LSJ 329 Final
LSJ 329 Final
segmentations. We think of the borders that dictate global relations and political
struggles. We see people desperately trying to make it across borders, from one state
to another. This all seems incredibly natural at first. It is the world we have all been
presented with, and our understanding of how the humans on the globe function is
informed by where they exist within these borders. People's lives are dictated by these
lines that define the modern world. Through the use of White by Law, Why Does
Immigration Occur, and The Many Global South’s, I will depict how we live in a global
society in which a select few have access to wealth and opportunity at the cost of the
wellbeing of the majority. White people in liberal democracies exist freely and with rights
and protections. However this freedom to live in this way is conditional on the
exploitation of people of color, both within and outside of the democracy. Within the
liberal democracy they will never experience the same levels of citizenship as their
white counterparts, and for many this will lead to violence and exploitation. The
extraction of wealth from globally southern countries. We live the way we do because
they often live in instability and poverty. And even when they try to escape these
The borders of our world are not natural. They are not set in stone, and they
represent so much more than lines on maps. Our modern world was carefully crafted by
decades of colonialism and neocolonialsim. Borders don’t just happen, they are crafted,
and the borders of the modern world were carefully constructed to create and maintain
power hierarchies. The global north and global south have emerged as two sides of a
coin. Their connection and interaction is informed and defined by conoliaslist practices
and modern power structures like the UN. Broadly speaking, the global north assumed
power positions of exploiter and the global south was and is theirs for exploiting. It is the
powerful liberal democracies of the west who control the politics of the globe, and they
have continually used this power to steal capital from the global south. Not only are
these countries left to deal with the scars of colonialism on their own, they are
continually losing capital to the global north. These two factors lead to systematic
instability within these places that poses a threat to the lives of the people who reside
there. Many of them try to migrate to the safety of the liberal democracy, but very few
So what is the “liberal democracy” and why is it such a coveted place? The
liberal democracy is the place of individual rights and freedoms, and it is coveted for the
opportunity it offers. In this space you can become anyone you want, you just have to
pull yourself up by your bootstraps and make the reality you want for yourself. However,
the system is rigged, making it a lot easier for certain individuals to “win”. As the writers
of the liberal democracy knew from their positions of power inherited from colonialism,
excelling in an individual based society is a lot easier with an advantage and a cheat
code. So a society is set up in which individuals have the right to live how they like, as
long as they can provide that reality for themselves. Racial hierarchies dictated that
white people were the only ones allowed to fully participate in society while being a
person of color meant that you were victim of exploitation. These are the foundations of
our modern society, and while we have progressed to a point where everyone has the
right to fully engage with society, the rules are still set up to empower white people and
leave people of color vulnerable to exploitation. It doesn’t matter if human, collective, or
global rights are violated. The health of the community, society, and world is outweighed
by the right of privileged white individuals to have all the freedoms and rights in the
world.
The way in which you are allowed to exist within society is defined by certain
identity traits such as race, so the way in which this concept is defined and employed
elements of morphology” (Haney Lopez 10). Race is a socially constructed concept that
gives meaning to different features and lineage. While these meanings are just
societally cultivated beliefs, they become concepts with force when they are reproduced
by who has wealth and who does not. Social and legal actors accept these ideas
meaning that the material wealth has become conditioned by race. When you consider
the individualistic ideals of a world controlled by the liberal democracy, you see that the
ability of people of color to excel and access safety and opportunity within this system is
considerably blocked. Individuals in the liberal democracy are expected to provide the
life they want for themselves, but there is no acknowledgment of the meaning of race
The process through which these various levels of interactions with society have
been managed through citizenship. Citizenship is both a legal and social institution.
Legal citizenship entails the rights and duties that an individual and the state owe one
another. However, legal citizenship has never had the effect of equal rights or inclusion
for many americans. Racist ideals institutionalized within law still deny many Americans
of color the equal rights and protections they are legally entitled to. Secondly, legal
society (Joseph, Golash 2). Citizenship is incredibly important as it defines the way in
which you will interact with the state and society. It determines if you will be given rights
and protections or if you will be left open to legitimate violence and exploitation form the
state. Citizenship has been used as a tool to empower certain populations and
disenfranchise others. The state has the sole ability to dictate who is a citizen and
therefore allowed to access the priveleges of society and who is doing so “illegally”.
There is no inherent difference between a citizen and non citizen, the disparities we see
are completely state created. Both kinds of people are simply existing within a space,
but an invisible label is what will decide how they are allowed to exist within that space.
By labeling the legal actions of undocumented people as “illegal” the state has created
an entire population that is open to exploitation and legitimate state violence. Without
documents undocumented workers are often exploited by working for low wages in
unsafe conditions. Additionally, because they are “illegal” the state has the right to
abuse these people without public complaint, and it regularly does so. In the series
manhandled multiple characters, lied and essentially kidnapped one, deported, and
were a pervasive negative force in their lives. All these instances depicted how the state
and being undocumented leads to violence and exploitation, why are people trying to
get into the position of being a migrant? Migration is an individual choice made by
millions of unique decisions. However, there are theories that we can use to understand
global migration as a whole. The world systems theory states, “political power is
perpetuate inequalities and reinforce a stratified economic order.” (Massey 40). This
theory explains how the dominant capitalistic countries are “core” nations while those
on the “periphery” are dependent on them. Due to years of colonialism and extraction
these countires experience higher levels of poverty and instability. Therefore in order to
exist in the capitalistic global society, they must engage in partnerships with core
nations that may be against their best interests. Wealth from the global south is
continually funneled into the global north, continually creating more poverty and
instability. People residing in these countires wish to escape this and find more
opportunity in the liberal democracy “core” nations. However, it is actually the poorest
countires that are recieve in the most refugees (Arar, Fitzgerald 135). In order to
preserve the stability and status quo within the core nations, they want to let few
numbers of migrants in. So they engage in what scholars call, “the grand compromise”
in which these wealthy countires essentially pay periphery states to host and manage
the worlds refugee (Arar and Fitzgerald 135). The high number of refugees in our world
right now is a direct result of the practices of wealthy capitalist democracies, and when
these people try to escape the conditions that were created for them, they are turned
away from rights and opportunity and forced to remain within the instability of the world
Borders and migration are the perfect depiction of global inequality. Borders
decide who gets to live in a stable and safe country and who will be subjected to lack of
colonialism. Borders determine who within a boundary will have rights and who will not.
They inform who gets to be a citizen and how that citizenship will be experienced.
Migration tells the story of people trying to escape the consequences of power hierarchy
and that power still winning. People try to leave the instability but remain trapped inside
of it, all while the citizens of the liberal democracy live their daily lives within the society
sense of twoness that minorities within the United Stated develop in response to the
ones culture while also existing within dominant white society. Joseph and Golash
applied this concept to immigrants, both documented and undocumented, within the
U.S. Anti immigrant sentiment is very apparent in American culture. We are told that
immigrants are a threat to our national security and economy, despite the fact that this
has been disproven. Immigrants simultaneously feel a sense of belonging and feeling
American while being told they are threats and unwanted. This leaves them with a
sense of twoness about their place in society. These discourses affect both how the rest
of society sees immigrants and the way in which they society and themselves. It can be
described as a veil one is looking through that taints the view they see. Double
consciousness is much more than just an ideology however, it has real life
consequences in the actions of those viewing immigrants through the veil. Immigrants
often experience racial profiling, interpersonal discrimination, and high tend surveillance
from law enforcement. In my drawing I have depicted your typical american family living
“the american dream” on one side of the road and another family on the other side
coming towards them. This is to represent the fact that they have just arrived and are
emigrants into this society. The two American flags are being used as curtain rods, and
they are holding up the veil. The veil depicts how the racialized legal status of
immigrants effects the way they experience society and the way society perceives them.
The flags are holding it up because it American culture, laws, and institutions that have