Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Unit 1 Lesson 3 GEED 10033 Reading in Philippine History Morales Jeremiah
Unit 1 Lesson 3 GEED 10033 Reading in Philippine History Morales Jeremiah
Reading
In
Philippine
History
A. Test of Authenticity
B. Test of Credibility
Similarities and
Persons Differences with
Objectives of Biases of the
Source Involved in the Other
the Event Author
Event Independent
Testimonies
Katipunan and First objective The Magdiwang Santiago V. Its similarity to
the Revolution: of the event is members Alvarez is one of the Revolt of the
Memoirs of a to talk about present in the the loads: The tale of
General the Tejeros eyewitnesses of Bonifacio and the
strengthening of convention are the Tejeros Katipunan is that,
the defenses of Andres conference in each of the
the regions that Bonifacio, March 25, 1897; specific chapters
are still below Jacinto additionally he's in the two books
the Magdiwang. Lumbreras, an active are tackling
It became the Mariano M. member of approximately
primary Alvarez, Pascual Katipunan and what took place in
dialogue earlier Alvarez, Ariston part of the the Tejeros
than Severino Villanueva, Magdiwang conference
de las alas have Mariano C. faction. With especially the
advised a new Trias, Diego regards to that election,
topic to address Mojica, records, it imparting the
about or to Emiliano R. de virtually offers equal targets of
address. Dios, Santiago an affect that the event and
Election of the V. Alvarez, he's biased on finishing of the
brand new Artemio Ricarte, his own narration.
officers for the Santos Nocon, celebration However,
government of Luciano San which is the Santiago V.
the Philippine Miguel, Pablo Magdiwang. In Alvarez’s
Republic have Mojica, his book, testimony in his e-
become the Severino de las specifically book became
second Alas, within the part greater
objective as it andSantiago of Tejeros designated since
turned into Rillo. While in conference he's an
argued via the the Magdalo, narration, he eyewitness and an
contributors; the only narratedthat energetic
two of them members most of the participant of the
insisted that it present in the individuals in Katipunan and
have to be the narration are the long table inside the
primary Baldomero was the occasion, making
intention of the Aguinaldo, Magdiwang, his e book as one
conference to Daniel Tirona, best 3 have of the primary
resolvethe and Cayetano been from the assets. Its
minor issues the Topacio. Mr. Magdalo. differences may
employer has. Antonio additionally, he be seen thru the
third goal Montenegro stated that date of the
turned into to Jose del Rosario Daniel Tirona convention, the
execute the Trining from Magdalo noted members’
election and the Josephine become gift inside the
appointment of Persons persuading and occasion and their
officers fairly mentioned after getting allies in biases. In
through the event to convincing Alvarez’s e-book,
establishing a Magdiwang the alternative it changed into
rule that no Troops Fr. individuals to indicated that the
person have to Cenon aspect with him, Tejeros
question about Villafranca and him being convention befell
the educational Nicolas Portilla- the one who on March 25,
attainment and Magdiwang Fr. disbursed the 1897.
country of Manuel Trias ballotsthen Additionally,
residing of the accompanied by Antonio
appointed using a warning Montenegro’s
officer in from Diego council within the
acertain role. Mojica, a two factions isn't
And ultimately, Magdiwang mentioned. The
Bonifacio member, that ultimate
addressing that the some of the distinction of
the election is ballots have Santiago V.
nulled and void been crammed Alvarez’s bookis
because of the up already. Base that it only
circumstance on that targeted on that
that Daniel situations, he is day of the
Tirona puzzled glaringly biased convention in
him because the to his birthday Tejeros and the 2
appointed party, and following days.
Secretary of the supporting the
indoors. it is one idea that the
of the objectives Magdalo faction
because most of is towards them
his allies have or sabotaging
agreed and left their plans as an
at once with entire because
him of the incidents
regarding Daniel
Tirona which he
narrated in his
memoirs. also,
he narrated that
the Magdalo
and other
elected officers
inside the
Tejeros
convention have
set a assembly
secretly and
have not
acknowledged
what Bonifacio
said before he
left the stated
occasion and
took their
positions,
handiest basing
on the
eyewitnesses
and rumors
Alvarez knew
The Revolt of the One of the The Magdiwang Teodoro Its similarity to
Masses: The objectives of the members Agoncillo being Katipunan and the
Story of occasion present in the the researcher Revolution:
Bonifacio and changed into to Tejeros of this specific Memoirs of a
the Katipunan speak about convention are event, his biases preferred is that,
first what they Andres are constrained each of the
are planning for Bonifacio, because he is unique chapters
the protection Jacinto not one of the in the books are
in their capital Lumbreras, number one tackling about
area that's Mariano M. sources of the what happened
Cavite. however Alvarez, Pascual beyond event. within the Tejeros
Severino de las Alvarez, Ariston He just conference in
sadly, one of the Villanueva, observed particular the
Magdiwang Mariano C. number one and election,
council, Trias, Diego secondary supplying the
countered Mojica, resources to be equal targets of
Jacinto Emiliano R. de able to explain the occasion and
Lumbreras’ Dios, Santiago what passed off ending of the
assertion of the V. Alvarez, in the past. but narration.
main topic, by Artemio Ricarte, him, Teodoro
using Santos Nocon, interviewing Agoncillo’s e-book
pronouncing Luciano San and basing on differs to Santiago
they should first Miguel, Pablo Emilio V. Alvarez’s book
agree what Mojica, Aguinaldo's due to the fact it's
form of Severino de las narration, one miles more of a
authorities to Alas, Teodoro way or the summarization
establish so one Gonzales and other, simplest since he
can take Santiago Rillo. confirmed that got the data from
manage of the While in the he's biased to different primary
entire us of a, Magdalo, the what Emilio and secondary
making it the only members Aguinaldo have assets. The
second present are narrated to the credibility of The
objective of the Baldomero interview. The rise up of the
occasion as Aguinaldo, part wherein hundreds: The
individuals have Daniel Tirona, Agoncillo just Story of Bonifacio
considered Cayetano targeted on and the Katipunan
doing an Topacio and what Bonifacio is not that set up
election of the Antonio felt that time when you
new officers for Montenegro. inside the consider that it's
the authorities Jose del Rosario closing a part of miles taken into
of the Republic the bankruptcy consideration as a
of the gave him away secondary supply
Philippines. of his prejudice most effective. It
Third goal to Bonifacio's has a lot of
become to push actions as variations with
aside what are maybe Katipunan and the
the elected motivated by Revolution:
officers’ activity way of Emilio Memoirs of a
are and their Aguinaldo’s general especially
academic narration. He with the cited
background. stated in the date of the
Ultimately, the chapter of the e Tejeros
election that book, Seed of conference,
occurred in Discontent, the Agoncillo implied
Tejeros were emotions and in his e book that
announced by superiority of the occasion came
means of Bonifacio in the about in March
Bonifacio, as direction of his 22, 1897, the
ineffective and co-members in birthday of Gen.
annulled due to Katipunan. also, Emilio Aguinaldo.
the violation of he did now not Additionally, he
the rule stated talk the got to determine
within the 0.33 occasion in what faction
objective of this Tejeros in Antonio
event. information as it Montenegro
became like belongs to that's
only a the Magdalo. In
summarization addition to its
of the variations with
convention, yet the other e-book,
he centered he indicated that
approximately Jacinto Lumbreras
Bonifacio’s who turned into
reactions and the presiding
sentiments even officer of
ultimately of the chairman of the
bankruptcy. convention, was
the performing
president of the
Magdiwang
council.
C. Finding/Conclusion
In your examination of the sources, what did Through disseminating and inspecting the
you find out? exclusive information in the books, I finish
that the Santiago V. Alvarez’s e book is an
genuine and number one source and
Teodoro Agoncillo’s e book is a secondary
source however, in phrases of credibility; we
can't depend on them completely because
they indicated the date of the Tejeros
convention in a different way. However, in
relation to the sequence of the narration of
the event, they're the identical. Furthermore,
the opposite info weren’t matching due to
the fact that the alternative book lacks with
that specific element from the opposite e-
book. They both defined what took place in
the Tejeros conference comprehensively
however with biases on account that they
have got specific assets as Santiago V.
Alvarez, the author of the first book is an
eyewitness, a member of the Magdiwang
faction and the son of Mariano Alvarez, even
as the writer of the second one e book is a
researcher who compiled unique primary and
secondary assets to acquire the records he
wished with a purpose to write his ebook. In
analyzing those excerpt from the two books, I
didn’t notice or see any signs of fabrication
due to the fact they both inform the identical
tale and result of what passed off in the
Tejeros conference specifically within the
election element, its targets suits with every
other and that’s what important in
determining if both are dependable for
purchasing an facts regarding the occasion.