Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Final Clusters and The Spanish-Speaking Learner: D. R. Powell
Final Clusters and The Spanish-Speaking Learner: D. R. Powell
Spanish-Speaking Learner
D. R. POWELL
Downloaded from http://eltj.oxfordjournals.org/ at University of Bath Library & Learning Centre on November 1, 2011
National University of Tucuman, Argentina
Downloaded from http://eltj.oxfordjournals.org/ at University of Bath Library & Learning Centre on November 1, 2011
with this one. It is unnecessary for me to offer another list here,
partly because Hill's list is reasonably complete, and also because,
final clusters being absent from Spanish, it is not possible to make
a comparison cluster by cluster, nor offer examples of their use in
English and Spanish words.
The following clusters might, however, be added to the above-
mentioned list:
With Two Consonants
/n3/ change (also pronounced /gt/ instinct (also pr. /rjkt/)
/nd 3 /) 2
With Three Consonants
/dst/ midst (also pr. /tst/) /pnl/ shrapnel
/ftn/ often (also pr. /fn/) /sns/ nuisance
/Ibd/ bulbed /tst/ blitzed
/nd6/ thousandth (also pr. /nt6/) 3 /zns/ presence
lounged (also pr. /nd3d/)2 /nts/ instincts (also pr. /gkts/)
With Four Consonants
/Ikts/ mulcts /nd0s/ thousandths (also pr.
/ntBs/ 3
/Itst/ waltzed (also pr. /Ist/) /stld/ pestled (also pr. /sld/)
/mznd/ crimsoned /znd9/ thousandth (also pr.
/zntB/)
/ndld/ handled /Qkts/ instincts (also pr. /gts/)
With Five Consonants
/znd9s/ thousandths (also pr. /zntBs/)
Other readers may have come across still further clusters which
could profitably be added to the list. As intimated in an earlier
ll
Final Ousters in English", E.L.T., XVII, 4, July 1963, pp. 167-72.
2
Where alveolar /d/ disappears after alveolar ,'n/. Cf. footnote 6 of L. A.
Hill's article. I have not come across written justification for including /Ij/
and /13d/ as English final clusters to be used as alternative forms of /ICI3/ and
/Id3d/, although it is tempting to include them in order to complete the
picture. It would appear to be a general tendency to eliminate the second of a
sequence of two alveolar consonants when the first is either /I/ or /n/: hands,
/h<cn(d)z/; builds, /bil(d)z/.
3
Tbe inclusion of /znd9/, /znt9/, /zndBs/ and /zntBs/ makes the listing of
/nd9/, /nt9/, /nd9>/ and /nt9s/ superfluous. /nd8/ and /nd9s/ are nevertheless
included here for the sake of completeness, since some of them already
appear in L. A. Hill's list.
Final Clutters and the Spanish-Speaking Learner 19
Downloaded from http://eltj.oxfordjournals.org/ at University of Bath Library & Learning Centre on November 1, 2011
/d3/ and /tj/ may be regarded as single consonants—and that is
probably how most practising teachers treat them—in which case
they would not be included at all as clusters, jd^dj and /tft/ would
figure among two-consonant clusters rather than three-consonant
clusters, and so on. This, however, is a theoretical point rather
than a practical one. Provided the teacher is consistent in his
classification, he need not make an issue of it, and there would
certainly be no point in bothering the pupils with it.
Alternative pronunciations need not be taught, although their
existence may be pointed out to advantage. For instance, only one
pronunciation of width need be taught: /wid9/ or /wit9/, the former
bearing a greater resemblance to the spelling of the word (see next
paragraph). In this particular case the cluster /t0/ would still have
to be taught for such a word as eighth /eitG/. Obviously prior
knowledge and usage of one form or other by a pupil should be
taken into account. Whatever pronunciation the teacher may use,
he would hardly be justified in correcting a pupil who is already
familiar with an acceptable alternative pronunciation.
With the exception referred to in the next paragraph, it would
seem advisable, on the whole, to teach the form that presents
greater similarity to the ordinary orthography of the word, since,
whether we like it or not, students are strongly influenced by
spelling. Given the choice, the pupil will generally take the course
just suggested.
As L. A. Hill points out (see paragraph 3 of his article), some
clusters may be dissolved by the insertion of the 'neutral' vowel
(and also, in some cases, by /i/ and /e/). Furthermore, he suggests
(paragraph 9) that the foreign student may find it easier to avoid
the cluster by inserting the corresponding vowel sound. This is
obviously the case with Spanish-speaking learners. Yet, owing to
the general tendency of these students to insert an incorrect vowel
sound (usually the Spanish equivalent suggested by the spelling), I
find it more convenient to teach the cluster rather than the pro-
nunciation with the vowel.
Spanish lacks final consonant clusters. In fact, final consonants
are rather limited in number, though the frequency of occurrence
of a few of them seems to be fairly high. On the other hand, there
appears to be a general tendency to weaken and drop final con-
sonants. In certain cases this is acceptable practice even in educated
forms of the language. In others, however, it is regarded as regional
or uneducated. But as education—particularly beyond the primary
20 D . R. P o w e l l
Downloaded from http://eltj.oxfordjournals.org/ at University of Bath Library & Learning Centre on November 1, 2011
pronunciation of English final consonants and consonant clusters.
Some of them insist on this to such an extent that it affects their
way of speaking, methodological techniques becoming habitual in
their speech. The techniques referred to include lengthening,
exaggerated aspiration, full voicing (where devoicing would
normally be expected), addition of some shade or other of'/a/,
extra strong breath force, and even ejection.
Although it is necessary to insist on the correct production of
final consonants and consonant clusters, teachers should be
careful not to go to such extremes, at least as normal procedure.
After all, there are ways of making sure that the pupil pronounces
correctly without the teacher using unduly exaggerated pro-
nunciations himself.
A brief consideration of Spanish and English consonant sounds
will be useful. Indeed, by the time the student reaches the present
stage he should have been through all the English (and Spanish)
consonants individually. In any case, the notes in my article on
initial clusters* (supplemented when necessary by reference to the
books listed in footnote 5 of the same article3 might be helpful.
Downloaded from http://eltj.oxfordjournals.org/ at University of Bath Library & Learning Centre on November 1, 2011
consonant when used as part of a cluster and when used in other
contexts. Attention must be paid to these differences in order to
attain a fair degree of accuracy, as well as to simplify matters for
the pupil. •
The following should be borne in mind:
(a) Incomplete plosion: When two plosives come together in a
cluster, only the second is exploded fully. When this is pointed out
to the student he tends to leave out the first plosive altogether,
thereby making no difference between words like cut—cupped.
The method of production must be carefully explained. (Incom-
plete plosion also occurs in Spanish, though not in final position:
apto, acto, etc.). Examples: /bd/, /pt/.
(b) Nasal plosion: When a plosive sound precedes a nasal the
soft palate must be lowered while the organs involved in the
articulation of the plosive are still in contact. Most pupils find this
difficult at first. Examples: /dn/, /tn/.
(c) Lateral plosion: When an alveolar plosive consonant is
followed by /I/, one or both sides of the tongue must be lowered
while the tip of the tongue is still pressed against the teeth-ridge.
This is achieved successfully by most Spanish-speaking students in
medial position, since /tl/ exists medially in Spanish, but not
finally. Examples: /kl/, /dl/.
(d) Dental articulation of /t/ and /d/ when followed by /8/. This
may not be an obstacle with some (since Spanish /t/ and /d/ are
dental), but the student who is conscious of the fact that English /t/
and /d/ are usually alveolar and not dental as in Spanish will need
to be warned about the difference.
(e) Dark /I/ ([+]) is foreign to Spanish and must therefore be
taught. Many students will tend to hear, and consequently
pronounce, /ul/ or /u:l/ instead of [I]. Examples: /gl/, /si/.
(/) Clusters made up of a succession of fricative sounds prove
difficult for most learners and require careful practice. Examples:
/fe/, /fes/.
(g) The devoicing of final 'voiced' plosives and fricatives when
followed by a pause or a voiceless sound.
(A) The fact that typically aspirated sounds (voiceless plosives)
are less aspirated finally.
(/) The fact that consonants generally are weaker in final position
(i.e. produced with less breath force than when found in other
positions').
22 D. R. P o w e l l
Downloaded from http://eltj.oxfordjournals.org/ at University of Bath Library & Learning Centre on November 1, 2011
(i) C +/s/ or /z/2 (the regular plural of nouns, the third person
singular of verbs in the present tense, the possessive case,
certain contracted forms);
(ii) C +/t/ or /d/ (the past tense and past participle of regular
verbs);
(3) Move on to less usual type (b) clusters, and add type (a)
sequences;
(4) Three-, four- andfive-memberclusters may be dealt with in
the same order.
Obviously the teacher will have to decide for himself which
clusters to include and which to leave out, and for this the main
consideration will be the frequency of occurrence in speech and, to
a certain extent, the amount of difficulty for his pupils. He need
not wait until the list of two-member sequences has been exhausted
before beginning with longer ones. Some of the longer clusters are
more useful than certain two-member ones. For instance, /In/ and
/0I/ are less likely to be required than /Idz/ and /gklz/.
It hardly needs to be mentioned that clusters are not to be
taught on their own, but in actual words, or at least with an initial
vowel sound. In choosing his words the teacher should aim at
finding the shortest possible words to begin with, with as few
strange or difficult sounds as possible, so that the learner may be
able to concentrate all his efforts on the cluster itself.
Finally, the stages suggested towards the end of my article on
initial clusters should be kept in view in dealing withfinalclusters.
Briefly they are as follows: (a) recognition; (b) production in
isolated words (whether meaningful or otherwise); (c) production
in controlled contexts (short phrases and sentences); (d) perform-
ance in actual speech.3
1
See L. A. Hill's article, paragraph 4. Some clusters belong to both types,
e.g. /ks/ box, books; /kt/ act, rocked.
S
C stands for any consonant sound capable of being combined with one of
the sounds indicated.
'Some useful lists of words (both meaningful and meaningless) and exercises
for practising some of the commoner clusters will be found in Drills and Tests
in English Sounds by L. A. Hill (Longmans, 1961). They will be found useful
also as a starting-point for devising further exercises.