TAX3761 EXAM PACK JPJBLF
TAX3761 EXAM PACK JPJBLF
Calculation of the normal tax liability of Barika (Pty) Ltd for the 2019 year of assessment.
R R
Service fees 1 890 000
Advertising (s11(a)) (23 000) (1)
Salaries (s11(a)) (500 000) (1)
Restraint of trade (s11(cA)) Lesser of: R400 000/2 or
R400 000/3 (133 333) (2)
Bad debts (s11(i)) (8 000) (1)
Debtor allowance previous year (s11(j)) (R18 000 x 25%) 4 500 (1)
Debtor allowance current year (s11(j)) (R25 000 x 25% x 90%) (5 625) (2)
Available [23]
Total [22]
The income tax rates applicable to a small business corporation are as follows:
PART B (8 marks)
R R
Taxable income Given 1 700 000
Machine SOL
Capital allowance – S12C R430 000 x 40% (172 000) (1)
Machine PAN
Cost price (R570 000 x 100/114) 500 000 (1)
Capital allowance S12C: 2017-2019: R500 000 x 20% x 3 (300 000) (1)
2020: R500 000 x 20% (100 000) (100 000) (1)
Tax value 100 000
Insurance payment received (630 000)
Recoupment 530 000 (1)
Limited to previous allowances 400 000
Recoupment deferred (R400 000 x 40%) 160 000 (1)
Available [10]
Total [8]
QUESTION 2 (20 marks)
Carry on a trade Rosemary Hill (Pty) Ltd sells second-hand furniture, therefore carries
(1)111on a
trade. (1)
Expenditure or Rosemary Hill (Pty) Ltd paid an amount of R103 040 to Electric4all (Joffe &
losses Co). (2)
Actually incurred The taxpayer paid R103 040 on 29 February 2020 and therefore the
expense was paid by Rosemary Hill (Pty) Ltd (Caltex Oil). (2)
During the year of The amount was paid on 29 February 2020, which is within the 2020 year
assessment of assessment.
The payment is for the 6-month period from 1 March 2020 to
31 August 2020.
Therefore, only R103 040 x 1/6 = R17 173 (1-month) relates to the 2020
year of assessment.
And R103 040 x 5/6 = R85 867 (5-months) relates to the 2021 year of
assessment (subject to section 23H as discussed below). (6)
In the production of The expense is closely linked to the operating income of the business. The
income payment is in the production of income (PE Electric Tramway). (2)
Not of a capital No enduring benefit for the company and therefore not of a capital nature
nature (Sub-Nigel) (2)
Section 23 Section 23H may delay the deduction in the determination of taxable income
or prepaid expenses until the following year of assessment.
Section 23H does not apply and the prepayment will be deductible. (5)
Conclusion As section 23H does not apply and Rosemary Hill (Pty) Ltd has actually paid
the amount of R103 040 and has an on-going legal liability to pay that (1)
amount, the prepayment qualifies as a deduction in the 2020 year of
assessment in terms of section 11(a).
Available [21]
Total [20]
QUESTION 3 (34 marks)
a) Calculation of Norman’s taxable income for the year of assessment ended 29 February 2020
(24 marks)
R R
Salary 90 000
Accumulated leave pay 19 800 (1)
Life insurance (capital – excluded) 0 (1)
Use of motor vehicle:
R405 882 x 85% (1) x 3.25% (1) x 2mths (1) 22 425
Less: Business usage
(R22 425 x (1 800km - 600km)/1 800km (1) (14 950)
7 475
Less: Fuel 600km (1) x R1.335* (1) (801)
* Determined value = R405 882 x 85% = R345 000 6 674 6 674
Foreign dividends (R1 975 x 50%) (1) - (R1 975 x 50% x 25/45) (1) 439
Provident fund fringe benefit 4 200 (1)
121 113
Less: Retirement fund contributions
PART A (5 marks)
• The 2019 year of assessment cannot be used as it was issued less than 14
days prior to the date of the estimate. (1)
• The 2018 year of assessment can be used as it was issued more than 14
days prior to the date of the estimate. Not more than 18 months have passed
from 28 February 2018 to 31 August 2019. (1)
Taxable income less taxable severance benefit less taxable capital gain
= basic amount.
R720 000 (1) - R110 000 (1) - R80 000 (1) = R530 000
PART B (5 marks)
R
Car donated to Shaun – donatio mortis causa 420 000 (1)
Residence in Johannesburg
Market value 5 100 000 (1)
Proceeds from fixed property in Botswana 1 200 000 (1)
Shares in private company – valued by independent valuer 400 000 (1)
Gross value of the estate 7 120 000
Less: Deductions
Value of improvements by beneficiary (180 000) (1)
Fixed property in Botswana inherited from non-resident (1 200 000) (1)
Master’s fees and Executor’s remuneration (347 000) (1)
Net value of estate 5 393 000
Available [7]
Total [5]
PART C (6 marks)
a) The 10% rental income paid to Dorothy, will be taxed in her hands (1) in terms of section 7(2), it is
not mainly paid for the reduction of Mr Amanzi's tax liability. (1)
b) The 10% rental income paid to Lisa, will be taxed in Mr Amanzi's hands. The deeming provisions
of s7(3) apply as she is a minor in terms of section 7(3). (1)
c) The R10 000 monthly annuity paid from dividend income to Winnie, will be taxed in Mr Nkosi's
hands, as the payments are made mainly to reduce his tax liability in terms of section 7(4). (1) As
the dividends are paid in the form of an annuity, no dividend exemption is available. (1)
d) The 10% rental income paid to Rendani, will be taxed in Mr Nkosi’s hands, as Rendani is a minor
child of Mr Nkosi and Mr Amanzi and Mr Nkosi have made reciprocal (cross) donations in terms of
section 7(4). (1)
e) The dividend income retained in the trust, will be taxed in Mr Nkosi’s hands in terms of section 7(5),
income arising from a donation that has a condition linked to it. (1) He can use the dividend
exemption (1) against this income.
Available [8]
Total [6]
UNIVERSITY EXAMINATIONS
TAX3761
Taxation of Business Activities and Individuals
100 Marks
Duration 3 Hours
This paper consists of nine (9) pages plus the annexure A (p i).
IMPORTANT INSTRUCTIONS:
Assumptions:
1. All amounts exclude Value-Added Tax (VAT) unless specifically stated otherwise.
2. The VAT rate changed from 14% to 15% on 1 April 2018.
3. All persons mentioned are residents of the Republic of South Africa unless stated otherwise.
4. SARS = South African Revenue Service.
7. Proposed timetable:
This question comprises two independent parts, namely Part A and Part B.
Barika (Pty) Ltd (“Barika”) is a recruitment agency, specialising in locating young entrepreneurs in rural
areas. Their main business focus on Gauteng and the surrounding areas. The company is a small busi-
ness corporation as defined in the Income Tax Act and its financial year ends on the last day of December.
Barika is a registered VAT vendor making only taxable supplies. All amounts exclude VAT, unless other-
wise stated.
You are provided with a list of income and expenses of Barika for the financial year ending on
31 December 2019:
Expenses
Advertising 1 (23 000)
Salaries (500 000)
Restraint of trade 2 (450 000)
Bad debts 3 (8 000)
Lease payments 4 ?
Legal expenses 5 (13 000)
Service contracts 6 (140 000)
Depreciation 7 (33 000)
Notes:
1. Advertising
Barika paid an amount of R23 000 to an advertising company to create posters to advertise its busi-
ness to local entrepreneurs.
2. Restraint of trade
Barika made a restraint of trade payment of R450 000 to one of their lead recruiters, Mr Chauke, on
31 August 2019. Mr Chauke was restrained from competing with the company for two years from
the date of the payment. Only R400 000 will constitute ‘income’ as defined in the hands of Mr
Chauke.
3. Bad debts
The company does not apply IFRS 9 accounting standards and 90% of the doubtful debts have been
in arrears for more than 60 days, but not more than 120 days. An allowance for doubtful debts were
allowed by SARS in the previous year of assessment.
3 TAX3761/201
QUESTION 1 (continued)
4. Lease payments
Barika entered into a lease contract with RENT (Pty) Ltd to occupy an office building from
1 February 2019 for a period of five years (Refer to note 6).
The leasehold improvements commenced on 1 March 2019 and were completed at a total cost of
R320 000 on 31 October 2019. The improvements were brought into use on 31 October 2019.
5. Legal expenses
The legal costs have been incurred for drawing up the lease contract (Refer to note 4).
6. Service contracts
7. Depreciation
• Second-hand furniture purchased for R80 000 (including VAT) on 15 June 2017.
• New computers for the company were purchased for a total value of R65 000 on 1 September 2018
from a non-vendor.
Binding General Ruling No. 7 makes provision for the following write-off periods:
• Computer…………………………………………………………. 3 years
• Furniture………………………………………………………….. 6 years
Additional information:
The company made a first provisional tax payment of R40 000 on 30 June 2019 and a second provisional
tax payment of R35 000 on 31 December 2019 in respect of the 2019 year of assessment.
REQUIRED: MARKS
Calculate the normal income tax liability of Barika (Pty) Ltd for the 2019 year of assessment. 22
4
QUESTION 1 (continued)
i-Solar (Pty) Ltd (“i-Solar”) manufactures solar panels that are mainly used to heat geysers. This is a
process of manufacture approved by SARS. The company is not a small business corporation as
defined in the Income Tax Act and its financial year ends on the last day of February. i-Solar is a registered
VAT vendor making only taxable supplies.
You are the tax auditor of i-Solar and your assistant manager calculated the taxable income correctly as
R1 700 000 for the year ending 29 February 2020, before taking the following into account:
• i-Solar purchased a new machine (Machine SOL) for R430 000 (excluding VAT) on 1 December 2019.
The machine is used in the manufacturing process. Machine SOL was purchased to replace Machine
PAN. Machine PAN was destroyed during a fire at the factory on 15 November 2019. Machine PAN
was purchased second-hand from a non-vendor for R570 000 (including VAT) on 20 April 2016.
i-Solar received R630 000 from its insurance company for Machine PAN on 30 November 2019.
REQUIRED: MARKS
Calculate i-Solar (Pty) Ltd’s taxable income for the 2020 year of assessment. The company
elects that the provisions of paragraph 66 of the Eighth Schedule to the Income Tax Act
should apply. 8
Rosemary Hill (Pty) Ltd sells second-hand furniture. Rosemary Hill’s financial year ends on the last day
of March and is a registered VAT vendor making only taxable supplies.
On 29 February 2020, the company paid an amount of R103 040 in advance to Electric4all Ltd for electricity
to be supplied during the six-month period from 1 March 2020 to 31 August 2020 relating to the property
it occupies for the purposes of its trade in selling second-hand furniture.
REQUIRED: MARKS
Discuss, supported with calculations and relevant legislation and case law principles,
whether the amount of R103 040 paid by Rosemary Hill (Pty) Ltd will qualify as a deduction
from the company’s taxable income for the 2020 year of assessment. In addition, consider
any other specific deduction in which the amount can be deductible. 20
5 TAX3761/201
Norman (54 years old) was involved in a fatal motor vehicle accident on 30 April 2019. He is survived by
his wife, Lucia, and by his 16-year-old daughter. Norman and Lucia were married in community of proper-
ty.
Norman was a full-time salaried employee at a private company until the date of his death. Details of
Norman’s receipts and/or accruals and expenses from the beginning of the 2020 year of assessment until
30 April 2019 were as follows:
Note R
Receipts and/or accruals and benefits
Salary 90 000
Accumulated leave pay 1 19 800
Life insurance 2 600 000
Use of motor vehicle 3 ?
Details of Lucia’s receipts and/or accruals until the date of Norman’s death:
R
Receipts and/or accruals
Foreign dividends (from a unit trust portfolio) (not a tax free investment) 1 975
Notes:
On 29 April 2019, Norman received R18 000 instead of leave that he had not taken.
2. Life insurance
Norman paid (non-deductible) insurance premiums to cover his own life, for the past 20 years. As a result
of his death, R600 000 was paid out by the insurer.
Norman received the free use of a company vehicle on 1 March 2019. The vehicle was purchased by his
employer 18 months ago at a cost of R405 882 (VAT inclusive). Norman received the right of use until the
date of his death. The vehicle was subject to a maintenance plan. Norman kept a valid and accurate
logbook, which indicated that he travelled a total of 1 800 kilometres during the period, of which 600 kilo-
metres were in respect of private trips. Norman had to pay all fuel costs for the period, which amounted
to R2 100.
6
QUESTION 3 (continued)
Norman’s total contributions to a provident fund, from 1 March 2019 until the date of his death, amounted
to R4 200. His employer also paid a total amount of R4 200 to the provident fund on his behalf.
During the same period, Norman also contributed R30 000 to a retirement annuity fund. Norman's
employer is not aware of this contribution.
For the purpose of these contributions only, you may assume that his remuneration for the period
amounted to R131 940 (correctly calculated).
5. Medical expenses
Norman was a member of a registered medical scheme. His membership terminated on the date of his
death.
Norman’s wife and daughter were registered as dependants on the medical scheme. No member of the
family has a disability as defined.
The following is an extract from Norman’s medical scheme tax certificate for the 2020 year of assessment:
R
• Medical scheme contributions by Norman 5 400
• Qualifying medical expenses not reimbursed by the medical scheme 8 000
13 400
Norman's employer is not aware of his medical scheme contributions or qualifying medical expenses.
REQUIRED: MARKS
a) Calculate Norman’s net normal tax liability for the 2020 year of assessment. 24
QUESTION 4 (continued)
Stella’s employer deducted employees’ tax amounting to R58 000 for the first six months of the 2020
year of assessment.
REQUIRED: MARKS
a) Calculate the basic amount that Stella would use for her first provisional tax return
for the 2020 year of assessment.
b) Provide brief reasons as to why a particular year of assessment was, or was not
selected, in the determination of the basic amount. 5
Ofentse (aged 52 years) died of a sudden heart attack on 4 February 2020. He was a South African
resident throughout his life.
• On 28 December 2019, Ofentse entered his first 100 kilometre cycling race. He was worried that he
might not survive the race because of his weak heart. Before the race, he promised his son, Shaun,
that he could have his car should he pass away due to a heart attack. The car was valued at
R450 000 on 28 December 2019.
At the date of Ofentse’s death, on 4 February 2020, the car was valued at R420 000.
Accept that the only liabilities in the estate are Master’s fees and executor’s remuneration of R347 000
(correctly calculated).
REQUIRED: MARKS
QUESTION 4 (continued)
You are a tax practitioner and one of your clients asks for your advice regarding the tax consequences of
transactions in the Amanzi and Nkosi Trust.
• Mr Amanzi and Mr Nkosi, both 45 years old and best friends and business partners, founded the
trust on 1 March 2018.
o Mr Amanzi,
o Mr Nkosi, and
o Their accountant.
o Mr Amanzi's wife, Dorothy, 40 years old, to whom he is married out of community of property.
Dorothy is unable to work due to a physical impairment preventing her.
o Mr Amanzi's daughter, Lisa, 14 years old and still in high school.
o Mr Nkosi's wife, Winnie, 41 years old, to whom he is married out of community of property.
Winnie does not work and she is a beneficiary mainly for reducing her husband's tax liability.
o Mr Nkosi's stepdaughter, Jeanne, 18 years old and working in Johannesburg (she is not
married).
o Mr Nkosi's son, Rendani, 15 years old and still in high school.
- A block of flats to the value of R10 million. Mr Amanzi donated the block of flats to the trust on
1 March 2018.
- A portfolio of shares listed on the JSE Ltd stock exchange of R12 million. Mr Nkosi donated this
investment to the trust on 1 March 2018.
o Each beneficiary has a vested right of 5% of the rental income and 5% of the dividend income,
which has not been distributed to beneficiaries at the end of the year.
o The trust deed has a condition that it remains in existence until Lisa turns 40, after which the
trust assets and any retained income (excluding vested amounts) must be divided equally
between the surviving beneficiaries (Lisa, Jeanne and Rendani’s vested rights accrue to their
estates should they die before this time).
9 TAX3761/201
QUESTION 4 (continued)
REQUIRED: MARKS
SCHEDULES
The income tax rates applicable to a small business corporation are as follows:
• 0% on taxable income not exceeding R79 000
• 7% on taxable income exceeding R79 000; but not exceeding R365 000
• R20 020 plus 21% on taxable income exceeding R365 001; but not exceeding R550 000
• R58 583 plus 28% on taxable income exceeding R550 000
Where the taxable income does not exceed R195 850 18% of each R1 of the taxable income;
R35 253 plus 26% of the amount by which the
exceeds R195 850 but does not exceed R305 850 .... taxable income exceeds R195 850;
R63 853 plus 31% of the amount by which the
exceeds R305 850 but does not exceed R423 300 .... taxable income exceeds R305 850;
R100 263 plus 36% of the amount by which the
exceeds R423 300 but does not exceed R555 600 .... taxable income exceeds R423 300;
R147 891 plus 39% of the amount by which the
exceeds R555 600 but does not exceed R708 310 .... taxable income exceeds R555 600;
R207 448 plus 41% of the amount by which the
exceeds R708 310 but does not exceed R1 500 000 . taxable income exceeds R708 310;
R532 041 plus 45% of the amount by which the
exceed R1 500 000 .................................................... taxable income exceeds R1 500 000.
Scale of values
Value of private use per month, vehicle not subject to maintenance plan = 3.5% x determined value
Value of private use per month, vehicle subject to maintenance plan = 3.25% x determined value
Daily allowance for food and incidental cost is R435 per day.
D. REBATES
Persons 75 and over (R14 220 + R7 794 + R2 601 ) ........................................................... R24 615
Maximum market value of all assets allowed within Definition of “small business” R10 million
the small business definition on disposal when in paragraph 57(1) of Eighth
person 55 years or older Schedule
Exclusion amount on disposal of small business Paragraph 57(3) of Eighth R1 800 000
when person 55 years or older schedule
Retirement savings thresholds:
Deductible retirement fund contributions:
Members of retirement funds may deduct their
contributions subject to certain percentage or
monetary ceilings
Monetary ceiling for total contributions to retirement Proviso to section 11F R350 000
funds
Deductible business expenses for individuals:
Car allowance:
Individuals receive an annual vehicle allowance to
defray business travel expenses, including deemed
depreciation on the vehicle.
Ceiling on vehicle cost Section 8(1)(b)(iiiA)(bb)(A) R595 000
Ceiling on debt relating to vehicle cost Section 8(1)(b)(iiiA)(bb)(B) R595 000
13 TAX3761/201
G. DECEASED ESTATES
The rate of estate duty shall be 20 per cent on the first R30 million of the dutiable amount of the
estate and 25% on the excess above R30 million.
Provided that where duty becomes payable upon the value of any movable or immovable property
or on a value determined by reference to the value of any movable or immovable property, and duty
has, upon the death of any person (hereinafter referred to as the first-dying person), who died within
ten years prior to the death of the deceased, become payable upon the value of that move-able or
immovable property or upon a value determined by reference to the value of that movable or
immovable property (or any movable or immovable property for which the Commissioner is satisfied
that that movable or immovable property has been substituted), the duty attributable to the value of
that movable or immovable property or, as the case may be, the value determined by reference to
the value of that movable or immovable property, but not exceeding (in either case) an amount equal
to the value on which duty has become payable on the death of the first-dying person, shall be
reduced by a percentage according to the following scale:
if the deceased dies within two years of the death of the first-dying person 100 per cent
if the deceased dies more than two years but not more than four years
after the death of the first-dying person 80 per cent
if the deceased dies more than four years but not more than six years
after the death of the first-dying person 60 per cent
if the deceased dies more than six years but not more than eight years
after the death of the first-dying person 40 per cent
if the deceased dies more than eight years but not more than ten years
after the death of the first-dying person 20 per cent
subject to a maximum reduction equal to so much of the duty previously payable upon the death of
the first-dying person as is attributable to the value of that movable or immovable property or, as the
case may be, to an amount equal to the value determined by reference to the value of that movable
or immovable property, and as is proved to the satisfaction of the Commissioner to have been borne
by the deceased.
15 TAX3761/201
TABLE A
THE EXPECTATION OF LIFE AND THE PRESENT VALUE OF R1 PER ANNUM FOR LIFE CAPITALI-
SED AT 12 PER CENT OVER THE EXPECTATION OF LIFE OF MALES AND FEMALES OF VARIOUS
AGES
Expectation of life Present value of R1 per annum for life
Age Male Female Male Female Age
0 64,75 72,36 8,237 91 8,331 05 0
1 65,37 72,74 8,328 28 8,331 14 1
2 64,50 71,87 8,327 76 8,330 91 2
3 63,57 70,93 8,327 14 8,330 64 3
4 62,63 69,98 8,326 44 8,330 33 4
5 61,69 69,02 8,325 67 8,329 99 5
6 60,74 68,06 8,324 80 8,329 61 6
7 59,78 67,09 8,323 81 8,329 81 7
8 58,81 66,11 8,322 71 8,328 69 8
9 57,83 65,14 8,321 46 8,328 15 9
10 56,85 64,15 8,320 07 8,327 53 10
11 55,86 63,16 8,318 49 8,326 84 11
12 54,87 62,18 8,316 73 8,326 08 12
13 53,90 61,19 8,314 80 8,325 22 13
14 52,93 60,21 8,312 65 8,324 27 14
15 51,98 59,23 8,310 29 8,323 20 15
16 51,04 58,26 8,307 70 8,322 03 16
17 50,12 57,29 8,304 89 8,320 71 17
18 49,21 56,33 8,301 80 8,319 26 18
19 48,31 55,37 8,298 41 8,317 64 19
20 47,42 54,41 8,294 71 8,315 84 20
21 46,53 53,45 8,290 61 8,313 83 21
22 45,65 52,50 8,286 13 8,311 61 22
23 44,77 51,54 8,281 17 8,309 12 23
24 43,88 50,58 8,275 64 8,306 33 24
25 43,00 49,63 8,269 59 8,303 26 25
26 42,10 48,67 8,262 74 8,299 81 26
27 41,20 47,71 8,255 16 8,295 95 27
28 40,30 46,76 8,246 77 8,291 71 28
29 39,39 45,81 8,237 37 8,286 97 29
30 38,48 44,86 8,226 94 8,281 70 30
31 37,57 43,91 8,215 38 8,275 83 31
32 36,66 42,96 8,202 57 8,269 30 32
33 35,75 42,02 8,188 36 8,262 10 33
34 34,84 41,07 8,172 62 8,254 00 34
35 33,94 40,13 8,155 36 8,245 09 35
36 33,05 39,19 8,136 47 8,235 17 36
37 32,16 38,26 8,115 58 8,224 26 37
38 31,28 37,32 8,092 74 8,211 99 38
39 30,41 36,40 8,067 81 8,198 66 39
40 29,54 35,48 8,040 30 8,183 86 40
41 28,69 34,57 8,010 67 8,167 62 41
42 27,85 33,67 7,978 44 8,149 83 42
43 27,02 32,77 7,943 44 8,130 12 43
44 26,20 31,89 7,905 47 8,108 81 44
16
TABLE A (continued)
Expectation of life Present value of R1 per annum for life
Age Male Female Male Female Age
45 25,38 31,01 7,863 80 8,085 27 45
46 24,58 30,14 7,819 24 8,059 56 46
47 23,79 29,27 7,771 09 8,031 19 47
48 23,00 28,41 7,718 43 8,000 26 48
49 22,23 27,55 7,662 36 7,966 17 49
50 21,47 26,71 7,602 01 7,929 50 50
51 20,72 25,88 7,537 13 7,889 67 51
52 19,98 25,06 7,467 48 7,846 46 52
53 19,26 24,25 7,393 87 7,799 65 53
54 18,56 23,44 7,316 31 7,748 34 54
55 17,86 22,65 7,232 34 7,693 55 55
56 17,18 21,86 7,144 14 7,633 63 56
57 16,52 21,08 7,051 78 7,568 96 57
58 15,86 20,31 6,952 25 7,499 27 58
59 15,23 19,54 6,850 04 7,423 21 59
60 14,61 18,78 6,742 06 7,341 35 60
61 14,01 18,04 6,630 10 7,254 57 61
62 13,42 17,30 6,512 32 7,160 20 62
63 12,86 16,58 6,393 01 7,060 46 63
64 12,31 15,88 6,268 22 6,955 37 64
65 11,77 15,18 6,137 89 6,841 61 65
66 11,26 14,51 6,007 26 6,723 93 66
67 10,76 13,85 5,871 65 6,598 93 67
68 10,28 13,20 5,734 03 6,466 35 68
69 9,81 12,57 5,591 82 6,328 18 69
70 9,37 11,96 5,451 65 6,184 66 70
71 8,94 11,37 5,307 75 6,036 07 71
72 8,54 10,80 6,167 44 5,882 78 72
73 8,15 10,24 5,024 37 5,722 22 73
74 7,77 9,70 4,878 76 5,557 43 74
75 7,41 9,18 4,734 90 5,388 93 75
76 7,07 8,68 4,593 54 5,217 27 76
77 6,73 8,21 4,446 63 5,046 79 77
78 6,41 7,75 4,303 09 4,870 92 78
79 6,10 7,31 4,158 98 4,693 89 79
80 5,82 6,89 4,024 40 4,516 47 80
81 5,55 6,50 3,890 51 4,343 99 81
82 5,31 6,13 3,768 02 4,173 15 82
83 5,09 5,78 3,652 76 4,004 82 83
84 4,89 5,45 3,545 46 3,839 88 84
85 4,72 5,14 3,452 32 3,679 21 85
86 4,57 4,85 3,368 64 3,523 71 86
87 4,45 4,58 3,300 66 3,374 26 87
88 4,36 4,33 3,249 07 3,231 75 88
89 4,32 4,11 3,225 97 3,102 96 89
90 4,30 3,92 3,214 38 2,989 12 90
0
TABLE B
PRESENT VALUE OF R1 PER ANNUM CAPITALISED AT 12 PER CENT OVER FIXED PERIODS
Skhothana (Pty) Ltd (Skhothana) is a South African company that imports luxury fashion
clothing brands from overseas to resell locally. Skhothana is registered for Value-Added Tax
(VAT) on the invoice basis and has a two-month tax period. The following amounts relate to
receipts and payments for the two-month period ending 31 March 2014.
Where applicable, all amounts are exclusive of VAT, unless otherwise stated.
Receipts Notes R
Cash sales 150 000
Credit sales 490 000
Rentals 1 140 400
Loan from Qhoma bank 2 100 000
Equity contributions from shareholders 2 150 000
Indemnity payment 3 80 000
Payments
Import of stock 4 300 000
Purchase of land 5 100 000
Sundry payments 6 32 490
Notes:
1. Rentals
Skhothana has excess floor space in its commercial buildings that it let to aspiring local
designers. The rentals received from the designers amounted to R62 400 for the two-month
period and constituted 8% of the total revenue of the company.
As part of its remuneration package, the company lets residential accommodation to its
employees at a discount to market value. The amount received for the period was R78 000
and makes up 10% of the total revenue of the company.
3. Indemnity payment
On 6 March 2014, a fire broke out at the Johannesburg branch and stock valued at R80 000
was destroyed. The insurance company indemnified the company with a cash payment of
R80 000 (inclusive of VAT).
4. Import of stock
On 28 February 2014, Skhothana imported the Ska-Vela brand of shoes from Italy. The
cost price and value for customs duty purposes was R300 000. Import surcharges of
R2 400 were levied. The date reflected on the Customs Billing of Entry is 4 March 2014.
QUESTION 1 (continued)
5. Purchase of land
R
Fuel cost 14 250
Bank charges 7 410
Maintenance costs 5 700
Insurance premium 3 990
Subscription fees 1 140
The fuel costs, bank charges and maintenance costs relate to the import business as well
as the property rental business. The insurance premium and subscription fees only relate to
the import business.
The subscription fees are for the purchase of international magazines and membership with
fashion trend forecasting agencies to ensure that the company stocks up on the latest
trends.
REQUIRED: Marks
Calculate the VAT payable by or refundable to Skhothana (Pty) Ltd for the
two-month tax period ending 31 March 2014. 20
Note: Where an amount is nil, please indicate and provide a brief reason.
QUESTION 2 (40 marks, 48 minutes)
Drum Rum (Pty) Ltd is not a small business corporation as defined and carries on business as a
liquor manufacturer. The company operates mainly in South Africa and sells most of its liquor
products on credit to liquor retailers in South Africa and neighbouring countries. The company
is a registered vendor for VAT purposes and its year of assessment ends on 28 February 2014.
All amounts exclude VAT, unless otherwise stated.
The company has a taxable income of R6 758 631 before the following information has been
taken into account:
R
1. Export sales – cash 750 352
2. Dividends received – South African companies 13 750
3. Imported liquor ingredients used in the manufacturing process 588 535
4. Inventory at cost – 1 March 2013 291 250
Inventory at market value – 1 March 2013 289 750
5. Inventory at cost – 28 February 2014 319 760
Inventory at market value – 28 February 2014 325 753
6. Bad debts written off during the 2014 year of assessment 75 205
7. List of doubtful debts at 28 February 2014 105 250
8. List of doubtful debts at 28 February 2013 85 725
9. Personnel costs:
- Incentive bonuses to all employees 350 000
- Contributions to the pension fund on behalf of employees. The 135 250
Commissioner has approved a remuneration of R2 000 000 for the
purposes of pension fund contributions.
10. Legal expenses incurred:
- Legal cost relating to collecting outstanding debtors 8 500
- Legal cost paid on behalf of one of the company’s directors re- 1 500
garding a private issue
11. Advertising costs incurred:
- Cost of advertising a vacant post in the Weekly Cape Mail 4 580
- Cost of erecting a billboard close to the BR International Airport in 35 600
Botswana
12. Drum Rum (Pty) Ltd purchased the following capital assets:
A new brewing manufacturing machine B was purchased on
31 December 2013 at a total cost of R350 000 and was brought into use
on the same date. Installation costs for machine B amounted to R14 250
(including VAT).
QUESTION 2 (continued)
R
A second hand delivery vehicle was purchased on 30 June 2013 at a total
cost of R125 000 to deliver the liquor products of Drum Rum (Pty) Ltd to
its clients. Owing to technical problems, the delivery vehicle was only
brought into use on 1 September 2013.
A new manufacturing building was erected on 30 April 2009 and brought
into use on 31 July 2009 at a total cost of R1 650 000. The building
houses the whole liquor manufacturing process of Drum Rum (Pty) Ltd.
13. Drum Rum (Pty) Ltd received a sudden demand for one of its flagship
products and was forced to look for additional manufacturing space. Bliss
CC was approached and a lease agreement was signed on 1 July 2013,
with a monthly rental payable of R15 000 as from 1 July 2013 for a period
of five years with the option to extend the lease period for another five
years. The lease agreement stipulated that Drum Rum (Pty) Ltd had to
make leasehold improvements of at least R550 000 and had to pay a
lease premium of R90 000. The lease premium was paid on 1 July 2013
and the leasehold improvements commenced on 1 August 2013 and were
completed on 1 December 2013. The total cost of the leasehold improve-
ments was R600 000 and the improvements was brought into use on
1 January 2014.
14. Drum Rum (Pty) Ltd sold a technologically outdated manufacturing ma-
chine on 1 February 2014 for R15 000. It was originally bought second
hand on 30 April 2011 for R100 000 and brought into use on the same
day. The company has elected a section 11(o) scrapping allowance.
15. The following costs were incurred relating to patents and trademarks:
- Renewal of patent J on 1 August 2013 8 500
- Purchase a new trademark on 31 December 2013 65 000
16. Drum Rum (Pty) Ltd entered into an agreement with Label Brew, the for-
mer brew master, on 31 December 2013, the date on which he resigned,
and paid him an amount of R580 000 as a restraint of trade payment for a
period of five years. The agreement was effective from 1 January 2014
and the R580 000 was paid on 15 January 2014, only R550 000 of which
was taxable in the hands of Label Brew for the 2014 year of assessment.
17. Drum Rum (Pty) Ltd donated R50 000 on 18 December 2013 to “Men in
Orange” a public benefit organisation and received a section 18A income
tax certificate on 31 January 2014.
QUESTION 2 (continued)
The company has an assessed loss brought forward from the 2013 year of
assessment of R112 314.
The company had also paid provisional tax of R1 351 584 for the 2014 year
of assessment.
REQUIRED: Marks
Calculate the tax liability of Drum Rum (Pty) Ltd for the year of assessment 35
ending 28 February 2014.
Buildings Ltd, a resident company, declared a dividend of R850 000 on 15 February 2014.
The contributed tax capital is R3 600 000. The company has an unutilised STC credit of
R100 000 carried forward from the dividend cycle that ended immediately before the effective
date.
REQUIRED: Marks
Calculate the net dividend received by each shareholder after the dividends tax 5
was deducted.
QUESTION 3 (25 marks, 30 minutes)
Blue Pools (Pty) Ltd, has a 31 January year-end. The business supplies you with the following
information with regard to a manufacturing building and a manufacturing machine that was sold
during the 2014 year of assessment:
REQUIRED: Marks
Calculate the taxable capital gain of Blue Pools (Pty) Ltd for the year of assess-
ment ended on 31 January 2014. Blue Pools (Pty) Ltd has an assessed capital 25
loss of R35 000 brought forward from the previous year of assessment.
QUESTION 4 (15 marks, 18 minutes)
Sunshine (Pty) Ltd is not a small business corporation as defined. Its year of assessment ends
on 31 March each year. Its records show the following:
REQUIRED: Marks
a) Calculate the first and second provisional tax payments for the 2014 year
of assessment. Clearly state on which date the payment must be made. 9
b) For the first provisional tax payment for the 2014 year of assessment,
what will the basic amount be if the 2013 assessment was issued on 1
15 June 2013?
c) Calculate the third provisional tax payment for the 2014 year of assess-
ment assuming that the actual taxable income for the 2014 year of assess-
ment was R1 890 850 and also indicate by which date such payment 5
should be made to SARS.
Ignore the Tax Administration Act that came into effect on 1 October 2012.
QUESTION 1: SOLUTION (20 marks, 24 minutes)
Output Tax
R Marks
Cash Sales (R150 000 x 14%) 21 000 (1)
Credit Sales (R490 000 x 14%) 68 600 (1)
Rentals from designers (R62 400 x 14%) 8 736 (1)
Rentals from employees – nil (1)
residential accommodation exempt
Loan from Qhoma Bank – financial services exempt nil (1)
Input Tax
Import of Stock:
Customs Value 300 000
10% of Customs Value 30 000 (1)
Import Surcharges 2 400 (1)
332 400
VAT R332 400 x 14% 46 536 (1)
Sundry Payments
Fuel Cost – zero-rated nil (1)
Bank Charges (R7 410 x 14/114 x 90%) 819 (2)
Maintenance Costs (R5 700 x 14/114 x 90%) 630 (2)
Insurance premium (R3 990 x 14/114) 490 (1)
Subscription fees (R1 140 x 14/114) 140 (1)
Total 21
Max 20
QUESTION 2(a) –SUGGESTED SOLUTION
CALCULATE THE TAX LIABILITY OF DRUM RUM (PTY) LTD FOR THE 2014 YEAR OF ASSESS-
MENT
R R
Taxable income - given 6 758 631
Export sales 750 352 (1)
Dividend received - exempt - (1)
Imported liquor ingredients (588 535) (1)
Opening inventory @ market value (lowest) (289 750) (1)
Closing inventory @ cost (lowest) 319 760 (1)
Bad debts written-off (75 205) (1)
Doubtful debts – 2013 (R85 725 x 25%) 21 431 (1)
Doubtful debts – 2014 (R105 250 x 25%) (26 313) (1)
Incentive bonuses (350 000) (1)
Pension fund contributions (R2 000 000 x 10%) = R200 000 (135 250) (1)
Legal expenses – in production of income (8 500) (1)
Legal expenses – director (private: prohibited) - (1)
Advertising – Weekly Cape Mail (4 580) (1)
Advertising – Billboard – capital in nature - (1)
Machine B - Cost 350 000
- Installation (R14 250 x 100/114) 12 500 (1)
362 500
Section 12C allowance – 40% x R362 500 (145 000) (1)
Section 11(e) delivery vehicle (R125 000/4 x 6/12) (15 625) (2)
Manufacturing building allowance (R1 650 000 x 5%) (82 500) (1)
Rent paid (R15 000 x 8) (120 000) (1)
Lease premium (R90 000/120 x 8) (6 000) (2)
Alternative: (R90 000/10 x 8/12)
Lease hold improvements (R550 000/115 x 2) (9 565) (2)
Alternative: (R550 000/9.583 x 2/12)
Building allowance (R600 000 – R550 000) x 5% (2 500) (1)
Disposal Machine D
- Cost 100 000
- Less: Section 12C – 2012 (R100 000 x 20%) (20 000) (1)
- Section 12C – 2013 (R100 000 x 20%) (20 000) (1)
- Section 12C – 2014 (R100 000 x 20%) (20 000) (20 000) (1)
Tax Value 40 000
Proceeds on disposal (15 000)
Section 11(o) scrapping allowance 25 000 (25 000) (1)
Renewal of Patent J (9 000) (1)
New trademark K (non-deductible) (prohibited) - (1)
Restraint of trade payment, the lesser of: - R550 000/5, or 110 000 (110 000) (2)
- R550 000/3 183 333
Sub-total 5 837 031
Less: Section 18A donation (R5 837 031 x 10% =
R583 703, but limited to actual donation (50 000) (1)
5 776 851
Less: Assessed loss brought forward from 2013 (112 314) (1)
Taxable income for 2014 5 664 536
SA Normal tax @ 28% 1 586 070 (1)
Less: Provisional tax paid (1 351 584) (1)
Calculated tax liability for 2014 234 486
Total (37)
Max 35
QUESTION 2 (continued)
R
Dividend declared 850 000
Less: STC credit (100 000) (1)
Dividend subject to dividends tax 750 000
Natural person
Dividend portion (R750 000 x 25%) 187 500 (1)
Less: Dividends tax (R187 500 x 15%) (28 125) (1)
Net dividend received 159 375
Manufacturing Building
Tax value: R
Cost 80 000 (1)
Less: Sec 12C Allowances (52 000)
2002 - 2013: (48 000) (1)
2014: R80 000 x 5% (4 000) (1)
Tax value on date of sale 28 000 (1)
Recoupment:
Proceeds: 890 000 (1)
Less: Tax value (28 000) (1)
Recoupment 862 000
Limited to previous allowances, thus 52 000 (1)
Adjusted proceeds:
Proceeds 890 000
Less: Recoupment (52 000) (1)
Base cost:
Valuation date value 166 700 (1)
Plus: Costs incurred after 1 October 2001 4 500 (1)
Base cost 171 200
SOLUTION: QUESTION 3 (continued)
R
Capital gain:
Proceeds (adjusted) 838 000
Less: Base cost (171 200)
666 800 (1)
Manufacturing Machine
Base cost:
Cost (R456 000 x 100/114) 400 000 (1)
Less: Sec 12C Allowance R400 000 x 20% (used machinery) (80 000) (1)
Add: Agent’s commission 30 000 (1)
Base cost 350 000
Taxable capital gain at the inclusion rate of 66.6% 454 079 (1)
Total 25
QUESTION 4 (15 marks, 18 minutes)
st (1)
a) 1 provisional tax payment (payable before/on 30 September 2013)
R
Basic amount 1 200 000 (1)
(must use 2012 assessment as 2013 is not more than 14 days old)
Increased by 8% for 2 years (16%) (2013 and 2014) 192 000 (2)
1 392 000
b) As it is more than 60 days old, the 2013 taxble income can be used
as the basic amount. It will not be adjusted, as it is the previous year’s 1 354 980 (1)
taxable income.
Total 15
QUESTION 1 (20 marks, 24 minutes)
Monate Bakers (Pty) Ltd (Monate Bakers) is a bakery that sells a variety of baked goods to its
customers. Monate Bakers is registered for Value-Added Tax (VAT) and has a two-month tax
period.
The accountant of Monate Bakers has prepared a VAT calculation for the two-month period
ending 28 February 2015 and has requested you to review it before he submits the VAT201
return to SARS. The amounts used in the calculation were exclusive of VAT unless otherwise
stated. The following is the accountant’s calculation:
Input VAT
Baking ingredients (R167 000 x 14%) 23 380
Baking ovens (R37 500 x 14%) 4 5 250
Donation (R7 643 x 14%) 5 1 070
Salaries (R140 000 x 14%) 19 600
Municipal rates (R2 570 x 14%) 360
Depreciation (R15 365 x 14%) 2 151
Total Input VAT 51 811
Notes:
1. On 12 December 2014, Monate Bakers borrowed R100 000 from Chelete Fela bank. The
loan is for a period of 24 months at an interest rate of 8,5% per annum. The loan was used
partly to finance the purchase of three second-hand ovens (refer to note 4).
2. On 5 January 2015, one of Monate Bakers’ delivery vehicles was hijacked en route to a
client. The vehicle was purchased two years prior to the incident for R171 000. The
insurance company indemnified the company with a cash payment of R150 000 on
3 March 2015. The delivery vehicle is not a motor car as defined in terms of the VAT Act.
3. The store manager has the sole use of one of the company’s vehicles, which the entity
purchased on 29 December 2014 for R96 900 (including VAT). The store manager does
not bear the full cost of repairs and maintenance of the vehicle. The vehicle is not a motor
car as defined in terms of the VAT Act.
4. On 7 February 2015, Monate Bakers purchased three second-hand ovens from a non-
vendor. The purchase price was R37 500 and the market value at the date of purchase
was R33 000 for the three ovens in total.
REQUIRED: MARKS
Revise the accountant’s VAT calculation for the two-month tax period ending
28 February 2015 by providing brief reasons for adjusting or not adjusting the
accountant’s calculations. 20
TIP: Adjust each of the accountant’s entries for the Total Output and Input VAT to
determine the correct VAT payable to SARS for the two-month tax period ending
28 February 2015.
Orion Industries (Pty) Ltd (Orion) manufactures jewellery including watches, necklaces and
bracelets. The company’s process is perceived to be a “process of manufacturing” by the Com-
missioner. The company is not a small business corporation as defined in the Income Tax
Act and its financial year ends on 31 March. Orion is a registered VAT vendor.
The following information is available to calculate the taxable income for the year of assessment
ended on 31 March 2015 (all amounts exclude VAT unless otherwise stated):
1. Sales (both cash and credit sales) amounted to R4 620 000 during the current year of
assessment.
01/04/2014 31/03/2015
Market Market
Cost Price Value Cost Price Value
Completed R R R R
Products 450 000 375 000 680 000 854 000
3. Orion purchased inventory amounting to R1 840 000 during the year of assessment.
4. The list of doubtful debts at 31 March 2015 amounted to R104 820. A detailed list was
provided to and approved by the Commissioner. There were no doubtful debts for the 2014
year of assessment.
5. The following expenses were incurred in connection with a design and a trademark:
6. Orion ordered a new specialised manufacturing machine (machine PP) from Austria at
a cost of €86 700 on 1 September 2014. Airfreight, customs and insurance costs amounted
to R54 300. The machine was received in South Africa and brought into use on
1 December 2014 (transaction date). Payment was made in full on 1 May 2015.
QUESTION 2 (continued)
Date R €
1 September 2014 13,86 1
1 December 2014 14,54 1
31 March 2015 15,85 1
1 May 2015 15,92 1
Average rate for the year 15,29 1
7. Orion entered into learnership agreements with two new employees, Lindile Mabuso and
Jason Armstrong, for a period of 12 months each from 1 January 2014. Jason Armstrong is
a person with a disability as defined in the Act. The agreements are registered and comply
with all the necessary requirements. Both employees have successfully completed the
learnership agreements.
8. On 1 June 2014, Orion entered into a lease contract with Green Bay CC for a period of ten
years, with the option to extend the contract for another ten years. In terms of the contract,
Orion had to effect improvements to the premises to the value of R620 000. The building
improvements commenced on 1 July 2014 and were completed on 30 October 2014. The
building was brought into use on 1 December 2014 and the building was used in the manu-
facturing process. The total cost of the improvements was R680 000. A rental amount of
R12 500 per month was payable by Orion to Green Bay CC from 1 June 2014.
9. On 1 January 2014, Orion purchased five new laptop computers for a cash amount of
R12 800 each (VAT inclusive). After installing an all-encompassing software program in
house on the laptops, specific to the jewellery industry, Orion sold three of the computers
to a competitor in the market for an amount of R21 500 each on 1 November 2014. The
proceeds on the sale are regarded as capital in nature.
Binding general ruling No. 7 makes provision for the following write-off period:
10. Orion declared a dividend of 50% of the net profit after tax. Assume the net profit after tax
amounted to R3 126 544. The dividend was paid out to the following shareholders:
REQUIRED: MARKS
Calculate the taxable income of Orion Industries (Pty) Ltd for the year of assess-
ment ended 31 March 2015, as well as the dividends ’ tax payable by each 36
shareholder.
QUESTION 3 (22 marks, 26 minutes)
Steelworks (Pty) Ltd, a registered VAT vendor, is a manufacturer and its year of assessment
ends on 31 March 2015.
Factory building
The company acquired a factory building at a cost of R4 332 000 (including VAT) on
1 August 1999 and brought it into use directly in a process of manufacture on the same date. A
huge storeroom was added to the factory building at a cost of R500 000 and it was brought into
use on 1 April 2004. No capital allowances could be claimed on this extension.
The building (factory and storeroom) were destroyed in a fire on 31 October 2014. Steelworks
(Pty) Ltd was informed by its insurance company that it was under-insured and received an
insurance payment on 15 November 2014 of R1 400 000 only.
The market value of the building was R4 000 000 as on 1 October 2001 and the time-apportion-
ment base cost of the building was R888 578. The total amount of capital allowances claimed
in respect of the factory building for the 2000 to 2014 years of assessment were R2 660 000.
Manufacturing machine
Steelworks (Pty) Ltd sold a specialised manufacturing machine on 15 March 2015. The capital
gain on this machine was R2 000 000. Steelworks (Pty) Ltd bought a new specialised manu-
facturing machine for R5 500 000 on 20 March 2015 to replace the one that was sold, and
brought it into use on the same date.
Other information
Steelworks (Pty) Ltd has an assessed capital loss brought forward from the previous year of
assessment of R30 000.
Steelworks (Pty) Ltd has elected to apply paragraph 66 of the Eighth Schedule of the Income
Tax Act with regard to the reinvestment in replacement assets.
REQUIRED: MARKS
Calculate Steelworks (Pty) Ltd’s taxable capital gain/assessed capital loss for the
2015 year of assessment. 22
QUESTION 4 (11 marks, 13 minutes)
Disa (Pty) Ltd is a retail company situated in Cape Town, South Africa. The company is a small
business corporation as defined in the Income Tax Act and its year of assessment ends on
28 February 2015. The accountant has provided you with the following information:
Included in the taxable income for the 2013 year of assessment was a taxable capital gain of
R50 117.
REQUIRED: MARKS
(a) Calculate the first provisional tax payment of Disa (Pty) Ltd for the 2015
year of assessment and clearly state on which date payment should be 7
made to SARS.
(b) Calculate the second provisional tax payment of Disa (Pty) Ltd for the 2015
year of assessment and clearly state on which date payment should be 4
made to SARS.
Medev Construction (Pty) Ltd is a South African residential property developer operating mainly
in Gauteng, South Africa. The company’s year of assessment ends on 31 March 2015 and it is
also a registered vendor for VAT purposes.
Medev Construction (Pty) Ltd (the seller) signed a sales contract with Mr P Dhlamini (the pur-
chaser) on 1 March 2015 for the purchase of a brand new town house for a purchase price of
R1 350 000 (including VAT). Mr Dhlamini has signed the purchase contract subject to a
condition that he obtains a 100% bond from Just Bond Bank before 20 March 2015 to fund the
purchase price of the new town house. The 100% bond was finally approved on 2 April 2015
and the sale of the town house was concluded on that date.
REQUIRED: MARKS
Discuss, with reference to the Income Tax Act and case law, whether the sale of
the town house by Medev Construction (Pty) Ltd to Mr P Dhlamini will be included
in the gross income of Medev Construction (Pty) Ltd for the year of assessment
ended on 31 March 2015. 11
SOLUTION: QUESTION 1 (20 marks, 24 minutes)
VAT payable to SARS (not refundable) (R64 105 - R27 433) 36 672 (2)
Total 24
Max 20
SOLUTION - QUESTION 2 (36 marks, 44 minutes)
Calculation of taxable income of Orion Industries (Pty) Ltd for the year of assessment ended
31 March 2015.
R R
Sales 4 620 000 1
Inventory @ market value – 1 April 2014 (sec 22(2)) (375 000) 1
Inventory @ cost – 31 March 2015 (sec 22(1)) 680 000 1
Purchases (sec 11(a)) (1 840 000) 1
Doubtful debts
Doubtful debts – (R104 820 x 25%) (sec 11(j)) (26 205) 1
Design and trademark
Design A for tennis bracelet (R34 600 x 10%) (sec 11(gC)) (3 460) 1
Trademark renewal (sec 11(gB)) (9 500) 1
Foreign exchange gain/(loss)
Machine PP
Cost price (1 December 2014) (€86 700 x R14,54) 1 260 618 1
Plus: Airfreight, customs and insurance costs 54 300 1
Total cost price 1 314 918
Foreign exchange loss on exchange item: foreign creditor
(€86 700 x (R14,54 - R15,85) (sec 24I) (113 577) 2
Capital allowance s12C (R1 314 918 x 40%) (525 967) 1
R R
Proceeds 64 500
Less: Recoupment (9 357)
Adjusted proceeds 55 143
Less: Base cost (24 326)
Original cost 33 684
Less: Allowances (9 357)
FACTORY BUILDING
Tax value R
Recoupment/Scrapping
Proceeds – indemnity payment 1 400 000 (1)
Less: Tax value (1 450 000) (1)
Scrapping- but not allowed as not a movable asset (50 000)
Proceeds
Proceeds – indemnity payment 1 400 000 (1)
Less: Recoupment -
Adjusted proceeds 1 400 000
R
Base cost
VDV 888 578 (1)
Plus: Costs incurred on/after 1 October 2001 500 000 (1)
Total 22
SOLUTION : QUESTION 4 (11 marks, 13 minutes)
R
Basic amount (must use 2013 assessment as the 2014 assessment is 1 120 579 (1)
not more than 14 days old (1)
Less: Taxable capital gain included (50 117) (1)
Adjusted basic amount 1 070 462
Tax (R59 451 + (R1 070 462 - R550 000) x 28%) 205 180 (2)
First provisional tax payment (50% x R205 431) 102 590 (1)
The taxable income is more than R1 million and therefore the calculation
will be based on the estimated taxable income 1 528 452 (1)
Tax (R59 451 + (R1 528 452 - R550 000) x 28%) 333 418 (1)
Less: First provisional tax payment made to SARS (102 590) (1)
In Mooi v SIR 34 SATC1, it was held that accrual could only (1)
take place when a taxpayer becomes unconditionally entit-
led to an amount.
During the year of The sales contract was signed on 1 March 2015, but the
assessment suspensive condition was only fulfilled on 2 April 2015.
Therefore the selling price of R1 184 211 will only be inclu-
ded in the gross income of Medev Construction (Pty) Ltd for (2)
the year of assessment ended on 31 March 2016.
Excluding receipts or Medev Construction (Pty) Ltd is in the business of develo-
accruals of a capital ping residential properties and therefore the selling of a town
nature house will constitute gross income because it forms part of (4)
the trading stock and will not be of a capital nature.
Conclusion All the requirements of the gross income definition have not (1)
been met for the 2015 year of assessment and therefore the
proceeds from the disposal of the town house to Mr P
Dhlamini will not constitute gross income in the hand of
Medev Construction (Pty) Ltd for the year of assessment
ended on 31 March 2015.
Thus, no amount is included in gross income.
Total 13
Max 11
QUESTION (29 Marks, 35 Minutes)
Sunshine Traders CC, supplies farming utilities to local farmers. Sales occur on a cash and
credit basis.
All amounts exclude VAT. Unless otherwise indicated. Sunshine Traders CC is registered on
the invoice basis for VAT.
The following information is supplied to you in respect of the year of assessment ending 28
February 2016:
Notes R
Income/ Receipts
Expenses/payments
Notes
The doubtful debt allowance for the year of assessment ended 28 February 2015 was R50
000. The list of doubtful debtors on 28 February 2016 amounts to R240 000.
2. Patent
On 1 March 2013 Sunshine Traders CC acquired a patent at a cost of R120 000 which was
used in the production of income. The expected useful life of the patent was 10 years at 1
March 2013. On 1 May 2015 the patent was sold for R150 000.
3. Cost of sales
The cost price of stock on hand at 28 February 2015 was R725 000.
The market value of stock on hand at 28 February 2016 was R775 000.
Sunshine Traders CC incurred a loan of R1 000 000 on 25 May 2015 at an interest rate of
16% per year, for ten years, to finance the project. The loan was approved on 1 June 2015.
The loan is repayable in 10 annual payments of R206 901 each, with the first payment
payable on 1 June 2016. The accrued interest due up to and including 1 June 2016
amounted to R160 000. You may assume that the interest is incurred evenly throughout the
year.
5. Cost of sales
6. Repairs
The dirt parking lot for approximately 40 vehicles, washed away after a cloudburst. The
parking lot was repaired and paved with bricks at a cost of R50 000. Additional parking
space for approximately 15 larger vehicles was provided simultaneously at a cost of
R25 000 on 1 March 2015.
7. Depreciation
7.1 Office furniture with a cost price of R100 000, purchased on 1 March
2013, was no longer suitable to the business, and was donated on 1
March 2015. Its market value was R25 000 on 1 March 2015.
The stock has already been taken into account in cost of sales under Note 3 above.
31 July 2015 $1 = R9
31 August 2015 $1 = R10
31 January 2016 $1 = R11
28 February 2016 $1 = R10
Calculate the income and deduction/allowances of Sunshine Traders CC for the year of
assessment ended 28 February 2016 and to reflect it, either under income or under
deductions/allowances. You do not have to calculate taxable income. (29)
Whizzers (Pty) Ltd manufacture sweets. The taxable net income of the company, before the
following transactions were taken into account, for the year of assessment ended 30 April 2016
amounted to R910 000:
1. On 1 February 2016 machine B, with a purchase price of R500 000, was purchased for the
factory in terms of an instalment sales agreement and was brought into use on the same
date. Interest of R113 201 will be paid over a 5 year period of which R7 585 relates to the
period 1 February 2016 to 30 April 2016.
This machine was purchased to replace machine Z which was technologically obsolete.
Machine Z was purchased 31 October 2011 for R228 000 (including VAT) and the original
installation costs amounted to R10 000. The cost to move machine Z from the old to the
new factory AAA amounted to R5 000 in the current year. Machine Z was sold on 1
February 2016 for R25 000. Assume that there was no paragraph 65 or 66 of the 8th
schedule application for the replacement.
2. Whizzers (Pty) Ltd further decided to build a new factory on vacant premises BBB, which
has been leased for a 10 year period from GGG Property Ltd. The lease contract was
signed on 1 July 2015 and stipulated the following:
On the signing of the contract a lease premium of R80 000 for the right of use of the land
was payable.
The erection of a factory building to the value of R480 000. Building commenced on 1
August 2015 and the factory was completed on 1 October 2015 at a total cost of R500
000 and brought into use on 31 October 2015.
The monthly rental amounted to R10 000 and was payable from 1 July 2015
3. The following legal costs were incurred during the year of assessment:
3.1 Legal costs relating to the collection of long outstanding debtors to the amount of R3
900.
3.2 Costs to draw up the lease contract, amounting to R2 800. This contract relates to the
lease on the factory premises BBB as set out in note 2.
3.3 Court, representations and witness fees arising out of a court case which was settled in
June 2015. Whizzers (Pty) Ltd was ordered to pay damages to a client after the client’s
child was accidentally poisoned by a product due to negligence during the
manufacturing process. The legal costs amounted R40 000. Indemnification insurance
was taken out to protect Whizzers (Pty) Ltd against similar claims and the damages
were paid by the insurers.
4. Patent A was acquired during the year of assessment by Whizzers (Pty) Ltd to be used in
the business. on 1 December 2015 at a cost of R10 000 and had an expected useful life of
10 years.
5. A trademark, GIZZ®, was purchased on 1 January 2015 for R100 000. The expected useful
life of the trademark was 8 years.
6. Whizzers (Pty) Ltd wants to claim bad debts and a doubtful debts allowance. SARS grants
an annual allowance of 25% to Whizzers (Pty) Ltd based on the list of doubtful debts at year
end. The debtor statistics was as follows:
Outstanding debtors at year end (before bad debts were deducted) were:
2014 R38 600
2015 R48 000
A debtor, Twizzers CC, was placed in liquidation during January 2016. It is expected that
the creditors will receive 50c in the rand. The client debt at year end amounted
R16 000. This amount was not yet included in the above mentioned bad debts or list
of doubtful debts for 2016.
7. Dividends to the amount of R20 000 were distributed to the only shareholder, Mr Whizz and
a salary of R60 000 was paid to him for the 2016 year assessment.
8. A fax machine with a tax value of Rnil and a market value of R500 on 29 February 2016,
was donated to the shareholder, Mr Whizz on this date. The fax machine originally cost R3
000.
9. Provisional tax payments for the 2016 year assessment amounts to R100 000.
11. The undertaking is not a small business corporation as defined in the Income Tax Act.
Calculate the income tax liability for the 2016 year of assessment for Whizzers (Pty) Ltd.
Assume that current legislation is applicable. Ignore Capital Gains Tax.
QUESTION 2 (40 marks, 48 minutes)
Dash Trading (Pty) Ltd is an importer of goods into the Republic which it then distributes locally.
The following information relates to the year of assessment ended 31 March 2017:
(All amounts exclude VAT unless stated otherwise).
1. Total sales amounted to R4 735 220. Of this amount R260 540 was not yet received in
cash on 31 March 2017, but still owing to the company as debtors. Included in these
debtors of R260 540 is R68 220 that is regarded as doubtful by Dash Trading. You may
assume that the Commissioner will apply its normal practice relating to doubtful debts. No
2. allowance for doubtful debts has ever been claimed by Dash Trading.
2.1 The amount for stock purchased on 20/03/2017 was still outstanding as a creditor on
31 March 2017, although stock was received by Dash Trading.
2.2 The average rate for the year of assessment was HKD 1.23 = R1. The spot rate on 31
March 2017 was HKD 1.25= R1.
3. The cost price of opening stock amounted to R182 300 with a market value of R273 000.
The cost price of closing stock amounted to R203 500 with a market value of R192 000.
4.1 On 22 April 2016 a dividend of R23 000 was received from Import (Pty) Ltd. Dash
Trading (Pty) Ltd holds 75% of the shares in Import (Pty) Ltd.
4.2 On 2 May 2016 a dividend of R35 000 was received from Exporters (Pty) Ltd. Import
(Pty) Ltd holds 25% of the shares in Exporters (Pty) Ltd and Dash Trading (Pty) Ltd
holds 45% of the shares in Exporters (Pty) Ltd.
4.3 On 17 August 2016 another dividend of R68 000 was received from Exporters (Pty)
Ltd (see note 4.2). This dividend was funded from capital profit from the sale of land
by Exporters (Pty) Ltd. The full profit relates to the period after 1/10/2001. You may
assume that if dividends are paid and received between companies which forms part
of the same group of companies (as defined), all the other requirements relating to
the exemption of these dividends from STC where applicable, will be met.
5. Salaries and wages paid amounted to R540 000. Included in this amount is an amount of
R55 000 for a loan to a shareholder and director which was written off on 30 June 2016.
6. Dash Trading leases office and store room space for Leasecor CC. This agreement was
concluded during March 2011. According to the agreement Dash Trading will lease office
and store room space from 1 May 2011 until 30 April 2016 (a 5 year period). A monthly
rental of R2 000 is payable. A lease premium of R480 000 was paid on 1 May 2011.
7. On 1 January 2016 Dash Trading commenced erecting a new building, containing their
offices and store rooms on land owned by Dash Trading. The building was completed at a
cost of R1 750 000 on 15 April 2016 and bought into use on 1 May 2016. Dash Trading
depreciate this building for accounting purposes at 5% per annum.
Interest paid on the loan for erecting this building were analysed as follows:
Period Amount
R
01/01/2016 – 31/03/2016 24 728
01/04/2016 – 30/04/2016 8 230
01/05/2016 – 31/03/2017 88 765
8. A trade mark was purchased for R385 000 from an unconnected person on 01/11/2016.
Dash Trading regards the useful life of this trade mark as being not more than 10 years.
9.2 R6 500 for setting the dispute arising from the unsuccessful renewal of the lease
contract (see note 6).
10.1 Short term insurance premiums on the business assets is paid monthly in advance
and amounted to R40 300 for the current year of assessment. Included in this amount
is the premium for April 2017 (R3 100) which was paid on 31 March 2017
10.2 The insurance on the building is paid annually in advance. The premium for the period
1 May 2017 to 30 April 2018 amounted to R52 000 and was paid on 31 March 2017.
11.1 A luxury passenger vehicle was leased by Dash Trading from 1 June 2016 and the
use of the vehicle was granted as a fringe benefit to the managing director. The cost
price of the vehicle was R438 900 (including VAT). The monthly lease payment
amounted to R95 350 in total for the period 1 June 2016 – 31 March 2017.
11.2 A delivery vehicle with a cost price of R142 500 (including VAT), was purchased and
brought into use on 1 January 2016. This vehicle was involved in an accident and
consequently scrapped by the insurance company on 28 February 2017. The
insurance indemnity payment amounted to R91 200 (VAT included). Refer to
paragraph 11.5 for the relevant write off period.
11.3 A new delivery vehicle was purchased on 1 March 2016 and brought into use on 1
April 2016. The cost price of the vehicle was R148 000.
11.4 An antique desk with a cost price of R36 000 and a tax value of R32 500 was donated
to the father of the managing director (who is not a shareholder) on 1 April 2016. The
market value of this desk was determined for insurance purposes as R36 000.
11.5 Computers with a cost price of R72 000 was purchases and brought into use on 1 July
2013.
12. The assessed loss brought forward to the current year of assessment amounted to R286
000.
14. On 1 January 2017 a dividend of R50 000 was declared to shareholders registered on 1
February 2017. The last dividend declared before this declaration was declared on 1
January 2016 and any STC related to this dividend was paid.
Revenue reserves were available at all times for the funding of any dividend or deemed
dividend.
(a) Calculate the normal tax payable by Dash Trading (Pty) Ltd for the year of assessment
ended 31 March 2017. You may ignore any Capital Gains Tax consequences. (30)
QUESTION 3 (22 marks, 26 minutes)
Mbisi CC manufactures plastic irrigation pipes for garden and agricultural use. Mbisi qualifies as a small
business corporation for the 2009 year of assessment.
The net profit for the financial year ended 31 March 2009 amounted to R1 796 530, before taking into
account the following information: (All amounts exclude VAT, unless stated otherwise).
01/04/2008 31/03/2009
Cost Price Market value Cost Price Market value
R R R R
Raw material 1 560 840 3 650 300 1 897 520 3 970 540
Packing material 867 230 950 460 880 450 550 640
Mbisi CC’s factory and office building needed extensive repairs to be effected. The following are the
details of amounts spent:
R
Replacing carpets and linoleum on the floors with tiles………………………………... 22 700
Painting the factory and office building…………………………………………………... 28 720
Erecting new car ports for customers to park under 38 900
Replacing the old diamond mesh wire fence with palisade fencing…………………... 18 300
Machine 20 was totally destroyed due to a technical error and consequently scrapped on 15 June 2008.
This machine was purchased second-hand and brought into use on 10 March 2006 and had a cost price
of R438 900 (VAT included). The insurance company settled the claim on 8 July 2008 and the
indemnity amounted to R320 000 (VAT excluded).
An order was placed on 1 July 2008 (the transaction date) for a replacing machine with a supplier in
England to replace Machine 20. This machine, Machine 35, was taken into use on 10 March 2009. The
cost price of the machine amounted to £100 000. Air freight, customs and clearing costs amounted to
R25 000. A foundation needed to be built for the machine which cost R37 000 to build. The purchase
price of Machine 35 was settled in full by bank transfer on 1 January 2009.
Date R £
1 July 2008 16.90 1
1 January 2009 14.85 1
10 March 2009 16.20 1
31 March 2009 17.00 1
Average rate for the year 15.42 1
A second hand machine, Machine 45, was purchased and brought into use on 1 November 2008 at a
cost of R85 000 (VAT excluded).
Computers were purchased on 15 August 2008 for the administration section of the business. The cost
amounted to R150 000. The computers were installed and taken into use on 1 October 2008.
A passenger vehicle was purchased and taken into use on 1 January 2005 to be granted as a fringe
benefit to the managing member, Mr Maluleke. The cost of this vehicle amounted to R256 000 (VAT
included). You may ignore the calculation of the fringe benefit consequences of this transaction.
Mbisi CC wanted to rent a vacant piece of land adjacent to the factory for store, parking and loading
space. The owner of the land actually wanted to sell the property and only granted the use of the land
on a leas to Mbisi CC and after Mbisi CC had agreed to pay a lease premium of R120 000 on 1 January
2009. The lease contract granted the use of the land to Mbisi CC for a period of 5 years from 1 January
2009. A monthly rent of R1 800 was also payable from 1 January 2009.
You may assume that where applicable any choice in terms of paragraph 65 and 66 of the Eighth
Schedule relating to the roll over provisions has been exercised by Mbisi CC.
Practice Note 19 lists the following write-off periods. Apply it where applicable.
REQUIRED:
Calculate the normal tax payable by Mbisi CC for the year of assessment ended 31 March 2009. (22)
QUESTION (20 marks, 24 minutes)
Veli Jeans (Pty) Ltd manufactures and sells fashionable jeans and jackets. The
company’s financial year ends on 31 March. Veli Jeans (Pty) Ltd is a registered vendor for
VAT purposes and is not a small business corporation. The following information is
available for calculating the 2015 taxable income (all amounts exclude VAT unless otherwise
stated):
2. Closing stock
On the evening of 31 March 2015, after the stock taking, there was a heavy
rainstorm. The water on the roof of one of the storerooms leaked onto some of the jeans
stock and caused damage to these items, to the amount of R250 000. These jeans were
considered unsaleable.
Veli Jeans (Pty) Ltd bought blue jackets from an agent in Cape Town. The cost incurred in
purchasing these items was R800 000. Transport costs of R10 000 were also paid to
transport the stock to Johannesburg. (Both these expenses are included in the
manufacturing costs and purchases of stock of R3 500 000 above). During the
South African fashion week, the company was shocked to discover that there
had been a sudden change in fashion: blue jackets had suddenly become
unfashionable and only black jackets were in demand. Veli Jeans (Pty) Ltd estimated
that the value of the jacket stock had now diminished by R600 000 owing to
these unforeseen circumstances. None of the blue jackets had been sold at year-end.
The CEO of Veli Jeans (Pty) Ltd (Jeepee) has a brother (Pololo) who owned a
clothing shop. He closed down his business in January 2015 and donated all his T-shirts
to Veli Jeans (Pty) Ltd. Pololo acquired the T-shirts at a cost of R300 000, but the market
value on the date of the donation was R200 000. None of these T-shirts had been sold at
year-end.
2
QUESTION (continued)
3. Opening stock
The cost of all closing stock on hand as at 31 March 2014 was R955 000 and the market
value R1 000 000, on the same date.
4. Restraint of trade
One of Veli Jeans (Pty) Ltd’s employees (John) resigned on 1 April 2014 and accepted an
appointment at BRO Jeans (Pty) Ltd, one of Veli Jeans (Pty) Ltd’s competitors. Veli
Jeans (Pty) Ltd thought it necessary to restrain John from sharing any of Veli Jeans
(Pty) Ltd’s manufacturing and trade secrets with his new employer for two years,
and gave John a restraint of trade payment of R300 000. This amount constitutes
income in the hands of the recipient.
5. Fixed assets
Machine S was purchased second hand on 1 January 2012 for R798 000 (including
VAT). It was brought into use on 15 January 2012.
An additional Machine M was purchased new on 1 February 2014 for R950 000 and
brought into use on the same day. Soon after, Veli Jeans (Pty) Ltd decided that it
no longer required the extra machine, and sold it on 1 May 2014 for R930 000.
Factory F was purchased on 30 November 2008 for R2 500 000. This building was
erected by the seller and never used prior to its purchase by Veli Jeans (Pty) Ltd.
6. Doubtful debts
A list of doubtful debts of R80 000 was supplied to the Commissioner. There
were no doubtful debts in the prior year of assessment.
REQUIRED:
Calculate the taxable income of Veli Jeans (Pty) Ltd for the year of assessment ended
31 March 2015. (20)
QUESTION (23 marks, 28 minutes)
Digital Systems (Pty) Ltd is a small business corporation. It researches, develops and manu-
factures electronic tracking systems.
The following information is available to calculate the company's tax liability for the
year of assessment ended 31 March 2015. All amounts exclude VAT, unless otherwise stated.
Expenditure
Notes:
The company elected that paragraph 66 of the Eighth Schedule relating to the roll-
over provision, apply.
2. In order to expand its operations, the company purchased a patent at a cost of R21 700 on
1 October 2014.
3. Management decided that the company’s brand needed to be protected, and as a result,
the company’s trademark registration was renewed on 1 February 2015, at a cost of R7
700.
5. The company added an extension to its existing premises to house its research facilities.
The extension cost R4 500 000 and was completed and brought into use on 1 July 2014.
Eighty per cent (80%) of the new building is used exclusively as a research laboratory and
20% for general office administration.
2
REQUIRED:
Calculate the income tax payable by Digital Systems (Pty) Ltd for the year of assessment
ended 31 March 2015. (15)
Clivia Nursery (Pty) Ltd sells plants and flowers to the public and is not a small business corpo-
ration.
The draft financial statements were prepared by the company’s accountant and
reflect net (accounting) profit before tax of R4 250 000 for the financial year ended 28 February
2015. The accountant requested you to help him calculate the company’s income tax liability.
The following information was supplied to you, but the accounting effect of these transactions
has already been recorded in the draft financial statements (you may ignore any VAT conse-
quences):
1. Fixed assets
Clivia Nursery (Pty) Ltd purchased a bakkie for delivery purposes on 1 January 2013 for
R140 000. The accounting depreciation expense for this vehicle for the 2015 financial year
is R40 000 and the entry in the accounting records was as follows:
2. Lease premium
3. Prepayment
An annual insurance premium to the amount of R90 000 for the period 1 January
2015 until 31 December 2015 was paid on 1 January 2009. The accountant
knows that this entry is incomplete, but has not made the correction in the accounting
records. Assume this is the only accounting entry, in respect of the prepayment, that
needs to be adjusted for tax calculation purposes. The accounting entry was as follows:
REQUIRED:
Calculate the income tax liability of Clivia Nursery (Pty) Ltd for the year of assessment
ended 28 February 2015. (8)
You must commence your answer with the net profit before tax as per draft
financial statements.
4
1
Earthquip (Pty) Ltd manufactures and sells earth moving machinery. Its current financial
year ended 30 June 2007.
The following information relates to Earthquip’s activities in respect of the current financial
year:
2. Earthquip contributes to a provident and medical aid fund on behalf of its employees.
Its annual contribution to the provident fund amounts to R75 000, and to the medical
aid fund R95 000. The Commissioner regards Earthquip’s approved remuneration as
R2 500 000.
3. One of Earthquip’s customers has been liquidated. The liquidators advised Earthquip
that it will receive 10 cents for each rand owned to it. The total amount of the debt
owing to Earthquip by this customer amounts to R100 000.
4. Included in Eaqrthquip’s outstanding debtors (after deducting the amount in note 3),
are doubtful debts of R3 000 000. The previous year’s amount of the doubtful debts
were R2 000 000. The South African Revenue Service allows 25% of the doubtful
debt list as an allowance. Earthquip makes use of this provision.
R R
7. On 1 July 2006 Earthquip paid an amount of R600 000 as compensation to one of its
former directors, as a restraint of trade payment. The restraining agreement is
effective for 5 years. Only R300 000 of the amount paid to the former director was
taxable in his hands.
The machine was bought to replace another machine, Crax, that had a cost of
R1,500,000 that was bought 2nd hand 2 years ago. The insurance paid out R1 200
000. Earthquip elected to make use of the provisions of section 8(4)(e) and
paragraph 66.
9. Earthquip has 4 delivery trucks and 4 trailers. A truck and a trailer operates as one
unit. Each truck and trailer cost R750 000 as a unit. They were all acquired on
31 December 2003. In terms of practice note 19, it can be written off over 4 years.
On 31 December 2006, one of the drivers arranged a New years party on the back of
one of the truck/trailers which was traveling along the coast of Cape Town. He drove
it onto a beach, where it got stuck. As the party mood got higher, so did the tide and
waves, and the vehicle was smashed by the waves against rocks and damaged
beyond repair. The insurance company did not pay out the claim. Earthquip
scrapped the asset.
The wear-and-tear allowances for the 4 delivery trucks and trailers are as follows:
10. Earthquip acquired 2 vehicles on 1 October 2006 and brought them into use on that
date. The vehicles consists of a delivery vehicle, costing R102 600 and a passenger
vehicle for the managing director’s use cost R285 000. Both the amounts include
VAT. In terms of practice note 19, delivery vehicles can be written off over 4 years
and passenger vehicles over 5 years.
Sparky CC is an enterprise which manufacture motorcar spare parts. Mr Shiny Sparky is the only member and
manager of the close corporation. The auditors are at present compiling the annual financial statements for the
financial year ending 28 February 2007 and has requested you, the accountant, to calculate the normal income tax
liability of the enterprise, in order for this calculation to be checked. The enterprise is a registered vendor for Value
Added Tax (VAT) purposes. All amounts exclude VAT where applicable, unless otherwise stated.
The following information relating to Sparky CC for the financial year ending 28 February 2007 was supplied to you:
Note R
INCOME
EXPENSES
Notes
R
1. Bad debts comprises:
3. Fixed assets
3.1 Depreciation
4. Fines amounting to R6 900 and interest amounting to R400 levied on the late
submission of a VAT return.
5. Repairs comprises the cost to replace water pipes and electrical wiring which were
damaged during the fire (refer Note 3). R2 000 of this cost however comprises cost to
install a security gate in order to improve security on the premises.
6. During November and December 2006 R120 000 was spent by Sparky CC in order to
design their own patent, “Sparks”. This patent was registered on 31 December 2006
at a total cost of R10 000. An existing patent right was also renewed on 1 February
2007 at a total cost of R13 000. A trademark was purchased on 1 February 2007 at a
cost of R100 000.
8 The company tax rate is 29%. The close corporation does not comply with the require-
ments of the Income Tax Act in order to be taxed as a small business corporation.
Calculate the normal income tax liability of Sparky CC, for the year of assessment ending on 28 February 2007.
1
ABC (Pty) Ltd is a manufacturing concern and a small business corporation as defined.
The following income statement of ABC (Pty) Ltd for the year ended 31 March 2007 was presented to you. The net
profit amounted to R755 000 and was calculated after taking into account the following items:
Note R
INCOME
Profit on sale of building 1 185 000
EXPENSES
Loss on sale of warehouse 2 65 000
Depreciation 3 183 250
Insurance paid 4 135 000
Notes:
1. On 10.08.2006 ABC sold their office building to an unconnected person. The profit of R185 000 is a capital
gain and calculated correctly according to the Eighth Schedule of the Income Tax Act.
2. On 05.11.2006 ABC sold a warehouse, also to an unconnected person. The loss of R65 000 is a capital loss
and calculated correctly according to the Eighth Schedule of the Income Tax Act.
ABC (Pty) Ltd complies with all the requirements of Practice Note 19. The write-off period for delivery vehicles
according to Practice Note 19 is 4 years.
4. The short term insurance policy of the company was renewed on 01.03.2006, for a period of 12 months until 28
February 2008, at an amount of R135 000.
5. The following provisional tax payments were made by ABC (Pty) Ltd:
Calculate the income tax payable by / refundable to ABC (Pty) Ltd for the year of assessment ended 31 March
2007. You may ignore VAT for purposes of this question.
QUESTION (30 marks, 36 minutes)
Cellcom (Pty) Ltd is in the cellphone industry reception and call services. They
have an extensive customer base which were created during the past few years.
The current financial year ended on 30 June 2007. You can assume that current
legislation applies.
The following information relates to Cellcom’s activities for the current financial
year:
1. Gross income amounts to R2 240 000, before taking into account the
following information:
2. Cellcom’s employees belong to the company’s pension fund and medical
aid fund. Cellcom contributes to these funds on behalf of the employees.
Contributions, on behalf of the employees, during the year to the pension
fund amounted to R110 000 and to the medical aid fund R135 000.
Cellcom’s total remuneration approved by the Commissioner is R2 350 000.
3. The financial manager, Mr Amounts, resigned on 31 July 2006. In order to
prohibit him from trading in direct competition to Cellcom, the company paid
him an amount of R550 000 as compensation for him restraint trade for the
following 5 years. The full amount was included in Mr Amounts’ income on
his 2007 income tax return.
4. The debtors clerk indicated that the doubtful debts amount to R2 500 000.
The commissioner will allow a doubtful debt allowance of R625 000 in the
current year. The doubtful debt allowance claimed in the 2006 year of
assessment amounted to R760 000.
5. Cellcom’s management decided to establish another service provider and
concluded an agreement with Shop-a-lot shopping centre to rent shop
space from them. The period of the lease is 10 years and occupation date
is 1 October 2006. According to the lease contract, Cellcom has to pay a
lease premium of R40 000 on occupation date, as well as monthly rent of
R7 000.
6. Cellcom concluded and agreement with Office Space (Pty) Ltd to lease a
piece of land with a small office building for their head office activities. The
lease determines that the lease period is 20 years as of 1 September 2006.
According to the contract, Cellcom has to affect improvements to the
existing buildings and extend the office space at a cost of R1 500 000. The
improvements commenced on 1 October 2006 and was completed on 1
January 2007 at a cost of R1 400 000. The building was also brought into
use on this date.
7. Legal cost to the amount of R175 000 was incurred for the following:
R
- Drafting all of the above lease contracts and agreements 35 000
- Collection of outstanding trade debtors 85 000
- Court case in respect of employees remuneration 55 000
(note: employee remuneration is deductible for purposes of this question)
8. Penalties and interest paid to the south African Revenue Service amounts
to R16 000.
9. Bad debts written off consist of: R
- Loan to director 80 000
- Trade debtors 122 000
10. The following prepaid expenditure was incurred:
- Rental of the switchboard system for head office for the period
1 July 2007 to 31 January 2008 40 000
- Security services for the period 1 July 2007 to October 2007 20 000
- Deposit for the purchases of a delivery vehicle that will be
delivered on 1 September 2007 85 000
11. Repairs were incurred for the following reasons:
- Service and repair of leased photocopy machine 4 000
- Repaving the parking area which was in a bad condition.
Undercover parking was erected at the same time at a cost
R20 000 (this cost is included in the total amount of R35 000) 35 000
12. The fixed assets of Cellcom that were used during the year
consisted of the following:
- Furniture (desks and chairs) purchased on 1 February 2004 120 000
- Photocopy machine purchased on 1 January 2002 8 000
- Computers purchased on 1 August 2006 90 000
Practice note 19 allows the following write-off periods for these assets:
- Furniture 6 years
- Photocopy machine 5 years
- Computers 3 years
All amounts exclude VAT. Show all calculations. Items which are not taxable or
deductible should be indicated clearly as such. Round of all amounts to the
nearest Rand.
Question (22 marks, 26 minutes)
Gizmo CC is a small business corporation that was incorporated in 2006 and started trading on 1 May
2009. It rents out a commercial building in Johannesburg from which it earns rental income. Gizmo
CC owns the building and has only one tenant, Mega Music, which occupies the building. Gizmo CC is
a registered VAT vendor
The following information relates to the year of assessment ended 29 February 2010: (All amounts
exclude VAT unless stated otherwise.):
Income
1. Rental income
Gizmo CC receives a monthly rental of R20 000 from Mega Music. The lease agreement was
entered into on 1 May 2009. Mega Music moved into the building on the same date.
2. Lease premium
Gizmo CC received an initial lump-sum amount of R50 000 (excluding the monthly rent) from
Mega Music on signing the lease contract on 1 May 2009. MEGA Music is entitled to occupy
the building from 1 May 2009 for a period of five years, with the right to extend the period
for a further five years. (assume a discounting rate of 0,74)
3. Leasehold improvements
The lease agreement imposed an obligation on Mega Music to effect improvements to the
building by adding a secured parking lot for customers at a cost of R90 000. The construction
of the parking lot commenced on 1 June 2009 and was completed and brought into use on 1
December 2009 at a cost of R110 000. (Assume a discounting rate of 0,74.)
Expenses
1. Improvements to commercial building
2. Interest on loan
Gizmo CC obtained a loan from a bank in order to effect the improvements made to the
rundown commercial building. Interest paid on the loan was incurred as follows:
Gizmo CC incurred legal fees in the amount of R12 000 in drawing up the deed of lease
between itself and Mega Music.
4. New computer
Gizmo CC purchased a new computer on 1 June 2009 for R13 500 (VAT included), which is to
be used for running the business.
5. Second-hand motorcycle
In November 2008 a second-hand motorcycle was purchased for R32 000, for making ad hoc
deliveries. In January 2010 the motorcycle was scrapped after being in an accident. Gizmo
CC elects the section 11(o) allowance.
Gizmo CC paid rates and taxes amounting to R8 400 for the period December 2008 to 30
April 2009.
7. Other
Expenses in the amount of R46 000 were incurred by Gizmo CC for the 2010 year of
assessment. Assume they were all tax deductible.
REQUIRED:
a) Calculate the income tax liability of Gizmo CC for the year of assessment ended 29 February
2010. (16)
b) Calculate the allowance tax deductions that Mega Music would be able to claim only in
relation to the lease agreement entered into with Gizmo CC. mega Music has a 31 December
year end. (6)
Question (38 marks, 46 minutes)
You are a trainee accountant and a member of the audit team currently performing the audit of
Betty B (Pty) Ltd (“Betty B”). Betty B manufactures lipsticks at its factories. One of the factories is
located in the south of Johannesburg, and it manufactures and distributes lipsticks locally. The other
factory is in East London, and it manufactures and distributes lipsticks to overseas markets. Betty B is
a registered VAT vendor.
The financial accountant at Betty B has almost completed the calculation of the taxable income for
the year of assessment ended 31 December 2009. She is unsure how to handle some of the
transactions that occurred during the year for taxation purposes and has asked that you complete
the taxable income calculation taking these transactions into account.
The taxable income she arrived at was R2 356 000. Assume the calculation of this figure is correct (in
terms of the provisions of the Income Tax Act).
The following are the transactions she is unsure of: (All amounts exclude VAT unless stated
otherwise.)
1. Dividends
Betty B received the following dividends during the year of assessment:
Betty B also paid out a dividend of R780 000 to its shareholders on 31 December 2009.
2. Insurance premiums
Insurance premiums of R245 000 were paid in full for the 12-month period from 1 August
2009 to 31 July 2010.
3. Fixed assets
3.1 Machine Forex was purchased new from a supplier in Germany for 100 000 Euros on 1
October 2009. Freight and insurance costs of R23 000 were paid. The machine was
delivered on 31 October 2009 and brought into use on 22 December 2009. The
purchase price was settled on 31 January 2010. Machine Forex is used to manufacture
the lipstick holders.
The spot rates were as follows:
3.2 Betty B purchased a portable generator from its South African subsidiary company for
R150 000 on 31 May 2009 and brought into use on the same day. (The cost of the
generator for the subsidiary was R80 000 and the current market value is R95 000).
Assume that the subsidiary had written R20,000 off the generator at the date of sale.
Interpretation note 47 accepts a five-year write-off period for portable generators.
Betty B sold the generator on 30 November 2009 for R200 000 as it had been decided
to purchase a more powerful generator in the next year.
3.3 Machine Hotex2 is a second-hand wax-melting machine that was purchased and
brought into use on 30 October 2009. The purchase price was R1 million. It cost Betty B
another R50 000 to install the machine in the factory. Machine Hotex2 was purchased
to replace Machine Hotex1 which had been destroyed in a fire earlier in the year.
Machine Hotex1 was purchased new in January 2006 for R850 000. It had a tax value of
R340 000 at the beginning of the current year of assessment. Betty B received an
insurance payout of R285 000 (including VAT) from the insurance company for the
destroyed Machine Hotex1. Betty B elected to apply paragraph 65 of the Eighth
Schedule.
4. Trademark
On 30 June 2009 one of the lipstick trademarks Betty B had registered in 2006 was renewed
for a further three years at a cost of R75 000.
5. Design
On 31 May 2009 Betty B purchased a specific design to be used for their lipstick winter range
from Levron Cosmetics for R120 000.
A dedicated team employed by Betty B was used in a highly scientific research and
development project. The aim of the project was to develop a lipstick range that would
colour lips for up to 16 hours without reapplying. Salaries amounting to R451 440 were paid
to the team in the year of assessment. On 1 January 2009 the team purchased a machine
used in the research and development of the range for an amount of R108 000.
7. Advertising
An extensive advertising campaign was launched to promote Betty B’s summer lipstick
range. The campaign included a billboard positioned near a Sandton shopping centre in
Johannesburg and a series of television advertisements during the seven o’clock news. The
campaign ran for a period of three months, from 1 July 2009 to 30 September 2009. The
total cost of the campaign was R450 000.
Betty B decided to move all operations to Johannesburg and therefore disposed of their East
London factory. On 30 June 2010 the factory was disposed of for R2 750 000. The valuation
date value of the factory is R2 million.
Betty B purchased the factory for R750 000 on 1 January 2001. In May 2006 the factory was
expanded. The expansion costs amounted to R250 000. The expansion was completed and
brought into use on 1 November 2006.
The tax value of the factory on the date of disposal is calculated as follows:
The current year allowances for the factory have already been taken into account in the
taxable income of R2 356 000.
The accountant does not know what to do with a capital loss that Betty B incurred on
various disposals of capital assets in the prior year. The loss amounted to R45 000.
REQUIRED:
Complete the taxable income calculation of Betty B (Pty) Ltd for the year of assessment ending 31
December 2009. (38)
You must start your calculation with the taxable income of R2 356 000 taking into account the
above-mentioned transactions for taxation purposes only.
SOLUTIONS
QUESTION
DED INCOME
WORKING 1 FURNITURE
WORKING 2
Patent
MACHINE Z
Calculation of the taxable income of Veli Jeans (Pty) Ltd for the year of assessment 31 March 2015:
R R
Closing stock:
Jeans
Cost: jeans 2 050 000
(4)
- Direct materials and labour 1 900 000
- Maintenance of manufacturing machines 400 000
- Bonus: marketing manager - not manufacturing -
- Damage: jeans (250 000)
T-shirts
- Donation: at market value 200 000
(1)
Calculation of the taxable income of Veli Jeans (Pty) Ltd for the year of assessment 31 March 2015:
R R
T-shirts
- Donation: at market value 200 000 (1)
PART A
Calculation of income tax payable by Digital Systems (Pty) Ltd for the year of assessment ended
31 March 2015
R R
Taxable portion of
Par 66 (100% x R387 600) 387 600 (1)
recoupment
Award mark if % recoupment agrees with Machine Z w & t %
Machine Z
Cost price 524 400
Supporting structure 12 540 (1)
Total cost 536 940
S 12E wear & tear allowance (R536 940 x 100%) (536 940) (1)
Operating research expenses (R2 350 000 x 150%) (3 525 000) (1)
Building improvements:
research facility
section 11D (R4 500 000 x 80%) (1) x 50% (1) (1 800 000)
section 13quin (R4 500 000 x 20%) x 5% (45 000) (1)
Office furniture (R68 000 x 50%) (34 000) (1)
Tax due
(R982 875 - R300 000) x 28% + R24 580 216 585 (1)
PART B
Calculation of the income tax liability of Clivia Nursery (Pty) Ltd for the year of assessment
28 February 2015
R
Less: Practice note 19- wear and tear R140 000/4 (35 000) (1)
Lease premium
Add: Accounting total lease premium
paid 600 000 (1)
Less: Lease premium (s11(f)) R600 000/15 (1) x 3/12 (1) (10 000)
Prepayment
Add: Prepaid insurance (s 23H) R90 000 x 10/12 Note 1 75 000 (2)
Note 1
The prepaid expense was for a period greater than six months after year end and therefore may not be
deducted for taxation purposes. Only the portion of the expense relating to the year end
may be deducted, therefore resulting in the prepaid portion being adjusted for.
QUESTION 2
Sparky CC : Calculation of normal income tax for the year of assessment ending 28 February 2007
Calculations R R
Sales 2 520 000 (½)
Cost of sales (1 348 000) (½)
Dividends received Exempt (R15 000 - R15 000) - (1)
Operating expenses (875 000) (1)
Bad debts Trade debtors (5 000) (1)
Loan to former employee (not
included in income previously) - (1)
Legal fees (s11(c) Collection of trade debtors (5 700) (1)
Loan to former employee (not in the production of income) - (1)
Computer equip (s11(e)) (R91 200 x 100/114)/3 x 5/12 (11 111) (2)
Motor vehicle (s11(e)) R273 600/5 x 9/12 (41 040) (2)
New machine A (s12C) [(R433 200 x 100/114) – R26 000] x 20% (70 800) (2)
Original machine B Cost price 210 000 (½)
2004: R210 000 x 20% (42 000) (½)
2005: R210 000 x 20% (42 000) (½)
2006: R210 000 x 20% (42 000) (½)
2007: R210 000 x 20% (42 000) (42 000) (1)
Tax value on date of destruction 42 000
Proceeds (R16 000 + R200 000) 220 000 (1)
Recoupment (limited to original cost not included in gross
income as per paragraph 65) 168 000 (1)
Capital gain (not all included paragraph 65) 10 000 (1)
New machine A (s12C) (R443 200 x 100/114) x 20% (77 754) (1)
Paragraph 65 recoup 20% X 168 000 33 600 (1)
Paragraph 65 CGT 20% X 10 000 X 50% 1 000 (1)
Interest paid Pre-production interest (s11(bA)) (5 776) (1)
Current year (s11(a)) (62 209) (1)
Fines Section 23(d) - (1)
Interest Section 23(d) - (1)
Repairs (s11(d)) Replacement of a component (20 000) (1)
Security gate – (capital in nature) - (1)
Patent dev & reg cost All own development therefore write off in full (130 000) (1)
Patent renewal (s11(gB)) (13 000) (1)
Trademark purchased No allowance after 29.10.99 - (1)
Distribution to member Capital in nature - (1)
Taxable income (152 790)
QUESTION 2:
t Workings Deduction Income Sales 4 735 220 Doubtful debts 68 220 x
Workings Deduction Income
Sales 4 735 220
Doubtful debts 68 220 x 25% 17 055
Purchase stock 1 240 000 / 1.14 1 087 719
Purchase stock 185 000 / 1.2 154 167
Forex loss (185 000 / 1.2) – (185 000 / 1.25) 6 167
Opening stock Lower cost or market value 182 300
Closing stock Lower cost or market value 192 000
22 April –div rec 23 000
Div exemption (23 000)
2 May Div 35 000
Div exemption (35 000)
17 Aug Div 68 000
Div exemption (68 000)
Salary (540 000 – 55 000) 485 000
Loan written off Not deductible -
Rent paid 1 x 2 000 2 000
* Lease premium 480 000 x 1 5 x 1 12 8 000
Depreciation office building Not depreciable -
Pre-production interest 1/1/06-31/03/06 deductible when 24 728
brought into use
Pre-production interest 1/4/06 -30/09/06 deductible when 8 230
brought into use
Post production interest 88 765
Trademark Not deductible -
Legal expense debtors 3 800
Legal expenses–lease Capital therefore not deductible -
Insurance Fully deductible < 6 months 40 300
1
2
Dividend cycle 1
1 Jan 2016 – 30 June 2016
Dividend cycle 2
1 July 2006 – 1 Feb 2007
2
3
3
QUESTION 3
SOLUTION TO QUESTION 2
Calculation of allowances, deductions and income of Earthquip (Pty) Ltd for the year of
assessment ended 30 June 2007
R R
Pre-production interest s 11(bA)
(R1 000 000 × 18% × 6/12) 90 000 (1)
Interest on loan s 11(a)
(R1 000 000 × 18% × 4/12) 60 000 (1)
Contributions to funds: Provident 75 000 (½)
Medical aid 95 000 (½)
170 000
Limited to 10% of R2 500 000 s11(1) 250 000 (½)
Thus 170 000 (½)
Bad debts s11(i)
[R200 000 × (R1 – R0,10)] 90 000 (2)
Doubtful debt allowance s 11 (j)
2006: Add back to income (25% × R2 000 000) (500 000) (1)
2007: Deduct from income (25% × R3 000 000) 750 000 (1)
Patents s11(gA)
Patent A: Greatest of (R30 000/10 years)
or (4% × R30 000) 93 000 (1)
Patent B: (R20 000 × 5%) 1 000 (1)
Stock: Opening 1 July 2005 11 000 000 (1)
Closing 30 June 2006 (15 000 000) (1)
Restraint of trade payment s 11(cA)
Deductible portion = portion regarded as
income in receiving person’s hands = R300 000 (1)
Limited to lesser of:
R300 000/5 years = R60 000; or (1)
R300 000/3 = R100 000, thus 60 000 (2)
s 12C allowance
Trax: Cost 2 700 000
Transport and installation 300 000 (1)
3 000 000
Less: wear and tear:
2007 (R3 000 000 × 40%) 1 200 000 1 200 000 (1)
2
R R
SOLUTION TO QUESTION 3B
Calculation of Profit CC’s taxable capital gains or assessed loss for the year of
assessment ended 31 December 2006
R
Calculation of proceeds
but limited to allowances in the past, of R3 300 000 3 500 000 (1)
Given – Rnil
Divide cost between pre 1/10/01 and post 1/10/01 costs: (1)
Pre 1/10 Post 1/10 Total
R R R
Cost 3 300 000 - 3 300 000
Less: Allowances 3 300 000 - 3 300 000 (1)
As the proceeds exceeds the expenditure, determine the following three items:
20% × (proceeds after deducting expenditure incurred after the valuation date)
= 20% × (R200 000 – R0)
= R40 000 (1)
QUESTION 4
Calculation of the tax payable by / refundable to ABC (Pty) Ltd the year of assessment ended 31 March 2007:
R R
Net profit (given) 755 000 (1)
Plus / minus:
Profit on sale of building (185 000) (1)
Loss on sale of warehouse 65 000 (1)
Depreciation – delivery vehicle - (1)
Depreciation – machine A 102 000 (1)
Wear-and-tear – machine A (written off in full) - (1)
Depreciation – machine B 10 000 (1)
Wear-and-tear – machine B (600 000) (1)
Insurance 135 000 (1)
Insurance – s23H (R135 000 / 12 x 1 mnth) (11 250) (1)
Calculation of total capital gain:
Capital gain – office building 185 000
Capital loss – warehouse (65 000)
Total capital gain 120 000
QUESTION
Calculation of the taxable income of Cellcom (Pty) Ltd for the year of assessment
ended 30 June 2007
R
Gross income 2 240 000 (1)
Doubtful debt allowance – 2006 760 000 (1)
Contribution to funds (R110 000 + R135 000) = R245 000
limited to: 10% × R2 350 000 (235 000) (1)
Restraint of trade payment (lesser of: R550 000/5 or R550 000/3) (110 000) (2)
Doubtful debt allowance – 2007 (625 000) (1)
Lease premium – Shop-a-lot (R40 000/10 × 9/12) (3 000) (2)
Rent paid – shop-a-lot (R7 000 × 9) (63 000) (1)
Leasehold improvements – Office Space (R1 400 000/19y 8m × 6/12) (35 593) (3)
Legal costs - lease contracts - (1)
- collection costs (85 000) (1)
- court cases (55 000) (1)
Penalties and interest – not deductible - (1)
Bad debts - loan to director (not previously included in income) - (1)
- trade debtors (122 000) (1)
Prepaid expenses - rent 7 months > 6 months) - (1)
- security services (4 months < 6 months) (20 000) (1)
- deposit (capital expenditure) - (1)
Repairs - photocopy machine (4 000) (1)
- paving (R35 000 – R20 000) (15 000) (1)
- undercover parking (renewal) - (1)
Wear-and- - furniture (R120 000/6) (20 000) (1)
tear - photocopy machine (8 000/5 × 6/12) - last few
months (800) (2)
- computers (R90 000/3 × 11/12) (27 500) (2)
[30]
1
Question 2
Workings Deduction Income
Rental 10 x 20 000 200 000
Lease premium 50 000
Lease improvement 90 000
11 (h) reduction (1 – 0.74) x 90 000 23 400
There was a net lease
improvement of 66 600
Building -
Improvement – Urban 200 000 X 20% 40 000
development building
Pre production interest 31 200
Post production interest 18 000
Legal fees 0
Computer 13 500 x 100/114 x 50% 5 921
2nd hand motor cycle Cost 32 000
2008 yr (16 000)
16 000 16 000
Sold for Nil
Loss 16 000
16 000
Expenses 46 000
135 079
6 608
Part B
Question
Workings Deduction Income
Taxable income 2 356 000
Div received – SA co 200 000
Exempt (200 000)
Div Rec – Foreign co 45 000
Div paid Not deductible 0
Insurance 245 000 x 5/12 102 083
Prepayment
245 000 x 7/12
=142 917
>6 months -
> 80 000
Not deductible
Machine Cost 100 000 x 9.2= 920 000
Freight 23 000
943 000
x 40% 377 200
Forex loss (10.5 – 9.2) X 100,000 130 000
Generator Cost is the lesser of actual
Acquired from a cost R150,000 or
connected person
Original cost 80,000
Less: Allowances (20,000)
Plus receoupment 20,000
Plus Taxable capital
Gain 70,000x50% 35,000
115,000
Cost 115,000
X 1/5 x 6/12 (11,500) 11 500
103,500
Sold for 200,000
Recoupment 11 500
Proceeds
200,000 – 11,500 = 198,500
Base cost
150,000 – 11,500 = 138,500
Working 1 – Generator
Workings 2
On sale of factory
Recoupment 300,000
Base cost = Base cost pre 2001 and Base cost post 2001
Total cap gain = R50,000 + 237,500 – 45,000 cap loss carried forward from last year = R242,500
QUESTION (17 Marks, 21 Minutes)
PART A
Manuals Ltd purchased a manufacturing building for R2 500 000 on 1 July 2001. They were
allowed the section 13 allowance (assume 5%) for buildings used in a process of manufacture.
The market value of the building on 1 October 2001 was R5 000 000. Due to constructional
defects that arose in the design, management decided to scrap the building. On 1 April 2006
the building was disposed of for R500 000.
On 15 December 2004, Manuals Ltd purchased 1 000 shares in Budget (Pty) Ltd for R400 per
share. These shares were sold on 1 June 2006 for R500 per share. Manuals Ltd is not a share
dealer as defined.
The time apportioned base cost of the building when sold was R1,125,000.
a) Calculate the proceeds and base cost for both the sale of the asset and shares for capital
gains tax purposes for the year of assessment ending 30 June 2006. (11)
b) Calculate the taxable capital gain or loss to be included in Manuals Ltd taxable income for
the year of assessment ended 30 June 2006. (4)
PART B
In the next year of assessment Manuals Ltd made a R800 000 capital profit on a sale of an
administrative building. There were no other capital gains or losses for the year of assessment.
Calculate the taxable capital gain or loss for the year of assessment ended 30 June 2006.
Assume current legislation is applicable for all years covered. (2)
Manufac CC is a manufacturing business. On 1 August 1999, it acquired a 2nd hand manufacturing building for R3
000 000. Transfer duty and legal costs amounted to R325 000. Repairs of R180 000 were effected during April
2004. The building was sold on 31 May 2007 for R5 000 000. The building was valued on 1 October 2001 at a
market value of R3 500 000.
Assume that the time apportioned base cost is R2 832 500 if applicable.
a) Calculate the capital allowances and recoupments of Manufac CC for the year of assessment ended 30 June
2007. (5)
b) Calculate Manufac CC’s capital gain or capital loss for the year of assessment ended 30 June 2007. (Refer to
Annexure A). (10)
1. A delivery vehicle, purchased on 1 July 2005 for R205 200, was sold on 30
November 2006 for R114 000. X Ltd qualified for the section 11(e) wear-
and-tear allowance (practice note 19) as well as the section 11(0) allowance
on this asset.
2. An office building was sold on 24 January 2007. The selling price amounted
to R2 250 000 (excluding VAT). The office building was purchased on 10
December 2004 for R1 600 000 (excluding VAT).
Costs incurred in connection with the office building, for the period
10/12/2004 until 20/01/2007, amounted to R1 076 000 (excluding VAT)
and consisted of:
R
Improvements 220 000
Transfer duty paid 236 000
Interest paid on mortgage bond 410 000
Property tax 210 000
1 076 000
Interest paid on the mortgage bond and property taxes were allowed as
deductions for income tax purposes.
3. X Ltd’s assessed capital loss brought forward from the previous year of
assessment, amounted to R75 000.
VAT 101
(14 MARKS, 17 MINUTES)
Formatica Limited has been manufacturing spare parts for computers for the past 10 years. They have
been registered for VAT on the invoice basis since the inception of VAT in 1991.
The following information has been extracted from the applicable account in the General ledger for the
two months ended 30 April 2007. All amounts exclude VAT (all tax invoices are available).
Note:
30% of all sales relate to sales made to customers in Zimbabwe which are all on credit.
Sales in South Africa are 20% cash sales and 80% credit sales.
Other information
During the two months ended 30 April 2007, debtors made payments amounting to R159 600.
this amount includes VAT.
Date
Asset description Date disposed of
purchased Amount Amount
Manufacturing machinery: R R
Machine A
(second hand) 20/02/2005 68 400 31/03/2007 57 000
Machine B 01/04/2007 79 800 -
Other assets:
Passenger vehicle 30/06/2007 91 200 -
Delivery vehicle 30/09/2006 121 000 -
Office furniture 30/04/2007 15 500 -
1
2
- The passenger vehicle is a pool vehicle for use by all management for business
purposes only. In terms of practice note 19 the write-off period is five years.
REQUIRED:
(a) Calculate the VAT payable by or refundable to Formatica Limited for the two
month period ended 30 April 2007. (12)
2
VAT 150 (24 Marks, 28 Minutes)
Maloi Vusi Manufacturers (Pty) Ltd trades as MV Manufacturers. The company is registered on the
invoice basis for VAT purposes. The company’s financial year-end is 28 February.
The accountant provided you with the following extract from the company’s records for the VAT
period 01.11.2007 to 30.11.2097. (All amounts include VAT, unless stated otherwise).
R
INCOME
Sales
- within RSA 1 589 425
- direct exports 15 895
467
AIS Insurers (Note 1) 205 200
EXPENSES
Raw materials purchased 7 659 448
Telephone 8 456
Petrol 18 965
Office tea and refreshments 1 852
Repairs – rented vehicles 25 312
Bank charges 3 894
Salaries and wages 485 742
Rent paid – existing factory building 228 000
Instalments – BASA Bank – new factory building (Note 3) 130 000
Notes:
1) One of the manufacturing machines, machine 42, was totally destroyed due to a mechanical
fault. The insurance company paid MV Manufacturers R205 200 in connection with the
insurance claim on 20 November 2007. Machine 42 was purchased second hand on 1
February 2006 at a cost price of R239 400.
2) A new manufacturing machine, machine 78, was purchased on 5 November 2007 at a cost
price of R285 000, with the intention to replace machine 42. The machine had to be installed
first, before it could be brought into use on 1 December 2007.
3) In order for MV Manufacturers to expand its capacity, the company began to erect its own
factory building during April 2007. The building was completed on 31 August 2007 at a cost of
R9 690 000 and was brought into use on 1 September 2007. The first instalment on the
mortgage loan from BASA Bank was payable on 1 October 2007. The instalments amount to
R130 000 per month.
YOU ARE REQUIRED TO:
a) Calculate the VAT payable by / refundable to MV Manufacturers for the VAT period ended 30
November 2007; and (14)
b) Calculate all the capital allowances, scrapping allowances and recoupments which will be
included in the taxable income of MV Manufacturers for the year of assessment ended 28
February 2008. (Ignore Capital Gains Tax). Assume that paragraphs 65 and 66 of the 8th
schedule will not apply to the replacement of any assets. (10)
1
VAT 100
(12 MARKS, 22 MINUTES)
The accounting system operated by Pebbles CC has provided the following analysis of income and
expenditure for its two-month tax period ended on 31 January 20X8. (All amounts are inclusive of VAT
where applicable):
Pebbles CC is registered on the invoice basis and the necessary tax invoices were issued by the CC or
received by the CC unless otherwise stated.
R
Income
Expenditure
Notes:
1. The insurance settlement of R36 480 was received in respect of a delivery vehicle
which was stolen from the CC ‘s premises in November 20X7. In January 20X8, on
receipt of the insurance settlement a new delivery vehicle was purchased by the CC
(See note 2).
- A Yotoya passenger vehicle driven by the sales manager which was purchased
in 20X6 for R99 850 (including VAT of R12 262). The sales manager had the
full use (private and business use) of this vehicle for the entire tax period and he
bears all costs relating to the vehicle.
- A delivery vehicle which was purchased in cash during January 20X8 at a cost
of R62 700 (including VAT of R7 700) to replace the vehicle that was stolen (see
note 1).
1
2
3. Insurance premiums were incurred in respect of the vehicles as well as the various
buildings owned by the CC.
R
Facsimile machine 2 736
Photocopier 1 482
Coffee machine 1 026
5 244
REQUIRED:
Calculate the net amount of VAT due to or by the Receiver of Revenue for the two-month tax period
ended on 31 January 20X8.
2
3
Input
Bank charges
Audit fees
Salaries and Wages
Delivery vehicle
Insurance premiums
Depreciation
Office rentals
3
1
VAT 103
(20 marks, 24 minutes)
Rentals (Pty) Limited is a property owning company which derives its income from commercial rentals.
Rentals (Pty) Limited is registered for VAT on the invoice basis.
The financial manager has provided you with the following analysis of income and expenditure for its two-
month tax period ending 31 January 2007All amounts are inclusive of VAT where applicable, except
where otherwise stated.
R
Income
Rentals 307 230
Interest levied on overdue rentals 10 659
Insurance settlement (Note 1) 40 128
Expenditure
Bank charges 1 380
Audit fees 15 675
Salaries and Wages 72 732
Sozo delivery vehicle (Note 2) 68 970
Depreciation (Note 2) 16 047
Maintenance (Note 3) 18 058
Insurance premiums (Note 4) 16 550
Interest on mortgage bonds 94 050
Office equipment rentals (Note 5) 5 760
Staff subsistence (Note 6) 815
Petrol 2 070
Bad debts 10 784
Notes:
1. The insurance settlement of R40 128 was received in respect of a delivery vehicle
that was stolen from the company’s premises on 1 November 2006. The book value
of the delivery vehicle at the time it was stolen was R28 820.
The delivery vehicle was originally purchased for R39 900 (including VAT of R4 900)
on 1 December 2005 and brought into use on the same date. In December 2006, on
receipt of the insurance settlement a new delivery vehicle was purchased by the
company (see Note 2).
h First, a Benzo passenger vehicle used by the managing director of the company
which was purchased in 2005 for an amount of R145 350 (including VAT of R17
850). The managing director had the full use of this vehicle for the entire tax
period.
h Secondly, a Sozo delivery vehicle that was purchased and brought into use on 1
December 2006 at a cost of R68 970 (including VAT of R8 470) to replace the
delivery vehicle that was stolen (see Note 1). the Sozo delivery vehicle is used
by various maintenance staff to transport the maintenance teams between the
buildings owned by the company.
1
2
3. Maintenance costs include paint, paint brushes and other hardware items purchased
in order to effect repair work to the various buildings owned by the company.
4. Insurance premiums were incurred in respect of the Benzo, the Sozo as well as the
various buildings owned by the company.
R
Facsimile machine 3 010
Photostat machine 1 630
Coffee machine 1 120
5 760
6. Staff subsistence includes tea and coffee provided to staff during working hours.
7. The write-off periods for vehicles in terms of Practice note 19 are as follows:
REQUIRED:
(a) Calculate the VAT payable by or refundable to Rentals (Pty) Limited for the two-
month tax period ended 31 January 2007. (14)
2
VAT 151 (15 Marks, 18 Minutes)
Zedcom Ltd is a manufacturer of children’s toys. Zedcom Ltd is registered for VAT on the invoice basis.
The accountant printed the following extracts from the general ledger for the period 1 April – 31 May 2006. All
amounts include VAT unless otherwise stated.
R
Receipts
Sales of toys – within RSA (Note 1) 300 000
Sales of toys – delivered outside RSA (Note 1) 150 000
Shares issued (Note 2) 500 000
Interest received on fixed deposit 25 000
Payments
Cash purchases of raw materials 200 000
Payments of suppliers (Note 3) 210 000
Fuel 7 500
Assets purchased for cash (Note 4) 166 000
Water and electricity 6 000
Notes:
1. Zedcom sells on credit to all its customers, both within and outside the RSA. Due to the struggling economy the
debtors have not been paying as they should. The directors decided to write off R5 000 worth of bad debt on 1
May 2005. The debt was more than 180 days old.
2. Zedcom Limited offered ordinary shares to the public. The company was authorised to issue 15 000 shares at R50
each. A total of 10 000 shares at R50 each were sold.
March R 70 000
April R120 000
May R 60 000
June R 90 000
4. Assets purchased:
Second hand computers were purchased from Seedy CC (not a registered VAT vendor) to the value of
R110 000.
Chairs and tables to be used in the staff tea room, purchased from Easy Seats (Pty) Ltd. for R56 000.
5. Zedcom provided one of their managers with a single cab bakkie as a fringe benefit from 1 May 2006. This light
delivery vehicle could be used by the manager for all his private travelling needs. The cost price of the vehicle was
R100 000 (excluding VAT), and was purchased during 2004.
Calculate the amount of VAT due by or refundable to Zedcom Ltd for the tax period ending 31 May 2006.
1
Hannah Ltd is a vat vendor that is registered as a category B vat vendor. You have
been asked to assist in the preparation of the February vat return. Hannah Ltd is a B
category vendor.
Income
Expenditure
Hotel for sales The company paid for the sales 6,000
manager manager to go on holiday
Rent paid Residential accommodation given to
marketing manager for the month of 10,000
February
Furniture acquired To put into marketing managers
house 18,000
Hotel – sales Out of town hotel costs for the sales
representative representative paid for various 2 day 8,000
stays at hotels.
Hotel – consultant Out of town costs for a consultant
employed by company who stayed
35 days out of town at same hotel 10,000
Meals provided to Meals provided in the staff canteen
staff at zero cost 90,000
Second hand office Acquired from Bertie Winsor, a non
furniture vendor. R40,000 was paid in
February and the remaining R60,000
is payable in April. R100,000
Dividend in specie to Trading stock with a cost of R3,000
shareholder and a market value of R3,500 was
declared as a dividend to the sole
shareholder 3,000
Dividend paid in cash 97,000
Bad debts Trade debtors 228,000
Bad debts Interest on trade debtors 16,000
Bad debts Export sales 60,000
Bad debts Staff loans 76,000
Salaries 467,000
Promotional material Promotional material with a cost of
R11,400 and an open market value
of R17,100 was handed to
5
customers 11,400
Payment to The managing director networked at
Wanderers club the Wanderers Golf Club and the
company paid his club subscriptions 6,500
Payment to UNISA For a employee studying CTA at
UNISA 11,100
Shares in supplier B Ltd supplied 30% of the raw
acquired material needed by the company. A
21% share in B Ltd was acquired 789,000
Notes
1. Cash sales of R20,000 that were stolen On 27 February, the insurance
company indicated R12,000 would be paid as a result of an insurance claim in
respect of the stolen cash. None of the above has been recorded in the sales
figure.
2. Trading stock was bought in December 14 months ago for R11,400. The
quality of the material was found to be substandard and an amount of R2,280
was paid to the supplier. The remainder has been under dispute for 14
months now.
3. The company was overpaid for goods in January by R3,000. They have not
refunded the amount to the debtor.
4. A deposit of R15,000 was received by the company. The amount is
refundable by the company. Another R5,000 deposit was forfeited. The
deposit was for trading stock debtor owing. Neither was recorded in the
income statement.
5. A loan of R700,000 was taken out to acquired to buy the shares in B Ltd (see
above)
6. Goods worth R9,000 were repossessed to settle a debtors account that was
shown at R5,700. No entries had yet been processed in this regard.
All amounts include VAT unless otherwise stated. Assume all expenditure was
incurred with vendors and the relevant vat invoices have been obtained unless
otherwise stated.
New South African Breweries Ltd (NSAB) is a company that is registered for vat as a
category C vendor.
In the past, SARS has agreed with the company that a turnover basis will be used to
apportion vat and the following percentages has been agreed upon:
• 50% local sales of beer
• 15% export sales of beer
• 10% commercial accommodation renting of chalets at a game farm
• 5% commercial rentals
• 20% residential accommodation provided to staff working in the factory
The following income statement has been provided. All amounts exclude vat.
Income
Local sales of local beer 3,000,000
Export sales of beer 900,000
Commercial rentals 275,000
Residential rentals 1,300,000
Sale of a commercial Profit on sale of building sold for
building R6,000,000. The building was acquired in
1988 before vat was introduced 4,800,000
Commercial More than 28 days 12,000
accommodation Less than 28 days 200,000
Profit on sale of The mainframe computer for the
computer accounting department was destroyed by
a fire. The computer cost R125,000 and
was fully written off as at the date of the
fire. The insurance company paid out
R30,000 for the computer. 30,000
7
Expenditure
Computer 1 acquired A computer was acquired for use in the
accounting department 10,000
Computer 2 acquired A computer was acquired for use in the
factory 5,000
Conversion of vehicle A vehicle that was a motor car as defined
expense was acquired in the previous vat period
for R200,000. The vehicle was converted
to a 9 seater game viewing vehicle during
the current period when its open market
value was R180,000. 30,000
Training course for
accounting staff 7,000
Bad debt Commercial accommodation bad debt for
customer who spent 45 days at resort 9,000
Cost of international flight Flight overseas for managing director
who was trying to negotiate distribution
rights for an international beer brand 23,000
Canteen expenses The canteen was operated to provide
subsidized lunch to factory employees 140,000
Local flight Flight by beer factory manager 5,000
Salaries of staff At residential accommodation 125,000
Salaries of staff Other staff 760,000
Rates paid For all buildings other than residential
accommodation -
Electricity and water For residential accommodation 15,000
Bank charges All bank accounts 1,900
Bus purchased, at cost The bus was purchased to transport
employees from the residential
accommodation to the factory. The 800,000
employees were not charged.
Bus coupons Purchased for other staff that do not live
in residential accommodation 45,000
Calculate all the output vat and input vat based on the information provided above.
8
SOLUTIONS
QUESTION
PART A
Therefore base cost = R1,125,000 (base cost pre 2002) + Nil (Base
cost post 2002) = 1 125 000 + Nil = 1 125 000 (1)
PART B
a) Calculation of the allowances and recoupments of Manufac CC for the year of assessment ended 30 June
2007
Total
R
Cost price 3 000 000
Plus: Transfer duty and legal fees 325 000 (1)
Total cost price 3 325 000
Less: Capital allowance (1 330 000) (1)
R3 325 000 x 8 years x 5% straight line no pro-rata
Tax value 1 995 000
b) Calculation of taxable capital gain or capital loss of Manufac CC for the year of assessment ended 30 June
2007
R
Proceeds (Note 1) 3 670 000
Less: Base cost (Note 2) (3 500 000)
Capital gain 170 000 (1)
1. PROCEEDS
Selling price 5 000 000
Less: Recoupment (1 330 000)
Proceeds for capital gains tax purposes 3 670 000 (1)
2. BASE COST
- Divide cost between pre and post 01.10.01
Before After
01.10.01 01.10.01 Total
R R R
Cost price 3 000 000 - 3 000 000
Plus: Transfer duty and legal fees 325 000 - 325 000
Total cost price 3 250 000 - 3 250 000
Less: Capital allowances R332 500 x 3 years (975 000) - (975 000)
Total Value / Cost for CGT 2 275 000 - 2 275 000 (1)
- Calculate valuation date value R
Apply par, 26, as adjusted proceeds > cost, thus choose the greater of:
• market value on 01.10.2004; or 3 500 000 (1)
• 20% x (proceeds – allowance expenditure incurred after valuation date) 734 000 (1)
• = 20% x (R3 670 000 – R0): or
• time apportionment base cost 2 832 500 (4)
• Given = R2 832 500
.
Calculation of X Ltd’s taxable capital gain for the year of assessment ended 31
March 2007:
Delivery vehicle
INCOME TAX CALCULATION: R
Capital gain -
Office building
Calculation of base cost R
Cost 10/12/2004 1 600 000
Plus: Improvements 220 000
Transfer duty 236 000
Interest paid -
Property tax -
[17]
1
Output tax R
82 441
Input tax
Salaries and Wages - (½)
Bank charges (R78 x 14%) 11 (1)
Entertainment expenditure - (½)
Fuel - (½)
Oil (R40 x 14%) 6 (1)
Sundry expenses (R323 498 x 14%) 45 290 (1)
Provisional tax - (½)
Telephone account (R500 x 14%) 70 (1)
Stationery (R680 x 14%) 95 (1)
Machine B (R79 800 x 14/114) 9 800 (1)
Office furniture (no deemed input tax) not second hand - (½)
55 272
1
SUGGESTED SOLUTION TO VAT 150
INPUT
Raw materials 14
7 659 448 × 946 634 (1)
114
Telephone 14
8 456 × 1 028 (1)
114
Petrol NIL (1)
Office tea and refreshments (Exempt) NIL (1)
Repairs on rented vehicles 14
25 312 × 3 108 (1)
114
Bank wages 14
3 894 × 478 (1)
114
MACHINE 42
CALCULATION OF RECOUPMENT
Cost 100
239 400 × 210 000 (1)
114
Section 12C 2006 tax year (42 000) (1)
Section 12C 2007 tax year (42 000) (1)
Section 12C 2008 tax year (42 000) (1)
84 000
Sold for 100
205 200 × 180 000 (1)
114
Recoupment 96 000 (1)
CAPITAL ALLOWANCES
Machine 42 42 000 (1)
Machine 78 100
285 000 × × 40%
100 000 (1)
114
Factory building 100
9 690 000 × × 5%
425 000 (1)
114
SCRAPPING ALLOWANCES
There are no scrapping allowances (1)
Note that the recoupment would have been deferred and recognised over the life of the
replacement asset if paragraph 65 of the 8th schedule had been applied.
1
R
Output
Input
11 900
1
1
1. Calculation of the VAT payable by or refundable to Rentals (Pty) Limited for the two-month tax
period ended 31 January 2007.
OUTPUT TAX R
42 752
INPUT TAX
16 708
1
2
2. Calculation of the capital allowances, recoupments and scrapping allowances applicable to the
assets for the year of assessment ended 28 February 2001.
R
Stolen delivery vehicle
Recoupment 8 020
Capital gain
Calculation of proceeds
2
SUGGESTED SOLUTION TO VAT 151
VAT due by or refundable to Zedcom Ltd for the tax period 1 April – 31 May 2006
Output tax
R
Credit sales – RSA (R300 000 x 14/114) 36 842 (1)
Credit sales – outside RSA (zero rated supply – export) - (1)
Share issue (exempt supply – financial service) - (1)
Interest received (exempt supply – financial service) - (1)
Fringe benefits (R100 000 x 0,6% x 14/114 x 1 month) 74 (2)
36 916
Input tax
All amounts include VAT and as such all amounts must be multiplied by 14/114
Output
1
2
in use 430
Fringe benefit – car to MD [(0,3% X 300,000 X 100/114) –
85] X 14/114 X 2 173
Fringe benefit – Holiday No vat input claimed, no vat
accommodation output -
Fringe benefit – Residential Residential accommodation
accommodation exempt -
Meals provided to staff Fringe benefit, but as it relates
to the supply of entertainment to
staff, no output vat charged as
no input vat claimed on
acquisition of the meals -
Dividend to shareholder Greater of R3,000 or R3,500 X
14/114 recorded as total change
in use 430
Promotional material Nil consideration X 14% -
2
3
Input
3
4
4
5
80% of supplies are considered to be taxable supplies. The 20% exempt supplies of
residential accommodation are not the provision of taxable supplies.
Output vat
Local sale of beer 3,000,000 X 14% 420,000
Export of beer Zero rated -
Commercial rentals 275,000 X 14% 33,772
Residential rentals Residential accommodation exempt -
Sale of commercial Even though vat not claimed on acquisition
building as vat had not been applicable on
acquisition, output vat chargeable
6,000,000 X 14% 840,000
Commercial >28 days 12,000 X 60% X 14% 1,008
accommodation <28 days 200,000 X 14% 28,000
Bus coupons to staff Fringe benefit. No output charged as bus
coupons are exempt from vat on
acquisition -
Computer lost in fire 30,000 X 80% X 14% (For insurance and 4,200
fringe benefits, vat output is apportioned)
Input vat
Commercial building No vat claimed on acquisition of building as
sold vat not yet introduced. Vat cannot be
claimed on sale -
Computer 1 acquired Accounting department used for all
supplies 10,000 X 80% X 14% 1,400
Computer 2 acquired Factory 5,000 X 100% X 14% 700
Game viewing vehicle Conversion cost 30,000 X 14% 420
Value on date of conversion180,000X14% 25,200
Training course for
accounting staff 7,000 X 80% X 14% 784
Bad debt 9,000 X 60% X 14% 756
Overseas air ticket Zero rated -
Canteen expenses Entertainment – Input vat denied -
Local flight 14% X 5,000 X 100% 700
Salaries – Res acc Not an enterprise -
Salaries – Other Not an enterprise -
Rates paid Zero rated -
Electricity and water Exempt supply residential accommodation -
Bank charges 1,900 X 14% X 80% 213
Bus purchased (30 Can claim input vat on 30 seater bus
seater) 800,000 X 14% X 100% - Used for factory
only. Not exempt as the company did not
charge a fare to employees 112,000
Bus coupons Transport of fare paying employees is an
exempt supply -
5
Provisional tax
Question 1
Bee Ball (Pty) Ltd has a 31 December year-end. The company is neither a small business corporation nor a
micro business:
The 2011 assessment (assessed 21 January 2013) reflected R750 000 as taxable in- come; and
The 2012 assessment (assessed 1 October 2013) reflected R790 000 as taxable income.
The financial director of Bee Ball (Pty) Ltd resigned on 30 November 2013 and as a result the accounting
records are not up to date and no estimated taxable income for the 2013 tax year is available.
When should the first provisional payment be made for the 2014 year of assessment?
When should the first provisional payment be made for the 2014 year of assessment?
What is the first provisional payment amount for the 2014 year of assessment?
When should the second provisional payment be made for the 2014 year of assessment?
What is the second provisional payment amount for the 2014 year of assessment?
Question 2
Sunshine (Pty) Ltd is not a small business corporation as defined. Its year of assessment ends on 31 March
each year. Its records show the following:
Tax year Taxable income Date of assessment
When should the first provisional payment be made for the 2014 year of assessment?
When should the first provisional payment be made for the 2014 year of assessment?
What is the first provisional payment amount for the 2014 year of assessment?
When should the second provisional payment be made for the 2014 year of assessment?
What is the second provisional payment amount for the 2014 year of assessment?
First provisional payment date
Question 2
Taxable income is more than R1 million therefore based on estimated taxable income 1 784 432