Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CH-6-Efficient Capital Markets
CH-6-Efficient Capital Markets
An efficient capital market is one in which the prices of all securities quickly and fully reflect all
available relevant information about the securities. The efficient markets have symmetric
information which means there is no gap in information flow among the investors in the market.
Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH):
Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH) states that a market is efficient if security prices
immediately and fully reflect all available relevant information. Efficient means
informational efficiency, not operationally efficient. Operational efficiency deals with the
cost of transferring funds. If the market fully reflects information, the knowledge that
information would not allow anyone to profit from it because stock prices already
incorporate the information.
Implication of Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH):
The efficient market hypothesis (EMH) has implications for investors and for firms:
1. In an efficient market information is reflected in prices immediately, investors should
only expect to obtain a normal rate of return. Because they take time to realize the
news and thus fails to earn any abnormal return. So awareness of information when it
is released does an investor no good. The price adjusts before the investor has time to
trade on it.
2. Firms should expect to receive fair value for securities that they sell. Fair means that
the price they receive from issuing securities is the present value. Thus, valuable
financing opportunities that arise from fooling investors are unavailable in efficient
capital markets.
Condition of Efficient Market:
There are several reasons why one would expect capital markets to be efficient as
follows:
1. The foremost being that there are a large number of independent, profit-maximizing
investors engaged in the analysis and valuation of securities.
2. A second assumption is that new information comes to the market in a random
fashion.
3. The third assumption is that the numerous profitmaximizing investors will adjust
security prices rapidly to reflect this new information. Thus, price changes would be
independent and random.
4. Finally, because stock prices reflect all information, one would expect prevailing
prices to reflect “true” current value.
There are three pillars, any one of which will lead to efficiency:
1. Rationality
2. Independent deviations from rationality, and
3. Arbitrage.
1. Rationality:
In an efficient market all investors should be rational. When new information is released
in the marketplace, all investors will adjust their estimates of stock prices in a rational
way.
Example: Suppose, at present FCC’s stock price is Tk.40 per share. Now investors will
use the information in FCC’s press release, in conjunction with existing information
about the firm, to determine the NPV of FCC’s new venture. If the information in the
press release implies that the NPV of the venture is Tk.10 million and there are 2 million
shares, investors will calculate the NPV equal tk.5 per share ( 10 million ÷ 2 million =
Tk.5)
Now, the price of FCC’s stock is Tk.(40+5) = tk.45 per share.
As a rational investor,
Seller: A seller would sell the share of FCC only at a price of at least Tk.45, not less than
Tk.45
Buyer: A buyer would now be willing to pay up to Tk.45 for FCC’s share not more than
Tk.45.
2. Independent deviations from rationality:
Suppose that FCC’s press release is not all that clear. How many new cameras are likely
to be sold? At what price? What is the likely cost per camera? Will other camera
companies be able to develop competing products? How long will this likely take? If
these and other questions cannot be answered easily, it will be difficult to estimate NPV
With so many unanswered questions, many investors may not be thinking clearly. Some
investors predict that the product will have huge demand as it is a new product and
believing in sales projections well above than rational. Thus they would overpay for new
shares. And if they needed to sell shares, they would sell it only at a high price.
If these individuals dominate the market, the stock price would likely rise beyond what
market efficiency would predict. On the other hand, some investors react to new
information in a pessimistic manner. Thus they would prefer to pay less than rational
level for the new share.
We see that an efficient market consists of not only rational investors but also irrational
investors having optimistic and pessimistic attitudes.
3. Arbitrage:
A world with two types of individuals:
a) The irrational amateurs and
b) The rational professionals.
The amateurs get caught up in their emotions, sometimes believing irrationally that a
stock is undervalued and at other times believing the stock is overvalued. Because they
are not clear about the information. Thus, they would tend to carry stocks either above or
below their efficient prices.
But in the case of professional individuals, they go about their business methodically and
rationally. They study companies thoroughly, they evaluate the evidence objectively, they
estimate stock prices coldly and clearly, and they act accordingly. If a stock is
underpriced, they would buy it. If it is overpriced, they would sell it. And their
confidence would likely be greater than that of the irrational amateurs. Rational
professionals would be willing to rearrange their entire portfolio in search of a profit
through arbitraging where they generates profit from the simultaneous purchase and sale
of different, but substitute, securities. If the arbitrage of professionals dominates the
speculation of amateurs, markets would still be efficient.
Types of Efficient Market:
The notion that stock prices already reflect all available information is referred to as the
efficient market hypothesis (EMH). It is common to distinguish among three versions of
the EMH: (1) the weak, (2) semi-strong, and (3) strong forms. These versions differ by
their treatment of what is meant by “all available information.”
1. The Weak-form of Efficient Market:
The weak-form hypothesis asserts that stock prices already reflect all information that can
be derived from studying past market trading data including the historical sequence of
prices, price changes, and any volume information. It does not use any other information,
such as earnings, forecasts, merger announcements, or money supply figures. A capital
market is said to be weakly efficient, or to satisfy weak form efficiency, if it fully
incorporates the information in past stock prices. The implication is that there should be
no relationship between past price changes and future price changes. Therefore, any
trading rule that uses past market data alone should be of little value.
Sell
Price
Price Movement Sell
Buy
0 Buy Time
AAAA
Strong Form
All information relevant to the stock
Weak Form
Evidence is the base through which we can measure different types of efficient market.
****Thank You****