What do you think?
Rate this book
The Singing Hills Cycle #3
Into the Riverlands
Wandering cleric Chih of the Singing Hills travels to the riverlands to record tales of the notorious near-immortal martial artists who haunt the region. On the road to Betony Docks, they fall in with a pair of young women far from home, and an older couple who are more than they seem. As Chih runs headlong into an ancient feud, they find themselves far more entangled in the history of the riverlands than they ever expected to be.
Accompanied by Almost Brilliant, a talking bird with an indelible memory, Chih confronts old legends and new dangers alike as they learn that every story—beautiful, ugly, kind, or cruel—bears more than one face.
Accompanied by Almost Brilliant, a talking bird with an indelible memory, Chih confronts old legends and new dangers alike as they learn that every story—beautiful, ugly, kind, or cruel—bears more than one face.
100 pages, Hardcover
First published October 25, 2022
About the author
Nghi Vo
37 books3,682 followersNghi Vo is the author of the acclaimed novellas The Empress of Salt and Fortune and When the Tiger Came Down the Mountain. Born in Illinois, she now lives on the shores of Lake Michigan. She believes in the ritual of lipstick, the power of stories, and the right to change your mind. The Chosen and the Beautiful is her debut novel.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,452 reviews
October 19, 2022
I liked this so much I'm going to go read again. Brb.
The third installment in a series of novellas that loosely centers on Chih, a disciple of The Singing Hills monastery in China, which collects stories. Any and all stories, traveling the land with their neixin bird, Almost Brilliant, who has eidetic memory and serves as a living story repository. They've come to the riverlands to seek new stories.
"The whole world talks about the martial legends that come out of the riverlands, and I would like to see what the riverlands might want to say if they were asked."
Character development is perfect for a novella length story, giving us insights into travelers Chih and Absolute Brilliance meet on their journey. They meet the young women Wei Jintai and Mac Sang in an inn when they stop for lunch, and are soon joined by the middle-aged couple Lao Bingyi and her husband Khanh. Chih's plays a larger role in this book, not just guiding story collection, and I found I enjoyed the moments the narrative focused on them.
"They weren't brave, and despite the shaved head and the indigo robes, they weren't particularly virtuous, but more than anything else, they were curious, and sometimes that could stand in for the rest."
Chih's development builds nice layering into the meaning of Into the Riverlands and about how stories are both historical and living; that even as we are the audience for stories, meaning is different on perspective; stories are also lived, and in fact, one may be part of a living story right now.
"'Sometimes you get told about it,' they said thoughtfully. 'Maybe you get told about it two or three times, and you just don't know what you're hearing.'"
There's also the story-within-a-story device, and those shorter pieces are equally well developed.
Really, it's an intriguing little tale that I wanted to go on and on. It reminds me quite a bit of Bridge of Birds, with less silliness, more gravitas. It also reminded me just a little of The Steerswoman, which also contains a community of people devoted to collected knowledge by travelling throughout the land. Highly recommended. This is a series that would be a delightful addition to have in hardcover for my library.
Many, many thanks to NetGalley and Tor/Forge Publishing Group for the ARC. Of course, all opinions are my own. Of course, all quotes are subject to change in the final edition, but they do give a flavor of the lovely writing style.
The third installment in a series of novellas that loosely centers on Chih, a disciple of The Singing Hills monastery in China, which collects stories. Any and all stories, traveling the land with their neixin bird, Almost Brilliant, who has eidetic memory and serves as a living story repository. They've come to the riverlands to seek new stories.
"The whole world talks about the martial legends that come out of the riverlands, and I would like to see what the riverlands might want to say if they were asked."
Character development is perfect for a novella length story, giving us insights into travelers Chih and Absolute Brilliance meet on their journey. They meet the young women Wei Jintai and Mac Sang in an inn when they stop for lunch, and are soon joined by the middle-aged couple Lao Bingyi and her husband Khanh. Chih's plays a larger role in this book, not just guiding story collection, and I found I enjoyed the moments the narrative focused on them.
"They weren't brave, and despite the shaved head and the indigo robes, they weren't particularly virtuous, but more than anything else, they were curious, and sometimes that could stand in for the rest."
Chih's development builds nice layering into the meaning of Into the Riverlands and about how stories are both historical and living; that even as we are the audience for stories, meaning is different on perspective; stories are also lived, and in fact, one may be part of a living story right now.
"'Sometimes you get told about it,' they said thoughtfully. 'Maybe you get told about it two or three times, and you just don't know what you're hearing.'"
There's also the story-within-a-story device, and those shorter pieces are equally well developed.
Really, it's an intriguing little tale that I wanted to go on and on. It reminds me quite a bit of Bridge of Birds, with less silliness, more gravitas. It also reminded me just a little of The Steerswoman, which also contains a community of people devoted to collected knowledge by travelling throughout the land. Highly recommended. This is a series that would be a delightful addition to have in hardcover for my library.
Many, many thanks to NetGalley and Tor/Forge Publishing Group for the ARC. Of course, all opinions are my own. Of course, all quotes are subject to change in the final edition, but they do give a flavor of the lovely writing style.
September 23, 2023
This was lovely. Just lovely. Understated, calm and quiet, and has that something that leaves me wonderfully content.
As always in this series, this is a story about stories, about how legends are made and how life turns into them, and what gets left by the wayside.
I loved the first novella in this loosely connected series about a traveling cleric who collects stories of the land, and was not moved much by the second, but this one made up for what the previous one lacked. It didn’t overdose on folksy poetic language, it kept the mystic undertones somehow grounded, and seemed more like a calm adventure (no, it’s not an oxymoron, I swear) than a take on a fairytale (fairytale retellings for me tend to be more miss than hit, but a road adventure with a legend undertone is apparently just fine).
I can’t let my review become longer than this short novella, so let’s just sum up: it’s lovely and I’m glad I’ve read it. No, it’s not my favorite Hugo’s contender (that would be Adrian Tchaikovsky’s Ogres) but it’s very good and it left me content, which is wonderful as far as I’m concerned.
4.5 stars, rounding up.
——————
Also posted on my blog.
“Sometimes you get told about it,” they said thoughtfully. “Maybe you get told about it two or three times, and you just don’t know what you’re hearing.”
As always in this series, this is a story about stories, about how legends are made and how life turns into them, and what gets left by the wayside.
“I’ll remember that I was terrified, Chih thought. I’ll remember what it was like to see a battle between people who don’t fight like people, who are what legends come from.”
I loved the first novella in this loosely connected series about a traveling cleric who collects stories of the land, and was not moved much by the second, but this one made up for what the previous one lacked. It didn’t overdose on folksy poetic language, it kept the mystic undertones somehow grounded, and seemed more like a calm adventure (no, it’s not an oxymoron, I swear) than a take on a fairytale (fairytale retellings for me tend to be more miss than hit, but a road adventure with a legend undertone is apparently just fine).
“The world is built on who carries what and for who,” Chih said, settling the weight more comfortably on their shoulders. “It’s not a bad world where we carry presents for people who feed us.”
I can’t let my review become longer than this short novella, so let’s just sum up: it’s lovely and I’m glad I’ve read it. No, it’s not my favorite Hugo’s contender (that would be Adrian Tchaikovsky’s Ogres) but it’s very good and it left me content, which is wonderful as far as I’m concerned.
4.5 stars, rounding up.
——————
Also posted on my blog.
January 21, 2024
We are back again with cleric Chih of the Singing Hills as they traverse the Riverlands in quest of new tales to share and as I delve into Vo's repertoire, expecting a familiar rhythm — this book surprises me with a refreshing departure of mood and and explores the essence of storytelling itself.
Vo's writing is beautifully lyrical — that, I have come to terms with when reading her works and this book is no different as she consistently paints vivid images of the Riverlands, drawing readers into its enchanting world. This novella provides a comforting read, delivering a powerful message in which I value the exploration of themes such as the shaping of history, the significance of stories, and their evolution over time; shedding light on their transformation amidst changing cultures, traditions, and beliefs.
Regrettably, the narrative predominantly centers on the concept of storytelling rather than a robust plot that it lacks clear direction and cohesiveness. To fan the flames, the characters — which I initially found challenging to understand, maintain an underdeveloped nature. Despite their potential for depth and complexity, the elusive nature of their gains impedes a full emotional connection, leaving a prevailing sense of detachment throughout the reading experience.
While this is not a standout entry in Vo's body of work, this book unmistakably reveals moments of brilliance. Vo's adeptness in creating enchanting imagery and exploring themes introduces thought-provoking elements, challenging readers to reflect on their own stories — considering how some of us shape our lives in the pursuit of recreating inherited narratives. Even with its flaws, the book offers a dose of beauty and introspection, catering to readers in search of a contemplative and atmospheric fantasy journey within the realms of Vo's storytelling.
Fortunately, the disjointed nature of these installments prevents any off-note from disrupting a larger narrative, and it did not deter me to continue enjoying the overall venture. However, I wouldn't say this particular outing is the pinnacle of Chih's saga.
"Not all stories are worth telling, cleric.”
"But it would be your story, it would be the truth. Wouldn't that be better than—"
“What my story is, cleric, is mine. You have the rest, and you’ll tell the rest. Be happy with that. My story’s mine, and you don’t get to have it.”
Vo's writing is beautifully lyrical — that, I have come to terms with when reading her works and this book is no different as she consistently paints vivid images of the Riverlands, drawing readers into its enchanting world. This novella provides a comforting read, delivering a powerful message in which I value the exploration of themes such as the shaping of history, the significance of stories, and their evolution over time; shedding light on their transformation amidst changing cultures, traditions, and beliefs.
Regrettably, the narrative predominantly centers on the concept of storytelling rather than a robust plot that it lacks clear direction and cohesiveness. To fan the flames, the characters — which I initially found challenging to understand, maintain an underdeveloped nature. Despite their potential for depth and complexity, the elusive nature of their gains impedes a full emotional connection, leaving a prevailing sense of detachment throughout the reading experience.
While this is not a standout entry in Vo's body of work, this book unmistakably reveals moments of brilliance. Vo's adeptness in creating enchanting imagery and exploring themes introduces thought-provoking elements, challenging readers to reflect on their own stories — considering how some of us shape our lives in the pursuit of recreating inherited narratives. Even with its flaws, the book offers a dose of beauty and introspection, catering to readers in search of a contemplative and atmospheric fantasy journey within the realms of Vo's storytelling.
Fortunately, the disjointed nature of these installments prevents any off-note from disrupting a larger narrative, and it did not deter me to continue enjoying the overall venture. However, I wouldn't say this particular outing is the pinnacle of Chih's saga.
November 1, 2022
The Empress of Salt and Fortune ★★★★★
When the Tiger Came Down the Mountain ★★★★★
2022 has truly just been the year of me devouring and loving all things by nghi vo, and this third installment was no different. i am very in love with cleric chih and their bird companion. i love seeing them pass through new parts in their journey and being told new stories. this entire series is truly a love letter to the power of stories and how they can be healing, escapism, comfort, knowledge, and remembering and retaining your history that would be rewritten and forgotten. but this installment has an extra emphasis on the power of remembering our past, too. while also the power of community and the power of preserving your communities stories.
and also good discussions on even within your communities, which stories are deemed more worthy of remembrance. and if those things could be based on the beauty and youth of the stars of the story.
i truly cant wait to see where this story goes next, and i'd follow chih through all the past and present adventures to come. i hope tor releases these forever. happy halloween, friends!
tw/cw: harassment leading to physical altercation, blood mention/depiction, murder, death, gore, violence, abandonment, and dead body descriptions. (some very brief mentions in the stories in this book of: kidnapping, assault, mention of what could be thought of as cannibalism.)
Blog | Instagram | Youtube | Ko-fi | Spotify | Twitch
When the Tiger Came Down the Mountain ★★★★★
"The world is built on who carries what and for who"
2022 has truly just been the year of me devouring and loving all things by nghi vo, and this third installment was no different. i am very in love with cleric chih and their bird companion. i love seeing them pass through new parts in their journey and being told new stories. this entire series is truly a love letter to the power of stories and how they can be healing, escapism, comfort, knowledge, and remembering and retaining your history that would be rewritten and forgotten. but this installment has an extra emphasis on the power of remembering our past, too. while also the power of community and the power of preserving your communities stories.
and also good discussions on even within your communities, which stories are deemed more worthy of remembrance. and if those things could be based on the beauty and youth of the stars of the story.
i truly cant wait to see where this story goes next, and i'd follow chih through all the past and present adventures to come. i hope tor releases these forever. happy halloween, friends!
tw/cw: harassment leading to physical altercation, blood mention/depiction, murder, death, gore, violence, abandonment, and dead body descriptions. (some very brief mentions in the stories in this book of: kidnapping, assault, mention of what could be thought of as cannibalism.)
Blog | Instagram | Youtube | Ko-fi | Spotify | Twitch
November 30, 2022
this series is doing more with less than 99% of YA fantasy novels.
sure, this was my least favorite so far, but these books rule. they tend to be action-packed and thematically rich and the characters are badass and the world is sick as hell.
it did feel like there was less going on both behind the scenes and, you know, in them, but still.
i eagerly await the next one.
bottom line: am i losing my hater tendencies??
3.5
---------------
currently reading updates
nghi vo hive we are eating today!!!
(thanks to netgalley for the e-arc)
---------------
tbr review
feels actually rude that this isn't out yet. and maybe intended to hurt my feelings, personally.
sure, this was my least favorite so far, but these books rule. they tend to be action-packed and thematically rich and the characters are badass and the world is sick as hell.
it did feel like there was less going on both behind the scenes and, you know, in them, but still.
i eagerly await the next one.
bottom line: am i losing my hater tendencies??
3.5
---------------
currently reading updates
nghi vo hive we are eating today!!!
(thanks to netgalley for the e-arc)
---------------
tbr review
feels actually rude that this isn't out yet. and maybe intended to hurt my feelings, personally.
December 21, 2022
I can’t believe I missed that this had come out. I saw a friend had reviewed it and I literally stopped what I was doing and drove to a bookstore to track it down. I gave the first two books 5/5 stars and declared them both amazing reads and the fact that I missed reading this the day it came out was a massive disappointment (in myself, not the book).
Well, now I’ve read it. All is right with the world again and I can give an assessment. So, is it another perfect masterpiece?
…
I’m sorry to report back that no, in my opinion it is not. Now hold on a moment though, that’s not to say it isn’t good! It is. Very good. In fact, it’s a delight from start to finish and kept me smiling throughout. There’s just something about this one that doesn’t quite hit me like the first two books did. I think this has to do with the nature of the structure of this one. You see, this one feels a little more... “rambling” is the wrong word, but so is “less structured.” It’s a very well plotted tale, and much like the first two books it examines how we narrate stories and reexamines what isn’t said. In this one though, it feels a lot looser with its structure. In the first two we know exactly how the stories are structured and we see the variation on the narratives as the stories are going. Here one could be forgiven for missing some of the ideas it is pointing out because it cleverly doesn’t ever fully explain them to you. Now, I love it when an author assumes intelligence for their reader and I liked the structure here... but at the same time, I missed how the first one told the reader “Here is what you should know and here is what they never told you.” I missed how the second had characters correcting each other telling the same story but showing how it could be changed to fit different cultures. Here it plays again with the details not said, and how things connect, but it doesn’t seem quite as playful in the telling.
I know I’m sounding very critical, but that is not my intention. I’m trying to explain why it is not a perfect 5/5 like the others, that’s not to say that I didn’t enjoy it or didn’t like what was done with it. It’s a wonderful read, and seeing the return of cleric Chih was a delight. I fully do recommend it and was content the entire time.
The Singing Hills Cycle may genuinely be one of my favorite book series that I’ve ever read. Each one has left me delighted and feeling the need to revisit it. All three have been marvelous examinations of how stories function and examine the details behind what we think we know. While I did not enjoy this quite as much as the first two (the second of which is in my opinion a masterpiece) this is still another solid entry and only increases my love for the series. 4/5 stars
Well, now I’ve read it. All is right with the world again and I can give an assessment. So, is it another perfect masterpiece?
…
I’m sorry to report back that no, in my opinion it is not. Now hold on a moment though, that’s not to say it isn’t good! It is. Very good. In fact, it’s a delight from start to finish and kept me smiling throughout. There’s just something about this one that doesn’t quite hit me like the first two books did. I think this has to do with the nature of the structure of this one. You see, this one feels a little more... “rambling” is the wrong word, but so is “less structured.” It’s a very well plotted tale, and much like the first two books it examines how we narrate stories and reexamines what isn’t said. In this one though, it feels a lot looser with its structure. In the first two we know exactly how the stories are structured and we see the variation on the narratives as the stories are going. Here one could be forgiven for missing some of the ideas it is pointing out because it cleverly doesn’t ever fully explain them to you. Now, I love it when an author assumes intelligence for their reader and I liked the structure here... but at the same time, I missed how the first one told the reader “Here is what you should know and here is what they never told you.” I missed how the second had characters correcting each other telling the same story but showing how it could be changed to fit different cultures. Here it plays again with the details not said, and how things connect, but it doesn’t seem quite as playful in the telling.
I know I’m sounding very critical, but that is not my intention. I’m trying to explain why it is not a perfect 5/5 like the others, that’s not to say that I didn’t enjoy it or didn’t like what was done with it. It’s a wonderful read, and seeing the return of cleric Chih was a delight. I fully do recommend it and was content the entire time.
The Singing Hills Cycle may genuinely be one of my favorite book series that I’ve ever read. Each one has left me delighted and feeling the need to revisit it. All three have been marvelous examinations of how stories function and examine the details behind what we think we know. While I did not enjoy this quite as much as the first two (the second of which is in my opinion a masterpiece) this is still another solid entry and only increases my love for the series. 4/5 stars
November 4, 2022
Hmm, this is very different from The Empress of Salt and Fortune (I haven't read When the Tiger Came Down the Mountain yet). I really like the change of narrative style: this book still keeps the story-within-a-story structure, but at the same time, there's actually a full-fledged plot for the outer story that connects seamlessly with the inner story. It makes Chih feel less like a mere narrative device, and I much prefer it that way. I also like the message about how legends are passed down through history and how everyone might take a different perspective on them over time.
On the other hand, I did find the writing here a lot plainer than The Empress of Salt and Fortune. The story itself is also not as interesting, though that's totally a personal thing -- I grew up on Chinese wuxia novels, which, as a popular asian genre, has clearly influenced this book, so that took away some of the novelty and aesthetic appeal for me. But for everyone else who isn't in the same boat, I'd recommend this book regardless of how much you enjoyed the previous installments of the series, because they are quite different in a good way.
On the other hand, I did find the writing here a lot plainer than The Empress of Salt and Fortune. The story itself is also not as interesting, though that's totally a personal thing -- I grew up on Chinese wuxia novels, which, as a popular asian genre, has clearly influenced this book, so that took away some of the novelty and aesthetic appeal for me. But for everyone else who isn't in the same boat, I'd recommend this book regardless of how much you enjoyed the previous installments of the series, because they are quite different in a good way.
August 6, 2024
I love The Singing Hills Cycle books. They feel like a nostalgic xianxia movie for which you curl up in the most comfortable blanket and like little myths in the making, this their first time being told to wide-eyed listeners. This novella was a bit different than the prequels since it featured multiple stories told to Chih instead of just one that we really got to immerse ourselves in, but I still enjoyed it a lot.
August 16, 2022
Ooo, this was a slow burn in the most delicious way! Obsessed with Almost Brilliant, and Chih is such a precious bean. This series is incredibly consistent in its quality - can't wait for more!!
September 11, 2023
I'm a really big fan of how Nghi Vo crafts narrative; her commitment to preserving the mysteries of history and the ambiguities of storytelling always hits exactly right. Chih's group for Into the Riverlands, including martial arts fighters Wei Jintai and Mac Sang and middle-aged couple Lao Bingyi and Khanh, are fantastic, each written with sound distinction. The historical tales here were my favorite of the novella. This didn't blow me away the same way one and two did, but still absolutely grabbed me and was a great read.
September 10, 2023
I enjoyed other installments in this series a bit more, as I prefer the use of stories within stories that this series does. I’ll continue with this series but it isn’t my favorite of the bunch.
Want to read
May 22, 2021THREE MORE SINGING HILLS CYCLE BOOKS??? ALL MY DREAMS AND PRAYERS HAVE BEEN ANSWERED
October 25, 2022
I absolutely love this series. I love how important story telling is, the passing of folk tales and important events from person to person to preserve their history and achievements. And in this installment the reader really gets to see how a person is perceived, or wants to be perceived, determines the stories they are remembered for. When you look at a person, you never really know what has come before and what they know. You can never know everything about another individual, and to unlock a secret about someone is a surprise and a gift, and this is described here so eloquently and so effortlessly that it swept me away immediately.
If anything I wanted this to be longer. The ending comes so suddenly that it left me desperate for more (as this series always does), and I wanted to learn more about Chih and Almost Brilliant. I know that their role is to observe and record, but I find them both utterly fascinating.
If anything I wanted this to be longer. The ending comes so suddenly that it left me desperate for more (as this series always does), and I wanted to learn more about Chih and Almost Brilliant. I know that their role is to observe and record, but I find them both utterly fascinating.
September 14, 2022
Reading Vlog: https://youtu.be/1awY-IHwbWI
Into the Riverlands isn't my favorite of the Singing Hills novellas, but it's still a strong installment. We yet again spend time with Cleric Chih as they travel and collect stories and history. What stood out to me in this novella was a discussion about how stories only every talk about beautiful women, never average or ugly ones. This novella seeks to remedy that with some stories of ugly women who were unsung heroes. Basically if you liked the earlier books, you will want to read this one as well. It just feels a bit more scattered and less focused. Still great though. Thank you to the publisher for sending a copy for review, all opinions are my own.
Into the Riverlands isn't my favorite of the Singing Hills novellas, but it's still a strong installment. We yet again spend time with Cleric Chih as they travel and collect stories and history. What stood out to me in this novella was a discussion about how stories only every talk about beautiful women, never average or ugly ones. This novella seeks to remedy that with some stories of ugly women who were unsung heroes. Basically if you liked the earlier books, you will want to read this one as well. It just feels a bit more scattered and less focused. Still great though. Thank you to the publisher for sending a copy for review, all opinions are my own.
December 28, 2022
4.5 stars.
I really loved this. The prose was beautiful, as always. I loved how the plot went in this and how Chih, our cleric with her hoopoe, was a part of the story rather than just a historian collecting tales on the sidelines. It made the plot more appealing. All the stories narrated were entertaining and we get to see a little bit of action in between, along with some nice surprises. Loved the focus of the plot.
All in all, there’s quite a bit packed in this short novelette yet it left me wanting for more.
I really loved this. The prose was beautiful, as always. I loved how the plot went in this and how Chih, our cleric with her hoopoe, was a part of the story rather than just a historian collecting tales on the sidelines. It made the plot more appealing. All the stories narrated were entertaining and we get to see a little bit of action in between, along with some nice surprises. Loved the focus of the plot.
All in all, there’s quite a bit packed in this short novelette yet it left me wanting for more.
April 14, 2024
The third novelette that has us follow cleric Chih as she collects tales; this time from the titular riverlands that are known best for the almost immortal martial artists living (or is it haunting?) there.
As with the other two books, we get a blend of old legends, the true inspiration for them, as well as a modern spin on things. One of the points I liked especially was the emphasis on how women usually have to be beautiful in stories in order to be worth rescuing or whatever, because how many tales (around the world) have the pretty ones be the princesses and the ugly ones posing as evil stepmothers or whatever?! It's just so superficial, sexist and, above all, unrealistic.
The other element I enjoyed the most was that of how tales change over time or get told the wrong way right from the beginning (victors write history). In this regard, was an interesting way of seeing it. Not sure I completely agree about that being the best way to do it but the fact that the book makes you think about such interesting questions (that are relevant in any era and any part of the world) is the mark of a fun and important work.
There were a number of wonderful characters here again that I cannot get too much into detail about because of spoilers, sadly. However, what I can tell you is that they were all very lively, distinct and quirky.
In general, this entry in the series was a bit ... quieter ... than the previous volumes. Of course, things happened here, too, but the story was more contemplative, calm and understated - kind of like a honey trap though. *grins*
As with the previous volumes, I love the stories-within-a-story trope as well as the true Asian style of the tale and general worldbuilding. They are all morality tales, but never too preachy. Rather, they lure you with pretty prose and interesting supernatural surprises, and I'm here for that.
As with the other two books, we get a blend of old legends, the true inspiration for them, as well as a modern spin on things. One of the points I liked especially was the emphasis on how women usually have to be beautiful in stories in order to be worth rescuing or whatever, because how many tales (around the world) have the pretty ones be the princesses and the ugly ones posing as evil stepmothers or whatever?! It's just so superficial, sexist and, above all, unrealistic.
The other element I enjoyed the most was that of how tales change over time or get told the wrong way right from the beginning (victors write history). In this regard, was an interesting way of seeing it. Not sure I completely agree about that being the best way to do it but the fact that the book makes you think about such interesting questions (that are relevant in any era and any part of the world) is the mark of a fun and important work.
There were a number of wonderful characters here again that I cannot get too much into detail about because of spoilers, sadly. However, what I can tell you is that they were all very lively, distinct and quirky.
In general, this entry in the series was a bit ... quieter ... than the previous volumes. Of course, things happened here, too, but the story was more contemplative, calm and understated - kind of like a honey trap though. *grins*
As with the previous volumes, I love the stories-within-a-story trope as well as the true Asian style of the tale and general worldbuilding. They are all morality tales, but never too preachy. Rather, they lure you with pretty prose and interesting supernatural surprises, and I'm here for that.
August 8, 2022
Thank you to the publisher for providing me with an e-ARC in exchange for an honest review!
There is truly nothing I love more than being back in this world. As always, Nghi Vo's writing is incredibly lush and beautiful, and I think this book will be a favourite for many people in the series because of how action-packed it is compared to the first two.
In Into the Riverlands, we're following Chih and Almost Brilliant as they travel to the Riverlands alongside some martial artists. I love how Nghi Vo has given us a wuxia novella in the Singing Hills world - it's so nostalgic and comforting for me personally, as these are the types of stories that I grew up with. As with a classic wuxia tale, we are introduced to some villains and some heroes, but what I loved most is how we also got to meet and discuss the characters that are often overlooked by these types of narratives - those who are not conventionally attractive, who are smaller and perceived as weaker, but just as important to the story.
My favourite part about this installment in particular is that for the first time, we really got to see Chih be the main character of their own story. Don't get me wrong, I've loved their role in the first two books as well, but I think they definitely took a backseat in the grand scheme of the story. Here, we finally get a glimpse into Chih's backstory, as well as a closer look at their relationship with Almost Brilliant (one of the best animal companions!).
Once again, Nghi Vo has delivered a beautiful, cozy, fantasy tale. If you enjoy stories within stories, folklore, whimsical vibes, and feminist tales, you must check out this series if you haven't already. I personally still recommend reading The Empress of Salt and Fortune first since I do think that it sets up the world the best, but if you did want to start with another book, here's my recommendation: I'd say if you like love stories, start with When the Tiger Came Down the Mountain, and if you like wuxia and martial arts stories, start with Into the Riverlands.
There is truly nothing I love more than being back in this world. As always, Nghi Vo's writing is incredibly lush and beautiful, and I think this book will be a favourite for many people in the series because of how action-packed it is compared to the first two.
In Into the Riverlands, we're following Chih and Almost Brilliant as they travel to the Riverlands alongside some martial artists. I love how Nghi Vo has given us a wuxia novella in the Singing Hills world - it's so nostalgic and comforting for me personally, as these are the types of stories that I grew up with. As with a classic wuxia tale, we are introduced to some villains and some heroes, but what I loved most is how we also got to meet and discuss the characters that are often overlooked by these types of narratives - those who are not conventionally attractive, who are smaller and perceived as weaker, but just as important to the story.
My favourite part about this installment in particular is that for the first time, we really got to see Chih be the main character of their own story. Don't get me wrong, I've loved their role in the first two books as well, but I think they definitely took a backseat in the grand scheme of the story. Here, we finally get a glimpse into Chih's backstory, as well as a closer look at their relationship with Almost Brilliant (one of the best animal companions!).
Once again, Nghi Vo has delivered a beautiful, cozy, fantasy tale. If you enjoy stories within stories, folklore, whimsical vibes, and feminist tales, you must check out this series if you haven't already. I personally still recommend reading The Empress of Salt and Fortune first since I do think that it sets up the world the best, but if you did want to start with another book, here's my recommendation: I'd say if you like love stories, start with When the Tiger Came Down the Mountain, and if you like wuxia and martial arts stories, start with Into the Riverlands.
![Profile Image for laurel [the suspected bibliophile].](https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/users/1645808644i/7494844._UX200_CR0,6,200,200_.jpg)
September 24, 2022
I absolutely love The Singing Hills cycle, and how Chih wanders about collecting histories and stories...well, their traveling companion Almost Brilliant does, Chih just provides the human facilitation of everything.
Exploring this world is so wonderful, because it carefully peels back layers of layers of myth and lore while revealing truth, and showing that things change but...they also don't because the core of humanity doesn't really change.
And it is so, so queer and I love it.
Looking forward to the next one.
I received an ARC from NetGalley
Exploring this world is so wonderful, because it carefully peels back layers of layers of myth and lore while revealing truth, and showing that things change but...they also don't because the core of humanity doesn't really change.
And it is so, so queer and I love it.
Looking forward to the next one.
I received an ARC from NetGalley
August 19, 2023
My comfort read. Might not be as excellent as the previous books but still a very solid entry. Can't wait for the fourth book soon.
December 25, 2022
This one is my favorite so far. So gorgeous and heartwarming, especially her acknowledgments.
Thank you, Nghi Vo.
Thank you, Nghi Vo.
November 7, 2022
Reread on November 7, 2022: Read via library/audio (narrated by Cindy Kay).
First read on August 1, 2022: Love this series so much — I could read dozens of adventures about Cleric Chih and Almost Brilliant’s quest to preserve folklore. This isn’t as exciting as the tiger installment (unsurprising because what could be more exciting than tigers threatening to eat you?!), but the “aha!” moment where you connect the dots is still very satisfying.
Disclaimer: I received a free e-ARC from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
First read on August 1, 2022: Love this series so much — I could read dozens of adventures about Cleric Chih and Almost Brilliant’s quest to preserve folklore. This isn’t as exciting as the tiger installment (unsurprising because what could be more exciting than tigers threatening to eat you?!), but the “aha!” moment where you connect the dots is still very satisfying.
Disclaimer: I received a free e-ARC from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
May 7, 2023
We belong to everyone and to no one, and when some bandit sets up as a ruler, the usual response is to call them what they want to be called and then not to cry very much when the next murderer comes in. We don't do well with kings here, or queens, or lords. We have a governor, I believe, who stays very politely behind his men at Mo-Lai Fortress, and we tolerate the mayors because they're mostly concerned with keeping the local roads fixed and the poor fed. They know how patient the riverlands aren't, and so they keep to themselves. Good.
Covid mush is still very much the state of my brain, but it's not too hard to write a review when the book is this good, and part of a series this fantastic. Read it, it's great! See? Even I can write that. But really, this entry, and the whole series of books, is just phenomenal. I'd say the side characters were my favourite yet, but I have a sneaky feeling that's going to be the case whichever book I read the most recently. This is inventive, though, and the way each book gives us more pieces of such an intriguing universe is something I'm really enjoying. Plus, jump in wherever - you could start this series with any book, and should.
Covid mush is still very much the state of my brain, but it's not too hard to write a review when the book is this good, and part of a series this fantastic. Read it, it's great! See? Even I can write that. But really, this entry, and the whole series of books, is just phenomenal. I'd say the side characters were my favourite yet, but I have a sneaky feeling that's going to be the case whichever book I read the most recently. This is inventive, though, and the way each book gives us more pieces of such an intriguing universe is something I'm really enjoying. Plus, jump in wherever - you could start this series with any book, and should.
November 13, 2022
#1) The Empress of Salt & Fortune ★★★☆☆
#2) When the Tiger Came Down the Mountain ★★★★☆
i'm crushed. this was a highly anticipated release of mine but it didn't hit nearly as hard as the first two books. i can't even be certain what this one was about 😞
Blog • Trigger Warning Database • StoryGraph
December 29, 2022
After Chih emphasizing the importance of collecting and telling stories throughout this series, I love that in this novella they also learn and respect that some people want to keep their stories for themselves. This book differed from the previous in its inclusion of multiple stories rather than one, and I have to say that it made it feel a bit disjointed. Even though I do feel like I got to know the characters in this better because they got to shine on their own outside of their stories, I do prefer the focus on the single story. Still, as always, a lovely book that feels so full despite its short length.
3.5 stars
3.5 stars
October 26, 2022
An insta-read, I loved the two first of this series of novellas, set in a kind of fantasy Vietnam (or neighbouring countries?). Cleric Chih and their bird-like companion Almost Brilliant set out to collect stories and history to record. And just like the first story was quite different, in narrative style and focus from the second, this third story is again different from those two first - we get more of Chih's personality, and particularly Almost Brilliant (who is very very very cute), the dialogue is often priceless, and the personality of seemingly random travelling companions.
I am going to reread this (maybe tonight) which is good, because I need to reread this to make sure I understood most of the implied references and some of what is going on. On the first story The Empress of Salt and Fortune I finished it and restarted it at once, but it was on a different way, there I was sure I understood what was going on and it was just for enjoyment. Here what was going on, a narrative of mythic creatures told differently from different folk tales it is a lot more elusive. It is very clever, perhaps too clever for me, and felt a bit unfocused (or maybe it was me the reader not focusing).
Incidentally this meandering through the riverlands telling each other stories, despite there being bandits about reminded me a bit of Becky Chambers - though I did like this a lot better!
I am going to reread this (maybe tonight) which is good, because I need to reread this to make sure I understood most of the implied references and some of what is going on. On the first story The Empress of Salt and Fortune I finished it and restarted it at once, but it was on a different way, there I was sure I understood what was going on and it was just for enjoyment. Here what was going on, a narrative of mythic creatures told differently from different folk tales it is a lot more elusive. It is very clever, perhaps too clever for me, and felt a bit unfocused (or maybe it was me the reader not focusing).
Incidentally this meandering through the riverlands telling each other stories, despite there being bandits about reminded me a bit of Becky Chambers - though I did like this a lot better!
February 14, 2023
the sheer audacity to make me wait until october 2022
don't do this to meeee
don't do this to meeee
Read
October 2, 2022Such a good installment in a xuanhuan series that in this installment felt like more of a balance of wuxia and xianxia in the most delicious way.
Every installment charms me more with Chih, the monk from Singing Hills, who wanders about with Almost Brilliant, collecting stories. And falling into stories, despite not being at all warlike.
I love the details of this world, and how it resonates with really old tales that I have read in translation, while folding in a more diverse view of character--there are a lot of active women in this one, and beings that present female. And of course Chih is non-binary.
My only criticism--and it's small--is that occasionally the "they" is confusing, especially if the subject of a sentence is more than one person and not Chih, which made for frequent backtracking, especially in action bits, and at the very end. However, I think this is a function of "they" now being accepted for characters who prefer not to own a gender, rather than zie or zir, or some of the other pronoun neologisms that writers have experimented with over the past few decades. Writers learn how to differentiate "he" and "she" if there are more than one of either gender in a bit of action or scene, and that will happen as more writers get used to "they" in the singular.
That extremely minor blip aside, I adore how each installment gets more vivid, and stronger, and weirder, and queerer, while still grounded in the magic of the jianghu world. SOOOOO looking forward to more of Chih and Almost Brilliant, Chih's fine feathered companion!
Every installment charms me more with Chih, the monk from Singing Hills, who wanders about with Almost Brilliant, collecting stories. And falling into stories, despite not being at all warlike.
I love the details of this world, and how it resonates with really old tales that I have read in translation, while folding in a more diverse view of character--there are a lot of active women in this one, and beings that present female. And of course Chih is non-binary.
My only criticism--and it's small--is that occasionally the "they" is confusing, especially if the subject of a sentence is more than one person and not Chih, which made for frequent backtracking, especially in action bits, and at the very end. However, I think this is a function of "they" now being accepted for characters who prefer not to own a gender, rather than zie or zir, or some of the other pronoun neologisms that writers have experimented with over the past few decades. Writers learn how to differentiate "he" and "she" if there are more than one of either gender in a bit of action or scene, and that will happen as more writers get used to "they" in the singular.
That extremely minor blip aside, I adore how each installment gets more vivid, and stronger, and weirder, and queerer, while still grounded in the magic of the jianghu world. SOOOOO looking forward to more of Chih and Almost Brilliant, Chih's fine feathered companion!
January 12, 2024
Nghi Vo is a contemporary American writing about an imagined ancient China. The characters are in some ways “stock” – a cleric, a rich wife and husband, two sisters traveling who all meet in interior Imperial China in a place between and west of Shanghai and Beijing.
The author weaves into her tale of these travelers, both their backstories and large measures of myth, history and fantasy. Unlike “forks in the road,” we may proceed down one path, jump to a parallel trail, return to the main plot or take time for bit of history. It could become confusing, but Nghi Vo shows a deft sense of how to arrange each element in the big picture.
Style isn’t everything, but here is an exchange that will give you a sense of this storytelling.
“The Shaking Earth Master and the girl from Taiyuan aren’t a story, they’re history,” protested Wei Jintai, but Lao Bingyi shook her head.
“That silly thing,” she said, contemptuous. “People keep wanting to tell old tired stories like that, that’s why the world is in such disrepair.”
“And why no one goes to temple anymore and children no longer respect their elders?” asked Chih wryly, earning themselves another peck from Almost Brilliant and a brisk slap on their arm from Lao Bingyi.
“And why clerics are more interested in free meals and gossip than they are in holiness and correct behavior, I shouldn’t wonder.” She scolded.
“I beg your pardon, auntie,” said Chih, “and I would be more than happy to hear the story about the governor who was meant to pave this road.”
The tale includes a variety of the fantastic ranging from the group’s encounters on the journey to Betony Docks, to the stories that they share. It is left open whether any of the group are what they seem, but the sex of the cleric, Chih ( self described as “more a historian and observer”), is deliberately left ambiguous. This, at times mitigates against clarity as in the following:
“She looked younger when she slept, especially with how she clung to Sang, and Chih was careful not to disturb them when they rose.” The pronoun could be read both to refer to Chic or to the two women.
A further delight is the neixin, a demi-human in the form of a bird that “records” everything that transpires or is said for its and Chih’s benefit.
My thanks to GR friend carol for pointing me in this direction and to Nataliya, as well !
The author weaves into her tale of these travelers, both their backstories and large measures of myth, history and fantasy. Unlike “forks in the road,” we may proceed down one path, jump to a parallel trail, return to the main plot or take time for bit of history. It could become confusing, but Nghi Vo shows a deft sense of how to arrange each element in the big picture.
Style isn’t everything, but here is an exchange that will give you a sense of this storytelling.
“The Shaking Earth Master and the girl from Taiyuan aren’t a story, they’re history,” protested Wei Jintai, but Lao Bingyi shook her head.
“That silly thing,” she said, contemptuous. “People keep wanting to tell old tired stories like that, that’s why the world is in such disrepair.”
“And why no one goes to temple anymore and children no longer respect their elders?” asked Chih wryly, earning themselves another peck from Almost Brilliant and a brisk slap on their arm from Lao Bingyi.
“And why clerics are more interested in free meals and gossip than they are in holiness and correct behavior, I shouldn’t wonder.” She scolded.
“I beg your pardon, auntie,” said Chih, “and I would be more than happy to hear the story about the governor who was meant to pave this road.”
The tale includes a variety of the fantastic ranging from the group’s encounters on the journey to Betony Docks, to the stories that they share. It is left open whether any of the group are what they seem, but the sex of the cleric, Chih ( self described as “more a historian and observer”), is deliberately left ambiguous. This, at times mitigates against clarity as in the following:
“She looked younger when she slept, especially with how she clung to Sang, and Chih was careful not to disturb them when they rose.” The pronoun could be read both to refer to Chic or to the two women.
A further delight is the neixin, a demi-human in the form of a bird that “records” everything that transpires or is said for its and Chih’s benefit.
My thanks to GR friend carol for pointing me in this direction and to Nataliya, as well !
October 26, 2022
This has been one of the most fun series I’ve read in recent times, so I was very excited when a new installment was announced. And this felt like something that was written just for me.
The past two years has been me absolutely binging and adoring Chinese wuxia dramas, so imagine my delight when I read the premise of this story. The author does a brilliant job bringing the delight and charm of those dramas to this lovely little novella and we get a tale of legends, amazing martial artists, awesome fight sequences and discussions of their styles (really reminiscent of Condor Heroes) and the overall freedom in being able to traverse through the dangerous riverlands and fight against bandits.
It’s always nice to be back with our favorite cleric Chic and the sassiest bird Almost Brilliant whose one liners make this book even more fun. But I thought this was all Lao Bingyi’s show - mysterious woman and brilliant fighter, who definitely has so much more to do and share with the world. Wei Jintai didn’t have too many lines in the book but she definitely is a legend in making herself and I had this intense wish to know what happens to her next.
Overall, this was a slightly bloody, but charming story, reminding one of all our favorite wuxia stories, whether you’ve watched the dramas or read Jin Yong’s books. It starts off with the signature tavern brawl and only gets more fun from there, so if you wanna indulge in some nostalgia, don’t miss this quick and entertaining read.
The past two years has been me absolutely binging and adoring Chinese wuxia dramas, so imagine my delight when I read the premise of this story. The author does a brilliant job bringing the delight and charm of those dramas to this lovely little novella and we get a tale of legends, amazing martial artists, awesome fight sequences and discussions of their styles (really reminiscent of Condor Heroes) and the overall freedom in being able to traverse through the dangerous riverlands and fight against bandits.
It’s always nice to be back with our favorite cleric Chic and the sassiest bird Almost Brilliant whose one liners make this book even more fun. But I thought this was all Lao Bingyi’s show - mysterious woman and brilliant fighter, who definitely has so much more to do and share with the world. Wei Jintai didn’t have too many lines in the book but she definitely is a legend in making herself and I had this intense wish to know what happens to her next.
Overall, this was a slightly bloody, but charming story, reminding one of all our favorite wuxia stories, whether you’ve watched the dramas or read Jin Yong’s books. It starts off with the signature tavern brawl and only gets more fun from there, so if you wanna indulge in some nostalgia, don’t miss this quick and entertaining read.
October 29, 2022
3.5/5
another great addition to the singing hills cycle verse - nghi vo continues to impress with how she's able to draw out an entire world and history and characters in a mere handful of pages. i enjoyed the action-packed wuxia element of this novella and how all the stories of famous martial artists came together towards the end. i also liked that our narrator chih felt more like a protagonist this time around and we even get a glimpse into their past.
while i do think the story-within-a-story format was done better in the previous book and i wasn't as connected to the characters in this one, it's still a fun, quick read and i'm looking forward to the rest of the series.
another great addition to the singing hills cycle verse - nghi vo continues to impress with how she's able to draw out an entire world and history and characters in a mere handful of pages. i enjoyed the action-packed wuxia element of this novella and how all the stories of famous martial artists came together towards the end. i also liked that our narrator chih felt more like a protagonist this time around and we even get a glimpse into their past.
while i do think the story-within-a-story format was done better in the previous book and i wasn't as connected to the characters in this one, it's still a fun, quick read and i'm looking forward to the rest of the series.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,452 reviews