The document compares Eastern and Western views of the self across several dimensions. It provides examples of philosophical schools and notable philosophers from both traditions. The key differences are that Eastern views see the self as sociocentric and interconnected with others and nature, while Western views are more egocentric and emphasize individualism. Eastern thought also views the universe as cyclical rather than linear and prioritizes intuition over reason.
The document compares Eastern and Western views of the self across several dimensions. It provides examples of philosophical schools and notable philosophers from both traditions. The key differences are that Eastern views see the self as sociocentric and interconnected with others and nature, while Western views are more egocentric and emphasize individualism. Eastern thought also views the universe as cyclical rather than linear and prioritizes intuition over reason.
The document compares Eastern and Western views of the self across several dimensions. It provides examples of philosophical schools and notable philosophers from both traditions. The key differences are that Eastern views see the self as sociocentric and interconnected with others and nature, while Western views are more egocentric and emphasize individualism. Eastern thought also views the universe as cyclical rather than linear and prioritizes intuition over reason.
Asia Europe Raises questions about the ultimate Conducts scientific investigation to meaning of life understand the self and developed Theories about “what it means to be theories and difference among them a human being” Importance of scientific methods to Relational rather than individual provide answers to understanding the Highly practical self Social roles They want an authentic evidence Collectivistic: group and social Duality: you are distinct from others relations are important Talks about personal attributes Values cooperation and hierarchy Individualistic: focus on the person Holistic thinking Analytical thinking
Eastern Concept of the Self
Hinduism The religion of ancient people known as the Aryans Also the third world largest religion with over 1.25 billion followers (80% of the world) Oldest religion From India Believes in the law of karma Law of Karma – most important doctrine in Hinduism Dharma – goodness Atman (soul/spirit) – Hindus believe that Atman being an immortal continues to be reincarnated from lifetime to lifetime until it is freed from the cycle of rebirth and reach a state of nirvana or non-birth Reincarnation – reborn in another body Karma does not end with a body’s death; its influence may extend through incarnation of the soul Nirvana- concept of heaven Buddhism Founded by Siddhartha Gautama Buddhism comes from the root word “budh” meaning awake All people have a seed of enlightenment – everyone has a potential to be Buddha 5 parts that compose the individual: 1. Matter/Form – own physical form 2. Sensation – made up of our feelings and emotion 3. Perception – thinking, cognition and reasoning 4. Mental constructs – habit, prejudice and willingness 5. Consciousness – awareness of sense to an object They believe that they have no self (soul) There is only nothing and all else is an illusion Nothing is permanent, but change Annica – impermanence; means that everything in life is always changing, nothing lasts forever ; ideal taught by Buddha The ideal is to experience Nirvana(heaven), a state of transcendence devoid of self-reference Nirvana can be achieved through meditation When a person’s desires and sufferings go away and they want nothing more (achieving the state of nirvana) From India Confucianism Philosophy and belief system from ancient china Founder is Confucius Regarded as a social and ethical philosophy rather than religion Golden rule (principle of reciprocity): “do not do to others what you would not want others to do to you” The individual’s greatest mission of attaining self-realization wherein self- cultivation is instrumental Self-cultivation – could be accomplished by knowing one’s role in the society and act accordingly Moral character is perfected through continuously taking every opportunity to improve oneself in thought and action Categories on how to the terms “Self” 1. Analytical 2. Individuality 3. Monotheistic 4. Rationalistic Yi – heart and righteousness Li – heart and property Len – heart and compassion Anih – heart and wisdom Taoism An ancient tradition of philosophy and religious belief attributed to Lao Tzu From China Believes that the self is an extension of the cosmos, not of social relationships Self as one of the limitless forms of the Tao The Tao – is commonly regarded as a nature that is the foundation of all that exists Perfect man has no self and the selfless person leads to a balanced life, in harmony with nature There should be unity and harmony among opposing elements; the Yin and Yang Yin – inward energy (Feminine, dark and negativity); black Yang – outward energy (Masculine, hot and bright energy); white Dimension Western Eastern Frame of reference There is a separation between Religion and philosophy are philosophy and religion/spirituality intertwined Example of school of Scholasticism Buddhism thought Rationalism Hinduism Empiricism Confucianism Phenomenology Taoism
Notable philosophers Socrates Confucius
Plato Lao Tzu Aristotle Siddhartha Gautama Rene Descartes (Buddha) John Locke Source of knowledge Reason rather than faith to pursue Trusted intuition associate wisdom with religious beliefs Modes of cognition Analytic and deductive Synthetic and inductive
View of the universe and linear Circular
life View of self egocentric Sociocentric Theological view Monotheistic Polytheistic (pluralistic)
ideal Self-actualization through personal To achieve a balanced life
growth and find one’s role in society Cultural framework individualism Collectivism
Balanced diet – consuming the right food at the right time and in the right proportion; should contain nutrients Water Sleep
Emotion management strategies
1. Smile to make yourself feel god 2. Smile to make others feel good 3. Get up and move 4. Check in with your body 5. Physically remove the tension 6. Breathe 7. Talk to someone 8. Disengage and re-engage emotions 9. Label your emotions 10. Label emotions for others
The Philosophical View of Self
Socrates: Know Yourself - Socrates is principally concerned with man. He considers from the point of his inner life. His famous life, “Know yourself”, tells each man to bring his inner self to light - A bad man is not virtuous through ignorance; the man who does not follow the good fails to do so because he does not recognize it - The core of socratic ethics is the concept of virtue and knowledge - Virtue is the deepest and most basic propensity of man. Knowing one’s virtue is necessary and can be learned Plato: the ideal self, the perfect self - Man in this life should imitate his former self, he should live a life of virtue in which true human perfection exists - Happiness is the fruit of virtue Immanuel Kant: Respect for self - Man is the only creature who directs and governs himself and his actions, who sets up ends for himself and his purpose, and who freely orders means for the attainment of his aims - Respect others as you would respect yourself Rene Descartes: “I think , therefore I am” - Self is a thinking entity distinct from the body - First famous principle, “Cogito, ergo sum”, which means “I think, therefore I am” John Locke: Personal Identity - Holds that personal identity (self) is a matter of psychological continuity. Personal identity is founded on memory and not on the substance of either the soul or the body - Personal identity is the concept of oneself that evolves over the course of an individual’s life David Hume: The Self is the Bundle Theory Of Mind - Hume is skeptical about the existence of life, specifically, on whether there is a simple, unified self that exists over time - Man has no “clear and intelligible” idea of the self
The Christian of Biblical View of Self
The Holy Bible The crown creation of self Religious Aesthetic Moral Sentiment Sensual and sexual Economic Social Intellectual Political Spiritual Rational Physical Emotional St. Augustine: Love and Justice as the foundation of the Individual Self - Virtuous life is a dynamism of love. It is a constant following of and turning towards love while a wicked life is a constant turning away from love Sigmund Freud: The psychoanalytic theory of self - Humans psyche (personality) is structured into three parts (tripartite) 1. Id (internal desires) – also called internal drives or instinctive drives, consists of the body’s primitive biological drives and urges which are concerned only with achieving pleasure and self-satisfaction. It lives completely in the unconscious 2. Ego (reality) – it is the “I” part of the individual that gives him/her the sense of identity. The ego is rational part of the personality 3. Supergo (conscience) – part of the personality concerned with morals, precepts, standards and ideas. It is a critical faculty of the personality Freduian Stages of Psychosexual Development Fred also argues that the development of an individual can be divided into distinct stages characterized by sexual drives 1. Oral (0-1) 2. Anal (Expulsive phase; 2-3) 3. Phallic – gets curious about genitals and becomes attached to the parents of the opposite sex (3-6) Oedipus complex – attraction of boy to his mother Electra complex – attraction of girl to her father 4. Latency – sexual motivations (10-12) 5. Genital – heterosexual relations (after puberty) Erik Erikson: The psychosocial stages of self-development - Concerned with how both psychological and social factors affect the development of individuals Development stage Age
Pre-natal period Conception to birth
Infancy Birth to second wee
Babyhood End of second week to end of the second year
Early childhood or preschool age 2-6 years
Late childhood or elementary age 6-10 or 12 years
Puberty or preadolescence 12 or 13 to 14years
Adolescence 13-14 or 18 years
Early adulthood 18-40 years
Middle age 40-60 years
Old age or senescence 60 years to death
Fourteen intelligent behaviors
Behavior is defined as the manner in which a person conducts himself/herself in various instruments 1. Persistence 2. Overcoming impulsiveness 3. Listening to others 4. Flexibility in thinking 5. Metacognition 6. Checking for accuracy and precision 7. Questioning and problem posing 8. Applying past knowledge to new situations 9. Precision of language and thought 10. Using all senses 11. Creativity 12. Living with a sense of wonderment 13. Cooperation 14. Sense of humor