Professional Documents
Culture Documents
FMDS0600
FMDS0600
Table of Contents
Page
©2002 Factory Mutual Insurance Company. All rights reserved. No part of this document may be reproduced,
stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in whole or in part, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical,
photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without written permission of Factory Mutual Insurance Company.
6-0 Elements of Industrial Heating Equipment
Page 2 FM Global Property Loss Prevention Data Sheets
List of Figures
Fig. 1. Effect of fuel-air ratio on firing explosion hazard. ............................................................................. 5
Fig. 2. Atmospheric inspriator mixer. ............................................................................................................ 7
Fig. 3. Aspirator mixer. .................................................................................................................................. 7
Fig. 4. Variable pressure mixer. .................................................................................................................... 8
Fig. 5. Blower mixer. ..................................................................................................................................... 8
Fig. 6. Cone-slide type carburetor mixer. ..................................................................................................... 9
Fig. 7. Premix burner. ................................................................................................................................... 9
Fig. 8. Nozzle mix burner. ........................................................................................................................... 10
Fig. 9. Typical gas burners. ......................................................................................................................... 11
Fig. 10. Semi-nozzle burner. ....................................................................................................................... 11
Fig. 11. Heavy fuel-oil heating system for horizontal rotary burner. ........................................................... 12
Fig. 12. Vertical rotary vaporizing burner. .................................................................................................... 13
Fig. 13. Oil gasifier or vaporizer. .................................................................................................................. 14
Fig. 14. Oil gasifier or vaporizer. .................................................................................................................. 14
Fig. 15. Pressure atomizing or gun-type burner. ......................................................................................... 15
Fig. 16. Pressure atomizing oil burner. ........................................................................................................ 15
Fig. 17. Pressure atomizing oil burner and combustion air register. ........................................................... 16
Fig. 18. Steam atomizing oil burner. ............................................................................................................ 17
Fig. 19. Horizontal rotary burner. ................................................................................................................. 18
Fig. 20. Horizontal rotary burner with air-driven spinner cup. ..................................................................... 19
Fig. 21. Light wave leng;ths for optical detectors. ....................................................................................... 21
Fig. 22. Grounding of safety control circuits. ............................................................................................... 23
Fig. 23. Underground d-c power supply, with ground fault detection. ......................................................... 24
Fig. 24. Two acceptable methods for maintaining periodic tightness checks for gas safety shutoff valves. . 25
Fig. 25. Acceptable arrangements for checking tightness, where two safety shutoff valves are installed.
In this arrangement, a deadman-type momentary switch is used on the vent valve. ................... 27
Fig. 26. Acceptable arrangement for checking tightness, where two safety shutoff valves are installed.
In this arrangement, an electricalsupervisory cock is used on the vent line. ................................ 28
List of Tables
Table 1. Properties of Typical Commercial Fuel Oils and Gases (English) .................................................. 4
Table 1. Properties of Typical Commercial Fuel Oils and Gases (Metric) .................................................... 4
1.0 SCOPE
This data sheet discusses the fundamentals of combustion, methods for fuel-air mixing, and types of burners
as pertains to industrial heating equipment. Combustion controls, safeguard functions, and recommended
maintenance test procedures are also described.
Recommendations to protect against explosion and fire are made in other data sheets relating to the specific
types of equipment.
2.0 DESCRIPTION
2.1 Hazards
Fuel-fired heating equipment has two major hazards: fires, which must be controlled in intensity and for the
quality of combustion, and fuel explosions. Control and prevention are an integral part of proper operational
sequence, which is established by the use of combustion controls, interlocks, and combustion safeguards.
These devices supervise the following aspects of burner operation: (1) fuel flow and pressure, (2) air flow
and pressure, (3) fuel-air ratio, (4) ignition, (5) combustion, (6) combustion chamber atmosphere, and (7) effect
of combustion heat.
2.1.1 Combustion
Combustion (or burning) may be considered to be the rapid oxidation of fuel resulting in the release of heat
and production of visible light.
2.2 Combustion
2.2.1 Reaction
The actual combustion reaction of fuel and air is complicated. A simplified reaction for methane and air is:
CH4 +2O2 + 8N2 — CO2 +2H2O + 8N2 + heat. Air is composed of about 21% oxygen and 79% nitrogen, plus
a fractional percentage of trace compounds. The inert nitrogen component of air does not participate in the
reaction except for some heat absorption. The trace compounds have been omitted for simplicity.
2.2.2 Fuels
Gaseous fuels are in a physical state ready for combustion. They only need to be mixed with air and provided
with the ignition energy.
Liquid fuels, in addition to air and ignition energy, require vaporization into the gaseous state. Some
decomposition may occur during vaporization and combustion, yielding carbonaceous residues.
Solid fuels also require production of the gaseous hydrocarbons, leaving carbonaceous residues and other
compounds behind. The solid carbons, such as from coal, will react with oxygen at about 2400°F (1320°C)
and 2700°F (1480°C) to form carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide.
makes up reminder)
requiring external
heat 16
Analysis of flue gas
volume of
H2 from combustion of
14 3 3
530-Btu/ft (19.8-MJ/m )
12
CO manufactured gas
10
8
Percent by
(nitrogen
flue gas
CO2 6
4
Over-rich CO2
combustion Over-lean combustion
2
Percent 0 100 Aeration
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 200 300 400
100
50 100 150 200 250 300
Percent excess air
90 -10 2
80 -20 4
Upper explosive limit
70 -30 6
Percent by volume-oxygen
Percent by volume of
Percent by volume-air
60 -40 8
e n
flue gas in air
ng io
Limits of
ra los
flammability -50 10
p
50
Ex
of flue gas
40 in air -60 12
30 -70 14 O2
20 -80 16
18
10 -90
20
-100 20.95
0
Note: Graph applies approximately to Natural gas, Propane and Butane.
For fuel oil, the Carbon Dioxide & Carbon Monoxide concentrations
would be higher and the Hydrogen concentration correspondingly lower.
When the products of combustion are a direct factor in the processing of material in a furnace, the burner
may be designed and adjusted to operate fuel-rich to produce a reducing atmosphere, or to operate with
excess air for an oxidizing atmosphere.
2.4.2 Aspirators
The aspirator-type mixer (Fig. 3) is similar to the atmospheric inspirator. In this case, air under pressure,
4 in. W.C. to 4 psi (0.9 to 27.9 kPa), (9 to 276 mbar), is the prime mover. A zero pressure regulator is installed
in the gas line to keep the gas at atmospheric pressure at the burner. This method of mixing is good for low
pressure gas supplies and has a wide turndown range.
Secondary air
register Primary
air
Inspirator body
(venturi) Spud
Gas
supply
Primary
air shutter Spud holder
Burner Mixer
To
burners
Inspirator
tube
Gas
supply Mixture
control
Air
Zero nozzle
regulator
Air control
valve
Pressure
sensing
line
Orifice
Gas
supply
Zero
regulator
Air
valve
To
burners
Orifice
Combustion
air blower
2 to 6 in. W.C.
0.6 to 1.5 kPa
Gas Adjustable gas
supply valve or orifice
To 2 to 12 in. W.C.
burners 0.6 to 3.0 kPa
Air
filter
Blower
Adjustable air
valve or orifice
Carburetor-type mechanical mixers are combination gas-air valves which respond to changes in demand
while maintaining the preset volume ratio. The three designs (piston, cone and orifice, and slide valve) can
be set at an infinite number of ratios. Figure 6 illustrates the cone and orifice type of carburetor.
1 to 25 psi
7 to 170 kPa
Air To
filter burners
Cones
Gas Slide plate
supply orifice
2.5.1 Premix
Premixing gas and air before the nozzle puts the mixture within its flammable limits (Fig. 7). There are three
methods of premixing:
Gas air
1. Blower or mechanical mixing is used as previously described in Gas/Air Ratio (Fig. 5). Low pressure
systems, <0.5 psi (3.4 kPa) (34 mbar), are located as close as possible to the nozzle to limit piping losses.
Since each system is designed for a specific mixture pressure and nozzle area, no valves can be put in the
mixture piping. High pressure systems, 5 psi (34 kPa), (0.34 bar), are usually used as central mixing stations
for a number of systems which can be separately valved.
2. The gas jet mixer, venturi, or inspirator operates as previously described under Atmospheric Inspirators
in Gas/Air Ratio Control (Fig. 2 and Fig. 3). This type of mixer can use high- and low-pressure gas, but the
mixture pressures produced are limited; 5 psi (34 kPa) (0.34 bar) of gas are needed for 1 in. W.C. (0.25
kPa) (2.5 mbar) of mixture at the discharge of the mixing tube. Higher mixture pressures are obtainable with
a mixing-tube gas jet mixer since gas is injected into an air stream.
3. An air jet mixer operates similarly to an aspirator. Air pressures range from 4 in. W.C. to 4 psi (0.9 to
27.6 kPa) (9 to 276 mbar).
Air
Gas
As an example of the flexibility of nozzle mix burners, short, intense flames are obtained by increasing the
air and fuel velocities, thus increasing the mixing rate. Long, luminous flames are obtained by lowering the air
and gas velocities and thereby delaying mixing. Flat, spiral flames are obtained by spinning the mixture,
changing the forward velocity to lateral. The latter also allows a reduction in combustion volume.
The increased turndown range of nozzle mix burners permits a lower input rate at low fire since flashback
is eliminated.
Burner
Air louver
Refractory spud
blocks
Gas
Gas supply
Air register
Burner tile
Air doors
Burner
Burner Gas driver tile Fan
support arm
Gas
supply
Primary
air
Gas
Secondary
air
Oil return
to tank
Relief valve Hinge
By pass
Thermostat
circulating
governing
line
electric
heater
Water return
to boiler
Fig. 11. Heavy fuel-oil heating system for horizontal rotary burner.
2.7.2 Volumetric
With volumetric control, either air or fuel is controlled by the output of some combustion variable such as
temperature. The rate of the controlled flow is then transmitted to a ratio control device which causes the flow
of the other fluid to respond to the first.
2.8.1 Vaporization
Light oils, Nos. 1 and 2, can be completely vaporized by heat, leaving little or no residue, and burned as
gas. The flame is nonluminous, and blue or purple in color.
In some vaporizing burners, oil is exposed to the radiant heat of an oil-vapor flame burning above a thin
layer of oil, or the oil is drawn into the burner by wicks where it is vaporized by the heat of the flame. In other
types a separate vaporizer is used and the oil vapor produced is burned in regular gas burning equipment.
Vertical rotary vaporizing burner (Fig. 12). In the vertical rotary vaporizing burner, oil enters the burner by
gravity through a constant-level device and flows through a hollow motor shaft to a rotating cup. The cup is
equipped with tubes from which oil is thrown in drops to a metal or refractory groove near the edge of the
firebox. The oil that collects in the groove is vaporized by the flame, and the vapors rise and burn above the
metal or refractory ring at the sides of the firebox.
Solenoid valve
Gas pilot with by-pass
Special Gas
Oil throwing supply
refractory Fan tubes
Oil
Motor Solenoid supply
valve
Oil metering
valve
Overflow trip
bucket valve
& strainer
Such burners usually operate intermittently under automatic control. The oil in the groove can be vaporized
and ignited by gas pilots or by a special flaming-arc type of electric ignition.
Because of the intermittent operation, an explosion hazard exists during the starting period. The hazard is
also present during the operating period, because of the possibility of a change in air adjustment which would
smother the flame.
Oil Gasifiers. One type of oil gasifier vaporizes light oil with a self-contained heater and mixes the vapor
with air to supply the burners as a substitute for gas in heat treating furnaces, some types of ovens, and other
gas heated equipment.
An early design is shown in Fig. 13, where a constant level of oil is maintained in the bottom of a vaporizing
chamber. Above this chamber is a mixing inspirator in which air at pressures up to 8 oz (3.5 kPa) (35 mbar)
passes through a nozzle and venturi tube, creating a suction in the vaporizing chamber. The inspirator
suction draws the hot products of combustion through the oil, vaporizing it. The vapor is drawn into the
inspirator, mixed with air, and delivered to the burners.
Vapor-air
mixture
Air
Burner
Startup pressure Vaporized
atomizer oil
Fuel oil Hot gases
A current design (Fig. 14) starts with a pressure-atomizing oil nozzle which discharges with the combustion
air into a venturi. After a brief interval the venturi assembly will draw hot gases back through the gasifier
line. The operating oil supply valve is then opened, and oil is vaporized by the returned hot gases and drawn
into the venturi. The atomizing nozzle is then shut down.
The heavier oils, Nos. 4, 5 and 6, cannot be satisfactorily burned in vaporizing burners because they break
down into light oils and residual material when heated. Most of the latter is carbon which does not burn readily
and eventually obstructs the burner.
In a gun-type burner (Fig. 15), oil is drawn to the burner by a rotary pump and discharged through an atomizing
nozzle at abut 100 psi (0.69 MPa) (6.9 bar). A relief valve regulates the pump discharge pressure by returning
excess oil to the tank or pump suction.
4 3 6 2 1
9
8
5 Oil slot
Orifice
Whirling
chamber
Sprayer Plate
Part 5
This face seats here
Distribution
annulus
Pressure Atomizer
1. Coupling and yoke
Nozzle Body
Part 3 2. Extension piece
3. Burner nozzle body
4. End cap
5. Sprayer plate
6. Distance piece
7. Coupling
8. Gasket
9. Coupling yoke screw
In an industrial mechanical-type burner (Fig. 16), preheated oil at 150 to 300 psi (1.0 to 2.0 MPa) (10 to 20
bar) is discharged from the burner nozzle in a fine mist. Air enters through a register and mixes with the
oil spray after passing a diffusing plate (Fig. 17).
Air register
control
Flexible
connection
from oil
supply valve
Shield
Oil tube
clamp
Nozzle
Removable Firebox
oil tube
Firebox
wall
Draft casing Air register
used with forced
draft, omitted
when burner is
operated with
natural draft
Fig. 17. Pressure atomizing oil burner and combustion air register.
Mechanical atomizers are limited to less than a 2 to 1 turndown since a drop in pressure drastically affects
the atomization.
Blower
Fixed oil tube Primary air
in hollow shaft control Spinner cup
Air
Motor directing
Oil vanes
inlet Gear driving
oil pump Gas pilot
Secondary
air inlets
Air inlet
register
Firebox
Air supply
from blower
Pilots
Pilots for automatic- and semiautomatic-ignited burners are of three types. A continuous pilot burns without
turndown throughout the entire period that the heating equipment is in service, whether or not the main
burner is firing. An intermittent pilot burns during light-off and while the main burner is firing, and shuts off
with the main burner. An interrupted pilot burns during the pilot flame-establishing and/or trial-for-ignition
periods, and cuts off (i.e. is interrupted) at the end of this period or during firing.
Safety Shutoff Valves
The safety shutoff valve is the master of all safety controls used to protect against explosion or fire which
could result from accidental interruption of various operations. Hazardous interruptions would include failures
involving the burner flame, fuel pressure, combustion-air pressure, exhaust or recirculation fans, temperature
controls, or primary power.
An approved fuel safety shutoff valve is held open by electrical energy, pressure or both. It is self-closing
within 5 seconds after the holding medium is cut off. Approved valves are available in manual or automatic
opening types. Both can be opened only after the holding medium is applied and are so enclosed that they
cannot be readily bypassed or blocked open. Blocking the valve’s operating handle does not prevent it from
closing when the holding medium is cut off.
All approved fuel safety shutoff valves, except the direct-acting, packless solenoid type, have a mechanically
actuated indicator to show whether the valve is open or shut. Some packless solenoid types have
magnetically actuated position indicators.
The three types of temperature detectors are (1) bimetal element and switch, (2) bulb and capillary
combination and switch, and (3) thermocouple and relay or solenoid.
The bimetal element consists of two dissimilar metals fastened together which provide motion to operate a
switch when heated. This type of detector is usually placed in the flue.
Bulb and capillary detectors consist of a metal bulb connected to capillary tubing which operates a bellows
controlling a switch. This type operates upon expansion or contraction of a fluid. It is usually used with small
gas pilots.
A thermocouple consists of two wires of different metals fastened to form a junction. When placed in a flame,
enough voltage is generated to initiate action to cause operation of a solenoid actuated fuel valve.
A flame rod depends upon the ability of a flame to conduct electricity. The rod acts as one electrode and
the burner head or furnace walls as the ground electrode across which an alternating voltage is applied.
Appreciable current will only flow between the two when the rod is negative and ground positive. The flame
thus acts as a rectifier. This current then feeds an amplifier whose output signal is strong enough to hold
open a fuel valve. Any current leakage causes an ac signal in the circuit and a subsequent shutdown.
Direct-currnt flame systems, which were the forerunners of flame-rectification ac systems, could not
differentiate between flame and current leakage and, therefore, are no longer used.
For a flame rod to function properly, the rod must be properly located, the ground area a minimum of four
to one, and the flame being monitored stable and in constant contact with the grounding area.
The use of flame rods is usually limited to the smaller gas flames, such as pilots, because of the rod’s
temperature limits. Rods are rarely used on oil burners because oil flames produce deposits on the rod which
may prevent electrical conduction.
There are no performance requirements for flamerods. They are compatible with any brand of combustion
safeguard.
Optical detectors sense the radiant energy produced by a flame. There are three types (Fig. 21).
cadmium sulfide
U.V. detector response
photocell
Response Oil flame
Gas flame
1. The visible-light rectifying phototube has a cathode containing cesium oxide which emits electrons in the
presence of visible light and, therefore, causes a current flow. Since the control circuitry operates on rectified
current only, it is protected from false signals due to short circuits.
Cadmium sulfide photocells are sensitive to radiation in the visible light spectrum. Their electrical resistance
is inversely proportional to light intensity.
These detectors are used only on single burner, oil-fired installations since they cannot differentiate between
the light of several burners. They are not used for gas flames because of the insufficient visible light emitted.
2. Infrared sensors contain lead sulfide which decreases in resistance when exposed to infrared radiation,
permitting a current flow. A special amplifier used for this current responds only to the flickering of a flame and
is not affected by refractory light.
Infrared sensors can be used on gas or oil flames, and are ideal for large oil burners.
3. An ultraviolet sensor has a cathode that emits electrons when it is exposed to ultraviolet light with a high
potential applied across its electrodes. The electrons ionize the gas in the sensing tube, permitting a current
flow.
Ultraviolet sensors can be used for gas and combination burners as well as multiple-burner installations and
pulverized coal burners. Electric ignition sparks emit ultraviolet light. Therefore this type of sensor must be
arranged to detect only the burner flame.
Some UV scanners have a self-checking feature. A shutter closes over the cell every six seconds for a fraction
of a second. If the scanner does not sense a loss of flame during the check, the scanner will initiate a
shutdown. UV scanner cells can fail in an unsafe manner and detect flame even when no flame is present,
although this is very rare. Equipment that operates continuously for periods longer than a week normally
uses this type of scanner (if using a UV scanner). The combustion safeguard does a safe-start check at each
startup and, in effect, a scanner check also.
The pilot-flame establishing period is that interval of time during lighting-off when a safety control circuit
permits the pilot fuel safety shutoff valve to remain open before the combustion safeguard is required to prove
the presence of the pilot flame.
The trial-for-ignition period is that time during lighting-off when a safety control circuit permits the main burner
fuel safety shutoff valve to remain open before the combustion safeguard is required to supervise the main
burner flame alone.
Distribution
Distribution transformer
transformer
220v 110v 1o
220v 110v 1 o 320v 110v 220v
110v
up 220v
Hot Hot 1o
Provide grounding conductor
Hot to ground at control transformer
1o 1o secondary
110v 110v
1o
110v
1o
110v Safety control circuit*
Safety control circuit*
C. Single phase - 3 wire supply mid point
ground at distribution transfer
A. Single phase 110v - 2 wire supply one side
ground at distribution transfer
Distribution
transformer 120v 208v
3o or 1o
220v 120v 208v 208v
220v 3 o 208v
220v
208v 208v Provide grounding
conductor to ground
220v at control transformer
or secondary
Provide grounding conductor
to ground at control transformer
secondary Hot Hot Hot
Hot
* Note: 1o 1o 1o 1o 1o
Non current carrying metal parts 120v 120v 120v 120v 120v
(equipment enclosures, conduit) Safety control circuit*
should also be grounded by connection Safety control circuit*
1o
to the grounding conductor.
110v D. Three phase - 4 wire supply grounded neutral
Safety control circuit* at distribution transformer
115v D.C.
L L
115v D.C.
R1 R2
C1 C2
Battery
Alarms
Fig. 23. Underground d-c power supply, with ground fault detection.
Fuel safety shutoff valves, combustion safeguards, temperature-limit switches, fan interlocks or other safety
controls may malfunction without the operator’s knowledge unless the faulty controls cause nuisance
shutdowns. In some cases, operators concerned primarily with production may bypass a faulty safety control
without reporting the trouble.
Tests should be made by personnel who are competent, well trained, and familiar with the equipment and
the specific functions of the various safety controls. It is usually better to have personnel from the mechanical
or electrical maintenance departments rather than the regular operators make inspections and tests, although
in smaller plants it may be necessary to use the operators. In larger plants, several people should be trained
so that competent personnel will always be available when tests are due. The inspection reports should go
to the management executive, whose responsibility includes both safety and production. Arrangements
should be made to insure coordination between operating and inspecting personnel. In many cases tests
can be made during nonoperating periods. Upon completion of the tests, covers of all safety controls should
be properly sealed in place to minimize tampering.
The following inspection and testing program should be conducted for all fuel fired heating equipment:
Fig. 24. Two acceptable methods for maintaining periodic tightness checks for gas safety shutoff valves.
Open cock 4 so as to vent any gas trapped in piping between valve 1 and cock 3 (method 1) or between
valve 1 and cock 6 (method 2). Then hold outlet end of hose just barely under the surface of some water in
a small container (can, bottle, etc.), and observe if bubbles appear. If no bubbling occurs, safety shutoff valve
may be reported bubble-tight.
If bubbling occurs and continues at a rate of more than one bubble per second through a 1⁄4 inch (6 mm)
tube, the safety shutoff valve should be immediately cleaned and overhauled or replaced. However, it may
be desirable to accurately measure the leakage rate beforehand: (a) fill a graduated glass cylinder with water
and invert it in a large container of water; (b) insert end of hose in end of cylinder, and measure time interval
required (seconds) to displace any given number of cubic centimeters of water displaced by seconds
required; (c) if leakage rate exceeds 400 cm3/hr, which corresponds to 0.014 ft3/hr, valve should be
immediately cleaned and overhauled or replaced. Repeat the test after installing the new or overhauled valve.
Important: At newly installed equipment, if this test discloses that the valve has leakage, it may indicate that
fuel gas piping was not properly cleaned out so as to be free of weld particles, pipe chips, etc. Have pipeline
and valve cleaned and then repeat test.
115 volts 60 HZ
Fuse
Line terminals of
combustion safeguard
Safety shut-
off valve
Motorized safety
shut-off valve
Vent valve
Safety shut-off valve Dead - man switch
(momentary contact)
Regulator Gauge Safety shut-off valve
C D
Gauge
A B To
Strainer burner
Regulator
Test valves
Rubber hose
Pilot safety Water cups
valve
Fig. 25. Acceptable arrangements for checking tightness, where two safety shutoff valves are installed. In this arrangement,
a deadman-type momentary switch is used on the vent valve.
5. Test main valve No. 2 for tightness. Shut off lubricated plug cock No. 2, remove plug at test connection,
and open valve to bleed line between main valve No. 2 and lubricated plug cock No. 2. Make bubble test.
6. Close valve in test connection, replace plug, and open lubricated plug cock No. 2.
7. Test vent valve for tightness. Remove plug at test connection and open valve to bleed line between vent
valve and supervisory cock. Make bubble test.
8. Close valve in test connection and replace plug.
9. Open supervisory cock. Control panel can now be energized to resume normal operation.
Combustion controls and safeguards, burners, and fuel air mixers are defined and described in several NFPA standards, such as No. 85
B, D, and E Boiler-Furnaces and No. 86 A, B, C and D Ovens and Furnaces. There is no known conflict with these standards.
D.P.D.T switch on
supervisory cock
NO NO
Contacts of D.P.D.T switch
NC NC are shown in position with
supervisory cock open
To outside
atmosphere
N.O. vent
valve N.C. main
N.C. main valve No.2
valve No.1
To burner
No.1 No.2
Lubricated plug cock
Fig. 26. Acceptable arrangement for checking tightness, where two safety shutoff valves are installed. In this arrangement,
an electricalsupervisory cock is used on the vent line.