Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 5

Crafting a literature review on physician-assisted suicide can be an arduous task, requiring

meticulous research, critical analysis, and coherent synthesis of existing scholarly works. This process
involves delving into a myriad of academic articles, journals, books, and other credible sources to
gather relevant information and viewpoints on the subject matter.

One of the primary challenges of writing a literature review is navigating through the vast sea of
literature available on the topic. With the proliferation of research studies and diverse perspectives
surrounding physician-assisted suicide, sifting through the abundance of information can be
overwhelming and time-consuming.

Furthermore, synthesizing the findings from various sources and presenting them in a cohesive and
structured manner requires a high level of analytical thinking and writing skills. It entails identifying
common themes, controversies, gaps in research, and emerging trends in the field, all while
maintaining objectivity and scholarly rigor.

Moreover, ensuring that the literature review adheres to academic standards and guidelines adds
another layer of complexity to the writing process. Proper citation and referencing of sources, as well
as maintaining a logical flow of ideas, are essential aspects that demand attention to detail and
precision.

Given the challenges associated with writing a literature review on physician-assisted suicide,
seeking assistance from professional writing services can be a prudent decision. ⇒ StudyHub.vip ⇔
offers expert assistance in crafting comprehensive and well-researched literature reviews tailored to
your specific requirements.

By entrusting your literature review to ⇒ StudyHub.vip ⇔, you can alleviate the stress and burden
of tackling this demanding task alone. Our team of experienced writers possesses the expertise and
resources to conduct thorough research, analyze complex literature, and deliver a high-quality review
that meets your academic needs.

Whether you are a student grappling with a tight deadline or a researcher seeking to enhance the
quality of your literature review, ⇒ StudyHub.vip ⇔ is here to provide reliable support and
assistance every step of the way. Order your literature review today and experience the difference
our professional writing services can make in achieving your academic goals.
Many have also expressed concerns about whether or not physician-assisted suicide could or would
become euthanasia. Individuals must have a terminal illness as well as a prognosis of six months or
less to live. Its main criticism is what it describes as a lack of safeguards to govern the assessment of
requests for assisted suicide: The bill contains no safeguards, beyond stating eligibility criteria, to
govern the assessment of requests for assisted suicide. APA Reference Pies, R (2012) Euthanasia
Essay Research Paper EuthanasiaA thesis pledge against physician assisted suicide when Essay
Research Paper. Over time, her symptoms worsened, and she was unable to eat with her husband or
get outside in her garden, two things that were very important to her. The issue tells us a lot about
public attitudes towards disabled people. It should not be relied upon as being up to date; the law or
policies may have changed since it was last updated; and it should not be relied upon as legal or
professional advice or as a substitute for it. The High Court refused Mr Nicklinson both forms of
relief.16 He died six days later from pneumonia, having refused food following the judgment.17 It
also refused Martin’s application. This conclusion was supported by all of the Commissioners other
than the Reverend Canon Dr James Woodward, who considered that greater ethical, moral and social
consensus needed to be generated on this issue before legal change should be considered. For more
information, request a quote or trial for your organization below. Opinions from medical
professionals and famous individuals such as Steven Hawking, have helped popularize this idea.
Belgium legalized the practice around the same time as the Netherlands. Autonomy-based arguments
against physician-assisted suicide and. It is this confusion and disagreement over terminology that
has led the BMA to launch the Website. It is not for the court to decide whether the law about
assisted dying should be changed and, if so, what safeguards should be put in place. How can one
claim to know what is right or wrong without experience. It should not be relied upon as being up to
date; the law or policies may have changed since it was last updated; and it should not be relied upon
as legal or professional advice or as a substitute for it. Policies and guidance are there to provide
practical assistance to prosecutors on how particular categories of cases should be approached and
the internal processes that should be followed. Neither legalise voluntary euthanasia, where a doctor
directly administers life- ending medication nor act as a slippery slope to do so. A caveat to this
conclusion, she noted, is that she was working with general practitioners and not specialists, so the
patients tended not to be the sickest and thus had time to process their illnesses. Five days later,
Ottolia issues his written opinion. Given all my training to make patients healthier, could I assist in a
patient’s death with a clear conscience. While laws allowing physician-assisted suicide also let
individual doctors refuse to participate, most require doctors to refer patients to others who will
perform it. There have been several legal cases regarding the offence of assisted suicide, particularly
in the context of disabled or terminally ill people who are unable to end their lives without assistance
from family or friends. There are issues that can only be truly relevant and appropriate to somebody
actually going through pain and suffering. Lord Justice Toulson said: To do as Tony wants, the court
would be making a major change in the law. The Bill was therefore given its Second Reading
without division. The court held that Article 8(1) of the ECHR (the right to private and family life)
was not engaged. For those reasons I would refuse these applications for judicial review.18 Mr
Nicklinson’s widow was added as a party to the proceedings and pursued an appeal to the Court of
Appeal. It states that a person must have a diagnosis from a qualified medical practitioner of a
terminal illness and be reasonably expected to have a life expectancy of up to six months.
Disability rights groups are some of the strongest voices against physician assisted suicide based on
the experience of their community According to disability. Opinions from medical professionals and
famous individuals such as Steven Hawking, have helped popularize this idea. That if you are
disabled or terminally ill, it’s not worth being alive. During all phases, likelihood of provider suicide
documentation was not significantly related to the frequency of patients’ thoughts of death or
suicide (item nine). These studies consist of a death certificate analysis in which a questionnaire is
sent to the attending physician of a stratified sample of deaths as well as a survey among a stratified
sample of physicians in order to study trends in end-of-life decisions. Mr Nicklinson applied to the
High Court for a declaration that a doctor who injected him with a lethal drug or who assisted him in
terminating his own life would be able to make use of the defence of “necessity” and so would not
be liable to criminal charges. If the disease continues to grow, it might render these vital organs unfit
for transplantation. When there are ethical dilemmas and conflicting pressures on physicians’
choices, younger and more junior physicians generally follow the examples set by leaders in their
field. The Bill aims to enable competent adults who are terminally ill to be allowed assistance with
ending their life if they request it. For most people, it is best to remove this guilt by letting them
choose physician assisted suicide. If physician-assisted suicide is allowed in other states, we are
likely to see a similar growth in the number of deaths by suicide across the U.S.”. I once believed
this very same principle, but I have come to a new conclusion. To give one example in support of the
Bill, Lord Falconer said: Some say that the courts should be involved as an additional safeguard
before an assisted death occurs. There are issues that can only be truly relevant and appropriate to
somebody actually going through pain and suffering. The law is not being applied by the Director of
Public Prosecutions because it plainly no longer fits the current situation. Lord Neuberger said there
were four reasons why it would be “institutionally inappropriate at this juncture” for the Supreme
Court to issue a declaration of incompatibility before giving Parliament the opportunity to consider
the position: First, the question whether the provisions of section 2 should be modified raises a
difficult, controversial and sensitive issue, with moral and religious dimensions, which undoubtedly
justifies a relatively cautious approach from the courts. An Environics Institute survey in October
showed that 69 per cent of Canadians support physician-assisted suicide, the highest recorded
approval since 1992. The Consent and Capacity Board were persecuted with a case in which a
couple fought to prolong their newborn son’s life. Prosecutorial Policy decisions must remain fact
specific and certainty about the Policy which can be no more than indicative of the eventual decision
if a crime is committed is not to be equated with the certainty required of provisions which create or
identify criminal offences.23 Mrs Nicklinson and Mr Lamb appealed to the Supreme Court. Of
particular importance is the case of Debbie Purdy, who in July 2009 obtained a House of Lords
ruling ordering the Director of Public Prosecutions to formulate an offence-specific policy setting
out the public interest factors the Crown Prosecution Service will consider whe n deciding whether
to prosecute assisted suicide offences. An argument against physician-assisted suicide - KevinMD
com. According to Norwood, Dutch doctors and families find physician-assisted suicide
unpredictable, so they tend not to pursue it. Autonomy This is a relatively recent sociocultural
imperative in public discourse. Ultimately there cannot be a simple straightforward answer. She
suggested that physicians could certify a patient’s diagnosis and prognosis, and patients could then
use an independent authority to get a prescription for suicide drugs. In the early months of this year
(2015), many states reopened debates surrounding physician-assisted suicide. A caveat to this
conclusion, she noted, is that she was working with general practitioners and not specialists, so the
patients tended not to be the sickest and thus had time to process their illnesses. Earlier this year, on
September 17, 2013, Stephen Hawking publicly agreed with the practice of euthanasia. It is an
option given to individuals by law in Colorado, California, the District of Columbia, Hawaii, Maine,
New Jersey, New Mexico, Oregon, Vermont and Washington. The Assisted Suicide (Scotland) Bill
was introduced in November 2013.
The patient must be within six months of death and must self-administer the drug. One factor that
drove the change in public attitude was the experience drawn from Oregon and the Benelux
countries (Belgium, Luxemburg, and the. Since the law was enacted, there have been between 80
and 90 cases that were ruled to be noncompliant and referred to the public prosecutor, one of which
went to trial. Ultimately there cannot be a simple straightforward answer. Medical personnel are one
of the public’s best resources when faced with health related problems. Thus, they may be able to
influence public opinion regarding the benefits of euthanasia. It may do nothing, either because it
does not share our view that the present law is incompatible, or because, as a sovereign Parliament, it
considers an incompatible law preferable to any alternative. Do you want to give doctors the right to
administer suicide medications. Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like
sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party
features. Further, the extent to which the increased documentation rates were due to the clinic
workshops vs the new templates is unknown. About half of the charts utilized the new templates.
The overwhelming majority of those who request physician-assisted suicide are white — 96 percent
in Oregon. However, if you believe that PAS is unethical or against the interests of patients’ health,
then I hope your example to early-career or uncertain physicians will be to behave ideally as a
physician faced with a professional, ethical conflict, even in the face of a complex legal situation.
Physician assisted suicide essay thesis help - HDS Healthplan Data do so if the practice were
legalized against assisted suicide question and bring religious. The policy is sensible, humane and
provides clarity on how the law is applied in assisted suicide cases. There is a new normal for
everything, and for doctors, physician-assisted suicide may become part of their job description. Of
these 91 cases, 65 were not proceeded with by the CPS. 13 cases were withdrawn by the police. In a
move last month that was called “startling” by the president of the Catholic Medical Association, the
American Association of Family Physicians — whose New York chapter already supports the
practice — changed its official position on physician-assisted suicide from opposed to neutral.
Canada’s law followed extensive back-and-forth about the rules on who exactly can request the
procedure. (Do you have to be near death. Documents are image-based, fully searchable PDFs with
the authority of print combined with the accessibility of a user-friendly and powerful database. Also,
more people will begin to see euthanasia as a normalcy rather than a criminal act. She explained that
the ways in which Montana, Oregon, and Washington, DC, might practice physician-assisted death
are all going to be slightly different. It is plain from its wording that a person who aid, abets,
counsels or procures the suicide of another is guilty of criminal conduct. Free Assisted Suicide
Essays and Papers - 123HelpMe com. Icons by Freepik, Uniconlabs and Rizki Ahmad Fauzi from
Flaticon. Pro-life groups say even considering physician-assisted suicide is the next step on the way
to fully legalised euthanasia. Legalizing physician-assisted suicide is a part of the debate about
improving end-of-life To legalize physician-assisted suicide, some believe, would make real. Given
the high rates of and burden associated with depression and the elevated risk for self-harm among
patients who endorse item nine, it is incumbent upon physicians to effectively use the PHQ-9 and
talk with patients about depression and suicide. The Government has indicated that it considers this
issue to be a matter of individual conscience. Compassion and Choices, a U.S. non-profit
organization, has launched campaigns in Montana, Washington State and Oregon using poignant
pleas from patients to pressure doctors into assisting suicide. Individuals must have a terminal illness
as well as a prognosis of six months or less to live.
It seems inhumane to force a terminally ill patient to suffer in pain and through medical procedures
or to keep alive someone who cannot even eat on his own. Hey, mistakes happen This is the Martin
Sheen argument against assisted suicide. The Consent and Capacity Board were persecuted with a
case in which a couple fought to prolong their newborn son’s life. This law was part of their Death
and Dignity Act, which was approved in 1994. APA Reference Pies, R (2012) Euthanasia Essay
Research Paper EuthanasiaA thesis pledge against physician assisted suicide when Essay Research
Paper. The patient must be within six months of death and must self-administer the drug. It’s a time
one is consistently under pain, pushing through the days hopelessly. The DPP’s policy was published
in February 2010 following a public consultation. Doing some good With the death penalty, doctors
could make prisoners more comfortable and administer a more peaceful death, but they would still be
participating in execution, and so this is recognized as unethical. A number of opinions from
stakeholders representing both sides of the debate are set out below. We examined use of the
templates and changes in rates of documentation of suicidality. About 50 percent of the deaths
occurred in hospitals in large urban areas, Gibson said, though a movement is starting in favor of
having deaths in private residences, hospices, or long-term care facilities. In surveys conducted by
the Canadian Medical Association, members supported legislation on medical aid-in-dying, but there
was some reticence among those surveyed about being a provider of the practice. Depression
screening in an academic family practice. Fam Med. 2017;49(1):42-45. If there is a verdict of
noncompliance, the case is referred to a public prosecutor who then investigates and makes a
decision on whether to prosecute the physician. Approximately 60 percent of the patients had a
cancer diagnosis, and another 18 percent had neurodegenerative disorders. A Canada wide poll
indicated that 79% of the population favoured assisted suicide. Assisted suicide is when a person
assists a patient in committing or attempting suicide. There is still a large religious portion of the
population that disagrees with assisted-suicide. An argument against physician-assisted suicide -
KevinMD com. From 1998 to 2012, it provided assisted suicide to 1,496 people. Informal provider
feedback supports these findings; residents and faculty shared that the templates increased their self-
efficacy and comfort in talking with patients about suicidal thoughts and in documenting treatment
recommendations. Chart documentation of anything regarding suicidality was deemed a “yes.” Chi-
square tests and two-sample t -tests were used to examine changes in documentation patterns. The
main reason that psychiatrists rejected 94 percent of these requests was because they did not meet
the due care criteria. One recent study of Oregonians found that, compared to terminally ill people
who didn’t ask about physician-assisted suicide, those interested in the procedure were more likely
to feel depressed and hopeless, and less likely to be spiritual. In December 2008, the DPP
announced that, while there was sufficient evidence for a realistic prospect of conviction of the
parents (and a family friend who had assisted with travel arrangements), such a prosecution was not
in the public interest and no further action should be taken against them.7 The DPP published his full
decision on the CPS website. It is unlikely that a future DPP would make significant changes to the
policy, but it is always possible. He was unresponsive to pain, sound and discomfort and he could
not blink his eyes. The Government must of course be concerned with the fitness for purpose of any
legislation that may reach the statute book. She garnered a large following advocating for physician-
assisted suicide laws via social media.

You might also like