Oriental Philosophy
Oriental Philosophy
-The Division in our Society is only caused with once profession and not by birth,
the creator made man equal but not similar. Every individual is born with attribute
and nature which determines his actions and profession
- If one abandons his "verna" he disturbs the peace in the society. It is better to
do one’s own duty badly than that of another well.
2. Brahmanas-is the starting point of the Indian Philosophy. Without the knowledge
Brahmanas one cannot understand Indian Religion and Philosophy. Each Samhitas contains
one or more Brahmanas. It is an elaboration of the complicated ritualism of the Vedas.
It portrays the significance and importance of the performance of the rituals and
the way they are performed.
3. Aranyakas- means "a text composed or read in the calmness in the forest". Gives a
a preliminary training to those who aspire spiritual knowledge and want relief from
the cycle of life and death. This marks the transition from ritualism to philosophical
thinking.
(The mantra and the brahmans are called the KARMAKANDA of the Vedas as they both deal
with ritualistic performance. The aranyakas and the upanisads are called the
Jnyanakanda of the Vedas as they are the portions that concern with knowledge.)
Sutras- these are considered as the connecting link between the Vedic and Post Vedic
Period. It provides information of the social, economic and religous aspect of the
Indian Culture. The significant works of the Sutra Literature are called /VEDANGAS/.
Division of Vedangas:
a. Siksa or Phonetics
b. Kalpa or Ritual Instruction
c. Vyakarana or Grammar
d. Nirukta or Etymology
e. Chhanda or Poetic Meters
f. Jyotish or Astrology and Astronomy
- The reading of the Sutras helps or makes the understanding of the Vedas clear, easy
and fruit bearing.
-The Ancient Seers arranged the whole Vedic Literature with the 4 Stages of Life.
-What can we infer from this:
The pre-UPANISHADIC Philosophers by observing nature was able to establish the principle
of causality and believed in the existence which is associated to each of these
phenomenon, without giving it form. But later where given an anthromorphic form. Then
lead to the monotheistic explanation of the cosmos, that there must be a God that created all
other gods. Which led ultimately to the Brahman (infinite, eternal, unitary principle)
which is the ultimate reality.
-Indian Philosophy (Darshana, view or direct experience) is divided int two pure reason and
practice.
-Ordthodox (Astika) Acknowledge Veda
Are listed in the order of complexity Vedanta as the highest Truth.
a. Nyaya (Realism)
b. Vaisesika (Pluralism)
c. Samkhya (Rationalism)
d. Yoga (Practicism)
e. Purva Mimamsa (Ritualism)
f. Vedanta/Uttara Mimamsa (Inquirism)
-Heterdox (Nastika)
a. Charvaka (Materialism)
b. Jainism (Restrainism)
c. Buddhism (Nominalism)
1. Object of Knowledge
a. Soul j. Results
b. Suffering k. Rebirth
c. Freedom from Suffering l. Mental defects
d. The Body
e. The Five Senses
f. The Object of the Senses
g. Cognition
h. Mind
i. Activity
2. Ways to Validate Knowledge
a. Valid Sources
i. Direct Perception
ii. Inference
iii. Comparison
iv. Testimony
b. Invalid Sources
i. Memory
ii. Doubt
iii. Erroneous Perception
iv. Hypothetical Argument
- 9 Substance
o Earth
o Water
o Fire
o Air
o Space
o Time
o Direction
o Soul
o Mind
- 24 Qualities
o Color
o Taste
o Smell
o Touch
o Sound
o Number
o Uniqueness
- Practical Teaching
o Mind turn one’s bliss into misery by its projection. So, Samkhya emphasizes to
polishing the mind to filter the right knowledge
o Discourages external rituals because people perform without understanding of its
significance.
o Reminds to examine one’s thinking process to purify and develop proper attitude
towards objects of the senses to minimize the attachment and aversions
o Advises to not run away from the world but have perfect mental control to stay in
control during ups and downs of life.
- Similarity
o Both accepts three valid sources of knowledge—Direct perception, inference, and
testimony
o Both accepts the dualist theory of Purusha and Prakriti
o Both accepts that ignorance is the cause of suffering
o Both emphasizes polishing and controlling the mind
o Both uses rational and practical approach
- The Creation of the World:
o The root cause of the entire universe is Prakriti not Purusha
o It is a journey of Consciousness (Purusha) into the matter (Prakriti)
o Unmanifest Prakriti is the limitless potential consisting of three fundamental forces
called the Guna--Sattva, Rajas, Tamas--in the equilibrium.
o The effective contact between the Purusha and the Prakrit disturbs the balance of the
Gunas in Prakriti and sets in motion the process of evolution, and creation of the
world
- The Practices
o Study and understand the Philosophy and scriptures
o Reflect on the gained knowledge
o Pracrtice Ashtanga Yoga with consistency, reverence and nonattachment for
longtime.
- Mimamsa Practices
o All the Vedic duties and rituals
o Daily duties, ceremonial and rituals of Hindus
o The legal matter such as inheritance, property rights, adoption etc. has close
relationship with Indian Law.
- Vedanta Philosophy
o Vedanta means “end of knowledge
o Vedanta clarify and reconcile the apparent contradictions in the teachings of
Upanishads
o Author: Sage Badarayana
o The purpose is to make the interpretation of the Brahmas and the Upanishads
- Basics
o Brahma Sutra primarily deals about Brahman (God, the Absolute). It provides
coherent philosophy about Brahman for the apparently conflicting statements in the
Upanisads
o Brahma Sutra is also known as the Vedanta Sutra, Uttara Mimamsa
o Brahma Sutra in this text is so iconic, that different master interpreted it differently
which created over several sub-schools.
- Three Schools
o Advaita /adwet/ (Monism/Non-Duality)—Sankara
Brahma Sutra (logical text)
10 Major Upanishads
Bhagvad Gati (practical text)
o Visistadvaita /vivishadwet/ (Qualified Monism/Non-Duality)—Ramanuja
o Dvaita /dwet/ (Dualism/Duality)—Madhva
- Vedanta on Creation
o Vedanta schools hold that without the guidance of conscious principle, unconscious
matter could not produce this world, which adheres to certain rules and laws. It
discards the theory of creation of Nyaya, Vaisesika, Samkhya, and Yoga
o It says Brahman is both the material and the efficient cause for this world. From
Brahman this world came into existence, in whom it inheres and to whom it return
at the end of a cycle of creation
o Brahman evolves himself into ether, air, fire, water, earth, and other by Will and
associated with every stage of the creation up to the last
o Since it is Brahman that ahs evolved into this world, this world is non-different from
than Brahman
- Vedanta on Creator
o Vedanta Schools agrees on the existence of God. But it says that the existence of God
cannot be proved or known by reasoning and logic alone
o God’s Existence can be established only through the direct experience or by
testimony. Reasoning ism however, necessary to justify fath, and to understand the
real teaching and to remove all doubts.
o Mainly two names are used for God:
Brahman- impersonal and transcendent aspect of the Supreme
Isvara- the ultimate reality that rules the world, represented as personal God.
- Practice
o Listening and Understanding Spiritual Knowledge (Sarvana)
Focus on understanding the essential nature of the self
o Reflecting on gained knowledge and establishing the firmness of mind (Manana)
Repeatedly analyzing the concept
o Contemplate and Meditate on the Self (Nididhyasana)
Applying the truth in daily life and must maintain a life-style in which true
consciousness is maintained
OM is the bow, Individual Self is the arrow, and Brahman is the target, so one should shoot
carefully, so that one should get fully absorbed in the Brahman-Consciousness.
NASTIKA SCHOOLS
Charvaka School
o The Materialist School—does not believes in anything that is immaterial
o Most ridiculed school
o Three Philosophical Issues of Indian Philosophy
The Law of Karma—as long as the person is alive he performs action, and
these actions are either good or bad. In order, to reap the fruits of his actions
of his present or past life the person has to again take birth in order to enjoy
the pleasure or suffering which is due to his past wrong doings.
The cycle of birth and death
Liberation and release from the cycle of birth and death
o It is only the Charvaka that is not concern with these problems
Rejecting the concept of soul, after life, and liberation
o Did not have any successor
- The Origin
o Its origin is uncertain, the name Charvaka—regarding as eastern epicureanism or
hedonism
o Emerged as a protest movement against the extreme ritualism and dogmatism of the
priestly class and to the doctrines which are no use to the normal man
o The History of the Indian Materialism: four stages of development
Stage of Opposition—knowledge in all forms and the authority of the vedas is
called to situation
Stage of Hedonism—the system got some structure perception is recognized
as the source of knowledge and nature as a self-sustaining entity. The theory
of body was accepted. Eat, Drink, Merry for tomorrow we may die.
Spiritualism is added, the self is associated the sense organs and the organs
of thought, probability and inference was accepted in the limited sense
THE BIRTH OF NASTIKA PHILOSOPHY
- The Epistemology
o Perception is the only source of knowledge
Rejects the principle of causality
Inductive and deductive reasoning
- Charvaka Metaphyics
o There are nothing beyond the four elements.
o There is no heaven, no final liberation, nor any soul in another world.
o Why not offer his own father?
- Charvaka Ethics
o They are hedonist
o “Eat, drink, and be merry”
NEGATIVE TAKE ON THE VEDAS AND THE PRIESTLY CASTE
- There four goals of men in the Vedas:
o Dharma—regulating principle guide the individual how to live a moralistic life
o Arta—how to live a comfortable life
o Ghana—satisfaction of desires
o Moksha—liberation from the cycle of birth and death
Jainism Origin
o Shraman Culture one of the Indian Culture
o Was founded by Mahavira the last of the 24 Thirthankars
o Teaching were group into 12 books which are called the Sutrangas
o The sacred text is called Agamas
o Jainism is founded on the teaching of Jin, and the practitioner of Jainism are called
Jain.
o Jain religion does not believe in worshipping an individual. It worships the real
qualities of a soul who has attained the state of ‘Jin’ i.e., who has destroyed the veils
of Karmas on knowledge, intuition and power of soul
- Jainism Philosophy
o The Jain system, like the Buddhist, is non-theistic. It does not acknowledge the
existence of creator of God. Another important feature is that it is pluralistic system.
The souls are many, infinite in number. Moksha is not absorption into the supreme
but the attainment of a perfect, luminous and blissed soul which is without body and
without actions.
o The religious philosophy of Jainism teaches that there are nine truths or realities
(Nav-tattva) They are: (1) soul (jiva) (2) non-soul (ajiva) (3) merit (punya) (4) sin or
demerit (papa) (5) influx of Karma (asrava) (6) stoppage of karmic matter (Samvara)
(7) bondage (bandha) (8) shedding of karmic matter (nirjara) and (9) liberation
(moksha)
- Nine Realities
o Jiva (soul)- the principle of Jiva is a conscious substance which is different in
different individuals. Th number of Jivas (souls) are infinite. The soul is not only the
enjoyer of the fruits of karma, but also the actor, deeply engaged in worldly affairs
and responsible for his act, good or bad. It transmigrates and takes successive births
accor=ding to the nature of stock of its deed. It can attain emancipation (moksha)
from the cycle of birth and death by freeing itself from all that is non-soul (ajiva), by
destroying accumulated karmas and by stopping further influx into it.
o Papa (sin or demerit)- it is called sin or evil, is a major factor in the bondage of jiva.
Injury to and killing of living beings is a heinous sin and results in terrible
punishments
o Asrava (influx of karma)- Asrava denotes the inflow of karmic matter by the soul.
Just as water flows into a boat through a hole, so the karmic matter flows through
asrava into the soul. The nature of activity is Shubha (meritorious) or ashuba
(demeritorious). The principle “like causes produce like results” is accepted as a
determining feature of the Jain doctrine of karma
o Samrava (Stoppage of Karmic Matter)- samvara means stopping, controlling or
ceasing of inflow of karmic matter into the soul, smavara is affected through self-
control (gupti), restrained movement (samti), virtues (dharma), contemplation
(anupreksha), conquest of hardships and monastic conduct.
o Bandha (bondage)- bandha is the union of jiva with pudgala (matter) or soul with
non-soul particles. The matter is determined by five causes, namely wrong belief,
attachment, carelessness, passions, and activity.
o Nirjara (Shedding the Karmic Matter)- nirjara means shedding off, drying up or
destruction. Nirjara is to destroy and burnup accumulated karma.
Take the example of Tank. By stopping the inflow of water into the tank, we arrest
the increase of water in the tank. That is samvara, but there I already some water in
the tank. In order to dry up this water, it may be exposed to the heat of the sun for
some time. This is nirjara.
o Moksha (Liberation)- Moksha is the supreme stage of spiritual attainment when all
causes of bondage having been uprooted, the soul is freed from karmic matter. It is a
stage of peace. Moksha is attained through right faith, right knowledge, and right
conduct.
For the perfecti0n of right conduct, five kinds of vows are recommended:
Non Violence
Truthfulness
Non Stealing
Chastity
No Greed
- Karma Philosophy
o Karma means “that which is being done”
o The whole universe is packed with fine karmic particles. But when these particles get
attracted to the soul and stick to it and bind it through its activity, then only they are
designated by the term karma
Dravya karma- physical karma
Bhava karma- internal or mental karma
o The soul is the doer of both of these karmas. They are mutually related as cause and
effect, just as a seed and a tree.
Cause of Bondage
First the soul is attracted to the soul then bound by it through the
activity of mind, speech and body. (asrava)
The binding of the karmic particles with the soul is due to the
unwholesome inclination, faith, or conviction, non-restrain, lethargy,
and passion. (mithyatva)
Philosophy of Rebirth
The series of soul’s birth has no beginning, it always has its reference
to its previous birth.
As per belied of Jain religion emancipation is defined as, “Just as the oil mill is operated to
separate from the sesamum seeds, churning is undertaken to separate ghee from butter milk,
and fire is used to separate ore from metal, so also the soul attains emancipation penance
through and self-control.”
- Jain Ethics
o Non-Violence: the Jain have laid great emphasis on Ahinsa Vrata. The doctrine of
Ahinsa (Non-Violence) is a cardinal principle of Jain Religion. It is so central in Jain
faith that it may be called the beginning and the end of Jain Religion.
o Anekantavad: the philosophy that believes that reality can be examined in several
standpoints and all can be equally true.
BUDDHISM
1.6 One day, Siddhartha got away from the palace, chanced upon 4 men: old man,
leper, corpse, beggar-monk. Puzzled, decided to look for the meaning of life.
1.7 Became a wandering ascetic for 6 to 7 years, sought hermits and sages.Tried
ascetic denial of body demands, almost starved to death, convinced it was not the
right path.
1.8 Sat under a tree, illumination under the Bodhi Tree.
1.9 Journeyed to the sacred city of Benares, at Sarnath before Benares, preached first
sermon, gathered disciples. For 40 years, proclaimed message
1.11 “Buddha”: The enlightened one. Other names: Sakyamuni: prophetic sage of the
Sakyas. “Tathagata”: perfect one, “he who has fully come through.”
Personality
2.1 combination of rich and responsive human sympathy, patience, strength, gentleness,
good will.
3.3 Brahman: origin and end of all things. “Sat-chit-ananda”: source and embodiment
of Reality, Knowledge and Bliss.
3.8 Karma: the principle that good choices, earnest efforts, good deeds build good
character while bad choices, inertia and evil deeds build bad character.
3.9 Dharma: “the way that man should follow in order to fulfill his true nature and
carry out his moral and social responsibilities.
4.3 Vedas taught as collection of authoritative texts rather than living truths to be
tested.
4.6 Religion straying people away from poignant practical needs, not leading them to
true fulfillment and happiness.
Development of Buddhism
7.1.4 Buddha, not pessimistic, because there is also joy in this life, but this joy is
superficial.
1. Trauma of birth
2. Pathology of sickness
3. Morbidity of decrepitude
4. Phobia of death
5. To be tied to what one abhors
6. To be separated from what one loves
7.1.6 five skandas (body. Senses, ideas, feelings, consciousness) are all painful.
7.1.8 Major hazards of existence: birth, decay, death, and uncertainty with regards to
the things of the world.
7.2.1 Tanha is desire for one’s own private fulfillment at the expense of other forms of
life.
7.2.3 Craving leads not only to suffering here and now but also to further suffering in
the future, in form of rebirth.
7.4. The way to eliminate craving and clinging is the eightfold path.
Eightfold path
8.1.1 To understand the true doctrine, that life is suffering, there is a cause to suffering,
there is an end to suffering, and there is a means to end the suffering.
8.2.2 to have a clear perception of the true doctrine and free oneself from lust, ill will
and cruelty.
9.2 Central teaching of the Buddha: Nothing in this world that does not come within
realm of causal laws Causality explains the arising and passing away of things.
10.2 A thing arises depending upon cause, so when cause is removed, thing ceases to be,
thus momentary.
Doctrine of Karma
1) external stimuli,
2) conscious motives
3) unconscious motives
11.5This is not deterministic: depending on the nature of karma and the circumstances
in which the action is committed, there would be appropriate consequences.
Rebirth or Transmigration
12.3 One who is ignorant of the fact that things are impermanent will cling to the
things of this world, leading to suffering.
12.4.1 Death is not the separation of body and soul but the end of a certain aspect of life
and the beginning of another.
12.10 For the person who has attained enlightenment, has eliminated craving for
existence, this consciousness finds no support in a new psychophysical
personality, and thus he is not reborn.
Doctrine of Nonsubstantiality
13.1 Anatta: atta means atman, anatta thus means “no self”
13.2 Buddha denied soul or self as a spiritual substance but believed in rebirth (like
flame being passed from candle to candle)
Nirvana
14.7 Dependent origination from point of view of relativity is samsara, but from point
of view of reality is Nirvana.
14.8 Beyond logic. All things hang between reality and nothingness: neither absolutely
real nor absolutely unreal. Between 2 extremes: middle path.
attainable in this life, the arhat experiences impressions of senses but detached,
unmoved by them, feels at peace in the midst of distraction & confusion
.
Understands nature of things: impermanence (anicca),
unsatisfactoriness (dukkha), nonsubstantiality (anatta)
7. conservative 7. liberal
Meaning
1.1 “Upanishad” means “sitting near devotedly”
1.4 more than 200 Upanishads (legendary) but only 108 are traditional, and 11 or 12
are considered philosophical.
2.1 Brahman
a. duality (Ramanuja)
b. identity (Samkara)
c. silence, escapes all definitions
2.1.5 All three are correct in that each corresponds to three different stages of the
perception of God:
describable indescribable
2.2 Atman
2.2.1 originally from “an” meaning “to breathe” or “at” meaning “to go”
2.2.4 All creation evolves as gradual uncovering of quintessence originally present and
incapable of modification
2.2.5 The Self, not the ordinary self which lives in ignorance, in mistaking Self for the
body, mind or senses (cf Chandogya Upanishad VIII, 1-3)
2.3.1 “Tat Tvam Asi”: “That thou art” cf. story of Svetaketu
2.3.2 Realization of Brahman: not just a theory of existence, that Brahman is Atman,
but to realize this is to enter into union with Brahman.
2.4.1 lower: knowledge of the Vedas: of the intellect and senses, limited to objective
finite world.
2.4.4 Higher kind of knowledge is freedom from ignorance, limitation, birth and death.
2.6.1 Life after death depends upon moral quality of person which in turn depends
upon his deeds, of past life, of present.
2.6.3 “karma” : deeds in stream of causation: each one being at once effect and cause,
fruit and seed.
2.6.4 If good, to the fathers and gods.
2.7.2 “maya”: power of god or demon to produce illusory effects, change form, or
appear in mask.
2.7.3 Atman: knowing subject within us, unknowable, the sole reality, the metaphysical
unity manifested in all empirical plurality.