Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Storage Electric Multiple Units On Partially Electrified Suburban Railway Lines - 45757
Storage Electric Multiple Units On Partially Electrified Suburban Railway Lines - 45757
Andrzej WILK1
Gdańsk University of Technology, Faculty of Electrical and Control Engineering (1), Civil and Environmental Engineering (2)
doi:10.15199/48.2020.04.33
Streszczenie. W artykule wskazano na potencjalne korzyści energetyczne, środowiskowe i częściowo ekonomiczne wynikające z zastąpienia
konwencjonalnych jednostek trakcyjnych nowymi zasobnikowymi zespołami elektrycznymi mogącymi się poruszać na liniach kolejowych częściowo
niezelektryfikowanych. Zespoły te mogą pracować w dwóch trybach – zasilania sieciowego lub zasobnikowego. Przeprowadzono odpowiednie
symulacje komputerowe w programie Matlab wskazując na parametry zasobnikowych zespołów trakcyjnych. Zasobnikowe zespoły trakcyjne w
transporcie podmiejskim
Keywords: railway electric traction, vehicle hybrid power, energy storage devices, computer simulation.
Słowa kluczowe: elektryczne pojazdy szynowe, hybrydowe zasilanie pojazdu, zasobniki energii, symulacja komputerowa.
Introduction
Improved versions of electric rail vehicles have been
implemented for over 100 years, capable of crossing routes
on non–electrified railway sections. The AT 3 series of two–
car electric battery traction unit, known as Wittfeld after the
name of the designer, eng. Gustav Wittfeld [1] is an
interesting vehicle from the beginning of the 20th century.
The train, which could seat 90 passengers, was powered by
two 62 kW motors and reached speeds of up to 60 km/h
with a tare weight of 60 t. In Gdańsk Pomerania region,
AT 3 units most often serviced suburban traffic. Subsequent
modernizations extended the range of the units up to
300 km. In the 1950s, worn–out battery rail–cars were
withdrawn from line use in Poland. Fig. 1. The route of the non–electrified Gdynia Chylonia – Port
Current global trends point to potential energy, Oksywie railway line
environmental and partly economic benefits resulting from
the replacement of conventional DMU (Diesel Multiple Unit) In the Tri–City agglomeration you can find many
traction units with new BEMU (Battery Electric Multiple Unit) sections of the line with similar features as, for example,
electric vehicles, and especially IPEMU (Independently regional line No. 213 Reda – Hel with a length of 62 km with
Powered Electric Multiple Unit) that can run on partially great touristic importance. The IPEMU unit can be supplied
non–electrified lines [2–8]. DMU and BEMU vehicles are from the catenary line on the Gdynia Główna – Reda
operated on non–electrified lines. IPEMU vehicles can work section, which is enough to travel from Reda to Hel station.
in two modes – overhead contact line or storage supply. On To charge the vehicle before the return trip, a charging
electrified sections, these assemblies draw energy from the station was assumed to be built to charge the unit while
overhead contact line for vehicle propulsion, non–traction stationary. Similar railways can also be found in other
needs and energy storage charging, while on non– national agglomerations.
electrified sections they consume energy from the
accumulator, which is recharged during regenerative Electrical drivetrain structure
braking. As energy storage, Li–ion batteries are used most Virtually all electric multiple units (EMUs) built nowadays
often, and sometimes as a hybrid storage in combination use an overhead contact line or a third rail for power supply.
with supercapacitors [9, 10]. Vehicle power systems based Vehicles operating in urban rail networks in Poland utilize
on fuel cells and hybrid storages are also considered in the DC line voltage of 3000 V. Thus, the construction and
literature [2]. maintenance of a costly railway electrification system is
An example of the Tri–City (Gdańsk–Sopot–Gdynia) necessary. However, depending on localization,
agglomeration railway line was selected for the sake of unobstructed construction works may be impossible. The
analysis and simulations presented below. A short 8– impact of electric catenary on the environment needs also
kilometer section of the single–track passenger line on the to be taken into account.
Gdynia Chylonia – Gdynia Port Oksywie route was Electric multiple units are characterized by drivetrain
considered, on which revitalization is planned that could spread over all carriages, with numerous induction motors,
reduce heavy traffic at rush hours (Fig. 1). On–board installed in pairs in motorized bogies and fed by inverters
battery storage of IPEMU units charged from the catenary (Fig. 2a). Such design allows for wide–range tractive effort
line while traveling on the Gdynia Główna – Gdynia regulation with good dynamics and regenerative braking.
Chylonia section of the Urban Rapid Railway (pol. Szybka Therefore, equipping EMU with on–board energy
Kolej Miejska, SKM) line would allow for further travel to the storage (Fig. 2b) that allows to travel through non–
Port Oksywie station and return travel without the need to electrified route sections might be worthwhile. Such
build electrical traction infrastructure [11].
rail vehicle with on–board storage where: Ez – energy consumed, η – drivetrain efficiency
factor, pn – power of auxiliary loads, T – analyzed run time.
Fundamental drawbacks for using energy storages in
railway vehicles are the large size and weight of such In order to estimate more accurately the energy
devices, and the necessity of additional energy converter consumption, a changing efficiency value of η(F, v) was
usage. In comparison to a vehicle supplied by an overhead adopted, using a predetermined table expressing the
line, IPEMU could have limited passenger space and dependence of the propulsion efficiency on the torque
slightly worse energy efficiency. Therefore, onboard storage produced by the engines and their angular velocity. The
applications are limited to light rail vehicles with various value of the power of the vehicle's own needs has been
drivetrain design. defined at a constant level.
Energy recuperated during electric braking of the
Vehicle model analyzed vehicle is computed as
Energy consumption analysis of rail vehicle equipped T T
with on–board battery storage has been conducted on the
basis of train run calculations [13–15]. For this task, a
(3) Eo
0
F v ( F , v)dt
p dt
0
n
simulation program was developed using Matlab/Simulink Onboard battery storage has been represented by a
software. Thanks to modular structure of the program, battery model, defined in Simscape/SimPowerSystems
editing input parameters can be easily done, allowing for library. Its capacity was calculated in order to allow the
multiple cases analysis (Fig. 3). vehicle to cover the analyzed route in both directions,
without using an overhead line nor charging the battery
underway. A fully charged state of batteries at the beginning
of non–electrified route was assumed.
Energy requirement for IPEMU on the analyzed railway
line
Initial run calculations were conducted for 2 MW, 4–
section electric multiple unit (Fig. 2a), which is a standard
Downloaded from mostwiedzy.pl
b) b)
REFERENCES
[1] Jerczyński M., Nasz portret: wagon akumulatorowy typu
„Wittfeld”, Świat Kolei 03 (1995)
[2] Pagenkopf J., Kaimer S.: Potentials of alternative propulsion
systems for railway vehicles – a techno–economic evaluation,
Ninth International Conference EVER, 2014
[3] Ghaviha N., Bohlin M., Holmberg C., Dahlquist E., Speed
profile optimization of catenary–free electric trains with lithium–
Fig. 7. Waveforms of currents, voltage and state of charge on– ion batteries, Journal of Modern Transportation, 2019
board storage: a) when passing the train without coasting; b) at the [4] Furuta R., Kawasaki J., Kondo K., Hybrid traction technologies
energy–saving passage with energy storage devices for nonelectrified railway lines,
IEEJ Transactions on Electrical and Electronic Engineering,
According to the manufacturer, Talent 3 generates noise Vol. 5, Issue 3, 2010, 291–297
and vibrations level 7 dB lower than DMU vehicles, does [5] H. al–Ezee, C. Gould, S. B. Tennakoon, Novel method for
energy management for catenary free system operation, 53rd
not emit NOx and indirectly generates CO2 only in power
International Universities Power Engineering Conference, 2018
plants. The installed energy storage increases the vehicle's [6] Y. Kono, N. Shiraki, H. Yokoyama, R. Furuta, Catenary and
energy efficiency compared to classic EMUs as a result of storage battery hybrid system for electric railcar series EV–
braking energy recovery and starting support. To compare E301, International Power Electronics Conference, IPEC, 2014
the costs of purchasing Talent 3, the prices of domestic [7] Shao–bo Yin, Li–jun Diao, Wei–jie Li, Rong–jia He, Hai–chen
producers' delivery were analyzed as part of tenders from Lv, On board energy storage and control for inter–city hybrid
2016 for EMU and DMU vehicles for the Wielkopolskie, EMU. 43rd Annual Conference, IECON 2017
Śląskie, Mazowieckie and Przewozy Regionalne railway [8] F. Becker, A. Dämmig, Catenary free operation of light rail
vehicles – topology and operational concept. 18th European
companies as well as for Poznań Metropolitan Railway.
Conference EPE'16 ECCE Europe, 2016
The average purchase costs are summarized in Table 1. In [9] Long Cheng, Wei Wang, Shaoyuan Wei, Hongtao Lin, Zhidong
Downloaded from mostwiedzy.pl
lines 2 and 3, there are approximate values which, together Jia, An improved energy management strategy for hybrid
with the lack of electrification cost of the sample line (line 4) energy storage system in light rail vehicles, Energies 2018
indicate the advantages of IPEMU. The full analysis of the [10] Radu P. V., Szelag A., Steczek M., On–Board energy storage
legitimacy of choosing the type of traction unit should devices with supercapacitors for metro trains – case study
include the cost of the entire Life Cycle Cost, which for analysis of application effectiveness. Energies, 2019, 12, 1291
IPEMU is still difficult to determine. [11] Telecki M., Studium zastosowania zasobnikowych
elektrycznych jednostek trakcyjnych na tworzonej pasażerskiej
linii kolejowej do północnych dzielnic Gdyni. Praca dyplomowa.
Summary Politechnika Gdańska, 2018
The simulation analyses carried out indicate that on both [12] Bartłomiejczyk M., Dynamic charging of electric buses. De
urban and suburban lines it may be beneficial to introduce Gruyter, 2019
electric storage traction units of the IPEMU type to service [13] Karwowski K. (red.), Energetyka transportu zelektryfikowanego.
passengers. Estimated costs presented in Tab. 1 indicate Poradnik inżyniera. Wyd. Politechniki Gdańskiej, Gdańsk 2018
the profitability of purchasing one IPEMU instead of classic [14] Bartłomiejczyk M., Mirchevski S., Jarzębowicz L., Karwowski
DMU while discarding 8 km section electrification. The K., How to choose drive’s rated power in electrified urban
transport? 17th European Conference, EPE’17 ECCE Europe,
purchase of a classic electric multiple unit together with the
2017
electrification of the section in question is similar in price to [15] Jakubowski A., Jarzębowicz L., Karwowski K., Wilk A.,
IPEMU without catenary line. However, the purchase of a Efektywność energetyczna pojazdu szynowego w różnych
larger number of IPEMUs can be economically justified if warunkach obciążenia, TTS Technika Transportu Szynowego,
they are also used to support other non–electrified sections, 12 (2018), 44–48
e.g. Gdańsk Wrzeszcz – Airport, Rumia – Hel and similar. [19] Takiguchi H., Overview of series EV–E301 catenary and
This relation of investment costs can be a challenge for battery–powered hybrid railcar, JR EAST Technical Review No.
domestic rail vehicle manufacturers in the construction of 31 (2015) 27–31
[20] Laperrière P., Realize your vision with Bombardier TALENT 3
light IPEMU with technical parameters sufficient to operate
BEMU, APTA Rail Conference, 2019
on both urban and suburban lines.