Skip to main contentSkip to navigationSkip to navigation
Melvyn Bragg
Melvyn Bragg criticised the trust’s behaviour in buying the land as ‘straight out of the mafia’. Photograph: Awakening/Getty Images
Melvyn Bragg criticised the trust’s behaviour in buying the land as ‘straight out of the mafia’. Photograph: Awakening/Getty Images

Melvyn Bragg accuses National Trust of bullying in farm row

This article is more than 7 years old

Broadcaster says charity’s ‘disgraceful purchase’ of land in Lake District could threaten rare breed of sheep

Broadcaster Melvyn Bragg has accused the National Trust of bullying after it acquired a piece of land in the Lake District that could threaten a farm that upholds an agricultural tradition going back thousands of years.

The charity last month bought Thorneythwaite Farm in Borrowdale, near Keswick, which has a flock of 413 Herdwick sheep, a rare breed that the author Beatrix Potter once helped save from extinction.

But the trust did not buy the farmhouse and there are now concerns about what will happen to the sheep, which are owned by the charity. The Times said its actions had upset residents of Borrowdale and farmers who had hoped to buy the house and land and keep it running as a working farm.

A Herdwick ram is prepared for showing at the annual Keswick Tup fair. Photograph: Christopher Thomond/The Guardian

Lord Bragg, a native of Cumbria, lambasted the trust’s actions, branding it a “disgraceful purchase” and a “nasty piece of work”, adding that its opening bid of £200,000 above the £750,000 guide price to put off other potential buyers was “straight out of the mafia”.

In a letter to the Times, he accused the National Trust of behaving badly and accused its director-general, Dame Helen Ghosh, of behaving “dictatorially”.

He said: “Had a billionaire bullied his way into this disgraceful purchase there would have been a deserved outcry.”

Bragg highlighted the Lake District’s historic farming system and rare native Herdwick sheep as being key to its nomination for recognition as a Unesco World Heritage site.

He said: “If the increasingly arrogant National Trust is there to protect anything of our past surely this is a prime example.”

He added: “The National Trust is about to destroy what centuries of working men and women have created. It used a shameful manoeuvre to achieve its aim. Who can check this bullying charity?”

A spokesman for the trust said it wanted the 303 acres of land for its value to wildlife, telling the Times: “We believe we can look after this land in a way that benefits nature, visitors and the local community.”

More on this story

More on this story

  • Theresa May condemns National Trust for axing 'Easter' from egg hunt

  • ‘The challenge is to provide for everyone’: the National Trust under fire

  • Teenage farmer attacks National Trust over Lake District land purchase

  • National Trust calls for complete reform of British farm subsidies

  • National Trust offers farm tenancy for £1 a year

  • Water voles to be reintroduced to England's highest lake

  • National Trust acquires Isle of Wight farmland that inspired Tennyson

Most viewed

Most viewed