Nilson Report Ecl
Nilson Report Ecl
February 2010
Issue 942
MasterCard Credit
Visa Debit
Discover Credit
00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09
2010 The Nilson Report
www.nilsonreport.com
Order back issues View front-page articles for the last 3 years Find links to upcoming conferences
Fast Facts P 2-3 purchase volume oN u.s. Gp carDs P 6 | u.s. GeNeral purpose carDs P 6 | creDit carD outstaNDiNGs iN the u.s. P 7 visa & mastercarD Debit & prepaiD carDs P 9 | 50 larGest issuers oF visa & mastercarD creDit carDs iN the u.s. P 10,11
CHARTS:
HSN Consultants Inc. 2010 THE NILSON REPORT Reproducing or allowing reproduction or dissemination of any portion of this newsletter in any manner for any purpose is a copyright violation subject to substantial fines. Yearly Subscription for 23 print and electronic issues is $1,295. ISSN 1087-8718 THE NILSON REPORT: 1110 Eugenia Place, Suite 100, Carpinteria, CA 93013 USA PHONE (805) 684-8800 FAX (805) 684-8825 [email protected]
Fast Facts > > > > > > > >
The Nilson Report #942 1st draft February 17, 2010 3:37 PM ddr
training session in Salt Lake City, Utah on Monday, February 22. Cost is $1,495 for nonmembers. Nilson Report subscribers receive a $200 discount. Register at www.globalplatform.org/ trasaltlakecity.asp
million to issuers of Visa cards for expenses related to a 2008 data breach has been accepted by 97% of the institutions affected. Robert Carr is CEO at HPS, (609) 683-3831, [email protected]. Eduardo Perez is Head, Global Payment System Security at Visa, (650) 432-2375, [email protected].
FEATURED CONFERENCE
MOBILE FINANCIAL SERVICES 2010
Two-Day Conference March 9-10, 2010 The Copthrone Tara Hotel, London, U.K.
20%
Topics include: mobile finance world changes over the last 12 months, Web payments models, the main business case for mobile financial services, convergences for the industry, Mobile Cloud, a security model for mobile payment, and engaging the consumer. Speakers represent: World Bank, Turkcell, Visa Europe, SFR, T-Mobile, Mobitel, Danske Bank, and more. Cost is $4,211 (2,948 + VAT). Contact Mubenah Khan at Informa Telecoms, 44 (207) 017-5827, mubenah.khan@ informa.com. Register at www.mobile-financialservices.com.
SHPS, one of the largest U.S. providers of account-based, consumerdriven healthcare solutions, has renewed its contract to offer Visa cards as the preferred payment brand for employee-benefit programs it administers. RJD Grimes is SVP, Sales at SHPS, (502) 267-3334, [email protected]. Stacy Pourfallah is Sr. Bus. Leader, Healthcare Prod. at Visa, (650) 432-2388, [email protected].
DO NOT COPY THIS REPORT. Reproducing or allowing reproduction of any portion of this newsletter in any - 1 manner for any purpose constitutes a copyright violation subject to substantial fines.
> > > > > > > > > Fast Facts
ECOMMLINK, operator of a prepaid card-processing platform, has CEDACRI, Italys top provider of outsourcing services to banks, has
partnered with TSYS to offer end-to-end card processing for consumer, commercial, and prepaid cards, as well as 3D Secure services and fraud solutions. Fabio Menghini is Sales Director at TSYS, 39 (348) 283-7590, [email protected]. Fabio De Ferrari is GM at Cedacri, 39 (348) 895-2972, [email protected]. opened an office in Medellin, Colombia to support business development in Latin America. Carlos Beltran is Head, Latin American Sales, 57 (310) 443-3000, [email protected].
I&M BANK in Kenya is the first bank in Eastern and Central Africa
to be certified by Visa to process online credit card payments for goods and services. Victor Ndlovu is Manager, Sub-Saharan Africa at Visa, 27 (11) 547-8466, [email protected]. V.S. Sekhera Reddy is General Manager, Card Products at I&M, 254 (20) 322-1217, [email protected].
PKO BANK POLSKI will reissue more than 6 million Visa debit
cards with contactless chips starting in the second half of 2010. Jakub Kiwior is Country Manager at Visa, 48 (22) 630-6801, [email protected]. Katarzyna Sosin is Head of Cards at PKO Bank Polski, 48 (22) 639-6190, [email protected].
GIESECKE & DEVRIENT'S Mobile Security Card for use with the
Android operating system offers applications including online banking, secure access to corporate networks, and electronic ticketing. Users insert the memory card into the microSD slot on their Android device to make phones a secure alternative to external smart cards. Kai Grassie is Head, New Business division, 49 (89) 4119-0, [email protected].
FIRST DATA CORPORATION will provide the Egyptian government with a managed service for issuing and processing more than 4.5 million prepaid reloadable smart cards in its family card project, which covers subsidized food and pension services. Masria Card, Egypts top card manufacturer, will supply the cards. George Tsoutsos is Managing Director, North Africa at First Data, 30 (697) 848-3966, [email protected]. Amr Rashad is Managing Director at Masria Card, 20 (2) 2291-4179, [email protected].
IF YOU ARE READING THIS NEWSLETTER BY WAY OF A WEB SITE OR SERVER, there has been a violation of copyright law which carries substantial fines. No company has been granted the right to post this publication.
-2-
fraud-detection support for credit card transactions generated at its more than 200,000 merchant accounts. The TSYS platform will also handle VPay and Maestro debit card, but not girocard (formerly electronic cash) debit card transactions. That business is cleared and settled by B+S into data centers operated by the cooperative, savings, and private banks. B+Ss back-office support had been supplied by Atos. Front-end authorizations for B+Ss 260,000 POS terminals are handled in-house. Other bidders for the back-office contract included First Data, Elavon, Six Multipay, and Atos. Last year, B+S settled 198 million credit card transactions valued at 14.90 billion ($20+ billion) from merchants in Germany, Austria, Switzerland,
Belgium, Italy, the Netherlands, Luxembourg, Slovenia, Hungary, Czech Republic, and Slovakia. B+S is owned by Germanys savings banks group led by Deutscher Sparkassen Verlag. Michael Pip is Managing Director at B+S Card Service in Frankfurt, Germany, 49 (69) 6630-5100, michael. other bidderS [email protected]. included FirSt Prior issue: 928
TSYS has two other clients in Germany. Deutsche Bank has used it for consumer card account processing since June 2009, and Degussa Bank will use it for commercial card account processing beginning next month. Conversion of B+S merchants to the TSYS platform, which is operated from the U.K., is planned for the first quarter of 2011. Bob Evans is Group Executive at TSYS International in York, U.K., 44 (207) 1609400, [email protected].
creditors will settle for a guaranteed amount in the near term rather than trying to collect the entire amount later and fail. Settlements typically range from 30 to 40 on the dollar. One of the biggest challenges faced by settlement companies
files on debtors so creditors can search those files for a match. By automating the process, Persolvo believes it has reduced the man hours required on the settlement companys end, while allowing creditors to collect without working with settlement companies directly.
by attorneys. Persolvo estimates that the amount of funds in trust accounts alone exceeds $5 billion and is growing at a rate of $1 billion per quarter.
is getting the funds saved by their clients into the hands of creditors. Many creditors have a long-standing distaste for dealing with these firms, although that appears to be shifting as the reputable ones find ways to distinguish themselves from those that bilk consumers. Persolvo Data Systems lets settlement companies upload
The companys database currently tracks $108 million that more than 200,000 consumers have set aside for proposed Once a match is found, the settlements up from $70 milcreditor goes through Persolvo lion tied to 90,000 consumers to send an offer to the in October 2009. All settlement company. If funds in the database the offer is accepted, are immediately all FundS in the consumer releases available to creditors, the datafunds to the crediwho pay Persolvo baSe are tor. The number of commissions that immediately searches initiated by range from 4% to aVailable to creditors since 8% of the settlement creditorS. October is up 50%, led amount. by a growing number Persolvo wont say of debt buyers. whether or not any card issuers Most funds are saved in trust have begun working with them accounts, although some are in yet, but they point out that most personal accounts or managed debtors go into a settlement
IF YOU ARE BEING FORWARDED a copy of this report, there has been a violation of copyright law which carries substantial fines. The right to possess digital versions of this newsletter are granted solely to the individual subscriber.
program when their accounts are still current or only 30 days past due, and so would enter the database before being placed
with a collection agency or sold by the issuer to a debt buyer. Teresa Dodson is COO at Persolvo Data Systems in Irvine,
California, (949) 340-7033, teresa@persolvodatasystems. com. Prior issues: 935, 929, 922
authorizations, coupled with state-of-the-art fraud detection technology, have allowed the card organizations to lift signature requirements for most low-value transactions. On the MasterCard network, U.S. there haS merchants in select categories inbeen no cluding gas stations, convenience uptick in stores, drugstores, and supermarFraud. kets since 1991 have been allowed to process transactions valued at $25 or less without requiring cardholders to sign a receipt. Called Quick Payment Service, the program was expanded in November by raising the floor limit to $50. Discover Financial Services began letting select U.S. merchants process transactions under $25 without a signature in the mid-1990s and has expanded the merchant categories over the years. Since October 2009, nearly all merchants have been allowed to participate. Transactions involving
money transfers, lottery tickets, and cash advances are excluded. American Express also has a $25 floor on the transaction amount that requires a signed receipt as long as merchants have swiped a card to initiate an authorization. Visa launched its $25 or less No Signature Required program in the U.S. in 2006 and will expand it from 26 merchant segments to approximately 98% of the 800+ merchant segments in the U.S. by July 1 of this year. Visa, MasterCard, American Express, and Discover say they have not seen any increase in fraud on transactions where no signature is required. At least 29% of the Visa, MasterCard, Discover, and American Express transactions that occur at the point of sale in the U.S. will soon qualify for no signature or receipt required programs along with the accompanying chargeback protection.
Alipay was processing 5 million transactions a day with average daily volume exceeding $176 million.
Alipay is owned by Alibaba Group, which owns and operates two online auction sites. Taobao.com is both businessto-consumer and consumer-toconsumer, and Alibaba.com is business-to-business. Alipay provides payment processing support for both sites as well as for another 500,000 China-based
Other payments are generated by credit and debit cards. Even when those cards carry China Registered buyers and sellers UnionPay, Visa, or MasterCard use one of two payment models. brands, settlement In the escrow occurs directly between model, Alipay is Alipay and the bank alipay prothe middle man, card issuers. ceSSeS 5 mil. holding a buyers tranSactionS money until the Alipay recently signed a daily Valued seller delivers contract with Asknet in the goods. Funds Germany, which operat $176 mil. are transferred ates Web portals for softfrom the buyers ware vendors and will bank account into their Alipay use Alipay as a new acceptance account. In the instant payments mark. model, the buyers funds are Stock trades on the Hong Kong transferred directly from their Stock Exchange. Stephen Zhu is bank account to the sellers Director of Business Intelligence Alipay account where they can at Alipay.com Co. Ltd. in Hangeither be moved into a bank zhou, China, 86 (571) 2688-8888 account or used to make auction x37315, [email protected]. payments.
FebruarY 2010 issue 942 the NilsoN report
DO NOT COPY THIS REPORT. Reproducing or allowing reproduction of any portion of this newsletter in any manner for any purpose constitutes a copyright violation subject to substantial fines.
American Express figures include credit cards issued by Bank of America, Barclays, Citi, GE Money, HSBC, and USAA. Discover figures include credit, debit, and prepaid cards issued by GE Money, HSBC, Alliance Data, and 27 other issuers.
2008. American Express credit cards had a 23.84% share, down from 23.95% in 2008. Discover credit cards reached 5.70%, up from 5.47% in 2008.
$2.971 Tril.
Visa 55.4% 194 MasterCard 27.1% 84 Amex 14.1% 102 Discover 3.4% 8
$1.761 Tril.
system, doesnt integrate statistics from that business with Discover statistics. Cirrus and Plus PIN-based ATM activity is also excluded.
Visa debit and prepaid card spending overtook Visa credit cards for the first time. Visa Visa gained 194 basis points in debit and prepaid cards held share of spending at merchants a 29.72% share of all general in 2009 against the combined purpose card spending, up from signature and PIN-based credit, 26.65% in 2008. Visa credit debit, and prepaid cards of cards held a 25.72% share in its competitors, from 53.50% 2009. MasterCard debit and to 55.43%. All other brands prepaid cards ended the year declined. Discovers share fell with a 11.00% share, up from 8 basis points to 3.38%. Master10.06% in 2008. Discover brand Cards share fell 84 basis points debit and prepaid cards numto 27.05%. American bers were low and Expresss share are counted with debit purchaSe declined 102 basis credit card figures. tranSactionS points to 14.13%. American Express, which has prepaid accounted For Comparing only card volume but no 61.52% oF the credit cards, Visa debit card volume, total, up From had the highest counts prepaid with 57.51%. market share of credit cards. purchase volume in 2009 at 43.40%, up Credit, debit, and from 42.43% in 2008. Masterprepaid cards in circulation Card credit cards held a 27.06% declined by 38.8 million to share, down from 28.16% in 1.08 billion by year-end 2009.
UY
Transactions (bil.)
Total Chg. Purchases Chg.
Cards
(mil.) Chg.
Visa Credit MasterCard Credit American Express Credit Discover Credit CREDIT CARD TOTALS Visa Debit & Prepaid MasterCard Debit & Prepaid DEBIT CARD TOTALS CREDIT & DEBIT TOTALS
$830.10 13.0% $525.40 16.8% $423.70 10.1% $108.69 $1,184.10 $450.40 $1,634.50 $3,522.39 9.6% 8.5% 6.5%
$764.20 7.3% $476.90 12.9% $419.84 9.8% $100.43 5.4% $882.60 $326.80
270.1 11.1% 203.0 21.9% 48.9 9.4% 54.4 5.5% 576.4 14.6% 382.0 18.3% 125.0 0.8% 507.0 13.4%
$1,887.89 13.3% $1,761.38 9.4% $126.52 45.9% 20.35 4.4% 20.16 4.2% 7.9% $301.50 5.8% $123.60 7.3% $425.10 10.4% 26.88 13.0% 23.91 13.8% 8.5% 9.34 10.9% 8.34 11.7% 9.8% 36.22 12.5% 32.25 13.2% 5.7% 52.42
8.0% $1,209.40
American Express and Discover include business from third-party issuers. Fgures include PIN-based debit figures for Visa (Interlink) and MasterCard to match their reporting. However, card figures for Visa do not include Plus cards that are not Visa cards. 2010 The Nilson Report
IF YOU ARE READING THIS NEWSLETTER BY WAY OF A WEB SITE OR SERVER, there has been a violation of copyright law which carries substantial fines. No company has been granted the right to post this publication.
Visa increased its share 435 basis points to 60.19% with the addition of 25.4 million cards. MasterCards share decreased by 394 basis points to 30.28% due to a decline of 56.0 million cards. American Expresss share declined by 30 basis points to 4.51% with a decline of 5.1 million cards, and Discovers share declined 11 basis points to 5.02% with a decline of 3.1 million cards. Credit card outstandings for all Visa, MasterCard, American Express, and Discover
$772.19 100.00%
$862.40 100.00%
* Includes third-party issuers. general purpose card accounts decreased by $90.22 billion in 2009, down 10.5%. Outstandings on MasterCard credit cards decreased by 12.3%, followed by American Express, down 10.6%. Visa fell by 9.8%, and Discover fell by 4.7%. Visa and Discover increased market share last year. The 507.0 million Visa and MasterCard debit and prepaid cards accounted for 46.80% of all general purpose cards in circulation, up from 39.83%
57.5%
in 2008. Prepaid cards were the main contributors to that increase. The $1.209 trillion in purchase volume generated by debit and prepaid cards equaled 40.71% of total general purpose card spending at merchants last year, up from 36.70% in 2008. The 32.25 billion purchase transactions on debit and prepaid cards accounted for 61.52% of all general purpose card purchase transactions last year, up from 57.51% in 2008. Prior issues: 924, 902, 895, 894, 874
36.9%
volume on Visa all products 10% combined grew by $4.44 bil99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 lion or 0.3%, *On U.S. general purpose cards. Note: Starting in 2006, PIN debit for compared to Visa (Interlink) and MasterCard is included to match how those companies report gures. 2010 Nilson Report a decline of $52.59 billion, or 6.1% for MasterCard products. Visas market share versus MasterCard grew to 67.20% from 65.73% in 2008. Combined signature and PIN-based purchase volume on Visa debit and prepaid cards increased by $64.62 billion, up 7.9%, while credit card purchase volume, which is all signature-based, decreased by $60.18 billion or 7.3%. MasterCard signature and PIN-based debit and prepaid card purchase volume increased by $17.92 billion, up 5.8%, while credit cards fell by $70.51 billion, a 12.9% decline. Visas 72.98% share of debit/prepaid purchase
volume versus MasterCard in 2009 compared to 72.59% in 2008. The average annual purchase volume per Visa debit card was $2,310 in 2009, down from $2,532 in 2008. The average annual purchase volume per MasterCard debit card was $2,614, up from $2,491. Combined, the average amount declined to $2,385 from $2,521. Debit and prepaid cards combined generated 49.35% of all purchase volume in the Visa and MasterCard systems, up from 45.10% in 2008. Visa purchase transactions at merchants on credit, debit, and prepaid cards combined held a market share of 69.81% in 2009, up from 68.79% in 2008. Visas share of credit card purchase transactions increased to 60.46% from 59.62%, while its share of debit card purchase transactions increased to 74.14% from 73.79%. Visa and MasterCard credit, debit, and prepaid cards in circulation in the U.S. declined by 30.6 million to 980.1 million in 2009. Visa added 25.4
... turn to page 8
IF YOU ARE BEING FORWARDED a copy of this report, there has been a violation of copyright law which carries FebruarY 2010 issue 942 the NilsoN report substantial fines. The right to possess digital versions of this newsletter are granted solely to the individual subscriber.
million credit, debit, and prepaid cards, compared to a 56.0 million decline by MasterCard. Visas
share of cards in circulation was 66.53%, up from 62.01%. Visas debit and prepaid card base
MasterCard
2009 Chg.
Amex
2009 Chg.
Discover
2009 Chg.
ACCEPTANCE LOCATIONS (mil.) 8.2 4.0% 100.0 7.4% CARDHOLDERS (mil.) CARDS (mil.) 270.1 11.1% Per Cardholder 2.70 4.0% Per Account 1.19 1.1% ACCOUNTS (mil.) 227.1 12.0% Per Cardholder 2.27 5.0% Active Accounts (mil.) 122.0 5.9% 53.7% 3.5 pts. Percent Active TRANSACTIONS (mil.) 9,119.8 2.7% 40.2 10.6% Per Account Average Amount $91 10.6% Purchases (mil.) 9,036.9 2.4% Percent of Total 99.1% 0.4 pt. Average Amount $85 5.0% Cash Advances (mil.) 82.9 29.7% Percent of Total 0.9% 0.4 pt. Average Amount $795 27.8% TOTAL VOLUME (bil.) $830.10 13.0% $3,073 2.2% Per Card Per Account $3,655 1.1% Purchases (bil.) $764.20 7.3% Percent of Total 92.1% 5.7 pts. Cash Advances (bil.) $65.90 49.3% Percent of Total 7.9% 5.7 pts. OUTSTANDINGS (bil.) $366.05 9.8% 44.1% 1.6 pts. Percent of Total Volume Per Card $1,355 1.4% Per Account $1,612 2.5% Delinquencies (bil.) $22.48 2.0% Pct. of Outstandings 6.14% 0.7 pt. GROSS CHARGE-OFFS (bil.) $40.23 43.9% 10.99% 4.1 pts. Pct. of Outstandings Pct. of Total Volume 4.85% 1.9 pts. Recoveries (bil.) $2.93 31.2% Pct. of Gross Charge-offs 7.28% 0.7 pt. NET CHARGE-OFFS (bil.) $37.30 45.0% 10.19% 3.9 pts. Pct. of Outstandings Pct. of Total Volume 4.49% 1.8 pts. Credit/Nonfraud (bil.) $36.75 46.5% Pct. of Total Volume 4.43% 1.8 pts. Net Fraud Loss (bil.) $0.55 14.9% Pct. of Total Volume 0.07% 0.0 pt.
8.2 80.0 203.0 2.54 1.19 170.0 2.13 90.0 53.0% 5,945.6 35.0 $88 5,908.8 99.4% $81 36.8 0.6% $1,318 $525.40 $2,588 $3,091 $476.90 90.8% $48.50 9.2% $267.57 50.9% $1,318 $1,574 $16.80 6.28% $29.27 10.94% 5.57% $2.01 6.86% $27.27 10.19% 5.19% $26.91 5.12% $0.36 0.07%
3.8% 4.9 5.7% 7.4 5.0% 20.0% 34.4 4.9% 40.0 5.6% 21.9% 48.9 9.4% 54.4 5.5% 2.4% 1.42 4.8% 1.36 0.1% 0.3% 1.47 0.9% 1.19 0.3% 21.7% 33.2 8.6% 45.6 5.2% 2.1% 0.96 3.9% 1.14 0.4% 19.5% 23.6 9.9% 19.3 4.7% 2.7 pts. 71.0% 1.0 pt. 42.4% 0.2 pt. 6.0% 3,622.4 7.4% 1,667.1 0.9% 19.9% 109.2 1.3% 36.6 4.5% 11.4% $117 2.9% $65 8.7% 5.8% 3,588.4 7.4% 1,635.1 0.3% 0.3 pt. 99.1% 0.0 pt. 98.1% 0.7 pt. 7.6% $117 2.5% $61 5.2% 36.1% 34.0 5.6% 32.0 26.7% 0.3 pt. 0.9% 0.0 pt. 1.9% 0.7 pt. 9.5% $113 30.5% $258 19.6% 16.8% $423.70 10.1% $108.69 9.6% 6.6% $8,665 0.7% $2,000 4.4% 6.2% $12,772 1.6% $2,383 4.6% 12.9% $419.84 9.8% $100.43 5.4% 4.1 pts. 99.1% 0.3 pt. 92.4% 4.1 pts. 42.2% $3.86 34.4% $8.26 41.0% 4.1 pts. 0.9% 0.3 pt. 7.6% 4.1 pts. 12.3% $86.06 10.6% $52.51 4.7% 2.6 pts. 20.3% 0.1 pt. 48.3% 2.5 pts. 12.3% $1,760 1.3% $966 0.8% 11.9% $2,594 2.2% $1,151 0.6% 1.3% $2.77 35.8% $2.94 14.6% 0.7 pt. 3.22% 1.3 pts. 5.60% 0.9 pt. 38.6% $6.98 29.0% $4.63 47.8% 4.0 pts. 8.11% 2.5 pts. 8.82% 3.1 pts. 2.2 pts. 1.65% 0.5 pt. 4.26% 1.7 pts. 19.5% $0.60 33.1% $0.43 26.1% 1.1 pts. 8.63% 0.3 pt. 9.30% 1.6 pts. 40.2% $6.38 28.6% $4.20 50.4% 3.8 pts. 7.41% 2.3 pts. 8.00% 2.9 pts. 2.1 pts. 1.51% 0.5 pt. 3.86% 1.5 pts. 41.3% $6.24 29.5% $4.12 58.0% 2.1 pts. 1.47% 0.5 pt. 3.79% 1.6 pts. 10.3% $0.14 2.6% $0.08 5.2% 0.0 pt. 0.03% 0.0 pt. 0.07% 0.0 pt.
Some prior year figures have been restated. American Express and Discover include third-party issuers. Third-party outstandings are not owned nor managed by Discover or Amex. 2010 The Nilson Report
DO NOT COPY THIS REPORT. Reproducing or allowing reproduction of any portion of this newsletter in any manner for any purpose constitutes a copyright violation subject to substantial fines.
MasterCard
2009 Chg. 2009
Total
Chg.
CARDS (mil.) 382.0 18.3% ACCOUNTS (mil.) 282.0 23.1% Active Accounts (mil.) 159.9 24.9% 56.7% 0.8 pt. Percent Active TRANSACTIONS (mil.) 26,879.1 13.0% 95.3 8.2% Per Account Average Amount $44 4.0% Purchases (mil.) 23,908.6 13.8% Percent of Total 88.9% 0.6 pt. Average Amount $37 5.2% Cash Withdrawals (mil.) 2,970.5 7.4% Percent of Total 11.1% 0.6 pt. Average Amount $101 2.8% TOTAL VOLUME (bil.) $1,184.10 8.5% $4,199 11.9% Per Account Purchases (bil.) $882.60 7.9% Percent of Total 74.5% 0.4 pt. Cash Withdrawals (bil.) $301.50 10.4% Percent of Total 25.5% 0.4 pt.
125.0 121.0 59.4 49.1% 9,343.5 77.2 $48 8,340.9 89.3% $39 1,002.6 10.7% $123 $450.40 $3,722 $326.80 72.6% $123.60 27.4%
0.8% 507.0 4.3% 403.0 7.1% 219.3 1.3 pts. 54.4% 10.9% 36,222.6 6.3% 89.9 3.9% $45 11.7% 32,249.5 0.7 pt. 89.0% 5.3% $38 4.3% 3,973.1 0.7 pt. 11.0% 4.1% $107 6.5% $1,634.50 2.1% $4,056 5.8% $1,209.40 0.5 pt. 74.0% 8.5% $425.10 0.5 pt. 26.0%
13.4% 16.8% 19.5% 1.2 pts. 12.5% 3.7% 4.0% 13.2% 0.6 pt. 5.2% 6.6% 0.6 pt. 3.0% 8.0% 7.6% 7.3% 0.4 pt. 9.8% 0.4 pt.
and prepaid, up from 44.23% in 2008. Visas card base was 41.42% credit, down from 48.46%. MasterCards card base was 61.89% credit, down from 67.71%, Prepaid Visa and MasterCard cards increase the number of debit cards in circulation to a greater extent than they increase debit purchase volume because most are the one-timeuse type and spending per card is low compared to a debit card tied to a traditional deposit account. Visa and MasterCard credit card purchase volume combined declined by $130.69 billion, or 9.5% in 2009. Visa held a 61.57% share, up from 60.10% in 2008. Annual average purchase volume per Visa credit card was $2,829, up from $2,714 the prior year. For MasterCard, the annual average credit card purchase volume was $2,349, up from $2,105.
turn to page 12
card base decreased by 57.0 million. Of the 980.1 million total Visa and MasterCard cards in circulation, 51.73% were debit
U.S. Visa & MasterCard Credit & Debit & Prepaid Card Totals
Visa
Category 2009 Chg.
MasterCard
2009 Chg.
Total
2009 Chg.
Credit
from 60.1%
Visa
MasterCard
from 39.9%
73.0%
Debit
from 72.6% from 27.4%
Visa
27.0% MasterCard
67.2% 32.8%
Visa
MasterCard
from 34.3%
CARDS (mil.) ACCOUNTS (mil.) Active Accounts (mil.) Percent Active TRANSACTIONS (mil.) Per Account Average Amount Purchases (mil.) Percent of Total Average Amount Cash (mil.) Percent of Total Average Amount TOTAL VOLUME (bil.) Per Account Purchases (bil.) Percent of Total Cash (bil.) Percent of Total
652.1 509.1 281.8 55.4% 33,998.9 70.7 $56 32,945.5 91.5% $50 3,053.4 8.5% $120 $2,014.20 $3,956 $1,646.80 81.8% $367.40 18.2%
4.1% 4.5% 9.4% 2.5 pts. 8.6% 3.9% 9.3% 8.8% 0.2 pt. 7.9% 5.9% 0.2 pt. 13.9% 1.5% 5.8% 0.3% 1.5 pts. 8.8% 1.5 pts.
328.0 291.0 149.4 51.3% 15,289.1 52.5 $64 14,249.7 93.2% $56 1,039.4 6.8% $166 $975.80 $3,353 $803.70 82.4% $172.10 17.6%
14.6% 980.1 3.0% 12.6% 800.1 2.4% 10.7% 431.3 1.5% 1.1 pts. 53.9% 2.1 pts. 3.6% 51,288.0 7.1% 18.6% 64.1 9.7% 10.7% $58 9.9% 3.8% 47,195.2 7.3% 0.1 pt. 92.0% 0.2 pt. 9.5% $52 8.6% 2.0% 4,092.8 4.9% 0.1 pt. 8.0% 0.2 pt. 14.7% $132 14.4% 7.4% $2,990.00 3.5% 5.9% $3,737 1.1% 6.1% $2,450.50 1.9% 1.1 pts. 82.0% 1.3 pts. 13.0% $539.50 10.2% 1.1 pts. 18.0% 1.3 pts.
2010 The Nilson Report
IF YOU ARE READING THIS NEWSLETTER BY WAY OF A WEB SITE OR SERVER, there has been a violation of copyright law which carries substantial fines. No company has been granted the right to post this publication.
JPMorgan Chase Delaware Bank of America Delaware Citigroup S. Dak., Nev., Md. Capital One Virginia Wells Fargo South Dakota HSBC Delaware U.S. Bank North Dakota USAA Savings Nevada Barclays Delaware Target South Dakota Navy FCU Virginia PNC Bank Delaware First Natl of Omaha Nebraska GE Money Utah Fifth Third Bank Ohio Cabelas WFB Nebraska RBS Citizens Rhode Island BB&T Financial Georgia Nordstrom Arizona State Farm Bank Illinois Pentagon FCU Virginia Associated Bank Wisconsin Town North Bank Texas SunTrust Bank Georgia Merrick Bank Utah Credit One Bank Nevada 1st Financial Bank S. Dakota ICBA Bancard Virginia San Diego County CU Calif. Commerce Bank Missouri Premier Bankcard So. Dakota Suncoast Schools FCU Florida CompuCredit Georgia BECU Washington Compass Bank Alabama TIB-The Ind. Bankers Texas America First CU Utah SchoolsFirst FCU California Pa. State Employees CU Pa. BMW Bank Utah M&I Bank Nevada First Hawaiian Bank Hawaii TD Bank Delaware Digital FCU (DCU) Mass. First Citizens N.C. VyStar CU Florida Columbus B&T Georgia UMB Missouri Wescom CU California American Savings Hawaii
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 14 13 12 15 18 17 16 21 22 20 23 24 25 30 27 26 28 29 33 31 32 34 19 37 36 35 39 38 43 40 41 42 48 44 46 45 47 51 49 68
$156,197.3 $134,723.7 $103,200.0 $53,880.0 $31,966.0 $23,225.0 $21,247.1 $12,697.5 $11,247.2 $7,655.0 $4,618.0 $4,584.8 $4,121.3 $2,966.7 $2,492.5 $2,412.0 $2,368.0 $1,767.9 $1,581.7 $1,581.2 $1,564.9 $1,259.0 $1,131.8 $1,020.0 $1,009.7 $981.0 $946.0 $945.0 $941.3 $935.7 $913.0 $701.5 $650.0 $607.9 $604.5 $562.4 $424.0 $407.4 $403.0 $394.7 $370.2 $362.0 $341.0 $329.6 $313.7 $307.9 $303.1 $273.3 $233.9 $222.2 $603,992.5
15% 16% 3% 10% 12% 15% 15% 4% 2% 11% 11% 7% 16% 4% 8% 3% 5% 16% 9% 3% 14% 7% 9% 9% 7% 16% 1% 1% 21% 4% 7% 1% 68% 10% 2% 20% 22% 3% 22% 8% 5% 3% 35% 1% 7% 0% 13% 18% 7% 48% 11%
1 2 3 4 6 7 5 9 8 12 14 10 13 15 16 11 17 20 18 21 26 59 27 19 49 36 43 23 50 24 31 51 79 32 38 28 37 54 60 47 30 29 41 46 33 63 40 34 69 87
1 2 3 4 6 7 5 8 9 13 16 11 14 18 17 14 19 21 20 23 28 50 30 22 44 36 41 24 51 26 37 52 33 34 43 29 42 55 61 48 32 31 54 45 38 64 49 39 63 86
$339,828.9 $250,666.1 $204,557.0 $101,274.0 $53,940.0 $35,344.0 $73,898.9 $25,996.6 $30,126.9 $10,068.9 $6,951.9 $16,575.0 $8,053.1 $5,769.9 $5,449.1 $10,700.0 $5,254.8 $4,839.7 $5,161.0 $3,905.4 $2,656.8 $490.0 $2,090.9 $4,985.7 $728.6 $1,015.0 $858.7 $3,594.0 $680.2 $3,310.8 $1,405.7 $639.4 $285.0 $1,282.2 $946.7 $1,828.4 $960.0 $585.0 $466.1 $821.7 $1,454.0 $1,625.4 $916.1 $826.3 $1,145.1 $399.0 $921.9 $1,063.2 $352.8 $242.8 $1,236,938.7
10% 21% 17% 13% 7% 19% 0% 2% 17% 20% 0% 18% 14% 2% 4% 4% 1% 4% 0% 11% 15% 38% 1% 8% 22% 22% 15% 18% 12% 10% 11% 12% 79% 5% 2% 19% 4% 13% 2% 8% 3% 6% 29% 11% 5% 9% 4% 4% 19% 10% 13%
1 2 3 4 6 7 5 9 8 12 14 10 13 15 19 11 17 20 16 22 26 130 27 18 49 36 43 23 61 25 31 52 82 32 41 28 47 54 57 46 30 29 40 44 33 63 38 34 68 119
1 2 3 4 6 7 5 8 9 12 16 11 15 17 19 14 20 22 18 25 30 103 29 21 47 37 41 23 62 26 35 56 36 34 48 28 49 55 58 46 32 31 51 43 38 63 45 39 67 127
$314,370.7 $220,447.3 $187,744.0 $93,500.0 $46,360.0 $32,144.0 $67,885.6 $24,061.6 $28,344.1 $9,981.0 $6,353.6 $12,875.9 $7,811.9 $5,733.6 $4,719.0 $10,000.0 $4,823.1 $4,554.2 $5,132.6 $3,749.7 $2,272.6 $55.6 $1,939.8 $4,810.7 $671.3 $958.1 $831.4 $3,344.0 $379.3 $2,973.0 $1,379.9 $536.0 $250.0 $1,209.2 $844.5 $1,760.5 $748.1 $515.0 $458.5 $801.0 $1,433.8 $1,595.1 $846.2 $816.9 $1,107.4 $373.2 $898.2 $1,052.2 $332.2 $116.0 $1,125,901.4
8% 12% 12% 9% 6% 16% 0% 0% 23% 20% 4% 1% 6% 5% 1% 4% 7% 4% 0% 3% 17% 68% 2% 9% 20% 21% 15% 17% 6% 16% 12% 8% 80% 3% 4% 18% 3% 12% 1% 5% 2% 6% 31% 11% 5% 7% 4% 4% 13% 9% 8%
1 3 2 4 7 5 9 13 10 6 21 15 12 8 16 18 17 24 20 26 33 63 29 34 27 19 28 25 71 30 11 44 22 48 32 31 47 43 52 39 37 42 41 45 40 58 36 35 56 114
75,041 46,252 56,623 33,571 15,200 27,643 9,687 3,184 5,792 22,001 1,793 2,603 3,733 12,093 2,587 2,110 2,222 1,071 1,979 793 413 85 592 289 722 2,049 641 1,020 64 542 4,099 164 1,620 151 430 534 151 172 131 221 229 181 202 164 220 107 252 283 113 31 341,849
18% 34% 11% 8% 2% 12% 10% 3% 13% 2% 12% 6% 27% 3% 19% 11% 5% 5% 8% 0% 11% 27% 15% 5% 18% 18% 3% 14% 1% 2% 6% 1% 45% 2% 1% 17% 0% 1% 6% 6% 4% 3% 17% 2% 9% 2% 2% 15% 1% 9% 14%
1 3 2 4 6 5 7 12 8 10 19 16 15 11 18 14 17 25 20 27 33 63 26 32 22 13 29 24 59 30 9 41 21 40 38 28 50 52 54 44 36 35 39 47 45 62 42 34 51 113
42,473 25,088 36,239 20,174 6,800 13,588 5,709 2,774 4,668 3,450 787 1,092 1,136 2,972 914 1,250 957 545 772 429 246 50 430 287 628 1,715 402 560 61 340 3,459 123 750 133 135 428 90 85 85 103 139 142 133 94 101 55 122 165 88 21 182,988
19% 13% 11% 7% 1% 11% 8% 6% 2% 18% 6% 2% 8% 4% 8% 10% 1% 11% 8% 4% 4% 12% 12% 8% 18% 15% 13% 12% 20% 2% 7% 1% 70% 3% 0% 21% 0% 0% 6% 3% 0% 2% 14% 5% 4% 2% 10% 16% 7% 2% 12%
1 3 2 4 7 5 9 12 10 6 21 14 11 8 19 17 16 18 23 26 29 64 28 34 30 22 32 25 70 27 13 42 20 43 33 31 46 47 51 49 41 45 40 50 36 59 35 39 57 112
93,801 54,088 79,200 40,874 17,400 32,615 12,373 2,774 10,757 23,887 1,738 3,514 4,564 14,511 2,242 2,470 2,519 2,339 1,502 1,154 619 100 693 375 565 1,706 534 1,160 81 814 3,895 249 1,900 248 440 536 203 202 182 188 261 241 265 187 321 130 342 282 133 38 422,930
18% 29% 14% 12% 0% 13% 11% 6% 1% 2% 11% 6% 26% 3% 8% 10% 9% 52% 6% 4% 12% 21% 15% 4% 32% 15% 9% 12% 2% 5% 7% 16% 49% 3% 5% 20% 1% 0% 5% 19% 2% 6% 30% 3% 2% 1% 22% 14% 3% 10% 14%
1 2 6 4 5 9 7 27 10 3 18 12 11 8 33 13 114 14 17 19 22 54 39 28 23 16 25 20 57 21 29 37 15 38 24 26 41 42 46 43 36 74 35 44 31 50 30 34 49 96
55,701 36,914 15,200 22,874 15,400 6,721 12,031 390 4,019 23,887 1,469 3,433 3,978 6,961 286 2,470 20 2,208 1,502 1,154 608 100 233 375 477 1,697 430 880 81 736 350 249 1,700 248 431 423 203 202 182 188 260 57 265 187 289 127 322 282 133 38 228,370
19% 28% 14% 5% 1% 12% 11% 6% 2% 2% 10% 5% 26% 24% 28% 10% 60% 53% 6% 4% 12% 20% 33% 4% 41% 15% 9% 12% 2% 2% 18% 16% 48% 3% 5% 19% 1% 0% 5% 19% 2% 12% 30% 3% 2% 1% 25% 14% 3% 10% 12%
2 5 1 4 12 3 17 8 7 20 30 15 6 13 11 23 56 81 16 28 61 27 19 33 9 21 63 25 80 22 41 75 48
38,100 17,174 64,000 18,000 2,000 25,894 342 4,103 6,738 0 269 81 586 7,550 1,956 0 2,499 131 0 0 12 <1 460 0 89 9 104 280 0 77 3,545 0 200 0 9 114 0 0 0 0 <1 184 0 0 32 3 21 0 0 0 194,561
17% 33% 13% 19% 2% 13% 16% 3% 7% 15% 36% 28% 11% 6% 8% 41% 11% 99% 28% 273% 14% 9% 13% 26% 11% 60% 12% 22% 13% 4% 3% 16% 9% 16%
Includes both consumer and commercial cards. Some prior year figures have been restated. Use percent change to calculate the 2008 results. IIssuers with total $1,040.0 mil.), Zions (#39, $945.9 mil.), Comerica (#42, $887.9 mil.), Regions (#44, $846.5 mil.), First Horizon (#45, $828.5 mil.), and RBC (#48, $748.3).
volume in the top 50 but with outstandings less than the top 50 include Comdata (#22, $3,803.6 mil.), Wright Express (#25, $3,082.8 mil.), BMO Harris (#35,
10
DO NOT COPY THIS REPORT. Reproducing or allowing reproduction of any portion of this newsletter in any manner for any purpose constitutes a copyright violation subject to substantial fines.
IF YOU ARE READING THIS NEWSLETTER BY WAY OF A WEB SITE OR SERVER, there has been a violation of copyright law which carries substantial fines. No company has been granted the right to post this publication.
11
Visa issuers lost $39.75 billion in outstandings, while MasterCard issuers lost $37.65 billion. Visa held a 57.77% market share at year-end, up from 57.07% the prior year. Purchase transactions generated by MasterCard and Visa debit and prepaid cards increased by 13.2% last year. Credit card purchase transactions
fell by 3.7%. Debit and prepaid signature and PIN-based purchase transactions increased by 3.77 billion compared to a decrease of 0.58 billion for credit cards. Debit and prepaid cards generated a 68.33% share of combined Visa and MasterCard card transactions at merchants, up from 64.71% in 2008.
profitability. It is best known for syndicated benchmark studies based on data supplied by issuers. Argus receives the full master file of data on each cardholder pertaining to behavior, transactions, pricing, and risk. Contributors are the 20 largest U.S. issuers, which
collectively account for 600 million accounts and 95% of the consumer card and 90% of the small business card markets. In the U.K., Argus now supplies services to 9 of the top 10 issuers. Collectively those portfolios account for more than 80% of the market. The economic crisis has increased issuers need to assess and track internal performance relative to external benchmarks. Participating issuers typically request benchmarks that reflect combinations of product type, vintage, and risk. All metrics in the studies aggregate data across at least five competitors to safeguard each participants confidential data. Issuers dont see competitor data and Argus doesnt see the names of cardholders. No marketing lists are generated.
In addition to its syndicated models and provides credit studies of the external marketbureau attributes to enhance place, Argus sells CardProfit benchmark data. Last year, software, which makes an the Office of the Comptroller issuers internal data wareof the Currency gave Argus house, or its data held at a a contract to provide data third-party processor, more aggregation support. The comuseful. CardProfit provides pany is looking for additional a model with all of the data, partners to provide added reports, and ongoing mainvalue to its customers. It is also tenance needed for customer looking to expand its current and portfolio management. staff with consumer financial The software has services executives with been deployed at 8 data management, data ...majority of the top 20 U.S. analysis, modeling, and owned by credit card issuers. consulting experience. Argus also provides Argus has been mamentS Since advisory services jority owned by Oak 2007. on product design Investments since 2007. and development, Funding has been used risk management, and marto broaden its product range keting. Clients have included and to help scale its business. nearly all of the top consumer In the U.S., Argus has begun financial services providers broadening data aggregation in the U.S. and U.K. Projects beyond cards to include dehave included activation and posit accounts. Leonard Laufer retention programs, spending is CEO at Argus Information programs, balance generation & Advisory Services in White programs, credit line increase Plains, New York, and decrease programs, and (914) 307- 3152, llaufer@ collections. argusinformation.com. Prior issues: 940, 807 First Data offers its cardholder account customers Argus studies and CardProfit. SAS Institute software is used by Argus for modeling. TransUnion works with Argus David Robertson, Publisher to develop custom and generic FebruarY 17, 2010
oak inVeSt-
12
N O W
Citi www.citi.com Columbus B&T www.columbusbankandtrust.com Commerce Bank www.commercebank.com Compass Bank www.compassbank.com CompuCredit www.compucredit.com Credit One Bank www.creditonebank.com Digital FCU www.dcu.org Discover www.discover.com e-onlinedata www.e-onlinedata.com Elan Financial Services www.elanfinancialser vices.com Elavon www.elavon.com eCommLink www.ecommlink.com Equifax www.equifax.com FICO www.fico.com Fifth Third Bank www.53.com First Citizens www.firstcitizens.com First Data www.firstdata.com First Hawaiian Bank www.fhb.com First Natl of Omaha www.fnni.com Galileo Processing www.galileoprocessing.com GE Money www.gemoney.com
Gemalto www.gemalto.com Global Cash www.globalcashcard.com GlobalPlatform www.globalplatform.org Heartland Payment Systems www.heartlandpaymentsystems.com HSBC www.hsbc.com HTC www.htc.com Hypercom www.hypercom.com I&M Bank www.imbank.co.ke ICBA Bancard www.icba.org IIR Espaa www.iirspain.com InComm www.incomm.com Integrated Bank Technology www.ibanktech.net IQPC www.iqpc.com JPMorgan Chase www.jpmorganchase.com M&I Bank www.mandibank.com Masria Card www.masriacard.com MasterCard www.mastercard.com Mercury Payment Systems www.mercurypay.com Merrick Bank www.merrickbank.com Mobile Financial Services www.mobile-financialservices.com Navy FCU www.navyfederal.org
C O N N E C T
C O N T I N U E D
N O W
C O N N E C T
FEBRUARY 2010