Digital Screen Time During The COVID-19 Pandemic Risk For A Further Myopia Boom
Digital Screen Time During The COVID-19 Pandemic Risk For A Further Myopia Boom
CHEE WAI WONG, ANDREW TSAI, JOST B. JONAS, KYOKO OHNO-MATSUI, JAMES CHEN, MARCUS ANG,
AND DANIEL SHU WEI TING
O
PURPOSE: To review the impact of increased digital de- N DECEMBER 30TH, 2019, DR WENLIANG LI ALERTED
vice usage arising from lockdown measures instituted the world about the possibility of a severe acute
during the COVID-19 pandemic on myopia and to respiratory syndrome–like virus outbreak in
make recommendations for mitigating potential detri- Wuhan, China.1 Several months later, the World Health
mental effects on myopia control. Organization (WHO) declared COVID-19 a ‘‘pandemic’’
DESIGN: Perspective. outbreak.2 As of November 13th, 2020, there were >53
METHODS: We reviewed studies focused on digital de- million infected patients worldwide, with >1.3 million
vice usage, near work, and outdoor time in relation to deaths.3 The exponential increase in infections has
myopia onset and progression. Public health policies on alarmed citizens across the globe, including heads of state
myopia control, recommendations on screen time, and in- and WHO leaders.4–6 Research has focused mainly on
formation pertaining to the impact of COVID-19 on the epidemiology, risk modelling, pathophysiology, and
increased digital device use were presented. Recommen- clinical features of severe acute respiratory syndrome-
dations to minimize the impact of the pandemic on myopia CoV-2,7,8 but the impact of increased digital screen time
onset and progression in children were made. caused by the lockdown and quarantine measures in
RESULTS: Increased digital screen time, near work, and many cities worldwide on myopia has largely been unno-
limited outdoor activities were found to be associated ticed. By 2050, it is estimated that 5 billion people world-
with the onset and progression of myopia, and could wide will be myopic,9–11 prompting many governments to
potentially be aggravated during and beyond the implement nationwide myopia control policies in the
COVID-19 pandemic outbreak period. While school clo- past decade. The rise in usage of digital technology and
sures may be short-lived, increased access to, adoption of, online e-learning during this pandemic outbreak may
and dependence on digital devices could have a long-term jeopardize the effectiveness of these policies.12 We discuss
negative impact on childhood development. Raising the disruption of the COVID-19 pandemic lockdown mea-
awareness among parents, children, and government sures on the learning environment of children and adoles-
agencies is key to mitigating myopigenic behaviors that cents, review the evidence on digital screen time and its
may become entrenched during this period. impact on myopia, and make recommendations to reduce
CONCLUSION: While it is important to adopt critical the detrimental effects on myopia during and beyond this
measures to slow or halt the spread of COVID-19, close outbreak.
collaboration between parents, schools, and ministries is
necessary to assess and mitigate the long-term collateral
impact of COVID-19 on myopia control policies. (Am
J Ophthalmol 2021;223:333–337. Ó 2020 Published by
GLOBAL TIGHTENING OF INFECTION
Elsevier Inc.)
CONTROL MEASURES
AT PRESENT, MANY GOVERNMENTS ARE IMPOSING STRICT
Accepted for publication Jul 21, 2020. quarantines and travel bans on an unprecedented scale,13
From the Singapore National Eye Center (C.W.W., A.T., M.A.,
D.S.W.T.) and the Singapore Eye Research Institute, Singapore Health based on a modelled study (N. M. Ferguson et al, unpub-
Service (SingHealth) (C.W.W., A.T., M.A., D.S.W.T.), Duke– lished data, March 2020). In this study, 2 fundamental stra-
National University of Singapore Medical School, Singapore; tegies were proposed to control the spread of COVID-19
Department of Ophthalmology (J.B.J.), Medical Faculty Mannheim,
Heidelberg University, Heidelberg, Germany; Department of among the community: mitigation and suppression. With
Ophthalmology and Visual Science (K.O-M.), Tokyo Medical and the mitigation approach, the study found that 8 of 10 peo-
Dental University, Tokyo, Japan; and Clearly (J.C.), London, United ple may still be affected, resulting in 510,000 deaths in the
Kingdom.
Inquiries to Daniel Shu Wei Ting, Singapore National Eye Center, 11 United Kingdom and 2.2 million deaths in the United
Third Hospital Ave, Singapore 168751; e-mail: [email protected] States by the end of the pandemic (N. M. Ferguson et al,
VOL. 223 DIGITAL SCREEN TIME AND MYOPIA IN THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC 335
study at home, but also include frequent breaks and indoor CONCLUSION
physical or household activities—cooking, baking, and
cleaning, for example. Third, where it is safe and legal to THE UNPRECEDENTED SCALE OF THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC
do so, outdoor activities with adequate social distancing has disrupted our lives beyond recognition. While the
should continue and be encouraged in school-going chil- world reels from the global impact of COVID-19, govern-
dren. Outdoor time of 2-3 hours per day may be even ments are also adjusting to allow everyday life to continue,
more achievable now with the flexibility of home-based such as the closure of schools with the education of our
learning.16 The health benefits of outdoor activities and school children using online platforms. In this regard, dig-
an active lifestyle should not be stifled by COVID-19.33 ital technology has been immensely beneficial in cush-
Amidst the worst outbreak known to human history, the ioning the disruption to school education, but it is crucial
world has been pushed to embrace digital technology at an to be cognizant of the impact of increasing dependence
unprecedented scale and pace. There is no denying the on digital devices. While it is important to adopt strict
benefits of digital technology in a time like this. Notwith- measures (eg, lockdown and home quarantine) to slow or
standing the global pandemic, it is of paramount impor- halt the spread of COVID-19, multidisciplinary collabora-
tance that parents help their children develop a healthy tion and close partnerships between ministries, schools,
relationship with digital devices. First, digital detox is a and parents are necessary to minimize the long-term collat-
method to encourage healthy digital device habits, using eral impact of COVID-19–related policies on various
digital applications to consciously monitor device usage health outcomes, such as myopia, which was already a ma-
and reminding users to disconnect from the digital world. jor public health concern before the pandemic.
Parents can set limits using in-device applications to
restrict the total screen time spent per day or per session.
Second, supervising digital content is important to ensure
that time spent on digital devices is maximized for learning
experiences. Guiding the child through digital device usage
helps to improve their ability to process and interpret dig- CRediT AUTHORSHIP CONTRIBUTION
ital content and thereby decrease the overall time spent on- STATEMENT
line. Third, having a daily schedule to allocate time for
specific activities and setting boundaries on when and CHEE WAI WONG: WRITING - ORIGINAL DRAFT, CRITICAL
where digital devices can be used can be an effective appraisal of the scientific content and final approval. Andrew
approach, while simultaneously building routine and disci- Tsai: Writing - original draft, critical appraisal of the scien-
pline during the COVID-19 pandemic where days are tific content and final approval. Jost B. Jonas: critical
largely unstructured. Fourth, parents should act as role appraisal of the scientific content and final approval. Kyoko
models by reducing their own digital device usage, Ohno-Matsui: critical appraisal of the scientific content and
spending more time with their children outdoors, engaging final approval. James Chen: critical appraisal of the scientific
their children in offline playtime, and involving them in content and final approval. Marcus Ang: Writing - review
nondigital indoor activities, such as chores, arts and crafts, and editing. Daniel Shu Wei Ting: Writing - original draft,
and music.31,34 critical appraisal of the scientific content and final approval.
ALL AUTHORS HAVE COMPLETED AND SUBMITTED THE ICMJE FORM FOR DISCLOSURE OF POTENTIAL CONFLICTS OF INTEREST.
Funding/Support: The authors indicate no financial support. Financial Disclosures: Dr Ting holds several patents on deep learning systems for eye dis-
eases and is an executive editor of artificial intelligence and digital technology for Ophthalmology and the British Journal of Ophthalmology. He is the
2018 USA Fulbright Scholarship recipient to Johns Hopkins University on a project for artificial intelligence and digital technology in medicine. Dr
Wong has received honoraria from Novartis, Bayer, and Roche and has intellectual property rights and is a patent holder for liposomal prednisolone phos-
phate (PCT/NL2017/050273). Dr Chen is the Chief Executive Officer and founder of Clearly. Dr Jonas is on the advisory board of Novartis and is a patent
holder with Biocompatibles UK Ltd. (Farnham, Surrey, UK; Treatment of eye diseases using encapsulated cells encoding and secreting neuroprotective
factor and/or antiangiogenic factor; patent number: 20120263794) and Europäische Patentanmeldung 16720043.5 and patent application US 2019
0085065 A1 (Agents for use in the therapeutic or prophylactic treatment of myopia or hyperopia). Drs Tsai, Ang, and Ohno-Matsui indicate to financial
conflict of interest. Contributions of Authors: Writing of the first and final drafts (C.W.W., A.T., D.S.W.T); Critical appraisal of the scientific content and
final approval (C.W.W., A.T., D.S.W.T., J.C., J.J., K.O.). All authors attest that they meet the current ICMJE criteria for authorship.
VOL. 223 DIGITAL SCREEN TIME AND MYOPIA IN THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC 337