Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Aneesha
Aneesha
Aneesha
By
ANEESHA.V.B
APRIL 2011
1
A STUDY TO ASSESS THE EFFECTIVENESS OF JACOBSON PROGRESSIVE MUSCLE
RELAXATION EXERCISE ON PREMENSTRUAL SYNDROME AMONG WOMEN
ATTENDING GYNAECOLOGY OPD IN KG HOSPITAL, COIMBATORE.
By
ANEESHA.V.B
APRIL 2011
2
CERTIFICATE
3
A STUDY TO ASSESS THE EFFECTIVENESS OF JACOBSON PROGRESSIVE MUSCLE
RELAXATION EXERCISE ON PREMENSTRUAL SYNDROME AMONG WOMEN
ATTENDING GYNAECOLOGY OPD IN KG HOSPITAL, COIMBATORE.
________________
Prof.( Mrs.) SHEEBA.R,
HOD, Obstetrics and Gynaecological Nursing,
K.G. College of Nursing,
Coimbatore-641018
________________
Dr. (Mrs.) CHANDRAKALA MARAN,
Chief Obstetrician and Gynaecologist,
K.G. Hospital,
Coimbatore-641018
_________________
Prof.( Mr.) SUBRAMANIAN.K,
Department of Bio- Statistics and Research,
K.G. College of Nursing,
Coimbatore-641018
APRIL 2011
4
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The essence of all beautiful art, all great art, is gratitude. Gratitude
can never be expressed in words but this is only deep perception, which
makes the words to flow from ones inner heart.
With a profound sense of gratitude, I praise and thank God Almighty for
his constant help and blessings showered upon me throughout this study.
5
I express my sincere gratitude to Prof. RAJI.K, Vice Principal and
HOD, Medical Surgical Nursing, K.G. College of Nursing for her
encouragement, inspirations and support for successful completion of this
study.
6
I honestly express my thanks to ,( Mrs.) MUTHUKANNU,
(Mrs.) VIMIJA. M, Associate Professors, (Mrs.)SANGEETHA,
(Mrs.)DHANAPANDI,( Ms.)SANGEETHA Lectures, Department of
Obstetrics and Gynaecological Nursing, K.G. College of Nursing, for
their encouragement and guidance in the completion of this study.
7
Above all with grateful heart I express my love to my beloved
HUSBAND, my MOTHER and my DAUGHTERS for their
unconditional love, immense help, encouragement, care and supporting
prayers.
8
INDEX
I INTRODUCTION 1-10
Need for the study 2-5
Statement of the problem 5
Objectives 5
Operational definitions 5-6
Assumptions 6
Hypothesis 6
Limitations 7
Projected outcome 7
Conceptual Framework 7-10
II REVIEW OF LITERATURE 11- 20
III METHODOLOGY 21-32
Introduction 21
Research approach 21
Research Design 21-22
Setting of the study 24
Variables 25-26
Population 27
Sample size 27
Sampling technique 28
Criteria for sample selection 28
Description of the tool 28-29
Content validity 30
Reliability 30
Pilot study 30
Method of data collection 31
Plan for data analysis 32
IV DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION 33-55
V RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 56-60
VI SUMMARY,RECOMMENDATIONSAND
61-64
NURSING IMPLICATIONS OF THE STUDY
BIBLIOGRAPHY
APPENDICES
9
LIST OF TABLES
TABLE PAGE
NO. TITLE NO.
1 Distribution of demographic variables among women with
premenstrual syndrome in experimental and control group. 35-36
2 Distribution of menstrual variables among women with 40-41
premenstrual syndrome in experimental and control group.
3 Distribution of intensity of premenstrual syndrome pre
test and post test scores among women in experimental 44
and control group.
4 Comparison of pre test and post test scores of premenstrual 46
syndrome among women in experimental group.
5 Comparison of intensity of premenstrual syndrome among 47
women in experimental group and control group.
6 Association of intensity of premenstrual syndrome among 48
women with selected demographic variables in
experimental group.
7 Association of intensity of premenstrual syndrome among 50
women with selected menstrual variables in experimental
group.
8 Association of intensity of premenstrual syndrome among 52
women with selected demographic variables in control
group.
9 Association of intensity of premenstrual syndrome among 54
women with selected menstrual variables in control group.
10
LIST OF FIGURES
FIGURE PAGE
NO. TITLE NO.
1. Conceptual framework 10
3. Relationship of Variables 26
11
LIST OF APPENDICES
APPENDIX TITLE
12
CHAPTER -1
INTRODUCTION
“One day she is in all smiles and happiness then, the another day there
will be no living with her, she flies into a rage.”
- Greek
Poet
13
ways and disrupt her day to day activities (American Psychiatric
Association, 2003).
14
premenstrual syndrome in general is about 2-10% for disabling
symptoms, while minor symptoms present up to 80% of women. In the
present series, a high prevalence of premenstrual syndrome was observed
in premenopausal women. A recent survey of 3,913 women of 15-54
years of age have premenstrual syndrome (J.V Joshi, S. N Pandey,
2010).
15
Women with severe and moderate symptoms should be referred for
evaluation and follow up (Hsia and Hong, 2008).
16
STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM
A Study To Assess The Effectiveness Of Jacobson Progressive
Muscle Relaxation Exercise On Premenstrual Syndrome Among
Women Attending Gynaecology OPD in K.G. Hospital,
Coimbatore.
OBJECTIVES
1. To assess the intensity of premenstrual syndrome of the women in
experimental and control group.
2. To provide Jacobson progressive muscle relaxation exercise to
women in experimental group.
3. To assess the effectiveness of Jacobson progressive muscle
relaxation exercise on premenstrual syndrome among women in
the experimental group.
4. To compare the intensity of premenstrual syndrome among women
in both experimental and control group.
5. To associate the findings with selected demographic variables and
menstrual variables.
OPERATIONAL DEFINITIONS
Effectiveness
Effectiveness refers to the reduction in the intensity of
premenstrual syndrome experienced by women after providing Jacobson
progressive muscle relaxation exercise.
Premenstrual syndrome
17
Premenstrual syndrome is a physical, psychological and
behavioural symptoms that occur two weeks prior to menstruation.
Women
Women in reproductive age group of 20-45 years.
ASSUMPTIONS.
1. Women experience pre menstrual syndrome two weeks prior to
menstruation.
2. Jacobson progressive muscle relaxation exercise is a means of
relaxation and decreases pre menstrual syndrome.
3. Most of the women are unaware of regarding Jacobson progressive
muscle relaxation exercise.
HYPOTHESIS
There is a significant difference in premenstrual syndrome among
women following Jacobson progressive muscle relaxation exercise and
in women not following the exercise
LIMITATIONS
The study is limited to
• Women attending Gynaecology OPD in K.G . Hospital,
Coimbatore.
18
• Women in reproductive age group of 20-45 years.
• Women who are able to understand Tamil and English.
• Women who have regular menstrual period
• Women not having medical and surgical problems.
PROJECTED OUTCOMES
• The findings of the study will identify the need and effectiveness of
simple non pharmacological measures of reducing pre menstrual
syndrome such as Jacobson progressive muscle relaxation
exercise.
• The findings of the study will help in relaxation, comfort, reduction
of premenstrual syndrome in women without any complications.
CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
This study was aimed at determining the effectiveness of
Jacobson Progressive Muscle Relaxation Exercise in reduction of
premenstrual syndrome.
Input
19
Based on J.W .Kenny’s open system model input can be a matter,
energy and information that enter into the system from the environment
through its boundaries.
Throughput process
Output
Output is any information that leaves the system and enters the
environment through system boundaries. It refers to the ultimate results,
which are expected following program implementation.
Feed back
20
According to the theorist, feedback is the information of environment
responses to the system. Output is utilized by the system in adjustment,
correction and accommodation to the interaction with the environment.
The effectiveness of Jacobson progressive muscle relaxation exercise in
reducing the intensity of premenstrual syndrome is considered as the
difference observed and expected. For the present study feedback is not
included.
21
FIGURE – 1
CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK BASED ON MODIFIED J.W. KENNY’S OPE
CLINICAL SET UP
Collection of
To evaluate the
demographic data and effectiveness of Jacobson Effectivenes
menstrual data from progressive muscle Jacobson progr
both relaxation exercise by muscle relax
experimental&control checking pre menstrual exercise in red
group of women syndrome score. of intensity o
having pre menstrual menstrual syn
syndrome by Modified C
Assessment of intensity of four point liker
Experimental group
pre menstrual syndrome in
experimental and control Providing Jacobson progressive
group using modified COPE muscle relaxation exercise
four point likert scale Control group
CLINICAL SET UP
22
CHAPTER II
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
Woman with pre menstrual syndrome can suffer from all of the most
common signs and symptoms. Breast pain and tenderness, bloating, backache,
painful thighs, mood swings, irritability, loss of control, headache, nausea,
vomiting, diarrhea, tearfulness, outbursts, depression, anxiety, fatigue, weakness,
dizziness. Some women can become isolated and withdrawn because of these
symptoms ( Dorrisnoel, Klinger,2002).
23
SECTION A: STUDIES RELATED TO PREVALENCE AND
PERCEPTION OF PREMENSTRUAL SYNDROME.
24
A study was conducted on the prevalence and frequency of symptoms
of premenstrual syndrome in female undergraduate students of university of
Calabar. A survey of 200 nulliparous subjects aged between 16 and 31 years
revealed that 83.5% of them regularly experienced symptoms suggestive of
premenstrual syndrome .The commonest symptom were lower abdominal pain,
pimples, puffy face, tender or painfully engorged breast and depression or tension.
The least frequent symptom were backache and common cold.42% of subjects
complained of severe abdominal pain. There was an association between severity
of abdominal discomfort and symptoms experienced by subjects (Diana. C. Dell,
2004).
25
demonstrated a significant increase in total personality diagnostic questionnaire
revised score from the follicular to the luteal phase. Women with premenstrual
syndrome had significantly higher total personality diagnostic questionnaire
revised scores than the asymptomatic controls during the follicular and luteal
phases (Berlin, R. et al., 2001).
26
perforatum (St John’s wort) tablets 900 mg/day or identical placebo tablets for two
menstrual cycles. After a placebo-treated cycle, the women crossed over to receive
placebo or Hypericum perforatum for two additional cycles. Symptoms were rated
throughout the trial using the Daily Symptom Report. There was a significant
reduction in premenstrual syndrome among women receiving Hypericum
perforatum than placebo ( Orsi. N, et al., 2007).
27
effective in alleviating the symptoms of premenstrual syndrome on comparison to
placebo (Yakir. et al., 2003).
28
syndrome symptoms specially mastidynia and fluid and electrolyte symptoms like
water retention and edema than placebo (Singh, V.K. 2002).
29
& heart rate of women with premenstrual syndrome was significantly higher than
the control subjects suggesting the presence of stress in women with premenstrual
syndrome. Following 1 week of 61-points relaxation training, the control group
showed a significant decline in systolic blood pressure, diastolic blood pressure
and heart rate respectively, the premenstrual syndrome group showed a significant
reduction in systolic blood pressure, diastolic blood pressure and heart rate,
immediately after cold pressor test. These results suggest a reduction in
sympathetic activity by 61-points relaxation training and it can be used as an
effective relaxation tool during premenstrual stress (Dvivedi J, Kaur H, 2009).
A comparative study was conducted to find out whether premenstrual
symptoms were relieved by massage therapy in Touch research institute, USA. 24
women were randomly assigned to a massage therapy or a relaxation therapy
group. The massage therapy group showed decrease in anxiety, depressed mood
and pain immediately after the first and last massage sessions. The longer term (5
week) effects of massage therapy included a reduction in pain and water retention
and overall menstrual distress. The study findings suggest that massage therapy is
an effective adjuvant therapy for treating severe premenstrual symptoms ( Reif.
M. H, et al., 2007).
30
exercise was taught to the experimental group with the help of video CD and each
participant was advised to do, twice daily for 4 weeks. The investigator checked
the performance every day. Post test was conducted after 28 days after the
administration of Jacobson progressive muscle relaxation exercise . There was a
significant reduction in premenstrual syndrome (p< 0.05). Jacobson progressive
muscle relaxation exercise was effective in reducing premenstrual syndrome
among college women. (Lindsie Mary. l, Tamilmani. R, 2009).
31
symptoms. In women with severe premenstrual symptoms, relaxation response
also improved emotional symptoms and social withdrawal symptoms compared
with reading leisure material or charting symptoms (Irene Kwan, Joseph Loze
Onwude 2009).
32
CHAPTER III
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
INTRODUCTION
RESEARCH APPROACH
In this present study the researcher had adopted quantitative approach.
RESEARCH DESIGN
21
Experimental group: O1 X O2
Control group : O3 - O4
22
FIGURE-2
SCHEMATIC REPRESENTATION OF RESEARCH DESIGN
Quantitative approach
23
SETTING OF THE STUDY
Setting are the more specific places where data collection occurs (Polit
and Beck, 2004).
The study was conducted in K.G.Hospital, Coimbatore, which is a
550 bedded multispeciality, NABH certified hospital. It is situated in the
heart of Coimbatore City. The hospital is renowned for its excellent
medical expertise, nursing care and quality of diagnostic services. The
Obstetrics and Gynaecology department of K.G hospital is well staffed
with two chief Gynaecologist,6 duty doctors and 12 staff nurses with
twenty four hours services and emergency care. It offers advanced and
affordable health care to the people. All the facilities are provided for
conducting normal and instrumental delivery. The facilities include
maternity wards, 4 outpatient departments, well equipped 3 labour rooms
and one neonatal ICU and operation department for emergency
management. There are about 1000 cases attending the out patient
department per month and nearly 150 deliveries are conducting per month.
Out of these 150 deliveries, there are 50 cesarean deliveries.
24
VARIABLES
Variables are the measurable characteristics of a concept and consist of
logical group of attributes (Polit and Beck, 2007).
Independent variable
Jacobson progressive muscle relaxation exercise.
Dependent variable
Premenstrual syndrome.
Influencing variables
Age, education, occupation, dietary pattern.
Extraneous variables
Support system, knowledge regarding alternative therapies.
25
FIGURE-3
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN VARIABLES
Extraneous
variables
Support system,
knowledge regarding
alternative therapies
26
POPULATION
Population represents the entire aggregation of cases that meet a
designed set of criteria that are accessible to the researcher for a study and
for which researcher is able to make generalizations (Polit and Beck,
2004).
Total population of the present study is 100. Target population is 50
SAMPLESIZE
4=Constant number
P=Percentage of population
Q=100-p
L=Allowable errors
P =50/I50x100=33
q =100-P=100-33=67
L= 15
n=4x33x67/15x15=39.3~40
According to this the researcher decided to have the sample size as 40 for
study.
27
SAMPLING TECHNIQUE
Sampling technique is the process of selecting a subset of
population in order to obtain information regarding a phenomenon in a way
that represents the entire population. (Polit and beck, 2007).
Convenience sampling technique was used for the study. The investigator
selected the persons who fulfilled the inclusion criteria formed for the study.
Exclusion criteria
• Women having medical and surgical problems
28
TOOL I
SECTION A- DEMOGRAPHIC VARIABLES
A self designed questionnaire developed by researcher herself which
comprises of 10 items for obtaining demographic data of the mother through
personal interview.
TOOL II
SECTION C- MODIFIED COPE (calendar of premenstrual experiences)
• To assess the intensity of pre menstrual syndrome among women
attending Gynaecology OPD.
• In order to assess the intensity of premenstrual syndrome, Modified
COPE by four point Likert scale was used by the investigator. It
consist of 22 items to rate the intensity of pre menstrual syndrome.
The items are scored as none, mild, moderate and severe on the scale.
Each subject is assessed according to the scorings.
29
CONTENT VALIDITY
Content validity is the degree to which the items in an instrument
adequately represent the universe of content for concept being measured
(Polit and Beck, 2004).
The tool was submitted to experts of the departments of Obstetrics and
Gynaecological nursing .A criterion rating scale for validation of tool was
developed. Experts were asked to give their opinions and suggestions about
content of the tool.
RELIABILITY
Reliability of the tool was established by using split half technique.
It showed rhh = 0.9 and hence the tool was found to be reliable.
PILOT STUDY
Pilot study is the scale version, or trial done in preparation for main
suitability, practicability, appropriateness and flexibility of the study and
tool (Denise F. Polit, 2004).
30
METHOD OF DATA COLLECTION
DESCRIPTION OF INTERVENTION
31
PLAN FOR DATA ANALYSIS
32
CHAPTER IV
33
Table-6 Association of intensity of premenstrual syndrome among women
with selected demographic variables in experimental group.
34
TABLE- 1
DISTRIBUTION OF DEMOGRAPHIC VARIABLES AMONG
WOMEN WITH PREMENSTRUAL SYNDROME IN
EXPERIMENTAL AND CONTROL GROUPS
S
Experimental group Control group
No Demographic Number Percentage Number Percentage
variables (n1=20) % (n2=20) %
1 Age in years
a)20-25 years 3 15 2 10
b)26-30 years 4 20 4 20
c)31-35 years 3 15 4 20
d)36-40 years 7 35 6 30
e)41-45 years 3 15 4 20
2 Education
a)Primary 3 15 2 10
b)Secondary 7 35 9 45
c)Graduate 10 50 9 45
3 Occupation
a)House wife 7 35 6 30
b)Coolie 1 5 2 10
c)Professional 10 50 9 15
d)Business 2 10 3 45
4 Marital status
a)Married 12 60 11 55
b)Unmarried 8 40 9 45
35
5 Habitation
a)Rural 2 10 1 5
b)urban 9 45 10 10
c)Semi urban 9 45 9 45
6 Dietary pattern
a)Vegetarian 6 30 5 15
b)Non- 14 70 15 75
vegetarian
7 Type of family
a)Nuclear family 12 60 10 50
b)Joint family 8 40 % 10 50
8 Family birth
order
a)First 11 55 10 50
b)Second 6 30 5 25
c)Third and 3 15 5 15
above
9 Social support
a)Family 11 55 10 50
b)Neighbors 4 20 3 15
c)Friends 4 20 5 25
d)Others 1 5 2 10
10 Sources of
health
information
a)Newspaper 11 55 9 45
b)Radio 1 5 2 10
c)TV 6 30 5 25
d)Internet 2 10 4 20
The above table showed that the distribution of demographic variables
of women in both group.
36
According to age of the women in experimental group,3(15%) were
between 20-25 years,4(20%) were between 26-30 years,3(15%) were
between 31-35 years,7(35%) were between 36-40 years and 3(15%) were
between 41-45 years. Considering the education 3(15%) had primary
education, 7(35%) had secondary education and 10(50%) were graduates.
Considering the occupation of the woman, 7(35%) were house wife,
1(5%) was coolie, 10(50%) were professional and 2(10%) were business
people in experimental group. In control group 6(30%) were housewife,
2(20%) were coolie, 9(45%) were professional and 3(15%) were business
people.
38
FIGURE – 4
DIAGRAM SHOWING THE DISTRIBUTION OF DEMOGRAPHIC VARIABLES AMONG WOMEN
WITH PREMENSTRUAL SYNDROME IN EXPERIMENTAL AND CONTROL GROUPS
PERCENTAGE (%)
39
TABLE- 2
DISTRIBUTION OF MENSTRUAL VARIABLES AMONG
WOMEN WITH PREMENSTRUAL SYNDROME IN
EXPERIMENTAL AND CONTROL GROUPS
Experimental Control group
Group
S
No
Menstrual
variables
Number Percentage Number Percentage
(n1=20) % (n2=20) %
1 Parity
a)One 11 55 10 50
b)Two 8 40 7 35
c)Three & above 1 5 3 15
2 Pain during
menstruation
a)Yes 17 85 15 75
b)No 3 15 5 25
3 Duration of
menstruation
a)2-3 days 6 30 5 25
b)3-4 days 10 50 8 40
c)5-6 days 4 20 7 35
4 Family history
of premenstrual
syndrome
a)Yes 13 65 11 55
b)No 7 35 9 45
40
Food preference
during
5 menstruation
a) Vegetarian 13 65 11 55
b) Non- 7 35 9 45
vegetarian
6 Awareness on
JPMRE
a)Yes 3 15 1 5
b)No 17 85 19 95
7 Any experience
of JPMRE
41
control group 15 (75%) had pain during menstruation and 5(25%) had no
pain during menstruation.
Considering duration of menstruation 6(30%) had 2-3 days of
menstruation,10 (50%) had 3-4 days of menstruation and 4 (20%) had 5-6
days menstruation in experimental group. In control group 5 (25%) had 2-3
days menstruation,8 (40%) had 4-5 days menstruation and 7 (35%) had 5-6
days menstruation.
43
TABLE-3
DISTRIBUTION OF INTENSITY OF PREMENSTRUAL SYNDROME PRE
TEST AND POST TEST SCORES AMONG WOMEN IN EXPERIMENTAL AND
CONTROL GROUP n=40
S No Experimental group control group
PMS Pre test Post test Pre test Post test
scores score score score score
NO % NO % NO % NO %
2 Moderate 15 75 5 25 17 85 14 70
44
FIGURE-6
DIAGRAM SHOWING THE DISTRIBUTION OF INTENSITY OF PREMENSTRUAL SYNDROME
AMONG WOMEN IN EXPERIMENTAL AND CONTROL GROUP
PERCENTAGE (%)
45
TABLE- 4
COMPARISON OF PRE TEST AND POST TEST SCORES OF
PREMENSTRUAL SYNDROME AMONG WOMEN IN
EXPERIMENTAL GROUP
n=20
Tabulated
Premenstrual value of ‘t’
S Mean SD
syndrome Calculated at 5% level
No
scores value of ‘ t’ of
significance
The calculated value of‘t’ (4.403) is greater than the tabulated value of‘t’
(2.093) at 5 % level of significance. The null hypothesis is rejected. It is
concluded that there is a significant difference between the pre test and
post test scores among women in experimental group.
TABLE- 5
46
COMPARISON OF INTENSITY OF PREMENSTRUAL
SYNDROME AMONG WOMEN IN EXPERIMENTAL AND
CONTROL GROUP
n=20
Tabulated
Premenstrual Calculated value of ‘z’
Mean SD
S No
syndrome value of ‘ z’ at 5% level
scores of
significance
1 Experimental
20.65 3.47
group 13.27 1.96
47
ASSOCIATION OF INTENSITY OF PREMENSTRUAL
SYNDROME AMONG WOMEN WITH SELECTED
DEMOGRAPHIC VARIABLES IN EXPERIMENTAL GROUP.
n=20
Calculated Tabulated
Demographic Above Below value of χ2 value of χ2
S variables median median at 5% level
No of
significance
1 Type of family
a)Nuclear 5 7
<1 NS 3.84
b)Joint 4 4
2 Dietary pattern
a)Vegetarian 4 2
<1 NS 3.84
b)Non-vegetarian 5 9
3 Habitation
a)Rural/Semi urban 5 7
<1 NS 3.84
b)Urban 4 4
4 Family birth
order
<1 NS 3.84
a)First/second 3 1
b)Third& above 10 6
48
The calculated value of χ2 is less than the tabulated value of χ2 at 5%
level of significance.
TABLE- 7
ASSOCIATION OF INTENSITY ON PREMENSTRUAL
SYNDROME AMONG WOMEN WITH SELECTED
MENSTRUAL VARIABLES IN EXPERIMENTAL GROUP
49
n=20
Tabulated
S Menstrual Above Below Calculated value of χ2
No variables median median value of χ2 at 5% level
of
significance
1 Pain during
menstruation
a)Yes 7 8 <1 NS 3.84
b)No 2 3
2 Duration of
menstruation
a)2-3/3-4 days 7 9 <1 NS 3.84
b)5-6 days 2 2
3 Parity
a)One/Two 6 11 <1 NS 3.84
50
There is no association between the pain during menstruation and
intensity of premenstrual syndrome.
TABLE- 8
ASSOCIATION OF INTENSITY OF PREMENSTRUAL
SYNDROME AMONG WOMEN WITH SELECTED
DEMOGRAPHIC VARIABLES IN CONTROL GROUP
n=20
Tabulated
51
S Demographic Above Below Calculated value of χ2
No variables median median value of χ2 at 5 % level
significance
1 Type of family
a)Nuclear 8 6
b)Joint 3 3
<1 NS 3.84
2 Dietary pattern
a)Vegetarian 7 4
<1 NS 3.84
b)Non-vegetarian 5 4
3 Habitation
a)Rural/Semi urban 9 4
b)Urban <1 NS 3.84
4 3
4 Family birth
order
a)First/second 5 8
<1 NS 3.84
b)Third& above 2 5
52
There is no association between the dietary pattern and intensity of
premenstrual syndrome.
TABLE - 9
ASSOCIATION OF INTENSITY OF PREMENSTRUAL
SYNDROME AMONG WOMEN WITH SELECTED
MENSTRUAL VARIABLES IN CONTROL GROUP
n=20
Tabulated
S
Menstrual Above Below Calculated value of χ2
No
variables median median value of χ2 at 5% level
of
53
significance
1 Pain during
menstruation
a)Yes 9 4
<1 NS 3.84
b)No 4 3
2 Duration of
menstruation
a)2-3/3-4 days 4 7
<1 NS 3.84
b)5-6 days 5 4
3 Parity
a)One/Two 5 10 3.84
54
There is no association between the parity and intensity of premenstrual
syndrome.
CHAPTER V
55
1. To assess the intensity of premenstrual syndrome of the women in
experimental and control group
56
With the supporting literature, Jacobson progressive muscle relaxation
exercise was provided to the experimental group, it was done twice daily
for one month.
Table 4 showed the comparison of pre test and post test scores of
premenstrual syndrome among women in experimental group. It revealed
that, the calculated value of ‘t’ (4.403) is greater than the tabulated value
of ‘t’ (2.093) at 5 % level of significance. So the hypothesis is accepted.
It is concluded that there is a significant difference in the intensity of
premenstrual syndrome among women in the experimental group.
A qualitative study was conducted among six female subjects
who were between 31-44 years of age attended a pre menstrual syndrome
clinic and participated in a group therapy program designed to alleviate
their pre menstrual symptoms. Rational-emotive therapy and Jacobson
progressive muscle relaxation exercise were offered in an effort to
alleviate severe psychological symptoms.. Pre treatment assessments
were carried out using Moods Menstrual distress Questionnaire.
Significant differences were found in a number of psychological and
physical symptoms of menstrual distress, in cognitive functioning and
neuroticism, following the combined group therapy (Micheal, E.
Bernard, L. 2009).
57
Table 5 showed the comparison of intensity premenstrual
syndrome among women in experimental and control group. It reveals
that, the calculated value of ‘z’ (13.27) is greater than the tabulated
value of ‘z’ (1.96) at 5% level of significance. The hypothesis is
accepted. It is concluded that there is a significant difference between the
pretest and post test scores of premenstrual syndrome of women between
experimental and control group.
5. To associate the findings with selected demographic variables and
menstrual variables.
The study was conducted on factors associated with age,
education, occupation, marital status, habitation, dietary pattern, type of
family, family birth order, social support, sources of health information in
assessment of premenstrual syndrome.
Table 6 showed the association of selected demographic variables
like type of family, dietary pattern, habitation, family birth order in
assessment of premenstrual syndrome in experimental group .Association
was found by using chi square test. The result showed that the calculated
value of chi square is less than tabulated value of chi square at 5% level
of significance. There was no association found between the premenstrual
syndrome and other demographic variables like type of family, dietary
pattern, habitation, family birth order and premenstrual syndrome.
Table 7 showed the association of selected menstrual variables
like pain during menstruation, duration of menstruation, parity, family
history of premenstrual syndrome in assessment of premenstrual
syndrome in experimental group .Association was found by using chi
square test. The result showed that the calculated value of chi square is
less than tabulated value of chi square at 5% level of significance. There
was no association found between the premenstrual syndrome and other
menstrual variables like pain during menstruation, duration of
58
menstruation, parity, family history of premenstrual syndrome and
premenstrual syndrome.
59
stress, physical activity, consumption of sweet tasting foods and coffee
(Rasheed. R. et al., 2003).
CONCLUSION
The present study was supported by a series of other studies which
confirmed that Jacobson progressive muscle relaxation exercise was
effective in reducing premenstrual syndrome. The respondent revealed
that Jacobson progressive muscle relaxation exercise was effective during
premenstrual syndrome to provide comfort, relaxation and sense of well
being. From the analysis and result the researcher concluded that
Jacobson progressive muscle relaxation exercise provided during
premenstrual syndrome is effective.
CHAPTER VI
SUMMARY
RECOMMENDATIONS
61
The following recommendations were made by the investigator after
the study.
• The similar study can be undertaken on a large sample.
• A similar study can be conducted separately for adolescent girls
and women.
• A comparative study can be performed to evaluate the
effectiveness of different relaxation techniques.
NURSING IMPLICATIONS
NURSING PRACTICE
• Nurses can provide holistic care with alternative and
complimentary therapies.
• Nurses can prepare the women from the luteal phase of menstrual
cycle to get better outcome during the premenstrual syndrome
period.
• Nurses can prepare the women in managing premenstrual
syndrome as an integral nursing intervention to achieve relaxation,
fitness and healthy lifestyle for better outcome.
NURSING EDUCATION
62
• The nursing curriculum should be updated with the inclusion of
topics on various relaxation techniques in premenstrual syndrome.
• The nursing curriculum could be strengthened with current concept
of premenstrual syndrome management to enable the nursing
students to provide appropriate information to the women with
premenstrual syndrome.
• Periodic conference, seminars, workshop and symposiums can be
arranged regarding various relaxation techniques in managing
premenstrual syndrome to make nursing professionals competent
enough to meet the ever changing needs of the society.
NURSING ADMINISTRATION
NURSING RESEARCH
63
• The study can be issued for further reference. It may form a base
for further study in the field. Research should be done in different
aspects of alternative relaxation techniques to reduce premenstrual
syndrome symptoms to the women during their menstrual cycle.
64
APPENDIX – D
65
APPENDIX – E
66
APPENDIX - F
Signature
67
APPENDIX - G
Signature
68
APPENDIX - H
Signature
69
APPENDIX – I
TOOL I
SECTION A
DEMOGRAPHIC VARIABLES
INSTRUCTION
1. Age in years
a) 20-25
b) 26-30
c) 31-35
d) 36-40
e) 41-45
2. Education
a) Illiterate
b) Primary
c) Secondary
d) Graduate
3. Occupation
a) House wife
b) Coolie
c) Professional
d) Business
4. Marital status
a) Married
b) Unmarried
5. Habitation
a) Rural
b) Urban
c) Semi urban
6. Dietary Pattern
a) Vegetarian
70
b) Non-vegetarian
7. Type of family
a) Nuclear family
b) Joint family
9. Social support
a) Family
b) Neighbours
c) Friends
d) Others
71
SECTION B
MENSTRUAL VARIABLES
INSTRUCTION
The investigator records according to the responses of the subjects
1. Age at menarche
3. Menstrual pattern
a.Regular
b.Irregular
4. Parity
a. one
b. two
c. Three or above
6. Duration of menstruation
a. 2-3 days
b. 3-4 days
c. 5-6 day
72
TOOL-II
MODIFIED COPE (CALENDAR OF PREMENSTRUAL
EXPERIENCES) FOUR POINT LIKERT SCALE
II BEHAVIOURAL
SYMPTOMS
12 Irritability
13 Anxiety/Tension
14 Mood Liability
15 Food cravings
16 Depression
17 Over sensitivity
18 Expressed anger
19 Crying easily
20 Isolation
21 Forgetfulness
22 Poor concentration
Scorings
0 – None
1-22 – Mild
23-44 –Moderate
45-66 – severe
73
fUtp – II
khw;wp mikf;fg;gl;l nfhg; ( khjtplha; fhyj;J mDgt';fs; ) ehd;F
g[s;sp ypfh;l; !;nfy:
kjpg;bgz; :-
0 : ,y;;iy
01 - 22 : rpwpjst[
23 - 44 : rhjhuzk;;
45 - 66 : jPtpuk;;
74
APPENDIX: J
PROCEDURE
• To begin with close your eyes and take three deep breaths,
exhaling slowly each time. As you exhale, imagine that tension
through out your body begins to flow away.
• Make a tight fist with your right hand, squeeze it tightly. Note how
it feels (p) now relax. Hold for 7-10 seconds and then release for
75
15-20 seconds. Use these same time intervals for all other muscle
groups.
• Once again squeeze your hand tightly and study the tension that
you feel (p) and just relax and think of the tension disappearing
from your fingers. (p)
• Make a tight fist with your left hand, squeeze it as tightly as you
can and note the tension in your fingers and your hand and
forearm. (p) now relax (p).
• Once again, squeeze your fist tightly. And again just relax. (p).
• Now make a tight fist with your right hand and raise your hand.
Hold it tightly(p). now relax totally. Feel the warmth escaping
down through your upper arm, forearm and out of your finger. (p).
• Now make a tight fist with your left hand and raise your hand.
Hold it tightly and feel the tension (p) now relax. Concentrate on
the feelings flowing through your arm. (p).
• Now squeeze both fists at once and bend both arms to make them
totally tense through out. Hold it and think about the tension you
feel.(p). now relax, and feel the total warmth flowing through your
muscles. All the tension is flowing out of your fingertip. (p).
• Now wrinkle your forehead and squint your eyes very tight and
hard. Squeeze them tight and hold. Feel the tension across your
forehead and through your eyes. Now relax. Note the sensations
running through your eyes. Just relax. (p).
• Squeeze your jaws tight together and raise your chin to make your
neck muscles tight. Hold it bite down hard, tense your neck and
squeeze your lips really tight (p) now relax (p).
• Now all together wrinkle up your forehead and squeeze your eyes
tight, bite down hard with your jaws, raise your chin and tighten up
76
you neck and make your lips tight. Hold them all and feel the
tension throughout your forehead and eyes and jaw and neck and
lips. Hold. Now relax. Just totally relax and enjoy the tingling
sensation. (p).
• Now squeeze both shoulders forward as hard as you can until you
feel your muscles pulling tightly across your back, especially in the
area between your shoulder blades. Squeeze them tight. Now
relax(p).
• Now squeeze your shoulders forward again and at the same time
tighten your stomach muscles. Feel the tension through out your
stomach. Hold it (p) now relax (p).
• Once again squeeze your shoulders blades forward again, tighten
your stomach muscles and feel the tension through out your upper
body. Now relax (p).
• Now review all the muscle systems that we have covered so far.
First take three deep breaths (p). Tighten both fists and bend both
your arms to squeeze your biceps tight. Wrinkle your forehead and
squeeze. Keep your eyes tight. Bite down hard with your jaws,
raise your chin and hold your lips tight. Squeeze shoulders forward
and tighten your stomach muscles. Hold them all feel the tension
through out. Now relax. Take a deep breath. Just feel the tension
disappearing. Think about the total relaxation through out all your
muscles. Just relax (p)
• Now with the legs. Make right heel tight push it down hard, raise
your toes so that your calf muscles and thigh are extremely tense.
Squeeze your toes up and push your heel down hard. Now relax
(p).
77
• Once again make your left heel tight. Push it down hard, raise your
toes so that your calf and thigh muscles are extremely tense. Push
down on the heel and raise your toes. Now relax (p).
• Now make your heels tight and push them down and raise your
toes so that your calf and thighs are extremely tense. Push heel
down, squeeze your toes up and squeeze your leg in tight. Now
relax (p).
• Now do both legs together. Squeeze your heels in tight. Push down
on your heels and raise your toes as high and as tight as you can.
Hold it (p) now relax (p).
• Now take three deep breaths (p). now tense all the muscles exactly
as you have practiced, fists and biceps, forehead, eyes, jaws, neck,
lips, shoulders, stomach, legs. Hold it (p). now relax. (p).
• Breath in deeply three times. Notice how relaxed all your muscles
feel. Now once again tense every muscles and hold it (p) and relax.
Let all the tension disappear. Breath normally and enjoy the
complete tension, free state of your body and muscles. (p).
TERMINATION
Now slowly open your eyes. Slowly get up and sit for a while. Now you
are completely relaxed, fresh and comfortable.
Each pause is for 10 seconds.
78
ASSESSMENT OF INTENSITY OF PREMENSTRUAL
SYNDROME OF WOMEN IN EXPERIMENTAL GROUP
BIBLIOGRAPHY
79
BOOK REFERENCES
80
13. Doris, Klinger. S, Sharon and Brien. O. (2003). Premenstrual
syndrome diagnosis and interventions. 13th edition, London:
Mosby publications.
14. Dutta, D.C. (2003). Text book of obstetrics. 8th edition, New Delhi:
New central agency.
15. Enise, Polit, Hungler, (1999). Nursing research principles and
methods. 1st edition, Philadelphia: Gypnott company
publications.
16. Hamilton Mary Persis, (1989).Basic Maternity Nursing.6th edition,
Toronto: C.V. Mosby Company.
17. Indrani, T.K. (2003). Text Book of Midwifery.5th edition,New Delhi
: Jaypee Brothers Medical Publishers.
18. Jacob Annamma, (2009). Manual of Midwifery.1st edition,New
Delhi: Pearson Publishers.
19. Kumar Ranjith, (2005).Research Methodology.2nd edition,New
Delhi: Jaypee Publishers.
20. Laura, A. Talbot, (1995). Principle and practice of nursing
research. 11th edition, Texas: Mosby publications.
21. Leifer, (2005). Maternity Nursing. 9th edition, London: Elsevier
Saunders publications.
22. Monika Malhotra, (2003). Premenstrual syndrome in Obstetrics
and Gynaecology today. 12th edition, New Delhi: New central
agency.
23. Paderbidri.V, Ela Anand, (2006). Text book of obstetrics New
Delhi: B I publications .
24. Pilliteri Adele, (1999). Maternal and child health nursing. 12th
edition, Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott company.
25. Potter and Perry, (2002). Fundamentals of Nursing. 5th edition,
London: Mosby publications.
81
26. Prabhakara, G.N. (2006). Biostatistics.1st edition, New Delhi:
Jaypee Brothers.
27. Mindi Miller, (1994). Women’s Health Care.1st edition,
Philadelphia: Mosby Publications.
28. Morgan Mark. et.al., (2005). National Medical Series for
independent study Obstetrics and Gynaecology.5th edition, New
York: Lippincott Williams and Wilkins.
29. Reeder, J. Sharon, et al., (1992). Maternity Nursing. 17th edition,
Philadelphia: J.B. Lippincott Company.
30. Rose Mary Payne, A. (2000). Relaxation techniques. 2nd edition,
China: Churchill Livingstone company.
31. Sundar Rao, Richard, J. (1997). An introduction to Biostatistics, a
manual for students in health sciences. 3rd edition, Calcutta:
Prentice hall of India Pvt Ltd.
32. Strausz, K. Ivan, (1996). Women’s Symptoms. 1st edition,New
York: Dell Publishers.
33. Studd John, (1997). Progress in Obstetrics and Gynaecology. 1st
edition, New Delhi: B.L.Churchill Livingstone.
34. Symonds, E. Malcolm’s, (1998).Essential Obstetrics and
Gynaecology.1st edition, New York: Churchill Livingstone
35. Varney Helen, (2005). Varney’s Text Book of Midwifery. 4th
edition,New Delhi: All India Publishers and Distributors.
36. Wilhelm, H. (1999). The prevention & progress in Obstetrics and
Gynaecology. London: Churchill Livingstone.
37. Wong, C. Donne et al., (1998). Maternal and Child Health
Nursing. 1st edition, U.S.A : Mosby Publications.
JOURNAL REFERENCES
82
38. Andra, C. Zukerman, (April 2009). Warding off symptoms of
premenstrual syndrome by combination theory. American Journal
of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, 52(12), 508-511
39. Andra, J. Rapkin, et al., (June 2005). New treatment approaches
for premenstrual disorders. The American Journal of Managed
care, 11(1) 481
40. Bruce, Kessel, (August 2000). Premenstrual syndrome advances in
diagnosis and treatment. American Journal of Obstetrics and
Gynaecology,27,625-631
41. Cheryl, A. Cahill, (1998). Differences in cortisol, a stress hormone
in women Turmoil type premenstrual syndrome. Nursing
Research,47,278-284
42. Debra, et al., (January 2000). Calcium carbonate and premenstrual
syndrome. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, 2,
443-452.
43. Diana, C. Dell, (2004). Premenstrual syndrome, premenstrual
dysphoric disorder and premenstrual exacerbation of another
disorder. Clinical Obstetrics and Gynaecology, 3 (10), 568-575.
44. Diana, Taylor, (June 1999). Effectiveness of professional peer
group treatment : Research in Nursing and Health, 22(12), 496-
511.
45. Doris, Noel, et al., (November 1998). Premenstrual syndrome;
Diagnosis and intervention. The Nurse Practitioner, 23 (3), 40-58.
46. Elizebath, R. Berton Johnson, et al., (September 2004) Calcium
and vitamin intake and risk of incident of Premenstrual syndrome.
Archives of Internal Medicine, 165(52), 1246-1252.
47. Freeman, E.W. (2003). Premenstrual dysphoric disorder,
recognition and treatment: Primary care comparison Journal of
Clinical Psychiatry, 5, 30-39.
83
48. Gwen Goetz, et al., (February 2001). Changes in Meniere’s
disease response as a function of the menstrual cycle. Nursing
Research, 50(20), 286-291.
49. Jeffry, L. Raresitt, ( April 2002). Role of Psychotropic medication
in the treatment of affective symptoms in Premenstrual syndrome.
Clinical Obstetrics and Gynaecology , 35(3) 85-92.
50. Joseph, F. Mortola, ( June 2001). Issues in the diagnosis and
research of premenstrual syndrome. Clinical Obstetrics and
Gynaecology, 35(5), 587-597.
51. Lindsie Mary l, Tamilmani, (June 2009). R Evaluation of
Jacobson progressive muscle relaxation exercise in Premenstrual
syndrome. Asian Journal of obstetrics and gynaecology ,1(2) 73-76
52. Michael, E. Bernard, L. ( September 2009). Jacobson progressive
muscle relaxation exercise to alleviate premenstrual symptoms.
Journal of Cognitive behavior therapy , 7(2) 45-49
53. Muraki Hotomi, (July 2002). Relaxation techniques and
Premenstrual syndrome: Effects on premenstrual syndrome.
Journal of Nagoya Women’s University, 8(1) 705-707.
54. M.W. Ward, T.D. Holiman, (June 1998). Pharmacological
treatment for Premenstrual syndrome. The Annals of
pharmacotherapy, 33(13),1356-1358.
55. .Penland, et al., (1998). Relaxation techniques on menstrual cycle
symptoms. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, 5,
1417-1423.
56. Rasheed, R. et al., Prevalence and prediction of premenstrual
syndrome. The Indian Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology,
27(13), 32-36
84
57. Ritz, D.E. et al., (April 2006). Prevalence and impact of
premenstrual syndrome. Clinical Obstetrics and Gynaecology,
35(2) 85-92
58. Rubinow, R. Roy Byrne, P. Premenstrual syndrome: overview
from a methodologic perspective. American Journal of Psychiatry,
(1994). 4(2), 163-172.
59. Sellaro, R. Endicott, J. (August 2001). The epidemiology of
premenstrual psychological symptoms. American Journal of
Obstetrics and Gynaecological Nursing. 10(2), 110-116.
60. Singh, V.K. ( August 2002). Premenstrual syndrome; Diagnosis
and intervention. The Nurse Practitioner, 3 (3), 20-28
61. Sueda Kaori, (April 2005). The role of relaxation exercise in
premenstrual syndrome. Journal of Nagoya Women’s University,
51(9), 45-54
62. Yakir, et al., (June 2003). The Annals of pharmacotherapy, 24(5),
54-59
NET REFERENCES
86
73. Klein Laansma, C.T. Jansen, J.C. ( July 2005) Semi standardized
homeopathic treatment of premenstrual syndrome. Women’s
health, 99(3), from http://medline/ebm.com
74. Koga, S. Yaegashi, N. ( August 2008). Prevalence of Premenstrual
syndrome and premenstrual dysphoric disorder. The American
Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, 13, from
http://www.medline/ebm.com
75. Lundman, B. (June 2009). Women’s Perception of Phenomina
They Label Premenstrual Tension: Normal Experiences Reflecting
Ordinary Behaviour. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 30 (23), from
http:// www.body and fitness. com
76. Morse. C. A. et al., (April 2002). coping skill training and
relaxation for premenstrual syndrome. Journal of behavioral
therapy, 27(7), from http://www.pubmed.com
77. Reif, M. Martinez, A. (August 2000) Premenstrual symptoms are
relieved by massage therapy. Journal of Psychosomatic Obstetrics
and Gynaecology, 21, from, http: // www.pubmed.com.
78. Robinson, A. (April 2007).Natural Remedies for Premenstrual
syndrome.Women’s Health, 11, from http://www.
Altmedicine.about.com/a/PMS.htm
79. Schellenberg, R. (August 2008). Treatment for the Premenstrual
syndrome with Agnus castus fruit extract: prospective,
randomized, placebo controlled study, 31, from http: //
www.pubmed.com
80. Simpson, N. Dye, L. (April 2000) The efficacy of Hypericum
perforatum (St John's wort) for the treatment of premenstrual
syndrome. American Journal of women’s health, 14 from http: //
www.nursing center. com
87
88