Assessment of The Macroskills: Pre-Competency Checklist
Assessment of The Macroskills: Pre-Competency Checklist
ASSESSMENT OF THE
MACROSKILLS
This chapter will introduce to you the different assessment strategies across the different
macro skills.
Learning Resources
The content of this chapter was taken from various resources and the student is advised to visit
these references for further reading:
Language and Literature Assessment: A Comprehensive Guide – Mildred B. Go, Ph.D. and
Ofelia T. Posecion, Ph.D. (2010)
Explore
A. Testing Listening
The four skills of speaking, listening, writing, and reading are seen as interrelated skills
that occur simultaneously in oral or written communication. Tests for each skill may involve
not only one but two or more skills, however, this module and the next will attempt to present
distinct classifications of assessments involved in each type in terms of tasks and test formats.
In general, the skill of listening may be tested in two ways: through sound discrimination
and listening comprehension. (Harris, 1969)
1. Sound Discrimination
For beginners of language learning, it is important that they are able to distinguish the
sounds of the language clearly to help them understand the message they hear. In English for
example, there are several sounds that are phonetically different. Words that are same except
for one sound may cause confusion to the listener who cannot discriminate these different
sounds. A teacher who instructs his/her students to bring a ‘mop’ the nest day find a ‘map’
instead, if the sound [o] instead of [a] was heard by the student.
A common task for students in testing auditory discrimination is distinguishing sounds
in minimal pairs. For beginning level groups, these are often formulated in selection test types
where the examinee identifies the different sounds in a group of similar sounds except one.
Examples:
I. BEGINNER
a. VOWEL SOUND
1) Directions: Write YES if the two words heard in each pair
have the same vowel sounds; NO, if they have different
sounds.
1. meat – met
2. still – steel
3. draw – drew
4. green – grin
2) Directions: Write the letter of the word that has a different
vowel sound in each group. If all the words sound the same,
write S.
1. a. been b. bean c. bin
2. a. cop b. cap c. cup
3. a. pill b. peel c. feel
4. a. him b. hymn c. hem
5. a. leak b. lick c. like
b. CONSONANT SOUND
Directions: Write YES if the initial consonant sound in each pair
sound the same; NO if they sound different.
1. pill – fill
2. thought – taught
3. best – vest
4. sip – sit
5. cool – call
II. ADVANCED
For advanced level learners, the words may be used in sentences which students will copy.
Another way is asking students to identify from a group of pictures one which is referred to by
the teacher in his/her sentences using words of similar sounds. In this test, students are expected
not only to rely on their listening skills but also on their comprehension and spelling skills.
Directions: On your paper, copy the following pairs of sentences:
1. His cot is small. His cat is small.
2. She bought a fan. She bought a pan.
3. The child drew a lamp. The child drew a lamb.
4. I placed the pin in my pocket. I placed the pen in my pocket.
5. The lady stood in front of the glass. The lady stood in front of
the class.
The same sentences may be accompanied by pictures illustrating them,
from which students will pick the right choice.
2. Listening Comprehension
Tests on listening comprehension also vary according to learner’s proficiency. For the
intermediate group, tasks may consist of responding to requests, answering questions,
following directions, repeating message, etc. Common test types for these tasks are question-
answer, stimulus-response, and listen-repeat.
Examples:
I. BEGINNER
a. FOLLOWING DIRECTIONS
Direction: Do the following actions:
1. Erase the writings on the board and sit down after.
2. Face the student behind you and shake his/her hand.
3. Open the door and the window nearest to it.
4. Stand in front and place both hands on the table.
5. Take your bag and hold it with your left hand.
b. ANSWERING QUESTIONS
Direction: Answer the following questions:
1. What are your parents’ occupations?
2. How long have you been stating in your current address?
3. Why did you choose to study in this school?
4. What do you often do during your free time?
5. Where would you want to travel, given the chance?
II. ADVANCED
Direction: Listen to the conversation between Joanna and Kyle in
school. Circle the letter of the answer that best completes the sentence
based on the conversation.
(Taped transcript)
Joanna: Hi Kyle! Have you written your essay in English 101?
Kyle: Not yet. I had to attend the choir’s rehearsal last week.
Joanna: Ah, yes. I heard you are competing in Malaysia next
month.
Kyle: Right. But I have been missing some classes because of it.
Joanna: You could probably ask our teachers for some make-up
assignments.
Kyle: I’m planning to, this week. I’m going to the library now to
write my essay.
Joanna: Good luck! See you in class.
In stories, alien creatures have visited the Earth for thousands of years. The
ancient Greeks and Romans told tales of gods who visited the Earth from the
heaves and who possessed exceptional powers. Although science has proven that
these tales are mythical, people have reported and continue to report seeing
unidentified flying objects (UFOs) and extraterrestrial creatures who come to the
Earth from outer space.
Little evidence exists of most UFOs sightings except for the testimony of the
witnesses, and without physical evidence, these people cannot prove that their
experiences are true. However, a few stories are more convincing. One such event
happened on July 5, 1947, near Roswell, Mexico, USA.
On July 5, 1947, Dr. Holden, a professor at Texas Tech University, and some
of his students were searching for archeological sites when they found a crash site.
He reported the site and bodies of alien creatures. Major Easley who was stationed
at the Roswell Army Field in 1947, arrived at the crash site with other military
personnel. He immediately cordoned off the area around the craft while it was
checked for radiation. Once he knew that there was no danger, photographers took
close-up pictures, and the military personnel questioned Dr. Holden and his
students about what they had seen and then took them to the air base for further
interrogation. Easley instructed them that because the event could threaten national
security, they must not repeat the findings.
Military witnesses at the site stated that the craft was about seven meters and
heel-shaped with scalloped edges at the back and rounded nose. The impact had
torn the front, so some of the interior could be seen. They described the five dead
bodies as slender and approximately 1 to 1.5 meters tall with very large heads and
long , thin arms, definitely not human. The facial features were human-like, but the
eyes were much larger than a human’s and skulls were covered with fuzz, not hair.
Those at the crash knew the bodies were not human and later told the other officers
and family members that they had seen creatures.
The bodies were out in bags and taken by ambulance to the military base. At
night they were taken to Washington, D.C., so that top government officials could
see the bodies. The craft was sent to Wright Field in Ohio, USA where the army
could study the wreckage. To date, there is no reliable report of an attempted
preliminary autopsy at the military base and no report on the craft.
(To learn more about the Roswell Incident, visit www.iufomrc.com)
From “Close Encounter of a Word Kind,”
English Teaching Forum, Vol. 37,
Number 4 (Oct-Dec 1999), 37.
A. Testing Speaking
Some language teachers consider testing the speaking and writing skills of the students
easier to evaluate that testing their listening and reading skills. The spoken and written skills
of learners are directly and immediately manifested, thus a teacher could tell off hand if they
are proficient or not in the language.
On the other hand, there are language specialists who believe that is more difficult to
assess the students’ productive skills with precision because of the simultaneous use of
different language abilities in speaking and writing. Either four or five components are
recognized as part of the speaking/writing process.
Regardless of its simplicity or complexity of evaluation, the construction of tests for the
productive skills is as varied as that of the receptive skills in terms of levels, types, and formats.
Speaking here does not refer to the eloquence of delivering a prepared speech but to
one’s ability to carry out a conversation using the language learned effortlessly.
In assessing the spoken ability of learners, several components have to be considered:
pronunciation, grammar, word choice, fluency. Often, these are the criteria used for evaluating
a person’s oral communication skill. Content and organization are not given as much emphasis
as the first four (Harris, 1969).
1. Testing Pronunciation
There are no fixed criteria for judging ‘good or bad’ pronunciation. Traditionally, correct
pronunciation is measured by the accuracy of imitating a native speakers’ way of pronouncing
words. To speak English correctly, one has to speak either the American or British way.
With the advent of the communicative approach of teaching/learning language, the
emphasis has shifted from accuracy to clarity/comprehensibility. As long as the pronunciation
does not impede the clarity of the message or the listener’s understanding of it, the
pronunciation is considered acceptable. Still, in testing specific sound production, one has to
follow certain standards.
Example:
RECOGNITION OF SIMILAR SOUNDS/STRESS
Direction: Form a list of words in each group, read the word that has the same vowel sound as
the guide word’s.
Guide Word
1. beat steak great leave break
2. food mood blood foot stood
3. map mall play said fast
4. saw small plow wow bough
5. let sit end lead grid
2. Testing Grammar
Grammar tests involve correct usage of the verb forms and tenses, nouns and pronouns,
adjective and adverb forms, etc. In oral communication, grammatical usage may be tested
through sentence conversion (from negative to affirmative, statement to question, etc.),
answering questions, expansion (by modification in context (past to present tenses, singular to
plural nouns, nouns to pronouns, etc.).
Examples:
I. SENTENCE CONVERSION
Directions: Read the following statements aloud and change to questions
answerable by yes/no.
1. My friend, Luisa lives in Makati.
2. She and her sisters are renting a condominium along Buendia.
3. They used to go home everyday to Bulacan after school or work.
4. After a few months they realized it was impractical.
5. Now they have more time for study and leisure.
II. ANSWERING QUESTIONS
Directions: Answer the following questions appropriately.
1. What do you like most about your school?
2. How will you describe your classmates in three words? Your
teachers?
3. Why is college education important to you?
4. What are your immediate goals after college?
5. Whom do you consider your closest friend and why?
The following activities must be evaluated using a rubric like the example
below:
Holistic Rubric for a Speech Activity
RAW SCORE DESCRIPTIVE SCORE
__________ 10 Speaks very fast; the message is very clear which
is highly evident of great comprehension of the
topic or question asked.
__________ 8 Speaks fast; the message is clear which is evident
of good comprehension of the topic or question
being asked.
__________ 6 Speaks moderately fast and the message is clear
enough which is evident of comprehension of the
topic or question being asked.
__________ 4 Speaks slow; part of the message is unclear which
is evident of limited comprehension.
__________ 2 Falters in speaking; the message is totally unclear
which means that no any comprehension is present.
__________ 0 Did not attempt to deliver a speech.
B. Testing Writing
Like in speaking, the teacher’s concern in testing the written skill does not pertain to
specific forms of writing such as creative or technical writing. Ability to write these forms is
later developed after the student has gained mastery of the basic writing skills.
Testing writing is focused primarily on evaluating the students’ ability to express their
ideas in writing taking into consideration its five component parts: Content, form, grammar,
style and mechanics (Harris, 1969).
1. Testing the Content
Content refers to the ideas expressed in the writing. Oneness of general idea must be
observed by the writer. All parts of the composition must relate to one main topic. Test items
focusing on content may include writing specific details, identifying and deleting unrelated
sentences in a paragraph.
Examples:
I. PROVIDEING SPECIFIC DETAILS TO GENERAL IDEAS
Directions: Write 5 specific details related to the given general statements.
1. Traveling to foreign countries is rewarding.
2. The Filipino drama series reflect the country’s cultural practices.
3. Some Filipino cultural traits are negative.
4. My best friend and I are the exact opposites.
5. Life is like a stage.
II. WRITING A GENERAL STATEMENT TO EXPRESS THE MAIN
IDEA OF EACH GROUP OF SENTENCES
Directions: Write a general statement to express the main idea of each
group of sentences.
1. __________________________________________________.
1) He is often absent in class.
2) He seldom recites.
3) He fails most of his quizzes.
4) He seldom passes an assignment or a seatwork.
5) He sometimes cuts classes.
2. __________________________________________________.
1) She is always near when I need her.
2) She remembers the special occasions in my life.
3) She can keep sensitive matters a secret.
4) We like almost the same things.
5) She’s lavish with her praises but candid with her criticisms.
3. Testing Grammar
Grammatical usage is always a part of any language test. A proficient speaker or writer
must have a good command of the grammar of the language he/she is using. A test in grammar
is a test of grammatical forms and syntactic patterns. Grammatical forms refer to the use of
correct parts of speech like the plural and possessive forms of nouns; the case, number and
gender; forms of pronouns; tense forms of the verbs; derivational and comparative forms of
adjectives and adverbs. Syntactic patterns involve the proper combinations of words and their
correct placement in sentences.
Examples:
I. CHANGING THE TENSE OF THE VERB
Direction: Change the forms of the verbs in the parentheses to past.
Soon after her family (leave) for the evening, Carol (start) to think
that her hospital room must be the loneliest place in the world. Nigh time
had (fall), her fears about her illness (be) back, and she (feel)
overwhelming despair as she (lie) there alone.
5. Testing Style
Style pertains to the choice of structures and lexical items to give a particular tone or
flavor to the writing. Choice of structures refers to various ways of expressing sentences. They
may start with the subject, the verb, or the modifiers; they may be expressed in active or passive
voice; they may be simple, compound or complex, etc.
Lexical items involve vocabulary usage. Style in writing, appropriateness, and variety.
The first rule in communication is clarity of ideas. Even in literary or creative writing, the
writer’s goal is to be understood. Next is appropriateness of word to the intended meaning.
Miscommunication can occur for using inexact words. Variety is the third guide. It prevents
monotony and redundancy.
Examples:
I. TESTING VARIETY OF STRUCTURES
Directions: Re-arrange the following sentences according to the directions
given.
1. The contestant was looking anxious when he encountered the theater.
(Begin with ‘When’ and ‘Looking’)
2. The ushers instructed the guests to wait at lobby. (Change to passive
voice)
3. She went home early yesterday. Classes were suspended because of
power outage. (Combine into complex sentence.)
II. TESTING LEXICAL ITEMS
Directions: From the given list, select the appropriate word to substitute
for word ‘beautiful’ in the paragraph. Use each word only once.
I was speechless at the sight of our new home! Everything looked
beautiful. It was beautifully painted with a combination of beige and
yellow. The grounds were enclosed by beautiful white picket fences. The
first thing that caught my attention as I opened the gate was the array of
beautiful flowers lining the pathway: roses, daises, carnations, gladiolas,
etc. There was a small veranda in front with a beautiful swing on the left
and a coffee table with two chairs on the right. As I opened the beautiful
carved wooden door, the brightly lighted living room greeted me with its
beautiful chandelier hanging at the center the walls were all made of glass
covered with beautiful white lace and flowery silk curtains. All the other
rooms in the house, from the kitchen to the bed rooms were furnished with
beautiful furniture and beautiful wall decorations. The house looked like
a showcase from a home magazine!
(attractive, cozy, marvelous, intricate, freshly, arresting, expensive, artistic, sturdy, colorful)
6. Testing Mechanics
The mechanics of writing refers to the proper use of graphic symbols such as
punctuation, capitalization, and abbreviation. Certain rules govern the use of these graphic
symbols. Since they are important in written communication, student must gain mastery in
suing these symbols by following the rules. A complete handbook on the mechanics of writing
is available in the library.
Examples:
I. TESTING PUNCTUATIONS
Directions: Insert in the parentheses provided the correct punctuation
marks.
When ( ) Stanley Jones ( ) well ( ) known missionary to India ( )
had the opportunity to meet with Mahatma Gandhi, he asked a searching
question of India ( ) s revered leader ( ) ( ) How can Christianity make a
stronger impact on your country ( ) ( ) Gandhi thoughtfully replied that
three things would be required ( ) First ( ) Christians must begin to live
more like Jesus ( ) Second ( ) the Christian faith should be presented
without any adulteration ( ) Third ( ) Christians should emphasize love (
) which is at the heart of the gospel
()
II. TESTING ABBREVIATIONS AND CAPITALIZATIONS
1. The 4,000-mile-long great wall of china was built to keep out invaders
from the north. The first wall was constructed by shi Huangdi, the first
emperor of china, who lived between 259 and 210 before christ. But
in anno domini 1644 the great manchus broke through the great wall
and overran china.
2. As soon as she earned her master of science degree in mathematics,
my friend liza, applied for scholarship at the Massachusetts institute
of technology where after three years of rigorous study and hardwork,
she finished her doctor of philosophy degree in mathematics. How she
is visiting lecturer at the university of California los angeles and a
consultant of a trading company in Washington, district of Columbia.
Discussion Board
1. As a language teacher, why do think we have to assess our students’
macro skills?
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
Create tasks intended for the assessment of the macro skills. Provide Rubrics if
necessary
1. Testing Listening
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
2. Testing Reading
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
3. Testing Speaking
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
4. Testing Writing
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________