Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Strategic Management of Human Capital
Strategic Management of Human Capital
VENKATESH GANAPATHY
STRATEGIC
MANAGEMENT OF
HUMAN CAPITAL
2
Strategic Management of Human Capital
1st edition
© 2018 Venkatesh Ganapathy & bookboon.com
ISBN 978-87-403-2036-7
Peer review by Ganapathy Dharmarajan, Director, Vega Cylinders, Mumbai
3
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Contents
CONTENTS
Acknowledgements 7
8 HR in small organizations 28
Month 16
I was a construction Mo
supervisor ina const
I was
the North Sea super
advising and the No
Real work he
helping foremen advis
International
al opportunities
Internationa
�ree wo
work
or placements ssolve problems
Real work he
helping fo
International
Internationaal opportunities
�ree wo
work
or placements ssolve pr
4
4
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Contents
15 Abusive leadership 55
18 Level 5 leadership 63
20 Servant leadership 71
21 Micromanagement kills 74
24 Induction program 80
28 Placement agencies 89
29 Bespoke headhunting 91
5
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Contents
References 168
6
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Acknowledgements
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This book is a result of my efforts spread over the last two years. A lot of people contributed
in no small measure to ensure that the book was completed on time. I must admit that
my family has been a great support as most of my personal time was invested in this
endeavor. Though I am not a HR practitioner, the seeds of my interest in HR were sown
just by observing my father Mr. D Ganapathy who has been a HR practitioner for more
than 50 years now. He has worked for organizations like Colgate Palmolive India Limited,
Associated Cements Corporation and DCW Limited. He is also a renowned head hunter
and an Industrial relations expert. This book is primarily dedicated to him.
I must thank Dr Brahm Sharma, Dr MJ Arul and Dr Radha Padmanabhan for helping me
learn the various facets of leadership in academic institutions. Dr Radha, present Director
of our management institution has a very unique leadership style that is inspiring and
invigorating. Her leadership always brims with positivity and cheer. Her dedication and
commitment to her profession are truly exemplary and worth emulating.
I would also like to thank three of my dear colleagues who, though junior to me in age,
are leap years ahead of me in terms of their academic experience, wit and wisdom. I would
like to thank Dr Irshad Nazeer for suggesting the title of this book. Thanks are also due to
Dr R Venkatraman, Dean-Presidency Business School for always encouraging and motivating
me. His people-centric leadership style and cherubic demeanor can convert the most dull,
morbid and insipid environment into a lively one. Thanks Dr Chandan Chavadi for teaching
me some of the virtues in life. Thanks for helping me reconnect with research after so many
years. Your willingness to lead, help others and taking initiatives to enrich the institution’s
intellectual capacity deserve commendation of the highest order. I am yet to see someone
who is as passionate about research as Dr Chandan.
Thanks are also due to Karin and her editorial team for the excellent support that they provided.
Last but not the least I would like to express my heartfelt thanks to Dr Nissar Ahmed,
Chairman, Presidency Group of Institutions, India. His encouragement and support have
always enabled me to raise the bar of excellence from time to time.
7
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL What is human capital management
Learning objectives:
1. To understand the concept of human capital management.
2. To identify the need for a human capital strategy.
3. To learn about the different types of human capital.
Business environment is highly turbulent today. Organizations build their own core resources
to achieve competitive edge. But this can be transitory. Employee’s individual and collective
learning, knowledge, skills and expertise, creativity and innovation lead to accumulation of
human capital. Accumulation of individual and collective knowledge is essential to meet
customer needs. Human capital is thus a key intangible form of value creation.
Human capital pool is highly skilled and motivated work force that has greater potential to
be a source of competitive advantage. Human capital pool must have both high levels of skill
and willingness to exhibit productive behavior. The advantage of human capital is that it is
a stock of exceptional human talent with latent productive capabilities (Fida Afiouni, 2009).
Coherent results oriented human capital program is essential. Human capital management is
not about top down decision making as it can cause adversarial relations between management
8
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL What is human capital management
and employees. Not reacting to workplace disputes or inability to resolve long standing
sources of conflict can be dampeners.
Collaborative work will ensure minimum conflicts. Even if there are conflicts they need
to be addressed fairly and efficiently. An inclusive workforce is a competitive advantage
for achieving results. The work culture has to be results oriented, externally focused and
individual performance must be fully integrated into the organization’s goals.
Performance management and rewards system are important for achieving strategic goals
and objectives. Clearly defined, transparent and consistently communicated performance
expectations addressing a range of results go a long way in ensuring success of a human
capital management program.
Formal human capital planning is important. There is a need for sustained commitment to
strategically manage human capital and support efforts to integrate human capital approaches
with our organizational goals. Refining HCM goals with respect to changing organizational
needs and the demonstrated successes of human capital efforts will lead to true success.
For employees to be empowered, they need to be engaged. Optimum alignment between
workforce and mission is essential. The human capital management strategy has to be
integrated into strategic plans, performance plans and budgets.
If resources are not upgraded and developed on a regular basis then they decline/diminish.
Business capacity to produce extra customer will lead to instant learning and increasing
application of knowledge to work by its people. Employees should learn and know about
company’s competitive business environment and this will lead to productive behaviors.
9
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL What is human capital management
1. Idiosyncratic.
2. Ancillary.
3. Core.
4. Compulsory.
This type of capital links with relational and organizational capital to increase performance of
this form of human capital through collaboration, team building and group based rewards.
Ancillary
Low value, Low uniqueness
Core
High value, high uniqueness
Companies should develop and maximize its value creating potential and differentiating
characteristics. Commitment based HR systems and developmental performance appraisals
to build specific knowledge and competitiveness.
10
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL What is human capital management
Organizations do not invest in human capital. This capital is not specific to any one company.
Employees are free within certain limits to sell their talents wherever they can achieve the
higher return. Organizations can organize the staffing process such that potential employees
can be identified to increase productivity.
Focus of human capital has to be sharper, broader and deeper to develop, retain and sustain
competitiveness of enterprise. Focus of HR has to be on developing employee’s working skills.
Human capital has to develop employee’s capabilities and help employees learn from mistakes.
Even high level of HRM and development practices lead to serious strategic and cognitive
failures by missing the focus of human capital. Ford, General Motors and Chrysler failed
to see the increasing threat of Japanese competition. What Sears failed to do, Walmart did
and tasted phenomenal success. IBM was late in entering the PC market.
Apple capitalized on Xerox’s R&D. Xerox missed out on the PC revolution. Compaq missed
the opportunity of JIT assembly of PCs as a result it was done by Dell with outstanding
success. People are the ultimate resource of an organization. Therefore, the ability of
enterprises to compete in highly competitive markets, creation of value added products and
services depend on employee’s accumulation of knowledge and capabilities – this depends
on effectiveness of human capital.
11
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Scope of human capital management
Learning objectives:
• To understand the scope of human capital management.
• To learn about the essentials of strategic human capital management.
• To identify the challenges associated with human capital management.
Knowledge, skills, attributes and brainpower that an employee possesses are viewed as the
organization’s human capital. The collective composition of an organization’s human capital
is considered a key strategic business advantage. Human capital defines and categorizes a
person’s embodied knowledge, health, skills and abilities as they affect production, exchange
and entrepreneurship as well as disembodied human knowledge as reflected in publications,
patents and other forms of intellectual capital that contribute to the formation and transfer
of new knowledge and innovation (Rainke, 2015).
Business strategy should also be shaped at times by people management strategy rather
than solely the other way round. Employee value proposition refers to what an individual
employee can expect to receive in return for his/her contribution (Rainke, 2015).
People are an agency’s most important organizational asset. An organization’s people define its
character, affect its capacity to perform and represent the knowledge base of the organization.
Effective strategic human capital management approaches serve as the cornerstone of any
serious change management initiative. Therefore organizations must become less hierarchical,
process oriented, stove piped and inwardly focused (Walker, 2002). The more flat an
organization is, it can become results oriented, integrated and externally focused. Shortfalls
in human capital will erode ability of an organization.
12
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Scope of human capital management
The critical success factors for managing human capital are interrelated and mutually
reinforcing. Compartmentalization of human capital issues is not advisable. These issues
cannot be dealt with in isolation from one another.
360°
thinking .
360°
thinking .
Two principles that are central to the human capital idea are:
1. People are assets whose value can be enhanced through investment. The goal is to
maximize value while managing risk and incompetence. Training is essential.
2. An organization’s human capital approaches should be designed, implemented and
assessed by the standard of how well they enable the organization to achieve results
and pursue its mission.
14
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Scope of human capital management
Modifying incentive structures to consider the long term impact of human capital management
decisions is vital. The organization must step up efforts to propagate an environment of
continuous learning.
15
15
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Need for human capital management
Learning objectives:
• To understand the purpose of a strategic approach to human capital management.
• To learn about human asset worth.
An organization’s human capital is the holder of tacit knowledge. As human capital grows, there
is stronger basis for organization to develop competitive advantage. Without human capital,
organization cannot innovate or develop strategic relationships (Adnan, Shah & Ahmad).
Human capital function has to strive hard to increase productivity of employees. Human
capital can be considered a production factor. Experience, exposure and training of employees
lead to further increase in productivity (Alzbeta, Emese & Martina, 2014).
Human capital management lays greater emphasis on current knowledge, their systematic
development and strengthening. Human capital management represents an organization’s
ability to maximize the use and share the potential of people both for every day work and
innovation. This includes a variety of processes and different management methods to work
with people and their development in the organization. Human capital management improves
performance of an organization and its employees (Alzbeta, Emese & Martina, 2014).
HCM leads to a productive and engaged work force, hiring the right talent, orienting
employee to the organization, making a new employee feel comfortable, training employees
to constantly upgrade their skills, retain employees, make employees self-sufficient and
prepare them for adverse conditions (Alzbeta, Emese & Martina, 2014).
16
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Need for human capital management
17
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Benefits of a HCM approach
Learning objectives:
• To identify the strategic benefits of a human capital management approach.
• To understand how a human capital approach can lead to an increase in productivity.
• To learn the correlation between an organization’s human capital and its performance.
Employees add value to a business. Human capital management is the strategy by which
this value can be leveraged to grow the business and make it profitable. The primary goal
of HCM is to streamline the process of recruiting, retaining and cultivating the best talent.
Reference
https://selecthub.com/hris/benefits-human-capital-management-strategy/
18
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Knowledge management and human capital management
5 KNOWLEDGE MANAGEMENT
AND HUMAN CAPITAL
MANAGEMENT
Learning objectives:
• To learn about knowledge management and its significance.
• To understand the correlation between knowledge management and human capital
management.
• To identify the essential pillars of a human capital strategy.
• To learn about the functions of knowledge management.
Organizations are realizing that knowledge management should play an important role in
human capital strategy. Learning and knowledge management pillar is part of the framework
in building a human capital strategy. Companies are creating positions like Chief Human
Resource Officer, Chief Learning Officer, and Chief Belief Officer to give importance to
19
19
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Knowledge management and human capital management
strategic human capital management. The challenge is – how best to integrate knowledge
management within the strategic management of human capital (Liebowitz, 2004).
Nourishing the roots of an organization (the human capital/the people) must occur if
the organization is to blossom and bear fruit. Human capital is the collective experience,
knowledge and expertise of those contributing to an organization’s mission. Knowledge
management refers to how best the knowledge within an organization can be leveraged
internally and externally to achieve organizational success.
The four essential pillars of a human capital strategy are (Liebowitz, 2004):
All the four pillars are interrelated and provide a foundation for building a human capital
strategy in the organization.
1. Knowledge identification.
2. Knowledge sharing.
3. Knowledge application.
4. Knowledge creation.
Once critical ‘at risk” knowledge is identified, this knowledge has to be captured and shared
with others; once knowledge is applied and internalized, new ideas should be generated.
Knowledge gaps are determined to identify leakages where critical at risk knowledge is lost
due to retirement, attrition and organizational transfers.
20
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Knowledge management and human capital management
To minimize the loss of knowledge we need to connect people with others via mentoring,
knowledge sharing forums, story-telling, shadowing, communities of practice, expertise
locator system etc. to transfer this valuable knowledge. This will strengthen relationships
leading to an increased sense of belonging and community in the organization. New ideas
will thus be generated. In the near future, organizations will be in a tenuous position if they
do not take knowledge management and human capital management seriously. Integrative
roles of knowledge management and human capital management strategies will ensure
that they influence each other to meet the strategic mission and vision of the organization
(Liebowitz, 2004).
Knowledge and expertise which employees develop in due course of time to further increase
the productivity of organizations refer to human capital. Employees sharpen skills over time.
Human capital represents stock of skills, knowledge and expertise of employees and this is
what plays an integral role in enhancing the productivity of employees (Alzbeta, Emese &
Martina, 2014).
How to disseminate the knowledge to those who need it? Success of any knowledge
management effort depends on having suitably motivated people to take an active role in
the process. Intellectual capital can lead to competitive advantage in a knowledge economy.
Therefore people management must become an integral part of corporate strategy and a
key responsibility of all managers. Human capital is the most important form of wealth
(Fida Afiouni, 2009).
Value represents the personnel knowledge into knowledge management systems that
organizations create and use. Origins of the notion of human capital can be attributed to the
work of Prahlad and Hamel (1990). They analyzed the competitiveness of organizations and
attributed this to core competencies. Human capital can be one of the core competencies of
an organization. Organization is nothing but a collection of competencies. Understanding
which knowledge is important and is of greater value is more important (Fida Afiouni, 2009).
Organizations have to strive to build their ‘organizational intelligence’ which is the collective
assemblage of all intelligences that contribute towards building a shared vision, renewal
process and direction for the entity.
21
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Knowledge management and human capital management
Knowledge management and sharing of knowledge will increase innovation and lead to
the creation of a learning organization. This will require creation of new organizational
structures. Organizations that are able to stimulate and improve the knowledge of their
human capital are much more prepared to face today’s rapid changes.
Innovation processes are becoming more interactive and more dependent on knowledge that
is widely distributed. Therefore knowledge management is central to strategic management
of human capital.
The strategic human capital planning approach involves forecasting human capital requirements,
analyzing them, developing and implementing them and finally evaluating them. Forecasting
involves attempting to understand what needs immediate attention and the current and
proposed challenges for meeting business priorities and predicting the future workforce
trends/demographics.
22
22
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Knowledge management and human capital management
-- What do we need?
-- What do we have?
-- What are gaps?
Develop and implementation phase indicates what we should be doing to meet organizational
goals and objectives. Evaluate phase involves asking questions like:
1. Customer/stakeholder.
2. Internal business process.
3. Financial.
4. Employee and organizational capacity.
All these factors are intertwined to complement each other to achieve overall organizational
goals and objectives. How can you hire, retain, train, develop, recognize and reward public
employees in ways that support overall strategic goals and objectives. Assessment of personnel
skills and competency needs is essential.
Human capital functions require monitoring and evaluation to attract, retain, develop and
motivate people. Strategic investments in human capital directly affect the capacity of an
organization to operate more efficiently and effectively.
Reimbursement of tuition fees for employees willing to pursue additional degrees will lead
to a more educated work force and will eventually benefit the organization.
Treat your employees as assets so that your financial assets are always more than your
liabilities. Increased emphasis on knowledge management has led companies to build a
knowledge sharing culture. Increased usage of recent retirees, term appointments, university
23
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Knowledge management and human capital management
and corporate relationships and outsourcing will promote a results-oriented, customer service
centric culture. Companies should know what kind of resources to outsource.
HRM function has narrow operational boundaries and needs to expand to look both within
and outside the organization. Human resource activities and knowledge management can
lead to a favorable learning environment and increase organizational performance (Fida
Afiouni, 2009).
24
24
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Differences between HRM and HCM
6 DIFFERENCES BETWEEN
HRM AND HCM
Learning objectives:
• To identify the key differences between human resource management and human
capital management.
• To understand the benefits of distinguishing between both the approaches.
• To learn about the link between human capital management and innovative potential
of employees.
In 1991, Barney wrote a seminal article on resource based view and made the theory very
popular. The resource based view examines the manner in which organizational resources
are applied and combined, the causes that determine the attainment of a sustainable
competitive advantage and the nature of rents generated by organizational resources. Firm
is accumulation of unique resources of a diverse nature. Collective knowledge of employees
is a key competitive tool from which innovation can emerge; organizations are supporting
collaboration between people (Fida Afiouni, 2009).
25
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL The HCM versus HRM dilemma
Learning objectives:
• To understand the practical benefits of treating employees as human assets.
• To appreciate the fact that without treating people as assets, employee engagement
is seldom an uphill task.
A recent report by Pricewaterhouse Coopers says that the way people are treated during an
economic recession affects the long term sustainability of the business. In the traditional sense,
the HRM discipline has treated human beings as resources – as a factor of production. But
contemporary world believes that human beings grow in competence as they age. Capital
grows as profits are pooled back into it. Treating employees as assets who deliver strategic
value to an organization is the right way to manage talent.
Organizations cannot talk about employee engagement if they are ruthless in implementing
a “hire and fire” policy. Rakhi Gupta, a HR executive in a software firm says, “The
moment the word is out that jobs are going to be cut, panic spreads in the organization
and productivity goes for a downward spiral”. Muralidhar adds a word of caution “It is
a classic case of taking the horse to the water. Firms may treat their employees as human
capital but there is only so much an organization can do. Beyond that an employee has to
manage his career all by himself ”.
But the truth is also that in many organizations, there is very limited autonomy and freedom
enjoyed by the HR department. In fact, the word HR itself is expanded to mean – human
resource. A resource is something that depreciates in value as it gets used up but so is not
the case with human beings. Human beings can sharpen their learning curve with time – but
there is a catch here. Employees need to have the intent to learn and grow their skill sets.
But the situation is gradually changing. The HR function, in many progressive firms, is
playing a key role in formulating a strategy for the organization.
26
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL The HCM versus HRM dilemma
With the advent of globalization, international human resource management has shot into
prominence. Cultural differences need a careful consideration. The role of a global HR
manager is more complex and all pervasive. Treatment of employees as assets has even
become even more relevant in the era of secondments and foreign job postings.
Says Rakhi, “Organizations wishing to follow the HCM approach need to adopt a strategic
outlook. This can help improve productivity which in any case is going to benefit the
organization. HR will eventually become a consulting function”.
During a downturn a business faces the heat and is forced to cut down spending on training,
recruitment and pay awards. But there are better ways of achieving operational efficiency.
Muralidhar says, “One thing that is very confounding is that during an economic recession,
the pay cuts are always for the low-tier and mid-tier executives. The top team should also
lead the way, but seldom does this happen”.
So long as the human capital strategy is aligned with the overall growth strategy of the
business, success will continue to elude businesses. The need of the hour is to encourage
a culture of adaptability within the organization and leverage technology to develop smart
HR practices.
Any dilemma regarding HCM or HRM can be easily resolved by looking at the corporate
strategy that is often shaped and reshaped by the vision and mission of an organization.
Despite advances in technology, people will continue to play a greater role in scripting the
success stories of organizations.
27
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL HR in small organizations
8 HR IN SMALL ORGANIZATIONS
Learning objective:
This chapter will dovetail the challenges of managing human resources in small scale
organizations.
Mahipal Sharma (not his real name) had put in his papers at a real estate firm and he was
ecstatic about joining a start up firm in the IT domain. The prospects appeared bright.
He was offered the role of HR Director and a salary that was 40% higher than what he
was drawing at the real estate firm. Unfortunately, the honeymoon was over even before it
began. Mahipal put in his papers within 3 months and was asked to stay back for 2 more
months to help with the transition.
So, what happened? May be it was a wrong decision. The role of the HR director in this
firm was ceremonial. Mahipal did not have much to do in the new firm. Even though 3
months is too short a time, Mahipal realized the writing on the wall much earlier. He was
lucky. The company went bust exactly 24 months later. There was a marked difference
28
28
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL HR in small organizations
between what the headhunter had told him in the briefing sessions and what he actually
experienced in the organization.
Of course not all organizations are like the one that was described above. There are small
organizations that have grown in stature and size. Infosys, Wipro, Mind Tree, Flipkart
began on a smaller note and then they developed their businesses and scaled new heights.
A HR manager who has worked in established organizations must be chary about moving to
a start up if he is not willing to let go of his ego or if he is unwilling to change and adapt
to the new work situation. More than thinking about what he can do for the firm, it will
be better if he asks the top management what is expected of him. In any case, recruitment
decisions in small firms are made by top management.
HR has to merely source the right candidate and provide the platform for the candidate
to meet the top management. Once a candidate is selected, HR has to step in with the
joining formalities, induction and training. Any HR manager who aspires to do something
more than this in a small firm is likely to face resistance from different quarters – more
so from the top management. Once the top team feels that this HR director is not on the
same page as them, they will not lose much time before asking the incumbent to go. If
the incumbent is shrewd and smart, he would have already plotted his way out before any
such eventuality.
The other problem in small firms is that most employees have a direct access to the top
management team. So, if the HR manager is not proactive enough then this can lead to
lots of uncomfortable situations. The most important aspect of success in working for
such firms is that the HR manager/director must learn to speak the language of the top
team. Dealing with people is never easy. It is an art. It is even more a challenge in case of
small firms. The open door policy is often abused in such small organizations often with
connivance of people at the top [even though this may be unintentional].
Someone who is bursting with new ideas that can be implemented in such small organizations
may be in for a big disappointment. Such firms are more interested in maintaining the
29
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL HR in small organizations
status quo. Each and every idea will need the buy-in of the top team which can be quite
frustrating and claustrophobic in the long run. A thorough home work before joining such
firms can be extremely rewarding for one’s career.
Cynics may say that Mahipal quit the firm may be like a coward instead of fighting it
out. But sometimes there is absolutely no point in fighting a losing battle. If you can’t
change others, it is better to change yourselves. Adaptability and change management are
important. In such firms, HR is considered more of a back office function that has to follow
the dictates of the top team. The sooner a HR director in a smaller firm realizes this, the
better. Joining an organization with a higher pay packet is no great deal. Survival is more
important in the long-run.
30
30
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Trends in human capital management
9 TRENDS IN HUMAN
CAPITAL MANAGEMENT
Learning objectives:
• To understand the process of developing human capital in organizations.
• To learn about the significant future trends in human capital management.
• To identify the impact of digital trends on the HR function.
For instance, HCL a global technology and IT Enterprise that operates in 31 countries
believes that their employees are more important than their customers. They believe that if
the employees are happy then they will be more productive and this will make the customers
happy. Therefore it is the responsibility of the organizations to compensate employees not
only in terms of handsome salaries and perquisites but also with development programs so
that the learning curve of employees improves.
India ranks 78th on human capital index according to the information published by the
World Economic Forum on October 1, 2013. India has been placed at a low slot out of
122 countries on a global Human Capital Index, which ranks countries on the basis of
economic potential of their labour force.
This clearly shows the need for Human Capital Development in India. The benefits of such
programs are reaped by the personnel themselves as well as the organization. The employees
gain skills, knowledge and technical exposure which are of great importance for their career
and they experience a sense of enlightenment in their current job roles and responsibilities.
On the other hand, organizations get a more sophisticated and smart employee right away
without the need to go head-hunting for knowledgeable employees.
The human resources become more loyal. Their morale gets a boost. Multinational organizations
like Hindustan Uni Lever (HUL) have understood the importance of managing their human
31
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Trends in human capital management
capital well and all the initiatives that they have launched in the markets that they operate
are geared to manage their human assets well. Such efforts increase the employee loyalty.
The morale of the employees gets a boost.
CEO of Tata Consultancy Services says “Our fundamental strength for the next decades is
the talent that we have”. To appreciate talent, the onus is on the organizations to reward
them, motivate them and keep them engaged.
High performing organizations are empowered networks where culture plays an important
role. Information systems and talent mobility play a pivotal role. Companies are exploring new
business models for the future. Networks and ecosystems are replacing organizational hierarchies.
As organizations become digital, they realize the need to redesign themselves to become
more agile to meet consumer’s growing demands and facilitate rapid learning among their
employees. Leading organizations are actively building the new organization. Business leaders
are worried that they should get the processes right.
Organizational design and change is complex. Any redesign with the sole intention of
cutting costs is bound to fail. 70% reorganizations fail because of “creative disobedience”
from the executive team. Top teams must never forget that organization design is a dynamic
and ongoing process – something that comes with an expiry date. For companies who are
willing to take up organizational redesign, it is a process that can pay-off in the long run
in terms of increased productivity and employee engagement.
Earlier, organization’s business models focused only on efficiency and effectiveness without
understanding that coping with unexpected situations is important too. Efficiency is passé.
Successful organizations must be designed for speed, agility and adaptability to win in a
global business environment.
Rather than a hierarchical model, organizations are considering a more flexible, team –centric
model. Real day-to-day work gets done in networks. Systems that encourage teams to regularly
interact with one another and share information transparently enable organizations to achieve
success in their strategies. An agile organization must have teams that are formed and
disbanded quickly. High performing organizations may build a “digital customer experience”
group, select individuals for the team and ask them to design a new product or service.
Companies are also rethinking the way they are managing learning and development
opportunities and helping employees manage their careers. Continuous learning is essential for
business success. Ability to learn and progress is high on an employee’s agenda. Organizations
are offering enriching assignments and opportunities to retain employees. Digital technologies
32
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Trends in human capital management
are leading to disruptive change. Skills are becoming obsolete at an alarming rate. Software
engineers must redevelop their skills every 16–18 months.
Talent sourcing and recruitment are under pressure. Talent and skill shortages make sourcing
manpower a complex issue. Innovative technologies are reshaping the workforce. Leading
companies are turning the open talent economy into an opportunity by keeping themselves
abreast of new technologies. Attracting skilled talent is as much a responsibility as it is of
top management.
An organization’s employment brand must be visible and attractive as candidates often find
the employer, not the reverse. Companies are actively managing their employment brand
to pull candidates toward them. Today workforce requires high level of engagement and
strong career opportunities. Employers must be careful about communicating the right value
proposition to their workforce. Dell redesigned its website so that messages were consistent. A
job search optimization site was launched. An aggressive campaign to attract candidates was
planned and implemented. As part of the plan, blog posts were posted on Dell’s career sites.
Organizations have radically changed the way they measure, evaluate and recognize employee
performance. Continuous performance management practices are being deployed. New
practices are becoming more standardized. Goal management has to become agile. Continuous
feedback mechanism is equally essential.
33
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Strategic management of human capital
10 STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL
Learning objectives:
• To identify initiatives that are needed to improve human capital management.
• To learn about the importance of data in decision making.
• To explore the types of data that will aid decision making.
• To evaluate the process for formulating a strategic human capital plan.
34
34
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Strategic management of human capital
Identifying current and future human needs, including the right number of employees,
identifying the key competencies and skills mix for mission accomplishment and appropriate
deployment of staff across the organization and create strategies for identifying and filling
the gaps.
Valid and reliable data are needed to assess the work force requirements and managers can
turn the spotlight areas for attention before crises develop. Cost of collecting data may
be significant – but the costs of making decisions without the necessary information can
be equally significant. Collecting and analyzing data is a fundamental building block for
measuring the effectiveness of human capital approaches.
35
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Strategic management of human capital
Appropriate geographic and organizational deployment of employees can support goals and
strategies. Effective deployment strategies can enable an organization to have the right people
with the right skills, doing the right jobs in the right place at the right time by making
flexible use of its internal work force. As value of people increases, so does the performance
capacity of the organization. Investing in and enhancing the value of employees can lead to
a win-win situation for both employees and the organization. Leaders must make available
resources and approve incentives that can maximize performance of employees.
Human capital management must become a strategic initiative of the firm. Firm’s managers along
with HR managers must be responsible for developing and implementing a strategic human
capital plan (Eric Rodriguez, Strategic Management of human capital – Business Practices).
1. Identify challenges.
2. Align strategies.
3. Clearly state goals.
4. Define and implement action plan.
5. Evaluate progress.
Firm must take a clear/critical look at itself and identify its shortcomings. Difficulties in
hiring highly qualified individuals retaining top performers or developing specific skill sets
in workers. Issues like non-diverse workforce, generational gaps and succession planning
that may not be as common or obvious but it may lead to gaps in a firm’s human capital.
A firm that is having increased revenues along with stagnant or decreased profits might
have a staff that is top-heavy with senior leadership positions.
A firm that is struggling to meet tighter schedules and budgets might have a work force
that is not receiving the proper training to take advantage of new technologies. Human
capital strategy must be well aligned with business strategy. Goals must be clearly stated
and measurable. Example – If the goal is highly skilled and trained workforce, this has to
be properly defined and a proper time frame has to be established. Clear measures are vital
and goals must not be open-ended – they must have a deadline sans any subjectivity.
36
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Strategic management of human capital
Strategy leader is the person responsible for human capital strategic plan as a whole.
Goal leader is the person who will take ownership of specific goals. He will perform the
tasks required to accomplish each goal. He will also ensure that resources are available to
designated goal leaders. Strategy leader manages a team of goal leaders to develop a process
to meet each goal. Both strategy and goal leaders must work together to ensure availability
of resources to attain each goal.
Once the human capital strategic team is in place, implementation of the strategic plan can
begin. Implementation can be a challenge because it involves a diverse group of individuals.
HR managers and line managers must be involved in implementation of the plan. Line
managers need to be informed not to sacrifice HC strategy obligations in favor of day-to-
day obligations.
The progress has to be evaluated periodically and the goal leaders must be made accountable.
Teams can know which action plans are on track for success and which are in danger of
failure. Is it poor team execution or unrealistic expectations? Corrective actions are important.
The process has to be dynamic right from identifying challenges to evaluating progress.
37
37
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Strategic management of human capital
New challenges can be worked into the current strategic plan or into an entirely new plan.
The way people from different generations learn, work and communicate are different. Just
as there is no one size fits all approach for a human capital strategic plan, there is no one
size fits all approach for managing people. Understanding the workforce and understanding
the challenges to building and maintaining a strong workforce are crucial factors for a
company’s success.
The work environment must support continuous learning, training and professional
development programs, recruitment and retention strategies or performance incentives.
Professional development and mentoring programs add value. Formal and on-the-job training,
individual development plans, rotational assignments, periodic consultations with senior
managers, periodic formal assessments and mentoring relationships with other employees
are some of the crucial steps.
Recruiting bonuses, retention allowances and skill based pay are essential to attract and retain
critical skills. The work force has to be steered in the right direction through appropriate
performance incentives. Performance measures must be result oriented; clients based and
also include employee feedback. Innovative best practices need to be adopted. Data driven
assessment of the organization’s specific needs and capabilities is important. While processes
have to be benchmarked, employees have to be involved in the planning process so that
they become empowered and feel included.
Insights about operations from frontline perspective reveal the understanding of employee’s
organizational goals and perspectives. Motivation and morale need to be improved. Internal
processes must enable managers to exercise their authority and be flexible so that they can
contribute to the organization’s mission.
Managers must use their judgment to meet their responsibilities rather than comply with
rigid rules and standards. Delegation of authority enables looking at customer needs in
an integrated way. Today employees have to interact in a diverse workplace and culture
to attract and retain high quality talent. So, creation of a work environment that fully
maximizes the ability of all employees to fully contribute to the organization’s mission.
Resolution of workplace disputes fairly and efficiently will become necessary for effective
human capital management.
The workplace must be free of discrimination and employees must have no fear of retaliation
for reporting waste, fraud or abuse. Employee satisfaction surveys will reveal gaps in the
company policy and procedures. Employee advisory councils, use of upward feedback and
promoting inclusiveness as part of organization culture will lead to perception of fairness
in the workplace.
38
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Strategic management of human capital
People are key assets that distinguish an organization from another. CEO must realize that
competitive edge that any organization has over others is its people. People represent the
brainpower to propel the organization through choppy waters or smooth waters. Human
resource accounting techniques to measure people’s worth must be explored. Measuring the
contribution of human capital to organization is essential (Liebowitz).
1. Competency Management.
2. Performance Management.
3. Knowledge Management.
4. Change Management.
Each pillar must be included in an organization’s human capital strategic plan. Each pillar
has a symbiotic relationship with each other and when combined form a powerful structure
for building a human capital strategy. 70–80% of learning is done through informal means.
A personalized approach as opposed to a codified approach to knowledge management and
building a learning organization should be a critical part of an organization’s human capital
strategy. Real work in organizations is done informally through personal contacts.
Executives can manage and enhance the effectiveness of the informal networks by focusing
their attention on key role players in the group. The 4 role players are:
1. Central Connectors.
2. Boundary Spanners.
3. Information Brokers.
4. Peripheral Specialists.
Central connectors link most people in an informal network with one another. Boundary
spanners connect an informal network with other parts of the company or with similar
networks in other organizations. Information brokers keep the various subgroups in an
informal network together. Peripheral specialists are people in an informal network that
others can turn to for specialized expertise.
Groups will become effective only when executives start working with informal networks.
Organizations as part of their human capital strategy should consider the impact of an
aging workforce. Analysis of current workforce followed by mining of employee data to
determine turnover patterns and retirement history and creating projections for the future
is part of planning. Companies should investigate the demographic mix of the community
that supplies the workers.
39
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Strategic management of human capital
Conducting qualitative and quantitative research with current older workers to learn how
a company could improve its relationship with older workers. Provide retirement education
workshops to help persuade aging workers to stay on the job. Organization’s success is
embedded in its people. There is need to develop metrics for measuring the intangible assets.
Strategic Management of Human Capital in the Energy sector (Nalbantian & Tenenbaum, 2012)
1. Challenges in meeting demand for talent to take full advantage of growth opportunities
around the world.
2. An aging workforce.
3. Lack of talent in human capital – pipeline. Companies need to recruit and retain
sufficient HC to assure enough career employees will be available to meet the
requirements. Company has to attract new generation of workers.
It is unlikely that the natural mechanisms for equilibrating labour markets – talent mobility
and pay adjustments will be sufficient to make these shortages quickly self-correct.
40
40
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Strategic management of human capital
Significant public and private impediment to talent mobility stubbornly remain. There is
intense competition for skilled talent and so a concerted effort by organizations will be
needed to break through the talent log jam.
Manage the processes by which they find access and develop their workforce. This is not a
pie-in-the-sky musing about the future. It is already happening. For example, the energy giant
Saudi Aramco has moved aggressively to bring a rigorous, quantitative discipline to managing
and deploying its talent pipeline. Systems thinking’ approach → sophisticated evidence based
approach to strategic workforce management and planning that helps identify and mitigate talent
risks. Companies cannot afford to sit on the sidelines and leave their talent needs to chance.
Organizations have to address their current talent challenges and pre-empt future talent gaps.
Organizations have to navigate the external labour markets with which they interact so that
they can manage their own internal labour markets. This will enable them to shape their
workforces to their business needs.
41
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Managing human capital in today’s economy
Learning objectives:
• To understand the new dimensions of manpower planning.
• To learn about the reward grid.
• To identify the different components of an organization’s value proposition.
-- Finding, securing and developing the right talent, now and in the future.
-- Motivating and engaging workforce in a post economic crisis and increasingly
multicultural world.
-- Optimizing labour costs.
-- Actual labour cost reflects both compensation expense and workforce productivity
effective cost management requires tracking and anticipating changes in
compensation levels and trends in global labour markets.
-- Trying to understand what actually drives workforce productivity.
Earlier manpower planning was about determining the number of full time employees in
specific roles to meet future business demand. Now the challenge is to gauge how and to
what extent the quality and mix of workforce capabilities need to support business objectives.
Conjoint analysis can be used to help leaders – those with the best understanding of where
the business is going and its key strategic differentiators – carefully think through the HC
implications of their business design.
Leaders have to develop a workforce ‘blueprint’ that spells out the mix of skills, knowledge
and experience required as well as workforce behaviors and attitudes needed to make the
workforce productive.
→ Identify workforce characteristics and future behaviors are important for future business
performance.
→ Results: Generic capabilities and behaviors like technical knowledge, teamwork and
adaptability to change were critical.
42
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Managing human capital in today’s economy
Firm specific factors like employee tenure and breadth of experience in company were of
little value. The survey results had an impact on the company’s existing talent and reward
strategies to develop and retain firm specific capabilities. Talent and reward strategies must
be geared to deliver what business and HR leaders believed they needed to be successful.
Employee tenure can also be important in driving revenue growth despite it being associated
with an entitlement mentality and resistance to change – ‘the attitudinal’ enemies of a
“performance culture”. Organization has to invest in policies and practices to grow workforce
tenure. Voluntary turnover: Resignation of talented employees can drain the firm’s efforts.
The progressive integration of labour markets across the globe has increased the overall
stock of talent available to organizations. It has also rendered the process of talent searching
more complex and competitive. Decisions about sourcing of talent require the evaluation
of numerous labour markets that exhibit different demographics, educational standards,
cultures, work rules, labour unions and laws.
Job mobility has become more important than people mobility. Job mobility is moving jobs
to where the talent is. People mobility is finding and moving the people to where work
is currently located. Organizations must constantly evaluate the economics of both sides
43
43
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Managing human capital in today’s economy
of this talent equation. Closing of talent gaps will involve giving opportunities to develop
multiple skills, job rotations and moving people across jobs.
Organizations move people through various assignments, jobs, locations and career levels.
They keep some and lose some through voluntary and involuntary turnover.
Administrative processes and procedures to manage the talent pipeline are essential.
1. Know who you are attracting into the organization and whether they are right
people. Recalibrate screening methods to select the best fit for your organization.
2. Know who you are retaining and why.
→ Who is leaving the organization and why? What management practices influence
turnover?
3. Strengthening career opportunities and reducing supervisor turnover.
4. Biggest effect in reducing turnover.
5. Pay and workload → retention of employees.
6. Attrition → career related factors like speed of promotion, frequency of job changes,
managerial stability.
7. Know how vulnerable your organization is to changes in labour market conditions.
Some organizations manage to insulate their workforces from outside market forces, either
through back loading of pay and benefits or by maintaining a premium reward proposition
or employment brand. Any slowness to adjust pay or other rewards to market rates will tend
to result in higher turnover. There is little to deter employees from voting with their feet.
Voting their feet is expressing one’s dissatisfaction with something by leaving, especially by
walking away.
Company needs to identify best performers: what are their characteristic traits? An
organization can give a slew of rewards to performers but it is important to understand
what the organization values collectively.
44
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Managing human capital in today’s economy
Over time a company becomes what it rewards. Performance linked pay relies on deciding
whether the organization needs to accord greater weight age to respecting tenure or
education – which is the source of value. In IT organizations, greater weight age is given
to new talent who are bursting with creative ideas and unbridled enthusiasm.
Outside of
Job
Business
Performance
On the job
performance
Expertise
Experience
Stretching
Team
abilities
Selection of team members must be made along with middle managers to remove bias. This
is called as peer interviews. Amazon & IBM follow this model to get a complete view of
potential hires.
Middle managers must understand employee’s value proposition which is nothing but the
set of characteristics that make a company a more attractive employer than all the rest.
45
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Managing human capital in today’s economy
6. Mentoring.
7. Developmental plans.
8. Performance milestones.
9. Talent inventories.
10. Electronic recruitment & screening systems.
Know how careers unfold and what ways exist to effectively accelerate employee development.
Organizations need to understand how their employees develop both through formal
education and training and through the process of job transition that drives their careers.
Few organizations have a real handle on how these programs and practices actually play
out within their workforces.
An organization’s workforce plan must be tight, granular and fact based – one that specifies
practical actions you can take to improve workforce outcomes. Companies should consider
long term collaboration with government and academic institutions. Inviting subject matter
experts to teach courses is not a bad idea. Summer student programs can be used to pick
up the most promising talent. Out of company assignments to develop leadership and
technical skills can help.
46
46
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Managing human capital in today’s economy
Company can collaborate with the alliance partners throughout the world to give exposure
to their employees to world class practices and diverse technology. This leads to internal
career mobility at all levels to broaden experience, better match people to jobs, strengthen
engagement and motivation.
Seasoned professionals can help with transfer of knowledge on latest technologies and
management practices. Expat employees need to have knowledge transfer as part of their
job. Businesses have to make investments in training and education. Securing the right
workforce is one thing. Engaging that workforce in a productive, innovative and adaptable
fashion to changing market conditions is another thing. This is an inordinately difficult task.
During the 2008 financial crisis, employee engagement took a hit with feelings of loyalty,
commitment to the organization and trust in leadership dipping dramatically. There is a big
pay-off to organizations that operate from a strong base of evidence rather than relying on
HR bromides, a gut feeling or a simple hope that the problem will go away. HR bromides
refer to actions people in HR take simply to protect their jobs or reputation or both.
Employee engagement gives organizations competitive edge.
Securing the right talent is not simply a matter of knowing and meeting the market price
for the talent that you need. Rather it is about knowing what actually drives value in your
organization, knowing what actually drives productive behavior among current and desired
workforce. Using this information to craft an employment proposition that aligns the needs
of the workforce with that of the business is important. The mix of pay, benefits, career
opportunity and work environment that is optimal for the organization is different from
the mix that optimizes workforce and business outcomes in competitor organizations.
Most organizations have all the data that they need from internal and external sources and
to deploy evidence based approach and turn their workforce management and planning into
a lasting source of competitive advantage. Human capital management is about attraction,
development and retention of talent. GE, Microsoft, IBM, Target, Starbucks are organizations
that are adopting a human capital management approach. It is important for organizational
performance. Decentralizing responsibility to middle managers to build up their capacity
47
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Managing human capital in today’s economy
to manage human capital well is important. GE realized its follies when it removed middle
managers moving away from a human capital management approach.
According to economists, human capital represents productive skills and technical knowledge
of workers. In the era of Knowledge economy, human capital has become very important.
Investment in human capital has become the cornerstone of performance improvement strategy.
48
48
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Leadership traits in the 21st century
12 LEADERSHIP TRAITS IN
THE 21ST CENTURY
I had the good fortune of attending a lecture by Shanker Annaswamy, ex MD of IBM
India Limited last week and once again my belief in the tenet that greatness and simplicity
go hand in hand was reinforced. Even though Mr. Shanker spoke about his experiences at
length, at no point in time did his speech border on vanity and arrogance. As someone
who has done some basic research on Level 5 leadership I was wondering if Mr. Shanker
could be classified as one.
A plain talk that was straight from the heart. No jargons. A simple message told in an
impactful manner. That was how Mr. Shanker delivered his speech. Two things struck me
instantly – his love for all the companies where he worked – GE, Philips, IBM and the
gratitude that he showed towards all his bosses who were responsible for his success. All the
management text books in the world cannot substitute for the wisdom that he generated
in his 30-minute speech that was interspersed with bitter sweet memories in his career. He
has come up through the rank and file and that shows in his demeanor.
Having come from a corporate background myself, I regret that I never had someone like
him as a boss during my salad days in the industry. But I was not in IT, so I do not know.
For the Gen Y population, it is worthwhile to listen to his advice – “Learn every day, Seek
connections, go and look out for mentors within and outside the organization”.
Mr. Shanker says that all his bosses gave him tough assignments that bolstered his self
confidence and shaped his overall persona. To his credit, he seems to have accepted all the
challenges that were thrown at him. He says that every company that he worked for – he
loved working there and believes that there is no point badmouthing an organization that you
have worked for and got paid for. Alas! Such an attitude is hard to find by in today’s world.
49
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Leadership traits in the 21st century
• Emotional intelligence, belief in self and self awareness about who you are and
what you stand for go a long way in your journey as a leader.
• Leaders should know the power of collaboration – how to connect with people to
build last longing relationships that are responsible for success of a business.
• A leader must be adaptable, willing to embrace change, learn continuously and
should never shy away from taking tough decisions.
I take this opportunity to add a few insights too. Leaders are not people who create more
followers. Leaders create more leaders for the future. A good leader is above the common
vices of envy, insecurity and aggression. A good leader has to motivate and tap the right
talent, has to be free from prejudices and personal biases. A leader is someone whom people
want to follow. Mental tenacity and ability to handle stress are important to become leaders.
One of my ex-colleagues once told me – “Political machinations in the corporate world can
help you stay in the organization but this may not be sustainable for too long.” No one
knows when the tide will change. Those who indulge in such practices seldom realize that
such behaviors take the essence of leadership trait away from them.
50
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL The true test of leadership
Leaders can share theoretical knowledge with their employees but when it comes to dealing
with customers’ problems, practical solutions are needed. Some leaders are adept in delegating
unwanted tasks to sub-ordinates and that is certainly not a good leadership trait. A true
leader’s influence leaves footprints in the minds of the employees long after they are gone.
A good team is a great asset for any organization. But often leaders tend to take the credit
for the successful outcomes of team effort. If a leader has a fantastic team then success is
assured. But the challenge for a leader is to deal with teams which are not performing so
that they can be motivated and energized to put in their best foot forward.
Dealing with people is a huge challenge for leadership. A leader has to unleash every
individual’s potential to its full extent to remove constraints. Leaders have to work through
constraints as though they do not exist. Businesses expect leaders to be successful amidst
all the constraints.
Human beings are blessed with unlimited potential. Sometimes people do not know what
they are capable of. Lack of self-confidence and self-limiting beliefs often come in the way
of people achieving their true threshold potential limit. It is the leader’s job to encourage
sub ordinates, unleash the potential in individuals and in the process help effectively deal
with constraints like budget, time and scope.
A true leader should not lean on a dream team for success – then where is the question of
his leadership contributing to the success? It is the job of a leader to create a dream team.
1. Leader must promote internalization of goals and objectives by teams. There has
to be a shared vision about the company’s goals. Working towards the company’s
objectives must be in every employee’s DNA. This will greatly enhance the quality
of decision making.
2. Planning is important for a leader. A leader has to use his vision and imagination
to predict how things will unfold. Experience of a leader helps him in dealing with
blind spots.
51
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL The true test of leadership
52
52
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Can leadership be taught or learned?
14 CAN LEADERSHIP BE
TAUGHT OR LEARNED?
One has often read statements like – “Leaders are not born, they are made” from management
philosophers. My view is that leadership can be certainly learnt – only if there is that inherent
quality in an individual to learn, acquire more knowledge and sharpen his learning curve
consistently. If an individual does not possess leadership capabilities, no amount of coaching
or mentoring or training is ever going to help.
1) A visionary.
2) Passion.
3) Ability to delegate and empower people.
4) Ability to strategies and think out-of-the-box.
5) Great people skills.
6) Humility.
7) Empathy.
8) Desire to be a mentor/coach.
9) Ability to value employees as human assets.
10) Great decision making ability.
11) A keen eye for detail.
12) Business sense and customer focus.
13) Excellent listening skills.
Every leader must either possess these traits or willing to be coached in areas where there
are gaps in his/her capabilities. There are certain skills that are inborn and are definitely a
result of a variety of factors – most notably the way an individual has been groomed and has
been brought up. Attributes like resilience surface after an individual experiences highs and
lows in his professional career. The test of true leadership is always reflected in unexpected
situations and the way in which the leader handles tense situations with élan and grace.
Equanimity of a leader in the most trying situations is a real blessing.
53
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Can leadership be taught or learned?
To a great extent, our professional lives are an extension of our personality. Whether you
like it or not, a positive attitude in a leader is a result of his inherent character so is his
ability to handle situations boldly. An individual who treats his family shabbily will find
that in some way or the other, the negative aspect of his character seeps into his profession.
In a likewise manner, an individual who is a bad boss can’t pretend to be a Samaritan in
his personal life. The roles, even if they are conflicting, will converge at some point.
If we look at great leaders and their lives, then we have to admit that there has been
someone who has scripted the success story of the leader. It may be the spouse, it may be
a mentor… Coupled with this, if the individual also happens to be at the right place at
the right time, then success is guaranteed. The ability of a leader to walk-the-talk also plays
a great role in his credibility.
To sum it up
Leadership can certainly be taught provided the individual has an open mind and consents
to be a great listener. Certain leadership traits like humility, people skills, empathy are in
born and can’t be coached. A leader can’t always expect to hear what he wants to – he
should also be willing to listen otherwise. There can be occasions when the personal and
professional lives of an individual can overlap to reflect his true self.
The success of a true leader is always measured by the number of followers that he leaves
in his trail. Going one step further, a true leader is one who creates more leaders out of
his followers.
54
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Abusive leadership
15 ABUSIVE LEADERSHIP
Learning objectives:
• To understand the various dimensions of abusive leadership.
• To identify the detrimental effects of abusive leadership.
• To evaluate the impact of abusive leadership on an organization’s growth.
The term “abusive leadership” has different connotations. At the end of the day, it is a
question of semantics. Abuse need not be only in the form of verbiage of words or violent
actions. Silence can also be used to abuse people. Many multinational corporations now
talk about “Diversity & Inclusion”. Not demonstrating inclusive behaviors can also be a
form of abuse.
Let us recollect the platitude – “Employees leave bosses, not organizations”. This can be
corrected as “Employees leave bad bosses, not organizations”. But what do employees do
when there is no other option? “Employees tolerate bad bosses when there is no other go”.
55
55
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Abusive leadership
This can adversely affect the health of employees and the health of the organization in the
long run. Dealing with people is the most difficult aspect of working in a business enterprise.
Bosses can often abuse their positional power and sometimes ideas that are sacred cows tend
to became albatrosses in the necks of those who are entrusted with the task of implementing
the idea. There are bosses who delegate all the unwanted tasks to subordinates to save their
skin. Is this also not a form of abuse? Abusive leadership also comes into play when bosses
set unrealistic targets just to get even with subordinates. Using organizational conflicts for
selfish interests is another form of abuse.
How can silence be a form of abuse? Just think about a situation when the boss does not
even greet you, does not assign any tasks to you and completely ignores you. It is a signal
that he wants you out. You might have done something that might have hurt his ego and
now he wants to get even with you. If he is not voluble about what has hurt him, the
situation only gets worse.
Blame it on the halo effect. Bias is another form of abuse. Street smart employees get away
with anything but those who are straight forward often get the hammer. Micromanagement
is one more form of abuse. How many times you have encountered a situation when the boss
is breathing down your neck checking if you are on track in completing the assigned task.
Abusive leadership can also dent the performance appraisal process rendering it an exercise in
futility. Despite monumental academic research on improving the effectiveness of performance
appraisals, the truth is that performance appraisals can never be completely objective in
their approach. The moment human beings are involved in a process, subjectivity tends to
creep in.
The grading method of performance appraisal (the bell curve) is now being eschewed by
organizations like Dell, Cisco and Wipro mainly because the method is not truly reflective of
the performance of an employee. The very idea of slotting employees in different categories
based on the budget allotted is ridiculous. Bosses can change the appraisal grades based
on the budget available. If there is a cut in the proposed budget, then the matter can only
get out of hand.
There are also situations when some employees get a good hike only based on the output.
A spike in sales can happen due to a various reasons – not necessarily due to the efforts
of the sales manager. When input efforts are seldom recognized with the focus solely on
output measures, then there is something wrong somewhere. The repercussions of such
indiscriminate decisions may not be felt immediately but no business can rule out the
tremors resulting from such gross unfair evaluation of performance.
56
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Abusive leadership
Thus an abusive leader can get even with his subordinates in a variety of ways. In James
Heskett’s service profit chain model, when employees are treated well, they tend to treat the
customers well and this improves the profitability of the firm. What about the converse?
How many organizations actually focus on this aspect?
Abusive leadership is like slow poison. If left unattended, good employees leave the organization
but bad bosses continue to stay on further contributing to the attrition in the firm. Abusive
leadership also gets amply demonstrated when employee loyalty is given greater weight age
instead of performance. Is there a way out?
Despite talk about strategic human resource management, redefining talent management
and treating employees as human capital, businesses have a long way to go before they stop
treating HR as another support function. HR is a cost centre. Thus, the expectation is that
it has to be subservient to the needs (both rational and irrational) of other functions that
are profit centers. Unless this mindset changes, there is little hope.
57
57
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Leadership and change management
Earlier the nature of change was simpler. So project sponsors could afford to spend less time
on projects. But today change is much more complex. Involvement of senior executives/
sponsors can make the difference between success and failure of a project.
Many sponsors are experiencing the need to be coached by change management experts.
Research has revealed that 90% of the time projects suffer due to communication breakdowns
between project managers and sponsors.
Project Managers – need to understand that Yesterday’s best is at best today’s good
58
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Leadership and change management
1. The governance policy must be linked with the project priorities at all times.
2. Asking for advice is not a sign of weakness – it only shows that the project manager
is working hard to fill in the gaps.
3. A project manager has to drive the change agenda. He must effectively deal with
resource crunches and mitigate the risk of scope creep. Effectively dealing with
sacred cow ideas and overcoming motivational, cognitive and political hurdles is
important too.
4. Use of straw man ideas to drive away blues in change management is essential too.
A project manager’s energy in dealing with this change synergizes the team output!
Reference:
http://www.girlsguidetopm.com/2013/02/the-tipping-point-between-effective-leadership-of-
change-and-the-role-of-project-managers/
59
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL It can be lonely at the top
Learning objectives:
1. To understand the role played by management coaches/mentors in supporting leaders.
2. To evaluate the role of mentors in decision making by top leaders.
As leaders move up the hierarchical ladder, they have fewer touch points within the
organization with staff at junior/senior level. They get drawn into a vicious cycle where it
is easy to lose touch with reality. In professionally managed organizations, this risk for a
CEO or a CMD is somewhat mitigated, because there are people at director levels who
report to the CEO or CMD and with whom there are lots of interactions by way of group
meetings, leadership workshops, etc. But, what about those firms that are founded by
entrepreneurs, where besides the main person who is at the helm of the affairs, there are
only 1 or 2 senior persons reporting directly to him and having direct access to him? This
is actually a trap and before they realize this, many CEOs end up creating an environment
in which, not many employees can freely approach them. Before too long, the CEOs realize
that it is lonely at the top.
These types of corporate situations have created a new breed of HR consultants called
‘executive coaches‘, who mentor and train such top level leaders. Generally, executive coaches
are senior level leaders who help the CEOs cope with change enabling them to keep their
ear on the ground. They try to help the CEOs eschew the normal tendency of insisting
on what they want to listen to rather than what they need to listen to. In a corporate
environment, many senior level leaders tend to become chary about sharing unpleasant
information with the top boss. This means that the CEO does not have a true picture. So,
in such a situation, it is only such ‘executive coaches’ who can help the CEO address his
shortcomings in a constructive manner and work towards correcting the gaps.
Ironically, years ago, a role that was quite popular in corporate circles was that of an
Executive Assistant (EA). Though an EA could not be called a mentor or a coach, he was
an important resource for the CEO. Sadly, over the years, many organizations misused such
profiles completely obliterating and totally blurring the distinction between an executive
assistant and an executive secretary. This eventually made many prospective candidates wary
of such type of strategic roles.
Ideally, a real EA has the shadow authority of the CEO and can be a key resource in the
organization having empowerment and authority. However, there were reports of candidates
who joined as EA being asked to do travel and hotel bookings, type letters, attend to
screening calls and carry out similar secretarial work.
60
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL It can be lonely at the top
With easy access to people at lower hierarchical levels, the EA would have been in a much
better position to keep the CEO/CMD informed about the situation on the ground. He
was also someone who acted as the sounding board for the CEO. The EA, to some extent,
had roles similar to that of an executive coach, but at a junior level. He was someone who
was encouraged to use a creative approach to resolve problems.
It is so very difficult to locate a candidate to fit in the role of an EA, who has the highest
standards of integrity and moral character. It is only references from past employers/bosses/
customers that act as a viable tool to make an informed decision while recruiting such
candidates. If the EA role had been given the respect it deserved, then CEOs would have had
someone who was dependable and resourceful in taking strategic decisions. But like throwing
the baby along with the bath tub, by clubbing the executive assistant and executive secretary
roles as one, organizations ended up dissuading promising talent to apply for such roles.
61
61
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL It can be lonely at the top
It must also be mentioned that the EA role was considered as a spring board for moving
onto other business roles and this was the key attraction. Sadly, the strategies changed and
today there are very few “real” executive assistant roles in the job market. Even for such
job roles, there are not many takers for the simple reason that the job market has not been
able to rebuild credibility for such positions.
The demise of the EA role has now led to new concepts in HR consulting. As mentioned
before, executive coaches are one such breed. There are management gurus like Robin
Sharma, Deepak Chopra, Shiv Khera and spiritual gurus like the Bangalore-based Swami
Sukhabodananda who train and mentor senior level leaders at specially organized workshops.
There are some others who call themselves ‘thought leaders’ and help the CEO gain a clear
business perspective through unconventional means.
I have every reason to believe that this is a healthy trend. For one, as all these consultants
are not part of the organization; you can expect them to be unbiased and constructive in
their approach. That apart, people who have retired from HR/strategy function can be
gainfully employed by such CEOs for sharing their wisdom that they have gained over the
years. But for all these mentoring/coaching efforts to succeed, it is important that CEOs
improve their listening skills, give the consultants the respect that they deserve and make
informed decisions based on the advice given. Eventually, it is the CEO’s call. There is no
compulsion on the CEO to follow each and every advice given by the coaches. But, rejection
of an idea suggested by the coach must have a valid reason.
I have observed that this model of individual coaching/mentoring is far better than the
other popular model of “strategy consultation”, especially when it relates to coaching the
CEO. This is because, the strategy teams who land in an office, start throwing attitude
taking advantage of their proximity to the CEO and before long they alienate the employees
within no time. In most organizations, the so-called strategy consultants are perceived as
‘butchers’ – all out to reduce the head count by hook or crook. There may be exceptions
to this rule; however, it is an open secret that anything remotely related to strategy is now
widely perceived as a decoy to slash jobs.
Last but not the least, the decision to engage such coaches must be taken at early stages
and not when the damage is already done. Coaches/mentors can enable the CEO/CMD
to look at a situation with the objectivity that is needed. At the end of the day, it is not
about business alone. It is also about addressing the social needs of the CEO.
62
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Level 5 leadership
18 LEVEL 5 LEADERSHIP
Learning objectives:
1. To understand the different levels of leadership.
2. To review the traits of a Level 5 leader.
3. To learn about real life examples of Level 5 leaders.
Level 5 leadership abilities were introduced to the world by the pioneering work of Jim
Collins who wrote the book – “Good to Great”. One of the fundamental qualities of a
level 5 leader is humility. A level 5 leader does not believe in marketing his contributions to
the business. He is somewhat reticent talking about his achievements and willingly credits
other people for success even while he accepts responsibility for failure.
Level 5 leaders are characterized by indomitable courage, keen business acumen, expert knowledge
and ability to organize (Jim Collins, 2001). Truly great leaders have a specific blend of skills.
But they also possess something else; certain characteristics which are harder to define. Collins
wrote about it in a well-respected 2001 Harvard Business Review article, and published his
research in his popular book, “From Good to Great.” The concept came about during a study
that began in 1996, when Collins began researching what makes a great company. He started by
looking at 1,435 companies, and ended up choosing 11 truly great ones. These 11 companies
were all headed by what Collins called “Level 5 Leaders.” These 11 companies achieved and
sustained greatness. Each of this company had a Level 5 leader at the helm.
According to Jim Collins, deep personal humility and intense professional will characterized
a level 5 leader. This was somewhat paradoxical. Level 5 leaders do not make headlines.
They credit others for success, sometimes attributing their success to good luck and external
factors. But when they faced failures, they blamed themselves. The level 5 leaders are utterly
intolerant of mediocrity. They will do whatever it takes to produce results. Level 5 leaders
select superb successors, wanting their companies to become more successful in the future.
63
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Level 5 leadership
!
GH
ROU
K TH
EA
BR
BUILDUP ...
According to Collins, the alchemy of a great business performance hinges on the unique
combination of a culture of discipline and an ethic of entrepreneurship. A company can
be thought of as three intersecting circles – what it can be best at, how its economics work
best and what ignites its people’s passions. Everything else can be eliminated. This is how
breakthroughs happen.[2]
64
64
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Level 5 leadership
Collins also compares the characteristics of a fox with that of a hedgehog. A fox knows a
little about many things. The hedgehog knows only one big thing very well. Simplicity of
hedgehog ensures its success.
Hedgehog
Thus level 5 leaders create a culture of discipline to transition the company’s progress from
good to great. Collins looked at cumulative stock returns of companies over a period of 15
years. The aim was to understand how other companies were distinctive from other players in
the industry. Collins sourced 6000 articles and conducted 87 interviews with key executives.
His team also pored through internal strategy documents of firms. The quantitative metrics
that were looked at were – financial metrics, executive compensation, management turnover,
company layoffs and restructurings and effect of acquisitions on stocks.
Level 5 leaders talked only about the company and seldom did they display hubris or
vanity. Leaders believed that they had got the opportunity as a leader due to luck or due to
serendipity. They affirmed that others in the company could do a better job than themselves.
From the examples narrated by Jim Collins in his seminal article published in Harvard
Business Review, the following attributes of level 5 leaders can be surmised.
• Level 5 leaders displayed eagerness to learn and keep themselves updated so that
they could be relevant to the organization with passage of time.
• They are silent runners and maintained a calm demeanor even during times of crisis.
• They believe that “good is not good enough” and hated mediocrity.
• Level 5 leaders believed in setting standards and enforcing them.
• For level 5 leaders, company came first and they succeeded in selecting successors
who could take the company forward. They left behind a company that would be
great without them.
• Many level 5 leaders had a spiritual bent of mind and life’s hardships inured them
to struggles in the board room.
65
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Level 5 leadership
Level 5 leadership qualities can be developed if the individual has an inner capability that
drives him to acquire and adapt to those skills. The level 5 leadership is shaped by the right
circumstances – having a good mentor to guide, having loving parents, having pleasant
childhood experiences, having cathartic experiences in life, having a loving and supporting
family. All these situations create the seed for development of an individual.
But the authors believe that there are scores of examples of leaders who may not have had the
right experiences during their childhood or who may not have had a great mentor. Yet these
leaders have managed to achieve success. This calls for further exploratory research on the subject.
At this level, you make high quality contributions with your work. You possess useful
levels of knowledge; and you have the talent and skills needed to do a good job.
At Level 2, you use your knowledge and skills to help your team succeed. You work
effectively, productively and successfully with other people in your group.
66
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Level 5 leadership
Here, you’re able to organize a group effectively to achieve specific goals and objectives.
Level 4 is the category that most top leaders fall into. Here, you’re able to galvanize
a department or organization to meet performance objectives and achieve a vision.
At Level 5, you have all of the abilities needed for the other four levels, plus you
have the unique blend of humility and will that’s required for true greatness.
Leaders need to develop humility and understand why arrogance is so destructive. Leaders
need to take responsibility for their team’s efforts, even when things go wrong. They do not
hesitate to seek help when they need it. Level 5 Leaders are incredibly disciplined in their
work. When they commit to a course of action, no matter how difficult it is, they stick to
their resolve. They don’t let naysayers dissuade them from a course of action.
67
67
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Tipping point leadership
Learning objective:
• To understand the concept of Tipping Point Leadership.
Two management researchers namely W. Chan Kim and Renee Mauborgne (both from
INSEAD blue ocean strategy institute) tried to analyze the triggers of high performance
and how a decrepit organization can be brought back to life.
Bratton’s example led the researchers to arrive at a concept called tipping point leadership. It
is all about successful management of change. Once the beliefs and energies of a critical mass
of people are unleashed, then one can expect a change for the better. How does it happen?
First, it is about leadership. Second, it is about focusing on resources that matter and then
mobilizing the commitment of the organization’s key players. These players have the charisma
to silence the carping critics who always focus on what can go wrong.
Often leaders dread the huge hurdles that come their way. But in the end it is all about
the courage and conviction with which the leader can overcome these hurdles. The authors
assert that Bratton’s success is not a matter of his personality alone – it is also about the
methods followed by him consistently. Thus Tipping point leadership can be replicated.
68
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Tipping point leadership
1. Resource Hurdle – Focus on areas that need attention and seek support where needed.
2. Motivational Hurdle – Define the challenge and show people how they can shine.
3. Cognitive Hurdle – Let managers face problems head-on and find out new ways
to communicate.
4. Political Hurdle – Identify, silence and isolate the arm-chair critics.
Often need for change is communicated to the team along with the rationale that invariably
focuses on numbers. But Bratton believed that managers should witness reality.
1. Bratton insisted that all police officials travel via the subway so that they get a feel
of the crimes that happen. The police officials started experiencing the problems
that were faced by the common man on a daily basis.
2. Once the regulatory authority in Massachusetts decided to order smaller squad cars
to cut corners. Bratton made the general manager travel in the smaller squad car
to make him experience the discomfort. But he did that in a diplomatic fashion.
Bratton did not fight the decision. But found an intelligent way to solve the problem.
3. He brought the policing staff to the community so that the latter’s grievances could
be heard and resolved.
4. Bratton appointed an expert communication advisor. He relied less on traditional
forms of communication like memos and bulletins. Video messages by Bratton
were flashed to the police staff and the advisor ensured that the media projected
the strong messages of Bratton.
5. Reallocation and resources of staff was done based on real time statistics of crime rates.
6. Rather than hire more policing staff, Bratton identified strategic zones where crime
rate was highest and he deployed plainclothesmen in these zones. The criminals
got the message.
7. Arrest processing time was reduced from 16 hours to 1 hour by converting old
buses as arrest processing centers.
8. In those days when no one knew what big data was, Bratton believed in data-driven
policing. He successfully built a crime database.
9. Bratton chose to motivate a few set of people who could bring in a dramatic
transformation in the way resources were managed and who could act as precursors
for change.
10. Perform or Perish. The performance reviews were held with the top police brass
and not just Bratton. As accountability increased, people became more wary of
performing well. There was no question of blame game.
69
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Tipping point leadership
“Youth and skill will win out every time over age and treachery.” This was what Bratton
firmly believed in.
A victim of political machinations within the organization, Bratton understood that it was
important to learn about the plotting and politics. He was able to identify a senior leader
in the top team who could be trusted and could act as the sponsor of the change.
Bratton’s alliance with the mayor’s office and the city’s leading media institution successfully
isolated the courts when they were up in arms against zero-tolerance policing.
This case reflects the challenges associated with management of change and the rewards that
can be reaped by addressing those challenges.
Reference:
https://hbr.org/2003/04/tipping-point-leadership/ar/1#
70
70
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Servant leadership
20 SERVANT LEADERSHIP
Learning objectives:
• To learn about the tenets of servant leadership.
• To understand the importance of servant leadership in enhancing organizational
performance.
– Robert Greenleaf
The words servant and leader are usually thought of as being opposites. When two opposites
are brought together in a creative and meaningful way, a paradox emerges. The term servant-
leadership was first coined by Greenleaf (1904–1990). The servant-leader is one who is a
servant first. It begins with the natural feeling that one wants to serve, to serve first. Then
conscious choice brings one to aspire to lead. The difference manifests itself in the care taken
by the servant-first to make sure that other people’s highest-priority needs are being served.
A servant-leader focuses primarily on the growth and well-being of people and the communities
to which they belong. While traditional leadership generally involves the accumulation and
exercise of power by one at the “top of the pyramid,” servant leadership is different. The
servant-leader shares power but puts the needs of others first and helps people develop and
perform as highly as possible.
Greenleaf ’s first Servant Leadership principle is listening. He describes listening as the active
participation and search for understanding. A good listener is ready with an open mind and
tries to understand what is being communicated. A Servant Leader actively listens to others
and is known by others as someone who will give the time to really pay attention and listen.
The second Servant Leadership principle is empathy. Empathy is the ability to put oneself
in another person’s situation. Can people really walk in someone else’s shoes? A Servant
Leader realizes that each person is unique and has strengths and weaknesses that they bring
to the workplace.
Healing is the third principle of Servant Leadership and is considered by many to be the
most powerful principle. Healing involves fostering the idea that people have the ability to
make whole. Servant Leaders understand this principle and its power by realizing that what
one says can either build another person up or tear the person down.
71
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Servant leadership
The fourth principle is awareness and Greenleaf states that this principle is a disturber and
awakener. Awareness involves being aware of others as well as being aware of oneself. With
this idea comes being ready to accept whatever one finds because often being aware means
something to be done. The Servant Leader is ready to work towards correcting things that
are wrong.
Persuasion is the fifth principle. The Servant Leader uses persuasion to convince others of
what needs to be done, as opposed to being coercive or authoritative. A Servant Leader
must use this power of persuasion to get others to trust and follow.
The sixth principle is conceptualization. Servant Leaders nurture the ability to be a visionary
in themselves and in others. Servant Leaders see a problem and are able to find short and
long term solutions. When there are many things going on in organizations, the Servant
Leader is able to keep calm even in the face of many struggles.
Foresight is the seventh principle and characterizes a leader who is intuitive and can make
decisions based on the past, present, and future. Servant Leaders are able to identify current
trends and make wise decisions.
The eighth principle is stewardship. A Servant Leader understands that he/she is entrusted
to take care of things that do not belong to him/her. Stewardship is about the legacy that
leaders create. Are leaders trusted enough to be entrusted with things that do not belong
to them?
Commitment to the growth of people is the ninth principle of Servant Leadership. Servant
Leaders are committed to the personal, professional, and spiritual growth of others. Servant
Leaders understand that others should be better off knowing them and Servant Leaders
recognize that they are responsible for the growth of those around them.
Finally, the tenth principle is building community. A Servant Leader inspires others to work
together towards a common goal. This type of leader builds teamwork within organizations
and families. A Servant Leader fosters the idea of teamwork by being the glue that keeps
everyone working together.
When all the ten principles are in place, more work gets done and organizations, communities,
and families prosper. Servant leadership is experienced so rarely because of trends in the
leadership environment, the scarcity of human qualities required and the demands that the
practice places on the practitioner.
72
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Servant leadership
Servant leadership is a philosophy and set of practices that enriches the lives of individuals,
builds better organizations and ultimately creates a more just and caring world. Servant
leadership is a timeless concept. The phrase “servant leadership” was coined by Robert K.
Greenleaf in “The Servant as Leader”, an essay that he first published in 1970.
The servant-leader is servant first It begins with the natural feeling that one wants to serve,
to serve first. Then conscious choice brings one to aspire to lead. That person is sharply
different from one who is leader first; perhaps because of the need to assuage an unusual
power drive or to acquire material possession. The leader-first and the servant-first are two
extreme types. Between them there are shadings and blends that are part of the infinite
variety of human nature.
The servant leadership approach goes beyond employee-related behavior and calls for a
rethinking of the hierarchical relationship between leaders and subordinates. This does
not mean that the ideal of a participative style in any situation is to be enforced, but that
the focus of leadership responsibilities is the promotion of performance and satisfaction
of employees.
Month 16
I was a construction Mo
supervisor ina const
I was
the North Sea super
advising and the No
Real work he
helping foremen advis
International
al opportunities
Internationa
�ree wo
work
or placements ssolve problems
Real work he
helping fo
International
Internationaal opportunities
�ree wo
work
or placements ssolve pr
73
73
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Micromanagement kills
21 MICROMANAGEMENT KILLS
Learning objective:
• To understand what micromanagement is and its deleterious effects on
organizational morale.
Micromanagement can be detrimental to the organization in the long run. This can be
avoided by giving employees greater autonomy and freedom to accomplish the tasks in their
own way. The expectations must be made clear at the beginning of every task and once it is
certain that everyone has understood what is expected of them, managers should keep their
hands out of it. In the corporate world, results are important and so long as there are no
unethical issues, it is fine that the employee adopts a process that he is comfortable with.
To re-call what Tom Peters once said, “Leaders are those who create more leaders and not
more followers”.
Leaders who feel that they have to check on every detail demonstrate their insecurities. The
leadership style is based on lack of faith and trust in others. It is repressive and discourages
the professional development of subordinates. There are great leaders who have allowed their
subordinates to make mistakes. But these leaders have also ensured that their employees
learn from their mistakes. If micromanagement continues for far too long, employees may
feel suffocated and this can lead to attrition.
The problem is that micro managers take positive attributes like attention to detail and a
hands-on attitude to the extreme. They always plan to read the atlas wrong. This may be
because they are obsessed with control or in their over zealousness to push everyone around
them to success, they end up sending the wrong signals and de-motivating their employees.
Needless to add, such micro managers never believe in giving constructive feedback and
end up hurting people to the point that employee is frustrated enough to call it a day. Such
managers limit each individual’s ability to develop and grow and they also limit what their
individual team members can achieve.
74
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Micromanagement kills
The inability of micro managers to “let go” and let other people make decisions and even
risk failure, ensures restriction in growth of business. Subordinates stop being productive
and are forced to wait for direction from the manager. Even simple decisions get delayed
because employees lack empowerment.
Effects of micromanagement
Employees will be distracted by constant monitoring. Employees will feel like they aren’t
trusted by the employer. It will cause stress and frustration. It will limit employees’ feelings
of empowerment, accountability, and responsibility. Constant updates and status meetings
will take time away from the actual task at hand. It will kill employees’ drives to be creative,
innovative, and find better solutions. It will make employees question their abilities and
limit their professional growth. It will make employees feel disrespected.
Micro management can be detrimental to the organization in the long run. This can be
avoided by giving employees greater autonomy and freedom to accomplish the tasks in their
own way. The expectations must be made clear at the beginning of every task and once it is
certain that everyone has understood what is expected of them, managers should keep their
hands out of it. In the corporate world, results are important and so long as there are no
unethical issues, it is fine that the employee adopts a process that he is comfortable with.
75
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL The power of delegation
Learning objective:
• To understand the importance of delegation in development of employees.
Fear is the most disintegrating element of human personality. From a management perspective,
delegation is sharing or transfer of authority and the associated responsibility from an
employer or superior to an employee or a subordinate.
Delegation is one of the most important management skills as well as it is the most
important in every aspect of our day-to-day life as we move on. Delegation is all about giving
opportunity to the person to whom we want to give the authority. Delegation improves the
360°
scope of performance. Delegation is grant of authority by one party to another.
thinking
Delegation is a two way process. Delegation is a very helpful aid for succession planning,
personal development, selling and promotion. Delegation enables us to gain experience to
assume higher responsibilities. Effective delegation is crucial for management and leadership
.
360°
thinking .
In the business world, “Power of Delegation” is the key to come up with new and fascinating
ideas to develop the business. This creates an open space for each one of the employees so
that they can share their talents, skills with others and execute the tasks entrusted to them
with a positive energy.
Effective delegation can enable an employee to sharpen his learning curve and increase his
productive capacity. It will boost an employee’s morale and instill self-confidence in him.
Unfortunately in the corporate world, some leaders never delegate while some leaders delegate
unwanted tasks to their sub-ordinates. These unwanted tasks are something that they do not
want to spoil their hands with. This is a malaise that employees have to often deal with.
If utilized effectively, delegation can be a boon for an employee’s personal development.
77
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Introduction to recruitment & selection
23 INTRODUCTION TO
RECRUITMENT & SELECTION
Learning objectives:
• List the skills and knowledge needed to conduct full and fair recruitment and
selection and be able to undertake it systematically.
• To understand the elements of job analysis.
Recruitment is the process of attracting the most suitable people for the position, selection
is the process of choosing the best person for the position, and induction is introducing the
person to the position. There is a series of well-tested steps to help you identify the right
person, to ensure he or she will fit well with your farm business, and to meet the various
legal obligations of an employer. If recruitment is done well, the business benefits from
happier and more productive people, reduced staff turnover, good working relationships
and ultimately a more profitable farm.
Though recruitment and selection are considered as one process, it will help to carve out
a distinction when planning staff recruitment and selecting an individual from a pool of
applicants. Recruitment has to be planned carefully to attract the right type of applicant.
This increases the chances of making a suitable selection and appointment.
Criteria of suitability must be overt and relevant to the job. This will facilitate rational
decisions about someone’s suitability for a job based on evidence rather than gut feeling.
The key to effective recruitment is preparation: knowing the job and what are the skill
sets required to perform that job well. The costs of recruiting the wrong person can be
significant. Incorrect assumptions about class, gender or physical disability can cloud the
objectivity while taking decisions about recruitment and selection.
The qualities of the successful applicant must match what the organization requires. Recruiter’s
perception is often influenced by striking characteristics or similarities to themselves. This is
called as halo effect and can work in either a positive or negative direction. Someone who
attended the same college or university as the recruiter would be at an advantage. People
judge more favorably those individuals with whom they have something in common. Years
ago, a top leader in P&G (India) had this practice of giving a favorable opportunity to
South Indians. However to his credit, he was largely unbiased.
78
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Introduction to recruitment & selection
Recruitment and selection involves the applicant and organization trying to discover how
their interests can converge. It is a two-way process. Applicants need to have a clear idea
about the job. They should also have a clear idea about the type of organization that they
are joining.
The traditional approach to recruitment and selection is based on the view that job
requirements must be specified carefully and then the effort must be to look for individuals
whose personal attributes fit those requirements. Selection techniques must be concerned
with accessing and measuring personal factors that can then be compared with those required
for the job. To find the right person for the job, you need to have a perfect idea about the
job and skill sets that the job demands. The skills that candidates bring to the table will
then need careful evaluation.
Most organizations do a job analysis. This helps them to re-prioritize the need for recruitment
and selection. It is possible that the vacancy can be filled internally.
79
79
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Induction program
24 INDUCTION PROGRAM
Learning objectives:
1. To understand what are the objectives of induction program.
2. Learn about the benefits of induction program for organization and employee.
Induction is the process for introducing a new employee to their work environment. It
extends from the moment the prospective employee reads the advertisement for the position
and fuses with their training and development as a part of the organization.
Why do we need an induction procedure? A proper induction will give both the employees
and the organization the following benefits:
An induction process is not simply for new employees. The same benefits can be received by
staff who have been promoted or transferred or those who have returned from a long period
of absence. An induction program must be made flexible and interesting. It must be employee
centered and ensure that new employee becomes productive as quickly as possible. An induction
program gives an opportunity for an employee to understand organization’s policies and procedures.
The employee can also get an idea about the performance standards of the job.
Objectives of induction
• Develop relevant skills, knowledge and behavior of employees.
• Help employees develop SMART (specific, measurable, action oriented, relevant
and time bound) goals.
• Enables the new recruits to acquire the necessary skills to get on with their jobs
immediately.
• Learning process of employees can be expedited.
• Reduce training costs.
• Reduce employee turnover.
• Quicker alignment of new employees to goals of the organization.
80
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Induction program
Benefits of an induction
• Reduces the time taken for a new colleague to become effective.
• Help to support staff retention and commitment.
• Introduces new staff to the “culture” of the University, its values & behaviors.
• Provides a greater understanding of the job and how it fits into the bigger picture.
• Begins the ongoing process of continuous professional development.
• Demonstrates that we are an employer that values its people.
• Encourages two-way communication and team working.
• Allows objectives to be set and the probation period to begin.
For the employees, induction programs reduce anxiety and enabling to know what is expected
of them. Roles and responsibilities get clarified. A good induction program enables the
employee to learn about the organization structure, its policies and communication methods.
As employees get information about policies and procedures, it improves their comfort levels.
81
81
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Innovative hiring in retail
Learning objective:
• To understand the innovative hiring in retail based on real life experience.
I happened to visit the Heritage Fresh Retail store in Bangalore. It was 8 am in the morning.
On the way back home after my morning walk I decided to purchase vegetables at this
store. I saw a senior citizen who was so energetic and active. He was walking about the
store, talking to the front line staff, welcoming customers with a warm and gentle smile.
Seldom do you see store managers standing at the entrance of a retail store and welcoming
customers! I had my doubts. Was he a customer? Was he a store manager?
As I finished my purchase and stood at the billing counter, I noticed him talking to other
senior citizens who happened to be customers. His geniality seemed to be infectious as most
of them stopped after their purchases to have a few words with him. He seemed to know
most of his customers by first name.
Intrigued by these events, I approached him and asked him if he was the store manager. He
replied in the negative and added, “Sir, my friend owns this store and I come here every
day from 7 am to 11 am to fill in for the store manager. The store manager comes at 11
am and works till the evening. I come here to pep up the front line staff, motivate the
security guards who are doing routine work day in and day out and say a few kind words
to the customers who come to shop here.”
Though he did not say that many customers came to the store not just to shop but to also
talk to him, it was clear that his behavior was promoting customer loyalty. Later I met
him one evening and we started chatting. He said, “My daughter is happily married and
settled in New Jersey. My son is in Australia. I was a very active person until I retired from
a multinational company. But soon I found it stifling to sit at home, read newspapers and
watch television. When I come to this store, I feel energetic. I joke with the staff, lighten
their mood, hip hop around. Thanks to this, my diabetes is now under control. All my
years I was working for a salary. But I am now working for giving something back to
society. I have never been so happy in life”. May be this was this gentleman’s own way of
ISR [Individual Social Responsibility]. Before he parted ways he told me, “I have always
felt young at heart. This is what keeps me going”.
That set my mind thinking. Generally store managers and store employees are a harassed
lot. They work for long hours and are underpaid. Ennui is bound to set in. If retail industry
82
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Innovative hiring in retail
starts looking at hiring senior citizens on a part time/free lance basis to take care of the
“nicer” aspects of customer care, wouldn’t that be great? This will be a win-win situation.
The collateral benefit of this effort would be customer loyalty/retention.
Retail marketing is all about creating a unique shopping experience for the customer. If we
add a dose of emotional touch to this, it will make the shoppers visit the store again and
again. This is another way of retaining customers, isn’t it? Such senior citizens who have
a zest for life and whose needs to socialize are high will act as a wonderful role model for
the younger generation. Do you agree?
83
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Smart hiring in start-ups
Learning objective:
• To understand the hiring techniques adopted by budding entrepreneurs.
On 17th August 2016, Ola has sacked 700 employees from a company called Taxi for
Sure – a company that it had acquired a few months ago. Reports say that in the current
season, start-ups have slashed 3500 jobs – this is a number that doesn’t augur well for the
future of entrepreneurship in India. The problem is that the start-ups are in a mad rush to
hire without doing a proper due diligence and soon when there is a down turn, handing
out the pink slips becomes an inevitable option. The same scene is getting played out year
after year and unfortunately there is no statutory regulation that can protect the rights of
the white collared employee.
Hiring is one of the important challenges faced by start-ups. Start-ups often lack capital
and they fail to procure institutional credit when they need. Secondly, they face shortage
of infrastructure and their marketing efforts do not bear fruit due to lack of competence
within the organization. So, hiring and talent management become important to ensure
that their strategic plans are implemented as per plan.
The average age of an Indian entrepreneur in the start-up ecosystem is between 25 and 35
years and it is clear that some of the start-ups lack the wisdom to sustain their business
in the long run. While entrepreneurs need to take a fair amount of risk, they cannot be
blinded by ambition. This is what is happening in the Indian start up space now. Almost
anyone worth his salt aspires to be an entrepreneur. While one is not sure how much of
this thinking is driven by passion, it is clear that earning money quickly seems to be an
important criterion for a youngster to enter the startup space. Anything that achieves success
far too soon may not be able to sustain it. This is what has happened in the case of Flipkart
and this is what happened when the dotcom bubble burst in the 2000s.
Ola has saved Rs 30 crores by firing people or so it claims. When business is in a downward
spiral, all these HR philosophies are thrown out of the window in the shortest possible time.
Business sense precedes egalitarianism. This pluralism in start-ups is difficult to fathom. On
one hand, they talk nineteen to the dozen about the potential of their employees and on
the other hand they lose no time in showing them the door. With smart hiring strategies,
such situations can definitely be avoided.
84
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Smart hiring in start-ups
SELECTING RIGHT
Today the avenues for interviewing and selecting a candidate are manifold. You have
Skype, conference calls, Google hangout where the candidate can be interviewed by HR in
a convenient time and space domain. However sourcing and selecting the right candidate
continues to baffle HR professionals. With Gen Y, the job aspirations are so difficult to
match. Today’s generation looks forward to a stimulating work environment more than a
fantastic pay.
Rather than selecting candidates in a hurry (haste is waste anyway) it makes sense to talk
to the candidate to gauge if there is a proper fit. Only experienced recruiters can do this
and not someone who thinks he is the best recruiter because he got a HR degree the day
before. It is natural to expect an employee to be trustworthy, reliable, honest, hardworking
etc. But does he have the fire in the belly? Does he have the passion to contribute his best
to the organization?
The organization must show the new-age candidates the bigger picture than presenting an
ambitious sales target. The vision and mission of the organization must be explained carefully.
The long term aspirations of the organization must be clearly articulated to the candidate.
This is where HR specialists who are experts in background referencing can play a vital
role. They can help in screening the right candidates so that productive time of HR is not
lost in contacting the wrong selection targets. It is also unfair to expect that the success of
a candidate in one organization can be exactly replicated in another organization.
Today’s Gen Y employees aspire to contribute their efforts towards achievement of social
and environmental objectives besides objectives to be achieved in the normal course of
business. So, influencing them with the right and smart strategies is important to ensure
that such (good) candidates not only join the start-ups but also contribute their best. Such
candidates need to be provided an environment that is fecund for their career growth and
for meeting their professional aspirations.
The days of hegemony are over. A pragmatic approach is what is needed in recruitment and
selection. Smart hiring is the solution.
85
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Emotional intelligence revisited
27 EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE
REVISITED
In 2004 while I was working for the research centre in Castrol, there was a leadership
transition happening in the centre. As a performance manager I was asked to facilitate a
workshop based on the management book – “Fish”. The new incumbent who was all set to
head the research centre wanted to energize the team by conducting this workshop. While
we were discussing the plans to conduct this workshop in a 5-star hotel near Powai, he
casually mentioned about emotional intelligence as a stress management technique.
Intrigued, I tried to explore more into the subject and found out that Daniel Coleman
had written a seminal book on the subject. But by then my reading habits had become so
poor that I couldn’t push myself into reading mounds and mounds of pages on the subject.
Ten years have passed since the workshop was conducted. So many things changed around
me – some that were good, some that were not so good. Yet the main lesson from “Fish”
has stayed with me ever since – “You do not have a choice about what you want to do,
but you do have a choice about how you do what is assigned to you”.
86
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Emotional intelligence revisited
Coming back to emotional intelligence, I had forgotten all about it until last year when I
was assigned to teach the subject of “Managerial Communication” for the first time. Before
the scheduled class on emotional intelligence, I was ready with the presentation on EI after
reading about it from a few books and research papers.
“Ek Kahani” (One Story) was a television serial telecast by the national broadcaster in
the early ’80s. Directed by the immensely talented Manju Singh, the serial featured one
short story in every episode. Manju was associated with Doordarshan for a long time and
she played a memorable role as Amol Palekar’s younger sister in the Bollywood comedy
“Golmaal” (1979).
India is land of unity in diversity. We have so many languages and cultures and it is difficult
to pick up award winning stories from the body of work in Indian literature. Manju Singh
had to perform this unenviable feat. This episode of “Ek Kahani” featured a Sindhi story.
It was, if I remember correctly, shot in Chembur in Mumbai. My memories are vague, yet
I am recollecting whatever I remember.
A young boy comes to live with his uncle for a few days during vacations and soon enough
he witnesses something strange happening in his neighborhood. This boy sees a middle-
aged man who stays in the opposite flat leaving home in the morning for office. He is at
his cherubic best as he waves good bye to his wife and children but things change for the
worse when he returns home in the evening.
As soon as he enters home in the evening, he starts shouting at his wife and yells at her.
Vessels roll in the household. This has now become an everyday affair. The boy’s uncle
cautions him and tells him not to poke in the personal affairs of others. But this boy is
determined to help the middle-aged uncle.
Over a period of time he manages to confront this neighbor, takes him to his doctor friend
and then the truth is revealed that this middle-aged neighbor is having a haranguing time
at his office. His boss is abusing him ceaselessly and he returns home like a wounded tiger
and attacks his poor family who become the unsuspecting victims.
87
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Emotional intelligence revisited
As this man is not highly qualified, he has his reservations about getting another job and
puts up with this abuse day in and day out. He simply does not know how to handle his
emotions. Thanks to the boy and his doctor friend, the neighbor is given a sagely advice
for overcoming this problem.
Now every evening after he returns home, this neighbor locks himself up in a room and
hits at a pillow with all his force assuming the pillow to be his boss. After venting out his
fury against the pillow, he comes out of the room – relieved and relaxed. Now this man has
learnt to handle his emotions. The last scene of the episode showed a happy family thanks
to the head of the family having learnt how to manage his emotions.
This example is only a slice of what EI is all about. EI is about managing your emotions and
also trying to understand emotions of others. EI and empathy are complementary. Greater is
the sense of empathy that you have, greater is the demonstration of emotional intelligence.
88
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Placement agencies
28 PLACEMENT AGENCIES
Learning objective:
• To review the role played by placement agencies in supporting the recruitment
efforts of organization.
• To learn about the process for selecting the placement consultant who can be a
right fit for the organization.
For HR managers who run short of time to pore through several resumes to recruit and
select the right candidate, a placement agency can be great help. Sadly the mushrooming of
placement agencies in India hasn’t resulted in productive support to HR functions. There
are too many placement agencies that masquerade as consultants with a bevy of people who
may or may not be talented. Some of these agencies extract money both from candidates
and organizations. There are so many foot soldiers out there that run placement agencies
with bare minimum resources but seldom do they get the attention that they deserve.
Let us look at the factors that a HR manager should consider before selecting the right
placement agency/consultant.
1. Don’t go by size
Often HR managers get impressed with the office atmospherics and staff strength in a
placement consultant‘s office. But they need to remember that greater the size, greater
will be the price that will be charged. Size cannot be the sole criterion.
89
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Placement agencies
not deliver anything except a great sales talk. It is vital to remember that matching a
candidate’s skill set with that of the requirements of the job is not like hailing a cab or a
taxi through an app. It is much more than that.
Imagine a scenario when a candidate is not interested in a posting outside his place of
residence. If the placement consultant is oblivious of this detail, he will only be wasting
the HR manager’s time if the posting is outside the city.
To sum up
Technology-enabled recruitment and selection of employees may be the reality today but
the HR manager should never ever ignore the hunch or the intuitive part of the process. A
calibrated reading of a person’s profile coupled with the placement agencies’ recommendations
complemented by the background reference checking will ensure selection of the right
candidate. This will not only save the HR manager’s time and effort but will also ensure
a proper fit between the candidate’s aspirations and the demands of the job. This is why
selection of the right placement agency becomes crucial.
90
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Bespoke headhunting
29 BESPOKE HEADHUNTING
Learning objective:
This chapter will introduce you to the fundamental concepts of head hunting.
The euphoria over India as a happening place is increasing day by day. Cynics believe that it
is all hype. Even the western world is smart enough and there is no point in deriding others
to stake your claim as a growing economy. The difference between India and developed
economies is that in India talent is cheaper than in the West. So, how is it for head hunters
in this scheme of things? The size of the hiring market in India is roughly about $14 billion.
Is this the time to be gung-ho about the prospects of headhunting?
Be that as it may, Indian headhunters are now swamped with calls from multi-national
corporations (MNCs) in other countries. So, why is there a keen interest in recruiting Indian
managers? Many MNCs believe that Indian managers are adaptable, have a high sense of
responsibility, are dependable and can work in ambiguous situations. Their ambidexterity
is what appeals to the MNCs the most.
91
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Bespoke headhunting
But selection of the right candidate can be a painful process according to a head hunter
based in Chennai. Lata Balachander says, “Headhunting is not easy as people presume it
to be. You need to know what the customer really wants. MNCs want CEOs who have
already worked in a structured environment. As regards entrepreneurs, the buck stops with
them. Head hunters need to know how to deal with entrepreneurs. Indian giants often want
CEOs who think like an entrepreneur but then the question is – why would candidates
who think like entrepreneurs want a job in a company as a CEO?”
Employees who have worked in a structured environment will find it almost impossible to
work in a start-up in an unstructured set up where the founder-entrepreneur has the last
word on everything. It is the headhunter’s job to screen candidates carefully. Otherwise, a
wrong selection can be disastrous for everyone – the client, the candidate and the headhunter.
Today, job portals have become the refuge for scouting for candidates for lower and middle
level positions. Linked In has become a popular tool to scout for candidates at the higher
level. But headhunting is not just about scouting and looking for probable candidates.
The companies have to be clear about what they want. This clarity has to be imbibed by
the headhunter and the vision must be translated to the potential candidates. When the
needs of the companies and the candidates match, the head hunter, has, in all probability,
scored a goal. Often a reluctant candidate becomes interested in a potential opportunity
only because the money is interesting.
Every aspect of head hunting revolves around the needs of the clients. So it makes sense to
offer bespoke solutions. MNCs hiring CEOs are more concerned about the learning curve
of CEOs. Says Lata, “In MNCs, the CEOs are expected to deliver right from day one. This
may vary from one company to another in terms of degree of expectations. Using tools like
LinkedIn to select the funnel of probable candidates, the head hunter has to relentlessly
work in selecting the right candidate for such set ups”.
Is head hunting only about looking at Linked In profiles? Lata refutes this and says, “Head
hunting is about elimination. It is about selection. This can happen only when the head
hunter has done sufficient research which can be a time-consuming process. From the basket
of 10–15 profiles, the head hunter has to narrow down the choices to a maximum of two
or three profiles. Decision making often needs a gut feel which comes through experience.
A head hunter needs to have a backup, a plan B. Otherwise nasty surprises at the last
moment can be unnerving. No wonder head hunting is a highly stressful job. It may take
up to 4–6 months to select the right candidate”.
92
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Bespoke headhunting
There are headhunters who have met probable candidates in the most bizarre places – coffee
shops, jogging parks, temples and spiritual meetings. Meeting the candidates in an informal
setting is highly recommended.
Interviewing candidates and selection of the candidate are critical processes in the value
chain. Jack Welch (GE) believed in spending personal time with the executives whom
he recruited. Often the gap between the CEO and the next level person can be huge in
terms of the pay packet. The next level person could be the one who is in the forefront for
resolving operational bottlenecks.
Some of the online portals have CEOs who are in the age bracket of 30–35. These CEOs
seek COO candidates who are in the age bracket of 23–27. There is abundant talent out
there in this age bracket. Today it is no longer about hiring only experienced people as
COOs as they may be luddites and may lack the chutzpah to get the work done from the
Gen Y crowd. Tech savvy Gen Y candidates who have the burning desire to excel are being
sought after by companies for leadership roles who want to up the ante when it comes to
exploiting the creative energies of its work population.
Today, age has truly become a mere number. The headhunters know this only too well.
The head hunter then prepares a directory of possible candidates whom he can target. The
head hunter may use different approaches like meeting the candidate informally in social
93
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Bespoke headhunting
gatherings, sending him feelers through inner circles or approaching him through social
media networks like Linked In. The initial reaction of the candidate will be negative. He
will even put off the head hunter with sarcasm. Yet the head hunter will stoop to generate a
recommendation from such a candidate by telling him, “Recommend a candidate who is like
you”. By this strategy, the head hunter will increase the list of candidates whom he should
meet. After eliminating those who are stubborn and at times rude, the head hunter will
zero in on possible candidates who initially will react positively at 5% of the expectations.
Then slowly the rapport is built up. Strict assertion of confidentiality by the head hunter
will generate further intimacy with the candidate. In due course, the candidate will be
informed about the company, the management, the background, the hierarchy etc and
candidate will be advised to define a swot (strengths, weaknesses, opportunities & threats)
method to find his suitability for the new company. This SWOT analysis will be reviewed
by the head hunter and candidate. This is the first step which may prove to be a harbinger
to reach finality. Normally for very senior positions, the MD of the company will meet the
candidate in a five star hotel and using this brief discussion both will develop a rapport.
From then on, the process gets faster. The appointment gets concluded.
94
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Bespoke headhunting
Normally engineers who are satisfied in this job will never read advertisements or circulate
their bio-data through job portals. In the present case, the head hunter after locating the
most nearest plant where Wartsila diesel engine is supplied, goes to the city, telephones the
company during the lunch hour and gets connected to the canteen and asks the canteen
man to connect him to the power plant man who is having a lunch there. The canteen
man in all sincerity calls a man who is in the power plant on the phone and the head
hunter develops a rapport with him and invites him for dinner in a nearby hotel and says
confidentially, “We will talk later”. This meeting which takes place is the beginning and
culminates in the appointment of the person.
Normally ex employees of companies will give lead to most eligible candidates to the head
hunter. Of course, the ex employee will expect some reward in return.
Head hunting essentially begins with elimination of those candidates whom the head hunter
has listed as probable candidates and who are curt, non responsive, rude, impolite and who
openly admit that they are not interested in changing their job. Another head hunter Mrs.
Mangala Parashuraman says that she eliminates those who are always job hopping.
Out of those who remain in the list with some speed, further contacts are established and
a quick judgment is made after meeting a few of them. Finally those who are positively
looking for a change will be met and informed about the company. In this process, eventually
a candidate is selected.
Did head hunters experience any last mile delivery issues? Mr. D Ganapathy, Mumbai-based
headhunter with 2 decades of experience in head hunting says, “I have come across people
who accept the letter of appointment and back off. They use this letter as a negotiating
tactic for higher salary and position in the present organization where they work”. He also
adds that head hunters caution such candidates not to follow such strategies as these will
not work in the candidate’s favor in the long run.
Is the big money that they get the only incentive for head hunters? Mr. Ganapathy refutes
this and says that, “The appreciation of the candidate for having placed him in an appropriate
role in a good organization is a greater incentive than money”. Such candidates also help
the head hunter in suggesting right candidates for the head hunter’s next assignments.
95
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Bespoke headhunting
So what is the latest trend in head hunting? Head hunters are also used by candidates to
locate companies in which they aspire to work. The candidate gives the list of companies
which the head hunter should concentrate. So, head hunting is no longer about hunting
“heads”, it is also about hunting “companies”. So, how is this trend different from a candidate
going to a placement agency?
Mangala says, “When you approach a placement agency, you don’t specify the companies
that you wish to work for. Essentially those who approach a placement agency or a HR
consultant or job portals are those who are active job seekers – those who are seriously
contemplating a job change”. The high fliers who approach the head hunters are not active
job seekers and they can afford to be choosy about the companies that they may wish to
work for. Once they land the dream job, such candidates reward the head hunter handsomely.
Purbi Kamat, a head hunter based in Pune, says, “A head hunter has to be a people person.
He should have a never-say-die approach. He needs to have HR skills, sales and marketing
skills to attract the right candidate. There can be no question of compromise on ethical
values or values like integrity. Otherwise, reputational damage will kill a headhunter’s career.”
96
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Reference checking: an effective tool for HR managers
30 REFERENCE CHECKING:
AN EFFECTIVE TOOL
FOR HR MANAGERS
Learning objectives:
1. To understand the need for reference checking as a tool for HR managers.
2. To learn the benefits of reference checking.
As technology evolves it presents opportunities and challenges to all functions and the HR
function is by no means an exception. There are various tools available to HR managers
to recruit and select candidates – psychographic test, referrals from existing employees or
exiting employees, social media profiles, profile, past employer, track record of employment
history etc. But there have been cases when all this information proved to be insufficient
to determine the integrity of a prospective employee. Businesses are now giving lots of
thrust to ethical behavior at work and so the process of reference checking assumes great
significance for the HR manager.
97
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Reference checking: an effective tool for HR managers
98
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Dipping morale in organizations
31 DIPPING MORALE IN
ORGANIZATIONS
Learning objective:
• To appreciate the fact that organizational morale can dip.
• To identify the reasons for dipping morale in organizations.
• To review the deleterious effects of dipping morale.
• To study and evaluate the corrective actions needed.
Low employee morale can be a cause of concern not just for the employees but for also the
business. Unhappy employees are not productive and in customer facing organizations this
can present significant problems in the quality of service rendered to customers.
Changing Goals
Though it might sound like a cliché, goal posts cannot keep on changing. If employees
cannot see the relation between their goals and overall mission of the company, they are
bound to get demoralized.
Performance Reviews
All of us undergo annual health checkups. Does it mean that we should ignore our health
at other times? Performance Reviews must be on-going though the formal mechanism for
conducting a performance appraisal can be arranged twice in a year.
99
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Dipping morale in organizations
Wasted Potential
Nothing is a bigger crime than wasting talent. This can happen if people are over qualified
for a job or if they have been promised something during the interview and given some
other portfolio after joining the organization. Deteriorating boss-subordinate relations can
also lead to bias and subordinates may be sidelined. This can only massage the ego of the
boss. It will do little to take the business forward.
Poor delegation is an anathema for success of a leader. A leader who does not delegate and
wishes to grab all the work himself is not leaving any elbow room for developing potential
human capital.
100
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Does 360 degree feed back always work?
Learning objectives:
1. To study the need for a 360 degree feedback mechanism.
2. To review the objectives of 360 degree feedback.
3. To understand the pre-requisites for a 360-degree feedback process.
4. To learn about the pitfalls of the 360 degree feedback mechanism.
Introduction
360 Degree Feedback is a system or process in which employees receive confidential,
anonymous feedback from their colleagues. This typically includes the employee’s manager,
peers, and direct reports. In some cases, feedback is also sought from customers and suppliers.
An anonymous online feedback form needs to be filled up in which the questions centre
on workplace competencies.
The forms have questions that are measured on a rating scale. In most cases, there is an
option for providing subjective feedback as well. There is also a self-appraisal by the employee
who is receiving the feedback in which the questions are similar. The idea is to give a clear
picture about what the employee thinks about himself vis-à-vis what others think about
him. The ultimate goal of a 360 degree feedback is to improve individual performance in a
manner that can impact the business performance in a positive manner. But does it always
work? Where are the gaps?
101
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Does 360 degree feed back always work?
system needs an additional follow-up mechanism to ensure that the respondents have taken
the feedback survey. Today, it is estimated that over 1/3rd of all the firms in the US use some
form of feedback to enhance the performance of their leaders.
Some organizations use the 360 degree system to appraise individual performance but
critics point out that this is not a good strategy. The 360 degree feedback focuses more on
individual behaviors and competencies and less on basic skills, job-based competencies and
ability to meet the performance objectives. A performance appraisal is an evaluation of the
individual’s performance by the immediate line manager. However, the 360 degree feedback
can be a subset of the individual performance appraisal process.
Thus, the core objectives of a 360 degree feedback process is to assess the behavioral
competencies of the individual – for example listening skills, planning skills, goal setting,
ability to work in teams and leadership effectiveness.
Planning the process is another crucial step. This is also an indication to the employees that
the organization is serious about the process and its implementation. A reasonable time
needs to be given to respondents so that they can give quality inputs.
102
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Does 360 degree feed back always work?
The things that are being measured need to be aligned with the organization’s mission,
vision and long term strategy. As with any initiative, such exercises need the support of
the top management so that it sends the right signal across the organization. Taking both
the individual as well as the respondents into confidence is a must. If the objectives of the
exercise are understood, then half the battle is won.
Many instances have been reported where employees are afraid to give honest feedback
because they experience a feeling of paranoia that their responses will not be taken in the
right spirit. An effective communication strategy will help combat this fear. This is also one
of the reasons why many organizations have outsourced the 360 degree feedback system
to a third party.
Negative feedback can always become counterproductive. This needs to be dealt with tact.
Rather than provide negative feedback, it is essential to provide constructive feedback. If
you fail to do anything with the data, you have wasted your time as well as the time of
both participants and respondents. Every person who receives feedback needs to create some
developmental goals based on the feedback he or she received – and remember – those goals
need to be both measurable and achievable.
103
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Does 360 degree feed back always work?
Developmental goals are meaningless unless people are held accountable for achieving
them. Generally, a follow up is done either semi-annually or annually to ensure that the
individual is working towards achievement of the development goals as envisaged in the
post completion phase of the 360 degree feedback process.
On the flip side, it is unfair to expect overnight changes in behavior after implementation
of the 360 degree process. Expectations from the exercise have to be realistic. Some firms
have used this process to support layoffs – in which case, the entire objective of the exercise
gets defeated.
There is also an inherent risk that the evaluators use it as a means to get even. Feedback can
hurt as the evaluators aren’t nice or positive or untrained in giving constructive feedback.
Evaluators can end up giving abstruse feedback.
Conflicting opinions compound the confusion. How to decide who is right? How accurate
and reliable and uncolored is the feedback? If respondent doesn’t like the person whom he is
evaluating, it is possible that he might equivocate. If the feedback isn’t truthful, it isn’t useful.
Managers who receive the feedback resolve to change but seldom take corrective actions
to meet the development goals. Those leaders who have strong personalities often become
the victim of “I-am-the-best” syndrome and will tend to look down upon the responses
condescendingly. Paucity of time can led to dithering from the commitment made by the
leaders. It is tempting to slip back into the usual behavior.
104
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Does 360 degree feed back always work?
105
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Gen Y: Is Maslow’s theory still valid?
33 GEN Y: IS MASLOW’S
THEORY STILL VALID?
Learning objective:
• To review the validity of Abraham Maslow’s motivational theory for Generation Y.
Abraham Maslow’s motivation theory talks about the needs of human beings that can be
constructed as a pyramid. Individuals are concerned about their basic physiological needs.
Once these needs are satisfied, individuals move on to the next level which is the need for
security – be it job security, financial security or personal security. The next need up on
the hierarchy is the need to socialize with others. If social needs are met, then the next
level is about meeting self-esteem needs where the individual craves for recognition from
others. The last need on the Maslow hierarchy is about self-actualization – exploitation of
potential. Pursuit of this can be akin to pursuing a mirage.
The key question is: Is the Maslow model still applicable for the present generation especially
Gen Y? Times have changed since Maslow introduced his model in the year 1943. What
drives individuals today is rather difficult to understand and relate to especially if you are
from another generation.
Social needs and self esteem needs seem to be dominating the spectrum of needs even as
security needs are being relegated to the background. Look at the popularity of social media
networking tools. This is clearly a reflection of changing norms and behaviors.
Money is no longer the only motivator. Even though 100% job satisfaction is impossible
to achieve, people are striving for the same. Technological advances have boosted the
confidence of Gen Y. Despite complaints about information overload, the easy accessibility
of information is a great driver of human behavior.
Gen Y resists anything that is imposed on them. They do not want to be control freaks
or perfection-addicts. They are also selective readers. They question age old traditions and
norms and are rebels in their own right. Having seen how the previous generation has fared,
they tend to think that discipline curbs freedom. But what they have failed to understand
is that discipline gives you more freedom.
Youngsters are now looking at the fun quotient in a job. This is why companies like Google
top the list of “great places to work”. Routine and monotonous jobs are either being shunned
106
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Gen Y: Is Maslow’s theory still valid?
or people set a time frame for doing such chores. Gen Y thus believes in enjoying life more.
Staying in an organization for more than two or three years is not considered a wise strategy.
Once a job ceases to be challenging, they start looking for the next challenge which can
drive them up the wall. They look for excitement in terms of the new projects offered –
working with cross-cultural teams or working in foreign locations is a big plus. As they
say, the world is their oyster and they wish to relish every moment. Gen Y simply cannot
do away without their gadgets. Logging onto social networking tools is a must for meeting
the social and self esteem needs.
Though Maslow’s theory is still valid decades after it was first introduced, the model needs
tweaking to make it more contemporary.
107
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Compensation management & pay parity
34 COMPENSATION MANAGEMENT
& PAY PARITY
Learning objectives:
• To review the factors that can affect compensation management.
Compensation is one of the important factors that influence the motivation of employees
in an organization. But when organizations plan the compensation schemes, they have to
consider a number of factors. Pay structures are designed in accordance with judgments
about job values in comparison with other jobs, and markets rates of pay for comparable
jobs. These judgments are made against the background of the factors which influence job
values. Job values may be established by using some form of job evaluation.
1. Organizational Provisions
Organizational provision states that the level of compensation largely depends upon
organizational operating policies and procedures. It is because the policies serve as a
guideline for formulating and implementing compensation plans and programs. Moreover,
organizational regulations, plans, objectives, ability for pay etc. also affect the level of pay.
2. Government Regulations
In order to protect the working class from wage exploitation by strong employers, the
government enacts various laws and judicial decisions. Such laws and regulations affect
compensation management. Because, they emphasize on minimum wage rate, overtime
rate, working hours, equal pay for equal work, payment of bonus, etc. So, an organization
has to design its pay system as per the government rules and regulations.
3. Equity Considerations
Equity considerations hold the philosophy that the compensation system should be fair
and equitable. It means the compensation system should be similar for the same type of
work within the organization. Similarly, it should be fair relative to what other people get
for the similar job in another organization. It is important because any imbalance between
what the employees contribute and what they obtain as return would lead to greater job
dissatisfaction, employee turnover and absenteeism.
108
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Compensation management & pay parity
4. Union Pressure
Labour unions are pressure groups that work in the interest of the workers. Such unions
lobby the management for the formulation of fair compensation plans. These organized
unions can ensure better wages for employees.
6. Cost of Living
Compensation is concerned with an overall return that an employee obtains from the
organization for rendering contributions towards organization objectives. Therefore, the
payment should be adequate to maintain the cost of living of the employees. Hence, the
employer should manage compensation viewing the cost of living of each individual.
7. Organizational Positions
Sometimes, the organization itself evaluates where it is in order to prepare compensation
plans. The position of the organization is determined by its productivity i.e. if the
productivity of the worker is high, it assess itself as a higher position. As a consequence
of it, the compensation system is determined at a higher level. Contrary to it, in case of
lower productivity, wages/salary rates tend to be low. Thus, any shift in productivity and
employee performance has direct impact on the wage level of the organization.
8. Productivity of Workers
Another factor of compensation management is the productivity of workers. This is the
new concept of linking pay with employee performance. Under it, if the workers are
highly productive, they get high compensation as compared to less productive workers.
Productivity is a key factor as it enhances organization’s image and status.
109
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL A good boss, handsome salary or career growth
A good boss, a handsome salary or career growth – this can be a difficult choice indeed.
An ideal situation would be to have all three. But then it will be too much to ask, isn’t it?
The world that we are living in is full of imperfections. The key challenge for all of us is to
achieve success despite all these constraints. No one can claim to be perfect in this world.
The extent of perfection can only be relative – there can never be any absolute definition of
perfection. Every leader has his inadequacies and shortcomings. Sometimes, the battle in the
mind of a leader is to seek an ideal balance between adopting employee-friendly approach
and a business-friendly approach. He faces the challenge of straddling between both worlds.
110
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL A good boss, handsome salary or career growth
Being accommodative to employees need not signal the end of business performance.
If it was so, we would not have had so many modern concepts in the field of human
resources today. Flexi timing, a sustained effort to promote work-life balance, efforts taken
by organizations to train employees and enable the latter to sharpen their saw, work from
home options, willingness of business to go back to the drawing board if it is needed to
protect human capital – the field of human resources has truly evolved today. The cost of
retaining a self-motivated and productive employee is far less than hiring a new employee,
training him and acclimatizing him to the organization’s culture.
The meaning of the word “good boss” can have several interpretations – depending on the
context. Is a good boss someone who always sanctions leave whenever you need it? Is a good
boss someone who allows you to take a day off despite the fact that you have important
meetings scheduled? Is a good boss someone who is kind to you to ensure that you are able
to meet your family commitments? Is a good boss someone who never reprimands you? The
balance between the humanitarian qualities and leadership qualities of a boss is important.
A good leader need not be nice to you. A good leader, who has interest and welfare of a
sub-ordinate in his mind, will not hesitate to point out his follower’s flaws when needed.
A good leader will also not hesitate to appreciate a subordinate’s outstanding performance.
There is a thin line between a ‘boss’ and a ‘leader’. One can stretch it a bit and say that a
boss is more like a task-oriented manager who can’t see beyond the immediateness of the
tasks at hand. Whereas a leader is someone who thinks beyond, has the vision and ability
to demonstrate inclusive and inspirational leadership!
A boss prides on the authority and the positional power the authority gives. It is up to the
boss to channelize this authority in the right direction to ensure his transition to an effective
leader. Often, the authority can lead to vanity which brings along with it a destructive
streak. This is the phase when the boss loses the chance to grow in his career due to wrong
perceptions about the authority bestowed upon him.
A good boss shows you the picture of the future. A good boss will never be able to track
the distinction between his roles as a boss, as a leader and as a mentor. All these roles will
blend seamlessly to characterize his professional working style.
111
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL A good boss, handsome salary or career growth
Anyone who works in the corporate world to achieve a rank in the popularity charts is only
deceiving the business. For business, it is all about profits and growth. So, a good boss is
one who never forgets that business performance is integral to his success as a leader.
A new theory that is already emerging is that of circumstantial leadership. More than the
experience, it is the situations in the corporate world that shape the leadership qualities.
Sometimes, challenges can bring out the best in a person and make him aware about the
inherent abilities that he possessed but never knew or never had a chance to utilize.
To sum it up
Fortunate are those who get a good boss early in their careers. Even more fortunate are
those who are able to grow in their career under the tutelage of a boss who happens to
be a great driving force in charting the career of his sub ordinate in the right direction. A
handsome salary then becomes an added bonus. But without the influence of a good boss
and a clear cut career growth plan, an attractive remuneration only serves a limited purpose
in increasing personal wealth, as it deprives one of good mental health. Wasting talent is a
crime that the corporate world unabashedly commits. Amongst the three parameters, every
individual must therefore choose career growth as the most important parameter as the other
two (having a good boss, earning a handsome salary) is outside his influence and control.
If an individual works diligently in enhancing his career prospects, money will follow. In
that case, having a great boss will prove to be a jewel in the crown.
112
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Dealing with frenemies in the work place
In this chapter, I would like to explore what the term “Frenemy” actually means and how
can one deal with them in the work place.
Frenemy is a portmanteau of “friend” and “enemy” that can refer to an enemy who pretends
to be your friend. The term can also refer to someone who is really your friend but also a
rival. Work environments are becoming more and more informal and the lines between an
individual’s professional and personal relations with a colleague often get blurred.
In a 24×7 work environment where stress to prove oneself in the workplace has increased
manifold and where performance has become the crucial determinant of professional success
in an organization, relationships tend to develop between colleagues even outside of the
113
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Dealing with frenemies in the work place
work environment. In a performance driven work culture, the number of hours put in by
an employee has also increased. This leaves little time for developing friendships outside
of work.
There is one category of employees in organizations who may be aptly labeled as “tale
carriers”. They are adept and adroit in carrying tales to the boss by adding their own version
of the news sourced from the grapevine. Needless to add, these employees form part of the
“inner circle” of the leader’s core team. The leaders depend on them for getting some real
time, on-the-ground information.
I have encountered many of them in my professional career and believe me; at times they
can actually scare you, with the amount of misinformation that they can pass onto the boss,
under the guise of “providing information”. With such colleagues, one has to be circumspect
about what to speak. On the humorous side, if you want some information to reach the
boss, you know whom to talk to. So, it actually works in both ways.
In 99 cases out of 100, the corporate world is full of such “tale carriers” who actually
taste professional success due to their proximity with the leader. I do not want to pull any
punches here, but the truth is that, despite all the talk about performance, only those who
are able to develop better inter personal skills with the leadership team, can hope to attain
a modicum of success in an organization, especially during the initial period.
In today’s networked world, with the advent of social media and opportunities to interact
with global teams, developing interpersonal skills with the immediate superior is not enough.
One has to gain enough visibility in the corporate world to get noticed. Good leaders who
are also mentors often act as a catalyst in giving a lift to the career prospects of their protégés.
Mumbai-based HR consultant Mr. Ganapathy Dharmarajan says, “In the corporate world,
it is not enough to be honest, you have to also appear as honest”. He cites an instance of a
chartered account in one of the firms where he worked who climbed up the popularity charts
in the organization by devising ingenuous ways of evading tax. The top management team
simply loved him (did someone say – ethics in the workplace? – but wasn’t that confined
to the scrap bin long ago?), believed every word of what he said, rewarded him handsomely
and made this employee encroach upon each and every function in the organization – HR,
Sales & Marketing, Purchase (to name a few).
The HR function in the above organization was affected the most as HR heads can seldom
hope their voice of reason to be heard by top management amidst the din and allure generated
by such sweet talkers. The said employee’s interventions in the organizational decision
114
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Dealing with frenemies in the work place
making processes soon became intrusions. But he tasted success for quite some time (close
to a decade) before he moved to the US. In the process, he managed to earn his millions.
This employee called everyone in the organization his friend but what he did behind their
backs was enough to make them lose their self confidence and tranquility. The fact that
this was an Indian organization actually worked in his favor. This desire of the employee to
overpower all others in the senior management team actually made them pallid and some
of them had no option but to put in their papers.
Leaders often talk about team dynamics and change management to bring about course
correction in the business. But such frenemies undo all the good work done by other
colleagues and are primarily driven only by their self-interest. Politics is endemic in all
organizations. This provides a fillip to the antics of the frenemies. Worst, some of them
are in the good books of the leadership team and their shadow authority only aggravates
matters. In the context of such employees, only the egg-headed will believe it when CEOs
proclaim that they are equal opportunity employers.
Here are some tips to deal with frenemies in the work place:
1. Do not talk anything about your personal life to anyone in your organization –
howsoever close he/she may be to you. Sometimes, it pays to follow Greta Garbo’s logic.
Your weaknesses/problems in your personal life can actually add to your vulnerability.
2. There has to be some enigma about you, something unique about you that should
help you in your personal branding exercise.
3. Identify the frenemies – they are the ones who actually pay you a compliment for
the wrong reason, gossip about you and when confronted will try to pretend that
they are saints.
4. Be wary of people who talk about others to you. They can talk about you too
to others…
5. There are some friends who sound genuinely happy with your success. Some
of them pretend to be happy but your intuition will guide you to see through
their superficiality.
6. If the frenemy’s actions are causing you injury and mental agony, you might as
well have a coffee table conversation with him or her in an informal setting. If the
frenemy shows little remorse and gives hints that he is not going to change, it is
better to withdraw yourselves.
7. There is a need to be professional at all times and our soured relation with a
colleague who has diabolical intentions should never come in the way of delivering
the tasks entrusted to us by the organization.
115
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Dealing with frenemies in the work place
8. Sometimes a frenemy’s actions may sound offending to you whereas in reality they
may be not. If your thinking is clouded, it is best to speak to someone whom you
can trust – it may be a friend who IS NOT working in the same organization, it
may be your dad or mom or even your spouse. These people will give a neutral
perspective on the matter. 9 out of 10 times they will be right and they will actually
help you connect the dots.
9. People who are blunt on your face NEED NOT be your enemies. Such people
actually help you to improve your weaknesses. People who are always sweet to you
and end up making sugary conversations with you NEED NOT be your well-
wishers. Remember – discretion is the better part of valor and whenever you are
confused, let the thought remain in cold storage until the point of time, when you
can revisit it to think about it in a concise manner.
10. Last but not the least, people are assets and one can still maintain a good relation
with frenemies in the work place by maintaining a reasonable distance from them.
Talk to the point – nothing more, nothing less. Try to develop friendships outside
the work place – you only need to keep your eyes and ears open to such possibilities.
116
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Impression management in organizations
37 IMPRESSION MANAGEMENT
IN ORGANIZATIONS
The theory of impression management was discovered in 1959 by Erving Goffman. The theory
reflected on the role played by interpersonal skills of an individual. How does an individual
actor in a particular set- up manage to influence the perception of others about him?
A keyword search in Google Scholar resulted in 1, 130, 000 results – shows how intensely
researched this topic is in the area of “Organizational behavior”.
Howsoever smart or diligent a person may be, if he/she is not savvy in impression management
the chances of him/her going far appear remote. Even for an entrepreneur, social capital
(the ability to form enduring social networks) is considered utmost essential.
I was once attending a lecture at Sydenham College where the speaker said that the person
claiming to be extremely busy is the one who has the most time in the world. How often
we see people claiming to be so busy that they can’t afford to pay attention to little details
whiling away their time in unproductive pursuits.
117
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Tale carriers
38 TALE CARRIERS
In every organization, there are some people who are always close to the boss. There are
some who maintain a distance from the boss. Some who are completely at loggerheads
with their bosses? The ones who are close to their bosses are often the beneficiaries of the
benevolent/benign grace of their respective bosses.
These employees who are close to the boss are often called – “The Inner Circle”. Some
prefer to call them – “The Core Task Force”. Managing the boss is something that the inner
circle is adept at. They get leave when they want, can talk to the boss 24×7 and get away
by doing less for more! But their lower productivity at work is taken care of by their agility
in keeping the boss informed about each and every event in the office. When the boss is
on leave or away on an official tour, he can trust the inner circle to keep him informed
about the goings-on in the office.
What are the characteristics of these tale carriers? How creative can they get in terms of
making things larger than they appear to be? “Impression management” is an academic area
that is witnessing lots of traffic in recent times as people struggle to explore the unique
traits of these special task force members.
118
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Tale carriers
6. While they work hard to improve their impression on the boss, they work doubly
hard to pull others down (albeit surreptitiously).
7. They are extremely possessive of their territory – no intruders are welcome!
8. Tale carriers are experts in making exaggerated claims about their work load. In
effect, they can market their work and market themselves more than the others.
(There are those souls who work hard and “not” smart and continue to be deprived
of what is due to them just because they have been unable to build bridges with
their bosses).
9. Tale carriers often poke their nose in the work of others with the mere intention
of pulling them down.
What happens to tale carriers when their boss is transferred or if the boss leaves the
organization? More often than not, a few tale carriers may lose out if the personality of the
new incumbent is radically different from his predecessor.
119
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Tale carriers
To sum up
Notwithstanding their qualities that can debilitate others, tale carriers have become an
integral part of an organization’s ecosystem. The truth is that the boss needs them as much
as they need him and this synergy is what makes their partnership a winning combination!
Way back in the ’70s Mc Clelland proposed the theory about the two faces of power (http://
bankofinfo.com/two-faces-of-power/#). It will be interesting to investigate which of these
faces of power has a greater influence on the success of tale carrying efforts!
120
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Five tips: should you quit your job?
Here are five simple tips that you should look at before taking that final decision to put
in your papers.
121
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Five tips: should you quit your job?
of someone’s wild imagination. But do not leave anything to chance. Keep your ears to
the ground. As an insider, you ought to know better. Do not believe the -” things will
be normal soon” blindly. The beginning of chaos in an organization signals the end of
rational thinking and logic. Be vigilant and start applying.
In such cases, the HR can do little except may be offer a few words of solace. If things
become too hot to handle, it is better to start exploring options. May be you have
something better in store for you.
122
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Writing a winning resume
Introduction
In this chapter we try to analyze the reasons why an effective resume is the most crucial
step in landing a job. We will also have a quick look at the key factors to be considered
while preparing a resume.
A well-crafted resume is the most important step in the process of searching for a job. A
resume that is written well can ensure that you get a call for an interview. The candidate’s
performance in the interview eventually determines if he succeeds in getting the job of
his choice.
1. Be clear about your objective in seeking a new job. Write down the objective on
a piece of paper, writing it, rewriting it and refining it as many times as you want
to make it sound professional.
2. Have a specific, concise and clear objective.
3. Customize the resume as per the job description, using the key words in the
job posting.
4. The objective should be followed by a summary of your skills (in bullet points),
educational summary and work experience that describes the skills.
123
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Writing a winning resume
5. While writing about the work experience, mention the period, name of the
organization, the position and the accomplishments on the job.
6. Many of us get carried away writing about the Key Result Areas or Job Responsibilities.
It is important to mention these along with accomplishments that are quantifiable.
For example: The job responsibility read as “Assigned to dispose of scrap” is routine
and vague. Does it tell anything about your skill and competence? Look at ways
of refining this statement as “Assigned to improve productivity of space: Disposed
off 90% scrap in a safe and organized manner over a period of four weeks and
generated revenue of Rs.x lakhs”.
7. Make your resume less wordy leaving adequate white spaces.
8. Never place your scanned photograph on the resume voluntarily.
9. There are mixed opinions about the length of a resume. Most of the views expressed
are absolute balder dash. We have a lot of experts saying that a resume is viewed
over 15 seconds and so a resume should not exceed one page. Do they understand
what 15 seconds means? Friends, do you really think anyone can do justice to a
resume evaluation in 15 seconds? This is mostly an exaggeration. Ideally, a resume
can be one to two pages and can extend to the third page if the person’s experience
is more than 10–15 years. It is always better to go by your instincts.
10. A resume is a powerful marketing weapon to showcase your talents to prospective
employers. Put yourself in the shoes of the reader and I am sure that you can come
up with a winning resume!
11. Do not use fancy words or fonts or colors in the resume. Do not use fancy e-mail
IDs like [email protected] or [email protected].
12. Use a simple font like Times New Roman (above 10) or Arial.
13. Avoid personal details like marital status, family background etc unless asked for.
14. The power of crafting an effective resume vests with the individual himself. But
this needs great concentration, the patience and perseverance to go through and
update the resume several times and seek feedback from colleagues, friends and
relatives. On quite a few occasions, we can hope to receive rare feedback/insight
from others which might have not occurred to us at all.
15. The job seeker may feel great about his achievements but if the prospective employer
doesn’t understand this or doesn’t need such skills, then there is a risk of all such
efforts going waste.
16. I strongly recommend writing a resume in a note pad using a pen and then editing
the draft several times in the next few days to make it more refined and professional.
17. Review the resume and give it to someone you know who can give you an
unbiased feedback.
18. Update the resume every three months.
19. Typos in a resume rob it of its utility value. It also projects a poor impression of
the job seeker as someone who is careless about paying attention to small details.
124
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Writing a winning resume
C – Concise, clear & clean – free of grammatical errors, spelling mistakes and typographical
errors; a resume that is less wordy and presents the information in an easy-to-read (bullet
points) style.
C – Convincing. If you as a job seeker are not convinced about the resume, how do you
expect the prospective employers to be convinced about it? Market yourself aggressively in
the resume but do not display it in a negative manner. To put it simply, briefly explain to
the prospective employer about the skills that you bring to the table if he hires you.
C – Cover letter. It makes sense to personally write the cover letter in your own handwriting
and scan it and send it as a soft copy. Use a separate cover letter for each vacancy that you
apply for.
The passion of the candidate must shine through while reading the resume. Use all the
creativity/ingenuity/out-of-box thinking to make your resume appealing.
125
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Writing a winning resume
Some experts advise that the CAR model be followed. CAR model talks about Challenge,
Action and Results. If you are flummoxed about what to write, sit in a secluded spot to
think through your strengths.
Some organizations encourage using the STAR model (S – Situation, T – Target, A – Action,
R – Results) to build your resume. The summary report written using the CAR model/
STAR model can be a useful feed to a superbly crafted resume.
Essentially there are two types of resumes – chronological and functional, of which the
former is more popular. The functional resumes are intended at a niche audience for certain
specific categories of jobs. Such resumes only highlight specific experiences. The chronological
resumes organize your work history by starting with the most recent job and then working
backward. The functional resumes deserve a more detailed review while the chronological
ones can benefit from general observations and feedback.
126
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Writing a winning resume
Today HR consultancy firms have mushroomed in every nook and corner. Most of them
seem to be paying peanuts to unskilled people whose only job is to send mass Emails
to candidates by doing a search on job portals. One doubts whether such people even
understand the job descriptions or candidate profiles. The turnover in these placement firms
is so huge that people change jobs in 3 months or 6 months. So, if you are hoping to get
a job through these dubious firms, then forget it! You should also know the reason why
the Emails that you send are never answered as the employees have left the firm and the
replacements do not have the intellectual capacity or competence to study your resume in
detail. It is too early to talk about the role of networking tools.
Many job portals are offering resume writing services. Carl Bradford, an executive recruiter
and trainer says that there is no need for resume writing services at all. He adds that in case
one wants to hire a professional resume writer, he needs to interact with them personally
and then impress on the writer about what separates a great resume from a good resume.
However, none of the professional writers want this. All of them insist on advance payment
and a copy of your current profile and believe that glamorizing your resume is all that is
required to make it professional.
There may be really good resume writers but they get camouflaged because of the fact that
resume writing service has become commoditized. There is no guarantee of good placements
even if you enlist such services. The best option is to work hard at creating an effective
resume all by you.
127
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Writing a winning resume
A well-crafted resume and the performance in a job interview will ensure how soon you
reach there. But what is due to you, will reach you – provided you have that intense desire
for the same. So, best of luck to all job aspirants!
What Color Is Your Parachute? 2014: A Practical Manual for Job-Hunters and Career-
Changers Paperback by Richard N. Bolles
128
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Appearing for an interview?
• Prior to the interview, read about the company thoroughly. Every company has a
web-site. Go through the web-site, know about the company’s vision, mission, the
top management team, the business structure, competition…every single thing that
you can lay your hands on.
• Having read the details, do a mind map of how your profile suits that company.
• Ask this question to yourself – What describes me? What skills do I bring to the
table? What is so unique about me? Try to correlate the unique qualities with the
job profile.
• Talk to others to extract information about the company.
• Keep a folder ready that has copies of your latest resume, a few passport photographs,
certificates and credentials.
• Try to write a one-page on “Why do I think I am the best person for this role?”
• A candidate should be able to connect the dots between past and present achievements
and use them to visualize a successful future career.
• Do as many mock interviews as possible practicing answers to questions like – “Tell
us something about yourself ”.
• Remember at all times – preparation is the key.
• Try to read information about the company that has appeared in newspapers and
business magazines. Does this information excite you about working for this company?
Then use the information in response to the questions asked during an interview.
Reach the interview venue on time. Dress formally and be presentable. Wearing a business
suit is highly recommended. Present a well-kept appearance. Carry a newspaper or a business
magazine with you while you wait for your turn. Do not be flustered if you are not called
during the appointed hour. Employers have this knack of testing your patience and if you
are able to come out of this unscathed, you have literally won half the battle.
Last but not the least, approach the battle with a winning attitude! The Universe will take
care of the next.
129
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Appearing for an interview?
A small amount of stress is normal. Candidates should remember that the line between
confidence and over-confidence is very thin. Vanity will spoil your chances of success.
1. Do a thorough research about the company and the position that you have applied for.
2. Do a mind mapping of how you will fit in the role given your experience and
educational background.
3. Practice answering some typical interview questions.
4. If you are not convinced about your suitability for the job, how can you expect
the employers to be confident about your abilities?
5. A good night’s sleep is important prior to attending the interview.
6. Always reach the venue before time. No amount of explanation about traffic jams
on the road or the story about how your bike broke down in the middle of the road
is going to help cut ice with the interview panel. If you are late for the interview,
prospective employers will assume that you are going to be late for work as well.
Remember: First impression is the lasting impression.
7. Have a light breakfast on the day of the interview. Do not overstuff yourself so
much that using a washroom becomes inevitable prior to the interview.
8. Appearances play an important role in the success of a candidate in an interview.
Unkempt appearances are a strict no. Dressing up for the occasion is important.
9. Mind your body language. Try to maintain a pleasant disposition. Maintain eye
contact with speakers as this shows that you are prepared for the interview.
10. Sit erect and offer a firm handshake both before and after the interview.
11. Projecting a calm demeanor is crucial for success. Breathing techniques aid the
relaxation process.
12. Speak slowly during the interview.
Candidates often get eliminated during the personal introduction phase due to lack of
presentation skills and inadequate planning/practice. Portray a picture of yourself that the
interviewer can easily relate to. Personal introduction is best done when the rate of speech
is moderate. One’s self-esteem can get a boost by rehearsing in front of the mirror.
130
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Appearing for an interview?
If a candidate follows the above steps religiously he can be assured of success in the interview.
Confidence of the candidate plays a very important role in facing an interview panel. Failures
are inevitable at times, but it is important to learn lessons from the experience so that one
can improve in the future.
Month 16
I was a construction Mo
supervisor ina const
I was
the North Sea super
advising and the No
Real work he
helping foremen advis
International
al opportunities
Internationa
�ree wo
work
or placements ssolve problems
Real work he
helping fo
International
Internationaal opportunities
�ree wo
work
or placements ssolve pr
131
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL The merits of career planning
Learning objectives:
1. To understand the dimensions of career planning.
2. To learn about the objectives of career planning.
3. To review the benefits of career planning.
4. To identify the components of career planning.
Career planning encourages individuals to explore and gather information, which enables
them to synthesize, gain competencies, make decisions, set goals and take action. It is a
crucial phase of human resource development that helps the employees in making strategy
for work-life balance.
Organizations also need to plan for their employees’ career development programmes.
Companies are designing career programmes in an effort to decrease employee turnover,
prevent job turnout and obsolescence, and improve the quality of employees’ work lives.
132
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL The merits of career planning
5. It ensures that senior management knows about the caliber and capacity of the
employees who can move upwards.
6. It can always create a team of employees prepared enough to meet any contingency.
7. Career planning reduces labour turnover.
8. Every organization prepares succession planning towards which career planning is
the first step.
Self Assessment
Exploration and
Research
Decision Making
Taking Action
Evaluation
1. Self Assessment
Self assessment revolves around the thoughtful consideration, reflection, and evaluation of
your interests, personality characteristics, values, and skills through a variety of methods,
such as the use of a whole host of career-related tools and instruments.
133
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL The merits of career planning
3. Decision Making
The decision-making step of the career planning process is when you put all the pieces
of information about yourself and your carefully collected career information together as
best as possible to produce a list of career-related goals and options.
4. Taking Action
Taking action is one of those things that’s easier said than done. This stage is about
literally being proactive with your career plans and following through with what you’ve
decided on doing.
5. Evaluation
After you have made your career-related decision and identified your goals, keep in mind
that many of the folks who achieve career success are the ones who continually evaluate
and assess their status. They keep track of their career progress throughout their lifetime.
360°
thinking .
360°
thinking .
135
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Talent management
43 TALENT MANAGEMENT
Learning objectives:
1. To study the concepts of talent management.
2. To understand differences between talent management and traditional HR function.
3. To learn about the importance of talent management.
4. To identify the different elements of a talent management program.
Many companies never think about the exact definition of talent. Do talent and potential
mean the same? Most people think so. Potential implies an individual has the capability
to take on future responsibilities that go beyond their current role. Yet potential implies
something to be realized in the future. A survey of 20 major corporations showed that
85% of organizations define talent based on the potential for vertical movement up the
organizational ladder.
Talent has to be defined properly considering the strategic aims and future business
challenges. Talent Management is a set of integrated organizational HR processes designed
to attract, develop, motivate, and retain productive, engaged employees. The goal of talent
management is to create a high-performance, sustainable organization that meets its strategic
and operational goals and objectives.
When companies start focusing on development opportunities aimed only at the talent
pool, they risk disengaging the rest of the workforce.
Social media and talent scarcity is enabling global mobility of talent. Employees are invaluable
assets, so organizations would need to ring-fence employees to align their goals with that of
the overall business goals. The value of the steady performer will keep on increasing. This
will be the beginning of the end of the bell curve.
Going forward, diversity is going to be a great differentiator with more women joining
the workforce and need for cross-cultural interactions; companies will be forced to look
at this with new lenses. Backward integration is not impossible. IT companies can start
engineering colleges and big corporate houses can start MBA colleges. Divyashree group
that is active in the real estate sector has set up REVA University. Wipro has established
Azim Premjee University.
In the future, there needs to be a greater collaboration between industry and academia. Talent
acquisition will become a global process. There will be a greater need to ensure consistency
136
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Talent management
and standardization in hiring process and criteria. The key questions shall be – how to
ensure a role fit and a cultural fit? The pay for performance cannot be stretched beyond a
limit as Gen Y employees give greater thrust on work-life balance.
Competency Fit
Recruit
Perform
Capability Framework
Develop
Cultural Fit
Retain
Motivational Fit
Talent management involves recruiting, selecting, training talent. To support the business
strategy, HCM needs to have processes to ensure that there is a greater level of employee
137
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Talent management
engagement in the organization. How to reduce attrition? How to keep employees motivated
so that they do not leave the organization. How can the training programs be linked to
specific goals of an individual employee?
It won’t be an exaggeration to say that globalization has had a major impact on HCM
strategy. As a result of globalization, the field of International HRM has evolved. This
makes HCM even more important. When an employee is sent on deputation to a foreign
country, the business incurs a huge cost on the same. The performance of the employee in
an overseas location depends on clarity of job responsibilities and the incentives offered by
the organization.
The HR has a role to play in ensuring that there is pay parity and the employee gets accultured
in a short period of time in the overseas location. Cross cultural training programs, cultural
sensitivity skills and language skills – the role of HR as part of the HCM strategy becomes
more and more complicated. Even though the global policy may be the same across all units
of the organization, there is a great deal of customization needed at the unit level. The HR
function has to act as an effective conduit to ensure a smooth transition of an employee
from an onsite location to an offsite location.
In the aftermath of globalization, economic recession has become a cyclical affair. Companies
resort to head count reduction (hire & fire policy) as part of the cost reduction efforts
but this ends up demoralizing the employees. A true HCM function should engage with
employees to improve productivity instead of resorting to extreme steps to reduce costs.
Seldom does one hear about top management getting a pay cut when there is a recession.
But middle and lower level employees often face the heat when there is a depression in the
economic system of a country. As the role of HR keeps evolving to strengthen the HCM
efforts of an organization, there is a need for the professionals to ensure that employees
are treated as assets of the organization. Expenditure on human resources is treated as
an investment.
Work life balance, flexi-timing, paternity allowances are becoming as important as fringe
benefits. Some IT companies allow employees to work from home. The concept of virtual
office is also gaining momentum. Thus, in the new scheme of things, talent management
has a much wider scope.
At the same time, businesses are also careful about spending money in the right fashion.
When capital is scarce, it becomes even more important to make investments that can
support the execution of the overall business strategy.
138
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Talent management
Business
Continuity
Supports
Employee and
effective
organizational
workforce
goal alignment
planning
Talent
Management
Program
Increases
Talent Pool
employee
Development
productivity
Supports
Richer career employee
development engagement
programs
Without HR analytics, organizations will lose the race for talent. HR leaders have to change
now to recruit, engage, develop and retain people to improve business performance in
today’s increasingly competitive environment. Analytics helps in consolidating discrete silos
of talent data sitting in various HR systems across the business. Analytics enables the quick
access and use of data. Thus, forward thinking organizations use HR analytics to redefine
the way they manage their talent to help drive better business results.
Redefinition of talent management also means predicting the best people for your high value
roles, predict people who will stay in your organization longer and analyze social chatter to be
in tune with employees in real time. In a competitive environment, HR has to demonstrate
how the talent management practices are adding value to the organization. Business leaders
are now asking for data on ROI when they hire people at stupendous salaries.
Employee engagement is becoming more relevant than before to address the productivity
losses. Better business results hinge on employee retention, engagement, collaboration, skills
development, knowledge transfer and optimizing the capacity and potential of your people.
139
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Talent management
Companies have to collect individual knowledge and share the right data to build corporate
wisdom through video and social collaboration technologies. The most important role of HR
is to hold up the mirror to the organization so that people can see and act on the truth.
The whole concept of moving across the vertical hierarchical leader is becoming obsolete
now. Leading organizations are embracing a more agile ‘lattice’ structure that facilitates
lateral career moves. Companies are facilitating stretch assignments which provide in valuable
opportunities for experiential learning. How can individuals navigate their own career paths?
How can employees take ownership for their own development?
Contextual variables like career stage, prior experience and organizational cultural fit are critical
determinants of success, which are simply not accounted for in standardized mainstream
talent management programs.
The employment contract will shift from quid-pro-quo to mutuality and partnership. As
talent acquisition will become talent resourcing going forward, the HR function will have to
demonstrate greater accountability. A large proportion of the transactional and operational
content of the HR function has been outsourced. The HR function is being shaped as a
business partner. This means that the HR professionals must be more business focused and
140
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Talent management
have to don the hat of a consultant. Recruiters have to become talent advisors, capable of
managing complex talent pipelines and advising the business on talent.
Talent management for companies with large frontline – workforces are experiencing a
massing transformation. Operations leaders and executives have had abundant access to
business intelligence and reporting tools for accurate historical analysis. Now the growth of
big data predictive analytics has enabled a new era for workforce – optimization. Instead
of begin reactive, organizations now have the ability to be adaptive, to anticipate problems
and stimulate impact.
To sum up:
Companies need to focus on retaining talent and for this employees need motivation and
encouragement through financial means (Compensation) and non financial means (Career
planning). Only then can businesses think about employee engagement at a strategic
level. Employee engagement cannot be a buzzword. It has to be something that the top
management needs to work on along with the support of the HR team. Employees need
to be treated as assets and not as resources. Unless there is a distinction between employees
based on performance and productivity, the commoditization of employee output cannot
be avoided. Employees who are passionate and self motivated will lose the morale if there
is no reward and recognition mechanism in the work place and every employee gets equally
rewarded despite his/her productivity/performance. Today Gen Y population is not looking
for jobs; they are looking for a career. Satisfying their aspirations needs a strategic approach
to human resource management.
141
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Differences between HCM and talent management
Learning objective:
• To understand the main differences between human capital management and talent
management.
• To know about talent acquisition process.
Talent management is all about having quality people with appropriate competencies in
mission-critical activities. Goals to attract, acquire, develop, promote and retain quality
talent are essential. Highly productive staff will result from highly motivated, enthusiastic
and ebullient staff. It is important to develop and retain a high performing work force.
Talent management is all about recruiting and developing skills necessary to implement the
human capital vision. Recruitment and retention strategies are needed to hire and retain
the right people with mission critical skills.
Business must have a good onboarding strategy. New employees must be integrated with
organizational culture. Best-in-class organizations acknowledge that onboarding efforts begin
by adopting a formalized plan ensuring that onboarding is an integral element of the overall
human capital management strategy and is on the radar screen of senior management.
Formalized socialization of new employees, mentoring or coaching new hires and opportunities
for developing skills will lead to employee retention.
The organization must attempt to answer the question – How can we increase the number
of high performing employees? Human capital management has to be improved to drive
increased strategic value to their organizations.
142
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Differences between HCM and talent management
Talent acquisition
Too much time for hiring or too many manual error prone processes or insufficient workflow
processes or a time consuming process for assessing candidates are the prominent challenges
in talent acquisition. Often there is a disconnect between HR and hiring managers.
Employee job posting in intranets is a good strategy but it can often be misused. There are
organizations where candidate is finalized even before the employee job posting is done.
So the entire process of internal recruitment can become an eye wash. Inefficient interview
management including scheduling and coordination can be unsettling for efficient talent
acquisition. Tracking job and vacancy statuses can be cumbersome. In some cases, onboarding
new employees can take too long. Inefficient use of existing talent pools can be extremely
damaging in the long run.
High level information for senior management and executives may be unavailable. How to
get the possible people in the door is an interesting question to ponder about. The hiring
process has to be easy on the candidate. Data driven approach to talent acquisition and
decision making will create a workable roadmap for implementing real change in HR in
months, not in years. Data and analytics put the spotlight on problem areas, opportunities
for improvement and actual real world successes.
Integrated talent management can quickly find the best possible talent and ensure that it
develops well and remains with the organization. Identification of next generation leaders will
ensure continuity across organization. The HR department has to ensure that best employees
are fully and productively engaged. Capture data at all touch points from recruitment
and hiring through performance and development. Data can show where your recruiting
resources are best spent, what characteristics make up your best employees and managers,
which employees are most engaged and the best fit for meeting your succession plans.
143
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Redefining talent management
45 REDEFINING TALENT
MANAGEMENT
Change has become inevitable in the business world today. Companies that can’t adapt themselves
to changes in the market place find themselves swept by the waves of competition. It is no
wonder then that today there is a need for redefining the concept of talent management.
To begin with, companies should start by looking at the leadership styles. The top leadership
teams today have become choosy. Why not? Considering the astronomical sums that they
get paid, it is only natural that after some time they start calling the shots. Top leaders do
not mind taking a sabbatical if the need arises and if they are disillusioned with their current
jobs. They need freedom and they resist control. They are irked with constant interference
and micromanagement.
Thus, in light of the above facts, an organization has to have a clear set of plans to develop
top talent. Never mind that Infosys has been in the news for all the wrong reasons, the
truth is that the IT bellwether is known for its astute succession planning. Businesses must
144
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Redefining talent management
realize that the plans must be actionable and command commitment of the highest order
from all the people in the organization who have to work in fructifying the plans.
Today the top team needs engagement about their development plans which cannot be force-
fed. Experts opine that talent has to be segmented against major drivers of business value
and success. Talent must have the capability to produce things that matter to the business.
Delivery is utmost essential. Looking too much into the long term is not recommended
today due to the impact of globalization which has changed the face of competition.
Research has time and again proved that a firm’s intangible value comes from its people
capabilities. HR is all about making people more capable, skilled and competent. The HR
inputs drive the operational efficiencies in an organization which in turn spurs performance.
Where needed, CEOs have to rework the firm’s human capital model and practices. Smart
HR is the need of the hour. Smart HR is when HR practices are blended into the core
business practices in a seamless fashion. There is talk about “intelligent” recruiting. Can
a HR manager identify if a candidate will stick to the organization? Reading the resume
carefully and looking at the candidate’s loyalty to the organizations where he has worked
supplemented by information gained during a personal interview can give important leads
in this aspect.
The expectations from the HR function have also increased considerably. Earlier performance
measurement was more abstract. However, with use of technology and sophisticated models,
it is possible to correlate the performance with the input measures of non-customer facing
functions like HR.
Let us remember that Gen X will soon hit their 50s. Gen Y is becoming the dominant labour
cohort. So, trying to conceptualize talent management without including Gen Y can look
absurd. Gen Y is not only tech savvy but they are also bold. They are avid risk takers. They
do not mind calling a spade a spade. They do not mince words. They are clear about what
they want. They like to work for socially responsible companies. Their confidence sometimes
145
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Redefining talent management
borders on arrogance. Gen Y looks at strong observable styles of servant leadership. The
servant leader shares power and puts the needs of others first. Leadership is no longer about
showing the direction. It is also about helping people to perform. True leaders create more
leaders and not more followers.
For Gen Y, business ethics and corporate governance play an important role in their
willingness to work for a firm. Self improvement is very much on their agenda. HR must
adjust to the expectations of Gen Y. Best global practices have to be shared. All said and
done, it can’t be refuted that neglect of talent is a very material risk to an organization’s
welfare, health, future prospects and growth.
146
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Curry leaves, banana & talent
46 CURRY LEAVES,
BANANA & TALENT
Anything that is easily available is seldom appreciated. So goes a saying in Hindi. A man
knows the benefits of a shade only when he walks in the hot sun. History is replete with
instances of how talented employees never get what is due to them in the corporate world.
Be it the world of cinema, politics, academics or any other field that you can think of –
meritorious employees are always sidelined. For every one talented employee who has got
the recognition, there are hundreds who never get what is due to them. This is indeed a
great travesty of justice.
Curry leaves are very popular in South Indian menus. Be it sambar, rasam or any other curries,
curry leaves are added to lend a unique flavor. Curry leaves contain chlorophyll and when
they are eaten raw early in the morning, they can be a good cure for your diabetes. Curry
leaves are roasted slightly with pulses and then ground into a fine powder. In the South,
this curry leaf powder is mixed with rice along with a dash of oil and it tastes divine! Curry
leaves, asafetida and butter milk along with a few granules of salt is a great concoction for
aiding your digestion. Curry leaves are also good for your eyes. Being fibrous, curry leaves
are a good antidote to reduce your cholesterol and triglycerides. Yet curry leaves are used
to lend flavor and then discarded. No one wants to eat them.
Banana deserves an award for being a crop that has been underestimated for generations.
Yet banana continues to deliver its benefits – generation after generation. The banana stem
is chopped into fine pieces and cooked with lentils and then sauntered with asafetida,
mustard seeds and red chillies to prepare a curry that is not only tasty but very good for
your kidneys. Banana flowers are also mixed with pulses to prepare a vegetable delicacy
that is good for health. Bananas can help people gain weight and are full of potassium,
vitamins and other minerals.
Yet bananas are always considered a poor man’s fruit just because they are cheaper and
there is an abundant supply of the fruit. In South India, it is customary to offer food to a
guest on a banana leaf and it is common to see food being served on a plantain leaf during
147
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Curry leaves, banana & talent
marriage ceremonies. But the poor banana has never been given its due. To add insult to
injury, we even have a slang term “going bananas”.
Are there management lessons that we can draw inspiration from? In real world, talent never
gets the recognition that is due. So long as the individual knows that he is talented and
can use this to build his self confidence and overall personality, this is fine. The hope that
true talent will get its recognition one day is what should drive the individual. As always,
it is wiser to remember the adage – The lower the expectations you have, the greater is the
peace of mind.
148
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Job enrichment & job enlargement
Example: For instance, in a graphics designing company, to enrich the job of the employee,
he or she can be given a task to upgrade to his or her workstation. Thus, job enrichment
can obviate the monotony in a routine job. A bank clerk who manually enters transactions
in a register can be trained in MS Excel.
Job enlargement does not give greater authority, just more duties. Job enlargement is often
called “multi tasking”. This perhaps violates one of the key principles of human achievement,
namely, concentration of effort. One can perhaps manage and work on a variety of projects
and still practice concentrated effort, but multitasking gets so out of hand that it often
prevents an employee from getting anything done.
Example: We can take the same example of the employee working in a graphics designing
company, an employee who does work in Photoshop to create images for the websites can
also be used to create graphics and icons for print media and mobile devices. He or she can
also be given the responsibilities to work closely with the programming team and supply
initial interface design. This will just increase his or her workload but working for different
media or team will be challenging.
Both Job enrichment and job enlargement can be rewarding to the employee and the
employer in the long run. Both these measures motivate an employee, providing new
dimensions to keep an employee engaged at work. Such efforts are also successful in reducing
employee attrition.
149
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Job-related stress
48 JOB-RELATED STRESS
“When he landed in my clinic, he was on the verge of giving up on life” says a city-based
psychiatrist about a 40-year old executive who had had a nervous breakdown. It is incredible
that job related stress can manifest itself to such an extent that an employee thinks of taking
away his life!
A further probing revealed the real reason – “abusive leadership”. The executive was working
under a leader who was hell bent on making the executive’s life a living hell. Rejecting the
executive’s leave applications, questioning his actions at every stage and verbal abuse on
most occasions literally made the executive shudder to face his boss. An otherwise talented
and diligent executive, this individual suffered simply because he was straight forward in
his interactions with his leader. Often leaders expect servility – all in the name of humility.
Why should someone continue to suffer abusive leadership? Amit Mishra who quit his well
paying job to establish his start up says, “I do not know whether you can call this mid-life
crisis. At the age of 40, some individuals do lose the confidence of landing another job.
Health problems begin to surface at this age. Some people fear facing an unknown devil
and so put up with insufferable bosses”.
In the first case, counseling made a lot of difference. The IT executive was advised to turn
to yoga and meditation. This gave him the clarity that he need not have suffered so much
and that life has a much wider canvass.
Eventually the executive put in his papers and took a sabbatical for 6 months. Head hunter
Girija Menon says, “Why do people work? They work primarily to earn their living but if
the job itself is going to take away your life, it is simply not worth it. Companies claim to
have employee-friendly policies. However, if you are unable to get along with a boss then
your future in the organization is doomed unless you have the patience and will power to
withstand such mental torture”.
In my classes on Human Capital Management, I often quote to students a real-life case that
I had read in Business World years ago. The case written by a renowned HR consultant was
about a talented female executive who dealt with a rude and abusive boss merely through
her will power and mental strength.
150
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Job-related stress
employees. It is important for every individual to look for a second line of defense – it
could be anything that interests the employee. An employee should moonlight for a few
years before taking the giant leap to doing something that he loves to do”. Stress has now
become a part of work place lexicon.
Companies that pay well will naturally expect employees to meet targets. To quote an oft-
repeated maxim – There is nothing called as a free lunch in this world. If an employee
cannot meet targets, employer will not hesitate in showing him the door. For employees
who are dissatisfied with their existing jobs, they should remember that – Achieving 100%
job satisfaction is more utopian than real.
In a highly stressful environment, work-life balance can seem distant. Station masters in
Bangalore protested a few days back citing the inhuman work conditions and their plight
was indeed heart rending.
Amit adds, “Decision to leave a well-paying job can be a tough one, but it is always better
to decide this quickly rather than visiting shrinks at a much later stage. At the end of the
day, what matters is whether we are happy or not”. Needless to add, the support from
151
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Job-related stress
family members is essential at this stage. They should rally around the employee and give
him the confidence to take the right decision.
No two individuals are alike in this world. The response of an individual to stress varies
according to his mental make-up. It is always better to have zero expectations in the work
place rather than fret and fume. If you are getting far too suffocated in a predictable work
environment, then it is important to ensure that this stress does not manifest itself into
some sort of an illness or an ailment.
To quote a famous saying – “All the successful people in this world may not be talented
and all the talented people in this world may not be successful”. So, if you are facing a
situation of living hell, it is better to stop, ponder and re-prioritize.
152
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Reverse mentoring
49 REVERSE MENTORING
Learning objectives:
• To understand the concept of reverse mentoring.
• To learn about the benefits of reverse mentoring.
• To appreciate the challenges in reverse mentoring.
Technology has cast its influence on the business world in ways that are unimaginable. Social
media networks and smart phone applications are proving to be great value additions to
grow the business. This technological growth has now fuelled the need for reverse mentoring
in organizations large and small.
Reverse mentoring, also called as upward mentoring, turns the traditional concept of
mentoring on its head. In reverse mentoring the younger employee acts as a mentor to
the senior employee by exposing the senior leader to different facets of technology and
its applications. Senior leaders are exposed to social media networks and their influence
on business.
Reverse mentoring helps such leaders to learn about real issues on the ground and listen
to the voice of lower management teams. The success of reverse mentoring depends on
the eagerness of the senior employee to interact with an employee years his junior and his
willingness to shed his ego and power. For the younger employee, reverse mentoring presents
an excellent opportunity to learn about decision making at higher hierarchical levels.
Reverse mentoring has become a necessity in modern business world today. Technological
advances are characterizing the way business is done. However, reverse mentoring – though
it appears to be simple on paper – is a complex process that the HR function needs to
simplify by establishing the rules of engagement. If it is planned and executed in a structured
manner, reverse mentoring can achieve its goal of bringing senior leaders and greenhorns/
new recruits on a common platform to share their knowledge.
The term “reverse mentoring” was coined by Jack Welch, former CEO. Senior employees
benefit from reverse mentoring wherein younger generation shares their expertise and skills
with the former.
Smart companies are learning how to turn generational differences into a business advantage
that can give them a competitive edge in the market. Reverse mentoring is an inexpensive
method for employees at two different hierarchical levels to interact and learn from each other
153
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Reverse mentoring
Reverse mentoring enables transfer of knowledge between mentor and mentee. It begins
to close the knowledge gap between long-time employees and newer hires. Young mentors
can offer insights into their target market, help define a brand voice via social media, or
provide advice on digital best practices.
Reverse mentoring infuses an organization’s leadership with different, fresh, and younger
perspectives. When pairing, consider that personal chemistry is often overrated. The
best matches are often mismatches, which broaden the opportunities for growth in both
participants. Mentoring relationships should not be restricted to people of the same gender,
or to those who have similar backgrounds, because we can learn so much more from people
who are different from ourselves.
Reverse mentoring is a great tool to strengthen existing company resources to make the
senior employees tech savvy. In 1999, Jack Welch popularized reverse mentoring when he
instructed 500 of his top executives to pair up with junior associates so that they could
learn how to use the Internet. Organizations like Cisco, HP and Hartford have adopted
reverse mentoring.
154
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Reverse mentoring
In today’s market place that is digitally dominated, CEOs have been struggling to adopt
all things digital. Thus reverse mentoring helps them to figure out how to move forward.
Colgate Palmolive is a company that got exposed to the digital market while planning its
strategy. It so happened that Colgate’s marketing department was in the early stages of
brainstorming an online company strategy. Consumers posted their responses on Instagram.
This is a radical transformation that needs the companies to develop flexibility to respond
to the needs of the market. Reverse mentoring brings the agility necessary to create forward
thinking business strategies.
The best solution is to support and cultivate a learning environment where people learn
from one another. Every new hire contributes to organizational learning. Conversations
between the top teams and fresh recruits have to be engaging in such a way as to take the
company forward.
Learning and development efforts often tend to be arcane. Reverse mentoring enables managers
to be savvier with current trends but this has a collateral benefit in terms of engagement
of fresh recruits and hence their retention. It is important to reinforce the belief that all
employees are lifelong learners.
Reverse mentoring has several benefits. Governance decisions improve. Strategic plans have
greater clarity. The company becomes more aware of its tacit knowledge. The mentors are
able to enhance their leadership skills and achieve job satisfaction.
One of the pitfalls of reverse mentoring is poor matching of mentor and mentee and the
problems that crop up as a result of the same. Time needs to be invested in matching mentor
and mentee. Defining clear objectives and establishing boundaries and timelines will help
set expectations for both mentor and mentee.
Executive hubris can be the main stumbling block in reverse mentoring. Those with a high
level of ego can find it humiliating to learn from someone who is raw talent and years his
junior. Level 5 leaders epitomize humility and this is where they are more amenable to
reverse mentoring.
155
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Reverse mentoring
There is also a concern that the mobile-crazy, gadget freaks characterizing the younger
generation may unwittingly share information that was discussed during mentoring with
their colleagues.
The objective of reverse mentoring is primarily to enable leaders and senior managers to
stay in touch with their organizations and the outside world. There are two main objectives
that reverse mentoring has proven successful in achieving. Advance the technical skills and
understanding of senior management. Executives are increasingly required to make strategic
decisions in response to technological changes.
Reverse mentoring gives junior employees a window into the higher levels of the organization
and helps them understand the business better. The mentoring process catapults the career
of the younger employee to a higher level as his competence becomes more visible to the
top team.
It is important to understand that all employees want to feel valued, empowered and
engaged at work regardless of the generation to which they belong. There is only so much
an employee can do in terms of motivating self. Younger employees can be visualized as
change agents who will help usher in a transformation in business processes and practices.
Managers benefit from reverse mentoring by forging closer relationships with their employees.
Millennial workers can help them see business challenges and opportunities from the point
of view of a generation that has a growing presence in the workforce.
Reverse mentoring ensures that everyone in the organization brings something to the table.
Ogilvy and Mather, a leading ad agency, launched a reverse mentoring program so that the
senior executives could improve their social media skills.
Reverse mentoring in Hartford financial services made business leaders realize the power
of having answers on the spot – backed by technology. This led them to take a decision to
empower other employees with a similar experience. This resulted in unlocking of social
networks and a surge in productivity.
156
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Reverse mentoring
Dealing with information on the social platform requires agility of a different order.
Meaningful communication becomes a collaborative process.
However the flip side is that the leaders have to ambidextrous while straddling the conflicting
demands placed by technological infrastructure that encourages free exchange and the need
for establishing controls to check abuse of such technological freedom.
In a world undergoing continuous and multi-faceted change, so fast moving is the business
landscape that organizations must adapt swiftly simply to survive. Organizational agility
is the ability to continuously adjust and adapt strategic direction in a core business. The
financial crisis that began in 2008 rendered many business models obsolete as organizations
throughout the world were plunged into chaotic environments.
The balance of power between employer and employees is shifting. Structural and cultural
practices add to the complexity in organizations. People responsible for public governance must
157
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Reverse mentoring
know how to convert data into information and information to knowledge. Organizations
seek leaders who can take people along while implementing strategy and delivering business
agendas that add value. During times of crisis, leadership is put to test as the leader has to
manage the diverse process of integrating the knowledge, skills and experiences of employees.
Leaders have to indulge in reflection, critical thinking, leading and following actions. They
need to have quality interactions with followers to motivate them and help them deal with
change. Leadership is about foreseeing a successful future of the organization and directing
actions towards fulfillment of the same. Leaders have to adapt themselves to a climate where
they need to constantly reinvent themselves by embracing opportunities for learning.
Growing diversity of the global era needs leadership to be more partnership oriented based
on mutual respect and empathy. Continuous process design and redesign is an imperative
for leadership. It is important to identify new opportunities presented by the modern
world. To get things done, leaders need to do real work themselves to manage themselves
and others well.
Digital revolution in India has given fillip to the opportunities for younger generation to
reverse mentor their seniors in the organization. 80% senior leaders in audit and consulting
firm Price water house Cooper responded positively to a suggestion to mentor them by
younger generation on matters like new technology and social media skills. A 32-year old
brand manager Karthik Perumal tutored Hindustan Unilever CEO Nitin Paranjpe on
social media.
Companies like Airtel and Accenture have used reverse mentoring to re-orient their
recruitment and HR strategies.
Reverse mentoring helps the older generation to stay current and informed about new
technologies or trends. Considering the speed at which technology is changing, reverse
mentoring is gaining more prominence. Some experts consider reverse mentoring more of
a coaching phenomenon.
158
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Reverse mentoring
Reverse mentoring has been identified as an innovative way to attract, retain and develop
women in leadership at all levels. For example – IBM currently pairs top leaders (often
male) with female mentors who have been identified as future leaders. The mentor/mentee
meet regularly and each learns from the other. Reverse mentoring also called reciprocal
mentoring is a classic example of how to create visibility of up-and-coming female leaders to
top leaders and involve female leaders in strategic development. Deloitte has a buddy system
in which the company matches senior male leaders to female talent for one to two years.
Effective reverse mentoring is a two-way flow of learning and organizations like BP call it
mutual mentoring to emphasize the duality of roles. It is important to prevent the senior
manager from slipping into dominant behaviors and encourage the junior employee to
feel empowered to speak up the truth. Through reverse mentoring leaders learn to be
more comfortable to have open, learning conversations with other people who come from
backgrounds and cultures substantially different from themselves.
Reverse mentoring can be a winning situation for everyone involved. Both partners need
to be clear on what they want to accomplish. Each partner must be fully committed to the
mentoring relationship, with regular – at least monthly – meetings and activities. Partners
should agree to be cooperative and respectful.
In a reverse mentoring relationship, both parties must genuinely want to learn from and
share with the other. The goal is to push each other outside of comfort zones and try new
ways of thinking, working, and being. Ideally, the partners will create a safe, professional,
yet risk-taking environment, and maintain confidentiality. Both partners must be open with
their feelings and with what they are thinking. They must be able to overcome differences
in communication style and be open to seeing situations from different angles.
Reverse mentoring is an agile people process in terms of developing a flexible work force
and strategic human resource management. Having the right people in the right place at
the right time is not enough. These people must have the right skill sets and a matching
attitude that can take the company forward. People need to be willing to give their best
and also willing to adapt to changing requirements. Leaders can build a culture of shared
leadership which is the bedrock of sustainable agility & renewal.
159
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL The involved employee – how to spot one!
160
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL The involved employee – how to spot one!
Organizations must spot the involved employee and make every attempt to retain him
through training, reward and recognition schemes and other non-cash incentives. Such
employees are precious assets who need nurturing.
161
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Dealing with Gen Y
The general perception is that Gen Y’s developmental needs are different from the previous
generation and that they are restless. While they may not be overly ambitious and are more
prone to aspire for an active social life, it is important to realize that their attention spans
are short and they are often labeled as poor listeners. HR programs and policies need to
be framed as per the needs of the Gen Y work force. Engagement of Gen Y at the work
place has assumed greater priority now.
Conservative talent management programs need replacement with innovative ones that focus
on an integrated approach. This means training programs in organizations must be more
skewed towards what these Gen Y employees are interested in rather than the other way
around. Selecting the right person for the right job has never been so difficult! Demanding
as they are, Gen Y employees need better retirement and welfare options and a greater
flexible work environment.
Company career sites, online job portals and employee referrals will continue to be sources
of recruitment and selection. However, innovative channels of recruitment will need to be
explored and this is not just about looking at profile updates in Linked In. A prospective
candidate’s behavior on social media can give vital clues. What else is technology there for?
Background referencing as a new HR function has seldom been given prominence and it is
high time companies looked at outsourcing background referencing as an effective screening
mechanism. Gen Y is synonymous with agile decision making and quick actions rather than
business processes that are painfully slow and arcane beyond one’s imagination.
162
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL Dealing with Gen Y
The role of HR in managing careers of Gen Y will become more pronounced in the future.
In the absence of such a strategy, attrition rates will be higher and this will propel re-hiring
and training costs northwards. Big data and analytics are expected to play a bigger role in
recruitment and selection more than ever before.
New age recruitment needs unique skill-sets and it is not about a fresh MBA graduate poring
through scores of applications to struggle to find out the right fit for the organization. A
technology-enabled screening process is bound to receive wider acceptance in the future.
However managing Gen Y is not a one-way street. These are a talented lot, people who
believe in ISR (individual social responsibility) and aspire to travel the extra mile to equip
themselves with latest technology. Whether technological disruptions are wreaking havoc
with their personal and professional lives is anyone’s guess. But investing in Gen Y employees
does ensure a good ROI for the organization.
Businesses need technology and Gen Y employees are effective conduits for technology
absorption.
The reality is: Gen Y’s need careers and not jobs.
163
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL The need to retain seasoned professionals
But whenever there is a takeover or a merger, the HR department starts planning the
headcount reduction with a view to rationalize its workforce. Seldom is there any thought
spared for the contribution of a seasoned professional. The onus is more on the compensation
package offered to such professionals. In a bid to reduce payroll costs, the common tendency
is to ignore the contribution made by seasoned professionals.
Many organizations are now open to the idea of recruiting talent from other industries that
have a diverse business landscape and operate in a different eco system. This is because the
same skills and same levels of competence can be successfully deployed in a different industry
for similar situations. For example – someone with an experience in process excellence or
quality or safety can be a valuable asset in any industry that needs such kind of exposure.
These competencies are hard to find and this is where the seasoned professionals can make
a significant contribution. Such professionals can prove to be deft in decision making and
are easily adaptable to new situations and business challenges. If such professionals have
added value to an organization in growth phase, then retrenching them during a downturn
is not exactly a good idea.
A business fails due to several reasons and people at the helm of the affairs have to assume
responsibility for business failures as much as they would like to take credit for business
successes. Seasoned professionals can contribute significantly in streamlining processes in
the organization and overcoming the barriers to growth. They can increase productivity by
identifying the factors that lead to operational inefficiencies.
Seasoned professionals can also act as excellent coaches and mentors to new recruits in an
organization and can help the organization in succession planning. This is why retaining
such professionals will help the organization in the long run. A successful professional in
one organization may not be able to replicate the same success in another organization.
There are various factors that deter an individual from repeating an encore of his past
successes in the new set up. Seasoned professionals who switch industries need to be given
164
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL The need to retain seasoned professionals
that elbow room to understand the intricacies of the business and market dynamics before
they enter the boxing arena.
Most organizations fail in the area of change management. Absence of delegation, delayed
decision making, lack of resources for implementation of project ideas are some of the reasons
seasoned professionals struggle to find a feet in the new set up. If the stalemate continues, it
will be detrimental for both the organization and the individual. Hence, corrective actions
need to be taken on war footing to improve the situation.
Retaining seasoned professionals is a good organizational strategy not just for the business
but to also other employees in the organization who will be excited at the prospect of
learning from such resourceful individuals and follow their career path to move up the
hierarchical leader.
165
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL When talent becomes a liability…
We often read about successful leaders and their turnaround strategies. But did they achieve
this all alone? What about the teams that they led? For every one successful leader, there
are scores of talented employees lurking in the background. These employees had leadership
potential but never got the opportunity.
There are several reasons for this. Organizational politics played by those who tend to use
all their ingenuity to thwart any attempts that can endanger their position or authority. It
is not necessary that all talented employees have outstanding networking skills. So, those
who cannot tom-tom about their talent lose the battle half way.
Others become more complacent with the status quo and fade out. The ones who are
ambitious decide to call it a day when they realize that it makes no sense to continue working
in such a listless manner. Some employees try to balance this by pursuing opportunities
outside of work. These opportunities may not be financially rewarding to them but they
give them immense satisfaction that no corporate job can ever hope to match. It helps such
employees to expand their social bandwidth. History is replete with several such examples
of potential leaders who gave up the fight half way and chose to be happy.
One of the prominent causes of talent not getting the attention that it deserves lies with
the leader. NK Bapna, a HR consultant says, “A leader needs to think beyond him. There
are so many examples of leaders becoming mentors to their sub-ordinates. A true leader
is one who plays the road map for creating future leaders. But this needs identification of
the right talent, grooming them, recognizing them and showing them the big picture. Very
few leaders tend to display the aptitude for this.” In a world marked by increasing levels of
self-centeredness and avarice, the truth is that one cannot expect much.
Bapna adds, “HR processes in some organizations do not have the flexibility needed to deal
with the requirements of multi-skill employees; job rotations are rare. The process of internal
recruitment is flawed and at times the employee job positions are doctored to match the
skill sets of a specific employee whom the organization wants to offer the job to”. Often,
the loss of a talented employee is felt long after he has moved out.
166
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL When talent becomes a liability…
There are also scores of examples of employees who possess a unique set of skills specific to
the organization that they work for. But during an economic downturn, these employees
realize that their skill sets have limited application elsewhere in the market. Employees in
the Nokia manufacturing unit in Chennai faced a similar predicament. Mr. G Dharmarajan,
a head hunter based in Mumbai, advocates the need for every employee to build a second
line of defense. One can never predict which skill will come handy when.
Amole Kulkarni, who runs his recruitment agency in Nasik, adds, “I have met candidates
who were outstanding in their jobs and were being paid handsome salaries; yet they chose
to quit. This is because they were unable to see the way forward in terms of career growth
and development. Just because you have been exceptional in your job due to the unique
skill sets that you possess, companies can’t saddle you with the same tasks for years and
years. Beyond a point this can be unnerving”.
Atul Redkar, a high flying IT geek based in Bangalore, became the victim of the economic
downturn in 2008 when the organization that he worked for was forced to downsize. For
quite some time he was nursing an ambition to learn a foreign language. With sizeable
savings in the bank account, there was little to worry. However he also had a number
of options before him after receiving the pink slip. He decided to pursue his unfulfilled
ambition of learning German. He put his heart and soul into it and is now a German
teacher in his own right.
Atul is now all set to pursue his doctoral program in German. Atul may have been lucky in
taking the right decision at the right time. But there may be so many others who struggle
to cope with such unexpected events in their lives.
I do wish that organizations use their collective wisdom to think about recognizing talent
when it is due. Only then will the word talent management find its true meaning.
167
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL References
REFERENCES
https://www.conference-board.org/retrievefile.cfm?filename=Strategic-Management-of-Human-
Capital-in-the-Energy-Sector1.pdf&type=subsite
Walker, D.M. (Ed.). (2002). A Model of Strategic Human Capital Management. DIANE
Publishing.
Liebowitz, J. (2004). Addressing the human capital crisis in the federal government: A knowledge
management perspective. Rutledge.
Condrey, S.E. (2010). The human capital phenomenon: Putting people first.
Afiouni, F. (2009). Leveraging human capital and value creation by combining HRM and
KM initiatives. International Journal of Learning and Intellectual Capital, 6(3), 202–213.
168
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL References
Penrose, E.T. (1959). The theory of the growth of the firm. New York: Sharpe.
Prahlad, C.K., & Hamel, G. (1990). The core competence of the corporation [electronic
versions]. Harvard Business Review Retrieved November, 26, 2000.
Adnan, Z., Abdullah, H.S., & Ahmad, J. Strategic Management of Human Capital in R&D
Organizations in Malaysia.
Kucharčíková, A., Tokarčíková, E., & Blašková, M. (2015). Human Capital Management–
Aspect of the Human Capital Efficiency in University Education. Procedia-Social and
Behavioral Sciences, 177, 48–60.
https://www.conference-board.org/retrievefile.cfm?filename=Strategic-Management-of-Human-
Capital-in-the-Energy-Sector1.pdf&type=subsite
Milanowski, A., & Kimball, S. (2010). The principal as human capital manager: Lessons
from the private sector. Teaching talent: A visionary framework for human capital in education,
69–90.
Rainke, S. (2015). Role of human capital management in banking sector. Int. J. Emer. Res.
In Manage, 4(9), 32–35.
https://hbr.org/2005/07/level-5-leadership-the-triumph-of-humility-and-fierce-resolve
Collins, J. (2006). Level 5 leadership: The triumph of humility and fierce resolve. Managing
Innovation and Change, 234.
http://www.educause.edu/research-publications/books/cultivating-careers-professional-
development-campus-it/chapter-5-importance-mentors
http://www.bizjournals.com/philadelphia/print-edition/2013/01/18/the-roi-of-reverse-
mentoring.html
http://ryan-jenkins.com/2014/07/14/2969/
169
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL References
http://www.insulationoutlook.com/io/article.cfm?id=IO140502
http://www.forbes.com/sites/joshsteimle/2015/05/05/reverse-mentoring-investing-in-tomorrows-
business-strategy/#2715e4857a0b36d46ed0666d
http://www.clomedia.com/2015/08/20/drive-business-forward-with-reverse-mentoring/
http://www.diversityjournal.com/6921-reverse-mentoring-fresh-perspectives-from-future-leaders/
http://www.corporate-eye.com/main/benefits-reverse-mentoring/
http://horizonsunlimited.com.au/pdf/Reverse_Mentoring.pdf
https://hbr.org/2010/05/mentoring-millennials
https://www.roberthalf.com/management-resources/blog/reverse-mentoring-turning-tables-
on-tradition
http://ceoworld.biz/2015/04/29/does-reverse-mentoring-really-work-in-the-workplace
http://www.mckinsey.com/insights/high_tech_telecoms_internet/six_social-media_skills_
every_leader_needs
Holbeche Linda, The Agile Organization: How to Build an Innovative, Sustainable and
Resilient business. Kogan Page Publishers. 2015. [http://www.koganpage.com/media/
project_kp/document/agile-organization-sample.pdf ]
Wuffli, P.A. (2016). How Leadership Tasks Become Inclusive. In Inclusive Leadership (pp. 133–191).
Springer International Publishing.
http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2012-12-20/news/35933896_1_social-media-
top-management-leaders
170
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
OF HUMAN CAPITAL References
http://www.management-mentors.com/resources/leadership-skills
http://www.fastcompany.com/3042405/strong-female-lead/6-ways-to-get-women-into-
leadership-positions-and-keep-them-there
https://dupress.deloitte.com/dup-us-en/focus/human-capital-trends/2017/organization-of-
the-future.html?id=us:2el:3dc:dup3817:awa:cons:hct17
http://www.josephaegan.com/elearning/mod/resource/view.php?id=532
171