Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Kashif Hidayat
Kashif Hidayat
Sacrifice:
Love:
"The Nightingale and the Rose" is a story about the nature of love. The
nightingale agreed to take a red rose for the greatest price, which was her life. He did it
because he believed that love is divine and random. This cannot always be expressed
logically. Nightingale finally proved it by sacrificing her life. What does true love mean?
To explain this, Wilde combines and separates two types of love. First, the story presents
love at a high price: the nightingale gives him life. Therefore, the Disciple can possess a
red rose, an object he ardently desires. On the other hand, it shows a different kind of love
between a young girl and a student. He asked for a red rose for his love. Later, when the
Student received the rose, the Girl suddenly changes her mind when another admirer
gave her jewels that she values more. By presenting the characters of the story in this
way, the author explains that true love involves countless sacrifices. If love is built based
on wealth or possessions, it is not true at all. The only "true lover" in the story was
Nightingale. He was the only one who had true feelings, and for those feelings, he was
ready to sacrifice his life. Even though he knew he would get nothing in return. The truth
was only loved for him. He did it for his love and to make his loved one happy, that was
enough for him. That's how love should be. We can learn a specific lesson from the bird
about how we should behave toward our loved ones.
Materialism:
"The Nightingale and the Rose" combines the extreme rationality of the
Student with the materialism of the girl. Because he only perceives the world in
"realism", the Student cannot come out with selfless behaviour. It gives no value to man
or bird by practising it. The girl is the most selfish and controlling character in the story.
As a result, rationality certainly breeds materialism if not reinforced by emotion. His
logic in refusing the student's red rose: "Everyone knows that jewels cost much more than
flowers." The only feelings the Student had for the Girl were material love because he
was only impressed by her beauty. Therefore, when the girl refused him, he threw the
rose and returned to his study, realizing that love is simply impractical. Because he didn't
appreciate Nightingale's true love, he got nothing in return. Love is such a pure feeling
that it cannot be explained or treated with materialism and beauty.