Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Desertation Research
Desertation Research
COLLEGE OF NURSING
A dissertation submitted to
APRIL - 2013
A STUDY TO EVALUATE THE EFFECTIVENESS OF AROMA THERAPY
MASSAGE ON ANXIETY AMONG ELDERS AT SELECTED OLD AGE
HOME, MADURAI-20.
MEDICAL EXPERT _
A dissertation Submitted to
APRIL -2013
CERTIFICATE
partial fulfillment of requirements for the award of the degree of Master of Science in
Nursing, Branch V, Psychiatric (Mental Health) Nursing Under our guidance and
Mrs.S.Poonguzhali M.Sc (N), M.A, MBA, Ph.D., Dr.N.Mohan, M.S., F.I.C.S., F.A.I.S.,
PRINCIPAL IN CHARGE DEAN
COLLEG OF NURSING MADURAI MEDICAL COLLEGE
MADURAI MEDICAL COLLEGE MADURAI – 20.
MADURAI-20.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
"My grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness.”
Therefore I will boast all the more gladly about my weaknesses, So that
Christ’s power may rest on me. That is why, for Christ’s sake, delight in
(II-Corinthians12:9, 10)
The satisfaction and pleasure that accompany the successful completion of any
task would be incomplete without mentioning the people who made it possible, whose
constant guidance and encouragement rewards, any effort with success. I consider it a
privilege to express my gratitude and respect to all those who guided and inspired me
in the completion of this study.
As a final note, my sincere thanks and gratitude to my sisters and their family,
all my friends and relatives who directly or indirectly helped me to complete this
study.
massage on anxiety among elders at selected old age home. Conceptual framework:
the conceptual frame work based on CIPP Model, this model was created by Daniel L.
process evaluation and product evaluation. Design: This study employed a one group
pre test and post test design and the samples were selected by using purposive
sampling technique. Setting of the study: The study was conducted in selected old
age homes (inba illam old age home) at Madurai. Subjects: The study was conducted
with the total number of 30 subject aged above 60 years. Intervention: The selected
Totally 15 sessions of aroma therapy massage was given. Main outcome: Pre and
post test anxiety were measured using Aaron beck anxiety scale before and after
aroma therapy massage. Findings: The aroma therapy massage proved that there is a
difference between the pretest and posttest. It revealed that the calculated “t” value
(17.743**) was much higher than the table value 2.05 at 0.05 level of significance.
Conclusion: These findings support that the aroma therapy massage is an effective
TABLE
TITLE PAGE NO
NO
FIGURE PAGE
TITLE
NO NO
1. Conceptual framework 30
APPENDIX TITLE
G. Consent Form
I. Photographs
CHAPTER - I
INTRODUCTION
Aging is the Normal Process of time related changes, begins with birth and
continues throughout life. The aging of population is a global phenomenon, the later
years of life the conventionally seen as one where pathologic of body, minds and
social relationship takes place.
World Health Assembly on aging (2001) Over the past few years, the world's
population has continued on its remarkable transition path from a state of high birth
and death rates to one characterized by low birth and death rates. At the heart of that
transition has been the growth in the number and proportion of older persons. Such a
rapid, large and omnipresent growth has never been seen in the history of civilization.
More recently James sterling Ross (2004) commented “you do not heal old
age” you protect it, and you promote it, life expectancy had increased in recent years.
In 2011, Indian aging population is 96million, the percentage to the total population is
8.2%. In India the life expectancy projected in 2011, 2016 has been 67 years for male
and 69 years for female, 21% of the Indian population will be above 60 years of age
by the year 2050. Industrialization urbanization, education and exposure of western
life style are bringing changes in values of life. The old age population has become
vulnerable due to which they become distressed, anxiety and depression. Growing old
in a society that has been observed with youth may have a clinical impact on the
manual health of many people. The situation has series implication for psychiatric
nursing.
The concept of “old” has changed drastically over the years. The Tamilnadu
census in the year 2011 shows there are more than 580 million people over 60 years
of age and their numbers are growing at over 11 million a year. More people are
living to older ages, with higher proportions of most countries’ populations aged 60
years and above than at any time in history.
Social aging involves patterns of interaction between the aging individual and
the social structure. Many social positions are related to chronological age, and
individuals are expected to conform to the age-based norms associated with these
positions. Social aging is also influenced by the size and composition of the social
structure as it changes over time, by change within a society and by cultural and
subculture variations in attitudes toward aging and the aged.
Elders often express concern about living "too long" and therefore becoming a
burden on others and useless to themselves. Knowing a person's general level of
anxiety, then, does not necessarily identify what it is that most disturbs a person about
the prospect of death. The fact that most people report themselves as having a low to
moderate level of death anxiety does not offer support for either Freud's
psychoanalytic or Becker's existential theory. Respondents do not seem to be in the
grips of intense anxiety, but neither do they deny having any death-related fears.
Kirshenbaum’s Edge theory offers a different way of looking at this finding.
According to the theory, most people do not have a need to go through life either
denying the reality of death or in a high state of alarm. Either of these extremes would
actually interfere with one's ability both to enjoy life and cope with the possibility of
danger. The everyday baseline of low to moderate anxiety keeps people alert enough
to scan for potential threats to their own lives or the lives of other people.
The constant state of worry and anxiousness may seriously affect older
people’s quality of life by causing them to limit their daily activities and have
difficulty sleeping. If untreated, generalized anxiety disorder may also lead to
depression. Other conditions considered anxiety disorders include phobias, panic
disorder, and obsessive compulsive disorder. With the months reported an overall
improvement in symptoms and quality of life. "Anxiety in people over age 60 might
have some similarities to anxiety in those younger, but it also has marked differences.
We can't just assume that we can treat the two age groups the same,” "We are decades
behind where we need to be in terms of research and treatments for anxiety in this
older age group.”
Anxiety is something everyone experiences and it may vary from time to time
and person to person. For most people, their anxiety is related to something concrete
and passes when the event is past. When there is no apparent reason for
"nervousness," and it becomes chronic, it is particularly hard for both the anxious
person and those around her to live with anxiety in the elders were demonstrated by a
variety of symptoms. We all know an older person who has an attack of "nerves" at
the drop of every hat. Some hyper-anxious people experience tremors, blurred vision,
diarrhea, shortness of breath, and even chest pain. "Not feeling well" and staying in
bed to avoid an anxiety provoking event is common.
Eric J. Lenze, MD, (2006) quoted that “Studies have shown that generalized
anxiety disorder is more common in the elders, affecting 7% of seniors. Surprisingly,
there is little research that has been done on this disorder in the elders.
Old age was always a problem, not only in India but also around the world.
Old age homes were alien in concept and elder abuse was considered a global
problem. As life expectancy has increased from 41 years in 1951 to 64 years today,
hundreds of old age homes have sprung up in India. Neglect of parents has become a
big issue, so that the Indian government has passed "The maintenance and welfare of
parents and senior citizens bill 2006", which makes it imperative for adult children to
look after their parents. As of 1998, there were 728 Old Age Homes in India. Detailed
information about 547 of these is available. Out of these, 325 homes are free of cost
while 95 old age homes are on pay & stay basis, 116 homes have both free as well as
pay & stay facilities and 11 homes have no information. A total of 278 old age homes
all over the country are available for the sick and 101 homes are exclusively for
women. Madurai has nearly 31 old age homes among them the inba illam is a oldest
old age home at Madurai. So the researcher interested to do the study at Inba illam.
Naomi Coleman (2005), Massage can be particularly useful for people suffering
from anxiety and panic attacks because it helps them relax - often for the first time in
their life, claim practitioners. Massage can be an important tool in helping to raise self
worth in mental health patients.
Aromatherapy makes use of the herbs and the fragrant essential oils in order
to promote the natural health and healing. The father of modern medicine,
Hippocrates also believed in the use of the herbs in order to maintain one’s health.
Several of his prescriptions contain fragrant crushed herbs and essential oils. Till the
tenth century, the books were being written in the Arabia, these books were devoted
to the utilization and benefits of the specific aromas.
Life seems to be meaningless. An individual slogs all through his life for the
family and with a view that a day would come when he/she can just relax in his
armchair and read his favorite book and tell tales of his youthful days to the younger
generation.
The researcher felt that age concern measures to break down the barriors of
seeking help Will modified the reluctant behavior of elders with anxiety. Since the
elders stayed in old age home are left alone without their family members may
aggregate the anxiety episodes.
Both medication and psychosocial therapies are used to treat anxiety in older
persons, although clinical research on their effectiveness is progressing.
Aromatherapy is one of the complementary and alternative medicines used to treat
various symptoms because essential oils have many kinds of pharmacologic actions
including anxiolytic anti-microbial, sedative, analgesic, and spasmolytic and estrogen
or steroid hormone like effects etc.
Zhou, Zhenyu, (2011) Aromatherapy is one of the fastest growing and widely
used complementary and alternative therapies in the world today. Nurses use
aromatherapy both in their working and private life for many purposes. Many
researches provided much evidence in the area. Zhou, Zhenyu, RN, RMN, BHSC
(Nursing) said in her paper critically evaluates the current knowledge of aromatherapy
and provides supportive evidences for nurses to incorporate aromatherapy into
practice. Aromatherapy enhanced relaxation, reduced anxiety and promoted sleep,
especially for the elders. It helped people to feel invigorated or rejuvenated,
depending on the types of oil used. Some studies stated that aromatherapy only had
transient effect. While other studies revealed massage had better effect than inhalation
in reducing anxiety level and pain, but more research are required to support these
therapeutic claims.
From the above evidence, it is learn that the elder’s anxiety and it also
increases the level of anxiety since they reside in the old age home, so the researcher
adopts certain measures and needs of aromatherapy towards reducing the anxiety
level of elders in old age home.
1.3 OBJECTIVES
To assess the pre and post test level of anxiety among elders at selected old age
home.
To evaluate the effectiveness of aromatherapy massage on anxiety among elders
To associate posttest score of anxiety among elders and selected demographic
variables
1.4 HYPOTHESES
H1 - The mean posttest score of anxiety will be significantly lesser than the
mean pretest score of elders.
H2 - There will be a significant association between the posttest score of
anxiety among elders and selected demographic variables
EFFECTIVENESS
AROMATHERAPY MASSAGE
ANXIETY
ELDERS
In this study the elders refers to an older individual (or) aging individual
between 60-80years of age.
OLDAGE HOME
In this study the old age home refers to the destitute of elders residing with
free of cost in Inba Illam, Pasumalai at Madurai.
1.6 ASSUMPTIONS
The study is based on the assumption that elders were residing at old age home
having varying degree of anxiety.
Aroma therapy massage is reducing anxiety among elders were residing at old
age home.
1.7 DELIMITATION
The study was delimited to elders residing in Inba Illam Old age home.
The study was delimited for a period of 4 weeks duration.
The study was delimited to elders between 60 - 80 years
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
“A good day is one where I cannot just read a book, but write a
review of it. Maybe today I'll be able to do that. I get for some
reason somewhat stronger when the sun starts to go down. Dusk is
a good time for me. I'm crepuscular.”
Christopher
Hitchens
A literature review is a body of text that aims to review the critical points of
current knowledge including substantive findings as well as theoretical and
methodological contributions to a particular topic. Literature reviews are secondary
sources, and as such, do not report any new or original experimental work.
The related literature was studied and reviewed to broaden the understanding
and to gain insight into the problems under the study.
Gerstorf, D. Smith, J. & Baltes, P. B (2006). The Berlin Aging Study, to examine
the distribution of anxiety symptoms and disorders in a representative community
sample. A sample of 258 old (70 to 84 years) and 258 very old (85 to 103 years)
subjects were examined. The raw score distributions of anxiety subscales obtained by
this procedure are examined by age, gender, education, personal living situation, and
psychiatric co morbidity. The weighted overall prevalence of anxiety in the elderly
community is 4.5% (n = 17), including specified (n = 8) anxiety disorders according
to the DSM-III-R and unspecified (n = 9) disorders. Prevalence rates in the younger
old were 4.3% and in the older old 2.3%. Weighted prevalence rates for males were
2.9% and for females 4.7%.Indepentently of the nosological level, 52.3% reported one
or more symptoms of anxiety. Factor analysis of anxiety-related symptoms yielded 5
independent subscales, reflecting hypochondrias is, panic, phobia, worries, and
vegetative anxiety. There were more phobic symptoms in the younger age group (P <
.001).
Tomader Taha Abdel Rahman (2005). Cross sectional study was done
among elders aged 60 -80yrs, to evaluate the prevalence of anxiety and depression
thus who were living in the old age home and geriatric clubs Cairo at Egypt. .They
are living at their own homes and going to geriatric clubs regularly as Elwaily,
Elshams and Eltayaran (group I) or living at geriatric homes as Elsafa, Elmarwa and
Oly Elalbab (group II). Sample size of at least 110 subjects from each group. The
duration of survey was 6 months, Hamilton Anxiety Scale was used in this study. It
consists of 14 items, each defined by a series of symptoms. Each item is rated on a 5-
point scale, ranging from 0 (not present) to 4 (severe). The total score is 0 – 17 for
normal individual, 18 – 24 for mild anxiety, 25 – 29 for moderate anxiety and ≥ 30
for severe anxiety. Data was coded for analysis test was used for categorical data. P-
value < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
Lenze, Eric, J (2001). Recent geriatric literature for studies associating late-
life depression or anxiety with physical disability. Studies showed that Anxiety in late
life was also found to be a risk factor for disability, although not necessarily
independently of depression. Increased disability due to depression is only partly
explained by differences in socioeconomic measures, medical conditions, and
cognition. Physical disability improves with treatment for depression; comparable
studies have not been done for anxiety. The authors discuss how these findings inform
current concepts of physical disability and discuss the implications for future
intervention studies of late-life depression and anxiety disorders.
Lai, T.K (2011). This study employed a randomized control group pre- and
post test design and included an aroma massage group, plain massage group, and
control group. To evaluate the effect of aromatherapy, the degree of constipation was
measured using a constipation assessment scale, severity level of constipation and the
frequency of bowel movements. The score of the constipation assessment scale of
the aroma massage group was significantly lower than the control group. Apart from
the improvement in bowel movements, the results showed significantly improved
quality of life in physical and support domains of the aroma massage group.
Cathy Wong (2009). A small study suggests that aromatherapy massage may
help ease anxiety among people with breast cancer. The study involved 12 breast
cancer patients, all of whom received 30-minute aromatherapy massages twice
weekly for four weeks. Results revealed that aromatherapy massage could help reduce
anxiety, as well as stimulate the immune system.
Yim, V.W.C. Adelina, K.Y. Hector, W.H. Tsang, & Ada ,Y. Leung (2009). A
study conducted in the Department of Rehabilitation Sciences, Hong Kong
Polytechnic University, Hong Kong. The review was conducted among five electronic
databases to identify all peer-reviewed journal papers that tested the effects of
aromatherapy in the form of therapeutic massage for patients with depressive
symptoms the results were based on six studies examining the effects of aromatherapy
on depressive symptoms in patients with depression and cancer. Some studies showed
positive effects of this intervention among these three groups of patients. We
recommend that aromatherapy could continue to be used as a complementary and
alternative therapy for patients with depression and secondary depressive symptoms
arising from various types of chronic medical conditions.
Soden ,K(2004). This study was designed to compare the effects of four-week
courses of aromatherapy massage and massage alone on physical and psychological
symptoms in patients with advanced cancer. There is good evidence that these
therapies may be helpful for anxiety reduction for short periods, Forty-two patients
were randomly allocated to receive weekly massages with lavender essential oil and
inert carrier oil (aromatherapy group), inert carrier oil only or no intervention.
Outcome measures included a Visual Analogue Scale of pain intensity, the Verran
and Snyder-Halpern sleep scale, the Hospital Anxiety and Depression scale and the
Rotterdam Symptom Checklist. Sleep scores improved significantly in both the
massage and the combined massage (aromatherapy and massage) groups. There were
also statistically significant reductions in anxiety and depression.
Jennifer Edge (2003). Conducted a pilot study in which she tested the effects
of aromatherapy massages on mood, anxiety, and relaxation on eight subjects. Each
subject was given a Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale where these levels were
tested both before and after completing the massage treatments. Every subject
received an aromatherapy massage for one hour, once a week, for six weeks. The
average improvement in relaxation and anxiety was 50% and mood was 30% after
each individual massage. The subjects were each tested again with the HAD six
weeks after the completion of their massages to measure their relaxation, anxiety, and
mood scores. Six weeks post-massage their levels had dropped in all three areas but
were still 30%, 10%, and 10% higher, respectively, than before the experiment
started. Only one of the eight subjects did not show any improvement in any of the
three areas. This study can conclude that aromatherapy massage does have positive
effects in the short term with relaxation, anxiety, and mood but the effects drop off if
the aromatherapy use is not persistent.
Moss, Cook, Wesnes, & Duckett (2003). The main findings were that the
subjects assigned to the lavender group were less alert than those exposed to
rosemary. Also, subjects in the control who received no aromatherapy treatment were
unhappier than those who did. This indicates that aromatherapy can have positive
effects on moods. A final finding of this experiment was that the aromatherapy
produced a slower reaction time to memory and performance, most likely due to a
higher state of relaxation.
Edge, J (2003). This study was carried out with eight subjects specifically
referred for aroma therapy; each received a standardized aroma
therapy massage weekly for 6 weeks. The subjects' levels of anxiety and depression
were measured using the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale prior to the
first massage and after the final massage. The subjects' levels of
mood, anxiety and relaxation were recorded using a visual analogue before and after
each massage and then again 6 weeks after the last massage. Improvements were
shown in six out of eight subjects' Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale results.
Improvements were also shown in all areas when comparing the visual analogue scale
results. The study was carried out over an 8-month period. To date there have been
few studies addressing the effect of aroma therapy massage on mood,
anxiety relaxation. It is acknowledged that whilst this is a small pilot study a number
of methodological issues are raised concerning research into the use
of aromatherapy in this clinical field.
Conceptual frame work deals with abstraction or concepts that are assembled
by virtue of their relevance to a common theme. Conceptualization is a process of
forming ideas which is utilized and forms conceptual frame work for development of
research design. It helps the researchers by giving direction to go about the entire
research process.
Context Evaluation:
Evaluation: It highlighted the environment, surrounding from where the
individuals engages and interact. In this study it included selected factors such as age,
sex, religion, educational status, income, place of domicile, duration of residing,
support system, and reason for residing. The setting of the study was inba illam,
Pasumalai, Madurai.
Input evaluation:
evaluation: It specified the resources used in the process such as men, money,
material. In this study it includes measuring pre test of anxiety level of the anxiety
among elderly. .
Process evaluation:
evaluation: It referred to the evaluation of implementing process including
the interaction between the client and care givers. In process the interaction is aroma
therapy massage. Aroma therapy massage it is a technique by which the back of the
recipient are held at various method, stroked gently and rhythmically to attain a
relaxation response. The aroma therapy massage was done according to the steps
stated in procedure for back massage.
Product evaluation:
evaluation: This information referred to the output as a result of the
intervention. It included measuring post test of anxiety among elderly.
Feed back:
back Referred to the information sent backward from the product evaluation to
the input and the process in order to gained understanding and modified or accepted
the strategies.
CONTEXT
INPUT PROCESS
PRODUCT
SELECTED VARIABLES POST TEST.
ANXIETY AMONG ELDERS PRETEST
Age. Anxiety. AROMA THERAPY Anxiety.
Sex. Assessment by using MASSAGE
Religion Effleurage Assessment by using
Education Aaron beck anxiety scale. Aaron beck anxiety
Income Stripping scale
Place of domicile NURSING AGENCY
Duration of residing Frictions
Support system Investigator. MATERIAL.
Reason for residing. Lavender oil Effleurage
SETTING: Inba illam
old age home, pasumalai, Base oil (safflower oil) For four week on
Madurai. alternative days
Reduction Of Negative No
Anxiety changes
Feed back
METHODOLOGY
In this study the research design was a Pre experimental design. The Study
emphasis no randomization, no control Group and Only manipulation.
The study was conducted at the old age home (Inba Ilam) at Pasumalai,
Madurai. It was established in the year 1967, by Dr. Samuel Amirtham, the bishop of
Kerala started it with mission of providing shelter to homeless, destitute, widows. It
was registered under Indian society act on the same day. There are 8 inmates when it
was started. Now the census is 50 inmates, 30 females and 20 males. It is the oldest
home for elders in Madurai at Tamilnadu. It is 6 kilometer for away from our College
of Nursing, Madurai Medical College, Madurai.
3.5 POPULATION
Target population
The individuals those who had anxiety among elders residing at old age home.
Accessible population
3.6 SAMPLE
It comprises of anxiety among elders residing at old age home who fulfill the
inclusion criteria.
The Sample size consisted of 30 subjects who had anxiety among elders
residing at old age home.
3.8 SAMPLING TECHNIQUE
In this study the researcher selected the sample through purposive sampling
technique. Purposive sampling is a non - probability sampling method in which the
researcher selects participants based on personal judgment about who might be most
representative or informative. It is also called as Judgmental Sampling.
INCLUSION CRITERIA:
Elders between the ages of 60 -80 years residing at Inba Illam Pasumalai,
Madurai.
EXCLUSION CRITERIA:
0 (not at all)
1 (mild)
2 (moderate)
3 (severe)
With a total score range of 0-63, where after the patient has completed the
test, add up the score for each of the 21questions and obtain the total score. The
highest score for each of the twenty-one items is three; the whole test of the
highest possible total score was sixty-three, if the elders marked any one of the
number from 0 to 3 on all the questions. The lowest score for each item was
zero, so the lowest possible score for the test was zero if the elder’s person
marked zero on each question. The following chart indicates the relationship
between total score and level of anxiety.
Minimal 0-7
Mild 8-15
Moderate 16-25
Severe 26-63
3.12 TESTING OF THE TOOL
CONTENT VALIDITY:
The content validity was obtained from 4 psychiatric (mental health) Nursing
experts and 1 Professor of Psychology at various institutions. Experts” suggestions were
incorporated in the tool.
RELIABILITY
The reliability of the tool was assessed by test retest method. The reliability of a
measuring instrument is a major criterion for assessing its quality and adequacy.
Reliability was the consistency with which it measured the target attributes. The
reliability was computed by spearman co efficient-correlation method r=0.853.Hence
the tool was found to be reliable.
Pilot study was conducted in old age home at Inba Ilam at Madurai, among 5
elders. The duration of study was one week period from 15.07.2011 to 21.07.2011to
test the feasibility, relevance and practicability of the intervention after obtaining
permission from ethical committee and content validity from 3 nursing personnel, 1
psychologist and one medical expert. The findings evidenced that there was
significant difference in pretest and post test scores on anxiety among elders. It
revealed that the study was feasible.
Data collection procedure was completed in two stages. First prior to nursing
intervention (aroma therapy massage) and after the nursing intervention. Subjects
were divided into two groups comprising of 15 subjects each group.
Session started with introduction of self, establishment of rapport, explanation
regarding the purpose and nature of the study and the benefits of participating during
the whole study programme. The pretest was conducted and selected the subjects of
mild and moderate anxiety with inclusion criteria by Aaron Beck Anxiety Scale. The
Aroma therapy massage on back of the elders (4ml of lavender oil mixed with 30ml
of base oil[safflower oil]) was given to the subject regularly 10 minutes duration on
alternative days for 4 weeks to each group after 4weeks the posttest was conducted.
Descriptive statistics
2. Mean and standard deviation were used to analyze changes in the level of
anxiety among elders
Inferential Statistics
2. Chi-square test was used to find out the association between the level of
anxiety and selected demographic variables among elders.
This chapter deals with the analysis of data is a process, the researcher
inspecting, cleaning, transforming, and modeling data with the goal of highlighting
useful information, suggesting conclusions, and supporting decision making. Data
analysis has multiple facets and approaches, encompassing diverse techniques under a
variety of names, in different business, science, and social science domains.
To assess the pre and post test level of anxiety among elders at selected old age
home, Madurai.
Section – III Comparison of mean and standard deviation between pre- test and
The above figure showed that the study participants 40% of them were
the age group of 65-70years, 34% of the participants were belonged to 70-75years,
13% of the participants were belonged to 60-65 years and 75-80years.
FIG - 3 DISTRIBUTIONS OF SUBJECTS ACCORDINGTOTHEIR SEX
The above The above pie chart showed that the age distribution
of the study subjects Males and females were equally distributed.
RELIGION DISTRIBUTION
73%
80
70
60
50
40
PERSENTAG
27%
30
20
10
0
0% 0%
HinduChristianMuslimOthers
RELIGION
The above figure showed that the study participants in this research Based on
religion there were 73% of the elders belonged to Hindu religion, 27% of the elders
were belonged to Christian none of the participants were belonged to Muslim and any
other religion.
FIG – 5 DISTRIBUTIONS OF SUBJECTS ACCORDING TO THEIR
EDUCATION
The above figure showed that the study subjects 60% of them were belonged to
primary education, 37% of the study subjects were belonged to high school education, 3%
of them were belonged to no formal education; none of them had graduate and
professionals.
FIG – 6 DISTRIBUTIONS OF SUBJECTS ACCORDING TO THEIR INCOME
The above figure showed that the study participants 100% of the elders were
belonged to no income groups.
FIG – 7 DISTRIBUTION OF SUBJECTS ACCORDING TO THEIR PLACE
OF DOMICILE
The above figure showed that the study participants of this research, 83%of the
elders were came from urban 17% of them were came from rural.
FIG – 8 DISTRIBUTIONS OF SUBJECTS ACCORDING TO THEIR
DURATION OF RESIDING
The above figure showed that the study subjects of this research, 69% of them
were residing in the old age home for 6 years and above 28% of the subjects were
residing within 3-6years, 3% of the subjects were residing within 1-3 years; none of
The above figure showed that the research participants 90% of them were
support from their siblings, 10% of the elders were support from their children, none
of them were supported by their spouse.
FIG -10 DISTRIBUTIONS OF SUBJECTS ACCORDING TO THEIR REASON
FOR RESIDING
The above figure showed that the study participants of this research, 100% of
the elders were came for the reason of family negligence.
SECTION II
The above table showed that the study participants of this research, most of
the elders 23(77%) were assessed to have moderate level of anxiety (score 16-25) and
7 (23%) were assessed to have mild level of anxiety (score 8-15) in the pretest which
is reduced to 12(40%) were mild anxiety and 18(60%) were minimal anxiety in the
posttest and there is no moderate level of anxiety.
FIG – 11 DISTRIBUTIONS OF SUBJECTS ACCORDING TO THE PRE AND
POST LEVEL OF ANXIETY
The above figure showed that most of the elders were 23 (77%) assessed to
have moderate level of anxiety (score 16- 25) in the pretest which is reduced. Mild
level of anxiety (score 8-15) in the pretest 7 (23%) was found increase to 12 (40%) in
the posttest. This revealed that aromatherapy massage great impact in reducing
anxiety score.
SECTION-III
TABLE.3
Comparison of mean and standard deviation between pre- test and post- test
MEAN STANDARD
VARIABLE MEAN
DEFERENCE DEVIATION
The above table showed that the mean score of anxiety among study
participants was 19.23 in the pre test, and mean score of anxiety among study
participants was 7.43 in the posttest the mean deference was 11.80 and the standard
deviation of anxiety among study participants in the pre test was 4.59, and 2.11 in the
post test. Hence the report revealed that the aroma therapy massage had significant
effect on reduction of anxiety level of elders at selected old age home, Madurai.
FIG - 12 COMPARISONS OF MEAN SCORE BETWEEN PRE- TEST AND
POST- TEST MEASUREMENT OF ANXIETY AMONG ELDERS.
The above figure showed that the mean score of anxiety among study
participants was 19.23 in the pre test, and mean score of anxiety among study
participants were 7.43 in the posttest.
SECTION – IV
TABLE -4
The above table represented that the study participants of this research had
highly significant reduction of level of anxiety in the post test. The paired “t” test
value conformed that aroma therapy massage significantly reduced the level of
anxiety among elders residing at selected old age home, Madurai.
SECTION- V
TABLE-5
PLACE OF Urban 15 10
0 1
DOMICILE Rural 3 2
DURATION 0-1 yrs - - 4.167 0.125
DEMOGRAPHIC MINIMAL MILD
χ2 value p-value
VARIABLE ANXIETY ANXIETY
OF 1-3 yrs 1 0
RESIDING
3-6 yrs 3 6
6 and above 14 6
Children 1 2
SUPPORT
Spouse - - 0.987 0.32
SYSTEM
Siblings 17 10
REASON Disaster - -
FOR Family 0 1
RESIDING 18 12
negligence
The above table showed that the demographic variables such as age, sex, have
significant association with post test score of anxiety level. The demographic
variables of the study participants recording age, the calculated chi square value was
8.056**, df=3, table value =7.82, p<0.05 level of significant. It revealed that the
calculated value greater than tabulated value at p<0.05 significance. so the report
revealed that the significant association between age of the study participants and
aroma therapy massage, and also the sex variables of the study participants calculated
χ2 value was 8.89**,df=1, table value =3.84,p<0.05 level of significant. It revealed
that the calculated value greater than tabulated value at p<0.05 level of significance.
and other demographic variables such as religion, education, income, place of
domicile, duration of residing, support system and reason for residing, doesn’t have
any significant association with level of anxiety and aromatherapy massage since the
calculated value is lower than table value at 0.05 level of significance.
CHAPTER - V
DISCUSSION
The chapter discusses about the result of the study interpreted from the
statistical analysis the effort of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of aroma
therapy massage on anxiety among the elders residing in a selected old age home at
Madurai.
According to age distribution of the study subjects Males and females were
equally distributed. Based on religion 23 (73%) of the elders were belonged to Hindu
religion, 8 (27%) of the elders were belonged to Christian none of them were
belonged to Muslim and any other religion.
The first objective of this study was to assess the pre and post test level of
anxiety among elders at selected old age home.
The findings revealed that the total number of 30 participants level of anxiety
were assessed by using beck anxiety scale, most of the elders 23(77%) were
assessed to have moderate level of anxiety (score 16-25) and 7 (23%) were assessed
to have mild level of anxiety (score 8-15) in the pretest which is reduced to 12(40%)
were mild anxiety and 18(60%) were minimal anxiety in the posttest and there is no
moderate level of anxiety after aroma therapy massage..
This finding was consistent with the study done by Amy, L. Byers., Kristine
Gaffe., Kenneth. E., Covinsky., Michael, B. Friedman., Martha ,L. Bruce., (2010)
Psychiatric Epidemiology Surveys study was conducted 12 months period at united
states known about prevalence of anxiety and mood disorder among older adult
dwelling at community. the probability sampling method used for this study, sample
size were 2575 among older below 55 and older in that 43%, 55-64 years;32%,65-75
years; 20%,75-84 years;5% >_85 years. The likelihood of having mood shown a
pattern of declining with age (p,>.o5). Disorders showed higher rates in women
compared with men, a statistically significant trend with age. In addition, anxiety
disorders were as 12% mood disorders 5% across age groups.
The findings were similar to the study conducted by Christina Bryant., Henry
Jackson., David Ames .(2007) to find out the prevalence of anxiety symptoms,
anxiety disorder or specified anxiety disorders in adults aged > 60 in either
community or clinical settings. The prevalence of anxiety in community samples
ranges from 1.2% to 15%, and in clinical settings from 1% to 28%. The prevalence of
anxiety symptoms is much higher, ranging from 15% to 52.3% in community
samples, and 15% to 56% in clinical samples. Generalized Anxiety Disorder is the
commonest anxiety disorder in older adults.
The findings revealed that the aromatherapy massage had greatly decreased
the anxiety level of the subjects. In the inferential statistical method proved that the
difference in the post means score show a significant change the level of anxiety with
in “t” value 17.743. The investigator believed that the difference was due to aroma
therapy massage.
This finding was consistent with the study done by Serfaty, M., (2011)
aromatherapy massages versus Cognitive Behavior Therapy in patients with cancer
outpatient clinics and screening eight or more for anxiety and/or depression on the
hospital anxiety depression scale, were randomized to Treatment as Usual plus up to
eight sessions weekly of either aromatherapy massage or cognitive behavior therapy,
offered within 3 months Of those suitable, over 60% (39/63) participated
(aromatherapy massage, n = 20; cognitive behavior therapy, n = 19) and over 90%
(36/39) were followed up. Both packages were well received. The preference was for
AM, with more sessions were taken up; (Mean number sessions aroma therapy
massage = 7.2 (standard deviation 2.0) and cognitive behaviour therapy = 5.4
(standard deviation 3.1); P<0.05). Significant improvements in POMS (Total Mood,
depression and anxiety scores) occurred with both interventions.
The third objectives to associate post test score of anxiety among elders
and selected demographic variables.
The finding of the study revealed that the level of anxiety was significantly
associated with demographic variables such as age and sex .Regarding age χ2 value
= 8.056**(table value=7.82) and sex the χ2 value = 8.89**(table value=3.84).at
p<o.o5 level of significance.
To assess the pre and post level of anxiety among elders at selected old age
home.
To associate post test score of anxiety among elders and selected demographic
variables.
H1 - The mean post test score of anxiety will be significantly lesser than
the mean pretest score of elders.
The conceptual frame work for this study was based on CIPP Model; this
model was created by Daniel L. Stufflebeam.it is an acronym that stands for context
evaluation, input evaluation, process evaluation and product evaluation.
A pre experimental design was used in this study. The independent variables
were aroma therapy massage and depended variables were anxiety. This study was
conducted at the old age home at Pasumalai, Madurai. The assessable population of
the study was elders who were residing at old age home at Pasumalai, Madurai.
The study subjects were selected using purposive sampling technique is a non –
probability sampling method in the researcher select the participant based o n the
personal judgment about which one will be most representative or informative. The
sample size was 30, the data collection tools used were
1. Demographic data.
2. Aaron beck anxiety scale-21 items scale
The reliability of the anxiety scale found to be reliable, content validity was
obtained from four experts specialized in psychiatric mental health nursing and one
expert in psychology. Pilot study was conducted on 5subjects to find out the
feasibility of the study and it did not show any major flaw in the design of the study.
Data collection was carried out for four weeks from 01.10.3011 to 31.10.2011.
Based on the objectives and hypotheses, the data collected were analyzed by using
descriptive and inferential statistics.
• Majority the study participants 12 (40%) were in the age group of 65-
70years
• The equal distribution of the male and female were had anxiety.
• None of them had graduate and professional education. 60% of them were
primary education and 37% of them were secondary education.
• Most of the elders came from urban 83%. Only 17% of them were come from
rural.
• Most of the elders were 69% were residing in the old age home above 6 years.
• The mean anxiety score in the pre test was reduced from 19.23 to 7.43 in post
test. This reduction was statistically highly significant with paired t test
(t=17.743 and p,<001).
• A significant association was noted between the age and the level of anxiety
among elders in the post test level x2=8.056,p=0.045 with 3 degree of
freedom.
• A significant association was noted between the gender and the level of
anxiety among elders in the post test x2=8.89,p=0.003 with 1degree of
freedom.
6.2 CONCLUSION
According to the result of this study the elders who were in 10minits aroma
therapy massage with lavender oil mixed with base oil (safflower) had a statistically
significant reduction in level of anxiety because aroma therapy massage was effective
for the reduction of anxiety among elders. The aroma therapy massage was less cost
effective non invasive, free from major side effects and highly feasible the researcher
concluded that it can be used as an effective intervention to reduced the anxiety
among elders were residing in the old age home.
6.3 IMPLICATIONS
The Psychiatric mental health nurse plays a vital role in the provision of
massage therapy. The nurse in the psychiatric area knows that anxiety is a baseline
cause for mental disorder. Massage can be an important tool in helping to raise self
worth in mental health patients. In cancer and chronic illnesses patients the
aromatherapy massage is a single complementary therapy and easy way of handling
the anxiety. It can be including our nursing practice therefore this study has important
implication in the following aspects of nursing
i. Nursing Practice
NURSING PRACTICE
The nurses must be trained to assess the anxiety level of the elders who were residing
in the old age home and in the hospital setting and community area.
In the clinical area nurses should practice massage with using aroma oil as the
findings of the study clearly state that the effectiveness in reduction of level of
anxiety.
NURSING EDUCATION
NURSING ADMINISTRATION
Anxiety provoking team can be formed to assist the anxious patient and elders
by implementing intervention that maintain restore a sense of well being.
The administrator can motivate, supervise and guide the nurses in the
assessment of anxiety for the elders were are admitted in the ward.
Administrator can encouraged the nurses to practice the massage technique
with using aroma oil in their routine care in the morning.
NURSING RESEARCH
This study can be used as a base line for the further studies to build upon.
6.4 RECOMMENDATIONS
1. A similar study can be replicated with a large sample size for better generalization.
2. A comparative study can be done between aroma therapy massage and other
complimentary alternative therapies to evaluate the effectiveness in reducing
anxiety level.
3. A study can be conducted to assess the current knowledge, attitude and practice of
Nursing staff on Complimentary and Alternative therapy for the management of
anxiety before surgical procedure, chemotherapy, and heamodialysis.
4. The effort of aroma therapy massage with using lavender oil can be assessed in
combination of other rosemary oil, It’s also having similar effect..
6.5 LIMITATIONS
Responses were based on their self report and hence the degree of truth
was not assured.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. Ann, J.Zwemer (2003). Basic Psychology for Nurses in India. (1sted) New
Delhi: B.I.Publication.
6. Fontaine & Fletche (2009). Mental health Nursing. (5th ed), New Delhi:
Dorling Kindersley India (P) Ltd.
7. Frisch & Frisch. (2007). Psychiatric Mental Health Nursing. (3rd ed).Haryana:
Thomson Delmer Learning.
9. Gail, W. Stuart (2009). Principles and practice of Psychiatric Nursing. (9th ed).
New York: Mosby publications.
10. Geri Lobiondo-Wood. & Judith Haber (2006). Nursing Research. (6th ed).
St. Louis: Mosby Publication.
11. Gertrude, K., & McFarland Mary Durand. (2001). Psychiatric Mental Health
Nursing. (5th ed). Philadelphia: Lippincott Company.
12. Kozier & Erbs (2008). Fundamentals of Nursing.(8th ed).New Delhi: Pearson.
13. Kothari C.R (2000). Research Methodology and Techniques. (2nd ed). New
Delhi: Vishwa prakash Publication.
14. Lalitha,K (2009). Mental Health Nursing. (5th ed). New Delhi: VMG Book
House.
16. Mary.C. Townsend (2007). Psychiatric Mental Health Nursing. (3th ed). New
Delhi: Jaypee Brothers Publications.
17. Michal Gelder., Paul Harrison (2006). Shorter Oxford Text Book of Psychiatry.
(5th ed). New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
18. Nancy Burns. & Susan, K. Grove (2007). Understanding Nursing Research.
(4th ed). St.Louis: Saunders Publications.
20. Niraj Ahuja (2002). Psychiatric Nursing. (1st ed). New Delhi: Jaypee brothers
Publications.
23. Rose Mare Linda (2008). Foundations of Nursing Research.(5th ed). New
Delhi: Pearson prentice Hall.
24. Sreevani R (2004). A guide to Mental health & Psychiatric Nursing, (3rd ed),
New Delhi, Jaypee Brothers Publications.
25. Tracy S. Diehl. & Kathy Goldberg (2004). Psychiatric Nursing made Incredibly
easy,. (1st ed ). New Delhi. Lippincott, Williams & Wilkins.
1. Annual report (2002.) Health plan and policy. New Delhi: Ministry of Health
and Family Welfare, Government of India.
30. Pereira, YD., Estibeiro, A., Dhume, R.,& Fernandez, J (2000). Geriatric
patients attending tertiary care Psychiatric hospital. Indian journal of
Psychiatry. 44:326–31.
34. Rho, KH., Han, SH.,Kim, KS., & Lee, MS ( 2006 ). Effects of aromatherapy
massage on anxiety and self-esteem in Korean elderly women: a pilot
study. International Journal of Neuro science. December. 116(12):1447-
55.
35. Singh, C., et al. (1994).Social profile of aged in a rural population. Indian
Journal of Community Medicine.19:23–5.
36. Schoevers Robert, A. Deeg, D. J.H. ,van Tilburg, W. Beekman, A. T.F (2005).
Depression and Generalized Anxiety Disorder: Co-Occurrence and
Longitudinal Patterns in Elderly Patients. American Journal of
Geriatric Psychiatry: 1 -31-39.
38. . Singh, GP., Chavan, BS., Arun, P.,& Lobraj Sidana, A (2004). Geriatric out
patients with Psychiatric illness in a teaching hospital setting. A
retrospective study. Indian Journal of Psychiatry. 46:140–3.
39. Seby, K., Chaudhury, & S., Chakraborty, R (2011). Prevalence of Psychiatric
and physical morbidity in an urban geriatric population. Indian Journal
of Psychiatry. 53:121–712.
40. Smith, MC, Stallings, MA., Mariner, S.,& Burrall, M (1999 ). University of
Colorado Health Sciences Center. Massage therapy & Hospitalized
patients. Journal of Nurse Midwifery. May-June. 44(3):217-30.
41. Stallings, MA. Martier, S.& Burrall, M(2004). Benefits of massage therapy for
elderly patients. Alternative therapies in health medicine. 5(4):64-71.
42. Sangeetha,M(2004).Effect of back massage on sleep among post-operative
CABG and Valve replacement patients. The nursing journal of India.
(c) 4:86-88.
47. Tiple, P., Sharma, SN.,& Srivastava, A.S (2006). Psychiatric morbidity in
geriatric people. Indian Journal of Psychiatry. 48:88–94.
50. Wolfe, N., Herzberg, J (1996). Can aromatherapy oils promote sleep in
severely demented patients. International Journal of Geriatric
Psychiatry. 11:926-927.
51. Yip, YB. & Tse, S.H.M (2004). the effectiveness of relaxation acupoint
stimulation and acupressure with aromatic lavender essential oil for non-
specific low back pain in Hong Kong. Complementary Therapies in
Medicine. Volume 12. Issue 1. March.28-37.
NET REFERENCE
http://www.aromatherapy.ir.article.aroma.
http://www.jco.ascopubs.org.com.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov.pubmed.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed.
http://www.healthychild.ucla.edu. maternal.com.
http://bjp.rcpsych.org/cgi.com.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed.com
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/
http;//ccn.aacnjournalscom.
http://www.bookfinder.com.
http://www.amazon.com.
http://www.sciencedirect.com.
http://jtcs.ctsnetjournals.org/cgi.
http:// journals.lww.com.
http://www.massagetherapyfoundation.org.
http:// hacetteephemsirelikdergisi. org.
http:// www.ncbi.nlm. nih.gov .
http:// www.ncbi.nlm. nih.gov/pmc.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed .
APPENDIX - A
SECTION—A
DEMOGRAPHIC DATA
1. Age in years
a) 60-65 years
b) 65-70 years
c) 70-75 years
d) 75-80years
2. Sex
a) Male
b) Female
3. Religion
a) Hindu
b) Christian
c) Muslim
d) Others
4. Education
a) No formal education
b) Primary
c) Middle
d) High school
e) Post high school
f) Graduate
g) Profession
5. Income
a) No income
b) Pensioner
6. Place of domicile
a) Urban
b) Rural
7. Duration of residing
a) 0-1yrs
b) 1-3yrs
c) 3-6yrs
d) 6 and above
8. Support system
a) Children
b) Spouse
c) Siblings
a) Disaster
b) Family negligence
SECTION-B
BECK ANXIETY INVENTORY
Please choose the answer which one is applicable for you which is 0, 1, 2, or3 it
indicates how much the statement applied to you over the past week. There is no right
or wrong answer .Do not spends too much time on any statement.
The rating scale is as follows:
0 - Not at all
1 - Mild
2 - Moderate
3 - Severe
1. Feeling hot 0 1 2 3
2. Muscle numbness or tingling 0 1 2 3
3. Feeling unable to relax 0 1 2 3
4. Dizzy or light headed 0 1 2 3
5. Feeling wobbly in the legs 0 1 2 3
6. Feeling unsteady 0 1 2 3
7. Heart racing or pounding 0 1 2 3
8. Nervousness 0 1 2 3
9. Chocking feeling 0 1 2 3
10. Trembling hands 0 1 2 3
11. Unsteadiness 0 1 2 3
12. Terror or fear 0 1 2 3
13. Afraid of losing control 0 1 2 3
14. Indigestion 0 1 2 3
15. Flushed face 0 1 2 3
16. Hot or cold sweats 0 1 2 3
17. Feeling scared 0 1 2 3
18. Having laborious breathing 0 1 2 3
19. Feeling the fear of dying 0 1 2 3
20. Feeling like the worst is happening 0 1 2 3
21. Feeling faint 0 1 2 3
THE SCORING KEY ARE AS FOLLOWS
Lowest score -0 highest score- 63
LEVEL OF SCORE TOTAL SCORE
Minimal 0-7
Mild 8-15
Moderate 16-25
Severe 26-63
gphpT - m
jdpegh; tpguk;
1. taJ
m. 60 Kjy; 65 tiu
M. 65 Kjy; 70 tiu
,. 70 Kjy; 75 tiu
2. ghypdk;
m. Mz;
M. ngz;
3. tUkhdk;
m. tUkhdk; ,y;yhjth;
M. xa;T+jpak; ngWgth;
4. fy;tpj;jFjp
m. mDgtf;fy;tp
M. njhLf;ff;fy;tp
,. eLepiyfy;tp
<. cah;epiyf;fy;tp
c. Nky;epiyf;fy;tp
C. g L;Lg;gbg;G
v. njhopw;fy;tp
5. kjk;
m. ,e;J
M. fpwp];jth;
,. K];yPk;
6. trpg;gpLk;
m. efuk;
M. fpuhkk;
8. rhh;e;jpUf;Fk;
epiy
m. Foe;ijfs;
,. cLd; gpwe;jth;
m. Nghpog;G
M. FLk;gj;jhuhy; Gwf;fzpg;G
BECK ANXIETY INVENTORY
1 c\;zkhf czh;fpwPH;fsh? 0 1 2 3
2 jirfs; kukuj;Jg; Nghd khjphp ,Uf;fpwjh? 0 1 2 3
Xa;T vLf;f Kbatpy;iyNa vd;W
3 czh;fpwPh;fsh?
0 1 2 3
2. Firm comfortable surface such as a (firm) bed, massage table or floor mat.
3. Massage Oil. Lavender oil 4drops and mixed with base oil 30ml, it was fine
for anxiety reduction.
4. Towels: to lie on and also to cover the body.
5. Cushions or pillows.
Massage tips:
1. Massage oil decreases the friction created on the skin and prevents the pulling
of hairs. Don't use too much: The less oil, the greater the friction and the
deeper the pressure.
2. Use slower movements for a soothing or calming response.
3. When applying pressure with finger or thumb, provide support with the other
fingers and thumbs.
2. Cover any parts of the body not being worked on with a warm towel.
3. Pour the massage oil onto your hands first, and then apply once the massage is
started, keep a hand on the person at all times, so that there are no surprises.
4. Avoid direct pressure on bony processes.
5. (Important!) - Ask the patient for feedback: Are you warm enough? Are you
comfortable? How's that feel?
Massage warnings:
Massage benefits:
There is a smaller area of contact, so the pressure is deeper. Both hands work in
circles - start at the lower back. Move in a circle, first outward, then upward and
return to the center. Gradually progress to the upper back (1 minutes).
Apply firm downwards pressure, and move the arm closest to the head up to just below
the shoulder blades. 6 strokes. (1minute)
Finishing with effleurage
Apply effleurage (stroking moves) with supported fingers, then effleurage with the
heel of the hand, then full handed effleurage. (1 minute) Then leave the patient quiet
for a few minutes.
APPENDIX - C
LETTER SEEKING PERMISSION FOR CONTENT VALIDITY
FOR TOOL
From
G.JAYANTHI.
I Year M.Sc. (Nursing)
Department of mental health nursing,
College of Nursing, Madurai Medical College, Madurai.
To
MRS. JANCY RACHEL DAISY. M.SC (N)
Reader in nursing,
C.S.I. College of Nursing, Madurai.
Through: The proper channel.
Respected madam
SUB: Requesting opinion and suggestion of expert for content validity
of “a study to evaluate the effectiveness of aroma therapy massage on
anxiety among elders at selected old age home, Madurai”.
I am I year master degree student of College of Nursing, Madurai Medical
College, Madurai. In partial fulfillment of master degree in Nursing. I have selected
the topic for the research project to submit to the Dr.M.G.R. Medical University,
Chennai. I have requested you to kindly validate the tool and give your opinion and
suggestion for necessary modification and also I would be very grateful if you would
refine the problem of statement and the objectives.
CONTENT VALIDITY CERTIFICATE
Medical Superintendent
APPENDIX -E
xg;Gjy; mwpf;if
ngah;: ehs;:
nfhs;tjpy;
vdf;F cWjpaspf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ.
,g;gbf;F
APPENDIX- H
appropriateness.
APPENDIX - I
PHOTOGRAPHS