Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • Statistical Indices For Assessment of Barrage/canal Performance

    Uploaded by

    shafique Ahmed
    14 views3 pages
    The document discusses evaluating water supply and demand data from three barrages in Pakistan to assess irrigation system performance. Key metrics like reliability, delivery to entitlement ratio, and consistency are calculated using the given formulas. The results are summarized in tables and graphs. An analysis of the Sukkur barrage canal system is provided based on evaluating these metrics and visualizations over multiple years.

    Original Description:

    chapter

    Original Title

    Chapter7_PerformanceAnalysis

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    The document discusses evaluating water supply and demand data from three barrages in Pakistan to assess irrigation system performance. Key metrics like reliability, delivery to entitlement ratio, and consistency are calculated using the given formulas. The results are summarized in tables and graphs. An analysis of the Sukkur barrage canal system is provided based on evaluating these metrics and visualizations over multiple years.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    Download as pdf or txt
    14 views3 pages

    Statistical Indices For Assessment of Barrage/canal Performance

    Uploaded by

    shafique Ahmed
    The document discusses evaluating water supply and demand data from three barrages in Pakistan to assess irrigation system performance. Key metrics like reliability, delivery to entitlement ratio, and consistency are calculated using the given formulas. The results are summarized in tables and graphs. An analysis of the Sukkur barrage canal system is provided based on evaluating these metrics and visualizations over multiple years.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    Download as pdf or txt
    of 3

    Statistical indices for assessment of barrage/canal performance

    Metrics and graphic representations can help to better understand system behavior, Identify

    opportunities for management interventions, and direct the system trajectory towards

    desired levels of performance. In following questions you will apply metrics and graphics

    to study the irrigation system for Sindh, Pakistan.

    Q # 1 Water demand and supply data for the three Barrages (Guddu, Sukkur and Kotri) for
    Rabi 2012-2013 is given in (Data/Q1). Evaluate the data provided to answer the following
    questions:

    a) Evaluate the water supply data for each barrage against the demand values provided
    and record the years with water demand deficit (Write your answers in the table 1).
    b) What was the severity of each deficit observed?

    Table 1

    Barrage Year Demand Deficit (MAF/yr) Severity =


    Deficit/Demand

    c) Evaluate the data to obtain Reliability at each Barrage.


    Use the following formulas to obtain the values (Write the values obtained in Table 2)

    a) Reliability = 1- p(F) where, p(F) is the probability of failure/demand deficit

    Table 2
    Performance Guddu Barrage Sukkur Kotri Barrage
    Metrics Barrage
    Reliability

    d) By analyzing table-1 and table-2, write a summary of your assessment for the

    Sukkur canal system.

    102
    Q # 2 for the Sukkur barrage canal system (Data/Q4/flow.csv) calculate:
    Note: You have to complete the script in Q4 folder (Data/Q2/Q2.py) to get the answers.

    a) Delivery to entitlement ratio [Daily]

    b) Canal entitlement compliance [Annual]

    Note: This metric quantifies the fraction at which the aggregate or total entitlement
    (allocation) for a season for a canal was fulfilled.

    c) Canal supply consistency [Annual]

    Note: The canal supply consistency, ui, is useful to get a measure of predictability
    for a canal while accounting for systemic factors that may make serving a specific
    entitlement challenging. Consider a case, where a canal is only delivered 80% of
    its stated entitlement. If it is done so consistently throughout the season, then the ui
    will have a small value
    (and consistency will be high). High consistency gives a level of predictability for
    water users and allows for better planning.

    d) Canal Supply Reliability [Annual].

    T = Annual

    Note: This is defined as the likelihood of receiving the allocated water entitlement
    during an irrigation turn.

    103
    Q # 3 Create the following graphs and provide your assessment of the Sukkur barrage canal
    system.
    Note: You have to complete the script in Q2 folder (Data/Q2/Q2.py) to get answer

    a) Plot delivery to entitlement ratio v/s time

    b) Box plot for delivery and entitlement for each year.

    c) Bar plot for canal entitlement compliance ,canal reliability, canal supply

    consistency v/s years

    d) By analyzing metrics and figures, write a summary of your assessment for the

    Sukkur canal system.

    104

    You might also like