HUM 2 Final - Eductive Propositions
HUM 2 Final - Eductive Propositions
This proposition:
“All men are bipeds”
implies that those who do not belong to the class of bipeds are not
men.
Eductive Propositions
In the proposition, “All men are mortal beings,” the predicate term
“mortal beings” has a complementary class of “non-mortal beings.”
In the same way, the proposition, “Some scholars are genius,” has a
complementary class of “non-genius.”
1. Obversion
Following the procedures outlined, we can now form the obverse of the
following proposition:
Obvertend:
All men are rational animals.
Obverse:
All men are not non-rational animals.
No men are non-rational animals.
1. Obversion
Obvertend:
No dogs are rational animals.
Obverse:
All dogs are non-rational animals.
1. Obversion
Obvertend:
Some students are scholars.
Obverse:
Some students are not non-scholars.
1. Obversion
Obvertend:
Some bipedal animals are not birds.
Obverse:
Some bipedal animals are non-birds.
Obvertend Obverse pattern Example
pattern Obvertend Obverse
All S is P. No S is non P. All angels are No angels are non-
spiritual beings. spiritual beings.
No S is P. All S is non P. No angels are All angels are non-
carnal beings. carnal beings.
Some S is P. Some S is not non Some students are Some students are
P. scholars. not non-students.
Some S is not P. Some S is non P. Some plants are Some plants are
not vines. non-vines.
2. Conversion
In modern logic it is only valid for the E and I propositions. There are
three rules to observe in making the conversion:
1. Swap the subject and predicate terms. This rule implies that the
quality of the proposition and the quantity of the terms should be left
unchanged.
2. Conversion
Convertend:
No carabaos are pigs.
Converse:
No pigs are carabaos.
2. Conversion
Convertend:
Some students are athletes.
Converse:
Some athletes are students.
2. Conversion
3. Do not extend any term. The quantity of the term must not be affected
in the process of conversion. If a term, either subject term or
predicate term, is particular, then in conversion, it must retain its
quantity. Concerning the quantity of the terms, as a general rule, the
predicate term of all affirmative propositions is always particular
while the predicate term of all negative proposition is always
universal.
2. Conversion
Convertend:
Some Filipinos are millionaires. (The predicate is
particular.)
Converse:
Some millionaires are Filipinos.
2. Conversion by limitation
Convertend (A proposition):
All plants are living beings.
Converse:
Some living being are plants.
3. Contraposition
Contraponend (A proposition):
All men are mortal beings.
Contrapositive:
All non-mortal (or immortal) beings are non-men.
3. Contraposition
Contraponend (O proposition):
Some prisoners are not innocent individuals.
Contrapositive:
Some non-innocent individuals are not non-prisoners.
3. Contraposition
Contraponend (A proposition):
All men are mortal beings.
Step 1. Obverse: No men are non-mortal beings.
Step 2. Converse: No non-mortal beings are men.
Step 3. All non-mortal (or immortal) beings are non-men.
3. Contraposition by limitation
Contraponend (E proposition):
No spiritual beings are mortal being.
Contrapositive:
Some non-mortal (or immortal) beings are not non-
spiritual beings.
3. Contraposition by limitation
Contraponend (E proposition):
No spiritual beings are mortal being.
Step 1. All spiritual beings are non-mortal beings.
Step 2. All non-mortal beings are spiritual beings.
Step 3. No non-mortal beings are non-spiritual beings.
Some non-mortal (or immortal) beings are not non-
spiritual beings.
3. Contraposition by limitation
Contraponend (E proposition):
No spiritual beings are mortal being.
Step 1. No mortal beings are spiritual beings.
Step 2. No non-mortal beings are non-spiritual beings.
Some non-mortal (or immortal) beings are not non-
spiritual beings.