Menifee Transcript 1
Menifee Transcript 1
3
STATE OF TENNESSEE *
4 *
Plaintiff, *
5 *
vs. *
6 *
MARVIN L. MENIFEE * CASE NO. 313847
7 KENNETH Z. MOORE * CASE NO. 313848
*
8 Defendant. *
9
March 30, 2023
10
TRANSCRIPT OF HEARING ON MOTION TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE
11
VOLUME ONE OF ONE VOLUME
12
THE HONORABLE BOYD M. PATTERSON, JUDGE
13
APPEARANCES
14
FOR THE STATE OF TENNESSEE:
15
Austin Scofield, Esq.
16 Assistant District Attorney General
Third Floor
17 City and County Courts Building
Chattanooga, Tennessee 37402
18
FOR THE DEFENDANT MENIFEE:
19
Mike Little, Esq.
20 Executive Assistant District Public Defender
Vikki Clark, Esq.
21 Assistant District Public Defender
720 Cherry Street
22 Chattanooga, Tennessee 37402
1
1 IN THE CRIMINAL COURT OF TENNESSEE AT CHATTANOOGA
THE ELEVENTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT
2 DIVISION III
3
STATE OF TENNESSEE *
4 *
vs. *
5 *
MARVIN MENIFEE, * CASE NO. 313847
6 KENNETH MOORE * CASE NO. 313848
13 Menifee?
2
1 to get as far as I could.
6 continuance?
12 evidence excluded?
19 right now?
23 to.
3
1 in less than two weeks. We need to know what this is
10 what it is.
18 excluded?
22 way.
4
1 Mr. Little or I, until they say otherwise, I'm going
21 of him and him being part of the State, but not only
5
1 And again, Judge, I just want to make it
8 to us.
13 at that time knew it was set for that date; and that
17 Facebook stuff.
6
1 that we've looked at it, but I'm, you know, I'm doing
23 Judge.
7
1 they finally got it working. It's on an external
2 hard drive.
15 stuff.
8
1 things. Other times it would be in person. The
9
1 whatever. But, like, it's -- and I would also admit
11 would say that the lion's share of that pie chart has
20 effect.
10
1 your clients have been locked up for a long time
5 Clark?
11 no -- he's twenty- --
13 lot less.
24 ability to --
11
1 THE COURT: Moore is 500,000?
12
1 solely because it was provided late, then based on
25 followup.
13
1 But that's the order of the Court as of today,
6 are denying the motion and that the remedy for that
8 this --
21 violation.
14
1 clear to us that if the bond was a thousand dollars,
16 ago, and they just sit on it? And that alone, Your
15
1 case that a defense attorney has. We have a
3 client.
16
1 MR. SCOFIELD: Your Honor, I mean, speedy
12 manpower.
24 had the moment the request was made. The State does
17
1 can't open. Certainly we are not trying to harass
2 anyone.
20 granted.
18
1 I think, given Your Honor's enormous cut on
9 things?
17 known.
19
1 for. And nobody is saying that they controlled any
2 of that stuff.
20
1 said, "I have literally begged the other D.A.," -- I
3 many times, and now our clients are the ones who are
16 back over.
18 April 11th was the date, and they had seven months to
21
1 MS. CLARK: Yes, Your Honor. You did not set
5 October 3rd.
24 defendant as well.
22
1 and resetting it for a trial date -- if the defense
5 this point.
9 not?
12 granted.
23
1 think -- you know, we all work well together. I just
13 Box.
24
1 would stipulate to the $25,000 bond for Mr. Moore,
8 Moore as well?
17 Gilbert, I can't --
25
1 THE COURT: And if there's merit to those,
22 this.
26
1 assertion has been preserved for the record, and I
6 accountable.
22 dates.
27
1 dates that maybe we could, between the three of us,
10 potential dates.
28
1 soonest trial date I can -- I want the 11th. If I
3 after that.
29
1 joined in?
5 was granted.
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
30
1 IN THE CRIMINAL COURT OF HAMILTON COUNTY, TENNESSEE
3 STATE OF TENNESSEE
4 VS.
6 KENNETH MOORE
20 ___________________________________
JUDGE
21
APPROVED:
22 ___________________________________
24 ___________________________________
31
1 REPORTER'S CERTIFICATE
12
13 ______________________, 2023
14
15
16 ____________________________
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
32