VisionIAS Weekly Focus November 2023 Indias Neighbourhood Policy Prospects and Challenges
VisionIAS Weekly Focus November 2023 Indias Neighbourhood Policy Prospects and Challenges
VisionIAS Weekly Focus November 2023 Indias Neighbourhood Policy Prospects and Challenges
T
he centrality of neighbours in
IN THIS DOCUMENT
India’s foreign policy stems from the
clear understanding that a peaceful 1. Who are India's neighbours and what is India's 2
periphery is essential for India to achieve neighbourhood policy?
her multifarious developmental goals. 1.1. How has India's Neighbourhood policy evolved? 3
However, India’s neighbourhood presents
complex dynamics, with many countries 2. What is relevance of India's Neighbourhood Policy in 4
suffering from high inflation, economic today's geopolitical landscape?
instability and popular unrest. Regional 3. What are the challenge that India face in pursuing the 5
cooperation becomes critical as geographic spirit of its Neighbourhood First Policy?
imperative binds neighbours i.e., any
challenges faced by people beyond the 4. How can India make its Neighbourhood policy more 7
border has huge potential to spill inside the robust and impactful
border. India’s 'Neighbourhood First' Policy 9
Conclusion
underlines the renewed primacy that the
country seeks to attach to its neighbouring Topic at a Glance 10
countries and achieve the goal of lasting
Boxes and Figures 11
peace, stability and prosperity in the region.
1
ONLINE | AHMEDABAD | BHOPAL | CHANDIGARH | GUWAHATI | HYDERABAD | JAIPUR | JODHPUR | LUCKNOW | PRAYAGRAJ | PUNE | RANCHI | RANCHI | SIKAR
#108
Extended
Neighbourhood
2
ONLINE | AHMEDABAD | BHOPAL | CHANDIGARH | GUWAHATI | HYDERABAD | JAIPUR | JODHPUR | LUCKNOW | PRAYAGRAJ | PUNE | RANCHI | RANCHI | SIKAR
#108
3
ONLINE | AHMEDABAD | BHOPAL | CHANDIGARH | GUWAHATI | HYDERABAD | JAIPUR | JODHPUR | LUCKNOW | PRAYAGRAJ | PUNE | RANCHI | RANCHI | SIKAR
#108
Box 1.2. Mandala theory: Looking back at the neighbourhood policy in ancient India
The Mandala theory of statecraft was proposed by Kautilya
(Chanakya) in 3rd century BC.
The litmus test for any state in the centre of the concentric circles
is to maintain the balance of power between other nations in
the region to safeguard its sovereignty.
On the question of treaties and alliances, he suggests, "a king should not hesitate to break any friendship or alliances
that later prove to be disadvantageous."
4
ONLINE | AHMEDABAD | BHOPAL | CHANDIGARH | GUWAHATI | HYDERABAD | JAIPUR | JODHPUR | LUCKNOW | PRAYAGRAJ | PUNE | RANCHI | RANCHI | SIKAR
#108
3. What are the challenges that India face in pursuing the spirit of its
Neighbourhood First Policy?
In its pursuit of the Neighbourhood First Policy, India faces a diverse array of challenges that range from historical tensions
to complex security dynamics. These include:
Lack of a comprehensive policy: Experts claim that due Security risks:
to the lack of a well-defined neighbourhood policy, Cross border terrorism: The existence of
India has focused more on ‘managing its relationships permeable borders, backing from the host nation
with its neighbours rather than shaping them. such as Pakistan, and the escalation of extremism
Strained bilateral relations among some nations in the in neighbourhood may collectively contribute to
region have posed severe challenges to implementation emergence of terrorist activities within India.
of policies at a regional level. Drug Trafficking: India's drug trafficking problems
For instance, out of the three agreements on cross- have been exacerbated by its proximity to Golden
border energy, motor vehicle movement and railway Triangle, and Golden Crescent.
cooperation presented in the last SAARC summit, Piracy off the coast of Somalia and use of
only one was signed on energy cooperation as waterways by terrorist.
Pakistan refused to sign the other two agreements.
5
ONLINE | AHMEDABAD | BHOPAL | CHANDIGARH | GUWAHATI | HYDERABAD | JAIPUR | JODHPUR | LUCKNOW | PRAYAGRAJ | PUNE | RANCHI | RANCHI | SIKAR
#108
China’s inroads in South Asia: With the push of OBOR, Effect of domestic politics: Domestic-political
China’s trade volume with SAARC countries has compulsions and ethnic considerations have many
grown significantly and at a fast pace over the past a time dictated India’s neighbourhood policy and
decade. impacted it adversely. For example;
Time and again India’s neighbours including Sri Teesta Waters agreement got delayed due to
Lanka, Maldives and Nepal among others have played opposition by West Bengal.
Chinese card against India. Support for the Sri Lankan Tamil struggle
» For example, Nepal projected China as a possible against Sinhala–Buddhist majoritarianism was due
alternative to India as a source of essential to ethnic considerations.
supplies during the border blockade. Support to the cause of Madhesis in the Terai
region of Nepal as they share close familial ties with
Suboptimal confidence building with neighbours:
India.
India's neighbours have long felt that it doesn't treat
them equally. India’s military involvement in Delayed implementation of development projects:
Bangladesh, Sri Lanka and Maldives is viewed even today India’s Line of Credit (LOC) projects to its neighbours
as evidence of regional apprehensions. increased from $ 3.3 billion in 2014 to $14.7 billion
in 2020 (50% of India’s global soft lending goes to its
Economic crisis in the neighbourhood: For example,
neighbours).
economic uncertainty and acute scarcity of foreign
exchange in Sri Lanka have hit India’s major exports to However, there is a huge delay in the
the island nation. implementation of such projects which can lead
to frustration, mistrust and reduces India's
Connectivity and Border Infrastructure: Poor influence in the region.
infrastructure limits the impact of free trade and
investment deals. Many of the border districts are less Climate Change and Natural Disasters: The region is
developed. prone to natural disasters and climate change-related
challenges. These environmental issues can disrupt
There were more railway connections between
development efforts and may even lead to issues of
India and East Pakistan in the early sixties than
Climate Migration.
there are today with Bangladesh.
The India-Nepal border is an open border on
paper. But circulation is extremely difficult due to
the absence of basic infrastructure.
Box 3.1. COVID-19: A challenge as well as an opportunity for Neighborhood First Policy
COVID-19 pandemic had placed enormous challenges on the entire South Asian region in terms of rising inflation,
reduced food security and increasing political instability. India emerged as a major provider for public-goods and
services such as healthcare, education, training and providing scientific and technical support in the neighborhood
during the crisis.
Vaccine Diplomacy: India prioritized providing COVID-19 vaccines to its immediate neighbours under the
Vaccine Maitri initiative. It served as a powerful soft power tool to counter china’s influence.
Leadership role: As part of NFP, India reactivated SAARC forum to formulate a regional action plan to combat
the pandemic and adopted bilateral diplomacy to reach out to its neighbours.
Build Trust and Cooperation: India mobilized military relief, set up laboratory for testing, and delivered
critical medicine and hospital supplies thus strengthening bilateral ties with countries like Maldives.
Goodwill: India's initiatives to help its neighbours including extended neighbours enhanced its global image
and earned goodwill.
6
ONLINE | AHMEDABAD | BHOPAL | CHANDIGARH | GUWAHATI | HYDERABAD | JAIPUR | JODHPUR | LUCKNOW | PRAYAGRAJ | PUNE | RANCHI | RANCHI | SIKAR
#108
7
ONLINE | AHMEDABAD | BHOPAL | CHANDIGARH | GUWAHATI | HYDERABAD | JAIPUR | JODHPUR | LUCKNOW | PRAYAGRAJ | PUNE | RANCHI | RANCHI | SIKAR
#108
4. How can India make its Neighbourhood policy more robust and
impactful?
Strengthening the impact and resilience of India's Neighbourhood First Policy requires a multifaceted approach that
addresses the diverse challenges and opportunities within the region. India can consider the following strategic measures:
Rejuvenating Regional Forums and Organizations: organizations and forums such as the United
To foster sustained diplomatic engagement among Nations, BRICS, and G20.
neighbouring countries, India should actively utilize
regional platforms such as SAARC, BIMSTEC, Indian Sustained engagement with smaller neighbours:
Ocean Rim Association (IORA), among others. India's diplomatic efforts should be attuned to
the expectations and apprehensions of its smaller
These forums can serve as vehicles for continuous neighbours.
engagement, dispute resolution, and the promotion
of regional integration. This can be accomplished by enhancing domestic
coordination and promoting closer collaboration
Engaging China: Ongoing negotiations should between the foreign and security ministries to craft
prioritize a clear definition of the Line of Actual individualized strategies for each country and the
Control (LAC). Simultaneously, India should be ready wider region.
to firmly oppose any incursion that violates the
established norms outlined in the Border Defence Bridging Connectivity Deficits: Make substantial
Cooperation Agreement between both nations. investments in the enhancement of infrastructure,
encompassing roadways, railways, inland waterways,
Addressing Terrorism from Pakistan: Proactively ports, energy networks, and digital customs.
collaborate with regional and international organizations Also, there is a need to think about economic
to create a unified platform for countering terrorism openness and connectivity to the neighbourhood as
within the framework of the NFP. an advantage and not its a threat to India’s security.
Additionally, India could explore the possibility The parliamentary committee has suggested to
of fostering economic connections with Pakistan, establish a regional development fund under the
should it demonstrate a commitment to promoting BIMSTEC for this purpose.
broader people-to-people interactions.
Promoting Tourism: Under the NFP, channelling
Strengthening internal security architecture: To investments into the tourism sector, including medical
elicit a proactive response from neighbouring nations, tourism, can significantly bolster people-to-people
India must first bolster its own internal security ties, amplify India's soft power, and foster economic
architecture to effectively address the challenges integration within the region.
posed by terrorism.
Numerous Bangladeshi nationals seek medical
Cooperation with global powers: India's historical treatment in India. Additionally, India witnesses
approach focused on keeping major powers out of its a considerable influx of visitors from Nepal for
neighbourhood. However, in the face of challenges religious tourism, exemplifying the potential for
posed by China and Pakistan, a reorientation of foreign enhancing regional tourism exchanges.
policy is necessary to address them effectively:
Water Sharing and Environmental Cooperation:
This involves forging strategic partnerships Collaborative efforts on water sharing, sustainable
with the United States, Russia, and the European resource management, and environmental protection
Union and active participation in multilateral can help address common challenges and promote
cooperation among neighboring countries. This can be
achieved through the exchange of data and scientific
research.
Post-World War II, the recognition that closer collaboration could prevent the horrors of war led to the establishment
of the European Union (EU).
Joining the EU requires member countries to relinquish some political and economic authority. In
return, they enjoy the benefits of a single European market, encompassing a free-trade zone, as well as the
free movement of people, goods, services, and capital throughout the EU bloc.
This framework fosters stability, prevents conflicts among members and enhances economic
8
ONLINE | AHMEDABAD | BHOPAL | CHANDIGARH | GUWAHATI | HYDERABAD | JAIPUR | JODHPUR | LUCKNOW | PRAYAGRAJ | PUNE | RANCHI | RANCHI | SIKAR
#108
competitiveness.
This makes the EU a unique governing body and the world’s first supranational organization.
Historical reconciliation: Success of EU is attributed to historical reconciliation between France and Germany.
Success of other regional organisations also need similar reconciliation. For example,
Reconciliation between Pakistan and India is a necessity for success of SAARC.
Similarly, a genuine reconciliation between Japan and China; and Japan and Korea is needed for success of
East Asia.
Political and public will: If integration is to succeed, the public along with the government should believe that
it is in their vital national interest.
Conclusion
India’s Neighbourhood First Policy (NFP) is a dynamic policy that adjusts to its renewed interests in the region while
evolving according to regional circumstances. India's commitment to its neighbourhood will continue to play a crucial role
in shaping the future of South Asia and beyond. As India navigates the complexities and opportunities of its neighbourhood,
a comprehensive approach is needed to ensure a stable and prosperous neighbourhood that aligns with India’s national
interests and foreign policy objectives.
9
ONLINE | AHMEDABAD | BHOPAL | CHANDIGARH | GUWAHATI | HYDERABAD | JAIPUR | JODHPUR | LUCKNOW | PRAYAGRAJ | PUNE | RANCHI | RANCHI | SIKAR
#108
Topic at a glance
India’s Neighbourhood Policy: Prospects and Challenges
Immediate neighbours: India shares borders and civilizational relations with them. They are Afghanistan, Bangladesh,
Bhutan, China, Maldives, Myanmar, Nepal, Pakistan, and Sri Lanka.
Extended neighbours: Located further away from India but still have significant political, economic, cultural and strategic
interactions with India.
Neighbourhood First Policy: This has been a core element of Indian foreign policy since 1947, focusing on strengthening
regional ties, fostering cooperation, etc.
Lack of a comprehensive policy: Therefore, India is more Rejuvenating Regional Forums: SAARC, BIMSTEC, IORA,
focused on managing relationships with Neighbours than etc. can serve as vehicles for continuous engagement,
shaping them. dispute resolution .
Strained bilateral relations: Thus regional forum like Engaging China: Prioritize a clear definition of the LAC and
SAARC are not able to achieve its potential. oppose breach of provisions of Border Defence Cooperation
Agreement.
Security risks: Cross border terrorism, Drug Trafficking,
etc. Addressing Terrorism from Pakistan: Collaborate with
regional and international organizations to counter such
China’s inroads in South Asia: Many of India’s neighbours
terrorism, also economically engage with Pakistan.
have played Chinese card against India.
Strengthening internal security architecture: It will
Other issues: Suboptimal confidence building, Economic
facilitate a proactive response from neighbouring nations.
crisis in the neighbourhood, Delayed implementation of
development projects, Climate Change, etc. Cooperation with global powers: It will help tackling
challenges posed by China and Pakistan.
Other: Sustained engagement with smaller neighbours,
Bridging Connectivity Deficits, Water Sharing and
Environmental Cooperation, etc.
10
ONLINE | AHMEDABAD | BHOPAL | CHANDIGARH | GUWAHATI | HYDERABAD | JAIPUR | JODHPUR | LUCKNOW | PRAYAGRAJ | PUNE | RANCHI | RANCHI | SIKAR
#108
Box 1.2. Mandala theory: Looking back at the neighbourhood policy in ancient India .................................. 4
Box 3.1. COVID19: A challenge as well as an opportunity for Neighborhood First Policy ................................. 6
Box 4.1. European Union (EU): A Model for Regional Integration ................................................................. 8
11
ONLINE | AHMEDABAD | BHOPAL | CHANDIGARH | GUWAHATI | HYDERABAD | JAIPUR | JODHPUR | LUCKNOW | PRAYAGRAJ | PUNE | RANCHI | RANCHI | SIKAR