Development of Logo-Cinematherapy Program On The Depression Level and Meaning in Life of The College Inmate Students in Camp Sampaguita, New Bilibid Prison
Development of Logo-Cinematherapy Program On The Depression Level and Meaning in Life of The College Inmate Students in Camp Sampaguita, New Bilibid Prison
ISSN No:-2456-2165
Keywords:- College Inmate Students, Depression, Logo- Despite of this, movies have always been considered
Cinematherapy Program, Meaning in Life. by people of all ages as a form of relaxation and
entertainment. In some instances it makes people cry, laugh,
freightened, or fascinated by the stories created by both local
and international film makers ( Sharp, Smith, and Cole,
2002 ). Movies are therapeutic and reflective ( Berg – Cross
Employing different statistical treatments to determine the validity and effectivity of the program development. The
following are the tables and results including the explanation of it.
Table 1 illustrates the demographic profile of the participants in terms of age, civil status, crime committed, and length of
sentence. Frequency and percentage is being used in presenting the data.
Table 1 Frequency and Percentage Distributions of the Participants when grouped according to Age, Civil Status, Crime
Committed, and Length of Sentence.
Demographic Profile Variable Experimental Group Control Group Frequency %
N = 40 N = 40
25 – 30 5 7 12 15
31 – 40 11 11 22 27.5
Age 41 – 50 11 15 26 32.5
51 – 60 9 7 16 20
61 – 70 4 0 4 5
Total 40 40 80 100
Single 21 14 35 43.75
Married 16 17 33 41.25
Civil Status Seperated 3 8 11 13.75
Cohabilitating 0 1 1 2.5
Total 40 40 80 100
Against Person 37 39 76 95
Against Property 3 1 4 5
Crime Committed Against Public Order 0 0 0 0
Total 40 40 80 100
1 – 10 13 16 29 36.25
Length of Sentence 11 – 20 17 19 36 45
21 – 30 1 0 1 1.25
31 – 40 9 5 14 17.5
Total 40 40 80 100
Table1 illustrates the demographic profiles of the participants. They are classified into four ( 4 ) categories such as their age,
civil status, crime committed, and length of sentence. Considering the age group of the participants most of them are in the ages
between 41 – 50 years old, 26 ( 32.5 % )closer to that is the age between 31 – 50 years, 22 ( 27. 5%), while very few of them are
classified as senior citizen, 4 ( 5% ). In civil status most of them are either single, 35 ( 43.75 % ) or married, 33 ( 41.25 % ). Only
1 member of the groups attested that he is cohabitating ( 2.5 % ). In the crime committed almost all of them violated crimes
referring to crime against person, 76 ( 95%), none of them were imprisoned due to crime against public order, 0. Many of them
where sentenced between 11 – 20 years of imprisonment , 36 ( 45% ) while 29, ( 36.25 % ) needs to languish between 1 to 10
years. While 14, ( 17.5 % ) where meted a prison length of Reclusion Perpetua or life imprisonment with a numerical value of 30
years and one day to 40 years.
Table 2 Shows the Pretest and Posttest Mean Score of the 8 Participants in Terms of Depression Level and Meaning in Life Pilot
Testing Group Test Result in Terms of Depression Level and Meaning in Life
Variable Pre Test Interpretation Posttest Interpretation
Depression Level 25.3 Moderate Depression 12.9 Normal
Moderate Normal
Meaning In Life 81.6 Unclear Meaning In Life 114.2 Clear Meaning In Life
Unclear Clear Meaning In Life
Table 2 displays the men score result of the pilot testing group. It shows that the depression level and meaning in life of the
group is negative, which means they are suffering from moderate depression and also experiencing unclear meaning in life. After
the sessions, it reflects that their the two variables improves to a normal range. Which indicates the success of the program given
to the participants.
Table 3 shows the results of Pretest and Post test of Purpose in Life Test. Computing the mean scores and standard
deviation of the 4 groups.
Table 3 shows the pretest and post test means scores and standard deviation of the 4 groups in terms of meaning in life. The
Experimental Group 1 has a pretest mean score of 80.3 which is classified as unclear meaning in life, with a standard deviation of
13.08, the post test mean score of 95.4 interpreted as indecisive meaning in life and a standard deviation of 17.85. The Control
Group 1 has a pretest of 84.1 or defined as unclear meaning in life with a standard deviation of 9.57, in posttest the mean score is
95.85 or indecisive meaning in life and a standard deviation of 9.69. The Experimental Group 2, has a mean in the pretest of 95.85
and a standard deviation of 22.48, while the Control Group 2 who remains in unclear meaning in life with a mean score of 90.05
with a standard deviation of 16.06.
The pretest mean score showed unclear meaning in life in Experimental Group 1 and Control Group 1. The post revealed
the interpretation of indecisive for Experimental Group 1, Control Group 1, and Experimental Group 2. While the Control Group
2 remain unclear. It displayed that the logo-cinematherapy is effective, while the NBP Program works effectively in Control
Group 1, but failed to Control Group 2.
Table 4 shows the results of Pretest and Post test of Becks Depression Inventory - 2. Computing the mean scores and
standard deviation of the 4 groups.
Table 4 Pretest and Post Test Mean Scores and Standard Deviations in the Depression Level of the 4 Groups
Groups Pretest Standard Deviations Post Test Standard Deviations
A. Experimental Group 1 20.05 11.95 7.92
Moderate Depression 6.47 Normal
B. Control Group 1 19.3 13.55 57.57
Mild Depression 4.85 Normal
C. Experimental Group 2 _________ __________ 13.4 8.52
Normal
D. Control Group 2 _________ __________ 17.15 9.77
Mild Depression
Table 4 explains the pretest and post test mean scores The pretest mean score in depression level is moderate
and standard deviation in terms of depression level among ( Experimental Group 1 ), mild ( Control Group 1) and
the 4 groups. The Experimental Group 1 has a mean score moves to normal in the posttest , same result yields to
of 20.05 or moderate depression, with standard deviation of Experimental Group 2. While the Control Group 2 remain
6.47, while the post test score of 11.95 indicates that they in Mild depression after being measured. It shows that the
have minimal level of depression or almost no depression Logo-cinematherapy is effective in decreasing the
experience at that time . In the Control Group 1, the result depression of the participants, while the NBP program does
of the pretest is 19.3 or mild depression and a standard not encompasses effectivity to all in terms of decreasing or
deviation of 7.92. In Experimental Group 2, the post test reducing the depression of the inmates.
score revealed that they have minimal or acceptable level of
depression, 13.4. While the standard deviation 8.52, While Table 5 displayed a significant difference between in
in Group 2, the depression level in mean score of the post the pretest and post test scores in the meaning in life of the 4
test remains to be depressed as they are classified groups. T – test of independent mean or uncorrelated for
experiencing mild depression with a standard deviation of Comparisons of Groups in the Pretest and Post test of
9.77. Experimental Group 1 and Experimental Group 1 vs.
Control Group 1. T – test of dependent mean or correlated
for Experimental Group 1, Control Group 1, and
Experimental Group 2 vs. Control Group 2, also in terms
Pretest and Post test.
Control Group 1 Yes Yes 9.60 2.032 Reject Ho 0.81 Large Effect
Significant
Experimental Group 2
Vs. Control Group 2 ------- Yes 2.31 2.032 Reject Ho 0.20 Very Small
Significant Efeect
Table 5 shows the comparison of groups in terms of In the comparisons of the groups between
meaning in life. The first comparison is between Experimental Group 1 and Control Group 1, the pretest
Experimental Group 1 and Control Group 1. The pretest scores of Experimental Group 1 and Control Group 1
mean score were compared and it shows that the tabular showed insignificant or it means that they almost have the
value ( 2.032 ) is greater than the computed value of 1.02. same level in meaning in life before the intervention or
The null hypotheses is accepted which means it is treatment. In the groups between Experimental Group 1 and
insignificant. With the same groups comparing their postest Control Group 1, the post test scores shows insignificant
mean score results, the computed value of 0.06 is lesser than which means that the logo – cinematherapy and NBP
the tabular value of 2.032,in which the null hypotheses is Programs are both effective in alleviating the meaning in
accepted as it implies insiginificant. The Experimental life. In the Experimental Group 1 as measured in pretest and
Group 1 examining the effect of logotherapy with them it posttest in meaning in life. This group who undergo logo-
displayed significant effect with a computed value of 10.1 cinematherapy showed increase in alleviating in meaning in
and the tabular value of 2.032 which the null hypotheses is life. It has a large effect as to compare the result of their
rejected and connotes significance. The computed effect pretest against the post test . In the Control Group 1, who
size of 0.83 gives an interpretation of large effect of the undergo the regular program of NBP showed increase in
program to this group of participants. The Control Group 1 meaning in life. From unclear meaning in life to indecisive.
as to determine if their meaning in life improves based from The effect was also large in effect, as to compare their
the program given by the NBP, using the pretest and posttest pretest to post test. In the groups between Expeoirmental
scores, the computed value is 9.60 and the tabular value of Group 2 and Control Group 2, as to compare their post test
2.032 which it rejects the null hypotheses and indication of scores result, it shows that there is a small effect on the two
siginificance of the program of NBP in terms of their group in terms of logo – cinematherapy and NBP Programs.
meaning in life. The computed effect size of large, signifies The NBP Programs failed to take effect on Control Group 2
that the program of NBP top this group is effective. The in meaning in life.
comparison of groups between the Experimental Group 2
and Control Group 2 considering the result of the post test Table 6 displayed a significant difference between in
coming from these two groups, the computed value is 2.31 the pretest and post test scores in the depression level of the
with the tabular value of 2.032 which indicates that the null 4 groups. T – test of independent mean or uncorrelated for
hypothesis is rejected which showed significance and the Comparisons of Groups in the Pretest and Post test of
effect size is very small. Experimental Group 1 and Experimental Group 1 vs.
Control Group 1. T – test of dependent mean or correlated
for Experimental Group 1, Control Group 1, and
Experimental Group 2 vs. Control Group 2, also in terms
Pretest and Post test.
Table 6 shows the comparison of groups in terms of depression level. The first comparison between Experimental Group 1
and Control Group 1 in their pretest scores showed that the computed value of 0.57 is lesser than the tabular value of 2.032 which
means it accepts te null hypotheses and same results yields to their post test using the same groups, whose computed value is in
the same value of 0.57 which also accepts the null hypotheses. Examining the pre test and post test scores of the Experimental
Group 1, the computed value of 14.79 and with a tabular value of 2.032, the effect size ( 0.91 ) which means a large effect on the
program they received. For the Control Group 1, the pretest and post test displayed a result of 4.99 for computed value with a
tabular value of 2.032 which means the null hypotheses is rejected. The effect size ( 0.54 ) which means a medium effect on the
program of NBP to the inmates who belongs to this group. The groups of Experimental Group 2 and Control Group 2 in the post
test scores reflects a computed value of 3.35 and the tabular value is 2.032 which resulted to the rejection of the null hypotheses
with an effect size of 0.98 which means a large effect in the result.
In the comparisons of groups between Experimental Group 1 and Control Group 1, the pretest scores showed it has almost
the same level of depression before the exposure of the groups either in logo-cinematherapy and NBP Programs. The posttest
scores of Experimental Group 1 and Control Group 1 is almost the same, both groups are normal in depression. It shows that the
Logo-cinematherapy and NBP Programs are effective in reducing or normalizing the depression. The Experimental Group 1, who
undergo logo – cinematherapy displayed effectivity. Their depression level becomes normal after participating in the 12 sessions.
It shows large effect in terms of pretest to post test result. The Control Grpup 1 reduced their depression and move to the normal
level, after going to the NBP Programs. The effect of this was in medium as to compare the result of the pretest and post test
results. The depression level of Expeirmental Group 2 and Control Group 2 has a large effect in the depression level. The
Expeirmental Group 2 becomes normal after logo-cinemetherapy while the Control Group 2 failed to have a normal depression.
Table 7 explains the effectivity of the logo-cinematherapy in the depression level of the participants.
Table 7 Effectivity of Logo-Cinematherapy Program on the Depression Level of the Two Groups
Groups In Logo-Cinematherapy Pretest Posttest
Experimental Group 1 20.05 11.5
Moderate Depression Normal
Experimental Group 2 ___________ 13.4
Normal
Table 7 explains the result of the pretest and post test mean scores of the two groups who undergo logo-cinematherapy. The
Experimental Group 1 showed a mean score of 20.05 for pretest which means moderate in depression level while the
Experimental Group 2 is also classified as a group suffering from depression. After sessions and participation in Logo-
cinematherapy, the depression of the participants both in the two groups becomes normal, as the post test reveals that it is 11.5 for
the Experimental Group 1 and 13.4 for Experimental Group 2. Which the two mean scores has an interpretation of Normal or
Minimal Depression.
The result of this table clearly explains that the program created for them particularly the logo-cinemetherapy is effective in
decreasing the level of depression experienced by the students
Table 8 explains the effectivity of the logo-cinematherapy in the meaning in life of the participants.
Table 6 shows the effect of logo-cinematherapy were facilitated to them, after watching discussions were
program on the meaning in life to the 2 groups of followed using the Socratic Method. In each sessions
participants. The Experimental Group 1 pretest showed a questions about the films and themselves were being
mean score of 80.3 which means unclear meaning in life discussed and they share their answers and perceptions with
while it shows the same result for the Experimental Group 2 each other. At the end of the sessions an assignment where
who also experienced the same meaning in life. After given to them to for them to fully understand and internalize
sessions of logo-cinemtherapy the post test mean score the movie seen and the logotherapy facilitated. Post test
showed an increase to Experimental Group 1, 95.4 which where also given to the two experimental groups after which
means Indecisive while 95.85 which also has an the control groups were also given the post test of the two
interpretation of Indecisive for Experimental Group 2. tools ( BDI-2 and PILT ).
The program of logo-cinematherapy displayed Computation and statistics shows that the demographic
significant effect on the meaning in life of the participants. profile of the participants respecting at their age, civil status,
The participants of the two groups have perceiving crime committed, and length of sentence. Most of the
somehow a clear meaning in life after actively participating participants in their age ranging from 41 to 590 years old
in the program. Although they are not totally move out from 26( 32.5%) and only 4( 5% ) of them are senior citizen age
the unclear meaning in life to a clear meaning in life but ranging 61 to 70 years old. In civil status, most are single
then the post test results suggest that the program itself can 35 ( 43.75 % ) and only 1 ( 2.5%) are cohabitating. Majority
assist them in having a better meaning in life. of them were imprisoned due to crime against person
76(95%). As per court decided meted there imprisonment
IV. DISCUSSION 36(45%). While 29(36.25%) are sentence to be imprison
from 1 to 10 years. The pretest and post test in terms of
The participants of the study are all interpreted having meaning in life as measured by the PILT showed that the
double negative interpretation. They are depressed which mean score in the pretest of the 4 groups are all unclear
varies in intensity either mild, moderate, or severe. At same meaning in life after the sessions of logo-cinematherapy to
time, they are also seen having unclear meaning in life or the two Experimental Groups their mean scores increases,
existential vacuum. From the entire population of the Experimental Group 1, 95.4 ( SD= 17.85 ), and for
college department in Camp Sampaguita, the pretest were Experimental Group 2, 95.85 ( SD = 22.48). The Control
facilitated and out of 320 students 98 of them are qualified Groups where continuously availing the NBP programs, the
with the set criterion of two negative interpretation. The 8 Control Group 1 has a mean score of 95.85 (SD = 9.56 ),
participants were randomly chosen to be a member of pilot and for Control Group 2, 90.05 ( SD = 16.06 ) which
testing which is composed of 2 sessions for Establishing indicates that this group ( CG2 ) remains to be in Unclear
Rapport and 12 sessions for Logo-cinematherapy, then the Meaning In Life. Referring for the depression level of the
post test is given after a week from the last session. The participants as measured by the BDI – 2, it shows that the 4
post test mean score for the 2 test shows that they reduced groups as reflected that they are depressed either in mild,
and eradicated depression which gives them an moderate, or severe level. After the sessions of logo-
interpretation of normal while their meaning in life changes cinematherapy, a post test is given and the two experimental
and turns to be indecisive. Based from the results and groups revealed that they are moved to normal level. The
observations from the dry run of the program mean score of the Experimental Group 1, 11.95 ( SD = 7.92
) , and for Experimental Group 2, 13.4 ( 8.52). The Control
Some revisions and improvements are made to make Groups who failed to experience the logo-cinematherapy,
the program suited and fitted for the participants in the showed that the Control Group 1, 13.55( 57.57 ) who were
actual group. It shows that the program logo – move to normal range, and for Control Group 2, who
cinematherapy is effective to the small group of population. remains to be depressed under mild depression with a mean
score of 17.15 ( SD = 9.77 ).
The actual group were composed of 4 groups to
comply for the research design of Solomon 4 Group. Using Examining the significant difference between the
the sampling technique of Purposive Sampling Technique, pretest and post test of the 4 groups. It shows that the
80 individuals were assigned randomly into the groups. comparing the pretest result of Experimental Group 1 and
Which has a total of 20 participants in each group. Same Control Group 1 from the computed value of 1.02 and the
with the pilot test group, they undergo 2 sessions of tabular value of 2.032, which the null hypotheses is accepted
Establishing Rapport, part of these is the introduction of the which means insignificant it also explains that the program
researcher to them and same with the participants who also has no effect to the participants since it haven’t started when
introduce themselves. 12 Sessions of Logo-cinematherapy the pretest for meaning in life is given. Comparing the post