Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ang De-Leon Tecson Villaver The-Intsik-Sitch
Ang De-Leon Tecson Villaver The-Intsik-Sitch
Submitted by:
Ang, Isabella Perri C.
De Leon, Sophia Leigh D.
Tecson, Tyrone Martin Z.
Villaver, Raine Miguel V.
June 9, 2022
1
ABSTRACT
Racism has been present within society for years, affecting the lives of numerous
marginalized groups. Since the COVID-19 pandemic struck, the emergence of racism around the
world can be observed (Addo, 2020). In this phenomenological study, the researchers
interviewed seven Filipino-Chinese citizens, selected through purposive and snowball sampling.
Informants were interviewed regarding their experiences with racism before and during the
pandemic. The objective of this study is to examine their lived experiences, primarily those
linked to racism during the COVID-19 pandemic, as well as the circumstances in which they
encountered racial discrimination, how it impacted them, and how they faced such incidents.
Furthermore, the authors provided certain recommendations for future studies and community
legislations. Findings indicate the various forms of racism and its impact, as well as the
2022
All Rights Reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in an information
photocopying, scanning, recording, or otherwise, except under the terms of the applicable law.
2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Title Page 1
Abstract 2
Table of Contents 3
CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION
2.1 Racism…………………………………………...…………………………………..14
Synthesis ……..………………………………………………………………………….24
CHAPTER 3 METHODOLOGY
3
3.2 Research Setting……………………………………………………………………..26
3.3 Instrumentation………………………………………………………………………26
REFERENCES 38
APPENDICES 45
4
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
Racism is prejudice, discrimination, or hatred directed against people on the sole basis of
skin color, ethnicity, and origin. It is frequently associated with acts of harassment towards a
particular racial group. However, this is not always the case, as racism can take various forms
and is not always violent. Racism can happen absolutely anywhere, and it hinders people from
enjoying dignity and equality (Australian Human Rights Commission, 2021). Racism can be
practiced in a subtle and non-obvious manner, even inadvertently for some people, with the
Racism has been present in society for decades on end. The root of the problem may be
traced back to a modern-day connection between two components. The relationship between
racism and nationalism demonstrates how history developed over time. Racism is a major
nineteenth-century ideology that focuses on persons and their potential symbolism, whereas
socialist, and liberal ideologies. This acts as a source of racism, causing not just forms of
discrimination but also a perception of inequalities between men and women of many social
Through further studies, various forms of racism have been distinguished and been
discovered throughout the years. The most explicit form of racism in global history is slavery,
specifically of those caused by Western colonies in Africa (Price, 2020). From erecting human
zoos to forcing extreme labor, Westerners justified this with the reason of eugenics, and deemed
5
Black people as “midway between man and monkey”. Eugenics is the ideology that one race is
superior to the other, and it is what validated the inferiority of Black people. It is what
constructed the idea of races and ultimately racism that can still be seen today (Goering, 2014).
Though slavery was already a common practice during the middle ages in Europe, it was not
based on skin color and race. Criminals and prisoners of war are the most customary slaves
during these times (Zdziebłowski, 2021). Indeed, racism remains prevalent in the world that
humans live in today. Various races experience this as each day passes – including Asians,
With the origins of the COVID-19 pandemic pinned in China, racial discrimination
against the Chinese and people who “look” Chinese have heightened more than ever across the
globe, and as a result, significantly impacting their security, businesses, and overall day-to-day
living (Addo, 2020). People from all around the world shunned individuals for being Chinese or
Chinese-looking and denied them services such as the use of cab services, using public
bathrooms, and many more (Tiu, 2020). There are countries such as Japan and Singapore that do
not approve of the Chinese visiting their country. Japanese citizens took to Twitter about the
Singaporean citizens signed a petition to ban Chinese citizens from entering their country. Other
countries like South Korea, Hong Kong, and Vietnam do not welcome people from Mainland
citizens for various reasons, usually political. In order to further understand this topic, Who
Counts as Filipino? Philosophical Issues of Identity and the Chinese Filipino, a journal article by
6
Noelle Leslie Dela Cruz of De La Salle University-Manila published last 2015, explores and
examines the aspect of identity formation philosophically, intersecting race categories, ethnicity,
and culture. In this study, Dela Cruz (2015) begins with a survey of existing paradigms of
identity, which was then applied to an analysis of public discourses generated by anti-Chinese
remarks produced by a notable Filipino novelist. An excerpt from the article explains prevalent
issues:
The issue of Filipino identity—i.e., who the “true” Filipino is— has recently
come to the fore as the media reported two separate incidents. The first concerns a
Artist for Literature, F. Sionil Jose. In his “Hindsight” columns, June 7, 2015, and
June 21, 2015, for The Philippine Star; as well as an essay published in the
Philippine Daily Inquirer on July 26, 2015, the 92-year-old Filipino novelist made
no secret of his suspicions against the ethnic Chinese in the Philippines, whom he
believed would side with China should war between the two countries break out.
The second involves the new record for the highest grade-point average achieved
Grace Uy, who graduated summa cum laude with a Bachelor of Science degree in
biology, was criticized on the Internet for her Chinese ancestry. She was perceived
as usurping a place in the university that could have gone to someone from a
school for the poor. These two issues—coincidentally occurring in the month of
7
the Philippine Independence Day—immediately became flashpoints for debate,
Dela Cruz (2015) then concludes that Filipino identity — wherein the Filipino-Chinese
globally ethical society. Others point out that being Filipino is not a perpetual or transcendent
attribute but a constructed idea with a history, asserting that “Filipino” became a rational
category only as a patriotic response to the logic of colonialism — a common issue of all
suppressed natives of the Philippines regardless of their ethnicities. They seek to acknowledge
the validity of one's identity not only to a single factor but to their association with the general
community. Since a National Artist for Literature in the Philippines cannot get away with racial
slurs, it just shows that the Filipino identity is not a concept of sovereignty controlled by a few.
Instead, it is shaped through a performative process where our understanding of our own history
Filipino-Chinese teenager’s identity in the country. She shared her story pertaining to how she
noticed the treatment she received from Filipinos — who she viewed as family — treat the
Filipino-Chinese and the Chinese communities with disgust and prejudice. She also shared a time
when she was with her mother at a grocery store, and when she spoke the Chinese language,
people looked at her. She reported feeling extremely ashamed of this, looked down, and spoke
Most of the information in this study comes from research done in other countries, and
there is a lack of literature discussing racism in the Philippines. News outlets only report racism
8
that is happening overseas, while racism in the Filipino-Chinese community is often ignored or
normalized. The lack of media exposure may contribute to the normalization of racism in the
Philippines. This study hopes to spread the awareness that racism is also prevalent in the
Philippines and that it should not be normalized. Given that the Chinese community is one of the
largest ethnic groups in the Philippines, this paper aims to dwell on the experiences
This study aims to describe the lived experiences of racism against selected
Filipino-Chinese during the COVID-19 pandemic. It also aims to describe their experiences with
racism during the COVID-19 pandemic, the situations on how they experienced racial
discrimination, how these affected them, and how they coped with such incidents. Specifically, it
6. How has the COVID-19 pandemic affected their experience of racial discrimination?
9
9. How did their coping mechanisms vary based on their experiences with racial
discrimination?
in stressful situations (American Psychological Association, n.d). When dealing with stress or
trauma, these are often used to control difficult or painful emotions (Good Therapy, 2016). In
this study, coping mechanisms are referred to as the methods used by the Filipino-Chinese to
Filipino-Chinese. These people are more ingrained with their Filipino roots than the first
generation of the Filipino-Chinese, wherein their cultural orientation leans more onto the
Philippines than China or Taiwan. They are often more fluent in English and Filipino than the
Chinese language, as defined and proposed by Dorothy Ang Chua in 2004. In this study, a person
1. If their parents originated from China, but they were born in the Philippines.
2. If one or both of their parents have Chinese roots and/or are born in the Philippines.
4. If they have Chinese roots but were born and grew up in the Philippines.
Racial Discrimination. It refers to the hostile, aggressive, and degrading attitudes, behavior, or
circumstances like race, ethnicity, descent, national or ethnic origin, or immigration status
compared to individuals who are the same as them (Australian Human Rights Commission,
10
2019). In this study, racial discrimination refers to the derogatory treatment of varying kinds to
specific group or race that is rooted wherein individual differences are not taken into account and
any information that is not consistent with the stereotype developed about a certain racial group
is discarded or ignored, as defined and proposed by Morin (2020) and University of Notre Dame
(2021). In this study, racial stereotypes are referred to as the widespread, oversimplified, and
that determine a specific group of people or population as defined and proposed by (Formplus
Blog, 2021). This study’s socio-demographic characteristics pertain to sex assigned at birth,
Xenophobia. It is defined as the fear or act of disdain towards someone who is foreign and
culturally different from oneself, as defined and proposed by the Dictionary in 2021. In this
study, xenophobia refers to the antipathy that Filipinos may harbor towards the Filipino-Chinese
and their Chinese counterparts because they are culturally and racially foreign.
11
1.4 Conceptual Framework
Figure 1
Research Model
community’s experiences of racism in the Philippines and explore the possibility of its upsurge
during the pandemic. The study included seven Filipino-Chinese individuals who are currently
residing in the Philippines. The study will cover their experiences on racial stereotyping,
xenophobia, racial discrimination, coping mechanisms, and how the pandemic has influenced
these experiences.
12
Due to movement restrictions, the interviews were conducted through an online video
conferencing application, Zoom. Collection of the participants’ data was executed through the
use of an online survey administration software, Google Forms. The interview, after
confirmation of the participants’ consent, was recorded and stored for analysis.
This study aims to contribute a body of knowledge on racism and raise awareness on how it is
The Filipinos and the Filipino-Chinese. The research will provide them a venue to share their
personal experiences on racial issues and thus contribute to raising awareness on such matters.
The Government. The study can provide policymakers insights into how racism is experienced
in the country, which can then be used as a resource to craft programs and guidelines to prevent
its perpetuation.
Future Researchers. Results from this study can provide future researchers with new and untold
13
CHAPTER 2
2.1 Racism
An article by McWorther in 2020 has provided three definitions of racism. The first being
referred to as prejudiced, wherein “a belief that race is the primary determinant of human traits,
and that racial differences produce an inherent superiority of a particular race.” In the 1960s, it
was used as a term to describe societal and institutional racism. The term racism is referred to as
a disadvantage of inferior groups in society due to bigot attitudes that were continuously
occurring. The second definition is specified as a “political or social system founded on racism,”
which was later on expanded by Kennedy Mitchum by writing a message to the editors of
Merriam-Webster to expand the definition to “social and institutional power”. Mitchum also
noted that racism is a “system of advantage based on skin color.” The third definition of racism is
race-based disparities and societal racism. It is the use of racism that is ought to be combated
which is often acquired by a person in college classes in the social sciences, wherein it is
fundamental to modern discourses of race and racism. To expound more on this, an example
used is about black students not performing highly on standardized tests compared to white
students, which means that the tests are racist for they are disadvantageous towards black
students. It is natural to call social differences racism because it is undeniable that bias-infused
Minority groups have always been victims of racism and are often oppressed by the
supposedly dominant race. It is harmful because it invalidates other races’ experiences, like
saying “all lives matter” when the Black Americans are currently being oppressed (Cuncic,
14
2020). There are three essential ideas that can be helpful to best understand and explain racism.
The first idea is history, wherein racism can be presented with the use of past events as to how
minority groups face racial discrimination. An example used to better describe the first idea is
the barriers that the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people dealt with that other Australians
do not face. A specific barrier that was discussed is how they were less likely to be selected for
jobs which means that they are at a disadvantage, especially when it comes to the standard of
living and health care. This all goes way back in the past, wherein the Aboriginal and Torres
Strait Islander people were seen as inferior. Although it happened a long time ago, one cannot
just forget about something racist that happened in the past. The second idea is institutions such
as the media, schools, and many more wherein they play roles in maintaining racism. History and
institutions have to work together in order to give people of certain groups a voice as to how
their country should be built. An example used to further explain this is the colonization of
Australia by the British, wherein their laws, schools, and other bodies of institutions were
molded by the superior group, while the people from the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander
were not included in the process. The third idea is power. Power and racism create a disparity of
power that is based on race when they work together. This is the reason why Asians can make
jokes about their own race. Racism is when a dominant race makes jokes about inferior races that
do not have the same power in terms of history and institution (ReachOut Australia, 2021).
15
2.2 Types of Racism
and institutional realities - such as legal, educational, and economic systems, as well as a
function of its distant origins (Salter et al., 2017). It can be expressed through racial
discrimination. Clair & Denis (2015) stated that racism is analytically distinct from racial
discrimination and racial inequality since racial discrimination concerns the unequal treatment of
races. In contrast, racial disparities affect unequal outcomes such as income, education, health,
etc. This leads to racial discrimination playing a considerable role in lessened opportunities and
According to Tougas et al. (2004), the two forms of racism are overt and neo-racism.
Overt racism is defined as the traditional type whereby visible minorities are denigrated on the
basis of innate characteristics. For instance, a report from the Council of Europe (2015) states
manifestations of this may be typically founded on physical appearance, especially skin color but
today tends to emphasize cultural features and religion. Meanwhile, the subtle type called
neo-racism incorporates authoritarian values and negative stereotypes in the blame of minorities
for undeserved gains and social issues (Tougas et al., 2004). This concept can take the form of
ethnocentrism, which involves judging other groups by one’s own, which is seen as perfect. It
can evoke the rejection of any culture different from one’s own which often leads to racial
Additionally, there are three levels of racism, as proposed by Camara Phyllis Jones in
2000. These are institutionalized racism, personally mediated racism, and internalized racism.
16
Institutionalized racism exhibits both material conditions like quality education and access to
power such as wealth. It involves unearned privilege, structural barriers, and many more. This
profiling, predatory banking, access to healthcare, hiring or promotion practices, and mandatory
minimum sentences. Personally mediated racism is a prejudice wherein there are assumptions on
motives and intent according to one’s race and discrimination wherein there is a difference in
terms of treatment according to one’s race. It can be intentional or unintentional and is usually
condoned by societal norms. Acts under this type include telling a racist joke, believing in the
inherent superiority of a certain race, crossing the street to avoid passing a person of a certain
race, and so on. Lastly, internalized racism is where the stigmatized race accepts the damaging
messages about their own abilities and worth. It is a concept that explains when people of color
consciously or unconsciously accept a racial hierarchy (Kohli, 2013). It reflects on the systems’
privileges, societal values and undermines an individual’s sense of worth. According to the
National Research Council (US) Panel on Race, Ethnicity, and Health in Later Life et al. (2004),
internalized racism may be considered similar to prejudice based on a study by Allport (1958).
significantly based on the individual's group membership (Crandall & Schaller, 2004). This is
usually a preconception, which aligns with the ideas of internalized racism. The critical
difference between the two is that internalized racism accepts negative stereotypes about one's
Phyllis (2000) used the analogy of the flowers as an example to further explain the levels
of racism. In this example, a gardener has two packets of flower seeds, the first packet of seeds
17
were red, and the second packet was pink. The gardener preferred red flowers over pink, so she
planted the red flower seeds on a pot with rich soil and the pink ones on a pot with poor soil.
After the flowers bloomed, she told herself that she was right to prefer the red flowers over the
pink ones. Institutionalized racism happened when the gardener put the seeds into different types
of soil and did not address the difference of the soils. The gardener had already preferred the red
flowers over the pink flowers, which is a regular aspect of institutionalized racism. Personally
mediated racism happened when the gardener ignored or rejected the pink flowers because they
looked scrawny and poor. Internalized racism comes into play when a bee comes to pollinate the
pink flowers, but the pink flowers told the bee that it prefers the red flower’s pollen because the
pink flower believes that the red flowers are better for they are strong and thriving.
In the Philippines, it can be observed that most Filipinos favor a lighter skin complexion
such that of the people from the Western world. The use of skin whitening products has been
normalized and advertised for decades as having fairer skin is considered a beauty requirement.
This normalization may have led to an ironic situation of anti-black attitudes even if Filipinos
themselves have naturally darker skin. Public figures with dark skin often face ridicule for their
complexion. Any person with a darker skin tone gets perceived as dangerous and undesirable
This hegemonic racial consciousness can be traced back as early as the Spanish Colonial
Period where racial hierarchies are prevalent. The Spanish were on the top of the pyramid and
were considered to be wealthy. These light-skinned men introduced themselves to be the chosen
18
messengers of God, and God, along with his angels, were projected as being white. This idea
alone had the capability to spark inferiority among people with a darker complexion (Gonzalez,
2020). The hierarchy was then followed by people born from native Indio mixed with Spanish
blood, which created the Mestizo culture in the Philippines (Doran, 1993). People who are in this
category all have fairer skin tones. The bottom of the hierarchy were Indios, native to the
Philippines. They were seen as savages for having dark skin and were the most discriminated
against.
During the American Rule after the Spanish Colonial Era, this consciousness continued.
The whitewashing brought about during the time of the Americans is still very much ingrained in
the present culture and media of the Philippines. The socioeconomic beauty standard of the
Filipino society is based on the fairness of skin, resulting in the always flourishing
origins are treated with bias without any special reason other than their whiteness and so-called
beauty.
The consciousness created during the Spanish colonial rule may have contributed to the
presence of racism in our present society. However, it is not the only factor that cultivated the
racial roots in the Philippines, as the colonialism of the United States of America also played its
role. The imperialization brought about during that era created conflicts in the identity of
Filipinos. It was the ultimate motivator that birthed Filipinos' racial pride and ideals, resulting in
the current nationalism and independence that the country sees today (Cadusale, 2016).
19
2.4 Racism Against the Filipino-Chinese Community
The Chinese are one of the many migrants who have long settled in the Philippines, but
have been viewed differently by society and the colonial government. The Chinese population in
the Philippines continued to grow between the years of 1899 to 1939 because of the economic
opportunities of the country despite the passage of policies and laws towards them (Langbid and
Ngo, 2016). After the post-war from 1946 to 1975, there were 600,000 Chinese that were
accounted for in 1972 and the Philippine Government imposed no consistent policy for them. In
all of Southeast Asia, it has been stated that the most legally undigested group were the Chinese
in the Philippines (Tan, 1993 as cited in Langbid and Ngo, 2016). The emergence of the growing
Filipino nationalism caused the formation of anti-Chinese policies, but the anti-Chinese
sentiments grew largely over the years which led to the acquisition of the Philippine Citizenship
(1) The Congress under the American regime passed the Philippine act of July 1902;
(3) The naturalization of overseas Chinese through the Letter of Instruction No 270;
wherein overseas Chinese can fully exercise their rights as citizens of the country, which gave
birth to the Filipino-Chinese community (Wong, 1990 as cited in Langbid and Ngo, 2016).
Despite being citizens of the country, Filipinos have suspicions as to where the
Filipino-Chinese’s loyalty lies—if they were to spread communism in the country—and their
choice of isolation from the majority of society (Langbid, 2014 as cited in Langbid and Ngo,
2016). The locals viewed the community as a danger, something lesser than dirt as an individual,
20
and preachers of communism as a collective group. The Filipino-Chinese community has its own
culture and brought its traditions and practices to the country, which raised the locals’ suspicions.
The community’s refusal to accustom to Filipino society was the reason as to why they were
intentionally isolated by the majority of the society which led to the Chinese isolating themselves
from Filipino society by choice (Weightman, 1967 as cited in Langbid and Ngo, 2016).
Hybrid communities with different cultures are not common in the Philippines thus, the
creating their own groups separating themselves from the majority of society (Yap, 2018). The
Filipino-Chinese community is usually oppressed or bullied with the use of offensive slurs. Some
of the many racial slurs Filipinos used to mock and ridicule the community include “Intsik
wakang” and “baboy tikangkang” (Langbid and Ngo, 2016) . The research conducted by Rose F.
Langbid and Michael Anthony R. Ngo included a personal interview with a 46-year-old Chinese
During our younger years, my brother and I were sometimes the targets of jokes
from our neighbors. They call us “Intsik waking”, and we don’t even know what
that means at that time. We didn’t mind them since they were our playmates. But
sometimes other kids also tried to call us such names. (p. 81)
The commonly used term, “Intsik,” was described from the history of the Igorots of the
Cordilleras, which means “The Other” as a way of setting apart people because of their “strange
However, it was said that “Intsik” might not be a slur from the beginning because, in Hokkein, it
21
According to Ang See in 1997, there is a perception that the Filipino-Chinese in Binondo
all belong to the upper middle class, however not all of them do. This stereotyping has caused
the generalization of Filipinos in viewing the Filipino-Chinese community and has caused harm
to the Filipino-Chinese community. From the late 1980s to the mid-1990s, kidnappers targeted
Filipino-Chinese children in exchange for money, generalizing that all Chinese-Filipinos are rich
(Yap, 2018).
In the present, hatred from the Filipinos towards the Chinese has increased during
Duterte’s administration due to the President’s seeming submission to China and neglect of the
situation and continuous harassment of the West Philippine Sea. Hence, Filipinos fear losing
their sovereignty more than ever, on top of Duterte’s joke about the Philippines turning into a
province of China (Aspinwall, 2019). Hau stated in the article by Nick Aspinwall in 2019:
Many Tsinoy friends and relatives I have felt insecure, “When they go out in
public, they want to emphasize they speak Filipino… There’s a sense it’s harder
Recently, there have been instances where the Chinese-Filipino community feels
vulnerable and has to show that they do speak the Filipino language to show that they are
Filipino citizens.
The othering theory is often associated with racism. Othering is defined as a phenomenon
of complex nature that possibly differs over time, depending on how collective and
intersubjectively constructed ideologies evolve in specific contexts (Dervin, 2016). Othering can
22
relate to various identity factors - such as nationality, race, language, religion, gender, and so on.
Additionally, othering is often accompanied by the belief that some social groups are
dehumanized, as they are considered inferior. This theory may lead to racist and xenophobic acts.
According to Dervin (2016), there are various meanings of othering, depending on the
political judgment of superiority and inferiority between ‘us’ and ‘them.’ In this
and self. The other is also often described through a deficit framework, a view
that she is not as good or capable as ‘we’ are, which leads to stereotypes and other
forms of representation. This often takes place in the media, public discourses,
and even in scholarly work, as stated by Krumer-Nevo and Sidi (2012). (p. 46)
The creation of othering consists of applying a principle that allows certain races to be
classified into two hierarchical categories: them and us. The out-group is only coherent as a
group due to its opposition to the in-group and its lack of identity. This lack is based upon
stereotypes that are largely stigmatizing. The asymmetry in power relationships is central to the
construction of othering. Only the out-group is in a position to impose the value of its identity
and to devalue the particularity of the in-group while imposing corresponding discriminatory
Based on Eichelberger (2007) and Joffe (1999), people often resort to othering
stigmatized groups or other minorities in the face of a public health crisis in order to reduce the
powerlessness experienced during the threat, although disease threat can not only lead to
23
stigmatization of out-groups but can stimulate violent xenophobic reactions and discrimination
(Li & Nicholson, 2021). Othering can be applied in certain names of diseases, such as in the 15th
century, syphilis was widely known as “French pox” by the English, “Morbus Germanicus” by
the French, or “Chinese disease” by the Japanese (Joffe, 1999, as cited in Li & Nicholson, 2021).
In line with this, conservative Americans racialized the pandemic, referring to it as the “Chinese
flu” or the “Wuhan virus” in early 2020 as the number of COVID-19 cases rose in the United
States and around the world (Reny & Barreto, 2020). Seeing that COVID-19 is still present
experiences.
Synthesis
individuals or communities. Race is the determinant root of human traits and capacities that
create racial differences and produce inherent superiority as stated by Merriam Webster. It was
shown that racism is a systematic advantage between the different colors of skin. Racism is a
Racism may be divided into three categories as stated by Camara Phyllis Jones in 2000:
racism manifests itself in both tangible circumstances, such as a good education, and power,
such as money. Personally mediated racism is prejudice in which assumptions about motivations
and purpose are made based on one's race and discrimination in which one's race is treated
differently. Finally, internalized racism occurs when members of a stigmatized race accept
24
harmful messages about their own talents and values. It reflects the system’s advantages, and
may change over time based on how collective and intersubjectively created ideologies grow in
certain situations. Othering is frequently accompanied by the assumption that some social groups
have been dehumanized because they are considered inferior. Given the persistence of
COVID-19, it is probable that the Filipino-Chinese community may face similar discrimination
As there had been a difference in societal ideas, Chinese racism has been prominent
among the community and the colonial authority. Because of Filipino nationalism, anti-Chinese
policies were developed in a direct and systematic manner. It brought about changes and
problems since some individuals and communities in the Philippines were opposed to the
philosophy of transition. Intentional isolation and both systemic and direct racism were
established as a result of the reluctance to make this change. The Chinese community introduced
its own culture, customs, and practices to the Philippines, dividing the Filipino-Chinese from the
25
CHAPTER 3
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
approach to explore the lived experiences of racism among selected members of the
Filipino-Chinese community during the pandemic. It also examined the coping mechanisms that
they have during such encounters. A semi-structured interview guide was utilized to collect
relevant data. The study also collected socio-demographic profiles of our informants to provide a
The study was conducted among selected members of the Filipino-Chinese community
3.3 Instrumentation
For this study, the researchers utilized a semi-structured interview guide. The interview
guide includes different sections covering different topics. These include experiences with
racism during the pandemic, its effect on their lives, and how they were able to adjust to these
experiences.
26
Table 1
For this paper, purposive and snowball sampling was utilized. Key informants were
chosen based on the following criteria: must be Filipino-Chinese, permanent residents of the
Philippines, and currently residing in the country. Despite the COVID-19 restrictions, ethical
A list of potential key informants who fulfill the above-mentioned criteria was created
from the researchers' friends and families. These potential key informants were contacted and
requested to participate in said study. When the minimum number of informants for the study
was not reached using the list, the researchers requested referrals from said contacts. They were
27
then contacted by the researchers for their participation in the study. This process was resumed
Participants would have received an Informed Consent Form — and a Parent's Consent
Form for those below the age of eighteen — prior to the commencement of the interviews. The
Informed Consent Form contains the nature and objectives of the research, the duration of the
research, the possible risks of participating in the research, and how the data will be gathered and
treated.
A date was then arranged with each key informant for their in-depth interview. Due to the
travel restrictions, an online interview was conducted using Zoom on the agreed-upon dates. A
semi-structured interview guide was utilized for said interviews. Before beginning the interview,
the researchers were assigned with inquiring the respondents if they authorize the recording of
their responses. Once the participants consent to this, the researchers would then start the
recording, and ask them again for their consent to be recorded during documentation. After
interviewing the participants, the researchers compiled all of their notes and watched through the
recorded copy of the meeting to avoid leaving out any necessary information. The researchers
then organized their notes among the participants who have experienced racial discrimination
To analyze the data, the researchers arranged the video and audio-recorded interviews
with the use of edited transcriptions. The researchers who are fluent in Filipino and English will
28
When nothing much is identified about an issue, and the goal of the research is to grasp
and make the most fundamental meaning of a phenomenon of interest from the perspective of
(Giorgi, 1997). This approach is suitable for this study because the researchers explore the depths
of racism prevalent in and in the eyes of the Filipino-Chinese community for clarity and
awareness.
The following steps used by the researchers were derived from Roger E. Broomé’s study,
(1) The researchers assumed a phenomenological attitude which is different from the
everyday understanding of the world. It is where the researchers put aside their
community.
(2) The researchers listened to the video and audio recordings of the interview with
the participants and went over their notes to have an understanding of the
the Filipino-Chinese participants and allow the researchers to form and theorize
(3) The researchers divided the meanings of the participants into categories within the
29
statements and grouping those that express similar meanings will connect and
(4) After dividing the meanings into categories, the researchers reconstructed the
that determine the qualities which are essential and accidental. The researcher’s
(5) Lastly, the researchers created a critical synthesis based on the collected data and
30
CHAPTER 4
Based on the seven interviews that were conducted, the researchers were able to reveal
similarities of experiences between them. The different classifications made by the types of
classification of different type of discriminatorical actions. It was observed that majority among
the seven participants had experienced discrimination through name calling, which was the most
prevalent, whereas the least common sort of discrimination was growing distant. Based on the
types of coping mechanisms, each participant is shown to have different ways of coping from
each other. When presented with racial experiences, the sole commonality between Participant M
and Participant D is that they both shrug it off. The two tables below show a representation of
Types of Racism, Xenophobia, Racial Discrimination, and Racial Stereotyping Experienced and
Table 2
31
Table 3
From the interview with Participant A, she notes the tendency of receiving slurs and
mockery directed toward her Chinese ethnicity. Call signs like “Ching Chong” and mimicry of
the Chinese language accent are the ones that were mentioned. She expressed feeling degraded
as it happened frequently and was also laughed about. During the pandemic, she reported hearing
others blaming the Chinese for the virus, and people were noticeably avoiding her most likely
due to her appearance. Her househelp even told her that she takes pity on the Chinese, stating
that they are “prone to diseases”. When asked how she copes with the instances that were
mentioned, Participant A says that avoidance is her common remedy for these issues.
32
In the interview with Participant C, she mentions that the discrimination present before
COVID-19 got worse during the pandemic. In one instance, a customer immediately ran out of
the store she was shopping at after letting out a small sneeze. The reaction scared her because she
saw the amount of hate the Chinese community was getting on social media. A direct statement
from Participant C, “Hindi naman pero at some point you will feel upset. Some people could
think like that talaga na porket Chinese ka, porket may dugo kang Chinese, ano kumakain ka na
ng bats and everything na doon nakuha yung virus ganun”. When questioned if she had any
particular methods used for coping, Participant C mentions that there is none since she is already
used to the discrimination that she experiences, “No naman kasi parang ano nasanay nalang
ako.” Furthermore, she also expressed that “Nakakaya naman kasi parang nasanay na rin and
a racial experience. He was with his friend in their condominium’s elevator when a man
supposedly of Filipino descent entered. Participant D, wearing a proper face mask, let out a soft
cough which triggered a mean and glaring look from the man they were with in the elevator.
When the interviewers asked how he coped with this experience, Participant D responded, “Kasi
parang rather than being offended pero hindi ako ganon I just brush it off with a laugh.”
In the interview of Participant K, she explained that she experienced being name-called
and receiving offensive remarks by others. Her experience of racial stereotyping was when her
friend group would always joke about when it is Chinese New Year, she has to treat them for
lunch or pakain. She said that she has not received any xenophobic instances, but she has
received types of racial discrimination. She said that in terms of physical discrimination, there
33
are none, but she always recieved this joke which is “Ching Chong 1000”, and growing up for
her was difficult. She said that her coping mechanisms were just to brush it off before, but now
for her, she would stand up for what is right and stand up for herself. With regards to during the
COVID-19 pandemic, Participant K mentioned that she has yet to experience racial instances
mainly due to the reason that she receives little socialization in quarantine.
From the interview of Participant M, it can be inferred that he has experienced types of
name-calling and offensive remarks among his peers and other people. Participant M mentioned
an instance or experience with racial stereotyping through the video game, Valorant, as people
asked if he was Chinese because of his accent. Participant M noticed that they were making fun
of him by saying "Lah" after every line they said — implying the Singaporean term. Another
instance he talked about was when people would ask him if he eats dogs. He said that it was
offensive as people asked him that question even if he knows that it was a joke. When participant
M was asked if he had experienced racism during the COVID-19 pandemic and he responded by
recalling an instance during the end of 10th Grade, his classmates would create jokes at him
saying , “Oh my god, does Marvin have COVID?” He responded saying how he found it weird.
At first, he thought that it was considered normal to be afraid, but it still had a negative impact
on his daily life. When the researchers asked him if he used any certain coping mechanisms for
the matter, he mentioned sleeping and shrugging it off. He says that it helps take it down a notch,
but for other people, it is possible that they can be more offended a lot more than him.
In the interview with Participant R, it was observed that he received name calling and
offensive actions based on his experiences. He said that the instances that he was racially
stereotyped is when people would say he is good in math just because he was Chinese, he also
34
notably said that people would avoid just because of his nationality. During the pandemic, he
gave an experience of when he rode a jeepney and he said that people were ignoring him when
he was asking for help to pass his payment to the driver in front. He specifically said,
“As for me naman, while I was trying to pass on yung bayad ko sa jeep, the
people in the front wouldn’t budge, like they literally wouldn’t - you know like nakalabas
na yung kamay ko. ‘Nakikisuyo po’, I said. And everybody just ignored me, and I had to
resort to literally walking through the middle of the jeepney while it was moving to pass
on my bayad.”
He observed that it was a case of racial discrimination because he saw another person
who came by after him that did not look Chinese pass his payment and everybody that was in his
row helped him. When the researchers asked Participant R what was the coping mechanism that
helped, Participant R said that listening to music and singing were the coping mechanisms that
helped.
other people. He stated that he was racially stereotyped as people assumed that he is good in
mathematics and business just because he is Chinese. He said an instance of racial discrimination
was experienced during the pandemic. Public school pupils taunted him for speaking Chinese
and coughing in front of him and his companions, implying that COVID-19 was circulated by
Chinese people. When asked what his coping mechanism was, he said he thinks positively, and
avoids dwelling on the thought too much in order to have fewer negative emotions.
35
CHAPTER 5
This phenomenological study is about the lived experiences of the selected members of
the Filipino-Chinese community regarding their experiences on racism before and during the
pandemic. It also aims to describe the situations on how they experienced racial discrimination,
how these affected them, and how they coped with such incidents. The researchers conducted an
interview with the seven Filipino-Chinese participants learning about their experiences with
racism, racial discrimination, racial stereotypes, xenophobia, and their coping mechanisms.
Results showed that all the participants have experienced racism. The findings in this
study reveal that the majority of the participants have experienced name-calling, followed by a
tie among receiving offensive remarks, offensive actions, and mimicking or mocking, and lastly,
through offensive jokes and mimicking or mocking. Apart from their experiences with racism,
findings show that the participants’ coping mechanisms vary from one another except for
individual efforts, given that it has been deeply integrated within society for years. When the
pandemic struck, racism was focused on the Filipino-Chinese in the Philippines. With this, much
observation has been given to propose that more multicultural studies should be done and given
light in order to educate the masses. The researchers recommend that racism and its various
aspects are to be taught in certain classes such as Values Education, Personal Development,
Physical Education & Health, and other related courses. Aside from educational institutions,
work institutions are also recommended to provide and practice proper regulations to avoid
36
similar experiences within their diverse communities and their clients or products. Moreover,
racism should be given importance and taken into consideration by lawmakers by providing the
necessary assistance and legislations needed for those experiencing high levels of abuse.
remarks, jokes, and many more regarding racism should be punishable by law depending on the
severity of the situation in the near future to protect people of all races and promote inclusivity.
Several procedures have been made to improve the study’s reliability, although ample
consideration should be observed in analyzing the findings. The minority of respondents and
homogeneity of the participants that engaged restricts the capacity to extrapolate the findings of
this study. The present investigation's technique combines individual accounts in order to find
common links among the seven individuals. Given the exploratory character of this study, the
the Filipino-Chinese community's lived experiences. Future studies under this field may be able
37
REFERENCES
Addo I. Y. (2020). Double pandemic: racial discrimination amid coronavirus disease 2019.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssaho.2020.100074
Alvarez, A. N., Juang, L., & Liang, C. T. H. (2006). Asian Americans and racism: When bad
Psychology. https://dictionary.apa.org/coping-mechanism
Ang See, Teresita. "The Chinese Filipinos as Manilans." The Ethnic Chinese as Filipinos Part II:
Ang See, Teresita, Caroline Hau, and Joaquin Sy, editors.Voices - Mga Tinig; The Best of Tulay.
Aspinwall, N. (2019, June 6). “We are Filipinos, and we hate China”: China’s influence in the
https://supchina.com/2019/06/06/we-are-filipinos-and-we-hate-china-backlash-against-t
sinoys/
Australian Human Rights Commission. (2019). Know your rights: Racial discrimination and
vilification.https://humanrights.gov.au/our-work/race-discrimination/publications/know
-your-rights-racial-discrimination-and-vilification
38
Broomé, R. E. (2011, November). DESCRIPTIVE PHENOMENOLOGICAL PSYCHOLOGICAL
https://phenomenologyblog.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/04/Broome-2011-Phenomenologica
l-Psychological-Dissertation-Method-Chapter.pdf
Cabreza, V. (2014, January 31). Is ‘Intsik’ a racial slur? Chinese-Filipino prof in US says it’s
not. INQUIRER.net.
https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/571793/is-intsik-a-racial-slur-chinese-filipino-prof-in-us-s
ays-its-not
Chua, D. A. (2004). From Chinese to Filipino : Changing identities of the Chinese in the
https://open.library.ubc.ca/cIRcle/collections/ubctheses/831/items/1.0091702
Clair, M., & Denis, J. S. (2015). Sociology of Racism. The International Encyclopedia of the
https://projects.iq.harvard.edu/files/deib-explorer/files/sociology_of_racism.pdf
https://www.refworld.org/pdfid/55b207ae4.pdf
https://www.verywellmind.com/the-psychology-of-racism-5070459
39
Dada Docot. (2020, June 23). [OPINION] Anti-Black attitudes among Filipinos, in the context of
https://www.rappler.com/voices/ispeak/opinion-anti-black-attitudes-filipinos-united-stat
es-empire
Dela Cruz, N. (2015). Who Counts as Filipino? Philosophical Issues of Identity and the
https://doi.org/10.13185/2249
https://doi.org/10.1057/978-1-137-54544-2_4
https://www.dictionary.com/browse/xenophobia
Formplus Blog. (2021, May 24). Socio-demographic: Definition & examples in surveys. Create
https://www.formpl.us/blog/socio-demographics
Giorgi, A. (1997). The theory, practice, and evaluation of the phenomenological method as a
Gonzalez, M. (2020, July 8). Positively Filipino | Online Magazine for Filipinos in the
http://www.positivelyfilipino.com/magazine/the-colonial-legacy-of-racism-among-filip
inos
Good Therapy. (2016, August 4). Coping mechanisms. GoodTherapy.org Therapy Blog.
https://www.goodtherapy.org/blog/psychpedia/coping-mechanisms
40
Goering, S. (2014). Eugenics (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). Stanford.edu.
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/eugenics/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1446334/pdf/10936998.pdf
Kohli, R. (2013). Unpacking internalized racism: teachers of color striving for racially just
doi:10.1080/13613324.2013.8329
Langbid, R.F. (2014). The Filipino-Chinese Families in Tubod, Lanao del Norte: A History of
the Trials and Triumphs in their New Community (Undergraduate Thesis, Mindanao
Langbid, R. F., & Ngo, M. R. (2016). A glimpse into the anatomy of the tribulations and
https://iafor.org/journal/iafor-journal-of-the-social-sciences/volume-2-issue-2/article-6/
Li, Y. and Nicholson, H.L., Jr. (2021), When “model minorities” become “yellow
McWhorter, J. (2020, June 22). The dictionary definition of 'Racism' has to change. The
Atlantic.
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/06/dictionary-definition-racism-has-ch
ange/613324/
41
Morin, A. (2020, July 31). How much damage can racial stereotyping cause? Verywell Mind.
https://www.verywellmind.com/harmful-psychological-effects-of-racial-stereotyping-5
069394
Mosse, G. L. (1995). Racism and nationalism. Nations and Nationalism, 1(2), 163-173.
Discrimination for Filipino and Chinese Americans: Implications for Mental Health.
https://eaop.ucsd.edu/198/group-identity/Ethnic%20group%20membership,%20phenot
ype,%20and%20perceptions%20of%20racial%20discrimination%20for%20Filipino%2
0and%20Chinese%20Americans.pdf
Price, S. (2020, July 17). Learning Together: Where Did Racism Begin? Undergraduate
https://admissions.nd.edu/visit-engage/stories-news/learning-together-where-did-racism-b
egin/
Rich, M. (2020, February 13). As coronavirus spreads, so does Anti-Chinese sentiment. The
New York Times - Breaking News, US News, World News and Videos.
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/30/world/asia/coronavirus-chinese-racism.html
ReachOut Australia. (2021). Understanding racism and how to spot it. Welcome to
https://au.reachout.com/articles/what-is-racism-and-how-to-spot-it?fbclid=IwAR1esjL
VxFNiOkoayUKmQKT2L4xs5WNxEv4TMOnu6SCpg5dsSUT889GYbno
42
Reny, T. T., & Barreto, M. A. (2020). Xenophobia in the time of pandemic: othering, anti-Asian
https://doi.org/10.1080/21565503.2020.1769693
https://scienceinpoland.pap.pl/en/news/news%2C32715%2Cresearcher-slavery-was-com
mon-medieval-europe.html
Salter, P. S., Adams, G., & Perez, M. J. (2017). Racism in the Structure of Everyday Worlds: A
150–155. https://doi.org/10.1177/0963721417724239
Tan, S.V. (1993). The Education of the Chinese in the Philippines and Koreans in Japan
hub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/40348/1/Fulltext.pdf?accept=1
Tiu, C. (2020, February 4). [Opinion] a Chinese-Filipino teen speaks out on racism and
https://www.rappler.com/voices/ispeak/opinion-chinese-filipino-teen-racism-coronavirus
Tougas, F., Desruisseaux, J.-C., Desrochers, A., St-Pierre, L., Perrino, A., & de la Sablonnière,
R. (2004). Two Forms of Racism and Their Related Outcomes: The Bad and the Ugly.
Weightman, G.H. (1967). Anti-Sinicism in the Philippines. Asian Studies Journal V: 220-231.
43
What is Racism? | Australian Human Rights Commission. (2021). Humanrights.gov.au.
https://humanrights.gov.au/our-work/race-discrimination/what-racism
WHENINMANILA. (2014, April 12). Philippines named as one of the most racist countries in
https://www.wheninmanila.com/philippines-named-as-one-of-the-most-racist-countries
-in-the-world/
Wong Kwok-Chu (1999). The Chinese in the Philippine Economy 1898-1941. Quezon City,
Yap, J. P. (2018). The Troubled Dual Construction of Ethnicity of Recent Chinese Migrants and
44
APPENDIX I
List of Figures
List of Tables
45
Table 2 - Types of Racism, Xenophobia, Racial Discrimination, and Racial Stereotypes
Experienced
46
Table 3 - Types of Coping Mechanisms
47
APPENDIX II
48
APPENDIX III
The Filipinos and the Filipino-Chinese. The research will provide them a venue to share their
personal experiences on racial issues and thus contribute to raising awareness on such matters.
The Government. The study can provide policymakers insights into how racism is experienced
in the country, which can then be used as a resource to craft programs and guidelines to prevent
its perpetuation.
Future Researchers. Results from this study can provide future researchers with new and untold
information which could contribute to their research.
STUDY PROCEDURES
49
These are the steps the researchers will apply during the interview:
(1) The participants will be contacted by one of the researchers if they are willing to
participate in the study.
(2) If the participant agrees to participate, they will be asked to sign the informed consent
form and a Parent’s consent form to be signed by the minor’s parents or legal guardian.
(3) During the meeting, the researchers will ask the participants if they consent to recording
the interview. If they consent, the researchers will ask again if they consent to recording
during documentation.
These are the steps the researchers will apply during data gathering:
(1) The researchers will listen to the video and audio recordings once again to have a better
understanding of the meanings of the participants.
(2) When applying imaginative variation, the researchers will not change the meanings of the
participants.
DURATION
As a participant, it is expected that you will be allotting a certain amount of time for the study’s
progression. The interview to be held in the Zoom application will require at least 45 minutes for
the complete set of questions to be answered.
VOLUNTARY PARTICIPATION
Your participation in this study is voluntary. It is up to you whether or not you decide to
participate. If you decide to participate, you will be asked to sign this consent form. After you
sign this consent form, you are still free to withdraw at any time and without giving a reason.
Withdrawing from this study will not affect the relationship you have, if any, with the researcher
and not bring you any sanction. If you withdraw from the study before data collection is
completed, your data will be destroyed. You are also entitled to review their remarks in
individual interviews and erase a part or all of the recording or note.
RISKS
Risks to those who will participate are extremely low. The foreseeable risks as a participant of
our study may include:
1. A participant may find themselves challenged by questions or ideas they had not
considered beforehand.
2. A participant recalling a racial incident that has happened to them may cause stress,
anxiety, emotional distress, and/or physical discomfort.
50
To minimize these, we practice ethical considerations and proper handling of these situations to
the best of our ability. You may decline to answer any or all questions and you may withdraw
your participation at any time if you choose.
BENEFITS
There will be no direct benefit to your participation in the study. Participants will have the
opportunity to reflect on, share, and become more aware of their thoughts and feelings about
their personal experiences. However, we hope that the information from this study may
positively influence the treatment towards the Filipino-Chinese community.
CONFIDENTIALITY
Your responses in this research will be anonymous. Every effort will be made by the researcher
to preserve your confidentiality, including the following:
1. Assigning codes/pseudonyms for participants that will be used on all research notes
and documents.
2. Keeping notes, interview transcriptions, and any other personal identifiers in a secure
Google Drive folder that only the researchers will have access to.
3. Deleting all records after three months after the final defense.
CONTACT INFORMATION
This study was approved by the Research Ethics Review Committee of De La Salle University. If
you have any questions at any time about this study, or if you experience any non-normative
sensations as a result of participation, you may contact the researcher whose contact information
is on the first page. If you have any questions regarding your rights as a research participant, or if
problems arise which you do not feel you can discuss with the Principal Investigator, please feel
free to contact the Director of the Research Ethics Office, Dr. Nelson B. Arboleda, Jr., at
[email protected] or by calling (632) 524-4611 local 513.
_______________________________________________________
CONSENT
I have read the provided information, or it has been read to me. I have had the opportunity to ask
questions about it and any questions I have been asked have been answered to my satisfaction. I
51
understand that I will be given a copy of this form, and the researcher will keep another copy on
file. I consent voluntarily to be a participant in this study.
If you are under the age of 18, we require your parent or legal guardian’s consent.
I, the undersigned, certify that I am the parent or legal guardian of the participant. I hereby
consent to the aforementioned child participating in the activities concerning this study. I have
read thoroughly and acknowledged all the information stated above.
52
APPENDIX IV
1. What is your sex assigned at birth, marital status, educational attainment, religious
belief/affiliation?
2. Have you experienced racial stereotyping? How? What were these stereotypes?
4. Have you experienced racial discrimination? How? What were the instances that you
5. What are your coping mechanisms when you experience racial discrimination? Were they
6. Do you have experiences of racism during the COVID-19 pandemic? If so, what are
they? Are there any differences between your experiences of racism before and during the
7. Have these racial stereotypes affected your experiences with racial discrimination? How?
9. Does the kind of racial discrimination you experienced affect your coping mechanism? In
what way?
53