Under or over absorbed overheads are disposed off by any of following methods:
a. One method suggest that the under or over absorbed overheads should be charged to costing profit &
loss account as loss or profit
b. Second method suggest that unabsorbed / over absorbed overheads should be charged to WIP,
Finished goods- stock and units sold (Traditional break-up method) by using supplementary rate
10 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Note1:
Under absorbed overhead
Supplementary Recovery Rate = Total units of production including equivalent WIP
Note 2: The under absorbed overhead relating to inefficiency or defective planning or defective
production policy is abnormal loss hence it is charged to profit and loss account as loss.
Note 3: For calculation of unabsorbed / over absorption OH, Actual overhead incurred should not include
nonrecurring expenses
amount paid to worker as per court order
previous years’ expenses booked to current year
wages paid in strike period
obsolete stores written off
1) Repeated / continuous distribution method: Following steps shall be applied under this method
assuming 3 production deptt. As P1, P2, P3 and 3 service deptt. S1, S2 and S3.
S.1 Original Cost of S1 is distributed among P1, P2, P3, S2 and S3 in given %.(1:5)
S.2 Original Cost of S2 Plus shared cost from S1 is distributed among P1, P2, P3, S1, S3 in given %.(1:5)
S.3 Original cost of S3 plus shared cost from S1 & S2 is distributed among P1, P2, P3, S1 and S2 in given
%.(1:5)
S.4 Repeat the above step -1, step – 2 and then step - 3 until cost of S1, S2 and S3 becomes small
figure. (Rs. 100 or Rs. 200). Now distribute this small figure over P1, P2 and P3
2) Trial and error method: Following steps are applied under this method assuming 3 production deptt.
As P1, P2, P3 and 3 service deptt. S1, S2 and S3.
S.1Original Cost of S1 is distributed among S2 and S3 in given %.(1:2) (No amount shall be reduced from
S1)
S.2 Original Cost of S2 along with shared cost from S1 is distributed among S1 & S3 in given %.(1:2)(No
amount shall be reduced from S2)
S.3 Original Cost of S3 along with shared cost from S1 & S2 is distributed among S1 & S2 in given %.
(1:2)(No amount shall be reduced from S3)
11 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
S.4 Repeat the process of distribution again beginning with S1 until the additional amount becomes
small amount (Rs.1 or Rs.2)
Note: Original cost is shared only once and additional cost is shared again and again.
S.5 Now distribute the [100% - Share of other Service Deptt. ] cost of S1, S2 and S3 among P1, P2 and
P3 only once.
Simultaneous equation method: Following steps are applied under this method assuming 3 production
deptt. As P1, P2, P3 and 2 service deptt. S1 and S2.
S.1 Make2 equation to show the total cost of S1 & S2 including its share (%) in S2 & S1 respectively.
S.2 Solve these 2 equations to find out the cost of S1 and S2.(Called Calculated Cost)
S.3 This calculated cost of S1 and S2 is then distributed only once over production deptt and service
dept. in given %.
Step ladder method: following steps are applied under this method assuming 3 production deptt. As P1,
P2, P3 and 4 service deptt. S1, S2, S3 & S4
S1 provide services to P1, P2, P3, S2, S3 & S4. (1:6)
S2 provide services to P1, P2, P3, S3 & S4. (1:5)
S3 provides services to P1, P2, P3 and S4. (1:4)
S4 provides services to P1, P2 & P3. (1:3)
S.1 Original Cost of S1 is distributed among P1, P2, P3, S2, S3 & S4.
S. 2 Original Cost of S2 along with shared cost from S1 is distributed among P1, P2, P3, S3 & S4.
S.3 Original Cost of S3 along with shared cost from S1 & S2is distributed among P1, P2, P3 and S4.
S.4 Original Cost of S4 along with shared cost from S1, S2& S3is distributed among P1, P2 & P3.
Concept 6:
Machine hour rate: while calculating machine hour rate,
Machine hour rate =
All expenses related to operating of machine are divided into fixed/standing charges and
running/machine expenses.
Comprehensive machine hour rate =Simple machine hour rate +direct wages per machine hour
𝑇𝑜𝑎𝑙 𝑑𝑖𝑟𝑒𝑐𝑡 𝑤𝑎𝑔𝑒𝑠
𝑇𝑜𝑡𝑎𝑙 𝑚𝑎𝑐ℎ𝑖𝑛𝑒 ℎ𝑜𝑢𝑟𝑠
Particulars Hours
Less:- Hours spent on holidays, festivals, Sundays, repair & maintenance (XXX)
Note: Depreciation of machine shall be fixed exp. if life of machine is based on Time OR Depreciation of
machine shall be variable exp. if life of machine is based on machine hours. Depreciation of factory
building shall always be fixed.
14 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Concept No. 1: Under Absorption Technique: Overhead cost is allocated over products on Single recovery
rate. This overhead recovery rate is calculated on the basis of:
1. Budgeted Output (Overhead Recovery Rate = ∗ 100
This absorption technique is also called traditional / conventional method. Under ABC Costing, Overhead
costs (Indirect Costs) is apportioned over different products on some reasonable basis. Overhead which
is activity oriented i.e. overhead which increases or decreases on increase or decrease in number of
activities i.e. set-up cost is indirect cost (OH) which will increase if number of set-ups on machine
increases and vice-versa. Inspection charges will increase if inspection in factory is conducted more
times.
3. Overhead which is not activity oriented i.e. overhead which is not affected by increase or decrease in
number of activities e.g. factory rent, depreciation on machine on SLM. This overhead is apportioned
among products using single recovery rate.
2. Statement of Cost
15 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
4. Indirect cost is overhead cost which may be production overhead, office & administration
overhead and Selling & distribution overheads.
First, we produce goods in factory (Factory OH incurred), then transfer these goods to showroom/shops
(Admin OH incurred), then we give job to Vivek Bindra for advertisement and finally receive order
through Amazon.com (Selling & distribution OH incurred).
Total Cost
Note 1: - Per unit Cost = Total Units
Conversion cost: It means cost incurred to convert raw material into finished goods.
Method 1: Conversion cost = direct Labour cost + direct expenses + factory overheads
Method 2: Conversion Cost = Factory Cost – Direct material cost
Concept 1: Valuation of closing stock – Absorption method & marginal cost method
Condition 1: if stocks are valued on marginal cost basis. Cost per unit of closing stock of FG shall be
Sum of only variable portion till cost of production.
Note: if nothing is given in question, we will assume absorption method to be followed.
Concept 2: How to categorize a cost into variable cost & fixed cost.
A Cost, which is same on per unit basis under different production level, is variable cost per unit.
Fixed portion in semi-variable cost = Total Cost – Variable portion (Units x variable portion per unit).
Concept 3: Apportionment of total cost in various products (How to calculate separate cost of 2
products if collective cost is given)
Total direct material cost of product A & B = Rs. 100000
Total direct Labour cost of product A & B = Rs. 200000
Units produced for product A is 1000 units and units produced for product B is 2000 units.
Calculate total material cost of A & B under each case?
Case 1:
Material cost ratio per unit (A:B) = 1:2
19 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Concept No. 1:
Meaning of integrated and non-integrated Accounts
Under non-integrated accounts - 2 sets of books are maintained. Cost records are maintained separate
while financial records are maintained separate.
Under integrated accounts, only 1 set of books is maintained & entries are made both for cost and
financial records e.g. Financial entries like cash paid to creditor and cash received from debtors shall
also be passed.
Most accounts are added with word ―Con lA un ‖.
Concept No. 2:
1. Raw Material / Stores – Stores Ledger Control Account.
2. Wages – Wages Control Account.
3. Factory – WIP Ledger Control Account.
4. Warehouse – Finished goods Ledger control Account.
5. Shop – Cost of Sales Account
Concept No. 3:
General Ledger Adjustment A/c (GLA A/c) OR Cost Ledger Control A/c OR Nominal ledger control A/c
Financial entries are not considered in cost sheet e.g. cash paid to creditors and cash received from
customers but in real world, these transactions happens. GLA account shall be used in place of account
not opened while preparing cost sheet e.g. share capital, reserve and surplus, debtors, creditors etc. For
Example
If management decides to charge the amount of under/over recovery of overheads in current year then
current year’s under/over recovery shall be transferred to current year’s profit & loss account.
CONCLUSION:
Account No. 1:
SLC Accounts is like material purchase account hence it is
Debited with opening stock of raw material and purchase of material
Credited with issue of material and closing stock of material.
Concept 1:
Concept Job Costing is that form of specific order costing under which each job is treated as a cost
unit and costs are ascertained separately for each job. A job may consist of a job, product, a service
or any other specific order. e.g. Visiting Cards
Concept 2:
Economic Batch Quantity (EBQ)
Meaning EBQ refers to the optimum quantity batch at
which Set up & Processing Costs and Carrying
Costs are together minimized.
2*Annual Demand*Set up cost per batch
Formula E.B.Q = √ Cost of carrying per unit of production per annum
26 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Concept 2:
There are 2 parties in a contract i.e. A contractor and A contractee. Contractor is the person who
undertakes the contract and contractee is the person who gives the contract.
Concept 3:
At the end of each year, work completed till end is checked & certified by architect of contractee. Now
contractee makes payment to contractor on the basis of work completed & certified. Normally
contractee pays only 80% to 90% of value of work certified as completed and remaining amount is kept
by contractee security money which is paid on 100% completion
of contract. Concept Value of work certified: It is expressed as a % of the contract price.
Example:
If contract price is Rs. 10 Lakh & work certified is 60% then value of work certified shall be 6 lakh
(contract price x work certified as %).
Concept 4:
Retention money: it is that portion of value of work certified which has not been paid by contractee and
kept as security money for future defective work.
Retention money = Value of work certified – Cash received by contractor
Concept 5:
Work uncertified: it is that portion of work which has been completed by contractor but has not been
certified by architect of contractee. We calculate cost here, not value
Cost of work uncertified = Total cost incurred till date – Cost of work certified
Concept 6:
Notional profit:
Value of work certified – Cost of work certified.
Note: Estimated Total Profit = Total Contract Price – Estimated Total Cost
Note: Estimated Total Cost = Cost of Contract up to date + Costs to be incurred
27 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Concept 9:
Contract account and Balance sheet is prepared in the following manner:
Particulars Rs. Particulars Rs.
To material issued to site XXX By Materials at site (Closing Stock)
To wages incurred (Paid + O/s – Prepaid) XXX By Materials returned from site
i.e. returned to stores
To Direct expenses (Paid + O/s – Prepaid) XXX By Bank A/c (Sale of Materials)
To Depreciation on Plant & Equipment XXX By Costing P&L A/c (Loss on sale)
To office & Adm. Exp. Incurred (Paid +O/s XXX
Prepaid)
XXX
To Cost of Contract b/d XXX By Work-in-progress
To Notional Profit c/d XXX — Value of Work certified (Like Sale)
XXX — Cost of Work Uncertified (Like closing
stock)
Concept: 1.
When 2 or more process are required in manufacturing a product then concepts of process costing
chapter are used to calculate
All cost incurred in each process.
Cost of FG transferred to next process.
Cost of FG directly sold in market& held as stock Hence a process account is prepared for each
process for above purposes.
Concept 2:
2 types of losses arise in process costing:
1. Normal loss: - loss which arise generally. Suppose 10,000 units are introduced in process & 2% is
normal loss then 200 units will be normal loss units.
2. Abnormal loss: - if Actual loss is above normal loss. If in above example, 300 units are lost in
processing then 100 units are abnormal loss
Sometimes actual loss is less than normal loss. If in above example, only 150 units are lost in processing
then 50 units are treated as abnormal gain.
Concept 4:
How to prepare Process A/c when output of one process is transferred to next process at an amount
higher than its cost.
Inter-process profit: when output of one process is transferred to next process not at cost but at
transfer price. Transfer price means cost plus some profit. In such case, transferor process makes some
profit. Under inter-process profit, we shall make 3 columns in process and finished goods a/c i.e. cost,
profit and total.
Under cost column, all cost is shown as incurred by company. Under profit column, profit included in
opening stock, closing stock and transfer is shown Under total column, total of both cost and profit is
shown. Transfer price is calculated as shown below for valuation of inventory at prime cost
Concept 5
How to prepare process A/c when Opening and closing work in progress (not 100% complete) is given
cost item wise.
Method 1: When FIFO method is used Method
2: When average method is used
32 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
In both above methods, we have to prepare additional 3 statements in addition to process A/c, Finished
goods A/c, normal loss A/c, Abnormal loss A/c etc. as follows:
Statement 1: Prepare Statement of Equivalent Production
Statement 2: Prepare Statement of Cost per Equivalent Unit
Statement 3: Prepare Statement of Evaluation
Under statement 1: St. of equivalent production (a) We calculate equivalent production units for
incomplete units using following formula: Equivalent production units (EPU) = No. of units x degree (%)
of completion performed in current period
EPU is calculated separately for each element of cost e.g. material, labour &OH because % of
completion with regard to each element of cost is different.
Output units =
Opening WIP now completed
+ units introduced in current period and completed
+ Units introduced in current period and not 100% complete till end i.e. Closing WIP
+ Normal loss units
+ abnormal loss units
– abnormal gain units
Under statement 2: St. of cost per equivalent production (a) We calculate cost per equivalent unit e.g.
material cost per equivalent unit, labour cost per equivalent unit and overhead cost per unit.
Cost per element = Cost Divide by Equivalent element units
33 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Case 1: Preparation of Process A/c when opening and closing WIP is given and FIFO method is followed
(a) FIFO means units transferred as 100% complete shall comprise all opening WIP and balance from
units introduced in current period.
Units Introduced and completed = Units Transferred - Opening WIP
Particulars Units Particulars Units % Com Units % Com Units % Com Units
Opening Opening
WIP WIP
Completed
Add: Units Units
Introduced Introduced
and
Complete
(Units
Transferred
– Op. WIP)
Closing WIP
Normal
Loss
Abnormal
Loss
Less:
Abnormal
Gain
Process Account
Particulars Units Amount Particulars Units Amount
To input Material By Normal Loss (Scrap Value per unit
* Normal Loss Units)
To All expenses By Abnormal Loss (Cost per Normal
Units * Abnormal
Units)
To Abnormal Gain (Cost per Normal By Next Process (Cost per Normal
Units * Abnormal units) * Finished
Units) Units
By Closing WIP
Case 2: Prepare Process A/c - opening and closing WIP is given and average method is followed
(a) Average method is used when it is not possible to identify opening WIP units in units transferred to
next process. Hence it is not possible to bifurcate Units Transferred into opening WIP and units
introduced & completed.
(b) Average cost per equivalent unit is calculated =
(c) Total Cost of units Transferred to next process = Equivalent Units x Average Cost per unit
Process Account
Particulars Units Amount Particulars Units Amount
To input Material By Normal Loss (Scrap Value per unit
* Normal Loss Units)
To All expenses By Abnormal Loss (Cost per Normal
Units * Abnormal
Units)
To Abnormal Gain (Cost per Normal By Next Process (Cost per Normal
Units * Abnormal units) * Finished
Units) Units
By Closing WIP
38 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Concept 1:
Distribution of joint cost among the joint’s products. For this purpose, following methods may be
adopted:
Method 1:
Physical unit method: - Joint cost is distributed in ratio of quantity manufactured. Physical unit
method: - Joint cost is distributed in ratio of quantity manufactured.
Method 2:
Sale value at separation point method: Joint cost is distributed in ratio of sales value at split off point.
Sale value at split off point = No. of units produced x selling price
Method 3:
Net realizable value (NRV) method: Joint costs are apportioned in the ratio of net realizable values of
joint products at separation point. NRV is calculated as follows:
Sale Value after further processing
(units manufactured * Selling Price)
Less: Further Processing Cost
Net Realizable Value
Method 4:
Average Unit Cost Method:
Average unit cost method: under this method, first average cost per unit is calculated using following
formula:-
Average Cost per unit = .
Share of each product in joint cost = No. of units of each product X Average cost per unit
39 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Method 5:
Contribution margin method
Under this method, joint costs are divided into variable cost and fixed cost.
Variable cost portion of joint cost is divided among products on the basis of physical units (Quantity /
Units Ratio)
Fixed cost portion of joint cost is divided among products on the basis of contribution ratio.
Contribution Ratio =
Method 6:
Constant Gross Margin Method:
Joint cost of joint products is calculated as balancing figure.
Particulars Product A Product B
Sale Value after further
processing
(No. of units manufactured *
Selling Price)
Less: Further Processing Cost
Less: Gross Margin (Sales *
Gross Margin Ratio)
Joint Cost Allocated
Gross Margin % =
Note:-Joint cost calculated under this method may be negative sometimes since balancing figure.
Note:-Joint cost calculated among all methods need not to be same
40 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Concept 2:
Decision as to go for further processing or not.
Yes process if incremental sales < incremental cost i.e. if Profit increases.
Decision: Go for further processing if profit increase as a result of further processing otherwise don’t go
for further processing.
Concept 3:
How to calculate joint cost of main products and by-products
When 2 or more products arise from same process using same raw material and almost of equal
importance they are called joint products but when any product has less selling price in market. It is
called by-products.
Step 2: Calculate Joint cost of main product = Total joint cost of all products -Net joint cost of all by-
product.
41 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Concept 2:
Various cost per unit shall be calculated as follows:
Service Provider Cost per unit Cost per unit Calculation
Ola Cab / Taxi Cost per Km. Total Cost of Operating
Total kms. run
School Bus, Chartered Bus, Railways, Airlines Cost per passenger Total Cost of operating
Total Passengers
Metro, DTC Bus Cost per passenger per km Total Cost of operating
Total passengers-kms
Goods Transport Service providers Cost per tonne per km Total Cost of operating
Total Tonnes-Kms
Concept 3:
1. We shall divide all expenses of transport industry in following 2 categories
a. Fixed Exp. / Standing Charges: as the name suggest, these charges are fixed by nature
and not dependent on running of a vehicle. Salary to driver, Insurance, Road Tax etc.
b. Running Charges / Variable Exp: as the name suggest, these charges are variable and
purely dependent on running of vehicle like petrol exp. diesel, Repairs.
Note 1: On Depreciation
Depreciation of vehicle shall be treated as Fixed expenses if life of vehicle is given in number of
years.
Depreciation shall be treated as variable expenses if life of vehicle is given in number of
kilometers.
If Nothing is given in question, we will assume depreciation to be Fixed Cost
Concept 4
Tonne km are of 2 types:
Absolute Tonne Km = Weight in tonne x km run
Commercial Tonne – Km – Total Km x Avg. Tonne Km.
Note: If nothing is specified in question then absolute tonne km shall be used to calculate cost per
tonne-km.
Concept 5
Total Collection for transport industry is called as total takings.
Particulars Amount (Rs.)
Total operating Cost XXX
Add: Profit XXX
Net Takings XXX
Add: Passenger Tax XXX
Total Takings XXX
Total Cost
Cost per unit of electricity generated = Total Units Generated
44 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Full Topic contains discussion over “should be (kitna Lagna Chiye tha)” and “Actual
happened(Kitna Laga)”.
Variance means comparison of actual and standard and their difference.
Variance may be Favorable or Adverse (unfavorable).
We will study mainly 5 types of variance
1. Material variances
2. Labour variances
3. Overhead variances
4. Sales variances
5. Profit variances
Actual cost if more than standard cost then Adverse variance & vice-versa.
Actual Sales & profit if more than standard sales & profit then favorable variance & vice-versa.
Example A student set standard time to study each day as 8 hours while actual time studied is 6
hours then 2 hours shall be variance. In this example, variance is unfavorable.
We will follow 8 box approach for standard costing chapter formula learning. Boxes are as follows: -
1. Material Variances
2. Labour Variances (Without Idle Time)
3. Labour Variances (With Idle Time)
4. Variable Overhead Variances
5. Fixed Overhead Variances (Without Calendar Variance)
6. Fixed Overhead Variances (With Calendar Variance)
7. Sales Variances
8. Profit Variances
Budgeted input for actual output = Actual output x budgeted input for 1 unit of output
45 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Trick to learn
1. Numerator shall always be same.
2. Input me divide and output me multiply arrange.
Concept 1:
Direct material variances: 5 Types
DMCV = Arise when total std material cost and total actual material cost is different.
DMUV = Arise when std material quantity and actually used material qty is different.
DMPV = Arise when std. price per unit and actual price per unit is different.
DMYV & DMMV= Arise when direct material is of 2 types or more and standard material mix ratio
is not followed.
Example:
Std Qty ratio for RM1 & RM2 1:1 while Actual Qty Ratio 3:1 (Raw material mix ratio)
DMCV = DMUV + DMPV
DMUV = DMYV + DMMV
RSQ = Revised standard quantity = it means total actual input in standard quantity ratio.
DMCV = M1 – M4
DMUV = M1 – M3
DMPV = M3 – M4
DMYV = M1 – M2
DMMV = M2 – M3
1. Production manager is responsible for DMUV thereby for DMYV and DMMV.
46 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Concept 2:
Material Price Variance at time of purchase: -DMPV is computed for the actual quantity of material
consumed. If AQ consumed is replaced by AQ Purchased then the result is known Direct material
purchase price variance (MPPV).
Formula: -
MPPV = SP x AQP –AP x AQP Where AQP = Actual Quantity purchased.
Concept 3:
ALTERNATIVE WAY TO CALCULATE DMYV
∑ M1 Actual input
DMYV = Actual output * (Actual output - budgeted input for 1 unit of output
Concept 4:
Direct Labour variances
Labour variances
Case 1: - Workers do not sit idle (Without Idle Case 2: -
Time) Worker sometimes sit idle (With Idle Time)
Unskilled
Total L1 L2 L3 L4
Case 2
When worker sometimes sit idle i.e. With idle time
Idle Time = Actual hours Paid (AHP) – Actual hours worked (AHW)
Labour variances:
Particulars SR X SHAO SR X RSH SR X AH AR X AH
Skilled
Semiskilled
Unskilled
Total L1 L2 L3 L4
Concept 5:
Labour Efficiency Ratio
Link to ACE (Activity, Capacity, Efficiency) ratio = SAS / BBA
Standard hours
Labour Efficiency Ratio = Actual hours
*100
48 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Standard cost
Standard labour cost per unit = No. of units produced
Actual Cost
Actual labour cost per unit = No. of units produced
Concept 6:
Overhead variance
Overhead means all indirect cost. Indirect cost means cost which is not directly connected to
production.
Overhead is of 2 types
1. Variable OH e.g. Electricity consumed on running of machine
2. Fixed OH e.g. Factory Rent.
Budget OH
1) Budgeted OH per unit = Budgeted Ouput
Actual OH
Actual OH per unit = Actual Output
Budgeted OH
2) Budgeted OH per hour = Budgeted hours
Actual OH
Actual OH per hour = Actual hours
3) Standard Hour for Actual Output = Actual Output x Std hour required for 1 unit of output
Expected output in actual hours = Actual hours * Std output (units) produced in 1 hour
Actual hours
Budgeted input for 1 unit of output
Expected Output in Actual Hours = Actual hours x Std output (units) produced in 1 hour
Actual days
Budgeted input for 1 unit of output
49 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
VOCV = VO 1 – VO 3
VO Eff. V = VO 1 – VO 2
VO Exp. V = VO 2 – VO 3
Case 1:
Fixed OH Variances (Without calender variance): -
Identification of calender variance: when information about budgeted days and actual days is given in
question then calender variance is to be calculated. It is covered in case 3.
FOCV = FO 1 – FO 4
FOVV = FO 1 – FO 3
FO Exp. V =FO 3 – FO 4
FO Eff. V = FO 1 – FO 2
FO Cap. V =FO 2 – FO 3
FOH Cost Var. = FOH Volume Var. + FOH Exp. Var.
FOH Volume Var. = FOH Efficiency Var. + FOH Capacity Var.
Case 2:
Fixed OH (with Calender Variance): -
Computation of Fixed Overheads variances
Output Absorbed Input absorbed Possible Budgeted Actual
F. OH F. OH F. OH F. OH F. OH
FO 1 FO 2 FO 3 FO 4 FO 5
FOCV = FO 1 – FO 5
FOVV = FO 1 – FO 4
FO Exp. V=FO 4 – FO 5
FO Eff. V =FO 1 – FO 2
FO Cap. V = FO 2 – FO 3
FO Cal. V =FO 3 – FO 4
FOH Cost Var. = FOH Volume Var. + FOH Exp. Var.
FOH Volume Var. = FOH Efficiency Var. + FOH Capacity Var. +
FOH Calendar Var.
Calender variance: A student planned to study for 24 days in a month & actually studied for 20 days.
This is calender variance.
51 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Capacity variance: A student planned to study for 10 hours in a day & actually studied 8 hours. This is
capacity variance.
Efficiency variance: A student studied 8 hours & completed 10 costing questions while these 10
questions must have been studied in 5 hours. This is efficiency variance.
Concept 7:
1) Sales Value Var. = Arise when budgeted sales value & actual sales value is different. Budget –
Sale for Rs. 200 but Actual Sales for Rs. 150 then Rs. 50 is sales value var.
2) Sales volume var. = Arise when budgeted sales volume & actual sales volume is different. Budget
– Sale for 200 units but Actual Sales for 150 units then 50 units is sales volume var.
3) Sales price var. = Arise when budgeted selling price & actual selling price per unit is different.
Budget – selling price for a unit is Rs. 100 but Actual – selling price for a unit is Rs. 60 then Rs.
40 is sales price var.
4) Sales Qty & MIX var. = Arise when product sold is of 2 types or more and budgeted sales (units)
ratio is not followed.
Budgeted S.P. per unit Budgeted S.P. per unit X Budgeted S.P. per Actual S.P.per unit
X Budgeted Qty Revised Std. Qty unit X Actual Qty x Actual Qty
S1 S2 S3 S4
Concept 8:
Profit variances: - 5 Types
Profit = Margin = Selling Price per unit – cost per unit
1) Profit Value Var. = Arise when budgeted value of profit & actual value of profit is different.
2) Profit price Var. = Arise when profit changes due to difference in budgeted selling price & actual
selling price p.u.
3) Profit Volume Var. = Arise when profit changes due to difference in budgeted sales Qty & actual
sales Qty.
52 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
4) Profit Qty & Mix Var. = Arise when sold product is of 2 types or more and budgeted sales (units)
ratio is not followed.
Budgeted Margin per Budgeted Margin per unit x Budgeted Margin per Actual Margin per
unit x Budgeted Qty Revised Std. Qty unit x Actual Qty unit x Actual Qty
P1 P2 P3 P4
P Val. V = P4 – P1
PPV = P4 – P3
P Vol. V =P3 – P1
P Mix V =P3 – P2
PQV = P2 – P1
Concept 9:
Production Volume Variance
It is that part of budgeted Fixed OH which is related to unutilized capacity of factory.
Formula = Unutilized capacity x Budgeted FOH per unit
Unutilized capacity = Actual capacity – budgeted capacity
Concept 10:
OH exp. Variance
It is difference between total budgeted OH cost (Fixed & variable) and actual OH cost (Fixed &
variable).
Formula = budgeted OH – Actual OH
Budgeted OH = budgeted FOH for budgeted production capacity + budgeted VOH for actual
production capacity.
53 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Concept 6: Contribution to Sales Ratio (Generally Known as PV Ratio): ∗ 100 (𝐼𝑛 𝑝𝑒𝑟𝑐𝑒𝑛𝑡𝑎𝑔𝑒)
Concept 7: In marginal costing, fixed cost is ignored for decision making. Hence If there is no fixed cost
then all contribution shall be profit so contribution to sales ratio is called Profit-volume ratio or P/V
ratio.
Contribution = Sales x P/V Ratio
PV RATIO = ∗ 100 OR ∗ 100 OR ∗ 100
54 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Concept 8: Break Even Sales means sales at which there is no profit no loss to the company.
Units Sold [BEP (In units)] =
Sales in Rupees:
Since at Breakeven point profit shall be zero and sales shall be called break even sales
P/v ratio = ∗ 100
Concept 10: How calculate P/V Ratio when profit and sales volume of 2 periods are given.
P/V Ratio =
Concept 12: Break Even Sales Ratio and MOS Sales Ratio
100% = Break Even Sales ratio + MOS Sales Ratio
Concept 15: Calculate sales level to earn desired profit given in question
Desired level of Sales (In units) =
A company has taken on rent a commercial space for 2 departments i.e. Dept. 1 & Dept. 2. Product A is
manufactured in dept. 1 and product B is manufactured in dept. 2. Rent given for whole commercial
space is Unavoidable FC while salary paid to manager of each department is avoidable FC
1. If actual sales are equal to or more than SDP Sales then it is better to continue production
2. If actual sales are more than SDP sales then it is better to shut down the production.
Concept 1: Budget: - it means the establishment of future targets on the basis of past experience and
other relevant factors.
Capacity Ratio =
Efficiency Ratio =
Fixed portion in semi variable cost = Total semi variable cost – Total variable portion in semi-variable
cost.
Concept 9: Formats
Production Budget
Sales
Add: Closing Stock
Less: Opening Stock
= Production
Question: 1:
Write short notes on
(i) Conversion Cost
(ii) Sunk Cost
(iii) Opportunity Cost
(May 2018, Nov 2016, May 2003)
Solutions:
(i) Conversion cost: It is the cost incurred to convert raw materials into finished goods. It is the sum of
direct wages, direct expenses and manufacturing overheads.
Formula:
Conversion Cost = Direct Labour Cost + Direct Expenses + Manufacturing Overhead
Or
Conversion Cost = Factory Cost - Direct Materials Cost.
(ii)Sunk Costs: Sunk costs are the historical costs which are incurred in the past. They play no role in
decision making in the current period.
(iii)Opportunity Costs: Opportunity costs refers to the value of sacrifice made or benefit of
opportunity foregone in accepting alternative course of action. For e.g. a company accepts an expansion
plan and for financing, withdraws money1 from its bank deposits. Then, the loss of interest on the bank
deposits is the opportunity cost for carrying out the expansion plan. This cost plays an important role in
managerial decision making process although these costs are not recorded in books of accounts
Question: 2:
Identify the methods of costing where:
(i) all costs are directly charged to a specific job.
(ii) all costs are directly charged to a group of products.
(iii) the nature of the product is complex and method cannot be ascertained.
(iv) cost is ascertained for a single product.
(Nov 2017)
Solutions:
(i) Where all costs are directly charged to a specific job - Job Costing.
61 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
(ii)Where all costs are directly charged to a group of products - Batch Costing.
(iii) Where nature of the product is complex and method cannot be ascertain - Multiple Costing.
(iv) Where cost is ascertained for single product.
→ Uni C t / Sin C s i g/Out C s i g.
Question: 3:
Explain ‘Cost Unit’ and 'Cost Centre’.
(May 2017)
Solutions:
Cost Unit:
It is a unit of product, service or time (or combination of these) in relation to which costs is ascertained
or expressed. It is unit of measurement. For example the cost of carrying a passenger in terms of km,
cost of hotel room expressed as cost per day etc.
Cost Centre:
It is a location, person or an item of equipment (or group of these) for which cost is ascertained and
used for the purpose of cost control. The main purpose of ascertaining cost centre is to control the cost
and to fix responsibility of the person in charge of a cost centre.
Cost Centres are of two types:
1. Personal Cost Centre.
2. Impersonal Cost Centre.
Cost centres in a manufacturing concern:
1. Production Cost Centre
2. Service Cost Centre.
Question: 4:
State the difference between Cost Accounting and Management Accounting.
(May 2017)
Solutions:
Basis Cost Accounting Management
Accounting
1. Nature It records the quantitative aspect It records both qualitative and
only. quantitative aspect.
62 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 5:
Narrate the essential factors to be considered while designing and installing a Cost Accounting System.
(May 2017, Nov 2010, Nov 1999, May 1996)
Solutions:
Essential Factors for installing a Cost Accounting System:
1. Objective The objective of cost system should be considered before
installation. Whether to fix selling prices or control costs or
both.
2. Nature of Business The costing system, which is suitable to the business
organisation, should be introduced.
3. Organisational Costing system should fulfill the requirement of different level
Hierarchy of management. Organisation structure should be studied to
determine the manner in which costing system should be
introduced.
4. Knowing the Product Nature of Product determines the type of costing system to be
implemented. The product which has by-products requires
costing system which account for by-products as well.
5. Knowing the A good costing system can never be established without the
production complete knowledge of production process.
process
x Method of Maintenance of The manner in which Cost and Financial accounts could be inter-
cost records locked into a single integral accounting system and in which
63 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 6:
What is meant by ‘Cost Centre’? What are the different types of cost centres.
(Nov 2016, May 2016, May 2015, Nov 2002, May 1997)
Solutions:
Cost Centre
Meaning It is defined as a location, person, or an item of equipment (or group of these)
for which cost may be ascertained and used for the purpose of cost control. It
is a part of an organization that does not produce direct profits and adds to
the cost of running a company.
Eg. R&D, marketing departments, help desk and customer services.
Cost Centre are of two types:
(i) Personal (ii) Impersonal
A personal cost centre consists of a person and an impersonal Cost Centre of a location or item of
equipment.
1. Production Cost Centre It is cost centre where raw material is handled for conversion into
finished product. Here both direct and indirect expenses are incurred.
Machine shops, welding shops and assembly shops are examples of
production Cost Centre.
2. Service Cost Centre It is Cost Centre which serves as an ancillary unit to a production cost
centre. Power house, gas production shop, material service centres,
and plant maintenance centres are examples of service Cost Centre.
3. Profit Centre Centres, which have the responsibility of generating and maximizing
profits are called profit centres The profit centre’s revenues and
expenses are kept separate from the main company’s profit in order to
maintain the profit centre’s profitability.
4. investment Centres Investment centres are similar to profit centres but they have
additional decision rights in terms of capital expenditure and
investment. The manager is assumed to have better knowledge of
input and output markets but also investment opportunities.
64 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 7:
What is meant by ‘Profit Centre”?
(May 2016, Nov 1997)
Solutions:
A profit centre is the centre whose performance is measured in terms of income earned and cost
incurred. Its main responsibility is to generate and maximise profit.
Profit Centres is a branch or division of a company that is accounted for an a standalone basis for the
purpose of profit calculation. A profit center is responsible for generating its own result and earnings,
and as such, its managers generally name decision making authority related to product pricing and
operating expenses. Profit centres are crucial in determining which units are the most and least
profitable within as organisation.
Question: 8:
State the method of costing and also the unit of cost for the following industries:
(i) Hotel
(ii) Toy-making
(iii) Steel
(iv) Ship Building
(Nov 2015)
Solutions:
(i) Hotel:
•Method of costing used in hotel is Operating Costing.
•The rate for unit of cost used is per room, per day or per half day or per bed for costing.
(ii) Toy - Making:
•Method of costing used in toy making industry is Unit Costing/Batch Costing
•The unit of cost used in toy making industry is per unit of output of toy or per batch.
(iii) Steel:
•The method of costing used in steel company is Process Costing.
•The unit of cost used in costing is the percentage of output on the basis of the some factory
administrative overhead etc.
(iv) Ship Building:
•The method of costing used in ship buildings is Contract Costing.
•The unit cost or per unit used for ship building is Project or Unit.
65 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 9:
Identify the methods of costing for the following:
(i) Where all costs are directly charged to a specific job.
(ii) Where all costs are directly charged to a group of products.
(iii) Where cost is ascertained for a single product.
(Nov 2014)
Solutions:
Methods of costing are as follows:
(i) Job costing
(ii) Batch costing
(iii) Single / Output costing
(iv) Multiple costing.
Question: 10:
Distinguish Between Cost Control and Cost Reduction.
(May 2016, May 2014, Nov 2011)
Solutions:
Sl. No. Basis of Difference Cost Control Cost Reduction
1. Meaning Cost control is the guidance and Cost reduction is the
regulation by executive action of achievement of real and
the cost of operating an permanent reduction in the unit
undertaking. cost of goods and services
without impairing their
suitability.
2. Emphasis It emphasises on past It emphasises on present and
performance and variance future performance without
analysis. considering the past
performance.
3. Approach It is a conservative approach It is a dynamic approach where
which stresses on the conformity in every function is analysed in
to the set norms. view of its contribution.
4. Focus It is a short term review with It seeks to reduce unit cost on a
focus on reducing cost in a permanent basis based on a
particular period. systematic approach.
66 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 11:
Define Explicit costs. How is it different from Implicit costs?
(May 2014, May 2005, May 2001)
Solutions:
Explicit Cost: Explicit costs refers the cost, involving immediate payment of cash, such as - Salary,
wages, commissions etc. Such costs are easily measurable it is also known as out of pocket cost.
Implicit Costs: It do not involved any immediate cash payment. It is also known an economic costs.
The main difference between Explicit cost and Implicit costs are:
(i) Explicit costs involves immediate outflow of cash where as implicit costs do not involve immediate
cash payment.
(ii) Explicit costs are entered in the books of accounts. Where as implicit costs are not recorded in the
book of account.
Question: 12:
State the unit of cost for the followings :
1. Transport
2. Power
3. Hotel
4. Hospital
(May 2014)
Solutions:
Unit of Cost:
1. Transport Passenger km., Tonne km.
2. Power Per kilowatt – hours
3. Hotel Per room, per day
4. Hospital Patient per day, room per day or per bed, per operation, etc.
Question: 13:
Cost of a product or service is required to be expressed in suitable cost unit. State the cost units for
the following industries:
(i) Steel
67 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
(ii) Automobile
(iii) Transport
(iv) Power
(May 2003)
Solutions:
1. Steel Tonne
2. Automobile Numbers
3. Transport Passenger Kilo-meter//Tonne Kilo-meter
4. Power Kilo-watt hour (Kwh)
Question: 14:
State the types of cost in the following cases:
(i) Interest paid on own capital not involving any cash outflow.
(ii) Withdrawing money from bank deposit for the purpose of purchasing new machine for expansion
purpose.
(iii) Rent paid for the factory building which is temporarily closed.
(iv) Cost associated with the acquisition and conversion of material into finished product.
(May 2012)
Solutions:
Type of costs
(i) Imputed Cost
(ii) Opportunity Cost
(iii) Shut Down Cost
(iv) Product Cost
Question: 15:
What are the essentials of a good Cost Accounting System.
Solutions:
To be successful, a good cost accounting system should possess the following essential features:
1. Simple and easy The system to be simple practical, flexible & capable of meeting
to operate the requirements of a concern.
68 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
3. Cost-effective The cost of installing and operating the system should justify
the results. The benefit from the system should exceed the
amount to be spent on it.
4. Management’s The top management should have full faith in the costing system
Role and should provide help towards its development and success.
5. Relevance of Data The system should handle and report relevant data for use of
managers for decision making. It should not sacrifice its utility
by introducing meticulous and unnecessary details.
Question: 16:
Distinguish between cost units and cost centres.
Solutions:
Difference between Cost Unit and Cost Centre:
Cost Unit: It is a unit of production, service, time or a combination of these, in relation to which costs
may be ascertained or expressed, it should be one with which expenditure can be most readily associated
or ascertained. Cost Unit differs from one business to another. They are usually units of physical
measurement like weight, area, volume, number, time, length and value.
Some illustrations of cost unit are as follows:
Industry/Product/Input Cost Unit
Cement Tonne
Power Kilo watt hour
Cost Centre:
It is defined as:
(a) A location e.g. Noida plant, Hyderabad factory etc.
(b) A person e.g. Area sales officer, Manager etc.
(c) An item or equipment e.g. Machine 1, 2, or Process A, B, etc.
Or a group of these, for which cost can be ascertained and used for the purpose of cost control. Cost
centres are of two types viz. Personal and Impersonal.
Question: 17:
State the method of costing that would be most suitable for:
(a) Oil refinery
(b) Bicycle manufacturing
(c) Interior decoration
(d) Airlines company
(Nov 2018)
Solution:
1. Oil Refinery Process costing
2. Bicycle manufacturing Multiple costing
3. Interior decoration Job costing but if on a larger basis then Contract costing
70 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 18:
(i) Define the following :
(a) Imputed cost
(b) Capitalised cost.
(Nov 2009)
Solution:
(a) Imputed Cost: Imputed costs are notional costs which do not involve any cash outlay. Examples of
imputed cost are Interest on capital, the payment for which is not actually made, these costs are similar
to opportunity costs.
(b) Capitalised Cost: Capitalised costs are costs which are initially recorded as assets and subsequently
treated as expenses.
Question: 19:
Discuss cost classification on the basis of Controllability.
(May 2018, Nov 2004, May 2003, Nov 2001, May 2001)
Solution:
Classification on the basis of Controllability:
On the basis of controllability cost is classified into two types:
1. Controllable cost
2. Non-controllable cost
1. Controllable cost: CIMA defines controllable cost as “Cost chargeable to a cost centre, which can be
influenced by the action of the person in whom control of the centre is vested.”
In practice all variable cost are controllable cost.
Example: Direct cost i.e. direct material cost, direct laour cost.
2. Non-Controllable Cost: CIMA defines non-controllable cost as a “Cost chargeable to a cost centre
which cannot be influenced by the action of the person in whom control of the centre is vested.”
In practice all fixed costs are non-controllable cost. Therefore such cost cannot be controlled by the
responsibility manager.
71 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Example: Expenditure on any service department is controlled by the manager of that service
department but if such expenditure is apportioned to production on dept, then manager of that
production dept, cannot control the expenditure of the service department.
Question: 20:
Distinguish between the following:
(i) Profit Centres and Investment Centres
(ii) Product Cost and Period Cost
(May 2009, May 2006)
Solution:
(i) Distinguish between Profit Centres and Investment Centres :
Profit centre is an organisational sub-units for which both cost and profit can be traced which are
engaged mainly on maximization of profit where as investment centre is an organisation sub-unit for
which both profit and investment are considered for performance appraisal which are mainly engage to
earn return on investment.
Question: 21:
Discuss cost classification based on variability.
(Nov 2004)
Solution:
Classification on the basis of Variability:
On the basis of variability, cost are classified into three types:
1. Fixed cost
2. Variability cost
72 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
3. Semi-variable cost.
1. Fixed Cost: CIMA defines fixed cost as “A cost which accrues in relation to the passage of time and
which whin certain output or turnover limits, tends to unaffected by fluctuation in volume of output or
turnover.
Characteristics of Fixed Cost:
(i) Amount of fixed cost remain constant for every level of output.
(ii) Average fixed cost (i.e. fixed cost per unit) will decreases with increased output.
(iii) Fixed cost in generally managed and controlled by the higher management.
Example of F.C.: Insurance, salary, rent etc.
2. Variable Cost: CIMA defines variable cost as “A cost which in aggregate tends to vary indirect
proportion to change in the volume of output or turnover."
Characteristic of Variable Cost:
(i) Variable cost varies directly with output/Sales.
(ii) Variable cost is easily chargeable output or department.
(iii) Variable cost is generally managed and controlled by the department heads.
Examples of V. C.: Direct materials cost Direct Labour Cost.
3. Semi Variable Cost: CIMA defines semi variable cost as “A cost containing both fixed and variable
elements, which is, therefore, partly affected by fluctuations in the output or turnover.
Characteristics of Semi-Variable Cost:
(i) Amount of semi-variable is neither fixed not varies directly along with the output.
(ii) Semi-variable expenses is generally managed by various level of management jointly.
Example of semi variable cost: Telephone bill, electricity bill etc.
Question: 22:
Discuss the four different methods of costing along with their applicability to concerned industry.
(Nov 1997)
Solution:
The various method of costing can be summarized as under:
1. Batch Costing: This costing is based on the concept of contract costing. This method is used to
determine the cost of a group of identical or similar products. The batch costing of similar products is
73 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
the unit and not single item within the Patch. This method can be applied for the production of nuts and
bolts, medicines and other items which are manufactured in distinct batches.
2. Job costing: This method is used in those concerns where production is carried out as per specific
orders and specifications. Each job is separate and distinct from other jobs and products. This method is
popular in enterprises engaged in house building, ship-building, machinery production and repairs etc.
3. Contract costing: This method of counting, based on the principle of job counting, is used by house
builders and civil contractors. The contract becomes the cost unit for which relevant cost are
accumulated.
4. Single or unit costing: This method is used when • a single item is produced and the final production is
composed of hr mogenous units. The per unit cost is obtained by dividing the total cost by the total
number of unit of units manufactured.
5. Process costing: Under this method of costing, the cost of completing each stage of work is
ascertained, like cost of making pulp and cost of making paper from pulp. This method is used in those
industries where manufacturing is done continuously like chemicals, oil, gas paper etc.
6. Multiple costing: This method is used in those industries where the nature of product is complex such
as motor cars, aeroplanes etc. In such cases costs are accumulated for different component making the
final product and then totaled to ascertain total cost of product.
74 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 23:
Specify the methods of costing and cost units applicable to the following industries:
(i) Toy making
(ii) Cement
(iii) Radio
(iv) Bicycle
(v) Shipbuilding
(vi) Hospital.
(Nov 1998)
Solution:
Industry Method Cost unit
Toy making Batch Per batch
Cement Unit Per tonne or per bag
Radio Multiple Per radio or per batch
Bicycle Multiple Per bicycle
Ship building Contract Per ship
Hospital Operating Per bed per day or per patient per day
Question: 24:
A factory manufactures only one product in one quality and size. The owner of the factory states that
he has a sound system of financial accounting which can provide him with unit cost information and as
such he does not need a cost accounting system. State your arguments to convince him the need to
introduce a cost accounting system.
(Nov 1999)
Solution:
Reasons for installing a cost accounting system in a single product manufacturing factory:
75 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
1. Management of a manufacturing unit needs information to draw plans for the future, to control the
working of the unit and for making day-to-day decisions. All these information are not available from
financial accounts which provides two documents viz profit and loss a/c and balance sheet at the end of
the financial year. These two documents take about 13-14 months to reach the executives but the
executives even then cannot set right anything that has gone wrong in the past. Therefore, in order to
facilitate executives to perform well the functions of planning, control and decision making the use of
cost accounting system is a must.
2. In financial accounting system no attempt is generally made to record data by jobs, processes,
products, departments etc. It only provides information in terms of income, expenses, assets and
liabilities for the company as a whole thus the available information is not quite useful for the
ascertainment of price, control of costs, ascertainment of products profitability etc. Cost accounting
records data in the manner that helps the ascertainment of price and profitability and also the control
of costs by using variances.
3. Government in its efforts to protect consumers, often resorts to statutory price control, cost
accounting can help by providing enough cost information which could be utilized to press upon the govt,
to convince for price and to arrive at a suitable price before their arbitrary fixation.
4. A sound system of cost accounting will highlight the capacity utilization and efficiency which will be
beneficial in taking suitable decisions for the improvement of operational results.
5.It also helps the management for the periodic assessment of the performance of its executives. This
can be done by establishing standards and presenting reports to appropriate authority.
76 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
CHAPTER 2: MATERIAL
Question: 1:
Distinguish clearly between Bin Cards and Stores Ledgers.
(Nov 2017, Nov 2004, May 2003, May 2002, May 2002, May 1999)
Solution:
Both bin cards and stores ledgers are perpetual inventory records. None of them is a substitute for the
other. These two records can be distinguished on the basis of following view point:
Sl. No Basis Bin cards Stores ledger
1. Maintained Bin card is maintained by store keeper Stores ledger is maintained by cost
accounting department
2. Nature It is the stores recording document It is an accounting record
3. Information It contains information as records to It contains both quantitative and
quantities i.e. their receipts, issue value information in respect of their
and balance. receipts, issue and balance.
4. Time of In bin card entries are made at the In stores ledger entries are made
recording time when transaction takes place. only after the transaction has taken
place.
5. Recording Bin cards records each transaction. Stores ledger records the same
information in a summarized form.
6. inter Inter departmental transfers of Inter departmental transfers of
department materials does not appears. materials appears here.
al transfer
Question: 2:
Differentiate between “scrap” and “defectives” and how they are treated in cost accounting
(Nov 2015, Nov 2008)
Solution:
Sr. No. Basis Scrap Defectives
1. Meaning Scrap is the incidental residue from Defective work signifies those
certain types of manufacture, usually units of production which can be
of small amount and low value, rectified and turned out as good
recoverable without further processing. units by the application of
77 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 3:
Write treatment of items associated with purchase of material:
(i) Cash discount
(ii) Subsidy/Grant/Incentives
(iii) GST
(iv) Commission brokerage paid
(May 2016)
Solution:
(i) Cash discount: It should be excluded from cost accounts because it is an item of purely financial
nature. It is not deducted from purchase price.
78 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 4:
Distinguish between Bill of Material, Material Requisition note.
(May 2012, May 1997)
Solution:
Sr. No. Basis Bill of Material Material Requisition Note
1. Preparation It is document by the drawing It is prepared by the
office & Production planning foreman of the consuming
department. department.
2. Scope It is a complete schedule of It is a document authorizing
component parts and raw Store-Keeper to issue
materials required for a Material to the consuming
particular job or work order: department.
3. Purpose It often serves the purpose of It cannot replace a bill of
a' Store Requisition as it material.
shows the complete schedule
of materials required for a
particular job i.e. it can
replace stores requisition.
4. Usefulness It can be used for the It is useful in arriving at
purpose of quotation. historical cost only.
5. Benefit It helps in keeping a It shows the materials
quantitative control on actually drawn from stores.
materials drawn through
stores Requisition,
Question: 5:
Write notes on: Bill of Material.
(May 1998)
79 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Solution:
1. BOM is a schedule of standard quantities of materials required for any job or other units of
production.
2. It is also known as Material Specification list or just material list.
3. It contains code, description and quantity of materials and other stores items required for carrying
out a particular work or job order.
4. It also acts as an authorization for issue of materials and stores items mentioned in it. Use of BOM
saves paper work and also ensures requisition of the exact quantity of materials.
5. It is prepared by Engineering/Planning deptt in a standard form, in quadruplicate to be used as
follows:
(a) Stores Department: For verification against request for issue of materials.
(b) Cost Accounts Department: For accounting of standard cost.
(c) Production Control Department: For control purpose.
(d) Engineering/Planning Department: For record, reference and control purpose.
Bill of Materials
MNP Company
Bill of Materials
BOM No:
Date:
Question: 6:
At the time of physical stock taking, it was found that actual stock level was different from the clerical
or computer records. What can be possible reasons for such differences? How will you deal with such
differences?
(May 1999)
80 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Solution:
When it was found that actual stock level was different from that of the clerical or computer records,
possible reasons for difference arising may be as follows:
1. Wrong entry might have been made in stores ledger account or bin card.
2.The items of materials might have been placed in the wrong physical location in the store.
3. Arithmetical errors might have been made while calculating the stores balances on the bin cards or
stores ledger when a manual system is operated.
4. Theft of stock.
When a discrepancy is found at the time of stock taking, the individual stores ledger account and the bin
card must be adjusted so that they are in agreement with the actual stock. For example, if the actual
stock is less than the clerical or computer record the quantity and value of the appropriate store ledger
account and bin card (quantity only) must be reduced and the difference in cost be charged to a factory
overhead account for store losses.
Question: 7:
Explain ‘Just In Time’ (JIT) approach of inventory management.
(May 2018, May 1999)
Solution:
Just-In Time Purchasing: JIT purchasing is the purchase of materials and supplies in such a manner that
delivery immediately preceedes the demand of use. This will ensure that stock are as low as possible or
nearly cut to a minimum. Considerable saving in material handling expenses in made by requiring
suppliers to inspect materials and guarantee their quality. This improved service is obtained by giving
more business to fewer suppliers, who can provide high quality and reliable delivery. Encouragement is
given to employees to render good service by placing with them long term purchasing order companies
which implements JIT, purchasing substantially reduces their investments in raw materials and W1P
stocks.
Question: 8:
What is ABC Analysis.
(May 2017, Nov 2011, May 2008, Nov 2005, May 2000)
Solution:
ABC Analysis: It is an important technique of inventory control on selective basis. Large manufacturing
units have such a large number of items in their stores for which it is often not possible for the
management to pay the same attention to each and every stock item. A system is therefore required by
which these items are classified according to their importance and then selective control is exercised.
ABC analysis or ‘selective control’ is a technique whereby the measure of control over an item of
inventory varies directly with ‘its usage value’. In other words, the high value items are controlled more
closely than the items of low value.
This method is known as “Always Better Control or the Alphabetic Approach.” ABC concept of
classifying goods in an inventory is very commonly used for exercising effective inventory control.
Under this technique the items in inventory are classified according to the value of usage.
Analysis and Control: The three categories are classified & differential control is established as under:
1. Smooth Flow This method ensures that minimum investment will be made in
inventories of stock of materials or stocks to be carried,
without any danger of interruption of production for want of
materials or stores, requirement.
2. Cost Savings The cost of placing orders, receiving goods & maintaining stocks
is minimized.
3. Control by exception Management’s time is saved since attention need be paid only to
some of the items rather than all the items.
4. Standardization of work With the introduction of ABC system, much of the work
connected with purchase can be systematised on a routine
basis.
Limitation of ABC:
1. In order to be fully cost effective, ABC analysis should be carried out with standardization and
codification.
2. The result of ABC analysis should be reviewed periodically & should be up dated.
83 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 9:
How is slow moving and non-moving item of stores detected and what steps are necessary to reduce
such stocks?
(Nov 2001)
Solution:
Slow moving and non-moving items of stores can be detected in the following ways :–
1. By preparing & scanning periodic reports showing the status of different items of stores.
2 .By calculating the stock holding of various items in terms of numbers of days/months of
consumption.
3. By computing ratios periodically, relating to the issues as a percentage of average stock held.
4. By implementing the use of a well designed information system.
Question: 10:
Describe perpetual inventory records and continuous stock verification.
(May 2001)
Solution:
Perpetual Inventory Taking:
1. Stock verification takes place at the end of a financial period say a year.
2. All items of stocks are covered in a single stretch of verification, say over 2-3 days.
3. Regular stores procedures like material receipts, issues etc. may have to be stopped to facilitate
stock taking.
4. Discrepancies can be known only at the end of the period. Responsibility cannot be easily fixed.
5. Inventory records may also be updated periodically, say weekly or monthly, in fact, at any time before
physical verification.
6. This does not facilitate or help the quick computation of interim or final financial results.
2. In each verification, 2-3 items are covered. In the entire period, all items are covered on rotation
basis.
3. There is no interference with regular work flow.
4. Discrepancies are ascertained immediately in order to take corrective action and avoid re-occurrence.
5. Due to surprise element involved, inventory records must be maintained upto date at all times. This is
called perpetual Inventory Records.
6. It provides stock figures on real-time basis. Hence, final accounts can be completed quickly, interim
results can be prepared conveniently.
Question: 11:
Discuss the use of perpetual inventory records and continuous stock verification, and its advantages.
(Nov 2006)
Solution:
Use of Perpetual Inventory Records
Under this system, a continuous record of receipt and issue of materials is maintained by the stores
deptt. and the information about the stock of materials is always available. In this method stock records
are maintained in such a way as to make an entry in the records, the physical movement of stock on
receipts and issue of materials and to indicate the balance of each item of material in the stores at any
point of time.
In this system, the entries are made in bin cards and stores ledger as and when the receipts and issue of
materials take place and the balance is ascertained after every receipt or issue of materials. The stocks
as per dual records viz. bin cards and stores ledgers are reconciled on a continuous basis.
Advantages:
1. This system facilitates production planning and inventory control.
2. It helps in having a detailed and more reliable check on the stores.
3. The stock records are more reliable and stock discrepancies are investigated and immediate actions
are taken.
Use of Continuos Stock Taking:
Under this system, physical stock verification is made for each item of stock on continuous basis. It is
physical chocking of stock records with actual stock on continuous basis.
It is a method of verification of physical stock on a continuous basis instead of at the end of the
accounting period. It is a verification conducted round the year, thus covering each item of stores twice
or thrice. Valuable items are checked more frequently than the stocks with lesser value.
Advantages:
85 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
1. Any discrepancies, irregularities or changes are detected at early stage and brought to the notice of
management.
2. It acts as a moral check on stores staff.
3. It insists on upto date maintaining of stock records.
4. The disruption in production caused by periodic stock taking is eliminated.
Question: 12:
“Perpetual inventory system comprises Bin Card and Stores Ledger, but the efficacy of the system
depends on continuous stock taking.” Comment.
(May 2013)
Solution:
• Perpetual Inventory system represents a system of records maintained by the stores department.
• Records comprise of (i) Bin Cards and (ii) Stores Ledger.
• Bin Card maintains a quantitative record of receipts, issues and closing balances of each item of
stores. Like a bin card, the Stores Ledger is maintained to record all receipt and issue transactions in
respect of materials. It is filled up with the help of goods received note and material requisitions.
• But a perpetual inventory system’s efficacy depends on the system of continuous stock taking.
Continuous stock taking means the physical checking of the records i.e. Bin cards and store ledger with
actual physical stock.
• Perpetual inventory is essentially necessary for material control. It incidentally helps continuous
stock taking.
Question: 13:
Explain, why the Last in First out (UFO) has an edge over First in First out (FIFO) or any other method of
pricing material issues.
(Nov 2007)
Solution:
Under LIFO method, production is charged with current market prices and hence pricing of the
production is facilitated.
Whereas in case of FIFO method, production is charged with old price (i.e ..low price under inflationary
trend). In the same way, under weighed price method, the rise in prices is spread over a large number of
units and therefore its effect is much reduced. The average price is always less than the current market
price. However, determination of the average price requires a iot of clerical work.
Therefore we prefer to use LIFO method so the product cost is near to market price.
Question: 14:
Discuss the accounting treatment of defectives in cost accounts.
(May 2009, May 2007, May 2005, May 2003)
Solution:
Treatment of Spoilage in Costing:
Normal If the cost of spoilage is normal & inherent in the process or operation, then the cost of
spoilage spoilage is absorbed by charging either to the specific production order or the product
overheads.
Abnormal If the cost of abnormal spoilage arises in the process then it is charged to costing Profit &
spoilage Loss A/c. If spoilt units are reused as raw materials in the same process no separate
accounting treatment is required. But if, spoilage is used for any other process or job, a
proper credit should be given to relevant process A/c of job A/c.
Normal Defective Charged to The entire cost of rectification of normal defective is charged to
Good Output good units.
Charged to Genera! overhead If the responsible department is not identified correctly, then the
rectification costs are charged to genera! overheads.
87 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 15:
How are normal and abnormal loss of material arising during storage treated in Cost Accounts?
(May 2001)
Solution:
Normal and Abnormal Loss of Materials:
At the time of physical verification of stocks, discrepancies may be found between physical stock shown
in Bin card and book stock shown in store ledgers. These discrepancies are in the form of
shortage/losses. For accounting purpose, the loss is classified into Normal or Abnormal loss. Normal
/Unavoidaole Loss:
1. Based on past data, a standard percentage of normal shortage is set.
2. Cost of normal shortage/loss should be treated as regular cost,
3. Cost of normal loss may be accounted under any of the following methods:
(a) As direct materials-by inflating the issue price; or
(b) As overheads.
Abnormal Loss:
1. It is the excess of actual loss over the normal loss (Note: Above normal = abnormal)
2. Cost of abnormal materials shortage is a loss and should be charged to costing profit & loss A/c.
3. If the losses or surpluses arise from errors in documentation, posting etc. they are not abnormal.
Such errors should be rectified through appropriate adjustment entries.
88 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 1:
Distinguish between “Direct and Indirect labour costs”.
(Nov 2001)
Solution:
Direct and Indirect Labour cost:
Direct labour cost is the labour cost that is specifically incurred for or can be readily charged to a
person identified with a specific job, contract, work order or any other unit of cost.
Indirect labour cost is the labour cost which cannot be readily identified with products or services bi_ is
generally incurred in carrying out production activity.
The importance of the distinction lies in the fact that whereas direct labour cost can be identified with
and charged to the job, indirect labours costs cannot be so charged & is therefore, to be treated as part
of the factory O/H and it is to be included in the cost of production.
Question: 2:
What do you mean by time and motion study? Why is it so important to management ?
(May 1999)
Solution:
Time study:
Under this study, a standard time is assigned for the performance of a given job on the basis of the
measurement of work required under a prescribed method. In this study proper allowance is provided for
fatigue natural needs {for nature's call) and unavoidable delay.
The main object of this study is to establish a standard time for a specific job, through a specific
method under a normal working condition by the average workers. The main object of this study means
to eliminate the wastage and minimise the labour cost.
Advantages:
1. It is helpful for the fixation of an incentive plan.
2. It is helpful for the calculation of production cost.
3. It is helpful for establishing the process of production, budgeting, scheduling, etc.
4. It is helpful for establishing standard cost under the standard costing system.
89 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Motion Study: Every operation requires certain body of motion and every motion has it’s own time and
own fatigue. So, by improving the operation we can eliminate unnecessary motion and as a result of
which productivity will increase by which cost per unit will decrease.
Advantages:
1. Faster and better working
2. Planning of operation
3. Better distribution of work.
4. Better working condition
So, the ultimate result is high productivity at low cost.
Question: 3:
Enumerate the various methods of Time booking.
(May 2007)
Solution:
The various methods of Time Booking are:
1. Piece work card
2. Daily time sheet
3. Weekly time sheet
4. Clock card
5. Time ticket
6. Job ticket
7. Combined Time and Job ticket.
Question: 4:
Discuss accounting treatment of idle capacity costs in cost accounting.
(May 2009)
Solution:
Idle Capacity: It represents the difference between practical capacity and the capacity based on long
term sales expectancy.
If the actual capacity is different from the capacity based on sales expectancy, then the idle capacity is
the difference between the practical capacity and the actual capacity.
90 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Idle capacity represents a part of practical capacity which has not been utilized due to regular
interruptions and which may not be avoided.
Idle capacity cost can be determined as:
Idle capacity cost = (Total OH related to plant)/(Normal capacity) × Idle capacity
It may be normal or abnormal.
1. Arising due to unavoidable Generally arises due to lack of demand or due to seasonal nature
reasons (Normal idle of the product. Production OHs are absorbed into the cost of
capacity) production either by the inflated OH absorption rate or by the
supplementary OH rate.
2. Arising due to avoidable It may arise due to lack of proper planning control or due to
reasons (Abnormal idle lack of managements forecasting. The cost of such idle
capacity) treatment capacity should be charged to costing Profit and Loss
A/c.
3. If arises due to trade Then it being normal in nature. The cost should, be charged to
depression or any other costing P/L A/c.
external factors
Question: 4:
What is idle time? Explain the causes leading to idle time and its treatment in cost accounts.
(May 2000)
Solution:
Idle time represents a loss of time for which the enterprise pays wages to the employees but secures no
benefit or work from such employees. It increases the labour cost without any increase in the output.
Idle time may arise due to some normal reasons which cannot be avoided or abnormal reasons which can
be avoided if proper precautions are taken at proper time.
91 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 5:
Discuss the accounting treatment of the following in cost-accounts: Idle time and Over-time wages.
(May 2006, May 2003)
Solution:
Idle Time:
Please refer 2000 - May [5] (b) on page no.
Over time:
Accounting treatment of overtime premium depends upon the circumstances of the work :
Case 1: If the overtime is worked on customer's instruction in order to complete the work at the
earliest then it should be directly charged to the job as a part of direct wages.
Case 2: If the overtime is worked due to shortage of the labour or any other reason- then it is treated
as a part of the labour cost and such overtime premium is appointed on the basis of total hours work on
different jobs.
Case 3 : If the overtime is worked to make-up the lost time due to unavoidable reason it means it is a
cost incurred for normal time and it should be treated as part of the production OH and it can be'
recovered from the job completed during the accounting period.
Case 4 : If the overtime is worked to make-up the time lost due to avoidable reasons i.e. abnormal idle
time - then it is charged to costing Profit/Loss A/c.
Case 5: If overtime is worked due to its management fault then it should be charged to that particular
department.
Question: 6:
Discuss the effect of overtime payment on productivity.
(Nov 2001)
Solution:
93 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Effect of overtime payment on productivity : Overtime work should be resorted to, only when it is
extremely essential because it involves extra cost.
The overtime payment increases the cost of production in the following ways:
1. The overtime premium paid is an extra payment in addition to the normal rate.
2.The efficiency of operators during overtime work may fall and thus output may be less than normal
output.
3. In order to earn more, workers may not concentrate on work during normal idle time and thus the
output during normal hours may also fall.
4. Reduced output and increased premium of overtime will bring about an increase in costs of
production.
5. Gives rise to associated costs like lighting etc.
6. Adversely affects the health of workers in long run.
7. Increases the wear and tear of machinery.
8. Promotes dissatisfaction among the workers who do not get the opportunity of overtime.
9. Create difficulty in discontinuance of the practice of overtime work if it is once allowed.
10. Promotes a tendency among the workers to keep the work pending so that overtime work is
necessitated.
Question: 7:
State the circumstances in which time rate system of wage payment can be preferred in a factory.
(Nov 2001)
Solution:
Circumstances in which time rate system of wage payment can be preferred is as follows:
1. Persons whose services cannot be directly or tangibly measured, e.g. general helpers, supervisory and
clerical staff etc.
2. Workers engaged on highly skilled jobs on sending skilled services, e.g. tool making, inspection and
testing.
3. Where the pace of output is independent of the operation e.g., automatic chemical plants.
Question: 8:
Which is better plan out of Halsey 50 percent bonus scheme and Rowan bonus scheme for an efficient
worker ? In which situation the worker get same bonus in both schemes?
(May 2010)
94 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Solution:
• Rowan Bonus Scheme pays more bonus if the time saved is below the 50 percent of time allowed and if
the time saved is more than 50 percent of time allowed then Halsey bonus scheme pays more bonus.
• Normally, time saved by a worker is not more than 50 percent of time allowed.
• Therefore, the Rowan bonus scheme is better for an efficient worker. When the time saved is equal to
50 percent of time allowed then both plans pay same bonus to a worker.
Bonus under Halsey Plan will be equal to the Bonus under Rowan Plan when the following condition holds
good
= Standard wage rate × 50/100 × Time saved
= Standard wage rate × (Time taken)/(Time allowed) × Time saved
or 1/2 = (Time taken)/(Time allowed)
or Time taken = 1/2 of time allowed.
Hence, when the time taken is 50% of the time allowed, the bonus under Halsey and Rowan Plans is
equal.
Question: 9:
Discuss the two types of cost associated with labour turnover.
(Nov 2003,Nov 1997)
Solution:
The two types of costs associated with labour turnover are :
1. Preventive costs: These are costs incurred to keep the labour turnover at a low level, e. g. cost of
medical services, welfare schemes and pension schemes. If the firm incurs high preventive costs, its
rate of labour turnover is usually low.
2. Replacement costs: These are costs arising due to high labour turnover and represents the amount
spent on new workers. Some examples are cost of employment, training and induction, abnormal
breakage and scrap, extra wages and overheads due to inefficiency of new workers. The company will
incurs high replacement costs if its rate of labour turnover is high.
95 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Hence every company must work out an optimum level of labour turnover keeping in view its personnel
policies and behaviour of replacement and preventive costs at various levels of labour turnover rates.
Question: 10:
What do you understand by labour turnover? How is it measured?
(May 2003)
Solution:
Meaning : Labour turnover refers to "the rate of change in the composition of labour force during a
particular period measured against suitable index ". It arises because an organisation is a dynamic entity
and not a static one.
Definition : Prof. B Banerjee has therefore defined labour turnover as "The rate of change in the labour
force of an organisation during a specified period."
Measurement of Labour Turnover: Three important methods are available to measure labour turnover.
The company may use any one of these methods for the purpose of measuring the rate of labour
turnover. But for the purposes of facilitating both the trend analysis (e.g. company’s labour turnover
rate during the year just ended with the preceeding years) and the inter firm comparison (e.g. comparing
the rate of labour turnover of a company with that of others), it is necessary to use the method selected
consistently year after year. Since each method lays emphasis on a particular aspect and therefore, no
useful and meaningful comparison can be made if there is a change or difference in the method of
measuring labour turnover. The three methods are :
1. Separation method
2. Replacement method
3. Flux method
1. Separation Method: Under this method, labour turnover is measured by . dividing the total number of
separations during a period by the average no. of employees on the pay roll. The result is to be
multiplied by 100 to express it in the form of percentage. Therefore,
LTO = (No.of separations during a period)/(Avg.no.of employees during the period) × 100
Where,
Avg. no. of employees = ([No.of employees at the beginning of period + No,of employees at the end of
the period])/2
2. Replacement Method: Under this method labour turnover is measured by dividing the number of
replacements made, irrespective of number of separations, during a period by the average number of
96 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
employees on the payroll. The important point to be noted is that only the replacements made to fill the
vacancies caused by the separations are to be considered for measuring labour turnover under this
method. Therefore,
LTO = (No.of replacement made during a period)/(Avg.no of employees during the period) × 100
3. Flux Method: Under this method, both the number of separations and replacements are considered.
Hence, labour turnover is computed by dividing the aggregate of no. of separations & replacements
during a period by the average number of employees. Therefore,
LTO = (No.of separations during a period)/(Avg.no.of employees during the period) × 100
Question: 11:
Discuss the three methods of Calculating labour turnover.
(Nov 2010, Nov 2004)
Solution:
Meaning : Labour turnover' refers to "the rate of change in the composition of labour force during a
particular period measured against suitable index". It arises because an organisation is a dynamic entity
and not a static one.
Definition : Prof. B Banerjee has therefore defined labour turnover as "The rate of change in the labour
force of an organization during a specified period."
Measurement of Labour Turnover : Three important methods are available to measure labour turnover.
The company may use any one of these methods for the purpose of measuring the rate of labour
turnover. But for the purposes of facilitating both the trend analysis (e.g. company’s labour turnover
rate during the year just ended with the preceding years) and the inter firm comparison {e.g. comparing
the rate of labour turnover of a company with that of others), it is necessary to use the method selected
consistently year after year. Since each method lays emphasis on a particular aspect and therefore, no
useful and meaningful comparison can be made if there is a change or difference in the method of
measuring labour turnover. The three methods are :
1. Separation method
2. Replacement method
3. Flux method
1. Separation Method: Under this method, labour turnover is measured by dividing the total number of
separations during a period by the average no. of employees on the pay roll. The result is to be
multiplied by 100 to express it in the form of percentage. Therefore,
LTO = (No.of separations during a period)/(Avg.no.of employees during the period) × 100
97 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Where,
Avg. no. of employees = ([No.of employees at the beginning of the period + No.of employees at the end
of the period])/2
2. Replacement Method: Under this method labour turnover is measured by dividing the number of
replacements made, irrespective of number of separations, during a period by the average number of
employees on the payroll. The important point to be noted is that only the replacements made to fill the
vacancies caused by the separations are to be considered for measuring labour turnover under this
method. Therefore,
LTO = (No.of replacements made during a period)/(Avg.no of employees during the period) × 100
3. Flux Method: Under this method, both the number of separations & replacements are considered.
Hence, labour turnover is computed by dividing the aggregate of no. of separations & replacements
during a period by the average number of employees.
Therefore, LTO = ([No of separations during a period] + [No.of replacements during a period)/(Average
no.of employees during the period)
Question: 12:
Enumerate the remedial steps to be taken to minimise the labour turnover.
(Nov 2007)
Solution:
The following remedial steps may be adopted to minimise labour turnover:
1. Exit interview with each outgoing employee to ascertain the reasons for his leaving the organisation.
2. Job analysis and evaluation carried out even before recruitment to ascertain the requirement of each
job.
3. Scientific system of recruitment, placement and promotion, by fitting the right person in the right
job.
4. Use of committee, comprising of members from management and workers to handle issue concerning
workers grievance, requirements etc.
5. Enlightened attitude of management - Mental revolution on the part of management by taking
workers into confidence and acting a healthy working atmosphere, with measures such as :
(i) Training service rules after discussion between management and workers union.
(ii) Provision of facilities for education, training and development of workers.
(iii) Introduction of procedures for settlement of workers grievances.
98 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 13:
Enumerate the causes of labour turnover.
(Nov 2007)
Solution:
In order to keep the labour turnover rate at the minimum level, it is necessary to understand the various
reasons as to why the people leave the
organisation. Though it is a very strenuous task to list all the reasons for or causes of LTO, an attempt
has been made in the following paragraph to identify some of the important & usual causes which can be
classified into two broad categories:
Causes of Labour Turnover
99 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
CHAPTER 4: OVERHEADS
Question: 1:
Distinguish between Fixed overheads and Variable overheads.
(May 2010)
Solution:
Fixed Overheads Vs. Variable Overheads
Fixed overheads are not affected by any variation in the volume of activity, e.g., managerial
remuneration, rent etc. These remain the same from one period to another except when they are
deliberately changed. Fixed overheads are generally variable per unit of output or activity e.g Rent,
insurance, Depreciation, Audit fees etc.
Whereas, the variable overheads that change in proportion to the change in the volume of activity or
output, e.g., power consumed, consumable stores etc. The variable overheads are generally constant per
unit of output or activity, e.g. direct material, direct labour, commission on sale.
Question: 2:
Distinguish between cost allocation and cost absorption.
(May 2013)
Solution:
Cost allocation: It is defined as the process of allotment or identification or assignment of whole items
to cost centers or costs units. Thus the charging of direct cost to a cost centre or a cost unit is the
process of allocation of costs.
Cost absorption : It is the process of absorbing all indirect costs (or Overheads) allocated or apportioned
over particular cost centre or production deptt. by the units produced.
Question: 3:
Discuss the difference between allocation and apportionment of overhead.
(May 2014, May 2008)
Solution:
Cost allocation:
The term ‘allocation’ implies relating overheads directly to the various departments. The estimated
amount of various items of manufacturing overheads should be allocated to various cost centers or
departments.
100 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Cost apportionment:
Those items of estimated overheads {like the salary of the works manager) which cannot be directly
allocated to the various departments and cost centers are apportioned. Apportionment implies “the
allotment of proportions of items of cost to cost centres or departments.” It implies that the
unallocable expenses are to be spread over the various departments or cost centres on an equitable
basis.
The differences between Allocation and Apportionment are as follows:
Basis of Difference Allocation Apportionment
Meaning Identifying a cost centre and Allotment of pro-portions of
charging its expenses in full. common cost to various cost
centre.
Nature of expenses Specific and identifiable General and common
Number of centre One Many
(Deptt.)
Basis Allocate directly Allocate Indirectly
Amount of overhead Charge in full Charge in proportion- able
Assumption Not required Required
Question: 4:
Write a note on ‘classification’, ‘allocation’ and ‘absorption’ of overheads. How does it help in controlling
overheads?
(May 1998)
Solution:
On the basis of a common base or characteristic features overheads are grouped into two or more
classes: This is known as classification of OHEs. There are no. of bases for classification. But the
selection of a particular base for classification depends upon a no. of factors such as nature and size of
the business, nature of product etc. However the following 3 bases are generally used for classification:
101 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Note:
The amount of fixed cost times remains constant for a particular range of level of activity upto a
specific period. This is known as "Relevant Range" and" Relevant periocf respectively concept of
relevant range is applicable to fixed cost as well as variable costs.
For Fixed Cost: It is related to the plant capacity or range of production level means after a certain
range of production it can be hiked.
For Variable cost: Per unit variable cost will behave differently outside the relevant range of
production. It means it is constant upto that Relevant Range.
e.g.: Quantity discount available on the basis of certain limit.
103 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Allocation of costs:
Allocation is the process of identification of O/H with cost centre. If an expenses which is directly
identifiable with a specific cost centre is known it is allocated to the same e.g.:
1. Power if separate meter for each cost centre is there.
2. Wage to indirect workers
3. Depreciation of plant and machinery
4. Insurance of plant and machinery
5. Fuel oil for boiler, generation, ovens etc.
Absorption of OH : Absorption is an excercise by which OH is properly spread over to production for the
period. After OH is collected, a basis for absorption of OH is found out for each departments so that
each product gets due share of OH. Thus OH absorption involves apportionment of OH relating to a
department among units produced in that department.
Question: 5:
2010 - Nov [7] (a) (4 marks)
What are the methods of re-apportionment of service department expenses over the production
departments? Discuss.
104 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Solution:
The following methods are generally used for re-apportionment according to the specified
circumstances:
Note: If all the service departments, provide service to equal no. of other departments, then it will be
difficult to re-apportion the cost of service departments In such case, it is apportioned on the basis of
largest amount to lowest one. It means first apportion largest amount, then the next largest and so on:
3. Reciprocal service method: This method is used when one service department renders services to
other department and vice-versa in addition to the services provided to the production departments
That is on reciprocal basis, it means, before determining the cost of each service department, they
should recognise the cost of inter service departmental services. ,
This method is generally used for the dealing of such problems :
(i) Trial and Error Method,
(ii) Repeated Distribution Method
(iii) Simultaneous Equation Method
Question: 6:
Discuss the step method and reciprocal service method of secondary distribution of overheads.
(Nov 2004)
Solution:
Step Method: When it is recognised that the service rendered by one service department to other
service department has been done on partial basis, the re-apportionment procedure involves the
following steps:
Step 1 : Find out such service deptts., which gives services to large no. of other deptts. Distribute
the.cost of this service depth to other deptts. (including other service deptts.) on an equitable basis.
Step 2 : Then identify other service deptts. which gives services to next largest number of deptts. After
that, distribute the cost of such service depth, to other deptts. (excluding the service depth Whose cost
has already been apportioned) on some equitable basis.
Step 3 : Continue the distribution process till the cost of service deptts., cost is apportioned fully.
Note: If all the service deptts. provide service to equal no. of other deptts., then it will be difficult to
re-apportion the cost of service deptts. In such case, it is apportioned on the basis of largest amount to
lowest one. It means first apportion largest amount, then the next highest and so on.
Reciprocal Service Method:
This method is used when one service deptt. renders services to other deptt. and vice-versa in addition
to the services provided to the production deptts. That is reciprocal basis it means before determining
the cost of each service deptt, they should recognise the cost of inter service departmental services.
This method is generally used for the dealing of such problems
(i) Trial and Error Method,
(ii) Repeated Distribution Method
106 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 7:
Explain, how under-absorption and over-absorption of overheads are treated in Cost Accounts.
(Nov 2015, Nov 2014, Nov 2010, May 2010)
Solution:
There are varieties of methods used for over or under absorption of OHEs in the accounts. However in
the corporate sector 3 important methods are widely used for accounting of over & under absorption of
POHEs:
1.Use of supplementary OH absorption rates.
2.Write off to costing P&L A/c.
3. Carry over to the next period accounts.
1. Use of Supplementary OH Absorption Rates: This method is used when it is caused due to normal or
avoidable reasons. When the amount of over & under absorbed POHEs is significant (i.e. more than 10%
of total OH incurred), supplementary absorption rates are computed by way of addition or deduction.
This rate may be called Negative Supplementary Rate if over absorbed amount is to be deducted, on the
other hand, the supplementary rate may be called positive supplementary rate if under absorbed amount
is to be added,
∴ Negative Supplementary Rate = (Over Absorbed FOEs)/(Actual value of the Base output)
And Positive Supplementary Rate = (Under absorbed POHEs)/(Actual value of Base output)
This method is preferred when:
107 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
2. Writing off to Costing P&L A/c: When the amount of over and under absorbed POHEs is not so
significant, it may be written off to costing P&L A/c. But if it is significant (sizeable) and it arises due
to:
(i) Some uncontrollable & abnormal factors.
(ii) Estimation of output is contingent.
Then such over or under absorbed POHEs may be written off to costing P&L A/c. But it suffers from
some limitation like it cannot be adjusted in the value of WIP, unsold stock or sold unit (it means pricing
policy cannot be adjusted).
Question: 8:
Why is the use of an overhead absorption rate based on direct labour hours generally preferable to a
direct wages percentage rate for a labour incentive operation?
(Nov 1995)
Solution:
A method of overhead absorption is considered appropriate if the total amount of overhead absorbed in
a period does not fluctuate materially from the actual expenses incurred in the period direct wage %
rate method do not posses the aforesaid feature. In other words, the O/H charged varies from period to
period due to changes in direct wages.
In fact, O/H expenses are generally a function of time. Therefore, a time based O/H absorption rate
method is always preferred over any other method. In the case of labour incentive operations. It is
advisable to use labour hour method for O/H absorption.
108 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 9:
What is blanket overhead rate? In which situations, blanket rate is to be used and why?
(Nov 2007, Nov 1999)
Solution:
Blanket OH Rate: Is also known as “Single” or “Plant” “wide OH absorption Rate”.
It is calculated as under:
Blanket rate = (OH cost for the entire factory)/(Total quantity of the base selected)
This method is used when the size of the company is small or when the burden of O/H is more or less
uniform among all the production deptts.. These rates are easy to compute and require clerical cost but
have a very limited use. The limitations of such rates are as under.
1. Such rates may give misleading results where several products are manufactured and are required to
be passed through various production departments.
2. As the performance of the individual deptt. cannot be assessed properly with this rate, so no
satisfactory managerial control is possible.
3. Such rate may render the valuation of WIP erroneous.
Question: 10:
Discuss the accounting of Selling and Distribution overheads.
(May 2005)
Solution:
CIMA England defines selling cost as “the cost seeking to create and stimulate demand and of securing
order” and Distribution cost as ‘The cost of the sequence of operation which begins with making the
packed product available for dispatch and ends with making the reconditioned returned empty package,
if any, available for reuse.” Accounting Treatment: Selling and distribution OHE's are recovered either
on the basis of products or channels of distribution or by territories'or zones or by any other means. It
is a very crucial decision what type of expenses relating to selling and distribution is recovered on what
basis?
Since S & DOH are incurred for the benefit of many cost centres so a suitable base it to be established
for apportioning it to the various cost centres, for e.g.
1. Direct selling expenses: Apportioned on the basis of sales revenue.
2. Cost of storage: Apportioned on the basis of sales volume, or size or weight, etc.
3. Advertisement and sales promotion: Apportioned on the basis of sales value or volume.
109 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
4. Transportation cost: Apportioned on the basis of sales volume, or weight or distance, or weight-
distance.
5. Credit collection cost: Apportioned on the basis of credit sale or no of invoices, etc.
After the allocation and apportionment they are absorbed on the basis of either the sales revenue or on
the basis of sales volume.
Question: 11:
What is ‘Idle Capacity’? How should this be treated in cost accounts?
(Nov 2015, Nov 2001)
Solution:
Idle Capacity Cost:
• Idle capacity is that part of capacity of a plant, machine or equipment which cannot be used due to
different reasons which may be avoidable or unavoidable. It is the difference between practical capacity
and capacity based on sales expectancy.
Accounting for idle capacity in Cost Accounting:
• Normal idle capacity cost cannot be avoided and it should be absorbed in cost by inflating the rate. But
if it is due to un-avoidable reasons, it may be charged to Profit and Loss Account.
Question: 12:
How do you deal with the following in Cost Accounts?
(i) Research and Development Expenses
(May 2005, Nov 2001)
Solution:
Research and Development Cost: R&D expenditures is a differed expenditure because it is incurred not
for benefitting a certain period, but for benefiting several accounting periods. Such expenditure is
incurred for innovating a new product or improving the existing product or developing new methods of
production.
Research Cost:
Research cost are incurred under 2 heads :
1. Basic research cost which is incurred for improving the existing scientific and/or technical knowledge.
2. Applied research cost applied research is done for the purpose of achieving some particular practical
motto or objectives.
Treatment in Cost A/cs:
110 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
1. Basic Research Cost: It should be treated as prod. OH for a particular period and absorb it in product
cost. Because it is related to all existing products or methods or techniques of production etc.
2. Applied Research Cost: It is further classified into 2 parts for the costing purpose. They are :
(i) If it is incurred for the improvement of the existing product and methods of production it should be
treated as POH and absorbed accordingly.
(ii) If it is incurred for innovating new products or methods then such cost is absorbed on the basis of
amortisation.
If whole of such expenditure is so huge, then it should be absorbed in subsequent years in which some
benefit is received by the producer. If applied research work becomes a failure, then such research
expenditure is charged against profit in costing P&L A/c. If size of such amount is heavy, then such
amount is speared over in subsequent year also.
3. Development Cost: Development cost is the cost incurred during the implementation of the decision
to produce a new product or improved new products or use new or improved methods.
Treatment of Development Cost: Cost incurred for development is treated similar as the treatment of
applied research cost.
Question: 13:
How do you deal with the following in Cost Accounts?
(i) Fringe benefits.
(ii) Bad debts
(Nov 1999)
Solution:
(i) Fringe Benefits: If any fringe benefits are incurred for factory workers, it should be treated as
Factory OH or Production. OH and apportioned among all the production or service department on the
basis of number of workers in each department.
Fringe benefits relating to office, selling and distribution staff should be treated as Office and
Administration OH and Selling and Distribution OH and recovered accordingly.
(ii) Bad Debts:
111 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
If any bad debt arises due to exceptional circumstances, then such expenses are excluded from cost
A/c and charged to P&L A/c.
Question: 14:
Explain:
(iii) Research and Development Costs
(iv) Training Costs.
(Nov 2000)
Solution:
(iii) Please refer 1998 - Nov [7] (d) (i) on page no. 276
(iv) Training Expenses :
If labour turnover rate is very high (i.e. abnormally high) training cost in such case will also be very high.
In such case over and above the normal limit cost should be excluded from the total training cost and
transferred to costing P&L A/c.
Question: 15:
112 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Solution:
(i) Packing Expenses:
OR
(ii) Fringe Benefits: If any fringe benefits are incurred for factory workers, it should be treated as
Factory OH or Production. OH and apportioned among all the production or service department on the
basis of number of workers in each department.
113 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Fringe benefits relating to office, selling and distribution staff should be treated as Office and
Administration OH and Selling and Distribution OH and recovered accordingly.
114 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 1:
What is the fundamental difference between Activity Based Costing System (ABC) and Traditional
Costing System? Why more and more organisations in both the manufacturing and non-manufacturing
industries are adopting ABC?
(Nov 2007)
Solution:
Fundamental difference between ABC and Traditional costing system are as follows:
Question: 1:
Write short notes on:
Cost Ledger Control Account
(Nov 1996)
Solution:
This control account is popularly known as 'General Ledger Adjustment Account' or 'Financial Ledger
Control Account' and is opened in cost ledger to complete double entry. All items of income and
expenditure taken from financial accounts and all transfers from cost account to financial books are
recorded in this account since the purpose of this account is to complete double entry in the cost
ledger, therefore all transactions in the cost ledger must be recorded through the 'Cost Ledger Control
Account'. The balance in this account will always be equal to the total of all the balances of the
impersonal accounts. If a transaction is of interval nature affecting cost accounts only i.e., transfer
from stores ledger control account to WIP control account. Then no entry is necessary in General Ledger
Adjustment Account, because double entry is possible without recourse to this balancing account.
Question: 2:
Write short notes on: Integrated Accounts.
(May 1999, May 1998)
Solution:
CIMA defines that "Integrated accounting system refers to the interlocking of the Financial & Cost
Accounting system to ensure all relevant expenditure is absorbed into the Cost accounts. Under this
system transactions are classified both according to their production and nature."
Features:
Typical features of Integrated accounts are as follows:
(i) Control accounts for stores, WIP and finished goods are manner in the General Ledger itself.
(ii) Wages & O/H accounts are maintained in the usual maintenance. At the year end analysis of these
accounts is made and transfer are made to WIP, service deptts. and production deptt.
(iii) Accruals and prepaid expenses are brought into accounts for each period, instead of at the time of
making final payment.
117 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Under integrated accounting system, both financial and cost accounting records are maintained in one
set of books to meet the requirements of financial accounting and cost accounting purposes. In other
words, it can be said that cost accounting is integrated into the financial accounting system.
Integrated accounting records provide the necessary information for ascertainment of cost of each
unit, batch or job or any other cost unit and simultaneously financial statements viz. Profit & Loss A/c &
Balance Sheet can be prepared without.any distortion of the Financial Accounting information. In this
system transactions are recorded based on double entry book-keeping and costs are classified on the
basis of function which enables the firm to ascertain product cost for e.g. the purchase of raw material
in analysed by its nature and instead of posting it to the purchase accounts as in Financial accounts,
directly posted into stores ledger control account WIP
Ledger control account or overhead account. Similarly, the payment of direct wages instead of posting
into Direct Wages account, posting is directly made into wages control account or overhead control
account.
Question: 3:
State the essential pre-requisites of Integrated Accounting System.
(Nov 2007, Nov 2001)
Solution:
The success of an integrated system of accounting depends upon certain pre-requisities which should be
ensured before the system is introduced. These are:
1. Deciding the extent of integration of the two sets of books. Some companies find it useful to
integrate upto the stage of primary cost or factory cost while others prefer an integration of the entire
accounting records.
2. A suitable coding system must be developed to serve the purpose of both financial and cost accounts.
3. To lay down the procedure for the treatment of provision for accruals prepaid expenses, other
adjustments necessary preparing interim accounts.
4. Perfect coordination should exist between the staff responsible for financial aspects and cost
aspects of the accounts. An efficient processing of accounting documents is to be ensured.
5. Under this system there is no need for a separate cost ledger of cause, there will be a nuhnber of
subsidiary ledgers; in addition to the useful customers ledgers & the bought Ledgers, there will be: ...
(a) Stores ledger
(b) Stock ledger, &,
(c) Job ledger.
118 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 4:
What are the advantages of integrated accounting?
(May 2010, May 2005)
Solution:
Advantages: The main advantages of Integrated Accounts are as follows:
(i) Economical process: It is economical also as it is based on the concept of “Centralisation of
Accounting function.”
(ii) Less Time consuming: No delay is caused in obtaining information as it is provided from books of
original entry.
(iii) No need for Reconciliation: The question of reconciling costing profit and financial profit does not
arise, as there is one figure of profit only.
(iv) Less efforts: Due to use of one set of books, there is a significant extent of saving in efforts made.
Efforts in duplicate recording of entries and to maintain separate set of books are saved. Thus, there is
saving of time and labour.
(v) Complete details available: Complete details of all receipts and payments in cash and complete
details of all assets and liabilities are kept and this system does not use notional account to represent
impersonal accounts.
(vi) No delay: Costing data are available from books of original entry and hence, no delay is caused in
obtaining information.
(vii) Complete analysis: Complete analysis of cost and sales is kept. Since financial books are subject to
a rigorous accuracy, checking integrated accounts ensures similar checks for cost account.
Question: 5:
Discuss the reconciliation of Profits as per Cost Accounts and Financial Accounts. (6 marks)
(May 2006, May 2005)
Solution:
Problem of reconciliation arises where cost and financial accounts are maintained independent of each
other.
Reconciliation between the results of the two sets of books is necessary due to following reasons :
(i) To find out the reasons for the difference in the profit or loss in cost and financial accounts.
(ii) To contribute to the standardisation of policies regarding stock valuation depreciation and
overheads.
(iii) To facilitate co-ordination and promote better co-operation between the activities of financial and
cost sections of accounting department.
119 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
(iv) To place management in better position to acquaint itself with the reasons for the variation of
profit.
Reason for disagreement in profit Following are the reasons of disagreement of profit between two sets
of books :
(i) Item shown only in financial accounts.
(ii) Purely financial charge.
(iii) Appropriation of profit.
(iv) Writing of intangible and fictitious assets.
(v) Purely financial income.
(vi) Item shown only in cost accounts.
(vii) Over or under absorption of overheads.
(viii) Different basis of stock valuation
(ix) Different method of changing depreciation.
Question: 6:
List the Financial expenses which are not included in cost.
(Nov 2009)
Solution:
Financial expenses which are not included in cost accounting are as follows:
1. Preliminary expenses
2. Underwriting Commissions
3. Discount on issue of Share
4. Income Tax
5. Interest on debentures and deposit
6. Bonus of Employee
7. Pension
8. Gratuity
Question: 7:
When is the reconciliation statement of Cost and Financial accounts not required?
(Nov 2009)
Solution:
120 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 8:
Solution the following:
“Is reconciliation of cost accounts and financial accounts necessary in case of integrated accounting
system?”
(May 2013)
Solution:
• Under integrated accounting system, cost and financial accounts are kept in the same set of books.
Such a system will have to afford full information required for Costing as well as for Financial Accounts.
• In other way we can say, information and data should be recorded in such a way so as to enable the
firm to ascertain the cost (together with the necessary analysis) of each product, job, process,
operation or any other identifiable activity. It also ensures the ascertainment of marginal cost,
variances, abnormal losses and gains. In fact all information that management requires from a system of
Costing for doing its work properly is made available.
• The integrated accounts give full information in such a manner so that the profit and loss account and
the balance sheet can be prepared according to the requirements of law and the management maintains
full control over the liabilities and assets of its business.
Since, only one, set of books is kept for both cost accounting and financial accounting purpose so there
is no necessity of reconciliation of cost and financial accounts.
Question: 9:
What are the motivational factors for adopting a reconciliation process? Explain.
(Nov 2017)
Solution:
When the cost and financial accounts are kept separately, it is imperative that these should be
reconciled, otherwise the cost accounts would not be reliable. The reconciliation of two set of accounts
can be made, if both the sets contain sufficient detail as would enable the causes of differences to be
121 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
located. It is therefore, important that in the financial accounts, the expenses should be analysed in the
same way as in cost accounts. Motivation for reconciliation is:
• To ensure reliability of cost data
• To ensure ascertainment of correct product cost
• To ensure correct decision making by the management based on Cost & Financial data.
122 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 1:
Distinguish between “Job costing and batch costing”.
(May 2006, Nov 2005)
Solution:
Difference between Job Costing and Batch Costing
1. Nature Job costing is a specific order Batch costing is a special type
costing. of job costing.
2. Applicability It is undertaken in such industries It is undertaken in such
where work is done as per the industries where production is
customers requirement. of repetitive nature.
3. Similarity No two jobs are alike. The articles produced in a
batch are alike.
4. Cost The cost is deter-mined on job The cost is determined on
determination basis. batch basis.
5. Output The output of a job may be 1 unit, 2 The output of a batch is usually
quantity units of a batch. a large quantity.
6. Cost The cost is estimated before the The cost is determined after
estimation production. completion of production.
7. Examples Industries where job costing is Industries where batch costing
undertaken are repair workshop, is undertaken are
furniture, general engineering pharmaceuticals, garment
works. manufacturing, radio, T. V.
manufacturing etc.
Question: 2:
Describe Job Costing and Batch Costing giving examples of industries where these are used. (3 marks)
(May 2018, May 2001)
Solution:
Job Costing :
Meaning: It is a method of costing which is used when the work is undertaken as per the customer’s
special requirement. When an inquiry is received from the customer costs expected to be incurred on the
123 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
job are estimated and on the basis of this estimate a price is quoted to the customer. Actual cost of
materials, labour and overhead are accumulated and on the completion of job, these actual costs are
compared with the quoted price and thus the profit or loss on it is determined.
Job Costing is applicable in printing press, hardware foundry, ship building, heavy machinery, general
engineering works, machine tools, interior decoration, repairs and other similar work.
Batch:
A batch is a group of similar and identical product which is produced in a factory and is treated as a
single cost unit.
Batch Costing:
Batch costing is a specific type of job costing and is used in industries whose production are of
repetitive nature and where articles are produced in definite batches and held in stock. It is that form
of job costing where in cost is ascertained collectively for a batch and then cost per unit is determined.
The salient features of Batch Costing are as follows:
(i) Batch costing is applied in industries where identical products are produced.
(ii) The output of a batch consists of a number of units and it is not economical to ascertain cost of
every unit of output independently.
(iii) Certain physical characteristics like size colour, taste, quality etc. are required uniformly over a
collection of units e.g. garments of same size, pharmaceuticals etc.
Batch Costing is usually undertaken in the following industries:
Pharmaceuticals, garment manufacture, manufacture of spare parts, Radio, T.V, Computer manufacture
etc.
Computation :
Batch costing is but a specific type of job costing. Hence cost of each batch is ascertained in the same
way as that of an individual job.
Under batch costing a unit cost is ascertained by dividing the batch cost by the no. of units in a batch as
follows.
Cost/Unit = (Total cost of the batch )/(No.of nits produced in the batch)
Question: 3:
: : ::4.1 2000 - May [4] (c) (2 marks)
Discuss the concept of Economic Batch Quantity (EBQ).
Solution:
124 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Economic batch quantity (EBQ) is the optimum size of a batch to be produced. It represents that
number of units to be produced in a batch which will keep the aggregate of set up cost and carrying cost
to its minimum.
The determination of EBQ is important because if batch size is kept low the per unit set up cost
increases. If the batch, size is increased it results in accumulation of inventory which increases the
carrying cost. Thus to minimize the set up cost per unit the batch size is to be increased and to minimize
the total carrying cost the batch size is to be lowered. Thus it is necessary to strike a balance between
these two costs to minimize the aggregate of these two costs and this balance is brought about by EBQ.
Question: 4:
In Batch Costing, how is Economic Batch Quantity determined?
(May 2001)
Solution:
The determination of EBQ involves:
(i) Set up cost
(ii) Carrying cost
(i) Set up cost: Production of each batch of output necessitates the setting up of machine and tools at
the commencement of production and again its disassembling on completion of production. The set up
cost is the cost of setting up and disassembling of the machines and tools.
The cost remains fixed respective of the batch size. Thus if the batch size is low the set up cost per unit
is high and vice-versa.
(ii) Carrying cost: The cost associated with the holding the inventory is called carrying cost. It includes
rent of the space occupied by the inventory, interest on capital etc. It is a variable cost and is
dependent on the batch size.
If the batch size is increased the carrying cost increases and vice-versa.
Thus to keep the aggregate of set up costs and carrying cost to a minimum EBQ is determined with the
help of the following formula
EBQ = √(2AS/C)
Where A = Annual demand for the product
S = Set up cost per batch
C = Carrying cost per unit of production
If the rate of interest (I) and unit cost of production (C) are given,
then EBQ = √(2AS/1C)
125 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 1:
What is meant by Job Costing? Give examples of (any four) industries where it is used.
(Nov 2016, May 2001)
Solution:
Job Costing :
Meaning: It is a method of costing which is used when the work is undertaken as per the customer’s
special requirement. When an inquiry is received from the customer costs expected to be incurred on the
job are estimated and on the basis of this estimate a price is quoted to the customer. Actual cost of
materials, labour and overhead are accumulated and on the completion of job, these actual costs are
compared with the quoted price and thus the profit or loss on it is determined.
Job Costing is applicable in printing press, hardware foundry, ship building, heavy machinery, general
engineering works, machine tools, interior decoration, repairs and other similar work.
Question: 2:
Solution the following:
Explain the terms notional profit and retention money in contract costing.
(Nov 2011)
Solution:
Notional Notional Profit is the excess of income till date over expenditure till date on a contract.
Profit Since actual profit can be computed only after the contract is complete, notional profit is
used to recognise profit during the course of contract.
Retention The contractor gets money on the basis of work completed as certified by the certificate
Money of work done. Sometimes the customer does not pay the whole value of work done. As per
the agreement, a certain percentage of the value of work done is retained by the
customer. This is called Retention Money.
The objective behind Retention Money is to place the customer in a favourable position as
against the contractor. It safeguards the interest of the customer as against failure of
127 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
the contactor to fulfill any of the clause of the agreement or against the defective work
found later on.
Question: 3:
Solution the following :
Explain ‘Retention Money' and 'Progress payment' in contract.
(Nov 2017)
Solution:
Retention Money in Contract Costing:
A contractor does not receive the full payment of the work certified by the surveyor. Confractee
retains some amount to be paid after some time, when it is ensured that there is no default in the work
done by the contractor. If any deficiency or defect is noticed, it is to be rectified by the contractor
before the release of the retention money. Thus, the retention money provides a safeguard against the.
default risk in the contracts.
Progress Payment:
Contractors receive payments based on the certificate issued by the architect.
PP = Value of Work Certified - Retention Money.
Question: 4:
What are the main features of ‘Cost-Plus-Contracts’?
(Nov 1996)
Solution:
Cost Plus Contract: A cost plus contract is one in which the contract price is ascertained by adding a
percentage of profit to the total cost of contract. In such a contract the, contract gets re-imbursement
from the contractee, of all allowable or specifically defined costs incurred, plus a percentage of these
expenses or a fixed amount as profit.
Main features of Cost-Plus Contract:
1. The cost-plus-contract is adopted in those contracts where the probable cost of contract can not be
estimated with reasonable accuracy.
2. It is adopted in those contracts which may take a long duration to complete.
3. It Is preferred in case of those contracts whose cost of material and labour cost is unsteady and is
likely to change in future.
128 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
4. Such a contract is beneficial for both contractor as well as customer. On one hand, it offers a fair
price to the customer, and a reasonable profit to the contractor on the other hand.
5. The contract price is ascertained by adding a fixed and predetermined percentage of profit to the
total cost of contract.
6. The different costs to be included in the contract are pre-decided so that no dispute arises in future.
7. The customer is allowed to scrutinize the concerned books, documents and accounts of the
contractor.
Question: 5:
Write note on 'Escalation Clause’.
(May 2015, Nov 2000)
Solution:
Escalation :
clause Is a stipulation in the contract that the contract price will be increased by an agreed amount or
percentage if the price of raw material, wages etc. rises beyond a certain limit. The object of' this
clause is to safeguard the interest of both sides against unfavourable change in price. By this clause,
the contractor’s interests are safeguarded as his percentage of profit is not reduced. The customer's
interest is safeguard as quality is ensured because due to the escalation clause the contractor does not
use materials of low quality.
Accounting Treatment
Step 1 : The increased contract price is determined with reference to the escalation clause.
Step II: The amount due from the customer is recorded in contract A/c by passing the following journal
entry.
Customer's A/c ---Dr.
To Contract A/c
129 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 1:
"The value of scrap generated in a process should be credited to the process account". Do you agree with
this statement? Give reasons.
(Nov 1995)
Solution:
The statement is incorrect. The treatment of scrap depends on the condition under which the scrap is
generated.
If scrap is generated out of normal loss then the value of scarp should be credited to the
respective process account.
If the scrap is generated out of abnormal loss or abnormal gain then the value of scrap should be
credited to the abnormal loss A/c or Abnormal gain A/c.
Thus the value of scrap generated in a process is not always credited to the process account.
Question: 2:
Explain normal wastage, abnormal wastage and abnormal gain and state, how they should be dealt within
Process Cost Accounts.
(Nov 1998)
Solution:
Normal Process Loss :
The loss, which is unavoidable and is expected during the course of production, is called normal process
loss. Normal process loss may arise due to evaporation, chemical reaction, shrinkage, etc.
Accounting treatment of normal process loss :
No separate account is maintained for normal process loss. This is because the cost of normal loss is to
be borne by the good units produced in the process. The cost of normal loss is ascertained and charged
to respective process account.
If normal loss is disposed off for some price, then the realisable value from the sale of normal
process loss is credited to the concerned process account. Thus, in this type of situation, only the
difference between the cost of normal process loss and its realisable value is to be borne by the good
units.
There are certain losses, which are caused by unexpected or abnormal reasons such as fire, theft,
breakage, negligence etc. Such losses are known as abnormal process loss from accounting point of
view.
Abnormal process loss = Actual process loss - Normal process loss.
Accounting treatment of abnormal process loss :
A separate account is maintained for abnormal process loss as Abnormal Process Loss Account. This is
so because, since the abnormal losses are avoidable and can be controlled, it is not fair to charge the
cost of abnormal loss to the good units.
All the costs of abnormal loss are ascertained and transferred to the Abnormal loss account.
The following formula is used to ascertain the cost of abnormal loss.
Cost of abnormal loss = ([Total Process Cost]-[Realisable value of normal loss if any])/(Normal Output)
× Number of units of Abnormal loss
Where,
Normal output = Total input - Normal process loss
Unit of Abnormal loss = Total or Actual Process Loss – Normal Process Loss
The cost and units of abnormal process loss computed as above are credited to the concerned process
account and debited to the Abnormal Process Loss A/c.
The abnormal process loss A/c is closed by transferring the balance to costing profit & loss A/c i.e.
debiting Costing P&L A/c and crediting Abnormal Loss A/c.
If the abnormal loss has some scrap value and is disposed off accordingly, then only the balance
abnormal loss is debited to Costing P&L A/c and credited to Abnormal loss A/c.
Question: 3:
Explain “Equivalent Production”.
(Nov 2015, May 2002)
Solution:
Equivalent Production:
The presence of opening or closing WIP poses an accounting problem as to the evaluation of inventory as
well as ascertainment of cost per unit of output. To solve this problem, the WIP or incomplete units are
expressed in terms of complete units, which are termed as equivalent units of production. Thus,
equivalent production refers to a systematic procedure of expressing the output of a process in terms
of completed units. It is, therefore, the conversion of uncompleted production into its equivalent
completed units.
Output
Total
Equivalent
Uhits
14,000 Units
132 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Equivalent units of production means converting the uncompleted production into its equivalent
completed units. To compute the equivalent units, in each process, an estimate is made of the
percentage completion of the closing WIP. The WIP is inspected and an estimate is made of the degree
of completion, usually on a percentage basis.
Then the equivalent units of WIP can be computed by the following formula:
Equivalent units of production.
= Actual no. of units in WIP × Percentage of work completed.
E.g.
If the units in WIP be 200 and 60% work is completed then
Equivalent Units = 200 × 60%
= 120 units.
Question: 4:
Explain briefly the procedure for valuation of Work-in-process.
(Nov 2002)
Solution:
Presently WIP is valued in two ways, depending upon the assumption made regarding the flow of costs:
1. FIFO (First-in-first out) method
2. Average cost method.
When the prices of raw material and rate of labour and overhead are more of less stable WIP is valued by
FIFO method.
Under this method it is assured that the raw materials issued to WIP pass through the finished goods in
a progressive cycle i.e. what comes out first goes out first.
The closing WIP is valued at costs during the new period while opening WIP is valued at costs of the old
period.
When the prices of raw material and rate of labour and overhead flactuate from period to period, WIP is
valued by “Average cost method.” Under this method the closing WIP in old period is add to the cost of
new period and an average rate is obtained which tries to even out price fluctuations.
Question: 5:
What is inter-process profit? State its advantages and disadvantages.
(Nov 2013, Nov 2012)
133 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Solution:
Inter Process Profit
Meaning: We know that in processing units the output for one process becomes the input for the next
process. The price at which the output of one process is transferred to another, is called interprocess
price. In some processing units the output from one process is transferred at cost plus a percentage for
profit. This profit (transfer price-cost) is called inter process profit. Thus, inter-process profit is the
profit made by the transfer of output from one process to another.
Advantage :
Inter-process profit facilitates to evaluate the performance of each process, from the cost
effectiveness point of view and also from the profit point of view.
Disadvantage:
However, it poses a problem especially for the valuation of closing WIP. This is because, for financial
statement purpose closing WIP should be valued at cost or market value whichever is lower. Whereas
under this system, WIP should be valued at cost plus profit.
Question: 6:
“Operation costing is defined as refinement of Process costing." Explain it.
(May 2007)
Solution:
Operation costing is used for establishing cost of services rendered or service offered for sale and no
items are produced. It is also applied to the operations concerned within an organisation which provides
services to production departments. It is solely concerned with the determination of the cost of each
operation rather than the process costing.
Operation costing provides better control and facilities, the computation of unit operation cost at the
end of each operation. So, it can be said that the method of operation costing is similar to output
costing but not as process costing.
134 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 1:
Describe briefly, how joint costs upto the point of separation may be apportioned amongst the joint
products under the following methods:
(i) Average unit cost method
(ii) Contribution margin method
(iii) Market value at the point of separation
(iv) Market value after further processing
(v) Net realizable value method
(May 2009)
Solution:
Methods of apportioning joint cost among the joint products :
(i) Average Unit Cost Method
• In this method, total process cost (upto the point of separation) is divided by total units of joint
products produced.
• On division average cost per unit of production is obtained. The effect of application of this method is
that all joint products will have uniform cost per unit.
(ii) Contribution
Margin Method:
1. In this method joint costs are segregated into two parts - variable and fixed. The variable costs are
apportioned over the joint products on the basis of units produced (average method) or physical
quantities.
2. When the products are further processed, then all variable cost incurred be added to the variable cost
determined earlier.
3. After that contribution is calculated by deducting variable cost from their respective sales values.
4. The fixed costs are then apportioned over the joint products on the basis of contribution ratios.
1. Under this method the basis of apportionment of joint costs is the total sales value of finished
products at the further processing.
2. The use of this method is unfair where further processing costs after the point of separation are
disproportionate or when all the joint products tire not subjected to further processing.
Question: 2:
How apportionment of joint costs upto the point of separation amongst the joint products using market
value at the point of separation and net realizable value method is done? Discuss.
(Nov 2010)
Solution:
Apportionment of Joint Cost amongst Joint Products using:
Market value at the point of separation
Under this method, the market value of the joint products at the separation point is ascertained and the
total cost is ascertained in the ratio of the value.
It is difficult to apply if the market value of the product at the point of separation are not available. It
is useful method where further processing costs are incurred disproportionately.
Question: 3:
How would you account for by-product in cost accounting:
(i) When they are of small total value.
136 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Solution:
From cost accounting point of view by products may be classified as under:
(a) By-products of small total value
(b) By-products of considerable total value
(c) By-products which require further processing
Treatment of by products of small total value: When the by products are off small total value then the
amount realised from its sale may be either:
(a) Credited toyP & L Me as miscellaneous income or as additional sales revenue.
Or
(b) Deducted from the either the cost of production or from cost of sales.
Treatment of by products of considerable total value: When the by products are of considerable total
value then they are considered some as joint products and treated in the same way as that of joint
products.
Treatment of by products which require further processing : When the by products require further
processing, the net relisable value at split off point is computed as under:
Final sales value of product XXXX
Question: 1:
Distinguish between the Absolute ton-kms and Commercial ton-kms.
(Nov 2006)
Solution:
When goods are transported, the cost unit is tonne kilometres or quintal kilometres which are computed
as:
1. Absolute (weighted average) tonne-kilometres
2. Commercial (simple average) tonne-kilometres
Absolute (weighted average) tonne- kilometres: It is the sum total of tonnes-kilometre which is
determined by multiplying various distances by respective load quantity carried.
or
Numerically, Absolute tonne-kilometres =∑(Distance covered between two stations local carried)
Question: 2:
Write Short Notes on Operating Costing.
(May 1997)
Solution:
•Operating costing is one of the methods of costing used to ascertain the cost of generating and
rendering services such as transport, hospitals, canteens, electricity etc.
• It is undertaken in industries which provides services such as canteens, hospitals, electricity,
transport etc.
• Operating Costing aims at ascertaining the operating costs.
• The cost incurred to generate and render services such as hospital, canteen, electricity, transport etc.
is called operating cost.
Question: 3:
State the unit of cost for the following industries : '
(a) Transport
138 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
(b) Power
(c) Hotel
(d) Hospital
(Nov 2008)
Solution:
The unit of cost for various industries are as follows :
Industry Unit of Cost
(a) Transport (i) Goods - Per ton km. or per tonne km.
(ii) Passengers - per passenger km.
(b) Power Per kilo-watt hour (Kwh) or Horse Power (HP)
(c) Hotel Per Room-day or Per Service-day
(d) Hospital Per Patient-day or Per Bed-day or per Operation
Question: 4:
“The more kilometers you travel with your own vehicle, the cheaper it becomes". Comment briefly on
this statement.
(Nov 1995)
Solution:
The cost per kilometre is arrived at by dividing the total cost incurred by the total kilometres travelled.
Since the majority of cost for running and maintaining vehicles are fixed in nature, the fixed cost per
kilometre decreases with increase in kilometre. Thus as more kilometres is travelled it becomes cheaper.
139 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 1:
Mention the causes that give rise to labour rate variance.
(Nov 1996)
Solution:
Labour variance arises due to the difference between standard labour hour rate specified and the actual
labour, hour rate paid. It is computed by multiplying the actual hours taken by workers on a job by the
difference between the standard and actual wage rate per hour.
Main causes which contribute for the occurrence of labour rate variance are as below:
1. Increase in actual wage rate per hour paid to workers.
2. Payment of special increments or allowances to workers.
3. Resorting to excessive overtime.
4. Using a gang or mix different from that used for setting labour standard.
5. Use of wrong type of labour i.e. for a job requiring the use of non-skilled labour uses skilled labour.
Since the wages of skilled labour are more than that of non-skilled labour, therefore this increased
wage rate per hour of skilled labour force accounts for the occurrence of iabour rate variance.
6. Non-anticipated wage increase at the time of setting standards.
Question: 2
“Overhead variances should be viewed as interdependent rather than independent". Explain.
(May 2006)
Solution:
Overhead variances occur due to the difference between actual overheads and absorbed overheads.
Therefore, if we have to calculate an overhead variance, we have to know the amount of the actual
overheads and that of absorbed overheads.
The actual overheads can be known only at the end of the accounting period when the expense accounts
are finalized.
The absorbed overheads are the overheads charged to each unit of production on the basis of a
predetermined overhead rate.
Such pre-determined rate is also known as standard overhead recovery rate, or standard overhead
absorption rate or standard burden rate.
To calculate the standard overhead recovery rate, we have to first make an estimate of the likely
overhead expenses for each department for the next year.
140 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
The estimate of budget of the overheads is to be divided into fixed and variable elements.
An estimate of the level of normal capacity utilization is then made either in terms of production or
machine hours or direct labour hours.
The estimated overheads are divided by the estimated capacity level to calculate the pre-determined.
Overhead absorption rate as shown below:
Std. Fixed Overhead Rate = (Budgeted fixed overheads)/(Normal volume)
Std. Variable Overhead Rate = (Budgeted variable overheads)/(Normal volume)
Question: 3
How are cost variances disposed off in a standard costing system? Explain.
(Nov 1998)
Solution:
There is no difference of opinion among the Cost Accountants regarding the disposition of variances.
The following are the commonly used methods by them for the disposition of variance.
1. Transfer all variances to Profit and Loss Account, Under this method, stock of work-in-progress,
finished stock and cost of sales are maintained at standard cost and variances arising are transferred to
profit and loss account.
2. Distributing variances on pro-rata basis over the cost of sales, work-in- progress and finished goods
stocks by using suitable basis.
3. Write off quantity variance to profit and loss account and spread price variance over to cost of sales,
work in progress and finished goods. The reason behind apportioning price variance to inventories and
cost of sales is that they represent costs although they are derived as variances.
Question: 4
"Calculation of variances in standard costing is not an end in itself, but a means to an end.” Discuss.
(May 1999)
Solution:
The gist of standard costing lies in variance analysis. Standard costing is the technique whereby
standard costs are predetermined and subsequently compared with the recorded actual costs. It is a
technique of cost ascertainment and cost control. It establishes predetermined estimates of the cost of
products and services based on management’s standards of efficient operation. It lays emphasis on
“what the cost should be”. These costs should be then compared with the actual costs. The difference
between standard cost and actual cost of actual output is defined as the variance. The calculation of
variances is simple. A variance may be favourable or unfavourable. If the actual cost is less than the
141 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
standard cost, the variance is favourable but if the actual cost is more than the standard cost, the
variance willbe unfavourable. These costs should be then compared with the actual costs. The difference
between standard cost and actual cost of actual output is defined as the variance. The calculation of
variances is simple. A variance may be favourable or unfavourable. If the actual cost is less than the
standard cost, the variance is favourable but if the actual cost is more than the standard cost, the
variance will be unfavourable. They are easily expressible and do not provide detailed analysis to enable
management to exercise control over them. It is not enough to know the figures of these variances from
month to month. Standard costing is required to trace their origin and cause of occurrence for taking
necessary remedial steps to reduce/ eliminate them.
Variances help the management to ascertain:
(1) the amount of a variance.
(2) the factors or causes of their occurrence.
(3) the responsibility to be laid on executives and departments.
(4) corrective actions which should be taken to obviate or reduce the variances.
The success of variance analysis depends upon how quickly and effectively the corrective actions can be
taken on the analysed variances. Variances give only information . The manager needs to act on the
information provided for taking corrective action. Information is the means and action taken on it is the
end.
Therefore, we can say that the calculation of variances in standard costing is not an end in itself, but a
means to an end.
Question: 5
Describe three distinct group of variances that arise in standard costing.
(May 2005)
Solution:
The three distinct groups of variances that arise in standard costing are :
1. Variances of efficiency: These are the variances, which arise due to efficiency or inefficiency in use
of material, labour etc.
2. Variances of prices and rates : These are the variances, which arise due to changes in procurement,
price and standard price.
3. Variances due to volume : These represent, the effect of difference between actual activity and
standard level of activity.
The above can be summarised as follows:
Element of cost Variance of efficiency Variance of price Variance due to volume
Materials Usage, mixture, Yield Price Revision
142 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 6
“Standard costing variances centre around comparison of Actual Performance with the standard and the
standards or plans are normally based on the environment anticipated when the targets are set and if
the current environment is different from that anticipated, such analysis cannot measure managerial
performance/’ Comment on the statement and how will you deal with the situation with reference to
material, labour and sales variances.
(Nov 2000)
Solution:
The statement given in the question shows a practical problem faced by our enterprises :
When the current circumstances are different from the anticipated circumstances, the use of routine
analysis of variance for measuring managerial performance is not desirable/suitable.
Variance analysis can be useful for measuring managerial performance if the variances computed are
determined on the basis of revised targets/standards based on current actual environmental conditions.
In order to deal with the above situation i.e. to measure managerial performance with reference to
material, labour and sales variances, it is necessary to proceed and compute the following variances.
Material variances :
In the case of material purchase price variance, suppose the standard price of raw material determined
was Rs. 50 per unit, the general market price per unit at the time of purchase was Rs. 55 and actual
price paid per unit was Rs. 53 on the purchase of say 1,000 units of raw material.
Labour Variances: As in the case of material variances, here also, labour efficiency and wage rate
variances should be adjusted to reflect changes in environmental conditions that prevailed during the
period. The labour efficiency variance would be equivalent to the following two variances :
(a) Uncontrollable labour efficiency planning variance
(b) Controllable labour efficiency variance
The above variances would arise when unskilled labour is substituted for skilled iabour.
Sales variances: The conventional safes volume variance reports the difference between actual and
budgeted sales, priced at the budgeted contribution per unit. Such variance merely indicates whether
sales volume is greater or less than expected. It does not indicate how well actual sales volume should
be compared with an expert estimate that reflects the market conditions prevailing during that period.
Total sales margin variance (planning element) :
= {Expert’s budgeted sales volume × (Expert’s selling price - Standard cost) - Original budgeted
sales volume × (Budgeted selling price - Standard cost)}
Total sales margin variance (appraisal element):
= {Actual sales volume × (Actual selling price - Standard cost) - Expert's budgeted sales volume ×
(Expert’s selling price - Standard cost)}
The amount of “Expert’s budgeted sales volume” for a particular product can be determined by
estimating the total market sales volume for the period and then multiplying the estimate by the target
percentage of market share.
Question: 7
State the features of Partial Plan of Standard Cost Accounting procedure.
(May 2001)
Solution:
Features of Partial Plan of Standard Cost Accounting procedure :
Standard cost operations can be recorded in the books of account by using partial plan.
Features of partial plan are as follows
1. Partial plan system uses current standards in which the inventory will be valued at current standard
cost figure.
2. The analysis of variance is done after the end of the month.
3. The closing balance of WIP is also shown at standard cost. The balance after making the credit
entries represent the variance from standard for the month.
4. Under this method, WIP account is charged at the actual cost of production for the month and is
credited with the standard cost of the month’s production of finished product.
144 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 8
’’Standard costing system is not compatible with Activity Based Costing System." Do you agree with this
statement? Explain your Solution.
(May 2002)
Solution:
It is not correct to say that standard Costing system is not compatible with Activity Based Costing
System.
Standard costing system is a tool for cost control. In this, standards are established for each cost
element. Variances between standard cost and actual costs are reported periodically to managers, who
use the information of remedial measures or for revision of standards.
Under ‘Activity Based Costing System’ costs are collected around activity pools and are assigned to
products and services using appropriate cost drivers. Standards can be established for costs for
carrying out each type of activity.
Question: 9
How the opportunity cost for inefficient use of scarce resources be presented in variance reports under
a standard costing system?
(May 2007)
Solution:
Opportunity cost arises from failure to use scarce resources efficiently, such as:
1. Inefficient capacity utilisation results in loss of production and consequently loss of contribution.
2. Inefficient use of scarce material results in lower production and loss of contribution.
So, it is appropriate to include contribution loss in reporting material usage variance or labour
efficiency variance, in case the material is scarce or labour hours is scarce. As a general rule, loss of
contribution should be included in the variance report and should be assigned to the manager, whose
below standard performance has caused the loss.
Question: 10
Under the single plan, record the journal entries giving appropriate narration, with indication of amounts
of debits or credits alongside the entries, for the following transactions using the respective control
A/c.
145 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Solution:
Under the single plan, Journal entries are :
(i) Material price variance (on purchase of materials)
Material Control A/c Dr.
Material price Variance A/c Dr or Cr. (Bal. Fig)
To Creditor A/c
(Being price variance during purchase of materials)
(ii) Material usages variance (on consumption)
WIP Control A/c Dr.
Material usage variance Dr or Cr. (Bal fig).
To Material Control A/c
(Being recording of usage variance at Standard cost of over/under utilised quantity).
Question: 11
: : ::6.9 2015-Nov [7] (b) (4 marks)
Solution the following:
Describe the various steps involved in adopting standard costing system in an organisation.
Solution.:
Standard costing is an accounting technique the breaks overspending and underspending on material
labour and overhead cost into their price and quantity Components. For e.g. a manager may notice that
the company spent too much on material last month. By implementing a standard costing system, the
manager will be able to determine how much of the overage is relating to the cost of materials and how
much is related to overuse. Understanding the first step of standard costing, implementing can help you
design a standard costing system for your small business.
146 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Steps:
• Practical or ideal standards
• Material standards
• Labour standards
• Variable standards
147 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Solution:
Difference between Differential Costing and Marginal Costing:
The basic differences between differential costing and marginal costing are as below:
1. Differential cost analysis is possible in both absorption costing and marginal costing.
2. The technique of marginal costing requires a clear distinction between variable costs and fixed costs
whereas no such distinction is made in the case of differential costing. In differential costing all total
relevant costs irrespective of the fact whether they are fixed or variable are considered whereas in the
case of marginal costing only variable costs are taken into account.
3. Marginal costs may be incorporated in the accounting system whereas differential costs are worked
out separately as analysis statements.
4. In marginal costing margin of contribution and contribution ratio are the main yardsticks for
performance evaluation and for decision making. In differential costs analysis, differential costs are
compared with the incremental or decremental revenues as the case may be, and then arrive at a
decision.
Question: 2
Distinguish between absorption costing and marginal costing.
(Nov 2003, Nov 2001)
Solution:
Difference between Absorption Costing and Marginal Costing
Sl. No. Basis Absorption Costing Marginal Costing
1 Calculation of In this, absorption rate includes, both Marginal costing rate includes
Manufacturing fixed and variable * manufacturing only variable manufacturing
Overhead overheads. overhead.
rates
2 Valuation of In Absorption costing, valuation is on Marginal costing will be at Prime
Inventory Product cost i.e. Prime cost + applied cost + applied variable
fixed and variable manufacturing manufacturing overhead.
overheads.
148 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 3
2002 - May [2] (a) Distinguish
Differentiate between ‘cost indifference point’ and ‘break-even point’.
(4 marks)
Solution:
Cost indifference point: Is the point at which total cost lines under the two alternatives intersect each
other.
149 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Whereas, Break-even point is the point where the total cost line and total revenue line for a particular
alternative intersect each other.
Breaks even point is calculated as under:
(Fixed costs)/(Contribution per unit) or (Fixed costs)/(PV ratio)
The following are the main points of distinction between cost indifference point and break-even point:
1. The cost indifference point is the activity level at which total cost two alternatives are equals,
whereas break-even point is the activity level at which the total revenue from a product or product mix
is equal to its cost.
2. Cost indifference point is used to choose between two alternative processes for achieving the same
objective. The choice depends on the estimated activity level. Break-even point is used for profit
planning.
Question: 4:
Write short notes on the following :
Angle of Incidence
(May 2012)
Solution:
Angle of incidence
• Angle of incidence is formed by the intersection of sales line and total cost line at the break-even
point.
• This angle shows the rate at which profits are being earned once the break-even point has been
reached.
• The wider the angle the greater is the rate of earning profits. A large angle of incidence with a high
margin of safety indicates extremely favourable position.
Question: 5
Indicate any five circumstances under which you will permit to fix a price, which is less than the
marginal cost of the product.
(May 1998)
150 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Solution:
Circumstances under which a firm may fix a price less than the marginal cost of the product are as
under:
1. When goods are of perishable nature.
2. When the concern had already purchased huge quantities of raw materials and the prices of these
materials is falling considerably in the market.
3. When competitors are to be eliminated from the market,
4. When a new product is to be introduced in the market.
5. To obviate shut-down costs
Question: 6
"Use of absorption costing method for the valuation of finished goods inventory provides incentive for
over-production." Elucidate the statement.
(May 2002)
Solution:
If absorption costing method is used, production fixed overheads are charged to product and are
included in product costs. Consequently, the closing stocks are valued on total costs (including fixed
overheads) basis. The net effect is that the charge of fixed overheads to P/L account gets reduced, if
the closing stock is greater than the opening stock. This situation has the effect of inflating the profit
for the period.
When stock levels are likely to fluctuate significantly, profits may be distorted if calculated on
absorption costing basis. If marginal costing is used, since the fixed costs are charged off to P/L
account as period cost, such a situation will not arise. The impact of using absorption costing on profits
can be summarized as under:
1. When sales are equal to production, profits will be the same under absorption costing and marginal
costing.
2. If production is higher than sales, the absorption costing will poster higher profit than marginal
costing.
3. If sales are in excess of production, absorption costing will show lower profits than marginal costing.
Since profit calculation in absorption costing can produce strange result, the managers may deliberately
alter the stock levels to influence the profits if absorption costing is used. Hence, it is true to say that
if absorption costing method is used managers have the incentive to over-produce to show better result.
Question: 7
“The use of Absorption Costing method in decision-making process leads to anomalies.: Discuss.
151 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
(May 2006)
Solution:
The statement is given in the question: : :: is correct in the following ways:
1. In this method all fixed costs are not charged against the revenue of the year in which they are
incurred. It is an unsound practice.
2. Behavioural pattern of costs is not given importance.
3. Absorption costing produces a means of determining selling prices, but in most cases accuracy cannot
be achieved due to the nature of overheads included in the calculations.
4. Assigning product cost with a reasonable share of fixed overhead obscures cost-volume-profit
relationship. When there are different types of cost units, the attribution of overheads to them is bound
to be arbitrary to some extent. If sales pricing decisions are based on total unit costs there is a danger
that some products will be over-priced and others under-priced, and total revenue and/or profit will not
be maximised.
5. This method employs highly arbitrary way of apportionment of overheads which reduces the utility of
cost data for control purposes. Neither the actual nor the predetermined method of absorption
distinguishes clearly the extent to which total unit costs are affected by volume changes and other
causes respectively. Thus, there is no one unit cost that may be used as a guide to decision-making when
the decision involve a change in volume.
6. In reporting enterprise results, the profit of a particular period will be affected by the amount of
overheads absorbed into closing inventories or work-in-progress or finished stock or charged against the
period when opening inventories are sold.
7. The decision-maker needs to know the costs that will vary as a result of his decision, and the costs
that will remain unchanged. Absorption costing does not provide a convenient basis for making such
calculations. Its main purpose is to provide cost information for stock valuation and the measurement of
reported profits.
8. The complaint is sometimes made that absorption costing often deals only with production costs and
ignores selling and administration costs.
Question: 8
What are the limitations of marginal costing? Explain.
(Nov 1998)
Solution:
1. Marginal costing technique is not useful for valuation of inventory.
2. Marginal costing cannot be successfully applied in cost plus contract unless a proper percentage over
marginal cost is charged to cover the fixed cost and profit.
152 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
3. Marginal costing technique excludes fixed cost for decision making which some times leads to wrong
conclusion. It may create difficulty in inter-firm comparison, higher demand of salaries, large tax
payment etc.
4. Marginal costing assumes that all costs can be classified into fixed and variable. But it is not so, as
there are costs which are neither fixed or variable. For example, various amenities provided to workers
may have no relation either to volume of production or time factor.
5. Contribution of a product itself is not a guide for optimum profitability unless it is linked with the
key factor.
6. Marginal Costing ignores time factor and investment. For example, the marginal cost of two jobs may
be the same but the time taken for their completion and the cost of machines used may differ. The true
cost of a job which takes longer time and uses costlier machine would be higher. This factor is not
disclosed by marginal costing.
7. The overheads of fixed nature cannot altogether be excluded particularly in large contracts while
valuing work-in-progress. In order to show the correct position, fixed overheads have to be included in
work-in- progress.
8. In the long run, the selling prices should be based on total cost, i,e, inclusive of fixed cost also. In the
short run or in special, situations when a product is sold below the total cost, customers may insist on
the continuation of reduced prices forever which may not be possible in all cases. Further, sales staff
may mistake marginal cost for total cost and sell at a price which will result in loss or low profit. Hence,
sales staff should be cautioned while giving marginal cost.
9. The main assumptions regarding behaviour of costs are not true. The variable costs do not remain
constant per unit of output. There may be changes in the prices of raw materials, wage rates, etc., after
a certain level of output has been reached due to shortage of material, shortage of skilled labour,
concessions of bulk purchases, etc. Similarly, the fixed costs does not remain static. They may change
from one period to another. For example, salary bill may go up because of annual increments or due to
change in pay rate etc.
Question: 9
What is contribution? How is it related to profit?
(May 1998)
Solution:
The excess of selling price over variable costs is known as contribution.
Contribution = Sales - Variable Cost.
Or
153 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Contribution is also known as the gross margin. It indicates the amount of sales revenue which is
available to cover fixed costs and profits. Once fixed costs have been fully received by the contribution,
every rupee of additional sale is a net addition to profits. Entire marginal costing is based on this
concept.
Contribution helps the management in solving the following problems:
1. Fixation of selling price.
2. Pricing in depression .
3. Accepting a special offer from a new market.
4. Level of activity planning.
5. Evaluation of profitability of various products, departments etc.
6. Selection of an optimum sales mix..
7. Alternative methods of production.
8. Operate or shut down decisions.
Question: 10
Explain, how Cost Volume Profit (CVP)-based sensitivity analysis can help managers cope with
uncertainty.
(Nov 2000)
Solution:
Sensitivity analysis focuses on how a result will be changed if the original estimates of the following
assumptions has changed.
Cost Volume Profit (GVP)-based sensitivity analysis can help managers to provide Solutions to the
following question: : ::s to cope up with uncertainty.
1. What will be the profit if the sales mix changes from that originally predicted?
2. What will be the profit if fixed costs increase by 10% and variable cost decline by 5%?
The use of spread sheet packages has enabled managers to develop CVP computerised models which can
Solution the above question.
Managers can now consider alternative plans by keying the information into a computer, which can
quickly show changes both graphically and numerically.
Therefore, managers can study various combinations of change in selling prices, fixed costs, variable
costs and product mix, and can react quickly without waiting for formal reports from the accountant.
In such a way the use of CVP based sensitivity analysis can help managers to cope up with uncertainty.
Question: 11
What is Cost-volume-profit analysis and what are it objectives
154 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
(May 2001)
Solution:
Cost-volume-profit analysis: It is the analysis of three variables, viz., cost, volume and profit, which
explores the relationship existing amongst costs, revenue, activity levels and the resulting profit.
Profit, as a variable, is the reflection of a number of internal and external conditions which exert their
influence on sales revenue and costs. Revenue depends upon selling prices, costs, volume of sales,
demand, competition, etc. Although none of these can be singled out as the most important, the volume
is considered to be a dominant factor. This is probably because changes in volume are more frequent,
takes place rapidly and are outside the purview of management control. Further costs rarely vary in
direct proportion to the volume and hence, a small change in the volume may have a more than
proportionate effect on profits than the other factors outlined above. It is thus, the volume which is
perhaps the largest single factor which influences costs. As such, an intimate relationship exists
amongst costs, volume and profit.
The cost-volume-profit analysis is an extension of marginal costing it makes use of the
principles of marginal costing. It is an important tool of short term planning and is more relevant where
the proposed changes in the level of activity are relatively small. It is useful in making short run
decisions.
Question: 12
Briefly discuss on curvilinear CVP analysis.
(Nov 2001)
Solution:
In CVP analysis, the usual assumption is that the total sales line and variable cost line will have linear
relationship, that is, these lines will be straight lines. However, in actual practice it is unlikely to have a
linear relationship for two reasons, which are :
1. After the saturation point of existing demand, the sales value may show a downward trend.
155 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
2. The average unit variable cost decline initially, reflecting the fact that, as output increases the firm
will be able to obtain bulk discounts on the purchase of raw materials and can also benefit from division
of labour. When the plant is operated at further higher levels of output, due to bottlenecks, and
breakdowns, the variable cost per unit will tend to increase. Thus the law of increasing costs may
operate and the variable cost per unit may increase after reaching a particular level of output.
In these cases, the contribution will not increase in linear proportion, i.e., based on the phenomenon of
diminishing marginal productivity, the total cost line will not be straight as assumed but will be of
curvilinear shape.
This situation will give rise to two break-even points. The optimum profit is earned at the point where
the distance between sales and total cost is the greatest.
Question: 13
State the assumptions of cost-volume-profit analysis.
(May 2012, May 2003)
Solution:
CVP Analysis: Assumptions
1. Changes in the levels of revenues and costs arise only because of changes in the number of products
(or service) units produced and sold.
2. Total cost can be separated into two components: Fixed and variable
3. Graphically, the behaviour of total revenues and total cost are linear in relation to output level within
a relevant range.
4. Selling price, variable cost per unit and total fixed costs are known and constant.
5. All revenues and costs can be added, subtracted and compared without taking into account the time
value of money.
6. Only one product is considered for entire analysis.
Question: 14
List out the assumptions of break even analysis.
(Nov 1998)
Solution:
Assumptions of Break-even Analysis:
1. All costs can be separated into fixed and variable.
2. Variable costs vary in proportion to output and fixed costs remain constant.
3. Costs and revenues are linear over the range of activity under consideration.
4. Costs and revenues are influenced only by volume.
156 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 15
Solution the following:
Explain and illustrate cash break even chart.
(May 2008, May 2001)
Solution:
A Cash Breakeven Chart records cash costs and revenues on the vertical axis and the level of activity on
the horizontal axis. In this chart, variable costs are assumed to be payable in cash. Beside this, the fixed
expenses are divided into two groups viz.
(i) Those expenses which involve cash outflow, e.g. rent, insurance, salaries etc. and
(ii) Those expenses which do not involve cash outflow, e.g. depreciation, bad debts etc.
The making of the cash breakeven chart would require us to select appropriate axes. Subsequently, we
will mark costs/revenues on the Y axis whereas the level of activity shall be traced on the X axis. Lines
representing (i) Cash Fixed costs, (ii) Total costs at maximum level of activity and (iii) Revenue at
maximum level of activity (joined to the origin) shall be drawn next. The cash breakeven point is that
point where the sales revenue line intersects the total cash cost line. Other measures like the margin of
safety and profit can also be measured from the chart.
It is computed as under:
Cash BEP (units) = (Cash Fixed Cost)/(Contribution Per Unit)
Question: 16
Differentiate between ‘cost indifference point’ and ‘break-even point’.
(May 2002)
Solution:
Cost indifference point: Is the point at which total cost lines under the two alternatives intersect each
other.
Cost indifference point is calculated as under:
157 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Whereas, Break-even point is the point where the total cost line and total revenue line for a particular
alternative intersect each other.
Breaks even point is calculated as under:
(Fixed costs)/(Contribution per unit) or (Fixed costs)/(PV ratio)
The following are the main points of distinction between cost indifference point and break-even point:
1. The cost indifference point is the activity level at which total cost two alternatives are equals,
whereas break-even point is the activity level at which the total revenue from a product or product mix
is equal to its cost.
2. Cost indifference point is used to choose between two alternative processes for achieving the same
objective. The choice depends on the estimated activity level. Break-even point is used for profit
planning.
Question: 17
What are the limitations of a break-even chart?
(May 1999)
Solution:
The limitations of Break-even Chart are as follows :
1. While preparing a break-even chart, it is assumed that revenue and costs can be represented with the
help of straight lines. It may not always be true.
2. The preparation of a break- even chart requires the segregation of semi¬variable costs into fixed and
variable components. It may not always be possible to segregate semi-variable costs cannot be split.
3. A break-even chart assumes that selling price and variable cost per unit are constant at all levels of
activity. It may not always be true. Selling price as well as variable cost may either increase or decrease
with the change in volume. Fixed costs also tend to vary beyond a certain output.
4. When a firm produces a number of products the apportionment of fixed expenses, over various
products may be difficult and often it may be done arbitrarily.
5. A break-even chart assumes that business conditions will not change. This is hardly so.
6. A break-even chart does not consider the amount of capital employed in the business, a very
important factor for determining profitability of a concern.
Question: 18
158 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Solution:
Margin of Safely:
Margin of safety is the excess of sales over the break-even sales, it may also be considered as the
excess of production over break -even point. It can be expressed in value as well as in percentage. The
size of margin of safety shows the strength of the business. Small size of margin of safety indicates
that the firm has large fixed expenses and is more vulnerable to changes in sales. In other words, if the
margin of safety is large, a slight fall in sales may not affect the business very much but when it is small
then a slight fall in sales may adversely affect the business.
The margin of safety is calculated by using the following formula:
Margin of safety = Actual Sales - Break -even sales
Margin of safety = Profit/(P⁄V ra )
Or
= Profit/((Contribution⁄Sal ))
Margin of safety is also immensely useful for making inter-firm comparison. This is being done by
calculating their margin of safety ratio. This ratio can be calculated by using the following formula:
Margin of safety ratio = (Margin of safety)/Sales × 100
Or
= (Actual Sales - Breakeven Sales)/Sales × 100
Question: 19
Solution the following:
What is the meaning of Margin of Safety (MOS)? State the relationship between Operating Leverage and
Margin of Safety Ratio.
(Nov 2013)
159 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Solution:
Margin of Safety:
Please refer 1999 - May [1] {C} (a) on page no. 878
Question: 20
Explain briefly angle of incidence and margin of safety in Break Even Analysis.
(May 1999)
Solution:
Angle of incidence (Refer to above diagram)
The point P where the sales line cuts the total cost line is known as a break¬even -point and the angle
formed by these lines is called angle of incidence. This angle tells us about the rate at which profits are
being made. The larger angle of incidence indicate higher rate of profit or versa.
Margin of safety:
The difference between total sales and sales at break-even-point represents the margin of safety. It is
the amount of sales above the break-even point. If there is a fall in the sales to the extent of margin of
safety, this situation would indicate that firm is operating at break-even-point.
Margin of safety can be expressed in absolute terms and also in terms of percentage.
In absolute terms :
Margin of safety = Actual sales - Sales at break even point
In terms of percentage, it is computed as under:
Margin of safety ratio = (Margin of safely in absolute terms)/(Actual sates) × 100
Question: 21
Discuss the relationship between Angle of Incidence, Break-even Level and Margin of Safety.
(Nov 1999)
160 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Solution:
1. If the break-even point is low and angle of incidence is large, the margin of safety is large and the
business enjoys financial stability. A low break-even point indicates that the business could be run
profitably even if there is a fall in sales, unless the sales are very low.
2. If the break-even point is low and angle of incidence is small, the conclusions are the same as in 1
above except that the rate of profit earning capacity is not so high as in 1.
3. If the break-even point is high and the angle of incidence is small, the margin of safety is low. The
business is very vulnerable, even a small reduction in activity may result in a loss.
4. If the break-even point is large and the angle of incidence is large, this shows that the margin of
safety is low. The business is likely to incur losses through a small reduction in activity. However after
the break-even point, the business makes the profit at a high rate.
Question: 22
What are the important decision-making areas where marginal-costing technique is used?
(May 2001)
Solution:
Marginal costing is a useful technique of decision making, used by the management of most of the
manufacturing concerns. Some of the important decision making areas where marginal costing technique
is used by these concerns are:
1.Fixation of selling price.
(i) Under normal circumstances
(ii) For special market (export market) or for a special custome*
(iii) During recession
(iv) At marginal cost or below marginal cost.
2. Decision relating to the most profitable product mix
(i) Selection of optimal product mix
(ii) Substitution of one product with another
(iii) Discontinuing or dropping of a product line
3. Decision relating to make or buy
4. Shut down or continue of determination or output level in period of recession of depression.
5. Retaining or replacing a machine
6. Selling in the home or in the export market
7. Change vs. Status quo
8. Expanding or contracting
161 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 23
Elaborate the practical application of Marginal Costing.
(Nov 2013)
Solution:
Practical Application of Marginal Costing:
Marginal costing is a useful technique of decision making, used by the management of most of the
manufacturing concerns. Some of the important decision making areas where marginal costing technique
is used by these concerns are :
1. Fixation of selling price:
(i) Under normal circumstances
(ii) For special market (export market) or for a special customer
(iii) During recession
(iv) At marginal cost or below marginal cost.
2. Decision relating to the most profitable product mix:
(i) Selection of optimal product mix
(ii) Substitution of one product with another
(iii) Discontinuing or dropping of a product line
3. Decision relating to make or buy
4. Shut down or continue of determination or output level in period of recession of depression.
5. Retaining or replacing a machine
6. Selling in the home or in the export market
7. Change vs. Status quo
8. Expanding or contracting
9. Decision relating to price-mix.
Question: 24
Solution the following:
What do you understand by Key factor ? Give two examples of it.
(May 2010)
Solution:
Key factor is a factor which at a particular time or over a period limits the activities of an undertaking.
It may be the level of demand for the products or service or it may be the shortage of one or more of the
productive resources.
162 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Solution:
Fixed Budgets: A budget prepared for a particular level of activity is called fixed budget. It presents the
cost details for a specific level of activity, Consequently, budgeted costs for budgeted level of activity
are compared with the actual costs for actual level of activity. Therefore, fixed budget is not going to
highlight the cost variances due to the difference in the levels of activity.
Flexible Budgets: A budget prepared for a range of activities rather than a single level of activity is
called flexible budget. It is capable of furnishing the budgeted cost at any level of activity. It
recognises the behaviour of costs and classifies them into variable, fixed and semi-variable. On the basis
of this, the budget is designed to change (i.e., flex) in relation to the level of activity attained.
Therefore, it is able to compute and compare the budgeted costs for actual level of activity attained. In
order to prepare the flexible budgets, tabular method is normally used.
Question: 2
Write a short note on “Key Factor”.
(May 1998)
Solution:
Every businessman aims to produce and sell unlimited units of the product manufactured by him. But it
is not possible due to some factor. There is always a factor which may limit the activity level of a firm
such a factor is known as the key factor. In most of the cases ‘sales’ is the key factor. It determines the
volume of output to be produced. Sometime sales may not be the key factor but some other factor such
as labour; machine capacity, material, finance etc. When may not be available in requisite quantity will
be a key factor. In other words, key factor is a factor that limits the quantum of activity of a firm at a
particular time or over a period of time. Key factor governs the decision “how much to produce” In case,
sales being the key factor, the profit ability of the product is measured by computing its profit volume
ratio. When any other factor is the key-factor, the most profitable product will be that which would
yield maximum contribution per unit of key factor.
Question: 3
Write a short note on “Budget Manual”.
(Nov 2000)
164 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Solution:
CIMA London defines budget manual as “a document schedule or booklet which sets out. inter alia,
responsibilities of the persons engaged in, the routine of, and the forms and records required for
budgetary control,”
Therefore budget manual should consist of responsibilities and duties of each executive, methods of
preparation of various budget etc.
The budget manual should include following:
1. Introduction, benefits principles and objectives of budgetary control system.
2. Organisation chart explaining the responsibilities of each executive.
3. Budgeting programme including the time table for periodical reporting.
4. Purpose, specimen form and number of copies to be used for each report.
5. The method of accounting, the account code and classification used by the company.
6. The budget period showing the date of completion of each part of budget and submission of reports.
7. The follow up procedure.
Question: 4
Write short note on ‘Zero Base Budgeting as an approach towards productivity improvement.’
(Nov 2005)
Solution:
Zero Base Budgeting approach plays key role in productivity improvement. It is beneficial in this regard
in the following manner:
1. ZBB ensures that the various functions adopted by the organisation are important and critical for the
achievement of its objectives and are being performed in the best possible way.
2. ZBB gives an opportunity to the management to allocate resources for different activities only after
proper cost benefit analysis.
3. In this approach, 'chances of arbitrary cuts and enhancement are. thus avoided.
4. Department budgets are closely linked with corporate objectives.
5. It provides a systematic approach for the evaluation of different activities and rank them in order of
preference for the allocation of scarce resources.
6. Wasteful expenditures can be easily identified and eliminated.
Question: 5
State four limitations of the budgetary control system.
(Nov 1998)
165 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Solution:
Limitations of Budgetary Control are :
1. Budgetary control is not suitable in rapidly changing conditions because it requires frequent revision.
Which is very costly and time taking process for organisation.
2. Sometimes budget can serve as constraints on managerial effectiveness because every executive
tries only to achieve budgeted target.
3. The budgetary control system is expensive for small organisations.
4. For application of budgetary control system, proper organisational structure should be followed
which is not possible in all the firms.
Question: 6
Discuss the components of budgetary control system.
(May 2009)
Solution:
Components of Budgetary Control System:
There are a number of bases for classifying the budgets into two or more categories. But the most
important and widely used bases are functional classification and classification according to flexibility.
The policy of a business for a defined period is represented by the master budget the details of which
are given in a number of individual budgets called functional budgets.
The functional budgets are broadly grouped under the following heads:
1. Physical Budgets: This budget contains information in terms of physical units e.g. Sales Qty, Product
Qty, Inventory, Manpower budget.
2. Cost Budgets: Manufacturing Cost, Administration Cost, Sales and Distribution cost, Ft & D Cost.
3. Profit Budget: A budget which enable in the ascertainment of profit, e.g. Sales Budget, Profit & Loss
Budget etc.
On the other hand, budgets may be classified into two categories on the basis of flexibility as fixed
budgets and flexibility budgets.
Question: 7
Essentials of budget
(Nov 2011)
Solution:
Essential of Budget:
166 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
1. Budget establishes the objective of the organisation and enables the management to conduct business
in the most efficient manner.
2. Budget is helpful in allocating scarce resources in most optimal way.
3. Budget identifies the areas of in-efficiencies within the organisation.
4. Budget is the most important tool of controlling because it provides a yardstick against which the
performance of organisation can be evaluated.
5. Budget is a basis for management by exception by comparing actual and budgeted results.
6. Budget ensures effective utilisation of men, machine, material and money.
Question: 8
Describe the steps involved in the budgetary control technique.
(Nov 2013)
Solution:
Steps involved in the Budgetary Control Technique
1. Definition of objectives: A budget being a plan for the achievement of certain operational objectives,
it is desirable that the same are defined precisely. The objectives should be written out; the areas of
control demarcated; and items of revenue and expenditure to be covered by the budget stated.
2. Location of the Key (or budget) Factor : There is usually one factor (sometimes there may be more
than one) which sets a limit to the total activity. Such a factor is known as key factor. For proper
budgeting, it must be located and estimated properly.
3. Appointment of Controller : Formulation of a budget usually requires whole time services of a senior
executive known as budget controller; he must be assisted in this work by a Budget Committee,
consisting of all the heads of department along with the Managing Director as the Chairman.
4. Budget Manual: Effective budgetary planning relies on the provision of adequate information which
are contained in the budget manual. A budget manual is a collection of documents that contains key
information for those involved in the planning process.
5. Budget Period: The period covered by a budget is known as budget period. The Budget Committee
determines the length of the budget period suitable for the business. It may be months or quarters or
such periods as coincide with period of trading activity.
6. Standard of Activity or Output: For preparing budgets for the future, past statistics cannot be
completely relied upon, for the past usually represents a combination of good and bad factors.
Therefore, though results of the past should be studied but these should only be applied when there is a
likelihood of similar conditions repeating in the future.
Question: 9
167 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Solution:
Flexible Budget
Flexible Budgets show the expected results of a responsibility center unless for several activity levels.
It is a budget which by recognising the difference between fixed, semi-variable and variable costs is
designed to change in relation to level of activity attained. It is hot rigid as it can be recasted on the
basis of activity level to be achieved. It consists of services of static budgets for different levels of
activity. Variance analysis through flexible budget provides useful information as each cost is analysed
according to its behavior.
It facilitates the ascertainment of cost, fixation of selling price and submission of quotations. Flexible
budgets provide a meaningful basis of comparison of the actual performance with the budgeted targets.
Such budgets are especially useful in estimating and controlling factory costs and operating expenses.
Flexible Budgeting may be resorted to in the following situations:
1.New Business:
In case of new business venture, due to its typical nature, it may be difficult to forecast the demand of
a product accurately.
2. Uncertain Environment:
Where the business is dependent upon the vagary of nature.
3. Factor Market Conditions:
In the case of Labour intensive industry where the production of the concern is dependent upon the
availability of labour.
Question: 10
What is Sales Budget? How is it prepared?
(Nov 1998)
Solution:
Sales budget: It is the foundation upon which the other functional budget are built. Sales forecast is
the commencement of budgeting and as such, the sales budget is of primary importance.
In fact when sales forecast is presented in monetary value, it takes the form of a sales budget. It
provides a basis for the production department to produce the required quantity of products.
The sales budget may be prepared according to products, sales territories, types of customers, salesmen
etc. While preparing the sales budget, the following factors are to be taken into consideration:
1. Past sales volume
2. General economic and industry conditions
168 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Question: 11
List the eight functional budgets prepared by a business.
(Nov 2009)
Solution:
A functional budget is prepared according to the various functions of the organization e.g.: Sales,
Production, Administration Research & development etc.
Following are the most popular functional budgets:
1. Sales budget
2. Production budget
3. Materials budget
4. Labour budget
5. Manufacturing overhead budget
6. Administrative cost budget
7. Plant utilisation budget
8. Research and Development budget
9. Capital expenditure budget
10. Cash budget.
Question: 12
State the considerations on which capital expenditure budget is prepared.
(Nov 2012)
Solution:
The preparation of Capital Expenditure Budget is based on the following considerations:
1. Overhead on production facilities of certain departments as indicated by the plant utilisation budget.
2. Future development plans to increase output by expansion of plant facilities.
3. Replacement requests from the concerned departments.
169 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
4. Factors like sales potential to absorb the increased output, possibility of price reductions, increased
costs of advertising and sales promotion to absorb increased output, etc.
Question: 13
State the considerations on which capital expenditure budget is prepared.
(Nov 2012)
Solution:
The preparation of Capital Expenditure Budget is based on the following considerations:
1. Overhead on production facilities of certain departments as indicated by the plant utilisation budget.
2. Future development plans to increase output by expansion of plant facilities.
3. Replacement requests from the concerned departments.
4. Factors like sales potential to absorb the increased output, possibility of price reductions, increased
costs of advertising and sales promotion to absorb increased output, etc.
Question: 14
State, how is Zero base Budgeting superior to Traditional Budgeting.
(May 2018, Nov 2002)
Solution:
ZBB is superior than traditional budgeting because :
1. ZBB provides a systematic base for evaluation of different actlvitr ∴
2. ZBB gives an opportunity for management to allocate resources to various activities after a proper
cost benefit analysis.
3. ZBB assigns that the functions undertaken are critical for the achievement of the objectives.
4. ZBB provides a base for a system of management by objectives.
5. ZBB provides a base for a system of management by objectives.
6. ZBB provides a close relationship between departmental budget and corporate objectives I budget.
7. ZBB helps in identification of wastage and then their elimination.
Question: 15
What are the advantages and limitations of Zero base Budgeting?
(Nov 2004)
Solution:
Advantages of ZBB:
170 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
1. ZBB process identifies inefficient operation and considers every time alternative ways of performing
the same task.
2. ZBB is used in identification of wastage and obsolescent items of expenditure.
3. ZBB is very much useful for the staff and support areas of an organisation such as research &
development, quality control, pollution control, legal and technical staff etc.
4. The core resources will be allocated more efficiently according to the priority of programme.
5. ZBB provides an opportunity to the management to allocate resources for various activities only after
having a thorough cost-benefit analysis.
6. Departmental budgets are closely linked with corporate objectives.
7. ZBB ensures that the various functions undertaken by the organisation are critical for the
achievement of its objectives and are being performed in the best way.
8. The technique can also be used for the introduction of the system of management by objective
(MBO).
Limitation of ZBB:
1. ZBB requires skilled and trained managerial staff.
2. ZBB is time consuming as well as costly.
3. ZBB faces various operational problems during the implementation of such technique.
4. ZBB requires full support of top management.
Question: 16
Write short note on ‘Zero Base Budgeting as an approach towards productivity improvement.’
(Nov 2005)
Solution:
Zero Base Budgeting approach plays key role in productivity improvement. It is beneficial in this regard
in the following manner:
1. ZBB ensures that the various functions adopted by the organisation are important and critical for the
achievement of its objectives and are being performed in the best possible way.
2. ZBB gives an opportunity to the management to allocate resources for different activities only after
proper cost benefit analysis.
3. In this approach, 'chances of arbitrary cuts and enhancement are. thus avoided.
4. Department budgets are closely linked with corporate objectives.
5. It provides a systematic approach for the evaluation of different activities and rank them in order of
preference for the allocation of scarce resources.
6. Wasteful expenditures can be easily identified and eliminated.
Question: 17
171 CA SANJEEV MITTAL - Cost & FM (CA Final & CA Final)
If you genuinely liked the lectures, Use Code : CASANJEEV & Get 10% Off. Also tell your Friends too
Solution:
Meaning:
Performance Budgeting is a techinque of presenting budgets for costs and revenues, in terms of
functions. So, programmes and activities are correlated with the physical and financial aspect of
individual items comprising the budget.
It aims at a continuous growth of the Firm, and meet the dynamic needs of its growing clientele and
customers. It enables the Firm to be sensitive and adaptive, preventing it from developing rigidities
which may affect its growth and requires the preparation of periodic performance Reports, to compare
budget and actuals to find out existing variances.
Focus:
Focus of Performance Budgeting is on functions, and not the cost of functions as such, The functions,
programmes, activities and tasks, are reported, along with costs thereof.
Steps in Performance Budgeting
1. Establishing a meaningful functional Programme and Activity Classification of operations,
2. Bringing the system of Accounting and Financial Management, in accordance with the above
classification,
3. Establishing suitable norms, yardsticks, work units of performance and unit costs, wherever possible,
under each programme and activity, for their reporting and evaluation.
4. Monitoring and evaluate performance on the basis of performance Reports.
S r . No To p ic T it le Pa g e No.
1 R is k An a ly s is in Ca p it a l Bud g e t in g 1 - 2
2 Co s t o f Ca p it a l 3 - 8
3 I n ve s t m e n t D e c is io n 9 - 13
4 L e a s e F in a n c in g 14 - 17
5 D ivid e n d D e c is io n 18 - 2 2
6 Ty p e s o f F in a n c in g 23 - 27
7 Wo r kin g Ca p it a l Ma n a g e m e n t 28
8 Ca p it a l S t r uc t ur e D e c is io n s 29 - 30
9 L e ve r a g e s 31
10 R a t io An a ly s is 32 - 33
TOPI C - R I S K ANALYS I S I N CAP I TAL BU D G E T I NG
CO NCE P T - 1 P r o b a b ilit y D is t r ib ut io n Ap p r o a c h
E xp e c t e d NP V/ E xp e c t e d Ca s h Flo w / E xp e c t e d Va lue =
CO NCE P T - 2 Ca lc ula t io n o f R is k Ad j us t e d NP V
R is k Ad j us t e d NP V
Ce r t a in it y E quiva le n t Ap p r o a c h ( CE C Ap p r o a c h) R is k Ad j us t e d D is c o un t R a t e Me t ho d ( R AD R )
R is k o f p r o j e c t w o uld b e a d j us t e d in " Ca s h Flo w " R is k o f p r o j e c t w o uld b e a d j us t e d in " D is c o un t R a t e "
I t in vo lve s d is c o un t in g o f c e r t a in Ca s h Flo w s in s t e a d o f To t a l ( 1+ R AD R ) = ( 1+ R is k- f r e e r a t e ) ( 1 + R is k P r e m ium )
Ca s h Flo w s.
No t e :
S t e p s in vo lve d : > U n d e r t his m e t ho d , P r o j e c t s ho uld b e d is c o un t e d us in g r is k-
S t e p 1: Ca lc ula t e a ll c a s h f lo w s a r is in g f r o m t he p r o j e c t . a d j us t e d d is c o un t r a t e r a t he r t ha n r is k- f r e e d is c o un t r a t e .
CO NCE P T - 3 S c e n e r io An a ly s is
S c e n a r io An a ly s is is a n a n a ly s is o f t he NP V o f a p r o j e c t un d e r a s e r ie s o f s p e c if ic .
S c e n a r io s ( w o r s t , m o s t like ly a n d b e s t s c e n a r io ) b a s e d o n m a c r o - e c o n o m ic s , in d us t r y a n d f ir m - s p e c if ic f a c t o
1
U n d e r t his , a ll in p ut s a r e s e t a t t he ir m o s t o p t im is t ic o r p e s s im is t ic o r m o s t like ly le ve ls a n d NP V is c o m p ut e d .
D e c is io n is b a s e d o n t he NP V un d e r a ll s c e n a r io s
CO NCE P T - 4 S e n s it ivit y An a ly s is
> Als o kn o w n a s ?W ha t if ? An a ly s is. Ke y f a c t o r s w hic h a r e us e d t o c a lc ula t e NP V a r e a s
> S e n s it ivit y An a ly s is is o n e o f t he m e t ho d s o f a n a ly z in g t he r is k f o llo w s : I n ve r s e E f f e c t
s ur r o un d in g t he c a p it a l e xp e n d it ur e . D e c is io n a n d e n a ble s a n a s s e s s m e n t t o
Ca s h I n f lo w s Dec r ease
b e m a d e o f ho w r e s p o n s ive t he p r o j e c t ?s NP V is t o c ha n g e s in t ho s e
va r ia ble s b a s e d o n w hic h NP V is c o m p ut e d . Ca s h O ut f lo w s I nc r ease
> S e n s it ivit y An a ly s is is a t o o l in t he ha n d o f f ir m s t o a n a ly z e c ha n g e in D is c o un t R a t e I nc r ease
t he p r o j e c t ?s NP V f o r a g ive n c ha n g e in o n e o f t he va r ia ble s.
L if e o f t he P r o j e c t Dec r ease
> U n d e r t his a n a ly s is w e t r y t o m e a s ur e r is k o f e a c h f a c t o r t a kin g NP V=0 .
D e c is io n R ule :
Ma n a g e m e n t s ho uld p a y m a xim um a t t e n t io n t o w a r d s t he f a c t o r w he r e m in im um p e r c e n t a g e o f a d ve r s e c ha n g e s c a us e s m a xim um
a d ve r s e e f f e c t
E xa m p le : I f NP V is t o b e c o m e Z e r o w it h 5 % c ha n g e in in it ia l in ve s t m e n t r e la t ive t o 10 % c ha n g e in c a s h in f lo w s , p r o j e c t is s a id t o b e
m o r e s e n s it ive t o in it ia l in ve s t m e n t t he n t o c a s h in f lo w s.
No t e : S e n s it ivit y An a ly s is is c a lc ula t e d f o r e a c h f a c t o r s e p a r a t e ly , ke e p in g o t he r f a c t o r s c o n s t a n t .
4A - Me t ho d 1 : Ma r g in o f S a f e t y Ap p r o a c h ( M O S ) 4B - Me t ho d 2 : S ho c k Ap p r o a c h
S e t NP V = 0 & Ca lc ula t e t he Br e a k E ve n Va lue s a n d Ma r g in o f S ho c k e a c h R is k Fa c t o r in t he a d ve r s e d ir e c t io n like 10 % / 20 % &
S a f e t y f o r E a c h Fa c t o r F in d o ut t he R e vis e d NP V o r %a g e f a ll in NP V
2
TOPI C - CO S T O F CAP I TAL
Co s t o f D e b t Co s t o f P r e f e r e n c e S ha r e s Co s t o f E quit y Co s t o f R e t a in e d E a r n in g s
CO NCE P T - 1 Co s t o f Ca p it a l
Co s t o f c a p it a l r e f e r s t o t he d is c o un t r a t e t ha t is us e d in d e t e r m in in g t he p r e s e n t va lue o f t he e s t im a t e d f ut ur e c a s h p r o c e e d s o f
t he b us in e s s / n e w p r o j e c t a n d e ve n t ua lly d e c id in g w he t he r t he b us in e s s / n e w p r o j e c t is w o r t h un d e r t a kin g o r n o w .
I t is a ls o t he m in im um r a t e o f r e t ur n t ha t a f ir m m us t e a r n o n it s in ve s t m e n t w hic h w ill m a in t a in t he m a r ke t va lue o f s ha r e a t it s
c ur r e n t le ve l. I t c a n a ls o b e s t a t e d a s t he o p p o r t un it y c o s t o f a n in ve s t m e n t , i.e . t he r a t e o f r e t ur n t ha t a c o m p a n y w o uld o t he r w is e
b e a ble t o e a r n a t t he s a m e r is k le ve l a s t he in ve s t m e n t t ha t ha s b e e n s e le c t e d .
CO NCE P T - 2 Co m p o n e n t s o f Co s t o f Ca p it a l
T he c o s t o f c a p it a l c a n b e e it he r e xp lic it o r im p lic it . T he e xp lic it c o s t o f a n y s o ur c e o f c a p it a l m a y b e d e f in e d a s t he d is c o un t r a t e
t ha t e qua ls t ha t p r e s e n t va lue o f t he c a s h in f lo w s t ha t a r e in c r e m e n t a l t o t he t a kin g o f f in a n c in g o p p o r t un it y w it h t he p r e s e n t va lue
o f it s in c r e m e n t a l c a s h o ut f lo w s.
I m p lic it c o s t is t he r a t e o f r e t ur n a s s o c ia t e d w it h t he b e s t in ve s t m e n t o p p o r t un it y f o r t he f ir m a n d it s s ha r e ho ld e r s t ha t w ill b e
f o r e g o n e if t he p r o j e c t p r e s e n t ly un d e r c o n s id e r a t io n by t he f ir m w a s a c c e p t e d .
CO NCE P T - 3 Me a s ur e m e n t o f S p e c if ic Co s t o f Ca p it a l f o r e a c h s o ur c e o f Ca p it a l
T he f ir s t s t e p in m e a s ur e m e n t o f t he c o s t o f t he c a p it a l o f t he f ir m is t he c a lc ula t io n o f t he c o s t o f in d ivid ua l s o ur c e s o f r a is in g
f un d s. Fr o m t he vie w p o in t o f c a p it a l b ud g e t in g d e c is io n s , t he lo n g t e r m s o ur c e s o f f un d s a r e r e le va n t a s t he y c o n s t it ut e t he m a j o r
s o ur c e s o f f in a n c in g t he f ixe d a s s e t s. I n c a lc ula t in g t he c o s t o f c a p it a l, t he r e f o r e t he f o c us o n lo n g - t e r m f un d s a n d w hic h a r e :
1. L o n g t e r m d e b t ( in c lud in g D e b e n t ur e s )
2 . P r e f e r e n c e S ha r e s
3 . E quit y Ca p it a l
4 . R e t a in e d E a r n in g s
CO NCE P T - 4 We ig ht e d Ave r a g e Co s t o f Ca p it a l
WACC ( w e ig ht e d a ve r a g e c o s t o f c a p it a l) r e p r e s e n t s t he in ve s t o r s ? o p p o r t un it y c o s t o f t a kin g o n t he r is k o f p ut t in g m o n e y in t o a
c o m p a n y . S in c e e ve r y c o m p a n y ha s a c a p it a l s t r uc t ur e i.e . w ha t p e r c e n t a g e o f f un d s c o m e s f r o m r e t a in e d e a r n in g s , e quit y s ha r e s ,
p r e f e r e n c e s ha r e s , d e b t a n d b o n d s , s o by t a kin g a w e ig ht e d a ve r a g e , it c a n b e s e e n ho w m uc h c o s t / in t e r e s t t he c o m p a n y ha s t o p a y
f o r e ve r y r up e e it b o r r o w s / in ve s t . T his is t he w e ig ht e d a ve r a g e c o s t o f c a p it a l.
Co s t o f c a p it a l is t he r e t ur n e xp e c t e d by t he p r o vid e r s o f c a p it a l ( i.e . s ha r e ho ld e r s , le n d e r s a n d t he d e b t - ho ld e r s ) t o t he b us in e s s
a s a c o m p e n s a t io n f o r t he ir c o n t r ib ut io n t o t he t o t a l c a p it a l.
3
CO NCE P T - 5 Co s t o f L o n g Te r m D e b t
E xt e r n a l b o r r o w in g s o r d e b t in s t r um e n t s d o n o t c o n f e r s o w n e r s hip t o t he p r o vid e r s o f f in a n c e . T he p r o vid e r s o f t he d e b t f un d d o
n o t p a r t ic ip a t e in t he a f f a ir s o f t he c o m p a n y b ut e n j oy s t he c ha r g e o n t he p r o f it b e f o r e t a xe s.
L o n g t e r m d e b t in c lud e s lo n g t e r m lo a n s f r o m t he f in a n c ia l in s t it ut io n s , c a p it a l f r o m is s uin g d e b e n t ur e s o r b o n d s e t c .
Fe a t ur e s o f d e b e n t ur e s o r b o n d s
D e b e n t ur e s o r Bo n d s a r e d e n o m in a t e d w it h s o m e va lue ; t his d e n o m in a t e d va lue is c a lle d f a c e va lue o f
t he d e b e n t ur e . I n t e r e s t is c a lc ula t e d o n t he f a c e va lue o f t he d e b e n t ur e s.
A. Fa c e Va lue
E .g . I f a c o m p a n y is s ue 9 % No n - c o n ve r t ible d e b e n t ur e s o f R s. 10 0 e a c h, t his m e a n s t he f a c e va lue is R s.
10 0 a n d t he in t e r e s t @ 9 % w ill b e c a lc ula t e d o n t his f a c e va lue .
E a c h d e b e n t ur e b e a r s f ixe d in t e r e s t ( c o up o n ) r a t e ( e xc e p t Z e r o c o up o n b o n d a n d D e e p d is c o un t b o n d ) .
B. I n t e r e s t ( Co up o n )
I n t e r e s t ( c o up o n ) r a t e is a p p lie d t o f a c e va lue o f d e b e n t ur e t o c a lc ula t e in t e r e s t , w hic h is p a y a ble t o
Rat e
t he ho ld e r s o f d e b e n t ur e s p e r io d ic a lly .
D e b e n t ur e s o r Bo n d s ha s a f ixe d m a t ur it y p e r io d f o r r e d e m p t io n . Ho w e ve r , in c a s e o f ir r e d e e m a ble
C. Ma t ur it y p e r io d
d e b e n t ur e s m a t ur it y p e r io d is n o t d e f in e d a n d it is t a ke n a s in f in it e .
D . R e d e m p t io n Va lue R e d e e m a ble d e b e n t ur e s o r b o n d s a r e r e d e e m e d o n it s s p e c if ie d m a t ur it y d a t e . Ba s e d o n t he d e b t
c o ve n a n t s t he r e d e m p t io n va lue is d e t e r m in e d
T he p a y m e n t o f in t e r e s t t o t he d e b e n t ur e ho ld e r s a r e a llo w e d a s e xp e n s e s f o r t he p ur p o s e o f
E . Be n e f it o f t a x s hie ld c o r p o r a t e t a x d e t e r m in a t io n . He n c e , in t e r e s t p a id t o t he d e b e n t ur e ho ld e r s s a ve t he t a x lia b ilit y o f t he
c omp a ny.
W he r e ,
E 1. Co s t o f I r r e d e e m a ble
Kd = Co s t o f d e b t a f t e r t a x, I = An n ua l in t e r e s t p a y m e n t ,
D e b e n t ur e s
NP = Ne t p r o c e e d s o f d e b e n t ur e s o r c ur r e n t m a r ke t p r ic e , t = t a x r a t e
W he r e ,
E 2 . Co s t o f R e d e e m a ble
NP = Ne t p r o c e e d s f r o m d e b e n t ur e s in c a s e o f n e w is s ue o f d e b o r
D e b e n t ur e s
Cur r e n t m a r ke t p r ic e in c a s e o f e xis t in g d e b t .
R V = R e d e m p t io n va lue o f d e b e n t ur e s , t = Ta x r a t e a p p lic a ble t o t he
c o m p a n y , n = lif e o f d e b e n t ur e s
I f d is c o un t o n is s ue a n d / o r p r e m ium o n r e d e m p t io n a r e t a x
d e d uc t ible , t he f o llo w in g f o r m ula c a n b e us e d t o c a lc ula t e t he c o s t o f
d ebt .
4
E 3 . Co s t o f D e b t us in g P r e s e n t va lue m e t ho d [ Yie ld t o m a t ur it y ( YT M ) a p p r o a c h) ] / I R R Te c hn ique
T he c o s t o f r e d e e m a ble d e b t Kd is a ls o c a lc ula t e d by d is c o un t in g t he r e le va n t c a s h f lo w s us in g I n t e r n a l r a t e o f r e t ur n ( I R R ) . He r e
YT M is t he a n n ua l r e t ur n o f a n in ve s t m e n t f r o m t he c ur r e n t d a t e t ill m a t ur it y d a t e . S o , YT M is t he in t e r n a l r a t e o f r e t ur n a t w hic h
c ur r e n t p r ic e o f a d e b t e qua ls t o t he p r e s e n t va lue o f a ll c a s hf lo w s.
T he r e le va n t c a s h f lo w s a r e a s f o llo w s :
Ye a r Ca s h Flo w s S t e p s t o c a lc ula t e r e le va n t c a s h f lo w s:
Ne t p r o c e e d s in c a s e o f n e w is s ue / Cur r e n t m a r ke t p r ic e in c a s e o f e xis t in g S t e p - 1: I d e n t if y t he c a s h f lo w s
0 S t e p - 2 : Ca lc ula t e NP Vs o f c a s h f lo w s a s
d e b t ( NP o r P 0 )
id e n t if ie d a b o ve us in g t w o d is c o un t r a t e s
1 to n I n t e r e s t n e t o f t a x [ I ( 1- t ) ] ( g ue s s in g ) .
n R e d e m p t io n va lue ( R V) S t e p - 3 : Ca lc ula t e I R R
No t e :
Am o r t is a t io n o f Bo n d
A b o n d m a y b e a m o r t is e d e ve r y y e a r i.e . p r in c ip a l is r e p a id e ve r y y e a r r a t he r t ha n a t m a t ur it y .
I n s uc h a s it ua t io n , t he p r in c ip a l w ill g o d o w n w it h a n n ua l p a y m e n t s a n d in t e r e s t w ill b e c o m p ut e d o n t he o ut s t a n d in g a m o un t . T he
c a s h f lo w s o f t he b o n d s w ill b e un e ve n .
T he f o r m ula f o r d e t e r m in in g t he va lue o f a b o n d o r d e b e n t ur e t ha t is a m o r t is e d e ve r y y e a r is a s f o llo w s:
No t e :
Co s t o f Co n ve r t ible D e b e n t ur e
Ho ld e r s o f t he c o n ve r t ible d e b e n t ur e s ha s t he o p t io n t o e it he r g e t t he d e b e n t ur e s r e d e e m e d in t o t he c a s h o r g e t s p e c if ie d n um b e r s
o f c o m p a n ie s s ha r e s in le iu o f c a s h. T he c a lc ula t io n o f c o s t o f c o n ve r t ible d e b e n t ur e s a r e ve r y m uc h s im ila r t o t he r e d e e m a ble
d e b e n t ur e s. W hile d e t e r m in in g t he r e d e e m a ble va lue o f t he d e b e n t ur e s , it is a s s um e d t ha t a ll t he d e b e n t ur e ho ld e r s w ill c ho o s e t he
o p t io n w hic h ha s t he hig he r va lue a n d a c c o r d in g ly it is c o n s id e r e d t o c a lc ula t e c o s t o f d e b t .
> Co n ve r t e d in t o e quit y s ha r e s a f t e r c e r t a in p e r io d .
> Co n ve r s io n R a t io = No. o f s ha r e R e c e ive d p e r Co n ve r t ible Bo n d
> W he n Co n ve r s io n Va lue > Bo n d va lue , o p t io n c a n b e e xe r c is e d o t he r w is e n o t .
CO NCE P T - 6 Co s t o f P r e f e r e n c e S ha r e s
T he p r e f e r e n c e s ha r e c a p it a l is p a id d ivid e n d a t a s p e c if ie d r a t e o n f a c e va lue o f p r e f e r e n c e s ha r e s. Pa y m e n t o f d ivid e n d t o t he
p r e f e r e n c e s ha r e ho ld e r s a r e n o t m a n d a t o r y b ut a r e g ive n p r io r it y o ve r t he e quit y s ha r e ho ld e r . T he p a y m e n t o f d ivid e n d t o t he
p r e f e r e n c e s ha r e ho ld e r s a r e n o t c ha r g e d a s e xp e n s e s b ut t r e a t e d a s a p p r o p r ia t io n o f a f t e r t a x p r o f it . He n c e , d ivid e n d p a id t o
p r e f e r e n c e s ha r e ho ld e r s d o e s n o t r e d uc e t he t a x lia b ilit y t o t he c o m p a n y . L ike t he d e b e n t ur e s , P r e f e r e n c e s ha r e c a p it a l c a n b e
c a t e g o r is e d a s r e d e e m a ble a n d ir r e d e e m a ble . Ac c o r d in g ly c o s t o f c a p it a l f o r e a c h t y p e w ill b e d is c us s e d he r e .
5
6a - Co s t o f I r r e d e e m a ble P r e f e r e n c e S ha r e s
P r e f e r e n c e s ha r e s is s ue d by a c o m p a n y w hic h a r e r e d e e m e d o n it s m a t ur it y is c a lle d r e d e e m a ble p r e f e r e n c e s ha r e s. Co s t o f
r e d e e m a ble p r e f e r e n c e s ha r e is s im ila r t o t he c o s t o f r e d e e m a ble d e b e n t ur e s w it h t he e xc e p t io n t ha t t he d ivid e n d s p a id t o t he
p r e f e r e n c e s ha r e ho ld e r s a r e n o t t a x d e d uc t ible .
Co s t o f R e d e e m a ble P r e f e r e n c e S ha r e
W he r e ,
P D = An n ua l p r e f e r e n c e d ivid e n d
R V = R e d e m p t io n va lue o f p r e f e r e n c e s ha r e s
NP = Ne t p r o c e e d s o n is s ue o f p r e f e r e n c e s ha r e s
n = L if e o f p r e f e r e n c e s ha r e s.
6b - Co s t o f R e d e e m a ble P r e f e r e n c e S ha r e s
W he r e ,
Co s t o f R e d e e m a ble P r e f e r e n c e S ha r e
P D = An n ua l p r e f e r e n c e d ivid e n d ,P 0 = Ne t p r o c e e d s in is s ue o f p r e f e r e n c e s ha r e s
CO NCE P T - 7 Co s t o f E quit y S ha r e Ca p it a l
a ) D ivid e n d P r ic e Ap p r o a c h b ) E a r n in g P r ic e Ap p r o a c h
c ) R e a liz e d Yie ld Ap p r o a c h d ) Ca p it a l As s e t P r ic in g Mo d e l ( CAP M ) Ap p r o a c h
7 a - D ivid e n d P r ic e Ap p r o a c h
a ) D ivid e n d P r ic e Ap p r o a c h/ D ivid e n d Va lua t io n Ap p r o a c h
( i) D ivid e n d P r ic e Ap p r o a c h w it h Co n s t a n t D ivid e n d : I n t his a p p r o a c h d ivid e n d is c o n s t a n t , w hic h m e a n s t he r e is n o - g r o w t h o r z e r o
g r o w t h in d ivid e n d . T he c o s t o f e quit y c a n b e c a lc ula t e d a s f o llo w s:
W he r e , Ke = Co s t o f e quit y , D = E xp e c t e d D ivid e n d , P 0 = Ma r ke t p r ic e o f e quit y ( e x- d ivid e n d )
T his m o d e l a s s um e s t ha t d ivid e n d s a r e p a id a t a c o n s t a n t r a t e t o p e r p e t uit y .
w he r e , F = Flo t a t io n c o s t p e r s ha r e .
6
7 b - E a r n in g / P r ic e Ap p r o a c h
( i) E a r n in g s / P r ic e Ap p r o a c h w it h Co n s t a n t E a r n in g s
T he c o s t o f e quit y s ha r e c a p it a l w o uld b e b a s e d up o n t he e xp e c t e d r a t e o f e a r n in g s o f a c o m p a n y
W he r e ,
E PS = Cur r e n t e a r n in g s p e r s ha r e , Po = Ma r ke t s ha r e p r ic e
( ii) E a r n in g s / P r ic e Ap p r o a c h w it h G r o w t h in E a r n in g s:
W he r e , E PS 1 = E xp e c t e d e a r n in g s p e r s ha r e , Po = Ma r ke t p r ic e p e r s ha r e , g = An n ua l g r o w t h r a t e o f e a r n in g s.
E s t im a t io n o f G r o w t h R a t e
T he c a lc ula t io n o f ?g ? ( t he g r o w t h r a t e ) is a n im p o r t a n t f a c t o r in c a lc ula t in g c o s t o f e quit y s ha r e c a p it a l. G e n e r a lly t w o m e t ho d s a r e
us e d t o d e t e r m in e t he g r o w t h r a t e , w hic h a r e d is c us s e d b e lo w :
Me t ho d 1 : Ave r a g e Me t ho d Me t ho d 2 : G o r d o n ?s G r o w t h Mo d e l
I t c a lc ula t e d a s T his m o d e l t a ke s E a r n in g s r e t e n t io n r a t e ( b ) & r a t e o f r e t ur n o n
in ve s t m e n t s ( r ) in t o a c c o un t t o e s t im a t e t he f ut ur e g r o w t h r a t e .
W he r e , I t c a n b e c a lc ula t e d a s :
D 0 = Cur r e n t d ivid e n d , D n = D ivid e n d in n y e a r s a g o W he r e ,
E xa m p le : T he c ur r e n t d ivid e n d ( D .) is R s. 16 .10 a n d t he d ivid e n d 5 r = r a t e o f r e t ur n o n f un d in ve s t e d
y e a r a g o w a s R s. 10 . b = e a r n in g s r e t e n t io n r a t io
7 c - R e a liz e d Yie ld Ap p r o a c h
Ac c o r d in g t o t his a p p r o a c h, t he a ve r a g e r a t e o f r e t ur n r e a liz e d in t he p a s t f e w y e a r s is his t o r ic a lly r e g a r d e d a s ?e xp e c t e d r e t ur n ? in
t he f ut ur e . I t c o m p ut e s c o s t o f e quit y b a s e d o n t he p a s t r e c o r d s o f d ivid e n d s a c t ua lly r e a lis e d by t he e quit y s ha r e ho ld e r s.
7 d - Ca p it a l As s e t P r ic in g Mo d e l ( CAP M ) Ap p r o a c h
CAP M m o d e l d e s c r ib e s t he r is k- r e t ur n t r a d e - o f f f o r s e c ur it ie s. I t d e s c r ib e s t he lin e a r r e la t io n s hip b e t w e e n r is k a n d r e t ur n f o r
s e c ur it ie s. T hus , t he c o s t o f e quit y c a p it a l c a n b e c a lc ula t e d un d e r t his a p p r o a c h a s:
W he r e , Ke = Co s t o f e quit y c a p it a l, R f = R is k f r e e r a t e o f r e t ur n , ß = Be t a c o e f f ic ie n t ,
R m = R a t e o f r e t ur n o n m a r ke t p o r t f o lio , ( R m ? R f ) = Ma r ke t p r e m ium
CO NCE P T - 8 Co s t o f R e t a in e d E a r n in g s
L ike a n o t he r s o ur c e o f f un d , r e t a in e d e a r n in g s in vo lve c o s t . I t is t he o p p o r t un it y c o s t o f d ivid e n d s f o r e g o n e by s ha r e ho ld e r s.
s o m e t im e c o s t o f r e t a in e d e a r n in g s r e m a in s b e lo w t he c o s t o f e quit y d ue t o s a vin g in f lo a t a t io n c o s t a n d e xis t e n c e o f p e r s o n a l t a x.
I n a b s e n c e o f a n y in f o r m a t io n o n p e r s o n a l t a x ( t p ) :
Co s t o f R e t a in e d E a r n in g s ( K r ) = Co s t o f E quit y S ha r e s ( Ke )
I f t he r e is a n y in f o r m a t io n o n p e r s o n a l t a x ( t p ) : K r = Ke - t p
7
No t e : 1) Ke o f n e w e quit y w ill a lw a y s b e g r e a t e r t ha n Ke o f e xis t in g e quit y / r e t a in e d e a r n in g s.
2 ) Flo a t a t io n Co s t is o n ly a p p lic a ble in c a s e o f n e w e quit y a n d n o t o n e xis t in g e quit y ( o r r e t a in e d e a r n in g s ) .
CO NCE P T - 9 W E I G HT E D AVE R AG E CO S T O F CAP I TAL ( WACC)
We ig ht e d a ve r a g e c o s t o f c a p it a l is t he w e ig ht e d a ve r a g e a f t e r t a x c o s t s o f t he in d ivid ua l c o m p o n e n t s o f f ir m ?s c a p it a l s t r uc t ur e .
T ha t is , t he a f t e r t a x c o s t o f e a c h d e b t a n d e quit y is c a lc ula t e d s e p a r a t e ly a n d a d d e d t o g e t he r t o a s in g le o ve r a ll c o s t o f c a p it a l
T he s t e p s t o c a lc ula t e WACC is a s f o llo w s :
S t e p 1: Ca lc ula t e t he t o t a l c a p it a l f r o m a ll t he s o ur c e s.
( i.e . L o n g t e r m d e b t c a p it a l + P r e f . S ha r e Ca p it a l + E quit y S ha r e Ca p it a l + R e t a in e d E a r n in g s )
St ep 2 : Ca lc ula t e t he p r o p o r t io n ( o r %) o f e a c h s o ur c e o f c a p it a l t o t he t o t a l c a p it a l.
E xa m p le - Ca lc ula t io n o f W CC
Ca p it a l Co m p o n e n t Co s t o f c a p it a l % o f t o t a l c a p it a l s t r uc t ur e To t a l T he c o s t o f w e ig ht e d a ve r a g e m e t ho d is
p r e f e r r e d b e c a us e t he p r o p o r t io n s o f
R e t a in e d E a r n in g s 10 % ( K r ) 2 5 % (Wr ) 2 .5 0 % ( K r × W r )
va r io us s o ur c e s o f f un d s in t he c a p it a l
E quit y S ha r e Ca p it a l 11% ( Ke ) 10 % ( We ) 1.10 % ( Ke × We ) s t r uc t ur e a r e d if f e r e n t . To b e
P r e f e r e n c e S ha r e Ca p it a l 9 % ( Kp ) 15 % ( Wp ) 1.3 5 % ( Kp × Wp ) r e p r e s e n t a t ive , t he r e f o r e , c o s t o f
c a p it a l s ho uld t a ke in t o a c c o un t t he
Long t er m d ebt s 6 % ( Kd ) 5 0 % ( Wd ) 3 .0 0 % ( Kd × Wd )
r e la t ive p r o p o r t io n s o f d if f e r e n t
To t a l ( WACC) 7 .9 5 % s o ur c e s o f f in a n c e .
CO NCE P T - 10 Cho ic e o f w e ig ht s
T he r e is a c ho ic e w e ig ht s b e t w e e n t he b o o k va lue ( BV) a n d m a r ke t va lue ( M V) .
i) Bo o k Va lue ( BV) : Bo o k va lue w e ig ht s is o p e r a t io n a lly e a s y a n d c o n ve n ie n t . W hile us in g BV, r e s e r ve s s uc h a s s ha r e p r e m ium a n d
r e t a in e d p r o f it s a r e in c lud e d in t he BV o f e quit y , in a d d it io n t o t he n o m in a l va lue o f s ha r e c a p it a l.
CO NCE P T - 11 Ma r g in a l c o s t o f c a p it a l
T he m a r g in a l c o s t o f c a p it a l m a y b e d e f in e d a s t he c o s t o f r a is in g a n a d d it io n a l r up e e o f c a p it a l. S in c e t he c a p it a l is r a is e d in
s ub s t a n t ia l a m o un t in p r a c t ic e , m a r g in a l c o s t is r e f e r r e d t o a s t he c o s t in c ur r e d in r a is in g n e w f un d s. Ma r g in a l c o s t o f c a p it a l is
d e r ive d , w he n t he a ve r a g e c o s t o f c a p it a l is c a lc ula t e d us in g t he m a r g in a l w e ig ht s.
8
TOPI C - I NVE S T M E NT D E CI S I O N
CO NCE P T - 1 I n t r o d uc t io n
> > Ca p it a l Bud g e t in g is t he p r o c e s s o f I d e n t if y in g & E va lua t in g c a p it a l p r o j e c t s i.e . p r o j e c t s w he r e t he c a s h f lo w s t o t he f ir m w ill
b e r e c e ive d o ve r a p e r io d lo n g e r t ha n a y e a r .
> > An y c o r p o r a t e d e c is io n s w it h a n I M PACT O N FU T U R E E AR NI NG S c a n b e e xa m in e d us in g c a p it a l b ud g e t in g f r a m e w o r k.
Ca t e g o r ie s o f Ca p it a l Bud g e t in g P r o j e c t s:
a ) R e p la c e m e n t p r o j e c t s t o m a in t a in t he b us in e s s
b ) R e p la c e m e n t p r o j e c t s f o r c o s t r e d uc t io n
c ) E xp a n s io n p r o j e c t s
d ) Ne w p r o d uc t o r m a r ke t d e ve lo p m e n t / D ive r s if ic a t io n d e c is io n s
e ) Ma n d a t o r y p r o j e c t s
CO NCE P T - 2 Ty p e s o f Ca p it a l Bud g e t in g P r o p o s a ls
M ut ua lly E xc lus ive P r o p o s a ls w he n a c c e p t a n c e o f o n e p r o p o s a l im p lie s t he a ut o m a t ic r e j e c t io n o f t he o t he r p r o p o s a l
Co m p le m e n t a r y w he n t he a c c e p t a n c e o f o n e p r o p o s a l im p lie s t he a c c e p t a n c e o f o t he r p r o p o s a l c o m p le m e n t a r y
P r o p o s a ls / Co n t in g e n t d e c is io n s t o it , r e j e c t io n o f o n e im p lie s r e j e c t io n o f a ll c o m p le m e n t a r y p r o p o s a ls.
I n d e p e n d e n t P r o p o s a ls / w he n t he a c c e p t a n c e / r e j e c t io n o f o n e p r o p o s a l d o e s n ?t a f f e c t t he a c c e p t a n c e / r e j e c t io n o f
Ac c e p t - R e j e c t d e c is io n s o t he r p r o p o s a l.
Tr a d it io n a l o r No n - D is c o un t in g T im e Ad j us t e d o r D is c o un t e d Ca s h Flo w s
Pa y b a c k Pe r io d Ne t P r e s e n t Va lue
Ac c o un t in g R a t e o f R e t ur n ( AR R ) P r o f it a b ilit y I n d e x ( P I )
I n t e r n a l R a t e o f R e t ur n ( I R R )
Mo d if ie d I n t e r n a l R a t e o f R e t ur n ( M I R R )
D is c o un t e d Pa y b a c k Pe r io d
9
CO NCE P T - 4 Ne t P r e s e n t Va lue ( NP V)
NP V = P V o f Ca s h I n f lo w s ? P V o f Ca s h O ut f lo w s
D e c is io n : I f NP V is
+ve Ac c e p t t he p r o j e c t - in c r e a s e s ha r e ho ld e r ?s w e a lt h W he r e , CF 0 = t he in it ia l in ve s t m e n t o ut la y ;
- ve R e j e c t t he p r o j e c t - d e c r e a s e s ha r e ho ld e r ?s w e a lt h CFt = a f t e r - t a x c a s h f lo w a t t im e t ;
Zer o I n d if f e r e n t - No e f f e c t o n s ha r e ho ld e r ?s w e a lt h K = r e quir e d r a t e o f r e t ur n f o r p r o j e c t
To t a l Fun d Ap p r o a c h / O ve r a ll P r o j e c t Ap p r o a c h
D is c o un t R a t e K 0
I n it ia l Ca s h To t a l Co s t o f Ne w As s e t
O ut f lo w s Ad d : I n s t a lla t io n / S e t - up Co s t
Ad d : I n ve s t m e n t in Wo r kin g Ca p it a l
Op e r a t in g Fut ur e Ca s h f lo w s a f t e r t a x
Te r m in a l Ca s h S V a d j us t e d f o r Ta x
f lo w s R e le a s e o f Wo r kin g Ca p it a l
NP V NP V o f a p r o j e c t
10
No t e 4 : Tr e a t m e n t o f Ta x
I f w e ha ve lo s s in a p a r t ic ula r y e a r , t he r e a r e t w o a d j us t m e n t s
1. S e t - o f f : a s s um e d t he f ir m a s o t he r p r o f it a ble b us in e s s , L o s s in a y e a r g e n e r a t e t a x s a vin g s in t ha t y e a r .
2 . Ca r r y Fo r w a r d : T he c o m p a n y ha s a n in d ivid ua l b us in e s s o r a n e w b us in e s s ha vin g n o o t he r o p e r a t io n s , lo s s in a y e a r w ill b e c a r r ie d
f o r w a r d t o f ut ur e y e a r s f o r t he p ur p o s e o f S e t - o f f . 1
No t e 5 : Ke y Po in t s t o R e m e m b e r
1. D e c is io n s a r e b a s e d o n c a s h f lo w s , n o t a c c o un t in g in c o m e :
Co n s id e r I NCR E M E NTAL CAS H F L O WS , t he c ha n g e in c a s h f lo w s t ha t w ill o c c ur if t he p r o j e c t is un d e r t a ke n .
3 . E xt e r n it ie s / Ca n n ib a liz a t io n
W he n c o n s id e r in g t he f ull im p lic a t io n o f a n e w p r o j e c t , lo s s in s a le s o f e xis t in g p r o d uc t s s ho uld b e t a ke n in t o a c c o un t & a ls o c o n s id e r
p o s it ive e f f e c t s o n s a le o f a f ir m 's o t he r p r o d uc t lin e .
4 . Ca s h f lo w s a r e b a s e d o n Op p o r t un it y Co s t s.
Op p o r t un it y c o s t s s ho uld b e in c lud e d in p r o j e c t s c o s t s.
5 . T he t im in g o f c a s h f lo w s is im p o r t a n t .
Ca s h f lo w s r e c e ive d e a r lie r a r e w o r t h m o r e t ha n c a s h f lo w s t o b e r e c e ive d la t e r .
6 . Ca s h f lo w s a r e a n a ly z e d o n a n a f t e r - t a x b a s is.
CO NCE P T - 7 S im p le Pa y - Ba c k Pe r io d Me t ho d ( P BP )
T he p a y - b a c k p e r io d ( P BP ) is t he n um b e r o f y e a r s it t a ke s t o r e c o ve r t he in it ia l c o s t o f a n in ve s t m e n t . I t is t he p e r io d a t w hic h
t o t a l c a s h in f lo w s f r o m t he p r o j e c t e qua ls t o t he c o s t o f in ve s t m e n t in t he p r o j e c t .
Ca s e I : W he n c a s h in f lo w s a r e c o n s t a n t / e qua l
11
Ca s e I I : W he n Ca s h in f lo w s a r e un e qua l Pa y b a c k p e r io d =
S t e p s I n vo lve d :
a ) D e t e r m in e t he in it ia l in ve s t m e n t o f t he p r o j e c t .
b ) D e t e r m in e t he CFAT f r o m p r o j e c t f o r va r io us y e a r s.
c ) Co m p ut e t he c um ula t ive CFAT a t e n d o f e a c h y e a r .
D e c is io n S ho r t e r t he P BP , b e t t e r t he p r o j e c t .
Dr a wba c k P BP d o e s n o t t a ke in t o a c c o un t t he t im e va lue o f m o n e y a n d c a s h f lo w s b e y o n d t he p a y b a c k p e r io d .
Be n e f it T he m a in b e n e f it o f t he p a y - b a c k p e r io d is t ha t it is a g o o d m e a s ur e o f p r o j e c t liquid it y .
CO NCE P T - 8 D is c o un t p a y - b a c k p e r io d
T he d is c o un t e d p a y b a c k p e r io d us e s t he p r e s e n t va lue ( P V) o f p r o j e c t ¡¦s e s t im a t e d Ca s h f lo w s.
I t is t he n um b e r o f y e a r s it t a ke s a p r o j e c t t o r e c o ve r it s in it ia l in ve s t m e n t in p r e s e n t va lue t e r m s.
D is c o un t e d p a y - b a c k p e r io d m us t b e g r e a t e r t ha n s im p le p a y - b a c k p e r io d .
CO NCE P T - 9 Pa y b a c k R e c ip r o c a l
I t is t he r e c ip r o c a l o f Pa y b a c k Pe r io d . I t is c o m p ut e d a s : E xa m p le :
A p r o j e c t w it h a n in it ia l in ve s t m e n t o f
R s. 5 0 la khs a n d lif e o f 10 y e a r s ,
g e n e r a t e s CFAT o f R s.10 la khs p e r
T he Pa y b a c k R e c ip r o c a l is c o n s id e r e d t o b e a n a p p r oxim a t io n o f I n t e r n a l R a t e o f R e t ur n , if : a n n um . I t s Pa y b a c k R e c ip r o c a l w ill b e
a ) T he lif e o f t he p r o j e c t is a t le a s t t w ic e t he p a y b a c k p e r io d , a n d 10 la khs / 2 0 la khs = 2 0 %
b ) T he P r o j e c t g e n e r a t e s e qua l a m o un t o f t he a n n ua l c a s h in f lo w s.
CO NCE P T - 10 I R R Te c hn ique s ( I n t e r n a l R a t e o f R e t ur n )
I R R is t he d is c o un t r a t e t ha t m a ke s P V o f a p r o j e c t ?s e s t im a t e d c a s h in f lo w s e qua l t o P V o f t he p r o j e c t ?s e s t im a t e d c a s h o ut f lo w s.
I R R is a ls o t he d is c o un t r a t e f o r w hic h t he NP V o f a p r o j e c t is e qua l t o Z E R O .
12
Ho w t o f in d t he s t a r t in g r a t e f o r c a lc ula t io n o f I R R : Ac c e p t / R e j e c t Cr it e r ia :
S t e p 1: Ca lc ula t e Fa ke Pa y - b a c k p e r io d I R R > Co s t o f Ca p it a l Ac c e p t t he P r o p o s a l
I R R = Co s t o f Ca p it a l I n d if f e r e n t
S t e p 2 : L o c a t e t he a b o ve f ig ur e in P r e s e n t Va lue An n uit y Fa c t o r Ta ble a n d t a ke t his I R R < Co s t o f Ca p it a l R e j e c t t he P r o p o s a l
d is c o un t r a t e t o s t a r t t he c a lc ula t io n o f I R R .
CO NCE P T - 11 Ac c o un t in g R a t e o f R e t ur n
1. I t ig n o r e s t im e va lue o f m o n e y .
Ave r a g e Ne t P r o f it = 2 . I t t a ke s in t o a c c o un t a c c o un t in g p r o f it s
r a t he r t ha n c a s h f lo w s.
CO NCE P T - 12 Ne t P r o f it a b ilit y I n d e x o r Ne t P I
; D e c is io n = Hig he r t he Be t t e r
CO NCE P T - 13 Mo d if ie d NP V/ I RR
W he n Co s t o f Ca p it a l & R e - in ve s t m e n t r a t e a r e s e p a r a t e ly g ive n , t he n w e c a lc ula t e Mo d if ie d NP V.
Mo d if ie d I R R : I t is t he d is c o un t r a t e a t w hic h Mo d if ie d NP V is Z e r o.
13
TOPI C - L E AS E FI NANCI NG
CO NCE P T - 1 I n t r o d uc t io n
Fr o m t he p o in t o f vie w o f " L e s s e e " Fr o m t he p o in t o f vie w o f " L e s s o r "
F in a n c e D e c is io n W he t he r t o p ur c ha s e t he As s e t o n L o a n vs W he t he r t o p ur c ha s e t he As s e t o r
W he t he r t o t a ke t he As s e t o n L e a s e G ive it o n L e a s e o r n o t ?
O ut f lo w D e c is io n NP V/ I n f lo w D e c is io n
I n ve s t in g D e c is io n D e c is io n : S e le vt o p t io n w hic h g ive s le a s t D e c is o in : I f NP V is +ve t he n Ac c e p t it
o ut f lo w I f NP V is - ve t he n R e j e c t it
L e a s in g is a n im p o r t a n t s o ur c e o f m e d ium - t e r m f in a n c in g o r le a s in g is t he p r o c e s s o f f in a n c in g t he c o s t o f a n a s s e t .
I t is a n a r r a n g e m e n t un d e r w hic h a n a s s e t is f in a n c e d a n d o w n e d by o n e p a r t y b ut p o s s e s s e d a n d us e d by t he o t he r
CO NCE P T - 2 Pa r t ie s t o t he le a s e a g r e e m e n t
Lessor T he O W NE R o f t he a s s e t is kn o w n a s le s s o r - w ho g ive s a s s e t s o n le a s e .
Lessee T he U S E R o f t he a s s e t is kn o w n a s le s s e e - w ho t a ke s a s s e t o n le a s e .
T he le a s e a g r e e m e n t d e t a ils o ut t he s p e c if ie d p e r io d a n d t im in g o f t he s e que n t ia l p a y m e n t s t o b e m a d e by t he le s s e e t o t he le s s o r
a s c o n s id e r a t io n f o r t he us e o f t he a s s e t . I t a ls o in c o r p o r a t e s r e p a y m e n t s c he d ule .
E xc e p t io n t o t his r ule :
1. T im in g D if f e r e n c e .
2 . I f d is c o un t r a t e is d if f e r e n t in b o t h o p t io n s.
No t e :
R e p a ir a n d Ma in t e n a n c e E xp e n s e s a r e a lw a y s b o r n e by t he us e r o f t he As s e t un le s s o t he r w is e s p e c if ic a lly s t a t e d .
I n s ur a n c e e xp e n s e s a r e a lw a y s b o r n e by t he o w n e r o f t he As s e t un le s s o t he r w is e s p e c if ic a lly s t a t e d .
Ad j us t m e n t No. 2
L o a n / P r in c ip a l R e p a y m e n t
1. Bulle t Pa y m e n t : P r in c ip a l w ill b e r e p a id in o n e s ho t a t t he e n d o f L o a n t e r m , in t his c a s e in t e r e s t is c a lc ula t e d f o r e a c h y e a r .
2 . P r in c ip a l a m o un t o f lo a n r e p a y m e n t : I n t e r e s t is c a lc ula t e d o n Ba la n c e a m o un t .
3 . E qua t e d An n ua l I n s t a llm e n t : I t in c lud e s I n t e r e s t a n d P r in c ip a l b o t h.
Ad j us t m e n t No. 3 : E qua t e d An n ua l I n s t a llm e n t ( E AI )
( W he n in s t a llm e n t is p a id a t t he e n d o f e a c h y e a r )
S t e p 1 : E qua t e d a n n ua l lo a n r e p a y m e n t in c lus ive o f in t e r e s t ( p a id a t t he e n d o f e a c h y e a r )
W he r e , r % = r a t e o f in t e r e s t b e f o r e Ta x ( Cha r g e d by b a n k) ; n = Pe r io d o f L o a n
S t e p 3 : Ca lc ula t e I n t e r e s t Ne t o f Ta x.
W he n in s t a llm e n t is p a id f r o m b e g in n in g o f e a c h y e a r / a n n uit y d ue
I f s ile n t , w e w ill a s s um e t ho s e r e n t a ls a r e p a id a t t he e n d o f e a c h y e a r .
D e c is io n : I f NP V is Po s it ive , le s s o r s ho uld le a s e t he a s s e t .
15
CO NCE P T - 5 Tr e a t m e n t o f D e p r e c ia t io n
D e p r e c ia t io n is a lw a y s c ha r g e d by t he o w n e r o f t he As s e t .
I n c a s e o f L o a n Op t io n , d e p r e c ia t io n is c ha r g e d by b o r r o w e r .
D e p r e c ia t io n is a n o n - c a s h it e m , it s ho uld n o t b e c o n s id e r e d w hile c a lc ula t in g c a s h f lo w s. Ta x S a vin g o n D e p r e c ia t io n
Ta x s a vin g s o n d e p r e c ia t io n s ho uld b e t a ke n a s c a s h in f lo w s = D e p r e c ia t io n Am o un t × Ta x R a t e
CO NCE P T - 6 Me t ho d s o f D e p r e c ia t io n
1. S t r a ig ht - lin e D e p r e c ia t io n Me t ho d :
S t r a ig ht - lin e d e p r e c ia t io n a llo c a t e s a n e qua l a m o un t o f d e p r e c ia t io n e a c h y e a r o ve r t he a s s e t ?s us e f ul lif e .
2 . W r it t e n - d o w n va lue D e p r e c ia t io n Me t ho d :- W D V D e p r e c ia t io n = [ Co s t - Ac c um ula t e d D e p r e c ia t io n ] x % o f D e p r e c ia t io n
No t e : I f R a t e o f D e p r e c ia t io n is g ive n us e W D V Me t ho d
We r e c o g n iz e m o r e d e p r e c ia t io n e xp e n s e in e a r ly y e a r s o f t he a s s e t ?s lif e a n d le s s d e p r e c ia t io n e xp e n s e in t he la t e r y e a r s o f lif e .
CO NCE P T - 9 Tr e a t m e n t o f Ta x
> Ca s h in f lo w s & Ca s h o ut f lo w s s ho uld b e t a ke n Ne t o f Ta x p r o vid e d c a s h in f lo w s & o ut f lo w s a r e p a r t o f t he p r o f it & lo s s a c c o un t
( Ta x S a vin g o r Ta x Pa id o n ly o n r e ve n ue it e m s n o t o n Ca p it a l it e m s ) .
> Ta x s a vin g s s ho uld b e t a ke n a s c a s h in f lo w s like t a x s a vin g s o n d e p r e c ia t io n , t a x s a vin g s d ue t o lo s s o n s a le o f a s s e t .
> Tr e a t m e n t o f Ta x w he n Ca s h in f lo w & Ca s h o ut f lo w a r is e s f r o m t he Be g in n in g o f e a c h y e a r .
E xa m p le : Tr a in in g e xp e n s e in c ur r e d a t t he b e g in n in g o f t he Ye a r 1 o r in Ye a r 0 R s. 10 ,0 0 0 . Ta x R a t e @ 4 0 %.
Ca lc ula t e I n f lo w & o ut f lo w f o r e a c h y e a r 16
Alt - 1 ( Ad j us t Ta x in y e a r 0 it s e lf Alt 2 - ( P r e f e r r e d by CA I n s t it ut e ) ( Ad j us t Ta x a t y e a r e n d 1)
1
Ye a r Ca s h Flo w Ye a r Ca s h Flo w
No t e : T he r e w ill b e d if f e r e n c e in a n s w e r un d e r b o t h
0 - 10 0 0 0 + 4 0 0 0 = - 6 0 0 0 0 - 10 0 0 0
a lt e r n a t ive s
1 Nil 1 + 40 0 0 6
CO NCE P T - 10 Br e a k- e ve n le a s e r e n t a ls ( Fr o m t he p o in t o f vie w o f L E S S E E )
Br e a k- e ve n le a s e r e n t a ls a r e t ho s e r e n t a ls a t w hic h:
P V o f o ut f lo w un d e r L o a n Op t io n = P V o f o ut f lo w un d e r L e a s e Op t io n
CO NCE P T - 11 Br e a k E ve n L e a s e R e n t a ls ( Fr o m t he p o in t o f vie w o f L E S S O R )
P V o f I n f lo w = P V o f O ut p ut
P V o f L e a s e R e n t a ls Ne t o f Ta x + P V o f Ta x S a vin g s o n D e p r e c ia t io n = Co s t o f As s e t
+ P V o f S V Ad j us t e d f o r Ta x - P V o f E xp e n s e Ne t o f Ta x
CO NCE P T - 12 Co n c e p t o f Blo c k o f As s e t s
Blo c k o f As s e t s m e a n s a g r o up o f a s s e t s f a llin g w it hin a p a r t ic ula r c la s s o f a s s e t s.
No d e p r e c ia t io n s ha ll b e c ha r g e d in t he y e a r in w hic h a s s e t is s o ld .
Ta x Be n e f it / L o s s o n S ho r t Te r m Ca p it a l L o s s / G a in s ha ll b e c a lc ula t e d o n p r e vio us y e a r W D V.
CO NCE P T - 13 Co n f us in g r e g a r d in g D is c o un t R a t e
Kd = I n t e r e s t ( 1- Ta x) , e ve n if c o s t o f c a p it a l is s e p a r a t e ly g ive n in t he que s t io n .
L e s s o r K 0 = Co s t o f Ca p it a l / D is c o un t R a t e / D e s ir e R a t e o f R e t ur n / Ta r g e t r a t e o f r e t ur n
No t e :
K 0 , Kd , d is c o un t r a t e & D e s ir e r a t e o f r e t ur n g ive n in t he que s t io n a r e a lw a y s Ne t o f Ta x.
Pe n d in g t w o p o in t s
p le a s e r e f e r o r g p d f
17
TOPI C - D I VI D E ND D E CI S I O N
CO NCE P T - 1 I n t r o d uc t io n
To t a l To t a l E a r n in g s No t e : To t a l E a r n in g s m e a n E a r n in g s a va ila ble t o e quit y s ha r e ho ld e r s
E a r n in g s D ivid e n d
L iquid a t in g D ivid e n d s Oc c ur s w he n c o m p a n y g o e s o ut o f b us in e s s a n d d is t r ib ut e s t he p r o c e e d s t o s ha r e ho ld e r s.
No t e :
R e la t io n s hip Be t w e e n D P R & R R :
R R + D P R = 10 0 % o r 1
> D ivid e n d y ie ld a n d E a r n in g Yie ld is a lw a y s c a lc ula t e d o n a n n ua l b a s is.
> D ivid e n d is 1s t p a id t o p r e f e r e n c e s ha r e ho ld e r b e f o r e a n y d e c la r a t io n o f d ivid e n d t o e quit y s ha r e ho ld e r s.
> D ivid e n d is a lw a y s p a id up o n F V( Fa c e Va lue ) n o t o n Ma r ke t Va lue
CO NCE P T - 4 T he o r ie s o f D ivid e n d s
R e le va n t T he o r y
R e le va n t T he o r y : D ivid e n d p la y e d a n im p o r t a n t r o le in d e t e r m in a t io n o f m a r ke t p r ic e o f
D ivid e n d Wa lt e r 's Mo d e l
s ha r e .
( Mo d e ls / G o r d o n 's Mo d e l
T he o r y ) I r r e le va n t T he o r y I r r e le va n t T he o r y : D ivid e n d d o n o t p la y a n y r o le in d e t e r m in a t io n o f m a r ke t p r ic e o f
M M Ap p r o a c h s ha r e / Ma r ke t va lue o f t he f ir m .
4 A - Wa lt e r 's Mo d e l
Wa lt e r ?s s up p o r t s t he vie w t ha t t he d ivid e n d p o lic y p la y s a n im p o r t a n t r o le in d e t e r m in in g t he m a r ke t p r ic e o f t he s ha r e .
He e m p ha s is t w o f a c t o r s w hic h in f lue n c e t he m a r ke t p r ic e o f a s ha r e :-
( i) D ivid e n d Pa y o ut R a t io.
( ii) T he r e la t io n s hip b e t w e e n I n t e r n a l r e t ur n o n R e t a in e d e a r n in g s ( r ) a n d c o s t o f e quit y c a p it a l ( Ke )
19
Wa lt e r c la s s if ie d a ll t he f ir m s in t o t hr e e c a t e g o r ie s:-
a ) G r o w t h F ir m :
I f ( r > Ke ) , I n t his c a s e , t he s ha r e ho ld e r 's w o uld like t he c o m p a n y t o r e t a in m a xim um a m o un t i.e . t o ke e p p a y o ut r a t io quit e lo w .
I n t his c a s e , t he r e is n e g a t ive c o r r e la t io n b e t w e e n d ivid e n d a n d m a r ke t p r ic e o f s ha r e .
I f r > Ke , L o w e r t he D ivid e n d Pa y - o ut R a t io Hig he r t he Ma r ke t P r ic e p e r S ha r e & vic e - ve r s a .
b ) D e c lin in g F ir m :
I f ( r < Ke ) , I n t his c a s e , t he s ha r e ho ld e r 's w o n 't like t he f ir m t o r e t a in t he p r o f it s s o t ha t t he y c a n g e t hig he r r e t ur n by in ve s t in g
t he d ivid e n d r e c e ive d by t he m .
I n t his c a s e , t he r e is p o s it ive c o r r e la t io n b e t w e e n d ivid e n d a n d m a r ke t p r ic e o f s ha r e .
I f r < Ke , Hig he r t he D ivid e n d Pa y - o ut R a t io , Hig he r t he Ma r ke t P r ic e p e r S ha r e & vic e - ve r s a .
c ) Co n s t a n t F ir m :
I f r a t e o f r e t ur n o n R e t a in e d e a r n in g s ( r ) is e qua l t o t he c o s t o f e quit y c a p it a l ( Ke ) i.e .( r = Ke ) . I n t his c a s e , t he s ha r e ho ld e r 's
w o uld b e in d if f e r e n t a b o ut s p lit t in g o f f t he e a r n in g s b e t w e e n d ivid e n d & R e t a in e d e a r n in g s.
I f r = Ke , An y R e t e n t io n R a t io o r An y D ivid e n d Pa y o ut R a t io w ill n o t a f f e c t Ma r ke t P r ic e o f s ha r e . M PS w ill r e m a in s a m e un d e r a n y
D ivid e n d Pa y o ut o r R e t e n t io n R a t io.
No t e : Wa lt e r c o n c lud e s:-
T he o p t im um p a y o ut r a t io is NI L in c a s e o f g r o w t h f ir m .
T he o p t im um p a y o ut r a t io f o r d e c lin in g f ir m is 10 0 %
T he p a y o ut r a t io o f c o n s t a n t f ir m is ir r e le va n t .
Ca t e g o r y o f t he F ir m r Vs. Ke Co r r e la t io n b e t w e e n M PS & D PS Op t im um Pa y o ut R a t io Op t im um R e t e n t io n R a t io
G r owt h r > Ke Ne g a t ive 0% 10 0 %
Co n s t a n t r = Ke No Co r r e la t io n E ve r y Pa y o ut is Op t im um E ve r y r e t e n t io n is Op t im um
D e c lin e r < Ke Po s it ive 10 0 % 0%
Va lua t io n o f E quit y a s p e r Wa lt e r ?s
Cur r e n t m a r ke t p r ic e o f a s ha r e is t he p r e s e n t va lue o f t w o c a s h f lo w s t r e a m s:-
a ) P r e s e n t Va lue o f a ll d ivid e n d .
b ) P r e s e n t va lue o f a ll r e t ur n o n r e t a in e d e a r n in g s.
I n o r d e r t o t e s t if y t he a b o ve , Wa lt e r ha s s ug g e s t e d a m a t he m a t ic a l va lua t io n m o d e l i.e .,
W he n
P 0 = Cur r e n t p r ic e o f e quit y s ha r e ( E x- d ivid e n d p r ic e ) / Fa ir o r T he o r e t ic a l o r I n t r in s ic o r E quilib r ium o r p r e s e n t Va lue P r ic e p e r S ha r e
D PS = D ivid e n d p e r s ha r e p a id by t he f ir m
r = R a t e o f r e t ur n o n in ve s t m e n t o f t he f ir m / I R R / R e t ur n o n e quit y
Ke = Co s t o f e quit y s ha r e c a p it a l/ D is c o un t r a t e / e xp e c t e d r a t e o f r e t ur n / o p p o r t un it y c o s t / Ca p it a liz a t io n r a t e
E PS = E a r n in g s p e r s ha r e o f t he f ir m
20
E PS ? D PS = R e t a in e d E a r n in g Pe r S ha r e
As s um p t io n s :
1) D PS & E PS a r e c o n s t a n t . 2) Ke & r a r e c o n s t a n t .
3 ) G o in g c o n c e r n a s s um p t io n , c o m p a n y ha s in f in it e lif e . 4) No e xt e r n a l F in a n c e
4B - G o r d o n ?s Mo d e l/ G r o w t h Mo d e l/ D ivid e n d d is c o un t Mo d e l
G o r d o n 's Mo d e l s ug g e s t t ha t t he d ivid e n d p o lic y is r e le va n t a n d c a n e f f e c t t he va lue o f t he s ha r e .
D ivid e n d Po lic y is r e le va n t a s t he in ve s t o r 's p r e f e r c ur r e n t d ivid e n d a s a g a in s t t he f ut ur e un c e r t a in Ca p it a l G a in .
Cur r e n t Ma r ke t p r ic e o f s ha r e = P V o f f ut ur e D ivid e n d , g r o w in g a t a c o n s t a n t r a t e
P0 = Cur r e n t m a r ke t p r ic e o f s ha r e .
Ke = Co s t o f e quit y c a p it a l/ D is c o un t r a t e / e xp e c t e d r a t e o f r e t ur n / Op p o r t un it y c o s t / Ca p it a liz a t io n r a t e .
g = G r owt h r at e No t e :
D1 = D PS a t t he e n d o f y e a r / Ne xt e xp e c t e d d ivid e n d / D ivid e n d t o b e p a id Wa t c h f o r w o r d s like ?J us t p a id ? o r ?r e c e n t ly
D0 = Cur r e n t y e a r d ivid e n d / d ivid e n d a s o n t o d a y / la s t p a id d ivid e n d p a id ?, t he s e r e f e r s t o t he la s t d ivid e n d D 0 a n d
E PS 1 = E PS a t t he e n d o f t he y e a r w o r d s like ?w ill p a y ? o r ?is e xp e c t e d t o p a y ? r e f e r s
b = R e t e n t io n R a t io t o D1 .
1- b = D ivid e n d p a y o ut R a t io
As s um p t io n s:
( i) No e xt e r n a l f in a n c e is a va ila ble . ( ii) K e & r a r e c o n s t a n t .
( iii) ?g ? is t he p r o d uc t o f it s R e t e n t io n R a t io ?b ? a n d it s r a t e o f r e t ur n ?r ?
( iv) Ke > g ( v) g & R R a r e c o n s t a n t . ( vi) F ir m ha s a n in f in it e lif e
Ap p lic a t io n s
1. E PS 1 ( 1- b ) = D PS 1 2 . I f E PS = D PS , R R = 0 t he n g = 0 3 . Ca lc ula t io n o f P 1 ( P r ic e a t t he e n d o f y e a r 1)
Pr oof : P r ic e a t t he b e g in n in g = P V o f D ivid e n d a t e n d
E PS 1 ( 1- b ) = E PS 1 x D ivid e n d Pa y o ut R a t io + P V o f m a r ke t p r ic e a t e n d
= D PS 1 4.
We kn o w t ha t D P R + R R = 1 o r 10 0 %
T he r e f o r e , E PS = D PS
n = E xis t in g n um b e r o f e quit y s ha r e s a t t he b e g in n in g o f t he y e a r As s um p t io n :
m = Ne w n um b e r o f e quit y s ha r e s , is s ue d a t y e a r e n d m a r ke t p r ic e Fun d s c a n r a is e o n ly by e quit y & r e t a in e d e a r n in g s.
P0 = Cur r e n t m a r ke t p r ic e a s o n t o d a y
P1 = Ma r ke t p r ic e p e r s ha r e a t t he e n d o f y e a r o n e No t e :
E1 = To t a l e a r n in g a t t he e n d o f y e a r o n e T he Ma r ke t P r ic e o f a s ha r e = P V o f d ivid e n d p a id
I1 = To t a l in ve s t m e n t a t t he e n d o f y e a r o n e a t e n d + P V o f m a r ke t p r ic e a t t he e n d a t t he
Ke = Co s t o f e quit y b e g in n in g o f a p e r io d
nP0 = Ma r ke t va lue o f t he c o m p a n y a s o n t o d a y
n +m = To t a l n o o f e quit y s ha r e a t t he e n d ( o ld + n e w s ha r e )
( n + m ) P 1 = To t a l m a r ke t va lue o f t he c o m p a n y a t t he e n d .
Am o un t r a is e d by is s ue o f n e w e quit y s ha r e s = I n ve s t m e n t ? [ E a r n in g ? D ivid e n d ] Ca lc ula t e P 1 f r o m t his f o r m ula e
Ne w n um b e r o f e quit y s ha r e
CO NCE P T - 5 G r a ha m & D o d d Mo d e l ( Tr a d it io n a l Ap p r o a c h)
w he r e m = m ult ip lie r
CO NCE P T - 6 L in t e r 's Mo d e l
We w ill c a lc ula t e d ivid e n d t o b e p a id by a n y Co m p a n y .
As s um p t io n :
D ivid e n d s ho uld n o t f a ll. I t m a y r e m a in c o n s t a n t o r m a y in c r e a s e b ut c a n ?t f a ll.
Fo r m ula :
D 1 = D 0 + [ E PS × Ta r g e t D ivid e n d Pa y o ut ? D 0 ] × AF
W he r e
AF = Ad j us t m e n t f a c t o r ; D 0 = D ivid e n d in P r e vio us Ye a r o r D ivid e n d Pa id ; D 1 = D ivid e n d t o b e p a id / d e c la r e d
22
TOPI C - T Y P E S O F FI NANCI NG
T O P I C - 1 E xt e r n a l Co m m e r c ia l Bo r r o w in g
1. E CBs r e f e r t o c o m m e r c ia l lo a n s ( in t he f o r m o f b a n k lo a n s , b uy e r ?s c r e d it , s up p lie r s c r e d it , s e c ur it is e d in s t r um e n t s ( e .g . f lo a t in g
r a t e n o t e s a n d f ixe d r a t e b o n d s ) a va ile d f r o m n o n - r e s id e n t le n d e r s w it h m in im um a ve r a g e m a t ur it y o f 3 y e a r s.
2 . Bo r r o w e r s c a n r a is e E CBs t hr o ug h in t e r n a t io n a lly r e c o g n is e d s o ur c e s like ( i) in t e r n a t io n a l b a n ks , ( ii) in t e r n a t io n a l c a p it a l m a r ke t s ,
( iii) m ult ila t e r a l f in a n c ia l in s t it ut io n s ( iv) e xp o r t c r e d it a g e n c ie s , ( v) s up p lie r s o f e quip m e n t , ( vi) f o r e ig n c o lla b o r a t o r s a n d
( vii) f o r e ig n e quit y ho ld e r s.
3 . E xt e r n a l Co m m e r c ia l Bo r r o w in g s c a n b e a c c e s s e d un d e r t w o r o ut e s viz ( i) Aut o m a t ic r o ut e a n d ( ii) Ap p r o va l r o ut e .
4 . U n d e r t he Aut o m a t ic r o ut e t he r e is n o n e e d t o t a ke t he R BI / G o ve r n m e n t a p p r o va l w he r e a s s uc h a p p r o va l is n e c e s s a r y un d e r t he
Ap p r o va l r o ut e .
5 . Co m p a n y ?s r e g is t e r e d un d e r t he Co m p a n ie s Ac t a n d NG O s e n g a g e d in m ic r o f in a n c e a c t ivit ie s a r e e lig ible f o r t he Aut o m a t ic R o ut e
w he r e a s F in a n c ia l I n s t it ut io n s a n d Ba n ks d e a lin g e xc lus ive ly in in f r a s t r uc t ur e o r e xp o r t f in a n c e a n d t he o n e s w hic h ha d p a r t ic ip a t e d
in t he t e xt ile a n d s t e e l s e c t o r r e s t r uc t ur in g p a c ka g e s a s a p p r o ve d by t he g o ve r n m e n t a r e r e quir e d t o t a ke t he Ap p r o va l R o ut e
TOPI C - 2 E ur o Bo n d s
1. T he n a m e E ur o b o n d s c a n b e m is le a d in g b e c a us e f r o m t he w o r d , y o u?d t hin k e it he r E ur o b o n d s w e r e a b o ut t he E ur o p e a n b o n d
m a r ke t s , o r a b o ut t he E ur o p e a n c ur r e n c y , E ur o s.
2 . E ur o b o n d s a r e a c t ua lly b o n d s t ha t a r e d e n o m in a t e d in a c ur r e n c y o t he r t ha n t ha t o f t he c o un t r y in w hic h t he y a r e is s ue d . T he y
a r e us ua lly is s ue d in m o r e t ha n o n e c o un t r y o f is s ue a n d t r a d e d a c r o s s in t e r n a t io n a l f in a n c ia l c e n t r e s.
3 . Co r p o r a t io n s , in c lud in g b a n ks a n d m ult in a t io n a l e n t it ie s is s ue E ur o b o n d s f o r m a n y p ur p o s e s in c lud in g f in a n c in g f o r c a p it a l a n d
o t he r p r o j e c t s.
4 . E ur o b o n d s a r e n o t r e g ula t e d by t he c o un t r y o f t he c ur r e n c y in w hic h t he y a r e d e n o m in a t e d .
E ur o b o n d s a r e s o - c a lle d ?b e a r e r b o n d s ?, t he y a r e n o t r e g is t e r e d a n y w he r e c e n t r a lly , s o w ho m e ve r ho ld s o r b e a r s t he b o n d is
c o n s id e r e d t he o w n e r .
5 . T he ir ?b e a r e r ? s t a t us a ls o e n a ble s E ur o b o n d s t o b e he ld a n o n y m o us ly .
TOPI C - 3 Fo r e ig n Bo n d s
1. T he s e a r e d e b t in s t r um e n t s is s ue d by f o r e ig n c o r p o r a t io n s o r f o r e ig n g o ve r n m e n t s.
2 . S uc h b o n d s a r e e xp o s e d t o d e f a ult r is k, e s p e c ia lly t he c o r p o r a t e b o n d s.
3 . T he s e b o n d s a r e d e n o m in a t e d in t he c ur r e n c y o f t he c o un t r y w he r e t he y a r e is s ue d , ho w e ve r , in c a s e t he s e b o n d s a r e is s ue d in a
c ur r e n c y o t he r t ha n t he in ve s t o r s ho m e c ur r e n c y , t he y a r e e xp o s e d t o e xc ha n g e r a t e r is ks. An e xa m p le o f a f o r e ig n b o n d ?A Br it is h
f ir m p la c in g D o lla r d e n o m in a t e d b o n d s in U S A?
TOPI C - 4 Me d ium Te r m No t e s
1. Ce r t a in is s ue r s n e e d f r e que n t f in a n c in g t hr o ug h t he Bo n d r o ut e in c lud in g t ha t o f t he E ur o b o n d .
2 . Ho w e ve r it m a y b e c o s t ly a n d in e f f e c t ive t o g o in f o r f r e que n t is s ue s. I n s t e a d , in ve s t o r s c a n f o llo w t he M T N p r o g r a m m e .
3 . Me d ium - t e r m n o t e ( ?M T N?) p r o g r a m s e n a ble c o m p a n ie s t o o f f e r d e b t s e c ur it ie s o n a r e g ula r a n d / o r c o n t in uo us b a s is.
4 . No t e s r a n g e in m a t ur it y f r o m o n e t o 10 y e a r s. By kn o w in g t ha t a n o t e is m e d ium t e r m , in ve s t o r s ha ve a n id e a o f w ha t it s m a t ur it y
w ill b e w he n t he y c o m p a r e it s p r ic e t o t ha t o f o t he r f ixe d - in c o m e s e c ur it ie s.
5 . All e ls e b e in g e qua l, t he c o up o n r a t e o n m e d ium - t e r m n o t e s w ill b e hig he r t ha n t ho s e a c hie ve d o n s ho r t - t e r m n o t e s.
23
TOPI C - 5 Ce r t if ic a t e o f D e p o s it ( CD )
1. A c e r t if ic a t e o f d e p o s it is a p r o m is s o r y n o t e is s ue d by a b a n k. I t is a t im e d e p o s it t ha t r e s t r ic t s ho ld e r s f r o m w it hd r a w in g f un d s
o n d e m a n d . Alt ho ug h it is s t ill p o s s ible t o w it hd r a w t he m o n e y , t his a c t io n w ill o f t e n in c ur a p e n a lt y .
2 . CD s c a n b e is s ue d by ( i) s c he d ule d c o m m e r c ia l b a n ks {e xc lud in g R e g io n a l R ur a l Ba n ks a n d L o c a l Ar e a Ba n ks }; a n d ( ii) s e le c t All- I n d ia
F in a n c ia l I n s t it ut io n s ( FI s ) t ha t ha ve b e e n p e r m it t e d by R BI t o r a is e s ho r t - t e r m r e s o ur c e s w it hin t he um b r e lla lim it ( p r e s c r ib e d in
p a r a g r a p h 3 .2 b e lo w ) f ixe d by R BI .
3 . Min im um a m o un t o f a CD s ho uld b e R s.1 la kh, i.e ., t he m in im um d e p o s it t ha t c o uld b e a c c e p t e d f r o m a s in g le s ub s c r ib e r s ho uld n o t b e
le s s t ha n R s.1 la kh, a n d in m ult ip le s o f R s. 1 la kh t he r e a f t e r .
4 . T he m a t ur it y p e r io d o f CD s is s ue d by b a n ks s ho uld n o t b e le s s t ha n 7 d a y s a n d n o t m o r e t ha n o n e y e a r , f r o m t he d a t e o f is s ue .
5 . CD s in p hy s ic a l f o r m a r e f r e e ly t r a n s f e r a ble by e n d o r s e m e n t a n d d e live r y
TOPI C - 6 Flo a t in g R a t e Bo n d s
1. T his a s t he n a m e s ug g e s t s is b o n d w he r e t he in t e r e s t r a t e is n o t f ixe d a n d is a llo w e d t o f lo a t d e p e n d in g up o n t he m a r ke t
c o n d it io n s.
2 . T his is a n id e a l in s t r um e n t w hic h c a n b e r e s o r t e d t o by t he is s ue r t o he d g e t he m s e lve s a g a in s t t he vo la t ilit y in t he in t e r e s t r a t e s.
3 . T his ha s b e c o m e m o r e p o p ula r a s a m o n e y m a r ke t in s t r um e n t a n d ha s b e e n s uc c e s s f ully is s ue d by f in a n c ia l in s t it ut io n s like I D BI ,
I CI CI e t c .
TOPI C - 7 Flo a t in g R a t e No t e s
1. A d e b t in s t r um e n t w it h a va r ia ble in t e r e s t r a t e . Als o kn o w n a s a ?f lo a t e r ?o r ?F R N,"
2 . Flo a t e r s a r e m a in ly is s ue d by f in a n c ia l in s t it ut io n s a n d g o ve r n m e n t s , a n d t he y t y p ic a lly ha ve a t w o - t o f ive - y e a r t e r m t o m a t ur it y .
3 . I n t e r e s t r a t e s a r e a d j us t e d t o r e f le c t t he p r e va ilin g e xc ha n g e r a t e s.
4 . T he y p r o vid e c he a p e r m o n e y t ha n f o r e ig n lo a n s.
5 . An F R N's in t e r e s t r a t e c a n c ha n g e a s o f t e n o r a s f r e que n t ly a s t he is s ue r c ho o s e s , f r o m o n c e a d a y t o o n c e a y e a r . T he ?r e s e t
p e r io d ? t e lls t he in ve s t o r ho w o f t e n t he r a t e a d j us t s. T he is s ue r m a y p a y in t e r e s t m o n t hly , qua r t e r ly , s e m i- a n n ua lly o r a n n ua lly . F R Ns
m a y b e is s ue d w it h o r w it ho ut a c a ll o p t io n .
TOPI C - 8 D e e p D is c o un t Bo n d s
1. D e e p D is c o un t Bo n d s is a f o r m o f z e r o - in t e r e s t b o n d s.
2 . T he s e b o n d s a r e s o ld a t a d is c o un t e d va lue a n d o n m a t ur it y f a c e va lue is p a id t o t he in ve s t o r s.
3 . I n s uc h b o n d s , t he r e is n o in t e r e s t p a y o ut d ur in g lo c k in p e r io d .
4 . I D BI w a s t he f ir s t t o is s ue a d e e p d is c o un t b o n d in I n d ia in J a n ua r y , 19 9 2 . T he b o n d o f a f a c e va lue o f `1 la kh w a s s o ld f o r `2 ,7 0 0
w it h a m a t ur it y p e r io d o f 2 5 y e a r s. T he in ve s t o r c o uld ho ld t he b o n d f o r 2 5 y e a r s o r s e e k r e d e m p t io n a t t he e n d o f e ve r y f ive y e a r s
w it h a s p e c if ie d m a t ur it y va lue a s s ho w n b e lo w .
T he in ve s t o r c a n s e ll t he b o n d s in s t o c k m a r ke t a n d r e a lis e Ho ld in g p e r io d ( y e a r s ) 5 10 15 20 25
t he d if f e r e n c e b e t w e e n f a c e va lue ( R s. 2 ,7 0 0 ) a n d m a r ke t Ma t ur it y Va lue 5 ,7 0 0 12 ,0 0 0 2 5 ,0 0 0 5 0 ,0 0 0 1,0 0 ,0 0 0
p r ic e a s c a p it a l g a in .
An n ua l r a t e o f in t e r e s t 16 .12 16 .0 9 15 .9 9 15 .7 1 15 .5 4
No t e t ha t D e e p D is c o un t Bo n d m a y ha ve in t e r e s t r a t e s w hic h c a n b e lo w e r t ha n t he us ua l r a t e .
24
TOPI C - 9 Z e r o Co up o n Bo n d s
1. A z e r o - c o up o n b o n d ( a ls o d is c o un t b o n d o r d e e p d is c o un t b o n d ) is a b o n d b o ug ht a t a p r ic e lo w e r t ha n it s f a c e va lue , w it h t he f a c e
va lue r e p a id a t t he t im e o f m a t ur it y .
2 . I t d o e s n o t m a ke p e r io d ic in t e r e s t p a y m e n t s , o r ha ve s o - c a lle d " c o up o n s " , he n c e t he t e r m z e r o - c o up o n b o n d . W he n t he b o n d
r e a c he s m a t ur it y , it s in ve s t o r r e c e ive s it s p a r ( o r f a c e ) va lue .
3 . S o m e z e r o c o up o n b o n d s a r e in f la t io n in d e xe d , s o t he a m o un t o f m o n e y t ha t w ill b e p a id t o t he b o n d ho ld e r is c a lc ula t e d t o ha ve a
s e t a m o un t o f p ur c ha s in g p o w e r r a t he r t ha n a s e t a m o un t o f m o n e y , b ut t he m a j o r it y o f z e r o c o up o n b o n d s p a y a s e t a m o un t o f
m o n e y kn o w n a s t he f a c e va lue o f t he b o n d .
4 . Z e r o c o up o n b o n d s m a y b e lo n g o r s ho r t t e r m in ve s t m e n t s. L o n g - t e r m z e r o c o up o n m a t ur it y d a t e s t y p ic a lly s t a r t a t t e n t o
f if t e e n y e a r s. T he b o n d s c a n b e he ld un t il m a t ur it y o r s o ld o n s e c o n d a r y b o n d m a r ke t s. S ho r t - t e r m z e r o c o up o n b o n d s g e n e r a lly ha ve
m a t ur it ie s o f le s s t ha n o n e y e a r a n d a r e c a lle d b ills. T he U .S . Tr e a s ur y b ill m a r ke t is t he m o s t a c t ive a n d liquid d e b t m a r ke t in t he
w o r ld
T O P I C - 10 D o uble Op t io n Bo n d s
1. T he s e ha ve a ls o b e e n r e c e n t ly is s ue d by t he I D BI . T he f a c e va lue o f e a c h b o n d is R s. 5 ,0 0 0 .
2 . T he b o n d c a r r ie s in t e r e s t a t 15 % p e r a n n um c o m p o un d e d ha lf y e a r ly f r o m t he d a t e o f a llo t m e n t . T he b o n d ha s m a t ur it y p e r io d o f
10 y e a r s.
3 . E a c h b o n d ha s t w o p a r t s in t he f o r m o f t w o s e p a r a t e c e r t if ic a t e s , o n e f o r p r in c ip a l o f R s. 5 ,0 0 0 a n d o t he r f o r in t e r e s t ( in c lud in g
r e d e m p t io n p r e m ium ) o f R s. 16 ,5 0 0 .
4 . Bo t h t he s e c e r t if ic a t e s a r e lis t e d o n a ll m a j o r s t o c k e xc ha n g e s.
5 . T he in ve s t o r ha s t he f a c ilit y o f s e llin g e it he r o n e o r b o t h p a r t s a n y t im e he like s.
T O P I C - 11 Am e r ic a n D e p o s it a r y R e c e ip t s
1. S ha r e s o f m a n y n o n - U S c o m p a n ie s t r a d e o n U S s t o c k e xc ha n g e s t hr o ug h AD R s.
2 . AD R s a r e d e n o m in a t e d a n d p a y d ivid e n d s in U S d o lla r s a n d m a y b e t r a d e d like r e g ula r s ha r e s o f s t o c k.
3 . T his is a n e xc e lle n t w a y f o r t he p ublic in U S t o b uy s ha r e s in a n o n U S c o m p a n y w hile r e a liz in g a n y d ivid e n d s a n d c a p it a l g a in s in
U .S . d o lla r s.
4 . O n e AD R m a y r e p r e s e n t a p o r t io n o f a f o r e ig n s ha r e , o n e s ha r e o r a b un d le o f s ha r e s o f a f o r e ig n c o r p o r a t io n .
5 . I f t he AD R 's a r e " s p o n s o r e d ," t he c o r p o r a t io n p r o vid e s f in a n c ia l in f o r m a t io n a n d o t he r a s s is t a n c e t o t he b a n k a n d m a y s ub s id iz e
t he a d m in is t r a t io n o f t he AD R .
6 . " U n s p o n s o r e d " AD R s d o n o t r e c e ive s uc h a s s is t a n c e .
7 . Fe e s a s s o c ia t e d w it h t he c r e a t in g o r r e le a s in g o f AD R s f r o m o r d in a r y s ha r e s , c ha r g e d by t he c o m m e r c ia l b a n ks w it h
c o r r e s p o n d e n t b a n ks in t he in t e r n a t io n a l s it e s.
T O P I C - 12 G lo b a l D e p o s it a r y R e c e ip t s
1. A b a n k c e r t if ic a t e is s ue d in m o r e t ha n o n e c o un t r y f o r s ha r e s in a f o r e ig n c o m p a n y .
2 . T he s ha r e s a r e he ld by a f o r e ig n b r a n c h o f a n in t e r n a t io n a l b a n k.
3 . T he s ha r e s t r a d e a s d o m e s t ic s ha r e s , b ut a r e o f f e r e d f o r s a le g lo b a lly t hr o ug h t he va r io us b a n k b r a n c he s. 25
4 . S e ve r a l in t e r n a t io n a l b a n ks is s ue G D R s , s uc h a s J P Mo r g a n Cha s e , Cit ig r o up , D e ut s c he Ba n k, T he Ba n k o f Ne w Yo r k Me llo n .
5 . G D R s a r e o f t e n lis t e d in t he Fr a n kf ur t S t o c k E xc ha n g e , L uxe m b o ur g S t o c k E xc ha n g e a n d in t he L o n d o n S t o c k E xc ha n g e , w he r e
t he y a r e t r a d e d o n t he I n t e r n a t io n a l O r d e r Bo o k ( I O B) .
T O P I C - 13 I n d ia n D e p o s it a r y R e c e ip t s
1. An I n d ia n D e p o s it o r y R e c e ip t ( I D R ) is a f in a n c ia l in s t r um e n t d e n o m in a t e d in I n d ia n R up e e s in t he f o r m o f a d e p o s it o r y r e c e ip t
c r e a t e d by a D o m e s t ic D e p o s it o r y a g a in s t t he un d e r ly in g e quit y o f is s uin g c o m p a n y t o e n a ble f o r e ig n c o m p a n ie s t o r a is e f un d s f r o m
t he I n d ia n s e c ur it ie s Ma r ke t s.
2 . T he f o r e ig n c o m p a n y I D R s w ill d e p o s it s ha r e s t o a n I n d ia n d e p o s it o r y .
3 . T he d e p o s it o r y w o uld is s ue r e c e ip t s t o in ve s t o r s in I n d ia a g a in s t t he s e s ha r e s.
4 . T he b e n e f it o f t he un d e r ly in g s ha r e s ( like b o n us , d ivid e n d s e t c .) w o uld a c c r ue t o t he d e p o s it o r y r e c e ip t ho ld e r s in I n d ia .
T O P I C - 14 S e e d Ca p it a l As s is t a n c e
1. T he S e e d c a p it a l a s s is t a n c e s c he m e is d e s ig n e d by I D BI f o r p r o f e s s io n a lly o r t e c hn ic a lly qua lif ie d e n t r e p r e n e ur s a n d / o r p e r s o n s
p o s s e s s in g r e le va n t e xp e r ie n c e , s kills a n d e n t r e p r e n e ur ia l t r a it s.
2 . All t he p r o j e c t s e lig ible f o r f in a n c ia l a s s is t a n c e f r o m I D BI , d ir e c t ly o r in d ir e c t ly t hr o ug h r e f in a n c e a r e e lig ible un d e r t he s c he m e .
3 . T he S e e d Ca p it a l As s is t a n c e is in t e r e s t f r e e b ut c a r r ie s a s e r vic e c ha r g e o f o n e p e r c e n t p e r a n n um f o r t he f ir s t f ive y e a r s a n d
a t in c r e a s in g r a t e t he r e a f t e r .
4 . Ho w e ve r , I D BI w ill ha ve t he o p t io n t o c ha r g e in t e r e s t a t s uc h r a t e a s m a y b e d e t e r m in e d by I D BI o n t he lo a n if t he f in a n c ia l
p o s it io n a n d p r o f it a b ilit y o f t he c o m p a n y s o p e r m it s d ur in g t he c ur r e n c y o f t he lo a n .
5 . T he r e p a y m e n t s c he d ule is f ixe d d e p e n d in g up o n t he r e p a y in g c a p a c it y o f t he un it w it h a n in it ia l m o r a t o r ium up t o f ive y e a r s.
6 . T he p r o j e c t c o s t s ho uld n o t e xc e e d R s. 2 c r o r e s a n d t he m a xim um a s s is t a n c e un d e r t he p r o j e c t w ill b e r e s t r ic t e d t o 5 0 p e r c e n t
o f t he r e quir e d p r o m o t e r 's c o n t r ib ut io n o r R s. 15 la c s , w hic he ve r is lo w e r .
T O P I C - 15 W ha t is Br id g e F in a n c in g ?
1. Br id g e f in a n c e r e f e r s t o lo a n s t a ke n by a c o m p a n y n o r m a lly f r o m c o m m e r c ia l b a n ks f o r a s ho r t p e r io d b e c a us e o f p e n d in g
d is b ur s e m e n t o f lo a n s s a n c t io n e d by f in a n c ia l in s t it ut io n s.
2 . T he b r id g e lo a n s a r e r e p a id / a d j us t e d o ut o f t he t e r m lo a n s a s a n d w he n d is b ur s e d by t he c o n c e r n e d in s t it ut io n s.
3 . Br id g e lo a n s a r e n o r m a lly s e c ur e d by hy p o t he c a t in g m o va ble a s s e t s , p e r s o n a l g ua r a n t e e s a n d d e m a n d p r o m is s o r y n o t e s. G e n e r a lly ,
t he r a t e o f in t e r e s t o n b r id g e f in a n c e is hig he r a s c o m p a r e d w it h t ha t o n t e r m lo a n s.
T O P I C - 16 L e a s e F in a n c in g
Ty p e s o f L e a s e c o n t r a c t :- 1. Op e r a t in g L e a s e 2 . F in a n c e L e a s e
Ba s is F in a n c e L e a s e Op e r a t in g L e a s e
Lease t er m Co ve r s t he e c o n o m ic lif e o f t he e quip m e n t Co ve r s s ig n if ic a n t ly le s s t ha n t he e c o n o m ic lif e
o f t he e quip m e n t
Ca n c e lla t io n F in a n c ia l le a s e c a n n o t b e c a n c e lle d d ur in g t he p r im a r y Op e r a t in g le a s e c a n b e c a n c e lle d by t he le s s e e
le a s e p e r io d . p r io r t o it s e xp ir a t io n
Am o r t iz a t io n T he le a s e r e n t a ls a r e m o r e o r le s s f ully a m o r t iz e d T he le a s e r e n t a ls a r e n o t s uf f ic ie n t e n o ug h t o
d ur in g t he p r im a r y le a s e p e r io d . a m o r t iz e t he c o s t o f t he a s s e t
R is k o f o b s o le s c e n c e T he le s s e e is r e quir e d t o t a ke t he r is k o f o b s o le s c e n c e . T he le s s e e is p r o t e c t e d a g a in s t t he r is k o f
o b s o le s c e n c e
Co s t s o f m a in t e n a n c e , t a xe s , in s ur a n c e e t c . I n c ur r e d by le s s e e un le s s c o n t r a c t p r o vid e s o t he r w is e . I n c ur r e d by t he le s s o r . 26
T O P I C - 17 Co m m e r c ia l Pa p e r
1. W ha t is Co m m e r c ia l Pa p e r ( CP ) ?
Co m m e r c ia l Pa p e r ( CP ) is a n un s e c ur e d m o n e y m a r ke t in s t r um e n t is s ue d in t he f o r m o f a p r o m is s o r y n o t e .
2 . W ho c a n is s ue CP :
Co r p o r a t e , p r im a r y d e a le r s ( P D s ) a n d t he All- I n d ia F in a n c ia l I n s t it ut io n s ( FI s ) a r e e lig ible t o is s ue CP .
3 . W ha t is t he m in im um a n d m a xim um p e r io d o f m a t ur it y p r e s c r ib e d f o r CP ?
CP c a n b e is s ue d f o r m a t ur it ie s b e t w e e n a m in im um o f 7 d a y s a n d a m a xim um o f up t o o n e y e a r f r o m t he d a t e o f is s ue . Ho w e ve r , t he
m a t ur it y d a t e o f t he CP s ho uld n o t g o b e y o n d t he d a t e up t o w hic h t he c r e d it r a t in g o f t he is s ue r is va lid .
4 . I n w ha t d e n o m in a t io n s a CP t ha t c a n b e is s ue d ?
CP c a n b e is s ue d in d e n o m in a t io n s o f R s.5 la kh o r m ult ip le s t he r e o f .
5 . W ho c a n in ve s t in CP ?
I n d ivid ua ls , b a n kin g c o m p a n ie s , o t he r c o r p o r a t e b o d ie s ( r e g is t e r e d o r in c o r p o r a t e d in I n d ia ) a n d un in c o r p o r a t e d b o d ie s , No n - R e s id e n t
I n d ia n s ( NR I s ) a n d Fo r e ig n I n s t it ut io n a l I n ve s t o r s ( FI I s ) e t c . c a n in ve s t in CPs.
6 . W he t he r CP c a n b e he ld in d e m a t e r ia lis e d f o r m ? Ye s.
7 . W he t he r CPs a r e t r a d e d in t he s e c o n d a r y m a r ke t ?
Ye s. CPs a r e a c t ive ly t r a d e d in t he OT C [ o ve r t he c o un t e r ] m a r ke t . S uc h t r a n s a c t io n s , ho w e ve r , a r e t o b e r e p o r t e d o n t he r e p o r t in g
p la t f o r m w it hin 15 m in ut e s o f t he t r a d e f o r d is s e m in a t io n o f t r a d e in f o r m a t io n t o m a r ke t p a r t ic ip a t io n t he r e by e n s ur in g m a r ke t
t r ansp ar enc y.
27
TOPI C - WO R K I NG CAP I TAL MANAG E M E NT
CO NCE P T - 1 Op e r a t in g o r Wo r kin g Ca p it a l Cy c le
Wo r kin g Ca p it a l c y c le in d ic a t e s t he le n g t h o f t im e b e t w e e n a c o m p a n y ?s p a y in g f o r m a t e r ia ls , e n t e r in g in t o s t o c k a n d r e c e ivin g t he c a s h f r o m s a le s
o f f in is he d g o o d s. Fo r e xa m p le , a c o m p a n y ho ld s r a w m a t e r ia ls o n a n a ve r a g e f o r 6 0 d a y s , it g e t s c r e d it f r o m t he s up p lie r f o r 15 d a y s , p r o d uc t io n
p r o c e s s n e e d s 15 d a y s , f in is he d g o o d s a r e he ld f o r 3 0 d a y s a n d 3 0 d a y s c r e d it is e xt e n d e d t o d e b t o r s. T he t o t a l o f a ll t he s e , 12 0 d a y s , i.e ., 6 0 ? 15
+ 15 + 3 0 + 3 0 d a y s is t he t o t a l w o r kin g c a p it a l c y c le .
I n t he f o r m o f a n e qua t io n , t he o p e r a t in g c y c le p r o c e s s c a n b e e xp r e s s e d a s f o llo w s: Op e r a t in g Cy c le = R + W + F + D ? C
R R a w Ma t e r ia l S t o r a g e p e r io d = ( Ave r a g e s t o c k o f r a w m a t e r ia l) / ( Ave r a g e c o s t o f r a w m a t e r ia l c o n s um p t io n p e r d a y )
W Wo r k in P r o g r e s s ho ld in g p e r io d = ( Ave r a g e Wo r k in p r o g r e s s in ve n t o r y ) / ( Ave r a g e c o s t o f p r o d c ut io n p e r d a y )
F F in is he d g o o d s s t o r a g e p e r io d = ( Ave r a g e s t o c k o f f in is he d g o o d s in ve n t o r y ) / ( Ave r a g e c o s t o f g o o d s s o ld p e r d a y )
D D e b t o r s c o lle c t io n p e r io d = ( Ave r a g e D e b t o r s ) / ( Ave r a g e c r e d it s a le s p e r d a y )
C Cr e d it o r s p a y m e n t p e r io d = ( Ave r a g e Cr e d it o r s ) / ( Ave r a g e c r e d it p ur c ha s e s p e r d a y )
Wo r k in p r o g r e s s x Ave r a g e W I P ho ld in g p e r io d
I n ve n t o r y ( in m o n t hs o r in d a y s )
Cur r e n t
As s e t s F in is he d G o o d s x Ave r a g e f in is he d g o o d s ho ld in g p e r io d
I n ve n t o r y ( in m o n t hs o r in d a y s )
Cr e d it o r s x Cr e d it p e r io d g r a n t e d by s up p lie r s
( in m o n t hs o r in d a y s )
Cur r e n t D ir e c t Wa g e s x Ave r a g e t im e la g in p a y m e n t o f w a g e s
L ia b ilit ie s Pa y a ble ( in m o n t hs o r in d a y s )
O ve r he a d s x Ave r a g e t im e la g in p a y m e n t o f o ve r he a d s
o ut s t a n d in g ( in m o n t hs o r in d a y s )
Ma n a g e m e n t o f Pa y a ble s W he r e , d = s iz e o f d is c o un t , i.e . f o r 6 % d is c o un t . d =6 , t =T he r e d uc t io n in t he p a y m e n t p e r io d
Co m p ut a t io n o f c o s t o f in d a y s , n e c e s s a r y t o o b t a in t he e a r ly d is c o un t o r D a y s Cr e d it O ut s t a n d in g ? D is c o un t
p a y a ble s Pe r io d .
28
TOPI C - CAP I TAL S T R U CT U R E D E CI S I O NS
CO NCE P T - 1 I n t r o d uc t io n
Ca p it a l s t r uc t ur e r e f e r s t o t he m ix o f a f ir m ?s c a p it a lis a t io n ( i.e . m ix o f lo n g t e r m s o ur c e s o f f un d s s uc h a s d e b e n t ur e s , p r e f e r e n c e
s ha r e c a p it a l, e quit y s ha r e c a p it a l a n d r e t a in e d e a r n in g s f o r m e e t in g t o t a l c a p it a l r e quir e m e n t ) .
CO NCE P T - 2 F in a n c ia l Br e a k- e ve n a n d I n d if f e r e n c e An a ly s is
F in a n c ia l b r e a k- e ve n p o in t is t he m in im um le ve l o f E BI T n e e d e d t o s a t is f y a ll t he f ixe d f in a n c ia l c ha r g e s i.e . in t e r e s t a n d p r e f e r e n c e
d ivid e n d s. I t d e n o t e s t he le ve l o f E BI T f o r w hic h t he f ir m ?s E PS e qua ls z e r o.
T he e quiva le n c y o r in d if f e r e n c e p o in t c a n a ls o b e c a lc ula t e d a lg e b r a ic a lly in t he f o llo w in g m a n n e r :
W he r e ,
E BI T = I n d if f e r e n c e p o in t , E 1=Num b e r o f e quit y s ha r e in a lt e r n a t ive 1,
E 2 =Num b e r o f e quit y s ha r e in a lt e r n a t ive 2 , I 1=I n t e r e s t c ha r g e s in a lt e r n a t ive 1,
I 2 =I n t e r e s t c ha r g e s in a lt e r n a t ive 2 , Alt e r n a t ive 1= All E quit y f in a n c e , Alt e r n a t ive 2 = D e b t - E quit y f in a n c e , T = Ta x r a t e ,
CO NCE P T - 3 Ca p it a l S t r uc t ur e T he o r ie s
a ) Ne t in c o m e a p p r o a c h : T he va lue o f t he f ir m o n t he b a s is o f Ne t I n c o m e Ap p r o a c h c a n b e a s c e r t a in e d a s f o llo w s: V = S + D
W he r e , V = Va lue o f t he f ir m , S = Ma r ke t va lue o f e quit y , D = Ma r ke t va lue o f d e b t
b ) Ne t o p e r a t in g in c o m e a p p r o a c h : NO I m e a n s e a r n in g s b e f o r e in t e r e s t a n d t a x. Ac c o r d in g t o t his a p p r o a c h, c a p it a l s t r uc t ur e
d e c is io n s o f t he f ir m a r e ir r e le va n t . An y c ha n g e in t he le ve r a g e w ill n o t le a d t o a n y c ha n g e in t he t o t a l va lue o f t he f ir m a n d t he
m a r ke t p r ic e o f s ha r e s , a s t he o ve r a ll c o s t o f c a p it a l is in d e p e n d e n t o f t he d e g r e e o f le ve r a g e .
29
CO NCE P T - 4 W ha t is Ve n t ur e Ca p it a l F in a n c in g ? [ To p ic s f r o m Ty p e s o f F in a n c in g ]
T he ve n t ur e c a p it a l f in a n c in g r e f e r s t o f in a n c in g o f n e w hig h r is ky ve n t ur e p r o m o t e d by qua lif ie d e n t r e p r e n e ur s w ho la c k e xp e r ie n c e
a n d f un d s t o g ive s ha p e t o t he ir id e a s.
I n b r o a d s e n s e , un d e r ve n t ur e c a p it a l f in a n c in g ve n t ur e c a p it a lis t m a ke in ve s t m e n t t o p ur c ha s e e quit y o r d e b t s e c ur it ie s f r o m
in e xp e r ie n c e d e n t r e p r e n e ur s w ho un d e r t a ke hig hly r is ky ve n t ur e s w it h a p o t e n t ia l o f s uc c e s s.
1. S o m e o f t he c ha r a c t e r is t ic s o f Ve n t ur e Ca p it a l Fun d in g a r e :-
2 . I t is b a s ic a lly a e quit y f in a n c e in n e w c o m p a n ie s.
3 . I t c a n b e vie w e d a s a lo n g t e r m in ve s t m e n t in g r o w t h- o r ie n t e d s m a ll/ m e d ium f ir m s.
4 . Ap a r t f r o m p r o vid in g f un d s , t he in ve s t o r a ls o p r o vid e s s up p o r t in f o r m o f s a le s s t r a t e g y , b us in e s s n e t w o r kin g a n d m a n a g e m e n t
e xp e r t is e , e n a blin g t he g r o w t h o f t he e n t r e p r e n e ur .
CO NCE P T - 5 W ha t is D e b t S e c ur it is a t io n ? [ To p ic s f r o m Ty p e s o f F in a n c in g ]
D e b t S e c ur it is a t io n is t he p r o c e s s o f c o n ve r s io n o f e xis t in g a s s e t s o r f ut ur e c a s h f lo w s in t o m a r ke t a ble s e c ur it ie s. I n o t he r w o r d s ,
s e c ur it is a t io n d e a ls w it h t he c o n ve r s io n o f a s s e t s w hic h a r e n o t m a r ke t a ble in t o m a r ke t a ble o n e s.
T he o r ig in a t o r , e n t it y o w n in g t he a s s e t s o ut o f a n a g r e e m e n t id e n t if ie s a p o o l o f ho m o g e n e o us a s s e t s , w hic h it d e s ir e s t o s e c ur it iz e .
1. O r ig in a t o r m a ke s s a le s t o c us t o m e r s in t he n o r m a l c o ur s e o f b us in e s s.
2 . O r ig in a t o r t r a n s f e r s t he a s s e t s t o a d if f e r e n t e n t it y w ho ha s t r us t a g r e e m e n t w it h t r us t e e , G ua r e n t e e a g r e e m e n t w it h
g ua r e n t e e a n d is t o p r a t e d by r a t in g a g e n c y , c o m m o n ly kn o w n a s s p e c ia l p ur p o s e ve hic le ( S P V)
3 . S P V w ill c o n ve r t s uc h a s s e t s in t o c e r t if ic a t e s kn o w n a s Pa y t hr o ug h o r Pa s s t hr o ug h c e r t if ic a t e s a n d s e ll t ho s e c e r t if ic a t e s t o
p ublic .
4 . Public s ub s c r ib e s t o s uc h c e r t if ic a t e s a n d p a y t o t he S P V.
5 . S P V a f t e r d e d uc t in g his c ha r g e s t r a n s f e r s t he p r o c e e d s t o O r ig in a t o r .
6 . T he d e b t o r s w ill d ue a m o un t .
7 . As a n d w he n S P V c o lle c t s m o n e y f r o m d e b t o r s , it w ill b e im m e d ia t e ly d is t r ib ut e d t o p ublic ( I n c a s e o f p a s s t hr o ug h c e r t if ic a t e s )
o r w ill a c c um ula t e up t o a p o in t o f t im e s a y a y e a r a n d t he n d is t r ib ut e t o p ublic ( I n c a s e o f p a y t hr o ug h c e r t if ic a t e s ) .
30
TOPI C - L E VE R AG E S
CO NCE P T - 1 Ty p e s o f L e ve r a g e s
Op e r a t in g L e ve r a g e F in a n c ia l L e ve r a g e
Op e r a t in g L e ve r a g e = F in a n c ia l L e ve r a g e =
3 . Co m b in e d L e ve r a g e
Op e r a t in g L e ve r a g e x F in a n c ia l L e ve r a g e
Co m b in e d L e ve r a g e =
Co m b in e d L e ve r a g e =
D e g r e e o f Op e r a t in g L e ve r a g e = D e g r e e o f F in a n c ia l L e ve r a g e =
D e g r e e o f F in a n c ia l L e ve r a g e =
Op e r a t in g S t r uc t ur e
S a le s XXX
- Va r ia ble Co s t XX
Co n t r ib ut io n XXX
- F ixe d Co s t XX
E a r n in g s Be f o r e I n t e r e s t a n d Ta x XXX
- I nt er est XX
E a r n in g s Be f o r e Ta x
- Ta x
XXX
XX
31
E a r n in g s Af t e r Ta x XXX
TOPI C - R AT I O ANALYS I S
A. L iquid it y
( Cur r e n t As s e t s ) / ( Cur r e n t L ia b ilit ie s )
1. Cur r e n t R a t io
( a ls o kn o w n a s Wo r kin g Ca p it a l R a t io )
4 . Ba s ic D e f e n s e I n t e r va l ( BD I )
D e t e r m in e s t he n um b e r o f m o n t hs y o u
5 . Ad e qua c y o f r e s o ur c e s c o uld o p e r a t e w it ho ut f ur t he r f un d s
r e c e ive d ( b ur n r a t e )
B. Ca p it a l S t r uc t ur e R a t io s
1. E quit y R a t io ( S ha r e ho ld e r s E quit y ) / ( To t a l Ca p it a l E m p loy e d )
2 . D e b t R a t io ( To t a l D e b t ) / ( Ca p it a l E m p loy e d )
( To t a l L ia b ilit ie s ) / ( S ha r e ho ld e r 's E quit y )
3 . D e b t t o E quit y R a t io
o r To t a l L ia b ilit ie s = L o n g Te r m D e b t
Ca p it a l g e a r in g r a t io is a ls o c a lc ula t e d
t o s ho w t he p r o p o r t io n o f f ixe d
4 . Ca p it a l G e a r in g R a t io
in t e r e s t ( d ivid e n d ) b e a r in g c a p it a l t o
f un d s b e lo n g in g t o e quit y s ha r e ho ld e r s.
C. Co ve r a g e R a t io s
1. D e b t S e r vic e Co ve r a g e R a t io ( E a r n in g s a va ila ble f o r d e b t s e r vic e ) / ( I n t e r e s t + I n s t a llm e n t )
2 . I n t e r e s t S e r vic e Co ve r a g e
R a t io
3 . P r e f e r e n c e D ivid e n d Co ve r a g e
32
R a t io
D . P r o f it a b ilit y R a t io s
I . Ma r ke t I n f o r m a t io n I I . Po in t o f vie w I I I . Ba s e d o n As s e t s / I n ve s t m e n t s I V. Ba s e d o n S a le s
I . Ma r ke t I n f o r m a t io n
1. P r ic e E a r n in g R a t io ( P E R a t io ) ( Ma r ke t P r ic e p e r s ha r e ) / ( E a r n in g p e r s ha r e )
2 . Yie ld Yie ld = ( D ivid e n d ) / ( Clo s in g s ha r e p r ic e ) x 10 0 o r Yie ld = ( D ivid e n d ) / ( Ave r a g e s ha r e p r ic e ) x 10 0
3 . Bo o k Va lue p e r s ha r e BV p e r s ha r e = ( Ne t w o r t h) / ( No. o f e quit y s ha r e s )
4 . Ma r ke t P r ic e p e r s ha r e M P p e r s ha r e = P E R a t io x E PS or M P p e r s ha r e = ( Op e n in g p r ic e + Clo s in g P r ic e ) / 2
I I . Po in t o f vie w
1. R e t ur n o n E quit y ( R O E ) R O E = ( PAT - P r e f . D ivid e n d ) / ( Ne t Wo r t h)
2 . E a r n in g p e r s ha r e ( E PS ) E PS = ( PAT - P r e f . D ivid e n d ) / ( No. o f o r d in a r y s ha r e s o ut s t a n d in g )
3 . D ivid e n d p e r s ha r e ( D PS ) D PS = ( To t a l D ivid e n d ) / ( No. o f E quit y s ha r e s )
I I I . Ba s e d o n As s e t s / I n ve s t m e n t s
1. R e t ur n o n Ca p it a l E m p loy e d /
R O CE = w he r e , Ca p it a l E m p loy e d = To t a l As s e t s - Cur r e n t L ia b ilit ie s
R e t ur n o n I n ve s t m e n t
2 . R e t ur n o n As s e t ( R OA) R OA = ( Ne t p r o f it a f t e r t a xe s ) / ( Ave r a g e To t a l As s e t s )
I V. Ba s e d o n S a le s
1. G r o s s P r o f it R a t io G P R = ( G r o s s P r o f it ) / ( S a le s ) x 10 0
2 . Op e r a t in g P r o f it R a t io O P R = ( Op e r a t in g P r o f it ) / ( S a le s ) x 10 0 W he r e , O P = S a le s ? Co s t o f S a le s
3 . Ne t P r o f it R a t io NP R = ( Ne t P r o f it ) / ( S a le s ) x 10 0
E . Ac t ivit y R a t io s
1. Ca p it a l Tur n o ve r R a t io CT R = ( S a le s ) / ( Ca p it a l E m p loy e d )
2 . F ixe d As s e t s Tur n o ve r R a t io FAT R = ( S a le s ) / ( F ixe d As s e t s )
3 . Wo r kin g c a p it a l T / o R a t io W CT R = ( S a le s ) / Wo r kin g Ca p it a l
3 .a I n ve n t o r y Tur n o ve r R a t io I T R = ( Co s t o f g o o d s s o ld ) / ( Avg I n ve n t o r y )
3 .b D e b t o r s Tur n o ve r R a t io D T R = ( Cr e d it S a le s ) / ( Ave r a g e Ac c o un t s R e c e iva ble s )
33
3 .b Cr e d it o r s Tur n o ve r R a t io CT R = ( Cr e d it Pur c ha s e s ) / ( Ave r a g e Ac c o un t s Pa y a ble s )