1 Wells - Complaint at Law FILED 2023.04.19
1 Wells - Complaint at Law FILED 2023.04.19
Plaintiff,
Complaint at Law
vs.
Defendants.
COMPLAINT AT LAW
Litem for the Estate of Tyre Deandre Nichols, by and through her attorneys, and in complaining
PRELIMINARY STATEMENT
On January 27, 2023, the world bore witness to videos of a gruesome, barbaric display of
police brutality on the streets of a quiet neighborhood in Memphis, Tennessee from the night of
January 7, 2023. Caught on film for all to see was the abhorrent and reprehensible conduct of the
City of Memphis’ unqualified, untrained, and unsupervised police officers, acting under the color
of law and pursuant to officially sanctioned, unconstitutional policies and practices. The innocent
victim was a 29-year-old father of one, who was on his way home to have dinner with his parents.
The disturbingly tragic events of the night were created and set in motion over a year prior
when the Memphis City Council appointed Cerelyn Davis as the new Police Chief. The savage
beating of Tyre Nichols was the direct and foreseeable product of the unconstitutional policies,
practices, customs, and deliberate indifference of the City of Memphis and Chief Davis, the City’s
In 2021, the City of Memphis hired Davis as its Chief of Police and Shawn Jones as the
Assistant Chief of Police. The City did so with full knowledge that both individuals had previously
served in the Atlanta Police Department where they played prominent roles in the RED DOG unit:
a police unit that was eventually disbanded due to numerous allegations of violations of the Fourth
Amendment to the United States Constitution, including—but not limited to—illegal searches and
seizures and excessive force. Turning a blind eye to these officials’ histories of disregard for the
Constitution and the rights of Atlanta citizens, the City of Memphis made a conscious choice to
disregard the rights of its own, to bring these two individuals on, and to bestow them with the
History would repeat itself as Davis and Jones reverted back to their RED DOG days in
Atlanta. In late 2021, the two created an identical unit within the Memphis Police Department that
1
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 3 of 139 PageID 3
they claimed would root out an alleged crime problem within the City. Instead, it predictably
implemented the same unconstitutional mandates, policies, and customs thereby breeding its own
insidious and institutionalized corruption that left a multitude of constitutional violations in its
wake. Their now-disbanded Memphis unit carried a name that will forever live in infamy for the
devastation and carnage it caused: the Street Crimes Operation to Restore Peace In Our
Rather than “restore peace” in Memphis neighborhoods, the SCOPRION Unit brought
terror. Taking its eponym to the extreme, the SCORPION Unit was designed as a “Sting” unit. In
officers turned loose on the Memphis community without any oversight. They were instructed to
strike without warning and, many times, without any valid constitutional basis. Consistent with
the directives received from Chief Davis, herself, SCORPION Officers carried out untold Fourth
Amendment violations with a focus on Black men living in Memphis. The ultimate irony is that
the Department and these officers’ mission was to enforce the law—not break it.
After a year of doing so and operating with impunity, the SCORPION Unit carried on into
2023 with its sanctioned mission to inflict terror and fear on the community in the name of
“stopping crime.” Just a week into the new year, on the night of January 7, the SCORPION Unit
set its sights on 29-year-old Tyre Nichols for one singular reason: he was a young, black man.
The basis for SCORPION Unit officers stopping Tyre’s car on January 7, 2023 has never
been substantiated nor could there ever be a basis for the frenzy of force that was about to be
unjustifiably unleashed. Two SCORPION Officers baselessly stopped Tyre’s car, forcefully
dragged him out onto the roadway, and violently apprehended him without ever articulating a
2
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 4 of 139 PageID 4
reason for the stop. As the SCORPION Officers escalated the situation with harsh and disgusting
profanity and hostility, Tyre attempted to deescalate with measured communication and calmness.
Upon recognizing these officers were operating with seething aggression and unjustified
force, Tyre fled the scene toward his home where he lived with his parents. What transpired next
can only be described as a pack of wolves attempting to hunt down their wounded prey. Just feet
from his parents and the safety of his home, five SCORPION Officers tracked Tyre down and
deployed their sting in the form of repeated punches, kicks, and pepper spray to a non-resistant,
restrained young man shouting for his mother while they unleashed their physical hostility upon
him. When Tyre fell to the ground, he was lifted back up so that officers could continue to tee-off
with more punches, strikes, kicks, and chemical sprays—all of this with full knowledge that their
body-worn cameras were recording every second. Such a ruthless and brutal beating could only be
carried out by officers that were devoid of any fear of discipline or intervention by a supervisor
and with a hardened, defined sense of impunity garnered from those running their Department.
To be sure, there was never any attempt to intervene by any officer or Memphis Police
Department official at any point as Tyre remained defenseless throughout the onslaught. When it
was finished, Tyre’s body was propped up against the police car to be displayed like a battered
trophy to be touted for the countless Memphis officials that would arrive on the scene. Pictures
would be taken, jokes would be made, and medical care would be withheld for over twenty minutes
as Tyre’s body lay devastated from the beating. Indeed, he was dying and those on scene knew it.
Tyre was eventually transported to the hospital where he battled for nearly three days until
his body could not fight any longer. At the time of his death on January 10, 2023, Tyre’s condition
in the ICU was compared to that of Emmitt Till—a young man brutally beaten and killed in
Mississippi in 1955. Like Till nearly 70 years prior, Tyre was left unrecognizable because of the
3
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 5 of 139 PageID 5
beating he endured at hands of a modern-day lynch mob. Unlike Till, this lynching was carried out
by those adorned in department sweatshirts and vests and their actions were sanctioned—expressly
Far from being the result of the actions of five rogue police officers, the events of January
mandate on the streets of Memphis without any fear of retribution or consequence because of an
acceptance of and deliberate indifference to unconstitutional conduct that had been fostered since
This lawsuit is a civil indictment under the laws of the United States against the City of
Memphis, its Police Department, its Chief of Police, the SCORPION Officers involved, and all
those complicit in the deprivation of Tyre Nichol’s constitutional rights, his pain and suffering in
his last days on this Earth, and his wrongful death on January 10, 2023.
4
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 6 of 139 PageID 6
1. This Court has jurisdiction over federal questions pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331,
1343; 42 U.S.C. §§ 1983, 1988; and supplemental jurisdiction over state law claims pursuant to
28 U.S.C. § 1367.
2. Venue is proper in this Court under 28 U.S.C. §1391(a) because all Defendants
reside in the State of Tennessee and at least one of the Defendants resides in the Western District
of Tennessee.
3. Venue is proper in this Court under 28 U.S.C. §1391(b) because all incidents,
events, and occurrences giving rise to this action occurred in Memphis, Tennessee, which is in the
PARTIES
4. At all relevant times and until the time of his death on January 10, 2023, Plaintiff’s
decedent, Tyre Deandre Nichols, was a citizen of the United States and the City of Memphis,
of Tyre Deandre Nichols on March 29, 2023 by the Probate Court of Shelby County, Tennessee.
6. Plaintiff RowVaughn Wells is a citizen of the United States and the City of
7. Tyre Nichols is survived by his next of kin, including his minor son.
8. The City of Memphis is and was at relevant times a political subdivision of the
State of Tennessee, organized and existing under and by virtue of the laws and the Constitution of
5
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 7 of 139 PageID 7
9. Under Article XI, Section 9 of the Constitution of the State of Tennessee, the state
10. The City of Memphis Charter is entitled, “Charter and Related Laws of the City of
Memphis.”
11. The City of Memphis fulfills its policing functions through the Memphis Police
Department, which is and was at all relevant times a law enforcement agency.
12. The Memphis Police Department is led by the Director of Police Services, also
known as the “Chief of Police,” who is bestowed with the following authority under the City of
a. The director of police services shall have general care of the peace of the
city, and shall see that all subordinates do their duty in preserving the
same. Title 2, Chapter 2-30, Sec. 28-3.
b. He or she shall have control over the entire police force and see to the
execution of every ordinance. Title 2, Chapter 2-30, Sec. 28-3.
c. He or she shall have general supervision over the subject of nuisances, and
the abatement of same, and shall exercise and discharge all such powers
and functions as pertain to his or her office and perform such other duties
as may be required of him or her by this Code or other ordinance. Title 2,
Chapter 2-30, Sec. 28-3.
e. The director of police may, from time to time, promulgate and shall
enforce such rules and regulations for the conduct of the police division,
not inconsistent with the Charter and ordinances of the city, as may be
necessary for the efficient conduct of the division and policing of the city.
Title 2, Chapter 2-30, Sec. 2-28-7.
6
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 8 of 139 PageID 8
13. The Director of Police Services, also known as the Chief of Police of the Memphis
Police Department, is and was at all relevant times the final policymaker as it relates to the
14. The Director of Police Services, also known as the Chief of Police of the Memphis
Police Department, is and was at all relevant times the final policymaker as it relates to the
implementation of police hiring and assignment to specialized units within the Memphis Police
Department.
15. The Director of Police Services, also known as the Chief of Police of the Memphis
Police Department, is and was at all relevant times the final policymaker as it relates to the
16. The Director of Police Services, also known as the Chief of Police of the Memphis
Police Department, is and was at all relevant times the final policymaker as it relates to the
17. In April 2021, the City of Memphis appointed Cerelyn Davis (“Chief Davis”) as
the Director of Police Services, also known as the Chief of Police of the Memphis Police
Department.
18. Upon information and belief, Chief Davis is and was at all relevant times a citizen
of the United States, the State of Tennessee, and the City of Memphis.
19. At all relevant times, Chief Davis was employed by the City of Memphis as the
duly appointed Chief of Police and Director of Police Services, was acting in her official capacity,
was acting under color of state law, and was acting within the scope of her employment with the
City of Memphis.
7
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 9 of 139 PageID 9
20. Upon information and belief, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III is and was
at all relevant times a citizen of the United States, the State of Tennessee, and the City of Memphis.
21. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III (hereinafter
“Martin” or “Martin III”) was employed by the City of Memphis through the Memphis Police
Department as a duly appointed and sworn police officer, was acting in his individual capacity,
was acting under color of state law, and was acting within the scope of his employment with the
City of Memphis.
22. Upon information and belief, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley is and was
at all relevant times a citizen of the United States, the State of Tennessee, and the City of Memphis.
23. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley was employed by
the City of Memphis through the Memphis Police Department as a duly appointed and sworn
police officer, was acting in his individual capacity, was acting under color of state law, and was
acting within the scope of his employment with the City of Memphis.
24. Upon information and belief, Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith is and was at all
relevant times a citizen of the United States, the State of Tennessee, and the City of Memphis.
25. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith was employed by the
City of Memphis through the Memphis Police Department as a duly appointed and sworn police
officer, was acting in his individual capacity, was acting under color of state law, and was acting
26. Upon information and belief, Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills Jr. is and
was at all relevant times a citizen of the United States, the State of Tennessee, and the City of
Memphis.
8
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 10 of 139 PageID 10
27. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills Jr. was employed by
the City of Memphis through the Memphis Police Department as a duly appointed and sworn
police officer, was acting in his individual capacity, was acting under color of state law, and was
acting within the scope of his employment with the City of Memphis.
28. Upon information and belief, Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean is and was
at all relevant times a citizen of the United States, the State of Tennessee, and the City of Memphis.
29. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean was employed by the
City of Memphis through the Memphis Police Department as a duly appointed and sworn police
officer, was acting in his individual capacity, was acting under color of state law, and was acting
30. Upon information and belief, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill is and was
at all relevant times a citizen of the United States, the State of Tennessee, and the City of Memphis.
31. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill was employed by
the City of Memphis through the Memphis Police Department as a duly appointed and sworn
police officer, was acting in his official capacity as a police officer for the Memphis Police
Department, was acting under color of state law, and was acting within the scope of his
32. Upon information and belief, Memphis Fire Department Emergency Medical
Technician Robert Long is and was at all relevant times a citizen of the United States, the State of
33. At all relevant times, Memphis Fire Department Emergency Medical Technician
Robert Long was employed by the City of Memphis through the Memphis Fire Department as a
duly appointed and sworn fire department officer and Emergency Medical Technician (EMT), was
9
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 11 of 139 PageID 11
acting in his individual capacity, was acting under color of state law, and was acting within the
34. Upon information and belief, Memphis Fire Department Emergency Medical
Technician JaMichael Sandridge is and was at all relevant times a citizen of the United States, the
35. At all relevant times, Memphis Fire Department Emergency Medical Technician
JaMichael Sandridge was employed by the City of Memphis through the Memphis Fire
Department as a duly appointed and sworn fire department officer and Emergency Medical
Technician (EMT), was acting in his individual capacity, was acting under color of state law, and
was acting within the scope of his employment with the City of Memphis.
36. Upon information and belief, Memphis Fire Department Lieutenant Michelle
Whitaker is and was at all relevant times a citizen of the United States, the State of Tennessee, and
37. At all relevant times, Memphis Fire Department Lieutenant Michelle Whitaker was
employed by the City of Memphis through the Memphis Fire Department as a duly appointed and
sworn fire department officer, was acting in her individual capacity, was acting under color of state
law, and was acting within the scope of her employment with the City of Memphis.
38. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Lieutenant DeWayne Smith was employed
by the City of Memphis through the Memphis Police Department as a duly appointed and sworn
police officer, was acting in his individual capacity, and was acting within the scope of his
10
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 12 of 139 PageID 12
39. Upon information and belief, Memphis Police Lieutenant DeWayne Smith is and
was at all relevant times a citizen of the United States, the State of Tennessee, and the City of
Memphis.
FACTUAL ALLEGATIONS
40. At the time of his brutal death and the violation of his constitutional rights by the
City of Memphis and its police officers, Tyre Nichols (“Tyre”) was a son, a father, a brother, a
42. Tyre was an employee at FedEx, where he worked second shift with his stepfather.
43. Tyre loved skateboarding, photography, and was a Starbucks coffee enthusiast.
44. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Department SCOPRION Officers Martin III,
Haley, Hemphill, Smith, Mills Jr., and Bean stopped Tyre Nichols without any reasonable,
articulable suspicion.
45. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Department SCOPRION Officers Martin III,
Haley, Hemphill, Smith, Mills Jr., and Bean detained Tyre Nichols without any probable cause.
46. On January 7, 2023, five Memphis Police Department SCORPION Officers Martin
III, Haley, Hemphill, Smith, Mills Jr., and Bean brutally beat Tyre within an inch of his life,
47. On January 7, 2023, at all relevant times, Tyre was unarmed, he was not resisting,
11
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 13 of 139 PageID 13
48. On January 7, 2023, numerous other government employees from the Memphis
Police Department, the Memphis Fire Department, and the Shelby County Sheriff stood by
49. On January 10, 2023, Tyre ultimately died from his injuries as a direct result of the
policies and practices of the City of Memphis, which were the moving force behind SCORPION
Officers Martin III, Haley, Hemphill, Smith, Mills Jr., and Bean’s unconstitutional stop, assault,
I. The City of Memphis’ Decision to Hire Cerelyn Davis as Police Chief with Full
Knowledge of Her History with Disbanded Police Suppression Units.
50. Chief Davis joined the Memphis Police Department in 2021 after tenures with the
51. Assistant Chief Jones joined the Memphis Police Department in 2021 after tenures
with the Atlanta Police Department, among other departments around the country.
52. Chief Davis’ history with the Atlanta Police Department and her time working on
the RED DOG (Run Every Drug Dealer Out of Georgia) Unit should have been a red flag for the
53. Assistant Chief Jones’ history with the Atlanta Police Department and his time
working on the RED DOG Unit should have been a red flag for the City of Memphis prior to hiring
54. In early June 2006, Chief Davis was appointed as a Special Enforcement Section
Commander for the RED DOG crime suppression and hot spot policing unit.
55. During her time with the RED DOG unit, Chief Davis was a street-level drug
12
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 14 of 139 PageID 14
56. Assistant Chief Jones was also involved with the RED DOG hot spot policing unit
57. The RED DOG Unit was comprised of over 30 officers working on larger teams of
58. The RED DOG Unit became infamous for their practices of “jumping out” to
ambush Atlanta citizens and aggressively harass them and strip search them in public.
59. Functioning like a gang, the RED DOG Unit also regularly presented false
information to obtain warrants and that they cut corners to make more time for lucrative side jobs
providing additional security to businesses, often while on duty, and receiving cash payments.
60. In 2006, just months into Chief Davis’ time as a Commander in the RED DOG
Unit, three narcotics officers shot and killed a 92-year-old woman in a drug raid gone wrong.
61. According to prosecutors of those narcotics officers, their “routine violations of the
62. The incident caused an overhaul of the RED DOG unit after the light was shed on
a pattern and practice of officers lying to obtain search warrants in violation of the Fourth
63. RED DOG officers’ testimony established that they were encouraged by
supervisors to engage in searches and seizures when there was no basis to do so in violation of the
Fourth Amendment.
64. RED DOG officer testimony established that officers were encouraged by
supervisors to omit written reports if they engaged in searches but found no drugs or weapons to
65. RED DOG officers were “told to get the job done, by whatever means” necessary.
13
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 15 of 139 PageID 15
66. The final straw came in 2009 when a RED DOG unit stormed into a popular
LGBTQ bar wearing black fatigues shouting profanity and homophobic slurs while throwing
patrons to the ground and handcuffing them without any probable cause.
67. The 2009 incident eventually led to a federal civil rights lawsuit under § 1983,
68. Numerous other lawsuits were also filed accusing members of the RED DOG unit
II. The City of Memphis’ Creation of the SCORPION Unit: An Institutionalized Police
Oppression Unit.
69. Fast forward over a decade and history would repeat itself in the City of Memphis.
70. Chief Davis was installed as the Police Chief of the Memphis Police Department,
71. Chief Davis was the first Black female and first female to serve as Chief of the
72. Chief Davis was also under immense pressure coming into the Memphis Police
73. Chief Davis was hired amidst a rising homicide rate in the City of Memphis and
the departure of many veteran officers due to changing compensation structures within the
74. Chief Davis knew that she would be under massive scrutiny in taking on this new
75. Less than a year after her appointment, Chief Davis and Assistant Chief Jones
resorted to their Atlanta roots and a familiar concept to gain approval: police suppression units.
14
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 16 of 139 PageID 16
76. That suppression units, the SCORPION Unit (Street Crimes Operation to Restore
Peace In Our Neighborhoods), was formed in November 2021 and was the brainchild of Chief
77. The SCORPION Unit was established as a special anti-crime policing unit under
the Organized Crime Unit umbrella of the Memphis Police Department, with officers hired and
78. Much like the RED DOG Unit, the SCORPION Unit was comprised of four roving
teams, with about 10 officers per team, operating 7 days a week and targeting different areas of
the city with the goal of addressing violent crime and homicides.
79. Much like the RED DOG Unit, the SCORPION Unit used unmarked police
vehicles, wore tactical clothing, and employed an aggressive “street-style” of policing that was
geared toward intimidation and force, rather than policing consistent with the Constitution.
80. The SCORPION Unit utilized the theory of patrolling purported “hot spot” crime
areas with “crime suppression” officers, while others focused on auto thefts and gangs.
seizing property from Memphis citizens in complete disregard of the United States Constitution
82. Much like the RED DOG Unit’s mandates to stop crime at any cost, Chief Davis
instructed the SCORPION Unit and advocated to stop citizens and deprive them of their property
83. Such instruction from Chief Davis expressly condoned SCORPION Unit Officers
15
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 17 of 139 PageID 17
84. Such instruction from Chief Davis expressly condoned SCORPION Unit Officers
85. Such instruction from Chief Davis expressly condoned SCORPION Unit Officers
86. Such instruction from Chief Davis demonstrated an explicit disregard for the
87. Much like the RED DOG Unit’s practices, the SCORPION Unit engaged in a
practice of “jumping out” to ambush Memphis citizens and aggressively harass them and search
them in public.
88. Much like the RED DOG Unit, SCORPION Unit officers were encouraged by the
Chief of Police and supervisors to engage in searches and seizures when there was no basis to do
89. Much like the RED DOG Unit, SCORPION Unit officers were encouraged by the
Chief of Police and supervisors to omit written reports if they engaged in searches but found no
90. Consistent with Chief Davis’ unconstitutional directive, SCORPION Unit Officers
engaged in pretextual traffic stops to attempt to find illegal drugs and guns by employing
aggressive police tactics to achieve quotas at the cost of the constitutional rights of Memphis
citizens.
16
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 18 of 139 PageID 18
92. Over the ensuing year and a half, the SCORPION Unit disproportionately focused
93. Like other similar police units utilized throughout the country, most of which have
been disbanded, the SCORPION Unit instilled terror in minority communities throughout
94. Like its Atlanta-predecessor in the RED DOG Unit, the SCOPRION Unit would
instill the same tactics as dictated by the two individuals intimately familiar with both: Chief Davis
95. Ultimately, SCORPION developed into a gang unit carrying out an oppression-
style of policing ratified by the Chief and Assistant Chief of Police with inexperienced, untrained,
96. The five officers who beat Tyre on January 7, 2023—Emmitt Martin III, Demetrius
Haley, Justin Smith, Desmond Mills Jr., and Tadarrius Bean—were all members of the Memphis
1 While SCORPION policing under the directive of Chief Davis and Assistant Chief Jones is the
focus of the City of Memphis allegations, there were abundant complaints of excessive force
against MPD officers in the years proceeding their appointment to MPD, including 1,200 calls to
dispatch reporting excessive force in 2021 alone, which is over 3 reports per day.
2
The New York Times reports that in reviewing a sample of arrest records, “90% of those arrested
by the (SCORPION) unit were Black—much higher than the share of the city’s population that is
Black, about 65%.” Steve Eder, Matthew Rosenberg, et. al., Muscle Cars, Balaclavas and Fists:
How the Scorpions Rolled Through Memphis. New York Times, February 4, 2023,
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/02/04/us/memphis-police-scorpion.html
17
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 19 of 139 PageID 19
97. The SCORPION Unit was responsible for Tyre’s death just 14 months after its
inception.
98. In the short time that SCORPION existed, it functioned as a notoriously violent
policing unit.
99. Tyre Nichols was not their first victim—though he is their first known fatality.
100. SCORPION Unit Officers could often be identified by their vehicles, frequently
101. Their uniforms were equally disguised as they regularly wore black hoodies and
102. SCORPION Unit Officers routinely utilized a course of conduct endorsed and
recommended by their Chief of Police: they would start their hostile and harassing encounters with
a traffic stop, sometimes for something minor like a seatbelt or tinted window infraction, or
103. Next, they would jump out of their unmarked squad vehicles while barking
commands. Those in the stopped vehicle were left confused, concerned, and frightened.
104. This pattern and practice of violent, aggressive, and unconstitutional policing is
demonstrated through the many examples of other community members who experienced similar
SCORPION encounters. Victims reported being “subdued” by pepper spray, batons, tasers, or with
105. Other SCORPION victims include, but are certainly not limited to, the following
individuals:
18
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 20 of 139 PageID 20
i. Mr. Harris maneuvered into a parking spot in the complex, and officers
ii. SCORPION Officers yelled at him to get out of his car and threatened
to shoot him.
iii. They punched him, threw him to the ground, and dragged him across
the concrete.
v. The officers only stopped when people from nearby apartments came to
vi. Mr. Harris filed a 42 U.S.C. § 1983 lawsuit against the City of Memphis
b. Cornell Walker: Just one day earlier, on January 3, 2023, Mr. Walker was
sitting in a parked car with his friend when Officer Emmitt Martin III and
19
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 21 of 139 PageID 21
shirt.
ii. Martin pulled Walker out of his car, with his gun drawn and pointed at
Walker, and dragged him to the unmarked squad where Walker was met
iii. Walker never learned why he was pulled from his car, and he was never
cited or arrested.
iv. He called the MPD Internal Affairs Unit to complain about the
conduct.
aggressively, and the people inside the car were wearing ski-masks.
ii. He was bumped by the SCORPION Unit unmarked car, and when he
20
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 22 of 139 PageID 22
iii. Officers later claimed that they approached him because he was walking
in the middle of the street, and upon searching his backpack they found
iv. Officer Mills, Officer Bean, and Officer Hemphill were all part of this
d. Sebastian Johnson, age 19 and Kendrick Johnson Ray, age 20: In August
in Memphis.
ii. Cousins Sebastian Johnson and Kendrick Johnson Ray were hanging
out with two other cousins outside at the complex when police arrived.
iii. They saw officers swarm the complex, yelling profanities with guns
unholstered.
iv. The SCORPION Unit Officers ultimately beat Mr. Johnson after
version of events.
v. Both cousins were left bloodied and bruised at the hands of the
being dismissed.
vi. At least three of the five SCORPION Officers responsible for Tyre
21
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 23 of 139 PageID 23
e. Davitus Collier, age 32: In May 2022, SCORPION Officers chased and pepper
sprayed Mr. Collier in the face when he was on his way to buy beer for his
i. He was one of three Black men in the car and was stopped by the
ii. Mr. Collier maintained that all three men were indeed wearing seatbelts.
iii. Officer Martin was one of several SCORPION Officers present, and he
demanded identification and then told Mr. Collier that there was a
iv. The car belonged to Mr. Collier’s 58-year-old father, and Mr. Collier
knew that Officer Martin was lying about the basis to needlessly detain
v. Martin began to pull Mr. Collier from his car, and out of fear Mr. Collier
witnesses.
vi. Mr. Collier slipped, and one of the SCORPION Officers tackled him
and sprayed him with pepper spray, telling him not to resist.
vii. This part of the encounter is memorialized on video and Mr. Collier was
not resisting, but rather was restrained when he was pepper sprayed.
22
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 24 of 139 PageID 24
2022, the brothers were unloading recording equipment from their car trunk at
ii. Mr. Wilbourn was terrified because he had no idea who the officers
enforcement.
iii. Officers claimed they smelled marijuana and found a legally obtained
pistol.
g. Johnny Graham, age 50: Mr. Graham has been stopped by SCORPION
Officers more than once, always pulled over by an unmarked squad for no
reason.
when they were forced to stand on the side of a busy roadway while
officers searched their car without basis and in view of many members
of the public.
23
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 25 of 139 PageID 25
106. Additional instances were brought to the attention of the Memphis City Council
Public Safety Committee at a hearing on December 6, 2022—just one month before SCORPION
107. At that meeting, local activists put the City of Memphis on further notice that
violent, pretextual traffic stops by Memphis Police Officers (including SCORPION Unit Officers)
were resulting in frequent injury and even several deaths and had been since 2013. 3
108. Police Chief Davis and at least five Memphis City Council members were in
attendance at that meeting and made fully aware of these instances of violence.
109. Despite these warnings, the City of Memphis and Chief Davis did nothing to
address the SCORPION Unit’s tactics and practices and turned a blind eye.
110. Rather, Chief Davis and other Memphis city officials allowed the SCORPION Unit
to continue to terrorize, victimize, and violate the Fourth Amendment rights of the citizens of
Memphis until it culminated in the death of Tyre Nichols one month later.
IV. The City of Memphis’ Staffing of the SCORPION Unit and the Broader Indifference
to Hiring Standards and Training Within the Memphis Police Department
111. Although fully aware that a police unit like SCORPION demanded extensive
training, experience, and judgment, the City of Memphis and Chief Davis failed to properly screen,
hire, and assign officers qualified to serve on the SCORPION Unit, knowing that such failures
3
Activists referenced Anjustine Hunter (killed in 2013 after a traffic stop), Darrius Stewart (killed
in 2015 after a traffic stop), and D’Mario Perkins (killed in 2018 after a traffic stop). While these
deaths pre-date the SCORPION unit, they are illustrative of the violent custom of MPD officers in
conducting traffic stops, the Department’s tolerance of the same, their refusal to make changes,
and the need for further training.
24
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 26 of 139 PageID 26
112. Chief Davis, as Director of Police Services, was specifically tasked with the hiring
of police officers and was the final policymaker for the City of Memphis in this capacity.
113. With a mission statement of “stopping crime at any cost,” the City of Memphis had
a constitutional duty to ensure that the officers it was hiring were qualified and capable of carrying
114. But rather than being elite, accomplished officers, SCORPION officers were often
115. The City of Memphis has a longstanding policy of declining to conduct thorough
116. For instance, five of the six named SCORPION Unit Officers who beat Tyre to
death had a record of misconduct, including those instances listed in paragraph 97, above:
ii. In March 2019, Martin left a loaded handgun in his Memphis Police
the shift.
iii. He claimed it was left accidently because he did not do a proper pre- or
post-shift inspection.
both women that they would both be arrested if he had to write a report.
25
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 27 of 139 PageID 27
b. Demetrius Haley
ii. The inmate sued Haley for excessive force, and 34 other inmates wrote
2020.
iv. In February 2021 he received a written reprimand for not filling out a
c. Justin Smith
speeding to a call, and occupants of all three cars went to the hospital.
d. Desmond Mills
ii. He said he did not realize that his actions necessitated that form.
26
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 28 of 139 PageID 28
e. Tadarrius Bean
i. Bean had been a police officer with the Memphis Police Department for
ii. Despite his lack of experience as a police officer, Bean was selected to
f. Preston Hemphill
ii. He also failed his physical fitness profile as an officer, and was moved
117. The hiring of inexperienced officers and officers with disciplinary issues were not
unique to the SCORPION Unit, as Chief Davis and the City of Memphis were hiring inexperienced
and problem officers throughout the department between 2020 and 2022, after significantly
118. Still experiencing a lack of interest, the City attempted to entice more recruits in
119. A year later in 2022, the City reduced the fitness test standards to secure more
“qualified” officers.
27
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 29 of 139 PageID 29
120. The City of Memphis also increasingly utilized arrest waivers for officers applying
to the Memphis Police Department, which permitted more officers with a prior criminal arrest
121. The police academy, which ultimately fed these recruits to the Memphis Police
Department, also relaxed standards by utilizing a more lenient grading structure and allowing
122. Failures that would have resulted in dismissal were now tolerated at the academy,
123. If a student could not grasp the material or perform skills test–such as utilizing their
service weapon—they were given multiple opportunities until they “passed” the already lower
minimum standards.
124. Even failures in shooting exams were now tolerated, as students unable to properly
utilize their firearm graduated the academy and applied for positions with the Memphis Police
Department.
125. These changes in protocols were not communicated in writing, but rather through
word of mouth.
126. The graduating Police Academy classes were larger, because with lower standards,
127. Recent graduates often lacked communication skills and the ability to recognize
4
Several former and current Police Academy instructors went on record with the Washington Post
concerning the Police Academy’s subpar practices from 2018 to present. See
https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2023/03/12/memphis-police-academy-tyre-
nichols/, published March 12, 2023.
28
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 30 of 139 PageID 30
Department officers reached an all-time high in 2020 5–a nearly 60% from the previous three
years’ average.
129. All five police officers who unconstitutionally stopped, detained, and beat Tyre
Nichols to death—Emmitt Martin III, Demetrius Haley, Justin Smith, Desmond Mills Jr., and
Tadarrius Bean—graduated from the police academy during this problematic period of decreased
130. Furthermore, the City of Memphis and Chief Davis were aware of the decreased
standards and subpar graduates at the Police Academy, and instructors within the Police
131. The subpar academy practices continued through 2022 under the leadership of
132. Even without lowering the standards within the department and the academy, the
City of Memphis and Chief Davis had chosen to turn a blind eye to potential problem recruits by
133. The City of Memphis and Chief Davis could have rectified their unconstitutional
hiring practices by properly training officers it placed in high-stress police suppression units like
134. Although fully aware that a police unit like SCORPION demanded rigorous
training, the City of Memphis and Chief Davis failed to properly train SCORPION Unit Officers,
5
Memphis Police Department Inspectional Services 2021 Annual Report, see
https://reimagine.memphistn.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/70/2022/03/2021-ISB-Annual-
Report.pdf, last accessed April 12, 2023.
29
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 31 of 139 PageID 31
135. The City of Memphis and Chief Davis failed to promulgate any specified policies
a. Terry stops;
c. Probable cause;
d. Traffic stops;
e. Foot pursuits;
136. The City of Memphis and Chief Davis failed to offer any specialized training to its
SCORPION Officers on a number of important categories, including but limited to the following:
a. Terry stops;
c. Probable cause;
d. Traffic stops;
e. Foot pursuits;
30
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 32 of 139 PageID 32
137. Turned loose on the streets of Memphis, SCORPION Unit Officers predictably
acted in derogation of the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments and violated the Constitution by
138. Such constitutional violations were the highly predictable consequence of failing
to hire qualified officers and train them on the bounds of the Constitution and proper policing,
139. Where hiring and training fall short of their Constitutional duty, the City of
Memphis and Chief Davis could have supervised officers to ensure their respect for the
140. Although fully aware that a police unit like SCORPION demanded close
supervision, the City of Memphis and Chief Davis failed to properly supervise SCORPION
Officers, knowing that such failures would result in Fourth and Fourteenth Amendment violations.
141. The SCORPION Unit was housed in a satellite MPD office versus one of the main
police stations.
142. The SCORPION Unit was frequently deployed on the streets of Memphis without
any supervisor on the team to ensure its officers—unqualified and untrained to begin with—
adhered to Constitutional principles and avoided violating the constitutional rights of Memphis
citizens.
31
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 33 of 139 PageID 33
derogation of the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments and violated the Constitution by engaging
144. Such constitutional violations were the highly predictable consequence of failing
to supervise the SCORPION Unit in situations that would inevitably arise such as searches,
VI. The Baseless Stop: Consistent with Chief Davis’ Directive, the SCORPION Unit Stops
Tyre Nichols Without Legal Justification.
145. Tyre spent the evening of January 7, 2023 taking photos of the sunset and
146. At about 8:00 p.m. that night, Tyre set out to return home from Shelby Farms Park
to 6743 Castlegate Lane, where he lived with his mother and his step-father.
147. While Tyre was at Shelby Farms, Memphis Police Department Officers Emmitt
Martin III, Demetrius Haley, and Preston Hemphill—officers in the SCORPION Unit—were on
148. As members of the SCORPION Unit, Officer Martin, Officer Haley, and Officer
Hemphill were responsible for carrying out the directive of Chief Davis to make stops, even
149. At approximately 8:20 p.m. Officer Martin, Officer Haley, and Officer Hemphill
150. In accordance with Chief Davis’ directives and the suspects (young, black males)
she instructed SCORPION officers to stop, even without a constitutional basis, Officer Martin,
32
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 34 of 139 PageID 34
151. Officer Martin called into MPD Dispatch to run Tyre’s license plate for warrants
152. Officer Martin had no lawful basis to stop Tyre’s vehicle, but Officer Martin
pursued Tyre waiting for an opportunity to stop him with Officer Haley and Officer Hemphill
following suit.
153. Officer Haley passed Officer Hemphill to be second in line, also waiting for the
154. None of the officers had reasonable articulable suspicion to stop Tyre’s vehicle, but
155. When Tyre pulled up to a red light at Ross Road and Raines Road and activated his
left turn signal, Officer Martin and Officer Haley saw their opportunity to attempt to seize him.
156. Officer Martin and Officer Haley pulled their squad cars up next to Tyre, boxed
him in, and descended on his car while he waited at the traffic light to take a lawful left turn.
157. Moments later, Officer Hemphill pulled up behind Tyre’s car in the left turn lane
as all three squad cars worked in tandem with unmarked police vehicles to encircle and block
158. There was no reasonable justification for this type of aggressive police tactic to be
used against Tyre, as there was no reasonable justification for stopping Tyre in the first place.
159. Officer Martin and Officer Haley quickly exited their unmarked vehicles and ran
up to Tyre’s car.
160. Officer Martin and Officer Haley both wore black sweatshirt hoodies over their
33
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 35 of 139 PageID 35
161. Officer Martin and Officer Haley were both wearing body worn cameras (“BWCs”)
and knew Officer Hemphill was present and likely had his BWC on recording their conduct.
162. Officer Martin and Officer Haley knew that Chief Davis’ directive was to make
stops and suppress crime even without a Constitutional basis, so they deactivated their cameras
knowing they could forge a reasonable basis after the fact and not face any repercussions.
163. Officer Martin and Officer Haley carried out their actions without any regard for
whether their conduct would ultimately be seen and reviewed by Memphis Police Department
officials.
164. Officer Martin and Officer Haley had a mindset of impunity as prior, similar
165. Officer Martin and Officer Haley immediately opened the drivers’ side door and
forcefully pulled Tyre out without explanation, prompting Tyre to ask, shocked and terrified,
166. Officer Martin and Officer Haley pushed Tyre down, and pulled at his arms yelling,
167. Officer Martin and Officer Haley unreasonably escalated the situation by physically
168. At no point prior to this encounter was Tyre suspected of committing a crime.
169. At no point prior to this encounter was Tyre a threat of bodily injury or harm to
170. Officer Preston Hemphill predictably reacted like the unqualified, untrained, and
unsupervised officer that he was as a result of the City of Memphis’ unconstitutional failures.
34
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 36 of 139 PageID 36
171. Officer Preston Hemphill sprinted out of his unmarked squad with his gun drawn,
held sideways, and pointed squarely at Tyre—ready to deploy deadly force on a non-resistant
Officer Hemphill immediately pulls out and points his gun at Tyre as he
approaches his fellow SCORPION Officers on scene.
172. Officer Hemphill unreasonably escalated the situation by threatening deadly force
Tyre looking up at Officers terrified and confused as to why he was pulled from the car.
35
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 37 of 139 PageID 37
173. At this point, Tyre was restrained by both Officer Martin and Officer Haley with a
gun pointed at him, as he pled for answers as to why he was dragged from his car.
174. Tyre, fearful and panicked, again shouted “What did I do?!” He never received an
175. Officer Martin and Officer Haley commanded that Tyre lay down and that he place
176. While attempting to comply, Tyre tried to be the calm voice of reason, asking what
177. Tyre said to Officer Martin and Officer Haley, in a scared yet measured tone,
178. In response to Officer Martin and Officer Haley barking that he must get down on
179. Tyre’s pleas fell on deaf ears despite his multiple attempts to de-escalate the
situation to no avail.
180. All three SCORPION Officers (Officer Martin, Officer Haley, and Officer
Hemphill) simultaneously restrained, pulled, and struck Tyre trying to force him further into the
181. Tyre did not resist and attempted to comply with the SCORPION Officers’ orders.
182. Any resistance perceived by the SCORPION Officers were Tyre’s reasonable
183. Despite Tyre’s efforts to comply with those unlawful orders, Officer Haley
proceeded to deploy pepper spray directly into Tyre’s eyes at close range.
36
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 38 of 139 PageID 38
184. Officer Haley had no reasonable basis to deploy pepper spray into Tyre’s face at
close range.
185. With Tyre’s eyes and face burning after attempting to deescalate the situation
multiple times and with a gun pointed at him, the SCORPION Officers’ tempers raged as they
186. Terrified and in fear for his life, Tyre was somehow able to loosen himself from the
187. Tyre then did the only thing he could to attempt to save his life and defend
himself—he ran.
188. Tyre was not suspected of committing any kind of crime at any time.
189. Tyre was never suspected of committing any kind of crime at any relevant time.
190. At no point prior to this was Tyre a threat to members of the public or to the
SCORPION Officers.
191. Without any reasonable justification, Officer Hemphill deployed his taser at Tyre,
192. With his parents’ home just a half mile away, Tyre ran for the safety of their home.
193. Officer Martin and Officer Haley both took off running after Tyre, furious that he
escaped the grip of the SCORPION Unit and their unconstitutional stop.
194. Both Officers gave up the foot chase and eventually got in their unmarked squads
195. Officer Hemphill stayed back at the intersection of Ross and Raines, calling
dispatch for more SCORPION Units to support Officer Martin and Officer Haley as they hunted
for Tyre.
37
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 39 of 139 PageID 39
196. As Officer Hemphill called for more SCORPION Units to assist Officer Martin and
VII. The Capture and the Retaliation: The Gang of SCORPION Unit Officers Beat Tyre
Within an Inch of His Life.
197. After tracking him for roughly four minutes, Officer Martin and Officer Haley
198. Tyre reached the intersection of Bear Creek Cove and Castlegate Road—just 100
yards from his parents’ home—before he was captured by the SCORPION Officers.
199. The intersection where he was stopped was also directly underneath a SkyCop
camera—a fixed pole-mounted and police-monitored camera designed to enhance safety and
200. Rather than capturing the crimes of civilians, the SkyCop camera recorded evidence
201. Officer Martin and Officer Haley immediately grabbed Tyre when they found him
and shoved him to the ground, pulling his hands behind his back.
38
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 40 of 139 PageID 40
203. Three more SCORPION Officers arrived moments later—Officers Justin Smith,
204. Without hesitation or justifiable reason, Officer Martin, Officer Haley, Officer
Smith, Officer Mills, Jr., and Officer Bean all proceeded to brutally beat Tyre Nichols, as set forth
205. The five SCORPION Unit Officers each took turns punching and kicking Tyre in
206. During this time, Tyre was restrained by at least one, but often two, SCORPION
Officers and held up for the other three or four SCORPION Officers to savagely beat him.
207. While still able to speak, Tyre screamed out for his mother—shouting “Mom!
Mom!” into the neighborhood in hopes that she or someone nearby would come to his aid as he
208. For approximately seven minutes straight, the five SCORPION Officers punched,
209. In accordance with their mission as members of the SCORPION Unit, the five
210. In accordance with their mission as members of the SCORPION Unit and
consistent with the directive of their Police Chief, they violated the Fourth Amendment.
39
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 41 of 139 PageID 41
The five SCORPION Officers (Emmitt Martin, Demetrius Haley, Justin Smith, Desmond Mills,
and Tadarrius Bean) ruthlessly beating Tyre Nichols to death.
211. As Tyre struggled to comply with a flurry of conflicting commands shouted at him
from all directions and begged for the onslaught to cease, three SCORPION Officers restrained
and repeatedly struck and punched Tyre in the face and body.
212. The remaining two officers then joined in restraining, punching, and kicking Tyre.
213. Officer Smith and Officer Mills sprayed Tyre in the face with pepper spray while
214. Either Officer Smith or Officer Mills menacingly yelled at and taunted Tyre, “You
wanna get sprayed again? Huh?” before spraying him in the face again while other SCORPION
215. Even with Tyre’s pleas and cries for help and with his attempts to cover his eyes
from the chemical assault being rained upon him, the SCORPION Officers continued to hold him
40
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 42 of 139 PageID 42
Officer Mills sprays Tyre directly in his face with pepper spray, despite already being on the
ground, while another SCORPION officer restrains Tyre.
216. While lying on the ground restrained and doused with chemical agents, Officer
Mills and Officer Smith took turns and struck Tyre repeatedly with a telescoping police baton.
217. After that, two SCORPION Officers propped Tyre up to make him an upright target
for other SCORPION Officers to continue to hit him and use Tyre’s body and face as a punching
bag.
218. Tyre fell to the ground and the SCORPION Officers held him on his stomach so
that he could be cuffed, which could have been accomplished minutes prior at the stoplight
immediately after the unconstitutional stop and before their unconstitutional assault began.
219. At least three SCORPION Officers held Tyre down, several sat on top of him during
this time.
220. At this point, another one of the five SCORPION Unit Officers took the opportunity
to kick Tyre while he was down on the ground, restrained, and handcuffed.
221. Ultimately the five SCORPION Officers beat Tyre within an inch of his life over
the course of seven unrelenting minutes without any justifiable reason and without any government
41
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 43 of 139 PageID 43
VIII. The Aftermath: The Indifference of SCORPION Unit Officers, MPD Officers, MFD
Agents, and Others Contribute to Tyre’s Death.
223. More MPD Officers arrived on scene as the original five SCORPION Officers
(Martin, Haley, Smith, Mills Jr., and Bean) finished with Tyre and left him on the street.
224. None of the original or newly arrived officers checked Tyre’s condition or
expressed any concern for the bloodied, dazed, handcuffed man left alone and barely moving in
the street. 6
225. Instead, as more MPD officers arrived, they smiled, laughed, and talked with their
fellow officers.
226. As they did so in complete and utter indifference, Tyre lay dying in the street just
6
At least one officer, Justin Smith, is a certified EMT and thereby trained in administering basic
medical care.
42
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 44 of 139 PageID 44
227. MPD officers, including the original five SCORPION Unit Officers (Martin, Haley,
Smith, Mills, and Bean), joked about the chase with Tyre and suggested that he might be on drugs
or perhaps reached for a service weapon despite there being no evidence to suggest either was true.
228. The original five SCORPION Unit Officers (Martin, Haley, Smith, Mills, and
Bean) bragged about their involvement with stopping and beating him.
229. At approximately 8:38 p.m. two officers dragged Tyre from his position laying on
the ground, and another officer helped them prop him up in a supine position to lean him against
230. Tyre passed in and out of consciousness, attempting to roll on several occasions,
43
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 45 of 139 PageID 45
231. Rather than attend to or acknowledge Tyre’s obvious need for medical care, officers
232. As a testament to their apathy and heartlessness, Officer Haley took out his cell
phone and took a photo of Tyre, who was beaten, bloodied, dazed and nearly unconscious.
Officer Haley is circled in red, taking a closeup photo of Tyre with the flash of his cell phone
camera activated.
44
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 46 of 139 PageID 46
233. Officer Haley sent that photo to at least five other people, including at least one
civilian, to brag about the beating he had just levied on a defenseless young man.
234. About four minutes after being propped up against the squad car, Tyre fell onto the
235. MPD officers then propped Tyre back up into a sitting position against the squad
236. At 8:41 p.m. three Emergency Medical Technicians (“EMTs”) arrived and
proceeded to disregard Tyre’s condition and failed to provide any of the clearly necessary medical
aid to him.
237. Two of those EMTs—Memphis Fire Department (“MFD”) EMTs Robert Long and
238. The third was Lieutenant Michelle Whitaker—a 25-year veteran with the MFD—
who had arrived in a fire engine nearby, could see Tyre and was informed of the incident, but never
239. EMTs Long and Sandridge knelt near Tyre briefly while carrying medical bags
240. At one point, EMT Sandridge pulled a blood pressure cuff from his bag.
241. MFD EMT Sandridge took out the blood pressure cuff, but failed to use it or
242. Rather than using the cuff to evaluate Tyre’s blood pressure, EMT Sandridge set it
back down after Tyre slumped over onto the ground at which time EMT Sandridge left him there.
45
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 47 of 139 PageID 47
EMT Sandridge declines to use his blood pressure cuff to evaluate Tyre.
243. For the next 19 minutes, all three EMTs failed to provide aid for Tyre:
d. They did not uncuff Tyre or adjust him against the squad car;
h. They did not place Tyre on a cardiac monitor to assist in his future care at
the hospital; and
244. MFD EMT Robert Long was aware of Tyre’s medical condition and plainly
46
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 48 of 139 PageID 48
245. MFD EMT JaMichael Sandridge was aware of Tyre’s medical condition and
plainly obvious injuries, but deliberately refused to provide necessary medical care.
246. MFD Lieutenant Michelle Whitaker was aware of Tyre’s medical condition and
plainly obvious injuries, but deliberately refused to provide necessary medical care.
247. Tyre attempted to roll into another position or move his legs, as he was clearly
writhing in pain.
248. Officers and EMTs did not address his physical state, and one of the original five
SCORPION Officers (Martin, Haley, Smith, Mills, and Bean) squatted down next to him, taunting
and mocking Tyre, saying “You can’t go nowhere! You can’t go nowhere, man. You ain’t goin’
nowhere. Be still.”
249. At one point, there were at least 12 City of Memphis employees within feet of
Tyre’s body and within range of being able to offer necessary medical aid.
250. None of them showed concern or attempted to help Tyre, even though he was
251. Officers nonchalantly circulated near Tyre for approximately 19 minutes total after
the beating, slowly walking around the area and speaking with each other.
252. Finally, at 8:55 p.m., 25 minutes after he was chased down and beaten by the
original five SCORPION Officers (Martin, Haley, Smith, Mills, and Bean), two new EMTs began
assessing Tyre and offered the medical attention he desperately and obviously needed.
253. The two new EMTs placed him on a stretcher and loaded him into an ambulance
254. Tyre was finally transported to St. Francis hospital: a 15 minutes' drive from where
he was beaten.
47
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 49 of 139 PageID 49
IX. The Late Arrival of Lieutenant DeWayne Smith and the Misrepresentations and Lies
to RowVaughn Wells.
255. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith was a supervisor within
the SCORPION Unit and arrived on the scene at the very end of the beating by his five fellow
Memphis Police Department SCORPION Officers (Martin, Haley, Smith, Mills, and Bean).
256. Following the beating of Tyre by the five Memphis Police Department SCORPION
Officers (Martin, Haley, Smith, Mills, and Bean), other government employees from the Memphis
Police Department, the Memphis Fire Department, and the Shelby County Sheriff began arriving
to the scene.
257. The other government employees stood by apathetically as Tyre laid bloodied and
258. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith was one of the employees
standing by as Tyre was battered, beaten, and propped up against the police car.
259. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith saw Tyre Nichols in the
260. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith knew Tyre Nichols was
261. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith knew Tyre Nichols had
262. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith knew Tyre Nichols was
263. After seeing the condition Tyre was in, at approximately 9:50 p.m. on January 7,
2023, Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith walked the 100 or so yards to
Tyre’s listed address at 6743 Castlegate Lane where he lived with his mother, RowVaughn Wells.
48
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 50 of 139 PageID 50
264. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith arrived at the home of
RowVaughn Wells and proceeded to tell her that Tyre was under arrest for DUI.
265. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith also told RowVaughn
266. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith had no evidence that Tyre
267. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith had no evidence that Tyre
was intoxicated or under the influence of any illicit drug or other substance.
268. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith did have evidence that
269. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith misled and lied to
RowVaughn Wells about her son being under the influence and being intoxicated.
270. RowVaughn Wells asked Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith
more than once where Tyre was, as she wanted to see her son and check on his well-being.
271. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith told RowVaughn Wells
272. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith told RowVaughn Wells
273. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith had not seen any
paramedics render any medical treatment or assistance to Tyre prior to the conversation.
274. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith had not ordered any
49
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 51 of 139 PageID 51
275. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith took no steps to alert
RowVaughn Wells to her son’s immediate and critical healthcare needs after misleading and lying
to her.
whereabouts 100 yard away, as well as his critical health condition, from RowVaughn Wells.
277. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith misled and lied to
RowVaughn Wells that her son was being treated in the neighborhood.
278. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith withheld that Tyre had
279. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith withheld that Tyre was
280. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith withheld that Tyre was
281. When Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith left RowVaughn
Wells’ home, he was concerned that if the Memphis Police transferred Tyre to the hospital he
282. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith knew that regardless of
any medical treatment, Tyre was not going to survive the beating on the night of January 7, 2023.
X. The Original Five SCORPION Unit Officers’ Use of Excessive Force and Failure to
Intervene in the Use of Excessive Force Contributes to Tyre’s Death.
approximately 9:35 p.m., Tyre had no pulse and was being treated with a manual resuscitator to
284. As a result of the extensive beating he received, Tyre had suffered cardiac arrest.
50
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 52 of 139 PageID 52
285. For the next three days, Tyre fought for his life in the Intensive Care Unit (“ICU”).
He was intubated and underwent dialysis as his kidneys were critically damaged due to the beating.
286. Tyre’s head and face were swollen to the point of being unrecognizable and he had
287. Tyre’s brain was so swollen from the repeated blows to his head that it was no
288. Tyre’s autonomic nervous system began to fail, as did his internal organs.
289. Despite the efforts of his medical team, Tyre died in the ICU three days after the
police ran him down and beat him to death in the street.
290. Tyre died swollen, bloody, and hooked up to devices that ultimately could not save
his life.
291. Tyre died as a direct and proximate result of the unconstitutional policies and
practices of the City of Memphis, which were the moving force behind the constitutional violations
292. Tyre died as a direct and proximate result of the brutal and excessive beating at the
hands of the five SCORPION Officers: Martin, Haley, Smith, Mills, and Bean.
293. Tyre died as a direct and proximate result of the deliberate indifference of
Defendants Long, Sandridge, and Whittaker to his plainly obvious, critical medical needs.
CAUSES OF ACTION
294. Plaintiff hereby incorporates and realleges Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though
51
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 53 of 139 PageID 53
295. The Director of Police Services, also known as the Police Chief of the Memphis
Police Department (hereinafter “Chief”), is the official with policymaking authority for the City
296. Cerelyn Davis (“Chief Davis”) was installed as the Police Chief of the Memphis
297. In her official capacity, Chief Davis’ actions and inactions are those of the City of
Memphis.
298. Shortly after her appointment, in November 2021, Chief Davis created and
established the Street Crimes Operation to Restore Peace In Our Neighborhoods, referred to as the
searching and seizing individuals and their property through traffic stops in complete disregard of
300. Chief Davis knowingly encouraged and authorized members of the Memphis Police
Department, especially SCORPION Officers, to disregard and violate the Constitutional and
Fourth Amendment rights of Memphis citizens to attempt to “stop crime” at any cost, including
301. Chief Davis knowingly encouraged and authorized members of the Memphis Police
Department, especially SCORPION Officers, to disregard and violate the Constitutional and
Fourth Amendment rights of Memphis citizens to attempt to “stop crime” at any cost, including
52
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 54 of 139 PageID 54
302. Chief Davis’ authorization to SCORPION Officers to disregard and violate the
Constitutional and Fourth Amendment rights of Memphis citizens constituted an official policy of
303. Chief Davis’ authorization to SCORPION Officers to disregard and violate the
Constitutional and Fourth Amendment rights of Memphis citizens was maintained with deliberate
304. Chief Davis’ authorization to SCORPION Officers to disregard and violate the
Constitutional and Fourth Amendment rights of Memphis citizens was the moving force behind:
Tyre Nichols;
Nichols;
305. Tyre Nichols’ injuries and death were a direct, foreseeable, and proximate result of
Chief Davis’ authorization to SCORPION Officers to disregard and violate the Constitutional and
53
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 55 of 139 PageID 55
306. The violation of Tyre Nichols’ constitutional right to be free from unreasonable
searches and seizures as well as excessive force were a direct, foreseeable, and proximate result of
Chief Davis’ authorization to SCORPION Officers to disregard and violate the Constitutional and
Officers to disregard and violate the Constitutional and Fourth Amendment rights of Memphis
citizens, Tyre Nichols suffered compensatory and special damages as defined under federal
Officers to disregard and violate the Constitutional and Fourth Amendment rights of Memphis
citizens, Tyre Nichols suffered catastrophic pain, suffering, emotional distress, anguish, personal
309. As a direct and proximate result of the acts described in this Count, Tyre Nichols’
next of kin have suffered pecuniary loss, including medical and funeral expenses; loss of future
wages and earnings; and loss of aid, counsel, guidance, advice, assistance, protection, and support
310. Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees as prescribed
311. Plaintiff hereby incorporates and realleges Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though
54
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 56 of 139 PageID 56
312. The Director of Police Services, also known as the Police Chief of the Memphis
Police Department (hereinafter “Chief”), is the official with policymaking authority for the City
313. In her official capacity, Chief Davis’ actions and inactions are those of the City of
Memphis.
314. The City of Memphis, through the Memphis Police Department, maintained a
custom of tolerance for SCORPION Officers’ unreasonable search and seizure of individuals, use
of excessive force, and the violation of the Fourth Amendment prior to the violation of Tyre
315. The City of Memphis’ custom of tolerance for SCORPION Officers’ unreasonable
search and seizure of individuals, use of excessive force, and the violation of the Fourth
Amendment was so permanent, well-settled, widespread, and commonly accepted within the
Memphis Police Department as to constitute and carry with it the force of law.
316. The City of Memphis was consciously aware and on notice that their custom of
tolerance for SCORPION Officers’ unreasonable search and seizure of individuals, use of
excessive force, and the violation of the Fourth Amendment was unconstitutional and would lead
317. Despite this awareness and knowledge, the City of Memphis maintained this
custom of tolerance for SCORPION Officers’ unreasonable search and seizure of individuals, use
of excessive force, and the violation of the Fourth Amendment with deliberate indifference to and
55
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 57 of 139 PageID 57
318. The City of Memphis’ custom of tolerance for SCORPION Officers’ unreasonable
search and seizure of individuals, use of excessive force, and the violation of the Fourth
Tyre Nichols;
Nichols;
319. Tyre Nichols’ injuries and death were a direct, foreseeable, and proximate result of
the City of Memphis’ custom of tolerance for SCORPION Officers’ unreasonable search and
seizure of individuals, use of excessive force, and the violation of the Fourth Amendment.
320. The violation of Tyre Nichols’ constitutional rights was a direct, foreseeable, and
proximate result of the City of Memphis’ custom of tolerance for SCORPION Officers’
unreasonable search and seizure of individuals, use of excessive force, and the violation of the
Fourth Amendment.
321. As a direct and proximate result of the City of Memphis’ custom of tolerance for
SCORPION Officers’ unreasonable search and seizure of individuals, use of excessive force, and
56
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 58 of 139 PageID 58
the violation of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols suffered compensatory and special damages
322. As a direct and proximate result of City of Memphis’ custom of tolerance for
SCORPION Officers’ unreasonable search and seizure of individuals, use of excessive force, and
the violation of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols suffered catastrophic pain, suffering,
323. As a direct and proximate result of the acts described in this Count, Tyre Nichols’
next of kin have suffered pecuniary loss, including medical and funeral expenses; loss of future
wages and earnings; and loss of aid, counsel, guidance, advice, assistance, protection, and support
324. Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees as prescribed
325. Plaintiff hereby incorporates and realleges Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though
326. The Director of Police Services, also known as the Police Chief of the Memphis
Police Department (hereinafter “Chief”), is the official with policymaking authority for the City
of Memphis regarding policing and police policies and practices relating to training.
327. In her official capacity, Chief Davis’ actions and inactions are those of the City of
Memphis.
328. The City of Memphis, through the Memphis Police Department and its Chief, had
a duty to train its police officers on the constitutional bounds of their police duties.
57
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 59 of 139 PageID 59
329. Specifically, the City of Memphis had a duty to train members of specialized police
units meant to handle stops, seizures, violent crime, and vehicular crimes— like SCORPION Unit
330. The City of Memphis had a duty to train members of specialized police units meant
to handle stops, seizures, violent crime, and vehicular crimes—like SCORPION Unit officers—
on the predictable and foreseeable situations they would encounter that would implicate the
331. The City of Memphis had a duty to train members of specialized police units meant
to handle stops, seizures, violent crime, and vehicular crimes—like SCORPION Unit officers—
beyond the ordinary academy training given the specialized nature of the SCORPION Unit.
332. The City of Memphis was aware that it had placed inexperienced officers on the
SCORPION Unit with the retirement and departure of older members of the force.
333. The City of Memphis was aware that it did not have enough senior staff members
334. The City of Memphis was aware that rookie and otherwise inexperienced officers
were placed on specialized units, like SCORPION, where they had no business serving and were
bound to violate the constitutional rights of Memphis citizens without proper training and
guidance.
335. The City of Memphis had a widespread practice or custom of failing to train its
officers in specialized units, like SCORPION, in the common, routine, and foreseeable tasks that
officers had to perform and, specifically, the constitutional limits of permissible stops and seizures,
and engagement with individuals suspected of violent crime and property theft, among other
things.
58
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 60 of 139 PageID 60
336. The City of Memphis had a widespread practice of failing to train its officers in
unreasonable force;
337. The City of Memphis’ failure to train in the aforementioned areas was so
permanent, well-settled, widespread, and commonly accepted that it constituted an official custom
or policy.
338. The City of Memphis was consciously aware and on notice of this pattern of
339. The City of Memphis was deliberately indifferent to the consequences of their
failures to train and to civil rights violations that were obvious, predictable, and readily foreseeable
as a result.
59
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 61 of 139 PageID 61
340. Alternatively, even without a widespread practice, the City of Memphis failed to
equip its officers in specialized units, like SCORPION, with the training to handle situations that
were bound to occur during the course of their specific job responsibilities.
341. The need for training SCORPION Officers on the constitutional bounds of their
jobs was so obvious that the City of Memphis knew that if training was not provided, then it was
highly predictable and likely to result in the violation of citizens’ constitutional rights.
342. Had the City of Memphis trained SCORPION officers in the areas alleged in
Paragraph 336, it would have prevented the violation of Tyre Nichols’ constitutional rights.
343. The City of Memphis’ failure to train its officers in specialized units, like
SCORPION officers, in the areas alleged in Paragraph 336, was the moving force behind:
Tyre Nichols;
Nichols;
60
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 62 of 139 PageID 62
344. Tyre Nichols’ injuries and death were a highly predictable consequence of the City
of Memphis’ failure to train its officers in specialized units, like SCORPION, in the areas alleged
in Paragraph 336.
345. Tyre Nichols injuries and death were a direct, foreseeable, and proximate result of
the City of Memphis’ failure to train its officers in specialized units, like SCORPION, in the areas
346. As a direct and proximate result of The City of Memphis’ failure to train its officers
in specialized units, like SCORPION, in the aforementioned areas, Tyre Nichols suffered
compensatory and special damages as defined under federal common law and in an amount to be
determined by a jury.
347. As a direct and proximate result of The City of Memphis’ failure to train its officers
in specialized units, like SCORPION, in the aforementioned areas, Tyre Nichols suffered
catastrophic pain, suffering, emotional distress, anguish, personal injuries, and death.
348. As a direct and proximate result of the acts described in this Count, Tyre Nichols’
next of kin have suffered pecuniary loss, including medical and funeral expenses; loss of future
wages and earnings; and loss of aid, counsel, guidance, advice, assistance, protection, and support
349. Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees as prescribed
350. Plaintiff hereby incorporates and realleges Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though
61
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 63 of 139 PageID 63
351. The Director of Police Services, also known as the Police Chief of the Memphis
Police Department (hereinafter “Chief”), is the official with policymaking authority for the City
of Memphis regarding policing and police policies and practices relating to supervision.
352. In her official capacity, Chief Davis’ actions and inactions are those of the City of
Memphis.
353. The City of Memphis, through the Memphis Police Department and its Chief, had
a duty to supervise its police officers on the constitutional bounds of their jobs.
354. Specifically, the City of Memphis had a duty to supervise members of specialized
police units meant to handle search and seizures, violent crime, and vehicular crimes—such as
those officers in the SCORPION Unit—to ensure the constitutionality of their conduct in situations
where they would predictably and foreseeably implicate the Constitutional rights of citizens of
Memphis.
355. The City of Memphis had a duty to supervise members of specialized police units
meant to handle search and seizures, violent crime, and vehicular crimes —such as those officers
in the SCORPION Unit—beyond the ordinary standards of supervision given the specialized
356. The City of Memphis was aware that it did not have enough senior staff members
357. The City of Memphis was aware that rookie and inexperienced officers were being
358. The City of Memphis had a widespread practice or custom of failing to supervise
officers in specialized units—such as those officers in the SCORPION Unit—concerning the tasks
62
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 64 of 139 PageID 64
that officers had to perform, including but not limited to engaging in searches, seizures, and
supervise its police officers in specialized police units—such as those officers in the SCORPION
Unit—in situations where they would predictably and foreseeably implicate or infringe upon the
360. The City of Memphis’ failure to supervise its officers in specialized units—such as
those officers in the SCORPION Unit—was so well-settled, widespread, and commonly accepted
361. The City of Memphis was consciously aware and on notice of this pattern of failures
362. The City of Memphis was deliberately indifferent to the consequences of their
failures to supervise and the civil rights violations that were obvious, predictable, and readily
foreseeable as a result.
363. Alternatively, even without a widespread practice, the City of Memphis failed to
supervise its officers in specialized units like SCORPION to such a degree and in such areas that
would obviously, predictably, and foreseeably implicate the Constitutional rights of Memphis
364. The need for supervision of those officers was so obvious that the City of Memphis
knew that, if not provided, it was highly predictable and likely to result in the violation of
constitutional rights.
63
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 65 of 139 PageID 65
365. The City of Memphis’ proper supervision of specialized police units meant to
handle search and seizures, violent crime, and vehicular crimes, like those officers in SCORPION,
366. The City of Memphis was consciously aware and on notice of these failures but
367. The City of Memphis was deliberately indifferent to the consequences of their
failures to supervise and the civil rights violations that were predictable and readily foreseeable as
a result.
indifferent.
369. Despite this knowledge and awareness, the City of Memphis failed to supervise its
officers in specialized units—such as those officers in the SCORPION Unit—at the expense of the
370. The City of Memphis’ failure to supervise its officers in specialized units—such as
Tyre Nichols;
Nichols;
64
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 66 of 139 PageID 66
371. Tyre Nichols’ injuries and death were a highly predictable consequence of the City
372. Tyre Nichols’ injuries and death were a direct, foreseeable, and proximate result of
the City of Memphis’ failure to supervise its officers in specialized units, like SCORPION.
373. As a direct and proximate result of The City of Memphis’ failure to supervise its
officers in specialized units, like SCORPION, Tyre Nichols suffered compensatory and special
damages as defined under federal common law and in an amount to be determined by a jury.
374. As a direct and proximate result of The City of Memphis’ failure to train its officers
in specialized units, like SCORPION, in the aforementioned areas, Tyre Nichols suffered
catastrophic pain, suffering, emotional distress, anguish, personal injuries, and death.
375. As a direct and proximate result of the acts described in this Count, Tyre Nichols’
next of kin have suffered pecuniary loss, including medical and funeral expenses; loss of future
wages and earnings; and loss of aid, counsel, guidance, advice, assistance, protection, and support
376. Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees as prescribed
377. Plaintiff hereby incorporates and realleges Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though
65
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 67 of 139 PageID 67
378. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III was patrolling the
379. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III witnessed Tyre
380. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III attempted to find
information sufficient to pull Tyre Nichols over by searching for driver’s license holds or active
381. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III found no
information relating to any warrants, history of traffic infractions, history of criminal activity, or
any other information that would justify a traffic stop of Tyre Nichols.
382. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III had no reasonable,
383. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III had no reasonable,
articulable suspicion that Tyre Nichols was about to be engaged in criminal activity.
384. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III had no
particularized and objective basis that Tyre Nichols was suspected of legal wrongdoing.
385. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III, upon pulling over
Tyre Nichols, was not taking reasonable steps to protect his own safety.
386. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III, upon pulling over
Tyre Nichols, was not taking reasonable steps to protect his fellow officers’ safety.
387. On January 7, 2023, prior to and while being stopped, Tyre Nichols was not:
66
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 68 of 139 PageID 68
388. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III lacked reasonable,
articulable suspicion for stopping Tyre Nichols in his vehicle at Ross Road and Raines Road.
389. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III proceeded to stop
390. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III effected an
unreasonable seizure of Tyre Nichols when Tyre yielded to Officer Martin’s show of authority.
391. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III violated the Fourth
Amendment and clearly established law when he stopped Tyre Nichols in his vehicle at Ross Road
392. Every reasonable officer would have known that stopping someone without
reasonable, articulable suspicion constituted an unreasonable search and seizure in violation of the
Fourth Amendment.
393. Every reasonable officer would have known that detaining someone without
probable cause constituted an unreasonable search and seizure in violation of the Fourth
Amendment.
394. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic personal injuries and
death.
395. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic conscious pain,
67
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 69 of 139 PageID 69
396. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions of Memphis Police
Officer Emmitt Martin III described in this Count, Tyre Nichols suffered compensatory and special
damages as defined under federal common law and in an amount to be determined by a jury.
397. Punitive damages are available against Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III
as a matter of federal common law and are hereby sought by Plaintiff given the reprehensibility of
398. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions described in this Count,
Tyre Nichols’ next of kin have suffered pecuniary loss, including medical and funeral expenses;
loss of future wages and earnings; and loss of aid, counsel, guidance, advice, assistance, protection,
399. Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees as prescribed
400. Plaintiff hereby incorporates and realleges Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though
401. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III identified and described
in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted excessive and deadly force in
violation of the Fourth Amendment of the United States Constitution, as incorporated to the states
402. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III identified and described
in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted excessive and deadly force in
68
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 70 of 139 PageID 70
403. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III was acting under
color of state law, as agent of the City of Memphis, and within the scope of his employment and
404. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III had no reasonable,
405. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III had no probable
406. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was compliant with Memphis Police Officer
407. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was not violating any laws of the City of
408. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was not resisting arrest.
409. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III could not have
410. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III had no reasonable
411. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III did not have a
reasonable fear of Tyre Nichols causing imminent bodily harm to Officer Martin or any other
person.
412. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was fully restrained and subdued by Memphis
413. Despite the aforementioned facts, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III
proceeded to:
69
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 71 of 139 PageID 71
h. Restrain Tyre Nichols while other Defendants punched Tyre Nichols; and
414. Every reasonable officer would have known that using force against a non-resistant
415. Every reasonable officer would have known that using force against a restrained
416. Every reasonable officer would have known that using force against a passively
417. Every reasonable officer would have known that restraining a non-resistant
individual while other police officers use force against him would be excessive force and a
418. Every reasonable officer would have known that restraining a passively resisting
individual while other police officers use force against him would be excessive force and a
70
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 72 of 139 PageID 72
419. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic personal injuries and
death.
420. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic conscious pain,
421. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III’s
unjustified, excessive, illegal, and deadly use of force, Tyre Nichols eventually died of his injuries.
422. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions of Memphis Police
Officer Emmitt Martin III described in this Count, Tyre Nichols suffered compensatory and special
damages as defined under federal common law and in an amount to be determined by a jury.
423. Punitive damages are available against Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III
as a matter of federal common law and are hereby sought by Plaintiff given the reprehensibility of
424. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions described in this Count,
Tyre Nichols’ next of kin have suffered pecuniary loss, including medical and funeral expenses;
loss of future wages and earnings; and loss of aid, counsel, guidance, advice, assistance, protection,
425. Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees as prescribed
71
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 73 of 139 PageID 73
426. Plaintiff hereby incorporates and realleges Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though
427. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III identified and described
in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted a failure to intervene to prevent
excessive and deadly force in violation of the Fourth Amendment of the United States Constitution,
as incorporated to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution.
428. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III identified and described
in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted failure to intervene to prevent
429. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III was acting under
color of state law, as agent of the City of Memphis, and within the scope of his employment and
430. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III could not have
431. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III had no reasonable
432. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III did not have a
reasonable fear of Tyre Nichols causing imminent bodily harm to Officer Martin or any other
person.
433. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was fully restrained and subdued by Memphis
72
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 74 of 139 PageID 74
434. Despite the aforementioned facts, Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III stood
435. Every reasonable officer would have known that failing to intervene while police
officers used force against a non-resistant individual would be excessive force and a violation of
436. Every reasonable officer would have known that failing to intervene while police
officers used force against a restrained individual would be excessive force and a violation of the
Fourth Amendment.
437. Every reasonable officer would have known that failing to intervene while police
officers used force against a passively resisting individual would be excessive force and a violation
438. No reasonable officer could have thought there was a justification for the use of
force against Tyre Nichols after he had been neutralized, subdued, restrained in handcuffs,
439. No reasonable officer could have thought there was a justification for the use of
force against Tyre Nichols after he had been neutralized, subdued, restrained in handcuffs,
73
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 75 of 139 PageID 75
440. Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III’s restraining of Tyre Nichols while
other Defendants used force against Tyre Nichols was objectively unreasonable and violated
441. Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III observed that the force being used by
442. Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III was in a position to intervene and stop
other Defendants’ use of unjustified, excessive, illegal, and deadly use of force against Tyre
Nichols.
443. Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III’s failure to intervene on behalf of Tyre
Nichols while other Defendants used force against Tyre Nichols was objectively unreasonable and
444. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic personal injuries and
death.
445. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic conscious pain,
446. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III’s
failing to intervene on behalf of Tyre Nichols while other Defendants used unjustified, excessive,
illegal, and deadly use of force, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic, conscious pain, suffering,
74
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 76 of 139 PageID 76
447. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III’s
failing to intervene on behalf of Tyre Nichols while other Defendants used unjustified, excessive,
illegal, and deadly use of force, Tyre Nichols eventually died of his injuries.
448. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions of Memphis Police
Officer Emmitt Martin III, Tyre Nichols suffered compensatory and special damages as defined
449. Punitive damages are available against Memphis Police Officer Emmitt Martin III
as a matter of federal common law and are hereby sought by Plaintiff given the reprehensibility of
450. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions described in this Count,
Tyre Nichols’ next of kin have suffered pecuniary loss, including medical and funeral expenses;
loss of future wages and earnings; and loss of aid, counsel, guidance, advice, assistance, protection,
451. Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees as prescribed
452. Plaintiff hereby incorporates and realleges Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though
453. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley was patrolling the
454. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley witnessed Tyre
75
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 77 of 139 PageID 77
455. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley attempted to find
information sufficient to pull Tyre Nichols over by searching for driver’s license holds or active
information relating to any warrants, history of traffic infractions, history of criminal activity, or
any other information that would justify a traffic stop of Tyre Nichols.
457. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley had no reasonable,
458. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley had no reasonable,
articulable suspicion that Tyre Nichols was about to be engaged in criminal activity.
particularized and objective basis that Tyre Nichols was suspected of legal wrongdoing.
460. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley, upon pulling over
Tyre Nichols, was not taking reasonable steps to protect his own safety.
461. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley, upon pulling over
Tyre Nichols, was not taking reasonable steps to protect his fellow officers’ safety.
462. On January 7, 2023, prior to and while being stopped, Tyre Nichols was not:
463. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley lacked reasonable,
articulable suspicion for stopping Tyre Nichols in his vehicle at Ross Road and Raines Road.
76
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 78 of 139 PageID 78
464. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley proceeded to stop
unreasonable seizure of Tyre Nichols when Tyre yielded to Officer Haley’s show of authority.
466. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley violated the Fourth
Amendment and clearly established law when he stopped Tyre Nichols in his vehicle at Ross Road
467. Every reasonable officer would have known that stopping an individual without
468. Every reasonable officer would have known that detaining someone without
probable cause constituted an unreasonable search and seizure in violation of the Fourth
Amendment.
469. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic personal injuries and
death.
470. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic conscious pain,
471. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions of Memphis Police
Officer Demetrius Haley described in this Count, Tyre Nichols suffered compensatory and special
damages as defined under federal common law and in an amount to be determined by a jury.
77
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 79 of 139 PageID 79
472. Punitive damages are available against Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley
as a matter of federal common law and are hereby sought by Plaintiff given the reprehensibility of
473. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions described in this Count,
Tyre Nichols’ next of kin have suffered pecuniary loss, including medical and funeral expenses;
loss of future wages and earnings; and loss of aid, counsel, guidance, advice, assistance, protection,
474. Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees as prescribed
475. Plaintiff hereby incorporates and realleges Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though
476. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley identified and described
in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted excessive and deadly force in
violation of the Fourth Amendment of the United States Constitution, as incorporated to the states
477. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley identified and described
in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted excessive and deadly force in
478. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley was acting under
color of state law, as agent of the City of Memphis, and within the scope of his employment and
78
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 80 of 139 PageID 80
479. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley had no reasonable,
480. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley had no probable
481. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was compliant with Memphis Police Officer
482. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was not violating any laws of the City of
483. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was not resisting arrest.
484. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley could not have
485. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley had no reasonable
486. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley did not have a
reasonable fear of Tyre Nichols causing imminent bodily harm to Officer Haley or any other
person.
487. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was fully restrained and subdued by Memphis
488. Despite the aforementioned facts, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley
proceeded to:
79
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 81 of 139 PageID 81
h. Restrain Tyre Nichols while other Defendants punched Tyre Nichols; and
489. Every reasonable officer would have known that using force against a non-resistant
490. Every reasonable officer would have known that using force against a restrained
491. Every reasonable officer would have known that using force against a passively
492. Every reasonable officer would have known that restraining a non-resistant
individual while other police officers use force against him would be excessive force and a
493. Every reasonable officer would have known that restraining a passively resisting
individual while other police officers use force against him would be excessive force and a
494. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Demetrius Haley’s violations
of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic personal injuries and death.
495. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic conscious pain,
80
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 82 of 139 PageID 82
496. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley’s
unjustified, excessive, illegal, and deadly use of force, Tyre Nichols eventually died of his injuries.
497. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions of Memphis Police
Officer Demetrius Haley described in this Count, Tyre Nichols suffered compensatory and special
damages as defined under federal common law and in an amount to be determined by a jury.
498. Punitive damages are available against Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley
as a matter of federal common law and are hereby sought by Plaintiff given the reprehensibility of
499. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions described in this Count,
Tyre Nichols’ next of kin have suffered pecuniary loss, including medical and funeral expenses;
loss of future wages and earnings; and loss of aid, counsel, guidance, advice, assistance, protection,
500. Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees as prescribed
501. Plaintiff hereby incorporates and realleges Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though
502. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley identified and described
in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted a failure to intervene to prevent
excessive and deadly force in violation of the Fourth Amendment of the United States Constitution,
as incorporated to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution.
81
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 83 of 139 PageID 83
503. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley identified and described
in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted failure to intervene to prevent
504. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley was acting under
color of state law, as agent of the City of Memphis, and within the scope of his employment and
505. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley could not have
506. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley had no reasonable
507. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley did not have a
reasonable fear of Tyre Nichols causing imminent bodily harm to Officer Haley or any other
person.
508. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was fully restrained and subdued by Memphis
509. Despite the aforementioned facts, Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley stood
82
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 84 of 139 PageID 84
510. Every reasonable officer would have known that failing to intervene while police
officers used force against a non-resistant individual would be excessive force and a violation of
511. Every reasonable officer would have known that failing to intervene while police
officers used force against a restrained individual would be excessive force and a violation of the
Fourth Amendment.
512. Every reasonable officer would have known that failing to intervene while police
officers used force against a passively resisting individual would be excessive force and a violation
513. No reasonable officer could have thought there was a justification for the use of
force against Tyre Nichols after he had been neutralized, subdued, restrained in handcuffs,
514. No reasonable officer could have thought there was a justification for the use of
force against Tyre Nichols after he had been neutralized, subdued, restrained in handcuffs,
515. Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley’s restraining of Tyre Nichols while other
Defendants used force against Tyre Nichols was objectively unreasonable and violated clearly
established law.
516. Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley observed that the force being used by
517. Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley was in a position to intervene and stop
other Defendants’ use of unjustified, excessive, illegal, and deadly use of force against Tyre
Nichols.
83
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 85 of 139 PageID 85
518. Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley’s failure to intervene on behalf of Tyre
Nichols while other Defendants used force against Tyre Nichols was objectively unreasonable and
519. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic personal injuries and
death.
520. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic conscious pain,
521. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley’s
failing to intervene on behalf of Tyre Nichols while other Defendants used unjustified, excessive,
illegal, and deadly use of force, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic, conscious pain, suffering,
522. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley’s
failing to intervene on behalf of Tyre Nichols while other Defendants used unjustified, excessive,
illegal, and deadly use of force, Tyre Nichols eventually died of his injuries.
523. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions of Memphis Police
Officer Demetrius Haley, Tyre Nichols suffered compensatory and special damages as defined
524. Punitive damages are available against Memphis Police Officer Demetrius Haley
as a matter of federal common law and are hereby sought by Plaintiff given the reprehensibility of
84
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 86 of 139 PageID 86
525. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions described in this Count,
Tyre Nichols’ next of kin have suffered pecuniary loss, including medical and funeral expenses;
loss of future wages and earnings; and loss of aid, counsel, guidance, advice, assistance, protection,
526. Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees as prescribed
527. Plaintiff hereby incorporates and realleges Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though
528. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith identified and described in
this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted excessive and deadly force in
violation of the Fourth Amendment of the United States Constitution, as incorporated to the states
529. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith identified and described in
this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted excessive and deadly force in
530. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith was acting under color
of state law, as agent of the City of Memphis, and within the scope of his employment and authority
531. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith had no reasonable,
532. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith had no probable cause
85
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 87 of 139 PageID 87
533. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was compliant with Memphis Police Officer
534. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was not violating any laws of the City of
535. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was not resisting arrest.
536. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith could not have
537. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith had no reasonable belief
538. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith did not have a
reasonable fear of Tyre Nichols causing imminent bodily harm to Officer Smith or any other
person.
539. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was fully restrained and subdued by Memphis
540. Despite the aforementioned facts, Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith proceeded
to:
86
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 88 of 139 PageID 88
h. Restrain Tyre Nichols while other Defendants punched Tyre Nichols; and
541. Every reasonable officer would have known that stopping someone without
reasonable, articulable suspicion constituted an unreasonable search and seizure in violation of the
Fourth Amendment.
542. Every reasonable officer would have known that detaining someone without
probable cause constituted an unreasonable search and seizure in violation of the Fourth
Amendment.
543. Every reasonable officer would have known that using force against a non-resistant
544. Every reasonable officer would have known that using force against a restrained
545. Every reasonable officer would have known that using force against a passively
546. Every reasonable officer would have known that restraining a non-resistant
individual while other police officers use force against him would be excessive force and a
547. Every reasonable officer would have known that restraining a passively resisting
individual while other police officers use force against him would be excessive force and a
548. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Justin Smith’s violations of the
Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic personal injuries and death.
87
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 89 of 139 PageID 89
549. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic conscious pain,
550. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith’s
unjustified, excessive, illegal, and deadly use of force, Tyre Nichols eventually died of his injuries.
551. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions of Memphis Police
Officer Justin Smith described in this Count, Tyre Nichols suffered compensatory and special
damages as defined under federal common law and in an amount to be determined by a jury.
552. Punitive damages are available against Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith as a
matter of federal common law and are hereby sought by Plaintiff given the reprehensibility of
553. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions described in this Count,
Tyre Nichols’ next of kin have suffered pecuniary loss, including medical and funeral expenses;
loss of future wages and earnings; and loss of aid, counsel, guidance, advice, assistance, protection,
554. Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees as prescribed
555. Plaintiff hereby incorporates and realleges Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though
556. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith identified and described in
this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted a failure to intervene to prevent
88
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 90 of 139 PageID 90
excessive and deadly force in violation of the Fourth Amendment of the United States Constitution,
as incorporated to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution.
557. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith identified and described in
this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted failure to intervene to prevent
558. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith was acting under color
of state law, as agent of the City of Memphis, and within the scope of his employment and authority
559. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith could not have
560. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith had no reasonable belief
561. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith did not have a
reasonable fear of Tyre Nichols causing imminent bodily harm to Officer Smith or any other
person.
562. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was fully restrained and subdued by Memphis
563. Despite the aforementioned facts, Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith stood by
89
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 91 of 139 PageID 91
564. Every reasonable officer would have known that failing to intervene while police
officers used force against a non-resistant individual would be excessive force and a violation of
565. Every reasonable officer would have known that failing to intervene while police
officers used force against a restrained individual would be excessive force and a violation of the
Fourth Amendment.
566. Every reasonable officer would have known that failing to intervene while police
officers used force against a passively resisting individual would be excessive force and a violation
567. No reasonable officer could have thought there was a justification for the use of
force against Tyre Nichols after he had been neutralized, subdued, restrained in handcuffs,
568. No reasonable officer could have thought there was a justification for the use of
force against Tyre Nichols after he had been neutralized, subdued, restrained in handcuffs,
569. Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith’s restraining of Tyre Nichols while other
Defendants used force against Tyre Nichols was objectively unreasonable and violated clearly
established law.
570. Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith observed that the force being used by other
571. Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith was in a position to intervene and stop other
Defendants’ use of unjustified, excessive, illegal, and deadly use of force against Tyre Nichols.
90
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 92 of 139 PageID 92
572. Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith’s failure to intervene on behalf of Tyre
Nichols while other Defendants used force against Tyre Nichols was objectively unreasonable and
573. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic personal injuries and
death.
574. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic conscious pain,
575. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith’s failing
to intervene on behalf of Tyre Nichols while other Defendants used unjustified, excessive, illegal,
and deadly use of force, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic conscious pain, suffering, and
emotional distress.
576. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith’s failing
to intervene on behalf of Tyre Nichols while other Defendants used unjustified, excessive, illegal,
and deadly use of force, Tyre Nichols eventually died of his injuries.
577. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions of Memphis Police
Officer Justin Smith, Tyre Nichols suffered compensatory and special damages as defined under
578. Punitive damages are available against Memphis Police Officer Justin Smith as a
matter of federal common law and are hereby sought by Plaintiff given the reprehensibility of
91
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 93 of 139 PageID 93
579. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions described in this Count,
Tyre Nichols’ next of kin have suffered pecuniary loss, including medical and funeral expenses;
loss of future wages and earnings; and loss of aid, counsel, guidance, advice, assistance, protection,
580. Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees as prescribed
581. Plaintiff hereby incorporates and realleges Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though
582. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr. identified and
described in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted excessive and deadly
force in violation of the Fourth Amendment of the United States Constitution, as incorporated to
the states through the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution.
583. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr. identified and
described in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted excessive and deadly
584. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr. was acting under
color of state law, as agent of the City of Memphis, and within the scope of his employment and
585. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr. had no
586. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills had no probable
92
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 94 of 139 PageID 94
587. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was compliant with Memphis Police Officer
588. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was not violating any laws of the City of
589. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was not resisting arrest.
590. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr. could not have
591. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr. had no reasonable
592. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr. did not have a
reasonable fear of Tyre Nichols causing imminent bodily harm to Officer Desmond Mills, Jr. or
593. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was fully restrained and subdued by Memphis
594. Despite the aforementioned facts, Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills
proceeded to:
93
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 95 of 139 PageID 95
h. Restrain Tyre Nichols while other Defendants punched Tyre Nichols; and
595. Every reasonable officer would have known that stopping someone without
reasonable, articulable suspicion constituted an unreasonable search and seizure in violation of the
Fourth Amendment.
596. Every reasonable officer would have known that detaining someone without
probable cause constituted an unreasonable search and seizure in violation of the Fourth
Amendment.
597. Every reasonable officer would have known that using force against a non-resistant
598. Every reasonable officer would have known that using force against a restrained
599. Every reasonable officer would have known that using force against a passively
600. Every reasonable officer would have known that restraining a non-resistant
individual while other police officers use force against him would be excessive force and a
601. Every reasonable officer would have known that restraining a passively resisting
individual while other police officers use force against him would be excessive force and a
602. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr.’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic personal injuries and
death.
94
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 96 of 139 PageID 96
603. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr.’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic conscious pain,
604. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills Jr.’s
unjustified, excessive, illegal, and deadly use of force, Tyre Nichols eventually died of his injuries.
605. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions of Memphis Police
Officer Desmond Mills, Jr. described in this Count, Tyre Nichols suffered compensatory and
special damages as defined under federal common law and in an amount to be determined by a
jury.
606. Punitive damages are available against Memphis Police Desmond Mills, Jr. as a
matter of federal common law and are hereby sought by Plaintiff given the reprehensibility of
607. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions described in this Count,
Tyre Nichols’ next of kin have suffered pecuniary loss, including medical and funeral expenses;
loss of future wages and earnings; and loss of aid, counsel, guidance, advice, assistance, protection,
608. Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees as prescribed
609. Plaintiff hereby incorporates and realleges Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though
95
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 97 of 139 PageID 97
610. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr. identified and
described in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted a failure to intervene to
prevent excessive and deadly force in violation of the Fourth Amendment of the United States
Constitution, as incorporated to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States
Constitution.
611. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr. identified and
described in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted failure to intervene to
612. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr. was acting under
color of state law, as agent of the City of Memphis, and within the scope of his employment and
613. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr. could not have
614. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr. had no reasonable
615. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr. did not have a
reasonable fear of Tyre Nichols causing imminent bodily harm to Officer Desmond Mills, Jr. or
616. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was fully restrained and subdued by Memphis
617. Despite the aforementioned facts, Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr.
96
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 98 of 139 PageID 98
618. Every reasonable officer would have known that failing to intervene while police
officers used force against a non-resistant individual would be excessive force and a violation of
619. Every reasonable officer would have known that failing to intervene while police
officers used force against a restrained individual would be excessive force and a violation of the
Fourth Amendment.
620. Every reasonable officer would have known that failing to intervene while police
officers used force against a passively resisting individual would be excessive force and a violation
621. No reasonable officer could have thought there was a justification for the use of
force against Tyre Nichols after he had been neutralized, subdued, restrained in handcuffs,
622. No reasonable officer could have thought there was a justification for the use of
force against Tyre Nichols after he had been neutralized, subdued, restrained in handcuffs,
623. Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr.’s restraining of Tyre Nichols while
other Defendants used force against Tyre Nichols was objectively unreasonable and violated
624. Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr. observed that the force being used by
97
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 99 of 139 PageID 99
625. Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr. was in a position to intervene and stop
other Defendants’ use of unjustified, excessive, illegal, and deadly use of force against Tyre
Nichols.
626. Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr.’s failure to intervene on behalf of Tyre
Nichols while other Defendants used force against Tyre Nichols was objectively unreasonable and
627. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr.’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic personal injuries and
death.
628. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr.’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic conscious pain,
629. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr.’s
failing to intervene on behalf of Tyre Nichols while other Defendants used unjustified, excessive,
illegal, and deadly use of force, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic, conscious pain, suffering,
630. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills, Jr.’s
failing to intervene on behalf of Tyre Nichols while other Defendants used unjustified, excessive,
illegal, and deadly use of force, Tyre Nichols eventually died of his injuries.
631. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions of Memphis Police
Officer Desmond Mills, Jr., Tyre Nichols suffered compensatory and special damages as defined
98
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 100 of 139 PageID 100
632. Punitive damages are available against Memphis Police Officer Desmond Mills as
a matter of federal common law and are hereby sought by Plaintiff given the reprehensibility of
633. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions described in this Count,
Tyre Nichols’ next of kin have suffered pecuniary loss, including medical and funeral expenses;
loss of future wages and earnings; and loss of aid, counsel, guidance, advice, assistance, protection,
634. Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees as prescribed
635. Plaintiff hereby incorporates and realleges Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though
636. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean identified and described
in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted excessive and deadly force in
violation of the Fourth Amendment of the United States Constitution, as incorporated to the states
637. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean identified and described
in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted excessive and deadly force in
638. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean was acting under
color of state law, as agent of the City of Memphis, and within the scope of his employment and
99
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 101 of 139 PageID 101
639. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean had no reasonable,
640. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean had no probable
641. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was compliant with Memphis Police Officer
642. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was not violating any laws of the City of
643. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was not resisting arrest.
644. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean could not have
645. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean had no reasonable
646. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean did not have a
reasonable fear of Tyre Nichols causing imminent bodily harm to Officer Bean or any other person.
647. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was fully restrained and subdued by Memphis
648. Despite the aforementioned facts, Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean
proceeded to:
100
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 102 of 139 PageID 102
h. Restrain Tyre Nichols while other Defendants punched Tyre Nichols; and
649. Every reasonable officer would have known that stopping someone without
reasonable, articulable suspicion constituted an unreasonable search and seizure in violation of the
Fourth Amendment.
650. Every reasonable officer would have known that detaining someone without
probable cause constituted an unreasonable search and seizure in violation of the Fourth
Amendment.
651. Every reasonable officer would have known that using force against a non-resistant
652. Every reasonable officer would have known that using force against a restrained
653. Every reasonable officer would have known that using force against a passively
654. Every reasonable officer would have known that restraining a non-resistant
individual while other police officers use force against him would be excessive force and a
655. Every reasonable officer would have known that restraining a passively resisting
individual while other police officers use force against him would be excessive force and a
101
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 103 of 139 PageID 103
656. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic personal injuries and
death.
657. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic conscious pain,
658. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean’s
unjustified, excessive, illegal, and deadly use of force, Tyre Nichols eventually died of his injuries.
659. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions of Memphis Police
Officer Tadarrius Bean described in this Count, Tyre Nichols suffered compensatory and special
damages as defined under federal common law and in an amount to be determined by a jury.
660. Punitive damages are available against Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean as
a matter of federal common law and are hereby sought by Plaintiff given the reprehensibility of
661. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions described in this Count,
Tyre Nichols’ next of kin have suffered pecuniary loss, including medical and funeral expenses;
loss of future wages and earnings; and loss of aid, counsel, guidance, advice, assistance, protection,
662. Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees as prescribed
102
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 104 of 139 PageID 104
663. Plaintiff hereby incorporates and realleges Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though
664. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean identified and described
in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted a failure to intervene to prevent
excessive and deadly force in violation of the Fourth Amendment of the United States Constitution,
as incorporated to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution.
665. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean identified and described
in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted failure to intervene to prevent
666. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean was acting under
color of state law, as agent of the City of Memphis, and within the scope of his employment and
667. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean could not have
668. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean had no reasonable
669. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean did not have a
reasonable fear of Tyre Nichols causing imminent bodily harm to Officer Bean or any other
person.
670. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was fully restrained and subdued by Memphis
103
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 105 of 139 PageID 105
671. Despite the aforementioned facts, Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean stood by
672. Every reasonable officer would have known that failing to intervene while police
officers used force against a non-resistant individual would be excessive force and a violation of
673. Every reasonable officer would have known that failing to intervene while police
officers used force against a restrained individual would be excessive force and a violation of the
Fourth Amendment.
674. Every reasonable officer would have known that failing to intervene while police
officers used force against a passively resisting individual would be excessive force and a violation
675. No reasonable officer could have thought there was a justification for the use of
force against Tyre Nichols after he had been neutralized, subdued, restrained in handcuffs,
676. No reasonable officer could have thought there was a justification for the use of
force against Tyre Nichols after he had been neutralized, subdued, restrained in handcuffs,
104
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 106 of 139 PageID 106
677. Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean’ restraining of Tyre Nichols while other
Defendants used force against Tyre Nichols was objectively unreasonable and violated clearly
established law.
678. Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean observed that the force being used by other
679. Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean was in a position to intervene and stop
other Defendants’ use of unjustified, excessive, illegal, and deadly use of force against Tyre
Nichols.
680. Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean’s failure to intervene on behalf of Tyre
Nichols while other Defendants used force against Tyre Nichols was objectively unreasonable and
681. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic personal injuries and
death.
682. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic conscious pain,
683. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean’s
failing to intervene on behalf of Tyre Nichols while other Defendants used unjustified, excessive,
illegal, and deadly use of force, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic, conscious pain, suffering,
105
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 107 of 139 PageID 107
684. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean’s
failing to intervene on behalf of Tyre Nichols while other Defendants used unjustified, excessive,
illegal, and deadly use of force, Tyre Nichols eventually died of his injuries.
685. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions of Memphis Police
Officer Tadarrius Bean, Tyre Nichols suffered compensatory and special damages as defined under
686. Punitive damages are available against Memphis Police Officer Tadarrius Bean as
a matter of federal common law and are hereby sought by Plaintiff given the reprehensibility of
687. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions described in this Count,
Tyre Nichols’ next of kin have suffered pecuniary loss, including medical and funeral expenses;
loss of future wages and earnings; and loss of aid, counsel, guidance, advice, assistance, protection,
688. Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees as prescribed
689. Plaintiff hereby incorporates and realleges Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though
690. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill was patrolling the
691. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill witnessed Tyre
106
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 108 of 139 PageID 108
692. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill attempted to find
information sufficient to pull Tyre Nichols over by searching for driver’s license holds or active
information relating to any warrants, history of traffic infractions, history of criminal activity, or
any other information that would justify a traffic stop of Tyre Nichols.
694. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill had no reasonable,
695. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill had no reasonable,
articulable suspicion that Tyre Nichols was about to be engaged in criminal activity.
particularized and objective basis that Tyre Nichols was suspected of legal wrongdoing.
697. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill, upon pulling over
Tyre Nichols, was not taking reasonable steps to protect his own safety.
698. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill, upon pulling over
Tyre Nichols, was taking reasonable steps to protect his fellow officers’ safety.
699. On January 7, 2023, prior to and while being stopped, Tyre Nichols was not:
700. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill lacked reasonable,
articulable suspicion for stopping Tyre Nichols in his vehicle at Ross Road and Raines Road.
107
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 109 of 139 PageID 109
701. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill proceeded to stop
unreasonable seizure of Tyre Nichols when Tyre yielded to Preston Hemphill’s show of authority.
703. On January 7, 2023, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill violated the Fourth
Amendment and clearly established law when he stopped Tyre Nichols in his vehicle at Ross Road
704. Every reasonable officer would have known that stopping an individual without
705. Every reasonable officer would have known that detaining an individual without
706. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic personal injuries and
death.
707. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic conscious pain,
708. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions of Memphis Police
Officer Preston Hemphill described in this Count, Tyre Nichols suffered compensatory and special
damages as defined under federal common law and in an amount to be determined by a jury.
709. Punitive damages are available against Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill
as a matter of federal common law and are hereby sought by Plaintiff given the reprehensibility of
108
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 110 of 139 PageID 110
710. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions described in this Count,
Tyre Nichols’ next of kin have suffered pecuniary loss, including medical and funeral expenses;
loss of future wages and earnings; and loss of aid, counsel, guidance, advice, assistance, protection,
711. Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees as prescribed
712. Plaintiff hereby incorporates and realleges Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though
713. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill identified and described
in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted excessive and deadly force in
violation of the Fourth Amendment of the United States Constitution, as incorporated to the states
714. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill identified and described
in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted excessive and deadly force in
715. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill was acting under
color of state law, as agent of the City of Memphis, and within the scope of his employment and
716. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill no reasonable,
717. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill had no probable
109
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 111 of 139 PageID 111
718. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was compliant with Memphis Police Officer
719. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was not violating any laws of the City of
720. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was not resisting arrest.
721. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill could not have
722. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill had no reasonable
723. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill did not have a
reasonable fear of Tyre Nichols causing imminent bodily harm to Officer Hemphill or any other
person.
724. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was fully restrained and subdued by Memphis
725. Despite the aforementioned facts, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill
proceeded to:
110
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 112 of 139 PageID 112
726. Every reasonable officer would have known that stopping someone without
reasonable, articulable suspicion constituted an unreasonable search and seizure in violation of the
Fourth Amendment.
727. Every reasonable officer would have known that detaining someone without
probable cause constituted an unreasonable search and seizure in violation of the Fourth
Amendment.
728. Every reasonable officer would have known that using force against a non-resistant
729. Every reasonable officer would have known that using force against a restrained
730. Every reasonable officer would have known that using force against a passively
731. Every reasonable officer would have known that restraining a non-resistant
individual while other police officers use force against him would be excessive force and a
732. Every reasonable officer would have known that restraining a passively resisting
individual while other police officers use force against him would be excessive force and a
733. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Preston Hemphill’s violations
of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic personal injuries and death.
734. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Preston Hemphill’s violations
of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic conscious pain, suffering, and
emotional distress.
111
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 113 of 139 PageID 113
735. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill’s
unjustified, excessive, illegal, and deadly use of force, Tyre Nichols eventually died of his injuries.
736. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions of Memphis Police
Officer Preston Hemphill described in this Count, Tyre Nichols suffered compensatory and special
damages as defined under federal common law and in an amount to be determined by a jury.
737. Punitive damages are available against Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill
as a matter of federal common law and are hereby sought by Plaintiff given the reprehensibility of
738. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions described in this Count,
Tyre Nichols’ next of kin have suffered pecuniary loss, including medical and funeral expenses;
loss of future wages and earnings; and loss of aid, counsel, guidance, advice, assistance, protection,
739. Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees as prescribed
740. Plaintiff hereby incorporates and realleges Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though
741. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill identified and described
in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted a failure to intervene to prevent
excessive and deadly force in violation of the Fourth Amendment of the United States Constitution,
as incorporated to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution.
112
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 114 of 139 PageID 114
742. The conduct by Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill identified and described
in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted failure to intervene to prevent
743. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill was acting under
color of state law, as agent of the City of Memphis, and within the scope of his employment and
744. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill could not have
745. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill had no reasonable
746. At all relevant times, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill did not have a
reasonable fear of Tyre Nichols causing imminent bodily harm to Officer Hemphill or any other
person.
747. At all relevant times, Tyre Nichols was fully restrained and subdued by Memphis
748. Despite the aforementioned facts, Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill stood
113
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 115 of 139 PageID 115
749. Every reasonable officer would have known that failing to intervene while police
officers used force against a non-resistant individual would be excessive force and a violation of
750. Every reasonable officer would have known that failing to intervene while police
officers used force against a restrained individual would be excessive force and a violation of the
Fourth Amendment.
751. Every reasonable officer would have known that failing to intervene while police
officers used force against a passively resisting individual would be excessive force and a violation
752. No reasonable officer could have thought there was a justification for the use of
force against Tyre Nichols after he had been neutralized, subdued, restrained in handcuffs,
753. No reasonable officer could have thought there was a justification for the use of
force against Tyre Nichols after he had been neutralized, subdued, restrained in handcuffs,
754. Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill’s restraining of Tyre Nichols while other
Defendants used force against Tyre Nichols was objectively unreasonable and violated clearly
established law.
755. Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill observed that the force being used by
756. Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill was in a position to intervene and stop
other Defendants’ use of unjustified, excessive, illegal, and deadly use of force against Tyre
Nichols.
114
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 116 of 139 PageID 116
757. Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill’s failure to intervene on behalf of Tyre
Nichols while other Defendants used force against Tyre Nichols was objectively unreasonable and
758. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Preston Hemphill’s violations
of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic personal injuries and death.
759. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill’s
violations of the Fourth Amendment, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic conscious pain,
760. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill’s
failing to intervene on behalf of Tyre Nichols while other Defendants used unjustified, excessive,
illegal, and deadly use of force, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic conscious pain, suffering,
761. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill’s
failing to intervene on behalf of Tyre Nichols while other Defendants used unjustified, excessive,
illegal, and deadly use of force, Tyre Nichols eventually died of his injuries.
762. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions of Memphis Police
Officer Preston Hemphill, Tyre Nichols suffered compensatory and special damages as defined
763. Punitive damages are available against Memphis Police Officer Preston Hemphill
as a matter of federal common law and are hereby sought by Plaintiff given the reprehensibility of
764. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions described in this Count,
Tyre Nichols’ next of kin have suffered pecuniary loss, including medical and funeral expenses;
115
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 117 of 139 PageID 117
loss of future wages and earnings; and loss of aid, counsel, guidance, advice, assistance, protection,
765. Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees as prescribed
766. Plaintiff hereby incorporates and realleges Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though
(“EMT”) Robert Long identified and described in this count and in the preceding factual
768. The conduct by Memphis Fire Department EMT Robert Long identified and
described in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted deliberate indifference
769. At all relevant times, Memphis Fire Department EMT Robert Long was acting
under color of state law, as an agent of the City of Memphis, and within the scope of his
employment and authority as a duly certified EMT with the City of Memphis.
770. At all relevant times, Memphis Fire Department EMT Robert Long was licensed
116
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 118 of 139 PageID 118
771. At all relevant times in which Memphis Fire Department EMT Robert Long
interacted with him, Tyre Nichols was suffering from injuries so obvious that even a layperson
772. Every reasonable EMT would have known that Tyre Nichols objectively required
c. He was bleeding from his face and his body, and his wounds were unattended;
773. Even a layperson, let alone a trained EMT, would have known that Tyre Nichols
was suffering from several serious medical needs and necessitated medical treatment.
774. Memphis Fire Department EMT Robert Long failed to transport Tyre Nichols to
775. Every reasonable EMT would have known that it was deliberately indifferent to fail
to provide medical treatment in the face of such easily recognizable and serious medical
conditions.
776. Memphis Fire Department EMT Robert Long was deliberately indifferent in
denying Tyre Nichols appropriate medical care that was obviously necessary.
777. As a trained EMT, Robert Long was required to transport patients with medical
117
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 119 of 139 PageID 119
778. Memphis Fire Department EMT Robert Long observed Tyre Nichols’ grave
condition for nearly twenty minutes, and only assisted in placing him on a stretcher when other
779. Memphis Fire Department EMT Robert Long showed deliberate indifference to a
substantial risk of serious harm to Tyre Nichols when he ignored Tyre Nichols’ condition, and
instead stood and walked around Tyre Nichols as his physical condition only worsened.
780. Memphis Fire Department EMT Robert Long failure to render medical attention
to Tyre Nichols or transport him to a hospital in a timely manner after he was in a critical medical
781. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Fire Department EMT Robert Long’s
deliberate indifference to serious medical needs, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic personal
782. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Fire Department EMT Robert Long’s
deliberate indifference to serious medical needs, Tyre Nichols experienced catastrophic conscious
783. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Fire Department EMT Robert Long’s
deliberate indifference to serious medical needs, Tyre Nichols eventually died of his injuries.
784. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Fire Department EMT Robert Long’s
deliberate indifference to serious medical needs, Tyre Nichols suffered compensatory and special
damages as defined under federal common law and in an amount to be determined by a jury.
785. Punitive damages are available against Memphis Fire Department EMT Robert
Long as a matter of federal common law and are hereby sought by Plaintiff.
118
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 120 of 139 PageID 120
786. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions described in this Count,
Tyre Nichols’ next of kin have suffered pecuniary loss, including medical and funeral expenses;
loss of future wages and earnings; and loss of aid, counsel, guidance, advice, assistance, protection,
787. Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees as prescribed
788. Plaintiff hereby incorporates and realleges Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though
Technician (“Advanced EMT”) JaMichael Sandridge identified and described in this count and in
the preceding factual paragraphs constituted deliberate indifference to serious medical needs in
790. The conduct by Memphis Fire Department Advanced EMT JaMichael Sandridge
identified and described in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted deliberate
791. At all relevant times, Memphis Fire Department Advanced EMT JaMichael
Sandridge was acting under color of state law, as an agent of the City of Memphis, and within the
scope of his employment and authority as a duly certified Advanced EMT with the City of
Memphis.
119
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 121 of 139 PageID 121
792. At all relevant times, Memphis Fire Department Advanced EMT JaMichael
Sandridge was licensed by the Tennessee Emergency Medical Services Division as an advanced
793. At all relevant times in which Memphis Fire Department Advanced EMT
JaMichael Sandridge interacted with him, Tyre Nichols was suffering from injuries so obvious that
even a layperson would have easily recognized the necessity for medical attention.
794. Every reasonable EMT would have known that Tyre Nichols objectively required
c. He was bleeding from his face and his body, and his wounds were unattended;
795. Even a layperson, let alone a trained EMT, would have known that Tyre Nichols
was suffering from several serious medical needs and necessitated medical treatment.
796. Memphis Fire Department Advanced EMT JaMichael Sandridge failed to transport
Tyre Nichols to receive medical care by a doctor for approximately twenty minutes.
797. Every reasonable EMT would have known that it was deliberately indifferent to fail
to provide medical treatment in the face of such easily recognizable and serious medical
conditions.
798. Memphis Fire Department Advanced EMT JaMichael Sandridge was deliberately
indifferent in denying Tyre Nichols appropriate medical care that was obviously necessary.
120
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 122 of 139 PageID 122
800. Memphis Fire Department Advanced EMT JaMichael Sandridge observed Tyre
Nichols’ grave condition for nearly twenty minutes, and only assisted in placing him on a stretcher
when other medical personnel arrived on scene to provide care for Tyre Nichols. Memphis Fire
risk of serious harm to Tyre Nichols when he observed Tyre Nichols’ condition, pulled out a blood
pressure cuff from his triage bag, and then failed to actually use it on Tyre Nichols.
ignore Tyre Nichols’ condition; instead standing near and walking around Tyre Nichols as his
render medical attention to Tyre Nichols or transport him to a hospital in a timely manner after he
was in a critical medical condition was deliberately indifferent and violated clearly established
law.
803. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Fire Department Advanced EMT
JaMichael Sandridge’s deliberate indifference to serious medical needs, Tyre Nichols experienced
804. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Fire Department Advanced EMT
JaMichael Sandridge’s deliberate indifference to serious medical needs, Tyre Nichols experienced
121
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 123 of 139 PageID 123
805. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Fire Department advanced EMT
JaMichael Sandridge’s deliberate indifference to serious medical needs, Tyre Nichols eventually
806. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Fire Department Advanced EMT
JaMichael Sandridge’s deliberate indifference to serious medical needs, Tyre Nichols suffered
compensatory and special damages as defined under federal common law and in an amount to be
determined by a jury.
807. Punitive damages are available against Memphis Fire Department Advanced EMT
JaMichael Sandridge as a matter of federal common law and are hereby sought by Plaintiff.
808. Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees as prescribed
809. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions described in this Count,
Tyre Nichols’ next of kin have suffered pecuniary loss, including medical and funeral expenses;
loss of future wages and earnings; and loss of aid, counsel, guidance, advice, assistance, protection,
810. Plaintiff hereby incorporates and realleges Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though
811. The conduct by Memphis Fire Department Lieutenant Michelle Whitaker identified
and described in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted deliberate
indifference to serious medical needs in violation of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United
States Constitution.
122
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 124 of 139 PageID 124
812. The conduct by Memphis Fire Department Lt. Michelle Whitaker identified and
described in this count and in the preceding factual paragraphs constituted deliberate indifference
813. At all relevant times, Memphis Fire Department Lt. Michelle Whitaker was acting
under color of state law, as an agent of the City of Memphis, and within the scope of her
employment and authority as a duly sworn and certified Fire Department Lieutenant with the City
of Memphis.
814. At all relevant times in which Memphis Fire Department Lt. Michelle Whitaker
observed him, Tyre Nichols was suffering from injuries so obvious that even a layperson would
815. At all relevant times in which Memphis Fire Department Lt. Michelle Whitaker
learned of Tyre Nichols’ medical condition through conversations with the EMTs and police
officers on scene, she would have easily recognized the obvious need for medical attention to his
injuries.
816. Every reasonable Fire Department Lieutenant would have known that Tyre Nichols
objectively required medical attention after observing or learning of the following physical
conditions:
c. He was bleeding from his face and his body, and his wounds were unattended;
123
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 125 of 139 PageID 125
817. Even a lay person would have known that Tyre Nichols was suffering from several
818. Memphis Fire Department Lt. Michelle Whitaker stayed in the fire engine upon
arriving at the scene of Tyre Nichols’ beating at Bear Creek Cove and Castlegate.
819. Memphis Fire Department Lt. Michelle Whitaker did not transport Tyre Nichols
to receive medical care by a doctor for approximately twenty minutes after arriving at Bear Creek
820. Every reasonable Fire Department Lieutenant would have known that it was
deliberately indifferent to fail to provide medical treatment in the face of such easily recognizable
821. Memphis Fire Department Lt. Michelle Whitaker was deliberately indifferent in
enforcement call for medical care, Lt. Michelle Whitaker was required to transport patients with
823. Memphis Fire Department Lt. Michelle Whitaker observed or was made aware of
Tyre Nichols’ grave condition for nearly twenty minutes before she assisted in transporting him to
824. Memphis Fire Department Lt. Michelle Whitaker ignored Tyre Nichols’ condition,
staying in the fire engine while Tyre Nichols’ physical condition only worsened.
825. Memphis Fire Department Lt. Michelle Whitaker was deliberately indifferent in
124
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 126 of 139 PageID 126
826. Memphis Fire Department Lt. Michelle Whitaker’s failure to render medical
attention to Tyre Nichols or transport him to a hospital in a timely manner after he was in a critical
medical condition was deliberately indifferent and violated clearly established law.
827. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Fire Department Lt. Michelle
828. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Fire Department Lt. Michelle
829. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Fire Department advanced Lt.
Michelle Whitaker’s deliberate indifference to serious medical needs, Tyre Nichols eventually
830. As a direct and proximate result of Memphis Fire Department Lt. Michelle
Whitaker’s deliberate indifference to serious medical needs, Tyre Nichols suffered compensatory
and special damages as defined under federal common law and in an amount to be determined by
a jury.
831. Punitive damages are available against Memphis Fire Department Lt. Michelle
Whitaker as a matter of federal common law and are hereby sought by Plaintiff.
832. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions described in this Count,
Tyre Nichols’ next of kin have suffered pecuniary loss, including medical and funeral expenses;
loss of future wages and earnings; and loss of aid, counsel, guidance, advice, assistance, protection,
125
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 127 of 139 PageID 127
833. Plaintiff is entitled to recovery of costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees as prescribed
834. Plaintiff incorporates by reference Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though fully plead
835. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith carried out the actions
and inactions on January 7, 2023 set forth in Paragraphs 255 through 282 with the intent to deceive,
836. The actions and inactions of Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne
Smith on January 7, 2023 described in Paragraphs 255 through 282 toward RowVaughn Wells
were so outrageous in character and so extreme in degree that they went beyond all bounds of
decency.
837. Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith intentionally lied to and
withheld information from RowVaughn Wells on January 7, 2023 as described in Paragraphs 255
through 282 that was certain to foreseeably cause severe emotional distress to RowVaughn Wells.
838. The actions and inactions of Memphis Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne
Smith on January 7, 2023 described in Paragraphs 255 through 282 toward RowVaughn Wells
were so outrageous in character and so extreme in degree that they are utterly intolerable in a
civilized community.
Lieutenant DeWayne Smith committed one or more of the following acts or omissions described
in Paragraphs 255 through 282, including—but not limited to—intentionally and/or recklessly:
126
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 128 of 139 PageID 128
a. Telling RowVaughn Wells that Tyre was driving under the influence with no
evidence or support;
support;
c. Lying to RowVaughn Wells about the reasons why Tyre was being arrested;
d. Withholding the reasons why Tyre was being arrested from RowVaughn Wells;
f. Failing to tell RowVaughn Wells that Tyre was around the corner from her
840. But for the aforementioned intentional acts by Memphis Police Department
Lieutenant DeWayne Smith, RowVaughn Wells would not have incurred the severe emotional
841. As a direct and proximate result of the intentional actions and inaction of Memphis
842. As a direct and proximate result of the intentional actions and inaction of Memphis
843. As a direct and proximate result of the intentional actions and inaction of Memphis
Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith on January 7, 2023, RowVaughn Wells suffered
compensatory and special damages as defined under state common law and in an amount to be
determined by a jury.
127
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 129 of 139 PageID 129
844. As a direct and proximate result of the intentional acts and omissions described in
this Count on January 7, 2023, RowVaughn Wells has suffered and will suffer pecuniary loss,
including medical expenses; lost wages and earnings; as well as emotional damages in the form of
severe emotional distress, loss of normal life, suffering, anguish, and disability in an amount to be
determined by a jury.
845. Plaintiff incorporates by reference Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though fully plead
Lieutenant DeWayne Smith committed one or more of the following acts or omissions described
a. Telling RowVaughn Wells that Tyre was driving under the influence with no
evidence or support;
support;
c. Lying to RowVaughn Wells about the reasons why Tyre was being arrested;
d. Withholding the reasons why Tyre was being arrested from RowVaughn Wells;
128
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 130 of 139 PageID 130
f. Failing to tell RowVaughn Wells that Tyre was around the corner from her
850. It was foreseeable that the aforementioned negligent acts by Memphis Police
Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith would lead to the severe emotional distress that
851. As a direct and proximate result of the aforementioned negligent acts by Memphis
Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith, RowVaughn Wells was caused to incur severe
emotional distress.
852. But for the aforementioned negligent acts by Memphis Police Department
Lieutenant DeWayne Smith, RowVaughn Wells would not have incurred the severe emotional
853. As a direct and proximate result of the negligent actions and inaction of Memphis
854. RowVaughn Wells’ emotional distress is the type that an ordinary person would be
unable to adequately cope with the mental stress caused by the aforementioned circumstances.
855. As a direct and proximate result of the negligent actions and inaction of Memphis
856. As a direct and proximate result of the negligent actions and inaction of Memphis
Police Department Lieutenant DeWayne Smith on January 7, 2023, RowVaughn Wells suffered
129
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 131 of 139 PageID 131
compensatory and special damages as defined under state common law and in an amount to be
determined by a jury.
857. As a direct and proximate result of the negligent acts and omissions described in
this Count on January 7, 2023, RowVaughn Wells has suffered and will suffer pecuniary loss,
including medical expenses; lost wages and earnings; as well as emotional damages in the form of
severe emotional distress, loss of normal life, suffering, anguish, and disability in an amount to be
determined by a jury.
858. Plaintiff incorporates by reference Paragraphs 1 through 293 as though fully plead
e. That her son, Tyre, was not in mental pain and anguish;
f. That her son, Tyre, was not at risk of mental harm and anguish;
i. That her son, Tyre, was likely to survive his injuries; and
130
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 132 of 139 PageID 132
Smith’s false representations to RowVaughn Wells were in regard to material facts, namely as to
false representations to RowVaughn Wells were made without belief in their truth.
false representations caused RowVaughn Wells to rely on these representations in delaying the
time she would go to check on the medical condition and health of her son, Tyre.
false representations caused RowVaughn Wells to rely on these representations in delaying the
time she would have sought medical attention for her son, Tyre.
131
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 133 of 139 PageID 133
compensatory and special damages as defined under state common law and in an amount to be
determined by a jury.
870. As a direct and proximate result of the misrepresentations described in this Count
on January 7, 2023, RowVaughn Wells has suffered and will suffer pecuniary loss, including
medical expenses; lost wages and earnings; as well as emotional damages in the form of severe
emotional distress, loss of normal life, suffering, anguish, and disability in an amount to be
determined by a jury.
of the Estate of Tyre Deandre Nichols, prays for judgment against Defendants as follows:
and the City of Memphis for all damages under the law, including—but not limited to—
compensatory damages and special damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable attorneys’ fees
under 42 U.S.C. § 1988; and pre-judgment and post-judgment interest as allowed by law.
872. As to Count II, as Administratrix, a money judgment against Chief Cerelyn Davis
and the City of Memphis for all damages under the law, including—but not limited to—
compensatory damages and special damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable attorneys’ fees
under 42 U.S.C. § 1988; and pre-judgment and post-judgment interest as allowed by law.
873. As to Count III, as Administratrix, a money judgment against Chief Cerelyn Davis
and the City of Memphis for all damages under the law, including—but not limited to—
132
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 134 of 139 PageID 134
compensatory damages and special damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable attorneys’ fees
under 42 U.S.C. § 1988; and pre-judgment and post-judgment interest as allowed by law.
874. As to Count IV, as Administratrix, a money judgment Chief Cerelyn Davis and the
City of Memphis for all damages under the law, including—but not limited to—compensatory
damages and special damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable attorneys’ fees under 42
875. As to Count V, as Administratrix, a money judgment against Emmitt Martin III for
all damages under the law, including—but not limited to—compensatory damages, special
damages, punitive damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable attorneys’ fees under 42 U.S.C.
876. As to Count VI, as Administratrix, a money judgment against Emmitt Martin III
for all damages under the law, including—but not limited to—compensatory damages, special
damages, punitive damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable attorneys’ fees under 42 U.S.C.
877. As to Count VII, as Administratrix, a money judgment against Emmitt Martin III
for all damages under the law, including—but not limited to—compensatory damages, special
damages, punitive damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable attorneys’ fees under 42 U.S.C.
for all damages under the law, including—but not limited to—compensatory damages, special
damages, punitive damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable attorneys’ fees under 42 U.S.C.
133
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 135 of 139 PageID 135
879. As to Count IX, as Administratrix, a money judgment against Demetrius Haley for
all damages under the law, including—but not limited to—compensatory damages, special
damages, punitive damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable attorneys’ fees under 42 U.S.C.
all damages under the law, including—but not limited to—compensatory damages, special
damages, punitive damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable attorneys’ fees under 42 U.S.C.
881. As to Count XI, as Administratrix, a money judgment against Justin Smith for all
damages under the law, including—but not limited to—compensatory damages, special damages,
punitive damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable attorneys’ fees under 42 U.S.C. § 1988;
882. As to Count XII, as Administratrix, a money judgment against Justin Smith for all
damages under the law, including—but not limited to—compensatory damages, special damages,
punitive damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable attorneys’ fees under 42 U.S.C. § 1988;
883. As to Count XIII, as Administratrix, a money judgment against Desmond Mills, Jr.
for all damages under the law, including—but not limited to—compensatory damages, special
damages, punitive damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable attorneys’ fees under 42 U.S.C.
884. As to Count XIV, as Administratrix, a money judgment against Desmond Mills, Jr.
for all damages under the law, including—but not limited to—compensatory damages, special
134
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 136 of 139 PageID 136
damages, punitive damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable attorneys’ fees under 42 U.S.C.
885. As to Count XV, as Administratrix, a money judgment against Tadarrius Bean for
all damages under the law, including—but not limited to—compensatory damages, special
damages, punitive damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable attorneys’ fees under 42 U.S.C.
886. As to Count XVI, as Administratrix, a money judgment against Tadarrius Bean for
all damages under the law, including—but not limited to—compensatory damages, special
damages, punitive damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable attorneys’ fees under 42 U.S.C.
for all damages under the law, including—but not limited to—compensatory damages, special
damages, punitive damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable attorneys’ fees under 42 U.S.C.
for all damages under the law, including—but not limited to—compensatory damages, special
damages, punitive damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable attorneys’ fees under 42 U.S.C.
for all damages under the law, including—but not limited to—compensatory damages, special
damages, punitive damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable attorneys’ fees under 42 U.S.C.
135
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 137 of 139 PageID 137
890. As to Count XX, as Administratrix, a money judgment against Robert Long for all
damages under the law, including—but not limited to—compensatory damages, special damages,
punitive damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable attorneys’ fees under 42 U.S.C. § 1988;
Sandridge for all damages under the law, including—but not limited to—compensatory damages,
special damages, punitive damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable attorneys’ fees under 42
for all damages under the law, including—but not limited to—compensatory damages, special
damages, punitive damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable attorneys’ fees under 42 U.S.C.
individually and as agent of the City of Memphis for all damages under the law, including—but
not limited to—compensatory damages and special damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable
attorneys’ fees; punitive damages; and pre-judgment and post-judgment interest as allowed by law.
individually and as agent of the City of Memphis for all damages under the law, including—but
not limited to— compensatory damages and special damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable
attorneys’ fees; punitive damages; and pre-judgment and post-judgment interest as allowed by law.
individually and as agent of the City of Memphis, for all damages under the law, including—but
136
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 138 of 139 PageID 138
not limited to— compensatory damages and special damages; costs, disbursements, and reasonable
attorneys’ fees; punitive damages; and pre-judgment and post-judgment interest as allowed by law.
896. For any other such relief that this Court deems just and equitable under the laws of
JURY DEMAND
897. Plaintiff hereby demands a trial by jury as set forth in the Seventh Amendment to
the United States Constitution and Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 38.
137
Case 2:23-cv-02224 Document 1 Filed 04/19/23 Page 139 of 139 PageID 139
138