Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Q. Describe The Relation Between Government & The Individual Reflected in Civil Disobedience by Thoreau?
Q. Describe The Relation Between Government & The Individual Reflected in Civil Disobedience by Thoreau?
Describe the relation between Government & the Individual reflected in Civil
Disobedience by Thoreau?
Answer:
In the Essay “Civil Disobedience” Thoreau appears as a social rebel and a critic
published under the title “Resistance of American government and society of his
time. ‘Civil Disobedience’ established his reputation in the wider political
world. Thoreau’s political theories were not well known during his own time. They
were usually presented as lectures to small audiences or as articles. In 1849, Civil
Disobedience was to Civil Government”. It is one of the most influential political
tracts ever written by an American.
This essay mainly deals with the relation between the citizen and the state.
It also talks about the nature of the Government, state and the individual. The
essay opens with a paradoxical view. According to Thoreau ‘That government is
best which governs the least’. That means Thoreau is in famous of the absolute
freedom of the individual citizen of a state. This absolute freedom should be the
basis of an ideal from of democracy. Then the government will not interfere with
the activities of the citizens as long as those activities will not clash with the
interest of the members of the society.
According to Thoreau, the government of his day did not come close to this
ideal for two basic reasons: slavery and the Mexican-American war. It is important
to remember that, although Thoreau’s imprisonment was a protest against
slavery, Civil Disobedience was written after the outbreak of the Mexican-
American war and protests both slavery and war.
Civil Disobedience is an analysis of the individual’s relationship to the state
that focuses on why men obey governmental law even when they believed it to
be unjust. But Civil Disobedience is not an essay of abstract theory. It
is Thoreau’s extremely personal response to being imprisoned for breaking the
law. He was arrested for not paying the taxes. One of his aunts paid the taxes and
he was released from the jail the next morning. This one night’s experience led
him to write his most famous essay on “Civil Disobedience”.
According to Thoreau, conscience should be the guiding force of
government or law. He gives the highest importance to conscience and the least
importance to the majority. His whole concept of civil disobedience is based on
the dictates of conscience. The human beings possess this conscience, not the
animals. Since a state consists of human beings, the conscience should be the
guiding force, not majority. Thoreau thinks that the majority in a so-
called democratic state is permitted to rule for long, not because they are most
likely to be in the right, but because they are physically the strongest. Thoreau
says that conscience makes an individual strong and self-reliant. This God gifted
conscience should decide what is just and what unjust, not brute majority. That is
why a man is a man first and secondly a citizen of state.
Thoreau further says that the masses of men serve the state, not mainly as men,
but as machines. They all constitute the army, police, militia, jailors etc. we see
soldiers marching to wars, against their will and conscience. They do not exercise
judgment or moral sense. Yet they are regarded as good citizens. But those who
serve the state with conscience are commonly treated as enemies.
Thus, Thoreau has considered the relation between the state and the
individual at different levels, and has convincingly shown that individual, and
individual conscience should be the basis of a good state.