Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Micro Economic Project
Micro Economic Project
ABSTRACT 2
HERFINDAHL-HIRSCHMAN INDEX 6
ENTRY BARRIERS 7
GOVERNMENT REGULATIONS 10
REFERENCES 16
1
ABSTRACT
The report is aimed at analyzing the Indian Telecom Sector and concluding whether it is moving
towards a duopoly. To do so we have analyzed multiple microeconomic factors like HHI, ARPU,
price sensitivity, and consumer behavior. We analyzed that the ARPU has significantly
decreased over the years which signifies that the number of firms has decreased increasing the
market concentration and we saw that the HHI has increased due to the increased market
competitiveness due to which the offered price by the companies have also decreased. We have
also looked upon the significant advances and changes that have taken place in the industry so
far. In the industry overview, we looked at the leading players in the industry and then we
analyzed the history of the telecom sector, the technological shifts that took place moving from
2G to 4G and now 5G. We also reviewed the effect on the market when Jio entered the market in
2016 and the current war between Jio and Airtel. Apart from that, we have analyzed the entry
barriers for the new entrants in the industry and all the regulations that the government has
imposed in the telecom industry. With help of this information, we have given our conclusion.
2
PORTER’S ANALYSIS OF THE TELECOM INDUSTRY
Supply: High supply in urban areas like metropolitan cities and low supply in rural village areas.
Demand: High demand due to the low tariff rates and scope for better penetration in the semi-
Barriers to entry: High capital required for the investments, strong network presence of the
established firms, spectrum allocation issues, continuously evolving technology, and lowest
Bargaining Power of Suppliers: Low bargaining power of suppliers due to the collaboration
between the telecom firms and suppliers of mobile handsets. Also, the large number of suppliers
Bargaining Power of Customers: High bargaining power for the customers due to the multiple
available alternatives and the low switching cost from one operator to another. Customers also
have readily available information about the different products available to make an informed
choice.
Competition: High competition among the players to gain market share has led to low prices
and decreased profitability. Currently, Reliance Jio and Airtel are leading the market with other
The Threat of Substitutes: Moderate threat from non-traditional services like Internet-based
calls which include online calls and video calls. These services are lately getting highly popular
due to the strong user base of applications like Whatsapp and Zoom.
3
HISTORY OF THE TELECOM SECTOR
Previously the Telecom sector in India had a Sweezy Oligopoly setup with a higher number of
players in the market, contesting over Prices with each player trying to gain the Monopoly
Power, and with the liberal policies adopted by the Government of India, that that strong
consumer demand has been evident in the rapid growth of the Indian telecom sector. The
government had enabled easy market access to telecom equipment and a fair and proactive
regulatory framework that had ensured the availability of telecom services to consumers at
affordable prices. Mr
Although a point to be noticed is that historically the sector has been lucrative for new entrants,
with a higher Net Profit Margin in the years 2004 to 2009, which has significantly fallen in
today’s time. With the shift from 2G, 3G, and 4G spectrums, and now the upcoming 5G
spectrums, what the market has unfortunately noticed is a colossal drop in ARPU and a steady
growth in Herfindahl–Hirschman Index by Subscribers. This is that critical barrier in the entry
that has pushed many operators to either accept mergers or withdraw from the market.
4
2016-17: THE JIO EFFECT
Internationally, India offers the lowest data prices according to a report by Cable.co.uk. Even in
Purchasing Power Parity terms, India’s data prices are lower than Russia, China, Brazil, etc. This
was majorly affected when Jio entered the market with their price regime trying to capture the
market’s share and every other player in the market was compelled to reduce their prices just to
protect their market share. Jio offered the 4G service at a significantly lower price. Jio also
forced the other competitors to offer meaningful incentives to customers who did high-value
recharges. As we can see in the table below the average revenue per user significantly dropped
for Airtel since Jio entered the market. The ARPU declined drastically for both Vodafone and
Idea since their merger dropped below 100 in September’18 between March’19. The following
5
HERFINDAHL-HIRSCHMAN INDEX
concentration and is often used to determine market competitiveness or in other words, How
much Monopoly Power is prevalent in a Market. The Higher the HHI of an Industry, the higher a
firm enjoys Monopoly Power in the market. Thus, a market with an HHI of less than 1,500 is
considered a fairly competitive market space, an HHI of 1,500 to 2,500 is considered moderately
Market Power.
Previously, in the years 2016-2018, even with the presence of Reliance Jio, the market was still
competitive as Jio had still not affected the market to a great extent. As the pricing policy of Jio
was extremely aggressive, it gradually captured higher market share while smaller firms kept on
losing market share, further leading to exit from the market due to a significantly low
Profitability. This is perfectly described by the HHI Index having a steep rise from the years
2018 to 2021. A significant point to be noted is that although Jio kept on occupying a higher
market share, Airtel was the only firm that could still manage to maintain its Market Share with
an equally competitive pricing policy as well as a focus in Data-Speeds. If the market doesn’t get
regularised by the Government further, this situation might get worsened for the Economy as a
Duopoly situation might lead to a Collusive environment that will incur a Deadweight Loss.
6
Fig 3- HERFINDAHL-HIRSCHMAN INDEX
ENTRY BARRIERS
The Telecom Industry is highly restrictive to new entrants due to the huge investment costs
associated with it. Some of the barriers to entry in the industry are as follows:
1. Infrastructural costs: The new entrants need to shell out huge capital to construct the
infrastructure required for a nationwide network. This includes the costs for equipment,
service, and networks in addition to the licensing fee for the various software. Such high
initial costs deter new entrants to the market. Another issue is the inflexibility of the
investment made by the new entrants as it is for a fixed network and only works in a
designated location. Unlike other industries, once an investment is made in the telecom
sector it is in a fixed asset and is considered a sunk cost, which means that the new entrants
7
2. Lack of Spectrum: Spectrum is the most important resource in the telecom industry. It is
also a finite resource and there is huge competition among the players to acquire the
spectrum channels at exorbitant prices. Another issue in this regard is that India has limited
availability of spectrum as it is 40% less as compared to European countries and 50% lesser
than China. This steep competition leads to high costs which the newer entrants cannot easily
3. Incumbent’s Wrath: Incumbent’s Wrath is used to define the control or leverage that
existing firms have on the industry. Well-established players like Reliance Jio and Airtel
already have a presence in all parts of the country with their nationwide network coverage
and command a strong market share. They also enjoy great brand awareness due to their
services and marketing. Hence, the new entrants not only need to enter the market but also
4. Lowest Tariffs Worldwide: India’s data tariff is one of the lowest in the world at $0.68
per GB as compared to the global average of $4.21. This was due to Jio’s entry into the
market and the ensuing competition in tariff prices among all the players in the industry. The
low tariff prices mean that the new entrants face the issue of low profits in a saturated
market.
characterized by technological advancements with the most recent one being the 5G network.
This means that the firms need to be constantly updating their technologies according to the
time. In addition to this, the firms also have the added burden of improving their equipment
which can lead to added costs. Hence, newer companies also face the pressure of incremental
8
charges for advancement. The above-mentioned period factors will restrain newer entrants
into the market and allow Reliance Jio and Airtel to solidify their dominance in the telecom
Success in a lifetime value program is dependent on how an organization uses customer data to
identify and leverage new customers. In the highly competitive business world that is prevalent
today, the creation of a single value proposition and a reason enough to be selected by the ideal
outlook is crucial. However, this can only be achieved when companies offer value propositions
that are in line with the needs of customers. And because customer needs and preferences are
We also need to look at the price sensitivity of each segment of our target market. For example,
the corporates prefer high quality of services, safe and secure services, and are less price-
sensitive, so companies can work to offer better quality services and fetch a higher amount from
this segment. On the other hand, the general public is very price sensitive and tends to switch the
service providers if they get it from someone else at a lesser price, since they prefer to substitute
The current price and product war between Airtel and Jio can be a perfect example of what
companies try to do to gain a market share in the oligopoly market by either engaging in the
price and a product war. This war when seen through the lenses of Game Theory gives us signs
of the ‘Dollar Auction Game’ where competitors constantly try to outbid each other to win a
9
dollar first by reducing their profits and then reducing their losses, and this is an infinite move
game.
So to gain the market share, both the companies have made huge capital expenditures in the past
and also plan to increase their Capex in the future with Airtel already targeting a $5 Billion in
Now with the entry of Jio in the telecom market, we saw a major decrease in the ARPU
(Average Revenue per User, as mentioned above) composition for all the major players as Jio
came with an extremely low pricing model because of which every other major player in the
industry had to decrease their prices in the 4G segment of Mobile Data as initially, they provided
mobile data for free, the consumer just had to purchase the sim card, this was followed by every
other player reducing their prices. Then Jio launched the JioFiber which was the Wi-Fi service
(which included optic fiber, which ensures high speed) at low prices. This was followed by
Airtel cutting its Wi-Fi prices. The market saw different offers from both the companies
With all this happening continuously over the period, we see companies trying to gain the market
share by either undercutting the other player with prices or offering a better-differentiated
GOVERNMENT REGULATIONS
Telecommunications in India started as a government monopoly, but in the early 1990s, it was
liberalized, and private sector participation was progressively allowed. BSNL (Bharat Sanchar
Nigam Limited), Bharti Airtel, and Vodafone are all major players in the Indian telecom market.
The industry has experienced exponential growth and development, thanks to massive
10
investments from both domestic and international investors. Due to its large user base, India has
seen remarkable growth in the telecom sector. In 2016 when Jio entered the market, to expand its
client base, it began offering free voice and data services to its subscribers as part of promotional
incentives. Vodafone India Ltd, Bharti Airtel Ltd, and Idea Cellular Ltd, the incumbents in the
telecom sector, claimed in multiple complaints before the CCI that Reliance Jio was engaging in
predatory pricing. It may be argued that the ‘promotion' was not a fair competition. The
allegations brought before the CCI, however, had no effect because Reliance Jio did not have a
dominant position. Reliance is in talks with Alphabet’s Google regarding offering a new
popular entry-level option, Vodafone's battle to retain customers may come to an end. The
government has shown little interest in getting involved so far, although it has a pair of
unproductive, overstaffed state-run telecoms in far worse shape. Merging them with a
nationalized Vodafone Idea might result in the preservation of jobs and valuable capital. SpaceX
contacted TRAI last year to express interest in launching Starlink broadband, which is supported
by Elon Musk in India. By the end of 2021, the business claims to be able to provide regular
Starlink coverage across the country. But it does not appear to be arriving in India anytime soon,
the Department of Telecom is looking into whether Starlink's beta version introduction violated
the Information Technology (IT) Act of 2000, the Satellite Communication (SatCom) Policy of
India of 2000, the Indian Wireless Telegraphy Act of 1933, and the Indian Telegraph Act of
But very recently, there has been some positive news for the telecom industry from the
government. Firstly, the government has provided the much-needed moratorium for pending
dues. This will allow companies, particularly Vodafone Idea which is almost at the brink of
11
bankruptcy due to cash-crunch, to improve its efficiency and pay off its due over a longer period.
The government has also redefined Adjusted Gross Revenue and now non-telecom revenues will
be excluded from AGR. This will save taxes of these companies which could be infused to
improve their business performance. The government has also decided to rationalize the
spectrum charges and has allowed 100% FDI through automatic route, which was earlier only
49%.
The total demand in the telecom industry is on the rise over the years. When we plot the number
of users for major service providers over the years the slope has always been positive, and this is
because India is on a demographic dividend, with a larger population in the age gap that are users
of the internet and cell phones. The disposable income has also increased over the years and
people are willing and able to pay more due to increased reliance on the Internet. The Covid-19
also created conditions where Education is shifting from offline to online and India has the
highest numbers of students in the world so anyways the demand is favorable for the sector and
at the same time the workforce all over is also moving towards Work from home and the demand
of internet with better connectivity and services is going to arise. Taking these points into
consideration we feel that the major players of the market will work to penetrate new markets
and thrive to provide the best of services to its customers to be the market leader.
To predict the future total demand (wireless and wireline), assuming all the variables change
invariably, we have forecasted based on the same trendline as from 2010 to 2021. For plotting
the Trendline we have used the concept of Linear Regression. Here the total number of users (in
millions) has been taken as the dependent variable on a Timescale. This time-series data is then
12
forecasted based on a Linear Regression Line. As we get a high R-squared value (~94%) for this
Trendline, we assume with high certainty that the predicted Trendline of the number of
subscribers over time has a good fit. The demand over the years would increase. With the
demand showing a rising trend, we can infer that the market is well available for new entrants or
revival of old players. It must also be noted that multiple advancements can take place that might
shift the forecasted demand. For example, a change in government’s policies, the introduction of
5G / 6G.
On 30th August India’s second-largest telecom operator by subscribers, Bharti Airtel, announced
plans for a rights issue to raise ₹210 billion. It puts this company in a stronger financial position
to weather an ongoing price war carved out by JIO and also while devising a 5G rollout. Airtel
started offering shares at a discount rate of 10% to the next Friday’s closing price, and the deal
was underwritten by the top investor Sunil Mittal Bharti. It underscored a solid position in a
13
cutthroat industry and made it clear that Airtel was the mentioned period going head-on in the
The third-largest operator Vodafone Idea is still clinging on to its previously acquired 255
million subscribers while already straining under a very high debt. It is also facing a funding
crunch if it doesn’t refinance or find new strategic investors. The key stakeholders, Kumar
Mangalam Birla and Britain’s Vodafone are demanding a minimum floor price to tackle the
Cheap Pricing Trick used by Reliance Jio. With the widening funding gap between rivals,
Bharti’s plans tee up an impending duopoly noticeably between Reliance Jio and Airtel. Since
this Aggressive Price War situation has emerged, multiple operators have gone bankrupt, and the
existing ones, excluding only Airtel, are struggling to stay in the market. The operators not only
have to expand their network but also pay off their debts. According to an ET Telecom report,
Devusinh Chauhan, Minister of State for Communications, in Rajya Sabha, recently claimed that
the Indian government is taking necessary steps to ensure that the telecom companies aren’t too
stressed financially.
Chauhan was asked by an Indian lawmaker whether the situation is heading towards a probable
duopoly and what is the government doing to ensure that it is avoided. According to Mr.
Chauhan’s claim the government has imposed a 35% price restriction on the total spectrum that
an operator can have in a specific telecom circle, preventing the market from becoming a
monopoly. Further, it can be noted that the operators were given the option to defer the spectrum
auction payment installments for two financial years, including 2020-21 and 2021-22. To further
help the telcos, the government has increased the number of installments for repayments.
14
The minister also mentioned how the Supreme Court had asked the telcos to pay their AGR dues
over 10 installments in 10 years. Regardless of these comments, a point to be noted is that there
still isn’t much help provided to Vodafone Idea and BSNL-MTNL by the government, which can
15
REFERENCES
1. Baye, M.R., & Prince, J.T. (2014). Managerial Economics & Business Strategy (8th
2. Bhalla, K. (2021, April 13th). As Telcos Push For Higher ARPU, India No Longer Has
https://inc42.com/buzz/as-telcos-push-for-higher-arpu-india-no-longer-has-the-worlds-
cheapest-mobile-data-plans/
https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/opinion/editorial/duopoly-concerns/
article35285906.ece
4. Competition Commission of India. (2021, January 22nd). Market Study on the Telecom
Sector In India.
https://www.cci.gov.in/sites/default/files/whats_newdocument/Market-Study-on-the-
Telecom-Sector-In-India.pdf
5. Equitymaster. (2021, January 7th). Indian Telecom Industry Report - Telecom Sector
https://www.equitymaster.com/research-it/sector-info/telecom/Telecom-Sector-Analysis-
Report.asp
https://www.financialexpress.com/industry/telecom-sector-on-way-to-to-be-a-duopoly-
mukesh-ambanis-jio-bharti-airtel-continue-to-beat-voda-idea/2066953/
16
7. India Today. (2021, July 29th). Airtel and Vodafone Idea each lost over 40 lakh
https://www.indiatoday.in/technology/news/story/airtel-and-vodafone-idea-each-lost-
over-40-lakh-subscribers-in-may-jio-gained-over-35-lakh-subscribers-1834323-2021-07-
29
8. Kaur, G. (2021, August 7th). Is India moving towards a duopoly?. Light Reading.
https://www.lightreading.com/asia/is-india-moving-towards-duopoly/d/d-id/770753
9. Sarkar, S. (2021, July 5th): Indian Telecom Sector: Duopoly or Hefty Tariff Hikes?.
Capital Mind.
https://www.capitalmind.in/2021/07/indian-telecom-sector-duopoly-or-hefty-tariff-hikes/
10. Singh, A. V. (2021, June). Market Analysis of Indian Telecom Mobile Industry. Research
Gate.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/
338010860_Market_Analysis_of_Indian_Telecom_Mobile_Industry
11. Taneja, M. (2021, August 4th) Telecom Diary: Duopoly in Indian Telecom Market. ET
Telecom.com
https://telecom.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/telecom-diary-duopoly-in-indian-
telecom-market/84916553
https://www.trai.gov.in/about-us/annual-reports
17