Skip to main contentSkip to navigationSkip to navigation
James Keir Hardie addresses a demonstration against first world war, Trafalgar Square, 1914
Scottish politician James Keir Hardie addresses a crowd in a peace demonstration against the first world war, Trafalgar Square, 1914. Photograph: Hulton-Deutsch Collection/CORBIS
Scottish politician James Keir Hardie addresses a crowd in a peace demonstration against the first world war, Trafalgar Square, 1914. Photograph: Hulton-Deutsch Collection/CORBIS

Are there beliefs to die for?

This article is more than 15 years old
Are there any causes you think you should be prepared to die for? Or is it always wrong to die for any abstract idea?

Friday is International Conscientious Objectors' Day. To mark this, we're asking: are there are beliefs worth dying, or killing for?

Soldiers, of course, must be prepared to kill in the name of their country, its values or strategic interests. Conscientious objectors hold that no cause can be worth the taking of a life. Do you agree? And if not, can you envisage circumstances in which you would be prepared to die, or take a life, for a belief, religious or otherwise? Or is it right to die, perhaps even to kill, for the sake of people you love, but never for the sake of an idea? Even the idea that no one should ever be made to die for an idea?

Monday's response

Alan Wilson: Perhaps the real value of lives given in war is determined not by the dead but by the living

Wednesday's response

Sue Blackmore: If it came to it, like the suffragettes before me, I would fight – even die – for my freedom

Thursday's response

Musab Bora: Islam elevates the concept of community duty, and I'd gladly fight for my neighbours

Most viewed

Most viewed