Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 3

Q.

Critically analyze the nature and significance of the Boxer


Movement.

The Boxer Rebellion or the Yi Ho Tuan movement of 1900 was a major peasant uprising
against imperialism. YI Ho Tuan means a society of Righteousness and Harmony. This
organization emerged and grew in China's Shantung province. What the Chinese officially
call the Yi Ho Tuan movement, Western scholars call the Boxer Rebellion. 'Boxer' is derived
from boxing as many of the activists and revolutionaries practised Chinese martial arts,
boxing being one of them.
Although this movement's first targets were missionaries who preached Christianity, the real
aim was to fight imperialism. This violent, dramatic and earth shaking movement was the
result of both the enslavement of the Chinese nation by foreign powers and also the
deteriorating socio-economic conditions, which reforms at the political level could not
prevent. As if Western imperialist encroachment on China was not enough, Japanese
imperialism too emerged as a new force to crush China further. The ruling Manchu or Ching
dynasty had weakened considerably on all fronts due to its own internal conditions as well
as imperialist domination of China. The Boxer uprising gave a crushing blow to both the
imperialist and Manchu rulers. The movement was contained by the government eventually
with the help of imperialist forces and resulted in the signing ofthe Boxer Protocolin 1901
most humiliating of all the unequal treaties. The indemnities the Chinese had to pay to the
foreigners were so massive that the Chinese populace was squeezed to derive it. This further
aggravated the internal problems of China, ultimately leading to more revolutionary uprising
and culminating in the downfall of monarchy in 1941.

NATURE OF THE BOXER MOVEMENI


The Boxers had not claimed to be "tuan" which connotes "militia" until the year 1898. The
change of name certainly had a political significance involving change in the relationship
between the Boxers and the imperial authorities. The Boxers were experiencing a kind of
crisis in their political identity. Their original stance was to overthrow the Qing and restore
the Ming, as reflected in their slogan: Fan Qing Fu Ming (Oppose the Qing and Restore the
Ming). But the inroads made by the imperialist powers into China's social and economic life
and the widely prevalent anti-imperialist feeling, made the Boxers change their stratagem.
They grabbed the anti-imperialist slogans of "fan yang" (Oppose the Foreigners) and "mie
yong" (Exterminate the Foreigners). This development made the Boxers not only accept the
"militia status bestowed on them by the imperialist authorities," but also adopt a new slogan
of "bao Qing mie yong" (Uphold the Qing and exterminate the Foreigner). After this the
followers of Boxer leaders Zhu Hongdeng and Monk Benming started attacking the churches
in 1899. G.N. Steiger proposes that the Boxers had nothing to do with any heretical sect, but
a militia force recruited with the express demands of the Qing government in November,
1898. He justifies it by saying that a secret society, holding heretical doctrines and known to
have revolutionary aims would never have attacked Christian missions as the Boxers had
done.

'Boxers" was the name given by foreigners to a Chinese secret society originally called the Yi
He Chuan literally meaning the Fist of the Righteous Harmony. This implied that they Were
ready to support the cause of peace and righteousness, if necessary, by force. As its
members practised Chinese boxing, they acquired the foreign name Boxers. The Yi He Chuan
or the Yi He Tuan as it came to be known later, is believed to have originated from the White
lotus Sect, a group of secret societies descended from the Ming Emperors. It emerged during
the reign of Jia Qing emperor (1796-1870). Its activities were suppressed in 1808 but it
maintained an obscure existence in many districts of Zhili and Shandong. Steiger, however,
contends that the Boxers were a volunteer militia recruited in response to the command of
the throne. This appears quite doubtful as there is little evidence of connection between the
Boxers and the Imperial court till mid-1899.

On the other hand, Chester T'an points out that a clear kinship can be established between
the Boxers and three secret societies, viz. the White Lotus,the Eight Trigram; and the Great
Sword Society. But Victor Purcell propounds that the Boxers "originated spontaneously and
independently of the government" and "belonged to the secret societies and heterodox
cults which had always been looked upon by the government as centres of revolutionary
danger."

Fan Wenlan considers the Boxer movement a potpourri{tuanti) of the anti-foreign forces of
the Boxers and the great Swords. He also points out that the rampant disunity amongst the
Boxer ranks was so typical of the secret societies. Fan Wenlan also sees religion as an
important component of Boxer life and discipline. Every Boxer while joining the organisation
had to go througha religious ordination. No doubt, Fan believes. 'The Boxers who went to
battle were all chaste juveniles of the peasant and working classes. The constraints of
superstition made the commandments sacrosanct to them." Hu Sheng further supports this
thesis when he points out that the celestial protection invoked by' the Boxers was typical
White Lotus indulgence in incantation. Moreover, Hu Sheng points out both the White Lotus
and the Boxer organizations existed in same sort of disorganized, small, and scattered
groups. Thus, Hu Sheng also believes that the Boxers were a secret society based.

Tan Chung believes that the Boxers can be treated as continuation of the White Lotus and
the Nian rebellions. Jerome Ch'en, however, believes that as there were various types of
militia and secret societies, there were various types of Boxers. "The Boxers" social
composition shows no difference from that of either the militia or the secret societies
(including religious sects). This ambiguity made their transformation from one into another
quite easy and formed the basis of the government's decision to transform them into militia
significant reason that Christianity was "foreign". Purcell further points out that the
meddling of foreign governments and other agencies with Chinese affairs was more than the
Chinese could bear. However, the methodology used to achieve their aims, their military
training and weapons were all traditional. They also used traditional concepts and customs
to mobilise the masses against the common enemy. In sum, it can, thus. be described as a
conservative movement with progressive aims, reflecting the problem of aslow developing
society threatened by the newindustrialised world.
SIGNIFICANCE

As a consequence of the Boxer Movement, the Qing government stood exposed as a


collaborator of the imperialists, leading a large number of people to believe in revolution as
the only panacea for the country's problems. The Boxer Uprising was a bold attempt to give
a blow to the imperialist aggression. Purcell thinks the Movement not only stopped the
foreign powers' attempt to partition China, but also signalized the birth of Chinese
nationalism. According to him, the Boxer Movement was a resurgence of revolutionary
fevour of the peasantry of North China in the true tradition of heretical sects.

In the opinion of the Chinese historians, the Boxer Movement scared the imperialist powers
out of their wits and put the brakes on imperialist designs to partition China. Another great
historical significance of the Boxer Movement lies in the awakening of the Chinese people's
patriotic consciousness. The Chinese historians believe that, the Movement not only
educatedthe Chinese people about the true nature of imperialist aggression, but also
exposedthe treasonous character of the Qing authorities.
Fan Wenlan observes that the Boxer Movement shook the entire country. Even the coolies
and domestic servants of the foreigners in Shanghai felt that the hour of finally settling score
with the foreigners had arrives. Hu Sheng further goes on to say that after this Movement,
the Chinese people never looked back. Their revolutionary movement surged forward wave
after wave till they achieved complete victory over feudalism and imperialism. The Chinese
government in its official declarations calls this Movement "a patriotic anti-imperialist
uprising, mainly of peasants" and the climax of the Chinese people's struggle against
aggression and partition which also hit hard at (the imperialism's) appendages, the feudal
forces. Thus, the Movement is alsO seen as "a cornerstone of the victory of the Chinese
communist revolution."

You might also like