What do you think?
Rate this book
Andy Carpenter #29
Dog Day Afternoon
Paterson, New Jersey’s favorite reluctant lawyer Andy Carpenter returns in Dog Day Afternoon, the next mystery in this fan favorite series from National Bestselling Author David Rosenfelt.
Retired lawyer Andy Carpenter has run the Tara Foundation—the dog rescue organization named after his beloved golden retriever—for years. It's always been his calling, even as Andy's pulled into representing clients in court. His investigator, Marcus Clark, has been at Andy's side for a long time. Even though they've known each other for years, Marcus keeps his personal life a mystery.
So it’s a shock when Marcus arrives at the Tara Foundation with two strangers in tow. Turns out Marcus takes disadvantaged young men under his wing, gets them jobs, a place to live, and a chance at a different life. And they want a dog. Andy’s specialty. One of the young men, Nick Williams, instantly falls in love with one of the dogs, Daisy.
When there’s a mass shooting at Nick’s work, leaving six dead, all signs point to Nick. Marcus, who's never asked Andy for anything, asks Andy for help. Despite Nick's troubled background, Andy trusts his friend and takes the case.
A Macmillan Audio production from Minotaur Books.
Retired lawyer Andy Carpenter has run the Tara Foundation—the dog rescue organization named after his beloved golden retriever—for years. It's always been his calling, even as Andy's pulled into representing clients in court. His investigator, Marcus Clark, has been at Andy's side for a long time. Even though they've known each other for years, Marcus keeps his personal life a mystery.
So it’s a shock when Marcus arrives at the Tara Foundation with two strangers in tow. Turns out Marcus takes disadvantaged young men under his wing, gets them jobs, a place to live, and a chance at a different life. And they want a dog. Andy’s specialty. One of the young men, Nick Williams, instantly falls in love with one of the dogs, Daisy.
When there’s a mass shooting at Nick’s work, leaving six dead, all signs point to Nick. Marcus, who's never asked Andy for anything, asks Andy for help. Despite Nick's troubled background, Andy trusts his friend and takes the case.
A Macmillan Audio production from Minotaur Books.
304 pages, Hardcover
First published July 2, 2024
About the author
David Rosenfelt
77 books2,578 followersI am a novelist with 27 dogs.
I have gotten to this dubious position with absolutely no planning, and at no stage in my life could I have predicted it. But here I am.
My childhood was relentlessly normal. The middle of three brothers, loving parents, a middle-class home in Paterson, New Jersey. We played sports, studied sporadically. laughed around the dinner table, and generally had a good time. By comparison, "Ozzie and Harriet's" clan seemed bizarre.
I graduated NYU, then decided to go into the movie business. I was stunningly brilliant at a job interview with my uncle, who was President of United Artists, and was immediately hired. It set me off on a climb up the executive ladder, culminating in my becoming President of Marketing for Tri-Star Pictures. The movie landscape is filled with the movies I buried; for every "Rambo", "The Natural" and "Rocky", there are countless disasters.
I did manage to find the time to marry and have two children, both of whom are doing very well, and fortunately neither have inherited my eccentricities.
A number of years ago, I left the movie marketing business, to the sustained applause of hundreds of disgruntled producers and directors. I decided to try my hand at writing. I wrote and sold a bunch of feature films, none of which ever came close to being actually filmed, and then a bunch of TV movies, some of which actually made it to the small screen. It's safe to say that their impact on the American cultural scene has been minimal.
About fourteen years ago, my wife and I started the Tara Foundation, named in honor of the greatest Golden Retriever the world has ever known. We rescued almost 4,000 dogs, many of them Goldens, and found them loving homes. Our own home quickly became a sanctuary for those dogs that we rescued that were too old or sickly to be wanted by others. They surround me as I write this. It's total lunacy, but it works, and they are a happy, safe group.
http://us.macmillan.com/author/davidr...
I have gotten to this dubious position with absolutely no planning, and at no stage in my life could I have predicted it. But here I am.
My childhood was relentlessly normal. The middle of three brothers, loving parents, a middle-class home in Paterson, New Jersey. We played sports, studied sporadically. laughed around the dinner table, and generally had a good time. By comparison, "Ozzie and Harriet's" clan seemed bizarre.
I graduated NYU, then decided to go into the movie business. I was stunningly brilliant at a job interview with my uncle, who was President of United Artists, and was immediately hired. It set me off on a climb up the executive ladder, culminating in my becoming President of Marketing for Tri-Star Pictures. The movie landscape is filled with the movies I buried; for every "Rambo", "The Natural" and "Rocky", there are countless disasters.
I did manage to find the time to marry and have two children, both of whom are doing very well, and fortunately neither have inherited my eccentricities.
A number of years ago, I left the movie marketing business, to the sustained applause of hundreds of disgruntled producers and directors. I decided to try my hand at writing. I wrote and sold a bunch of feature films, none of which ever came close to being actually filmed, and then a bunch of TV movies, some of which actually made it to the small screen. It's safe to say that their impact on the American cultural scene has been minimal.
About fourteen years ago, my wife and I started the Tara Foundation, named in honor of the greatest Golden Retriever the world has ever known. We rescued almost 4,000 dogs, many of them Goldens, and found them loving homes. Our own home quickly became a sanctuary for those dogs that we rescued that were too old or sickly to be wanted by others. They surround me as I write this. It's total lunacy, but it works, and they are a happy, safe group.
http://us.macmillan.com/author/davidr...
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 290 reviews
July 13, 2024
3.5 stars
In this 29th book in the Andy Carpenter series, the Paterson, New Jersey attorney represents a man accused of mass murder.
*****
Ever since he inherited a large fortune, defense lawyer Andy Carpenter takes very few cases.
Instead, Andy prefers to hang out with his wife Laurie, son Ricky, and dogs Tara (a golden retriever), Hunter (a pug), and Sebastian (a basset hound). Andy also likes to watch sports; help run a canine rescue operation called 'The Tara Foundation'; schmooze with his friends at Charlie's Sports Bar; and so on.
On the rare occasions Andy takes a case, he assembles his team, one of whom is private investigator Marcus Clark. Marcus is known for two traits: he's the toughest guy on the planet; and he doesn't talk much, usually just grunting and nodding.
Marcus has had Andy's back on innumerable occasions, so when Marcus speaks up and asks Andy to take a case, Andy agrees. It seems Marcus mentors young men who've gotten into trouble, and one of his 'wards', Nick Williams, is being accused of mass murder.
Nick, a handyman/cleaner, has been employed at a personal injury law firm called Moore Law. One day, when Nick is absent from work, a masked man walks into Moore Law and shoots six people.
Two survivors, a lawyer called Sally Montrose and a paralegal named Laura Schauble, say the killer resembled Nick, with a hook tattoo on his arm and distinctive striped sneakers.
When the murder weapon is found in a dumpster near Nick's home, with Nick's print on the gun, the police figure 'case closed.'
Nick's story is that he was abducted on the morning of the murder, and held in a room somewhere. Later, when the kidnappers released him, Nick was told to turn himself in to the police.
Andy knows the district attorney has a very strong case, and he'll have to hustle to prepare a compelling defense. So Andy assembles his squad. This consists of lawyer Eddie Dowd - who's great with paperwork and filings;
accountant Sam Willis - a computer hacker extraordinaire;
office manager Edna - who goofs off more than she works;
and The K-Team, a private detective firm consisting of Marcus Clark as well as other PIs, including:
Andy's wife Laurie, an ex-cop;
Corey Douglas, also an ex-cop, and Corey's police dog, Simon Garfunkel.
. This time, Sam Willis also recruits reinforcements for computer searches, an elderly couple called Eli and Hilda Mandelbaum. This is a real bonus because Hilda makes unbelievably great rugelach.
As Andy prepares Nick's case for court, he interviews the survivors at Moore Law; relatives of the victims; clients who got big personal injury settlements; and more.
Andy comes to suspect that Moore Law was a party to fraudulent claims, and it seems he might be right, because people start trying to kill him. Of course Andy eventually figures out what's going on.....but is it soon enough to save Nick?
The Andy Carpenter books are formulaic, but fun. Andy is a sarcastic quipster whose frequent wisecracks make him unpopular with cops, prosecutors, and judges, but VERY popular with fans of the series.
In one amusing passage, Andy - who's in the habit of discussing the case with his dog Tara - records this exchange:
" 'Tara, what do you think I should do?'
She turns towards me and gives her cute head tilt; no one tilts their head as cute as Tara. But she's giving me a message, she's saying, 'What are you asking me for? I told you not to take the case.'
I can't say I'm thrilled with her attitude, but Tara doesn't beat around the bush."
I always enjoy these cozy mysteries, and I'll keep reading them as long as David Rosenfelt keeps writing them.
Thanks to Netgalley, David Rosenfelt, and Minotaur books for a copy of the manuscript.
You can follow my reviews at https://reviewsbybarbsaffer.blogspot.com
February 18, 2024
Someone has entered a law office in Andy's hometown of Paterson, NJ and murdered several people. The blame falls on Nick, who is a friend of Marcus. Marcus has never asked Andy for anything, but he requests that Andy take Nick's case, which looks hopeless. Nick says he was kidnapped and held for several days, but doesn't know where, or by whom, which many find hard to believe. Andy has the whole team working on the case--Marcus, Corey, Laurie, Sam, Eddie, Eli, and Hilda. It's always such a pleasure to come back to this well-written series with great characters, a mystery to keep the reader guessing and, of course, dogs. Thanks to Edelweiss and the publisher for the opportunity to review this advance copy.
June 13, 2024
Another great installment! I was really happy with where this story took us. I was getting tired of the mafia links in this series and this story went in a different direction.
This has the typical banter, which is fun to listen to. I had the story mostly figured out, but not exactly. I was happy with missing a bit. I really did enjoy this one.
As usual, this can be read as a standalone, but you will miss out on the background of all the characters. It has been fun to watch them over time.
I listened to the audio, which is narrated by Grover Gardner. He is just perfect for the story and at this point I can't imagine Andy's voice any other way. If you have the opportunity to listen to the book, I would recommend it.
4.5 stars
Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for providing me with a complimentary electronic copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
This has the typical banter, which is fun to listen to. I had the story mostly figured out, but not exactly. I was happy with missing a bit. I really did enjoy this one.
As usual, this can be read as a standalone, but you will miss out on the background of all the characters. It has been fun to watch them over time.
I listened to the audio, which is narrated by Grover Gardner. He is just perfect for the story and at this point I can't imagine Andy's voice any other way. If you have the opportunity to listen to the book, I would recommend it.
4.5 stars
Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for providing me with a complimentary electronic copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
July 27, 2024
DOG DAY AFTERNOON is the twenty-ninth book in the Andy Carpenter series. For long time fans of the series, each book feels like a good old-fashion homecoming with lots of hugs, laughter and catching up on the latest family gossip. Series regulars - Marcus, Corey, Laurie, Sam, Eddie, Eli, Hilda, and the dogs - appear in significant roles in each book, working together like a well-oiled machine. And yet, for new readers to the series, each book stands alone with just enough background included to welcome you into the fold where you’ll enjoy a remarkable story. Chances are, once you read one, you'll join the fan club and come back for more.
A mass shooting at a law firm leaves six dead with two eyewitnesses making reluctant accusations against a fellow, well-liked employee, Nick Winter. The fact that Nick disappeared for several days during the time of the murders adds fuel to the prosecutor’s case against him. Marcus is a mentor to Nick and firmly declares his innocence to Andy as he asks Andy to defend him. It's well known that Andy’s a wealthy retired lawyer trying, with little luck, to remain retired and that he finds it impossible to turn down requests to take on cases when he believes the person is falsely accused - and therein lies the problem with Nick's case. Andy doesn't believe he has a snowball chance in the down yonder of proving Nick's innocence, but unable to refuse Marcus, he caves and accepts the case. With a lack of evidence to exonerate his client, Andy knows the only way to prove his innocence is to find the real killer, so Andy calls in his team and with Nick's court date looming closer, they roll up their sleeves, put on their detective hats and go in search of the truth.
Author David Rosenfelt's ability to continuously render fresh, engaging plot lines with complex cases, engaging characters and hilarious dialogue in fast-paced whodunnit's is a testament to his amazing ability as a storyteller. DOG DAY AFTERNOON is a delightful addition to the series with a heavy dose of courtroom drama, fraud, conspiracy, laugh aloud banter, family and lovable dogs to fawn over. Andy's long walks and talks with one of his dogs, Tara, are not to be missed nor are his visits to the dog rescue organization he started, Tara's Foundation.
DOG DAY AFTERNOON is a riveting, engrossing mystery with an abundance of heart. While there's a big side of lighthearted fun and humor woven throughout, to mistake this book and series for anything less than a tautly plotted, beautifully written mystery with an intriguing, complex murder mystery to be solved would be a mistake. Being a huge fan of audiobooks, I jumped at the chance to listen to this one. As always, narrator Grover Gardner gives a killer performance as he lends his voice to this iconic cast. In my eyes and ears, he IS Andy Carpenter!
DOG DAY AFTERNOON is a highly addictive, immersive mystery that's impossible to put down once you begin. Fans of mysteries and courtroom dramas will enjoy this one.
Many thanks to Minotaur Books & MacMillan Audio for an audiobook arc of this title. All opinions expressed are my own. This review first appeared in Mystery & Suspense Magazine and is also available on my blog Cross My Heart Reviews.
A mass shooting at a law firm leaves six dead with two eyewitnesses making reluctant accusations against a fellow, well-liked employee, Nick Winter. The fact that Nick disappeared for several days during the time of the murders adds fuel to the prosecutor’s case against him. Marcus is a mentor to Nick and firmly declares his innocence to Andy as he asks Andy to defend him. It's well known that Andy’s a wealthy retired lawyer trying, with little luck, to remain retired and that he finds it impossible to turn down requests to take on cases when he believes the person is falsely accused - and therein lies the problem with Nick's case. Andy doesn't believe he has a snowball chance in the down yonder of proving Nick's innocence, but unable to refuse Marcus, he caves and accepts the case. With a lack of evidence to exonerate his client, Andy knows the only way to prove his innocence is to find the real killer, so Andy calls in his team and with Nick's court date looming closer, they roll up their sleeves, put on their detective hats and go in search of the truth.
Author David Rosenfelt's ability to continuously render fresh, engaging plot lines with complex cases, engaging characters and hilarious dialogue in fast-paced whodunnit's is a testament to his amazing ability as a storyteller. DOG DAY AFTERNOON is a delightful addition to the series with a heavy dose of courtroom drama, fraud, conspiracy, laugh aloud banter, family and lovable dogs to fawn over. Andy's long walks and talks with one of his dogs, Tara, are not to be missed nor are his visits to the dog rescue organization he started, Tara's Foundation.
DOG DAY AFTERNOON is a riveting, engrossing mystery with an abundance of heart. While there's a big side of lighthearted fun and humor woven throughout, to mistake this book and series for anything less than a tautly plotted, beautifully written mystery with an intriguing, complex murder mystery to be solved would be a mistake. Being a huge fan of audiobooks, I jumped at the chance to listen to this one. As always, narrator Grover Gardner gives a killer performance as he lends his voice to this iconic cast. In my eyes and ears, he IS Andy Carpenter!
DOG DAY AFTERNOON is a highly addictive, immersive mystery that's impossible to put down once you begin. Fans of mysteries and courtroom dramas will enjoy this one.
Many thanks to Minotaur Books & MacMillan Audio for an audiobook arc of this title. All opinions expressed are my own. This review first appeared in Mystery & Suspense Magazine and is also available on my blog Cross My Heart Reviews.
June 7, 2024
Retired attorney Andy Carpenter insists he wants to stay that way, but somehow he keeps getting pulled back into court. This time, his trusted but somewhat reclusive investigator, Marcus Clark, asks for a favor - the only time in their long association that's happened. It seems that one of the young men Marcus has helped get on the straight and narrow - Nick Williams - has been identified as a mass murderer after six employees were brutally shot at the law firm where he's been working.
When Marcus gets a call from Nick, who's been missing, to say he was kidnapped on the day of the murders and spent several days tied up in some kind of warehouse before his kidnappers inexplicably set him free. Marcus then calls Andy, who really doesn't want any part of the case, but he can't say no to Marcus. Reluctantly, Andy gathers his super-competent team around him, including Marcus and Andy's ex-cop wife, Laurie Collins - and they begin to plot their strategy despite misgivings that include a couple of witnesses who are for the most part convinced that the man with the gun they saw was, in fact, Nick.
As usual, the story is narrated by Andy, who enjoys talking to his own dogs while taking them for walks. He's an extremely personable guy with a sense of humor and a penchant for acting up in the courtroomwith both adding a bit of fun to each adventure (and eliciting an occasional giggle from me). Since the motive attributed to Nick seems thin - and both he and Marcus are so insistent that Nick wasn't involved in any way - the team begins to look for another reason for the murders. As clues turn up, Andy shares them with readers (and I'll leave those reveals up to him, thank you very much) right up to the somewhat surprising conclusion.
Speaking of thank you very much, all that's left for me to say is that - to the publisher, via NetGalley - for giving me the opportunity to read and review a pre-release copy of another installment in a favorite series. Well done, as always!
When Marcus gets a call from Nick, who's been missing, to say he was kidnapped on the day of the murders and spent several days tied up in some kind of warehouse before his kidnappers inexplicably set him free. Marcus then calls Andy, who really doesn't want any part of the case, but he can't say no to Marcus. Reluctantly, Andy gathers his super-competent team around him, including Marcus and Andy's ex-cop wife, Laurie Collins - and they begin to plot their strategy despite misgivings that include a couple of witnesses who are for the most part convinced that the man with the gun they saw was, in fact, Nick.
As usual, the story is narrated by Andy, who enjoys talking to his own dogs while taking them for walks. He's an extremely personable guy with a sense of humor and a penchant for acting up in the courtroomwith both adding a bit of fun to each adventure (and eliciting an occasional giggle from me). Since the motive attributed to Nick seems thin - and both he and Marcus are so insistent that Nick wasn't involved in any way - the team begins to look for another reason for the murders. As clues turn up, Andy shares them with readers (and I'll leave those reveals up to him, thank you very much) right up to the somewhat surprising conclusion.
Speaking of thank you very much, all that's left for me to say is that - to the publisher, via NetGalley - for giving me the opportunity to read and review a pre-release copy of another installment in a favorite series. Well done, as always!
July 2, 2024
PUBLICATION DAY
Thank you St. Martin's Press - Minotaur Books for allowing me to read and review Dog Day Afternoon An Andy Carpenter Mystery on NetGalley.
Published: 07/02/24
Stars: 5
This is the 29th book in the series of which I have read only a handful randomly. I was introduced to Andy and the gang in last year's Christmas story. I am a fan. However, I am not able to binge read the series for every reason I love -- I find senseless in large doses -- the sense of humor and sketchy backgrounds and multiple personalities of the cast with the common denominator a love for dogs. This works for me 2-3 times a year; eventually I could read them all, eventually.
This installment was delightful. Of course there is murder, mayhem, laughs and family time.
There is also a warmth in the familiarity of the characters. This time they felt real.
I would gift these to young readers moving to adult books, grandparents, elderly, etc. I like that I could have read these out loud to residents in a nursing home.
Thank you St. Martin's Press - Minotaur Books for allowing me to read and review Dog Day Afternoon An Andy Carpenter Mystery on NetGalley.
Published: 07/02/24
Stars: 5
This is the 29th book in the series of which I have read only a handful randomly. I was introduced to Andy and the gang in last year's Christmas story. I am a fan. However, I am not able to binge read the series for every reason I love -- I find senseless in large doses -- the sense of humor and sketchy backgrounds and multiple personalities of the cast with the common denominator a love for dogs. This works for me 2-3 times a year; eventually I could read them all, eventually.
This installment was delightful. Of course there is murder, mayhem, laughs and family time.
There is also a warmth in the familiarity of the characters. This time they felt real.
I would gift these to young readers moving to adult books, grandparents, elderly, etc. I like that I could have read these out loud to residents in a nursing home.
June 28, 2024
This originally appeared at The Irresponsible Reader.
---
WHAT'S DOG DAY AFTERNOON ABOUT?
Overall, I'm not sure that the body count in this book is that much higher than in other books in this series—but the way it opens is very different. The instigating crime feels like something straight out of a mass-shooter video your HR people make you watch annually (assuming your workplace is similar to mine, I guess)—it's cold, calculated, with a casual disregard for human life we don't often see in this series. (Andy says something similar at one or two points).
So you're left wondering—how does Andy get roped into representing the accused? (although many readers are going to read that scene and pick out the places the defense is going to take advantage of). This is where Marcus comes in.
Andy learned about this earlier, but we readers learn about this now—Marcus mentors young people in his neighborhood who have had a rough time of it and have run afoul of the law in the past. They need some help, some guidance, and some favors—Marcus provides this.
He also helps a couple of those he mentors to adopt a dog from the Tara Foundation. One of these two is accused of the crime—Marcus comes to Andy for help, and he gets it. That Willie also vouches for the accused helps—there's no chance that Willie agrees to let one of their dogs go to someone capable of this crime.
That's not evidence he can introduce in court, but it's compelling for Andy. Now he just needs to find something that will be compelling in court.
MARCUS
Marcus can't become too well-rounded of a character—we need him in the shadows, doing things that defy belief. But we can learn more about him than we have prior to this.
We see that he can have attachments to people other than Laurie (and by extension, Andy). We see just how far he's willing to go to help someone.
I was interested in this book because I've enjoyed almost every one of its predecessors enough that I don't bother to see what they're about before I add them to the TBR list. But once I noted that this one featured Marcus like that—my excitement grew. I love watching the character at work, and to see him in a different situation than we're used to made my day. Also, we got just what the doctor ordered from a Marcus-centric book.
SO, WHAT DID I THINK ABOUT DOG DAY AFTERNOON?
I cannot believe that I've read 29 books in this series (plus a few in a spin-off). Twenty-nine. That's just insane. Now, am I going to say that they're all as fresh as they were in 2002 when Open and Shut came out? Of course not. But they have their moments when they feel that way.
* According to my logs, I read it in 2011—I've been with these characters for 13 years. Mind-boggling.
So, Rosenfelt has his work cut out for him to do something to keep the audience engaged. Over the last few books, he's worked on deepening the relationship between Andy and Marcus, which has been nice. This book takes a big step forward in that. I don't know that we're going to see much more than this anytime soon—you need to preserve some of Marcus' mystique to keep him nearly-superhuman in Andy's (and the reader's) eyes. Similarly, we readers can know Hawk a little better than when Spenser first ran into him in Promised Land—but not too much.
So, we'd better enjoy what we get here, right?
And naturally, that's really easy. Other fun bonuses—Andy getting along with the prosecutor. Cory clearly being annoyed with Sam Willis wanting to get in on the action. Even some of the Andy and Tara interactions felt a little different (not unusually so, and not negatively). There was also the attempt of a law firm to hire the most reluctant lawyer in the world—that did bring a smile to my face.
There's a good mix of the tried and true Andy bits, fun material with our old friends, a clever mystery, a new side of Marcus, and Rosenfelt's trademark zippy prose. It's easy to see why this series has gone on as long as it has—and may it continue to do so.
Can you hop on here? Absolutely—and you'll have the fun bonus of a healthy backlist to work your way through once you get done with this one.
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book from St. Martin's Press via NetGalley—thanks to both for this.
---
WHAT'S DOG DAY AFTERNOON ABOUT?
Overall, I'm not sure that the body count in this book is that much higher than in other books in this series—but the way it opens is very different. The instigating crime feels like something straight out of a mass-shooter video your HR people make you watch annually (assuming your workplace is similar to mine, I guess)—it's cold, calculated, with a casual disregard for human life we don't often see in this series. (Andy says something similar at one or two points).
So you're left wondering—how does Andy get roped into representing the accused? (although many readers are going to read that scene and pick out the places the defense is going to take advantage of). This is where Marcus comes in.
Andy learned about this earlier, but we readers learn about this now—Marcus mentors young people in his neighborhood who have had a rough time of it and have run afoul of the law in the past. They need some help, some guidance, and some favors—Marcus provides this.
He also helps a couple of those he mentors to adopt a dog from the Tara Foundation. One of these two is accused of the crime—Marcus comes to Andy for help, and he gets it. That Willie also vouches for the accused helps—there's no chance that Willie agrees to let one of their dogs go to someone capable of this crime.
That's not evidence he can introduce in court, but it's compelling for Andy. Now he just needs to find something that will be compelling in court.
MARCUS
Marcus can't become too well-rounded of a character—we need him in the shadows, doing things that defy belief. But we can learn more about him than we have prior to this.
We see that he can have attachments to people other than Laurie (and by extension, Andy). We see just how far he's willing to go to help someone.
I was interested in this book because I've enjoyed almost every one of its predecessors enough that I don't bother to see what they're about before I add them to the TBR list. But once I noted that this one featured Marcus like that—my excitement grew. I love watching the character at work, and to see him in a different situation than we're used to made my day. Also, we got just what the doctor ordered from a Marcus-centric book.
SO, WHAT DID I THINK ABOUT DOG DAY AFTERNOON?
I cannot believe that I've read 29 books in this series (plus a few in a spin-off). Twenty-nine. That's just insane. Now, am I going to say that they're all as fresh as they were in 2002 when Open and Shut came out? Of course not. But they have their moments when they feel that way.
* According to my logs, I read it in 2011—I've been with these characters for 13 years. Mind-boggling.
So, Rosenfelt has his work cut out for him to do something to keep the audience engaged. Over the last few books, he's worked on deepening the relationship between Andy and Marcus, which has been nice. This book takes a big step forward in that. I don't know that we're going to see much more than this anytime soon—you need to preserve some of Marcus' mystique to keep him nearly-superhuman in Andy's (and the reader's) eyes. Similarly, we readers can know Hawk a little better than when Spenser first ran into him in Promised Land—but not too much.
So, we'd better enjoy what we get here, right?
And naturally, that's really easy. Other fun bonuses—Andy getting along with the prosecutor. Cory clearly being annoyed with Sam Willis wanting to get in on the action. Even some of the Andy and Tara interactions felt a little different (not unusually so, and not negatively). There was also the attempt of a law firm to hire the most reluctant lawyer in the world—that did bring a smile to my face.
There's a good mix of the tried and true Andy bits, fun material with our old friends, a clever mystery, a new side of Marcus, and Rosenfelt's trademark zippy prose. It's easy to see why this series has gone on as long as it has—and may it continue to do so.
Can you hop on here? Absolutely—and you'll have the fun bonus of a healthy backlist to work your way through once you get done with this one.
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book from St. Martin's Press via NetGalley—thanks to both for this.
July 2, 2024
Dog Day Afternoon is the 29th installment in the long-standing Andy Carpenter series. And while this is my first novel from the series, I had no problems reading it as a standalone.
The novel follows main protagonist Andy Carpenter as he navigates his role as a defense attorney. There’s a lot of court procedural narrative so it does come across as long winded at times. However, it moves along nicely due to Carpenter’s snarky sense of humor which I enjoyed.
Because of the long-standing nature of the series, the characters didn’t come across as anyone noteworthy. I would probably have to read the earlier novels to get a feel for all of the characters. But for what it’s worth, I liked the main character, but I could have used more background information on the other players.
Though the novel appears to be a dog-centric series, the dogs play a very minor role in the story. But that’s okay since there was enough action to keep me engaged. And the surprising finale made for a great read. Four stars.
I received a DRC from St. Martin’s Press through NetGalley. This review is completely my own and reflects my honest thoughts and opinions.
The novel follows main protagonist Andy Carpenter as he navigates his role as a defense attorney. There’s a lot of court procedural narrative so it does come across as long winded at times. However, it moves along nicely due to Carpenter’s snarky sense of humor which I enjoyed.
Because of the long-standing nature of the series, the characters didn’t come across as anyone noteworthy. I would probably have to read the earlier novels to get a feel for all of the characters. But for what it’s worth, I liked the main character, but I could have used more background information on the other players.
Though the novel appears to be a dog-centric series, the dogs play a very minor role in the story. But that’s okay since there was enough action to keep me engaged. And the surprising finale made for a great read. Four stars.
I received a DRC from St. Martin’s Press through NetGalley. This review is completely my own and reflects my honest thoughts and opinions.
July 13, 2024
"Dog Day Afternoon" by David Rosenfelt is #29 in his Andy Carpenter series of cozy courtroom mysteries. It was my first book by this author. I followed it pretty well, so I can say it works as a stand-alone. It is a bit out of my preferred genres.
I recommend this book for readers who enjoy cozy mysteries, specifically with courtroom proceedings.
I liked the main character, defense attorney Andy Carpenter. The narrator for the audiobook is Grover Gardner, who does a great job voicing the main character and the others, as well.
This book features a mass murder in an office with two survivors who ID the shooter's voice, tattoo, and shoes. The suspect claims he was kidnapped and held at the time.
The title seems to be a misnomer because the dogs figure very little in this book other than Andy talking about the case to his dog, Tara, and the suspect's plan to adopt a dog before he was a suspect.
Characters - 4/5
Writing - 4/5
Plot - 4/5
Pacing - 3/5
Unputdownability - 2/5
Enjoyment - 3/5
Narration - 5/5
Cover - 4/5
Overall - 29/8 = 3 5/8 rounded up to 4 stars
Thank you to Netgalley, Macmillan Audio from Minotaur Books, and David Rosenfelt for providing this audiobook in exchange for my honest review.
I recommend this book for readers who enjoy cozy mysteries, specifically with courtroom proceedings.
I liked the main character, defense attorney Andy Carpenter. The narrator for the audiobook is Grover Gardner, who does a great job voicing the main character and the others, as well.
This book features a mass murder in an office with two survivors who ID the shooter's voice, tattoo, and shoes. The suspect claims he was kidnapped and held at the time.
The title seems to be a misnomer because the dogs figure very little in this book other than Andy talking about the case to his dog, Tara, and the suspect's plan to adopt a dog before he was a suspect.
Characters - 4/5
Writing - 4/5
Plot - 4/5
Pacing - 3/5
Unputdownability - 2/5
Enjoyment - 3/5
Narration - 5/5
Cover - 4/5
Overall - 29/8 = 3 5/8 rounded up to 4 stars
Thank you to Netgalley, Macmillan Audio from Minotaur Books, and David Rosenfelt for providing this audiobook in exchange for my honest review.
August 7, 2024
Andy Carpenter is back!
And, as usual, he’s not all that happy about it.
Andy wants to retire, but his wife and friends always manage to find him one more person in need of his criminal defense expertise. The crime this time is a tough one to solve. Andy and his investigative team will be scrambling to put all the pieces together.
The plot is entertaining and kept me guessing.
But Andy’s constant snarkiness and childish sarcasm is beginning to grate on me. I feel like there’s been zero character growth over the course of this series. And I miss the dogs. Didn’t they play a bigger part in the earlier books?
At any rate, this is a fun, light mystery that’s easy to read in an afternoon.
*I received a free copy from Minotaur Books.*
And, as usual, he’s not all that happy about it.
Andy wants to retire, but his wife and friends always manage to find him one more person in need of his criminal defense expertise. The crime this time is a tough one to solve. Andy and his investigative team will be scrambling to put all the pieces together.
The plot is entertaining and kept me guessing.
But Andy’s constant snarkiness and childish sarcasm is beginning to grate on me. I feel like there’s been zero character growth over the course of this series. And I miss the dogs. Didn’t they play a bigger part in the earlier books?
At any rate, this is a fun, light mystery that’s easy to read in an afternoon.
*I received a free copy from Minotaur Books.*
August 10, 2024
And a Dog Day Afternoon it is in steamy Florida!! Feels like is 115 degrees. A good time to enjoy Andy’s courtroom skills in the comfort of air conditioning. This 29th addition to the series had a much better plot than usual with a surprise baddy.
Marcus Clark had a leading roll this time. He has been described as a Neanderthal, the scariest person on the planet, and a fearless man with physical prowess. Not very flattering attributes. We know he has committed murder (when necessary) over the years. Is that why the author no longer identifies him as a Black Man?? I’ve always wondered about that.
Fifty percent of the book was taken verbatim from previously written accounts, but I still enjoy Andy’s antics.
My final note - in the 28 preceding episodes, all but 2, i think, have had a character named Daniel, or some deritive thereof. I asked Mr Rosenfelt if there was a reason - no he said!! Well, it wasn’t until the second to last page that Dani showed up this time. Yay. She is Corey’s girlfriend. Also, I happen to know that Dr Dowling’s first name is Daniel, even though it wasn’t indicated. So, even though Mr Rosenfelt says it doesn’t mean anything, I’m always glad when I come across a Dan. Ricky’s father was Danny and I remember a waiter with the same name. I think I’ve read too many of these books!!!
Marcus Clark had a leading roll this time. He has been described as a Neanderthal, the scariest person on the planet, and a fearless man with physical prowess. Not very flattering attributes. We know he has committed murder (when necessary) over the years. Is that why the author no longer identifies him as a Black Man?? I’ve always wondered about that.
Fifty percent of the book was taken verbatim from previously written accounts, but I still enjoy Andy’s antics.
My final note - in the 28 preceding episodes, all but 2, i think, have had a character named Daniel, or some deritive thereof. I asked Mr Rosenfelt if there was a reason - no he said!! Well, it wasn’t until the second to last page that Dani showed up this time. Yay. She is Corey’s girlfriend. Also, I happen to know that Dr Dowling’s first name is Daniel, even though it wasn’t indicated. So, even though Mr Rosenfelt says it doesn’t mean anything, I’m always glad when I come across a Dan. Ricky’s father was Danny and I remember a waiter with the same name. I think I’ve read too many of these books!!!
June 29, 2024
I've only recently discovered the Andy Carpenter mysteries even though this is the 29th book in the series! Andy is a defense lawyer that wants to retire, but can't turn down people who are falsely accused and need his legal help. Andy is also a dog lover and owns part of a dog rescue organization. He has a reliable team who help him with his cases, including his wife who is a former police officer.
In spite of the cute cover, I would classify the book as more of a traditional mystery with some elements of a legal thriller as opposed to a cozy mystery. In this book, as a favor for a friend, Andy defends a man accused of being a mass shooter at his place of employment. Nick has an explanation as to why he left the scene of the crime but insists he is innocent of this atrocious crime. The subject matter is intense, but Andy's sarcastic sense of humor helps lighten the mood. The plot gets very complicated, but the resolution is satisfying. I'm late to the party, but am happy to have found this series.
I received an advance copy of this ebook at no cost from NetGalley and Minotaur Books. My review is voluntary and unbiased.
In spite of the cute cover, I would classify the book as more of a traditional mystery with some elements of a legal thriller as opposed to a cozy mystery. In this book, as a favor for a friend, Andy defends a man accused of being a mass shooter at his place of employment. Nick has an explanation as to why he left the scene of the crime but insists he is innocent of this atrocious crime. The subject matter is intense, but Andy's sarcastic sense of humor helps lighten the mood. The plot gets very complicated, but the resolution is satisfying. I'm late to the party, but am happy to have found this series.
I received an advance copy of this ebook at no cost from NetGalley and Minotaur Books. My review is voluntary and unbiased.
June 5, 2024
Two reasons I keep coming back to this series – adorable covers and Grover Gardner as the narrator. It doesn’t even really matter what the mystery is. Wannabe-retired lawyer Andy Carpenter is called in to defend a dog lover who is accused of a crime they didn’t commit. Andy and his team find out who the real bad guy is. Andy’s client doesn’t end up in jail. This time around it’s a young man accused of killing 6 people at his workplace.
The plot is a bit complicated, but all of the regulars are back, human and canine, to help sort it out. Andy is his sarcastic, funny, in real life would be obnoxious but works well in fiction, self. As is often the case, the solution is bigger than I really like in my mysteries. I like more personal motives and less organized crime, but it’s not out of the ordinary for a Carpenter book and I do enjoy the characters and humor enough to make up for it.
The plot is a bit complicated, but all of the regulars are back, human and canine, to help sort it out. Andy is his sarcastic, funny, in real life would be obnoxious but works well in fiction, self. As is often the case, the solution is bigger than I really like in my mysteries. I like more personal motives and less organized crime, but it’s not out of the ordinary for a Carpenter book and I do enjoy the characters and humor enough to make up for it.
July 5, 2024
Wow, this was a unique story with twist and turns I didn’t see coming. A perpetrator walks into the Moore Law Firm and starts shooting and kills six employees. Nick is accused of the heinous crime and Marcus doesn’t think he’s guilty. Marcus coaxes his friend Andy, who is retired to defend him. Nick claims he was kidnapped, held captive, and told to call in and confess to this crime. Shocking revelations are revealed when Andy solves this crime. This is the only book that I have read in this series and it was very well done. Grover Gardner did an excellent job with the audio narration. This book was just published 7/2/24. Thank you @macmillan.audio for the ALC. #macaudio2024 #bestestbookclubever
May 18, 2024
Andy Carpenter book # 29
This mystery has a lot of legal aspect to it and a bit of court shenanigans but mostly is my preferred: the subdued humour that slips from time to time to make me smile. This author knows how to talk to us and tells stories in the first person narrative. Yes Andy whispered everything; he is totally in my head.....
Although this novel is part of a series it stands well on its two feet and can be read as a standalone with no trouble.
Although retired Andy carpenter runs a dog rescue organization for years his calling is representing clients in court. His long-time friend Marcus Clark is his sidekick who keeps his personal life to himself. Marcus takes disadvantage young men under his wings. So when Marcus needs Andy’s help no doubt he has it. Marcus friend Rick William is the prime suspect in the murder of 6 of his colleagues at work and needs all the help he can get...Springs into action, his our debonair lawyer....and we are into a very engaging mystery.
This mystery is witty, well-paced and filled with snappy one liner and to top it all amazing characters. The court room scenes are at a minimum but give the needed punch with all the legal verbalism...
“Dog day Afternoon”, makes it at the top of my best read list so far this year.
Excellent read I enjoyed passing time with.
I received this ARC from St Martin’s Press via Netgalley for my thoughts: this is the way I see it.
This mystery has a lot of legal aspect to it and a bit of court shenanigans but mostly is my preferred: the subdued humour that slips from time to time to make me smile. This author knows how to talk to us and tells stories in the first person narrative. Yes Andy whispered everything; he is totally in my head.....
Although this novel is part of a series it stands well on its two feet and can be read as a standalone with no trouble.
Although retired Andy carpenter runs a dog rescue organization for years his calling is representing clients in court. His long-time friend Marcus Clark is his sidekick who keeps his personal life to himself. Marcus takes disadvantage young men under his wings. So when Marcus needs Andy’s help no doubt he has it. Marcus friend Rick William is the prime suspect in the murder of 6 of his colleagues at work and needs all the help he can get...Springs into action, his our debonair lawyer....and we are into a very engaging mystery.
This mystery is witty, well-paced and filled with snappy one liner and to top it all amazing characters. The court room scenes are at a minimum but give the needed punch with all the legal verbalism...
“Dog day Afternoon”, makes it at the top of my best read list so far this year.
Excellent read I enjoyed passing time with.
I received this ARC from St Martin’s Press via Netgalley for my thoughts: this is the way I see it.
July 19, 2024
All of these are very good. This one may be the best. You think you've got it figured out before Andy...but then nope. The series is great for light, quick but high quality mysteries. You don't need to start at the beginning, but it always helps. Or, read this one and you will want to go back.
June 13, 2024
Dog Day Afternoon
Deceptions, lies and one man’s life hangs in the balance as someone enter Moore Law firm and methodically and tactfully kills 6 people leaving 2 alive but for how long. Andy Carpenter learns about the murders when Marcus his bodyguard and investigator asks him to defend the young person accused of committing the murders. Nick Williams is the suspect that he requests he defend with his team. Marcus takes in disadvantaged young men and mentors them even getting them jobs and housing. Nick went to the Tara Foundation to adopt a dog named Daisy. The mass shooting where he works sparks a fervor though out Andy’s office and life as Marcus finds Nick brings him to Andy and with the help of his friend Pete at the police department they bring him in, but this is just the beginning. Chapter one sets the terrifying scene in motion as you witness the deaths, hear the voice of the killer and the two left alive and behind. The media got hold of the murders and flashes Nicks name all over stating he’s the killer. Pete Stanton is the head of the Homicide Division of the Patterson Police Department and he and Andy have a friend/foe relationship. Sarcasm, humor, quips and sharp tongues reign when the team surfaces and their roles define. Nick was kidnapped and kept a darkened room for three days and released but hurt by his captors. Nick Williams is wrongly accused and hopefully won’t get to trial but there are many pieces and puzzles that the author through Andy need to be connected in the puzzles frame.
The team includes Marcus Clark, Eddie Dowd, Sam Willis, Corey Douglas Willie Miller Tara Foundation and Edna the non-working secretary and his wife Laurie. Each has a role and Andy oversees it all or he thinks so. The prosecutor is going to try the case himself and he and Andy meet to talk preliminaries. Steven Loomis is the new head of the law firm and things heat up fast. As Andy reflects on a short conversation with someone he learns that the killer called Sally Montrose , Monty and why was he spared and what about the other survivor.
Questioning witnesses and members of the deceased, Andy comes across the wife of Gerald Bullock and his death caused by malpractice given an antibiotic to which he was allergic. and yet his wife collects 2 million from the hospital’s insurance company and 95000 life insurance and does not appear to care about the outcome of his death plus Andy sees her with the man who’s the medical consultant for the law firm and was cited for prescriptions that were for digital opioids.
Events spiral out of control and then Andy and his team learn who one member of the kidnapping team was Ronald Wheeler and they form a plan to take him down, but Wheeler’s life ended by not being careful and calling those he thought were on his side.
Laura Schauble was the paralegal who worked for Moore Law and was helping Sally on a case. She described what she heard and saw then Russell was dead and Derek Shaffer the Dr who lost his license for writing those digital prescriptions of opioids and then claiming he’s a medical consultant. Charles Brisker was killed , one of the 6, meeting with Gerald Stoneham of Quantum Care the company that settled the Bullock case. Tempers fly and threats against Andy are hurled who Loomis and Shaffer are not happy he served him with a subpoena to testify.
The trial begins and the testimonies are straight forward while Andy has Laurie looking into two cases of malpractice that might be part of what he thinks is fraud as some of the people were paid full amount but in two instalments and part to the family and part to a third party . The missing money that Bullock did not get was wired to an untraceable account and many did not receive the amount due but were cheated or ripped off.
Some for hundreds of thousands of dollars. Then character witnesses and much more to come as a crucial decision is made regarding whether Nick should testify.
Fraud, murder, conspiracy and money that was not paid and the new owner of Moore Law ,Loomis at the top of the list and Andy determined to prove fraud and take him and the company down. As the defense begins to present its case Andy has a tough decision to make. Will Nick testify and is that the only way his story will be told?
Someone is calling all the shots and who is next to be eliminated how and why? Murders, fraud, conspiracy and deceptions Andy has yet to reveal all three players and the power running the show. Author David Roosevelt once again takes Andy through his paces but this time the volume is turned up, the witnesses are questioned and the killer or killer exposed how, why and wait for the ending only this author can create.
The final chapters will endear you more to Andy and of course Marcus as the hidden truths and lies about who set up Nick, how the emails were sent, the fraud, the conspiracy and the malpractice cases where people were shorted money. A surprise ending and a distinctive home for a precious dog.
Andy is at his best and Ricky saves the day. Dog Day Afternoon enjoy the fun.
Fran Lewis just reviews
Deceptions, lies and one man’s life hangs in the balance as someone enter Moore Law firm and methodically and tactfully kills 6 people leaving 2 alive but for how long. Andy Carpenter learns about the murders when Marcus his bodyguard and investigator asks him to defend the young person accused of committing the murders. Nick Williams is the suspect that he requests he defend with his team. Marcus takes in disadvantaged young men and mentors them even getting them jobs and housing. Nick went to the Tara Foundation to adopt a dog named Daisy. The mass shooting where he works sparks a fervor though out Andy’s office and life as Marcus finds Nick brings him to Andy and with the help of his friend Pete at the police department they bring him in, but this is just the beginning. Chapter one sets the terrifying scene in motion as you witness the deaths, hear the voice of the killer and the two left alive and behind. The media got hold of the murders and flashes Nicks name all over stating he’s the killer. Pete Stanton is the head of the Homicide Division of the Patterson Police Department and he and Andy have a friend/foe relationship. Sarcasm, humor, quips and sharp tongues reign when the team surfaces and their roles define. Nick was kidnapped and kept a darkened room for three days and released but hurt by his captors. Nick Williams is wrongly accused and hopefully won’t get to trial but there are many pieces and puzzles that the author through Andy need to be connected in the puzzles frame.
The team includes Marcus Clark, Eddie Dowd, Sam Willis, Corey Douglas Willie Miller Tara Foundation and Edna the non-working secretary and his wife Laurie. Each has a role and Andy oversees it all or he thinks so. The prosecutor is going to try the case himself and he and Andy meet to talk preliminaries. Steven Loomis is the new head of the law firm and things heat up fast. As Andy reflects on a short conversation with someone he learns that the killer called Sally Montrose , Monty and why was he spared and what about the other survivor.
Questioning witnesses and members of the deceased, Andy comes across the wife of Gerald Bullock and his death caused by malpractice given an antibiotic to which he was allergic. and yet his wife collects 2 million from the hospital’s insurance company and 95000 life insurance and does not appear to care about the outcome of his death plus Andy sees her with the man who’s the medical consultant for the law firm and was cited for prescriptions that were for digital opioids.
Events spiral out of control and then Andy and his team learn who one member of the kidnapping team was Ronald Wheeler and they form a plan to take him down, but Wheeler’s life ended by not being careful and calling those he thought were on his side.
Laura Schauble was the paralegal who worked for Moore Law and was helping Sally on a case. She described what she heard and saw then Russell was dead and Derek Shaffer the Dr who lost his license for writing those digital prescriptions of opioids and then claiming he’s a medical consultant. Charles Brisker was killed , one of the 6, meeting with Gerald Stoneham of Quantum Care the company that settled the Bullock case. Tempers fly and threats against Andy are hurled who Loomis and Shaffer are not happy he served him with a subpoena to testify.
The trial begins and the testimonies are straight forward while Andy has Laurie looking into two cases of malpractice that might be part of what he thinks is fraud as some of the people were paid full amount but in two instalments and part to the family and part to a third party . The missing money that Bullock did not get was wired to an untraceable account and many did not receive the amount due but were cheated or ripped off.
Some for hundreds of thousands of dollars. Then character witnesses and much more to come as a crucial decision is made regarding whether Nick should testify.
Fraud, murder, conspiracy and money that was not paid and the new owner of Moore Law ,Loomis at the top of the list and Andy determined to prove fraud and take him and the company down. As the defense begins to present its case Andy has a tough decision to make. Will Nick testify and is that the only way his story will be told?
Someone is calling all the shots and who is next to be eliminated how and why? Murders, fraud, conspiracy and deceptions Andy has yet to reveal all three players and the power running the show. Author David Roosevelt once again takes Andy through his paces but this time the volume is turned up, the witnesses are questioned and the killer or killer exposed how, why and wait for the ending only this author can create.
The final chapters will endear you more to Andy and of course Marcus as the hidden truths and lies about who set up Nick, how the emails were sent, the fraud, the conspiracy and the malpractice cases where people were shorted money. A surprise ending and a distinctive home for a precious dog.
Andy is at his best and Ricky saves the day. Dog Day Afternoon enjoy the fun.
Fran Lewis just reviews
May 20, 2024
Another doggoned good Andy Carpenter case
When Marcus Clark asks reluctant lawyer Andy Carpenter to defend a young friend who is accused of invading the law office where he is employed and shooting six people to death, there is no way that Andy is going to turn down a request from Marcus, who is his employee, good buddy, and, by the way, savior of Andy’s life on several occasions. It also doesn’t hurt that the accused was in the process of adopting an injured dog from the dog rescue operation that Andy founded. Things do not look good for the defendant, though, since he was positively identified by a surviving employee of the firm based on a distinctive tattoo and tennis shoes, although the murderer was wearing a mask. Of course, as Andy looks into the case, things are not as straightforward as they might seem, nor are these the last murders that will occur.
The plot was interesting and sneaky, and Andy’s personality shone as always, but there were a few points that seemed a LITTLE unlikely to me. I also am not sure how I felt about the clever ending, which gave me a big smile and an equally big frown in the space of the last two pages.
But Andy Carpenter’s personality (and the dogs) is, I believe, the reason this series is so popular. Narrator Andy is up to his usual form, giving me my first chuckle in paragraph three. Despite Andy’s sassy humor, his team, which includes his wife Laurie, a former cop, is composed of people who care, and another hallmark feature of the series is the warmth and humanity of the characters. Other team members include Eddie Dowd, who, Andy says ,”is a calming influence on me, which is surprising when you consider that in his previous life he was a tight end for the New York Giants, ” ex-cop Corey Booker, and Marcus. Andy also gets up to his usual courtroom antics.
You can enjoy this book even if you have not read anything else in the series, but I highly recommend you begin with the first, Open and Shut, so you get the context and a proper introduction to the characters (and they ARE characters!). After that, you can enjoy them in any order.
I received an advance review copy of this book from NetGalley and Minotaur Books.
When Marcus Clark asks reluctant lawyer Andy Carpenter to defend a young friend who is accused of invading the law office where he is employed and shooting six people to death, there is no way that Andy is going to turn down a request from Marcus, who is his employee, good buddy, and, by the way, savior of Andy’s life on several occasions. It also doesn’t hurt that the accused was in the process of adopting an injured dog from the dog rescue operation that Andy founded. Things do not look good for the defendant, though, since he was positively identified by a surviving employee of the firm based on a distinctive tattoo and tennis shoes, although the murderer was wearing a mask. Of course, as Andy looks into the case, things are not as straightforward as they might seem, nor are these the last murders that will occur.
The plot was interesting and sneaky, and Andy’s personality shone as always, but there were a few points that seemed a LITTLE unlikely to me. I also am not sure how I felt about the clever ending, which gave me a big smile and an equally big frown in the space of the last two pages.
But Andy Carpenter’s personality (and the dogs) is, I believe, the reason this series is so popular. Narrator Andy is up to his usual form, giving me my first chuckle in paragraph three. Despite Andy’s sassy humor, his team, which includes his wife Laurie, a former cop, is composed of people who care, and another hallmark feature of the series is the warmth and humanity of the characters. Other team members include Eddie Dowd, who, Andy says ,”is a calming influence on me, which is surprising when you consider that in his previous life he was a tight end for the New York Giants, ” ex-cop Corey Booker, and Marcus. Andy also gets up to his usual courtroom antics.
You can enjoy this book even if you have not read anything else in the series, but I highly recommend you begin with the first, Open and Shut, so you get the context and a proper introduction to the characters (and they ARE characters!). After that, you can enjoy them in any order.
I received an advance review copy of this book from NetGalley and Minotaur Books.
March 17, 2024
The only thing sadder than waiting for a new Andy Carpenter book is reaching the end of an Andy Carpenter book. “Dog Day Afternoon” does not disappoint. This time around, Andy is asked by Marcus Clark to defend Marcus’s friend, Nick, who is accused of committing a heinous mass murder at a local legal firm. Of course, we know from the outset that Nick is innocent and that he is a dog lover, so no surprise there. As with any Andy Carpenter book, the fun is in watching Andy get to the bottom of it all. From the legal offices, to insurance agencies, to hospitals, to Chicago crime lords, it’s all here. All of our old friends are accounted for, most importantly, Tara. I fear the day when Tara becomes too old to keep Andy in line. That will never happen as I’m sure that Tara, like my own dog, has promised to live for at least 20 years. Seriously, as a devout fan of David Rosenfelt’s books, this is a worthy addition. I will even go so far as to say that when the audiobook is released, Grover Gardner and I will have a date. Just don’t tell my husband. Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for the advanced copy in return for my honest review.
July 8, 2024
Rounded up to 5 for Goodreads
Dog Day Afternoon- David Rosenfelt
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫 4.5/5
Wow-this fast paced crime mystery, Dog Day Afternoon is my first book by author David Rosenfelt and I absolutely enjoyed it!
This book was published July 2, 2024. Thank you Minotaur Books for this advance copy.
Synopsis-
Andy Carpenter is trying to retire and when he does practice law, he only likes to take cases where he knows and believes the client is innocent. On the request of his friend Marcus Clark, who has protected Andy quite effectively in the past, Andy agrees to take the case of an accused mass killer, Nick Williams, who Marcus assures him is innocent. Was this young kid set up like he claims ? But the bigger question is can Andy verify and prove it ?
While he’s a new author to me, Rosenfelt has written many books. Dog Day Afternoon is part of the Andy Carpenter series, but I didn’t feel that not having read the other books in the series interfered in my enjoyment. I’ll definitely look for other books in this series and by David Rosenfelt.
Dog Day Afternoon- David Rosenfelt
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫 4.5/5
Wow-this fast paced crime mystery, Dog Day Afternoon is my first book by author David Rosenfelt and I absolutely enjoyed it!
This book was published July 2, 2024. Thank you Minotaur Books for this advance copy.
Synopsis-
Andy Carpenter is trying to retire and when he does practice law, he only likes to take cases where he knows and believes the client is innocent. On the request of his friend Marcus Clark, who has protected Andy quite effectively in the past, Andy agrees to take the case of an accused mass killer, Nick Williams, who Marcus assures him is innocent. Was this young kid set up like he claims ? But the bigger question is can Andy verify and prove it ?
While he’s a new author to me, Rosenfelt has written many books. Dog Day Afternoon is part of the Andy Carpenter series, but I didn’t feel that not having read the other books in the series interfered in my enjoyment. I’ll definitely look for other books in this series and by David Rosenfelt.
June 30, 2024
This was great cozy mystery with a case that Andy takes with Nick who is accused on a shooting at his workplace. I wasn't too sure how the story was gonna take us to prove Nick's innocence and I enjoyed how it unfolded.
I have only read another book in this series and that one, the dogs played a role in the story whereas this one really dogs weren't much part of it.
Grover Gardner did a great job with the narration and kept me interested in the mystery.
Thank you @minotaur_books @macmillan.audio @netgalley for a copy of this book.
I have only read another book in this series and that one, the dogs played a role in the story whereas this one really dogs weren't much part of it.
Grover Gardner did a great job with the narration and kept me interested in the mystery.
Thank you @minotaur_books @macmillan.audio @netgalley for a copy of this book.
May 31, 2024
This was an easy and quick read. A light hearted cozy type mystery with dogs 🐕. Great palate cleanser between reads. I enjoyed the narration and thought it was perfect for Andy's character. This wasn't my first Rosenfelt novel, and I still enjoyed it, but it did have a bit more language than I remember in other books. It wasn't a ton, but there was enough to make me stop and think about the others I've read. Thank you, NetGalley and MacMillan Audio, for the opportunity to listen and review this advanced copy.
August 30, 2024
A shooter takes out the six people left working in a law office late on a Friday. Two people escaped but are witnesses. They describe Nick Williams as the shooter. But Andy Carpenter is determined to prove his client’s innocence despite all the evidence against Nick. A clean read legal mystery with rescue dogs in the mix. I always enjoy reading about the antics of the sarcastically witty Andy Carpenter and his team of investigators as they try to make sure justice is done right.
June 4, 2024
Thank you @minotaurbooks for the ARC of Dog Day Afternoon. I really enjoyed it from start to finish.
The main character, Andy Carpenter who is a retired lawyer was hysterical through out the story. Even though he was trying to find out who gunned down six individuals at a law office, his humor was on point. I appreciated the recap Andy did about everything we learned so far in the middle of the book. It helped organize my brain with all of the facts. I really enjoyed this murder investigation and how it all came together in the end. Marcus Clark was a nice touch in this story and I laughed everytime he was mentioned. The story flowed together nicely and I enjoyed the writing style. This was my first book by this author and I would definitely read more books by David Rosenfelt.
The main character, Andy Carpenter who is a retired lawyer was hysterical through out the story. Even though he was trying to find out who gunned down six individuals at a law office, his humor was on point. I appreciated the recap Andy did about everything we learned so far in the middle of the book. It helped organize my brain with all of the facts. I really enjoyed this murder investigation and how it all came together in the end. Marcus Clark was a nice touch in this story and I laughed everytime he was mentioned. The story flowed together nicely and I enjoyed the writing style. This was my first book by this author and I would definitely read more books by David Rosenfelt.
July 4, 2024
I'm glad that Rosenfelt moved away from Andy stopping terror attacks and back to good old fashioned murder.
I figured out reasonably early who was involved and some of the motivation but I didn't figure it all out until "Andy" explained it. I enjoyed listening to this one so much that I even finished the book at the gym, a thing I rarely do (too many distractions there).
I figured out reasonably early who was involved and some of the motivation but I didn't figure it all out until "Andy" explained it. I enjoyed listening to this one so much that I even finished the book at the gym, a thing I rarely do (too many distractions there).
May 30, 2024
I love these books. Andy Carpenter keeps me entertained. We get to know all his thoughts and some are quite humorous. What a team he has put together! I would definitely go to him if I had a situation that would call for that action. I would love to have Marcus for a friend. I can’t wait to see what Andy and friends get involved in next. I received this book from NetGalley, but my opinion is my own.
July 4, 2024
I always enjoy listening to this series. Great escape and funny.
July 5, 2024
So sad that now I've finished the latest installment and will now have to wait for the next one.
August 12, 2024
When a new Andy Carpenter book is released, I just have to read it. It was pretty good, and it did have a different ending than all the other books, which was a nice change.
August 31, 2024
Excellent book, as always this series does not disappoint
Displaying 1 - 30 of 290 reviews