What do you think?
Rate this book
Stranger Things Happen
This first collection by award-winning author Kelly Link takes fairy tales and cautionary tales, dictators and extraterrestrials, amnesiacs and honeymooners, revenants and readers alike, on a voyage into new, strange, and wonderful territory. The girl detective must go to the underworld to solve the case of the tap-dancing bank robbers. A librarian falls in love with a girl whose father collects artificial noses. A dead man posts letters home to his estranged wife. Two women named Louise begin a series of consecutive love affairs with a string of cellists. A newly married couple become participants in an apocalyptic beauty pageant. Sexy blond aliens invade New York City. A young girl learns how to make herself disappear.
These eleven extraordinary stories are quirky, spooky, and smart. They all have happy endings. Every story contains a secret prize. Each story was written especially for you.
Stories from Stranger Things Happen have won the Nebula, Tiptree, and World Fantasy Award. Stranger Things Happen was a Salon Book of the Year, one of the Village Voice's 25 Favorite Books of 2001, and was nominated for the Firecracker Alternative Book Award.
Contents:
- Carnation, Lily, Lily, Rose (1998)
- Water Off a Black Dog's Back (1995)
- The Specialist's Hat (1998)
- Flying Lessons (1995)
- Travels with the Snow Queen (1996/1997)
- Vanishing Act (1996)
- Survivor's Ball, or, The Donner Party (1998)
- Shoe and Marriage (2000)
- Most of My Friends Are Two-Thirds Water (2001)
- Louise's Ghost (2001)
- The Girl Detective (1999)
Cover painting by Shelley Jackson
These eleven extraordinary stories are quirky, spooky, and smart. They all have happy endings. Every story contains a secret prize. Each story was written especially for you.
Stories from Stranger Things Happen have won the Nebula, Tiptree, and World Fantasy Award. Stranger Things Happen was a Salon Book of the Year, one of the Village Voice's 25 Favorite Books of 2001, and was nominated for the Firecracker Alternative Book Award.
Contents:
- Carnation, Lily, Lily, Rose (1998)
- Water Off a Black Dog's Back (1995)
- The Specialist's Hat (1998)
- Flying Lessons (1995)
- Travels with the Snow Queen (1996/1997)
- Vanishing Act (1996)
- Survivor's Ball, or, The Donner Party (1998)
- Shoe and Marriage (2000)
- Most of My Friends Are Two-Thirds Water (2001)
- Louise's Ghost (2001)
- The Girl Detective (1999)
Cover painting by Shelley Jackson
266 pages, Paperback
First published July 1, 2001
About the author
Kelly Link
202 books2,533 followersKelly Link is an American author best known for her short stories, which span a wide variety of genres - most notably magic realism, fantasy and horror. She is a graduate of Columbia University.
Her stories have been collected in four books - Stranger Things Happen, Magic for Beginners, Pretty Monsters, and most recently, Get in Trouble.
She has won several awards for her short stories, including the World Fantasy Award in 1999 for "The Specialist's Hat", and the Nebula Award both in 2001 and 2005 for "Louise's Ghost" and "Magic for Beginners".
Link also works as an editor, and is the founder of independant publishing company, Small Beer Press, along with her husband, Gavin Grant.
Her stories have been collected in four books - Stranger Things Happen, Magic for Beginners, Pretty Monsters, and most recently, Get in Trouble.
She has won several awards for her short stories, including the World Fantasy Award in 1999 for "The Specialist's Hat", and the Nebula Award both in 2001 and 2005 for "Louise's Ghost" and "Magic for Beginners".
Link also works as an editor, and is the founder of independant publishing company, Small Beer Press, along with her husband, Gavin Grant.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 801 reviews
November 27, 2017
it's not me, it's you, Stranger Things Happen. what is it the kids say these days? I just can't. I'm just not that into you. but it's not my fault! God knows I was patient and I tried to be supportive and I tried and I tried and I tried. a whole long month of trying. I just can't with you though. and not to play the blame game, but seriously it's all your fault, not mine!
you have talent to burn so I don't blame myself for having high expectations. you're like a combo of Aimee Bender and, as others have said, Robert Aickman and Angela Carter. now those are two of my favorite authors (and Bender is pretty great too) so how could I not expect something amazing? or at the very least absorbing. but you didn't absorb me at all, quite the opposite. you were a chore to read, all the quirk and eccentricity and ambiguity curdled into something precious and cutesie-poo and not at all refreshing. your characters felt like they were held at arm's length from me so there was little to draw me into caring about their tiresome, fragile little lives. all of the attempts to tie their trials and tribulations into various fairy tales and fables didn't resonate; it just felt like being clever to be clever, or putting on too much make-up and jewelry instead of letting any inner beauty shine. you made a dazzling first impression (especially that cover!) but I soon realized we had very little to talk about.
still, you're no 1-star relationship. we did have that weekend together, "The Specialist's Hat". it was a wonderful weekend, eerie and endearing and chilling and just the right kind of strange. I loved it! a perfect weekend. for that, at least, you get 2 stars.
you have talent to burn so I don't blame myself for having high expectations. you're like a combo of Aimee Bender and, as others have said, Robert Aickman and Angela Carter. now those are two of my favorite authors (and Bender is pretty great too) so how could I not expect something amazing? or at the very least absorbing. but you didn't absorb me at all, quite the opposite. you were a chore to read, all the quirk and eccentricity and ambiguity curdled into something precious and cutesie-poo and not at all refreshing. your characters felt like they were held at arm's length from me so there was little to draw me into caring about their tiresome, fragile little lives. all of the attempts to tie their trials and tribulations into various fairy tales and fables didn't resonate; it just felt like being clever to be clever, or putting on too much make-up and jewelry instead of letting any inner beauty shine. you made a dazzling first impression (especially that cover!) but I soon realized we had very little to talk about.
still, you're no 1-star relationship. we did have that weekend together, "The Specialist's Hat". it was a wonderful weekend, eerie and endearing and chilling and just the right kind of strange. I loved it! a perfect weekend. for that, at least, you get 2 stars.
September 1, 2009
This book will sleep with you on the first date. Then when you wake up beside it in the early morning you will spend some serious time considering whether it was great, or whether it would have been better to wait a bit.
For me it was a bit wild, which I like, from a book, but also a little cold, a little impersonal. This book may have issues with nymphomania. It's definately ready and willing to give you a thrill, but even though you've spent some time with it, it still doesn't quite love you back. Sometimes I like a quickie on the T, or during my lunch break, but I really want to feel like the book loves me back. This relationship was fun, but I just don't feel like the commitment was really there.
Don't get me wrong; I like this book, but in several of the stories I felt as though the strangeness was there to be strange, and that's not enough for me. I think the best surrealists and fantasy writers can tap easily into strange, but even the cryptic moments come together for cohesive delight.
One story in this collection is not to be missed. In "Vanishing Act" the strangeness is more subtle, and the magic totally feasible. The characters feel the most real, the most lovingly conceived, and I, the reader, love it without reservation for its uncanny mixture of tragedy and hope.
This is a first collection, maybe the second collection will still have that spontaneity I love, but with a little more of the maturity I crave. From books.
For me it was a bit wild, which I like, from a book, but also a little cold, a little impersonal. This book may have issues with nymphomania. It's definately ready and willing to give you a thrill, but even though you've spent some time with it, it still doesn't quite love you back. Sometimes I like a quickie on the T, or during my lunch break, but I really want to feel like the book loves me back. This relationship was fun, but I just don't feel like the commitment was really there.
Don't get me wrong; I like this book, but in several of the stories I felt as though the strangeness was there to be strange, and that's not enough for me. I think the best surrealists and fantasy writers can tap easily into strange, but even the cryptic moments come together for cohesive delight.
One story in this collection is not to be missed. In "Vanishing Act" the strangeness is more subtle, and the magic totally feasible. The characters feel the most real, the most lovingly conceived, and I, the reader, love it without reservation for its uncanny mixture of tragedy and hope.
This is a first collection, maybe the second collection will still have that spontaneity I love, but with a little more of the maturity I crave. From books.
September 20, 2012
I sort of feel I should apologize for this rating. I picked this up on the strength of some good ratings and reviews here. But I just didn't like this book. I don't mean to be hard to get along with, but I found the stories rather silly.
Again, I'm sorry if you like this book and please enjoy...
I wanted to like this book. Based on what I'd read I picked it up ready for some enjoyable weird stories. The first one left me cold...the "dead man" exploring his situation (and also his genitals. This was the most "grope happy corpse I ever heard of). He finally puts it all together..whoopee.
I almost put the book down there but I thought, no give it a chance. To Me...let me emphasize that again "To Me" the next story and "the father's nose collection" were just as silly. It was like a book of television episode outlines, something that might have been seen on the old "Night Gallery" series.
Okay sorry, if you enjoy this please continue to enjoy. If I want weird tales I'll go back to H.P. Lovecraft and the like. I just found this one not for me.
I almost went with one star...but I didn't actually hate it. I just didn't find it worth the time to read. Sorry I see a lot of you like or even love this collection, not me however.
Again, I'm sorry if you like this book and please enjoy...
I wanted to like this book. Based on what I'd read I picked it up ready for some enjoyable weird stories. The first one left me cold...the "dead man" exploring his situation (and also his genitals. This was the most "grope happy corpse I ever heard of). He finally puts it all together..whoopee.
I almost put the book down there but I thought, no give it a chance. To Me...let me emphasize that again "To Me" the next story and "the father's nose collection" were just as silly. It was like a book of television episode outlines, something that might have been seen on the old "Night Gallery" series.
Okay sorry, if you enjoy this please continue to enjoy. If I want weird tales I'll go back to H.P. Lovecraft and the like. I just found this one not for me.
I almost went with one star...but I didn't actually hate it. I just didn't find it worth the time to read. Sorry I see a lot of you like or even love this collection, not me however.
June 18, 2010
The only reason I finished this book is because I read Magic for beginners first and I liked that one slightly more than this collection.
In the end, I guess Link just isn't for me. I like my stories to make sense, to have some internal logic and structure I can follow and, possibly, an ending or a hint of an explanation my mind can work upon.
Link's stories instead feel to me more like a dream - scenes, images, moments where time slows down like molasses or jumps all over the place, where strange things happen without reason beyond 'odd is cool'. The characters felt just as dreamlike, devoid of life and motivations, and I couldn't really sympathize with them. I finished every segment asking myself what actually happened, and why, and why should I care.
If you like when people tell you their latest weird dreams, Kelly Link's books are definitely up your alley. If you're looking for stories, well, they're not.
In the end, I guess Link just isn't for me. I like my stories to make sense, to have some internal logic and structure I can follow and, possibly, an ending or a hint of an explanation my mind can work upon.
Link's stories instead feel to me more like a dream - scenes, images, moments where time slows down like molasses or jumps all over the place, where strange things happen without reason beyond 'odd is cool'. The characters felt just as dreamlike, devoid of life and motivations, and I couldn't really sympathize with them. I finished every segment asking myself what actually happened, and why, and why should I care.
If you like when people tell you their latest weird dreams, Kelly Link's books are definitely up your alley. If you're looking for stories, well, they're not.
February 21, 2021
Masterfully written, but at times so weird it was hard to fully comprehend them.
January 30, 2012
The stories are unusual and not at all predictable. But they're dull. They seem to have been written to impress critics or other authors with their strangeness. The author seems to delight in showing us how clever and creative she can be. For example, there's lots of cute but ultimately meaningless word play. Unfortunately, the stories are not compelling or engrossing at all.
Regarding its favorable reviews: I'd say there's a major "Emperor's New Clothes" effect with this book. To compare her with Borges and Chandler, as Salon did, is absurd. Borges and Chandler managed to be innovators while writing utterly engrossing stories. Link hasn't figured out how to do that.
Regarding its favorable reviews: I'd say there's a major "Emperor's New Clothes" effect with this book. To compare her with Borges and Chandler, as Salon did, is absurd. Borges and Chandler managed to be innovators while writing utterly engrossing stories. Link hasn't figured out how to do that.
June 22, 2007
Short Stories. This was stamped "science fiction" by the library, but these short, fantastic stories have more in common with magical realism and retold fairy tales than science- or even speculative fiction. Plenty of ghosts, being dead, being haunted, dating a son of Zeus, searching for the lover that the Snow Queen stole away -- that sort of thing.
Written with a light hand, these stories are bittersweet, spooky, absurd, crazy, and freeing. Each one is perfectly self-contained, but taken together it's easy to see hints of a bigger world, tiny details that make you think everything might be related, so the book on the whole feels nicely tied together. Link even writes in such experimental forms as second person and present tense, which is not something you see very often in published fiction. She treats the fantastic like it's ordinary, and the ordinary like it might be something secretly fantastic, and I loved every moment of it.
Five stars. Link writes great short stories. And I say this as someone who does not generally enjoy a short story. But these I'm going to read again and again.
Written with a light hand, these stories are bittersweet, spooky, absurd, crazy, and freeing. Each one is perfectly self-contained, but taken together it's easy to see hints of a bigger world, tiny details that make you think everything might be related, so the book on the whole feels nicely tied together. Link even writes in such experimental forms as second person and present tense, which is not something you see very often in published fiction. She treats the fantastic like it's ordinary, and the ordinary like it might be something secretly fantastic, and I loved every moment of it.
Five stars. Link writes great short stories. And I say this as someone who does not generally enjoy a short story. But these I'm going to read again and again.
January 21, 2011
I really love Kelly Link's writing style. It falls somewhere between magical realist and full-blown surreal, and it manages to be very emotionally affecting without sacrificing subtlety. It is frequently surprising, often delightful, occasionally horrific. Link can get me to agree to suspend my disbelief in some of the most wildly imaginative and implausible situations, and she has a real knack for being gently disturbing.
However, I am only giving this collection, Link's earliest, (which focuses largely on referenced, re-imagined, and re-arranged fairy tales, myths, and legends) 3 stars, because 3.5 isn't an option, and I loved her collection Magic for Beginners considerably more. (It was simply stellar.) These stories are worth the reader's time, and some are downright brilliant. But some left me neutral, and the overall feeling I was left with was one less bowled-over than when I'd finished Magic For Beginners.
My recommendation: If you've never read Kelly Link, start with Magic for Beginners, as it was wonderful and whimsical and weird and freaky and creepy across the board. Then, if you enjoy that, explore her earlier work in this collection, Stranger Things Happen.
However, I am only giving this collection, Link's earliest, (which focuses largely on referenced, re-imagined, and re-arranged fairy tales, myths, and legends) 3 stars, because 3.5 isn't an option, and I loved her collection Magic for Beginners considerably more. (It was simply stellar.) These stories are worth the reader's time, and some are downright brilliant. But some left me neutral, and the overall feeling I was left with was one less bowled-over than when I'd finished Magic For Beginners.
My recommendation: If you've never read Kelly Link, start with Magic for Beginners, as it was wonderful and whimsical and weird and freaky and creepy across the board. Then, if you enjoy that, explore her earlier work in this collection, Stranger Things Happen.
October 29, 2012
"Um, he's sick. My best friend's sister's boyfriend's brother's girlfriend heard from this guy who knows this kid who's going with the girl who saw Ferris pass out at 31 Flavors last night. I guess it's pretty serious. "
That was funny in Ferris Buehler's Day off. It was just a couple lines. Now imagine an entire book done in that same sort of frantic voice. No real authority or ownership of the events that happened, just a string of hearsay from a high school girl. If you can do that, you understand what you are in for with this collection of short stories.
Still not clear enough? Ok - imagine a book where the goal is not to entertain or teach anything, but instead to try and convince everyone else that they were clever. When you get to the end of a short story, it isn't clever. . . the feeling is just one where I was left asking "so what"? It is the kind of thing where if you are expecting more - you are just not smart enough to get it says the rabble in the room. Nope. I got it. It just isn't compelling, interesting, entertaining or insightful in any real way.
I had to keep checking back to see that this book was written by Kelly Link and not Lois Cook. Yikes. To be fair, KL's grammar was fine I suppose. . .
Hey! Here is some Cinderella Fan Fic where the prince doesn't find her and instead develops a foot fetish. He spends his time going around being broken and creepy with a glass slipper in his pocket. I just saved you 30 pages. You are welcome.
On to the next story (every story) written in a stream of consciousness style where the reader is kept at an arms length but I am sure makes perfect sense to the 12 year old girl who was being channeled. I imagine little hearts above every dotted "i" if this were written on paper.
I had to commit to finishing this book because I think it is unfair to review a book that you have not finished. That being said, I LOVE to read. This book made me find other things to do over and over and postpone finishing it. A book that makes me not want to read is a book that I want to tell others not to read either. At least my office is really clean and organized.
That was funny in Ferris Buehler's Day off. It was just a couple lines. Now imagine an entire book done in that same sort of frantic voice. No real authority or ownership of the events that happened, just a string of hearsay from a high school girl. If you can do that, you understand what you are in for with this collection of short stories.
Still not clear enough? Ok - imagine a book where the goal is not to entertain or teach anything, but instead to try and convince everyone else that they were clever. When you get to the end of a short story, it isn't clever. . . the feeling is just one where I was left asking "so what"? It is the kind of thing where if you are expecting more - you are just not smart enough to get it says the rabble in the room. Nope. I got it. It just isn't compelling, interesting, entertaining or insightful in any real way.
I had to keep checking back to see that this book was written by Kelly Link and not Lois Cook. Yikes. To be fair, KL's grammar was fine I suppose. . .
Hey! Here is some Cinderella Fan Fic where the prince doesn't find her and instead develops a foot fetish. He spends his time going around being broken and creepy with a glass slipper in his pocket. I just saved you 30 pages. You are welcome.
On to the next story (every story) written in a stream of consciousness style where the reader is kept at an arms length but I am sure makes perfect sense to the 12 year old girl who was being channeled. I imagine little hearts above every dotted "i" if this were written on paper.
I had to commit to finishing this book because I think it is unfair to review a book that you have not finished. That being said, I LOVE to read. This book made me find other things to do over and over and postpone finishing it. A book that makes me not want to read is a book that I want to tell others not to read either. At least my office is really clean and organized.
October 16, 2022
-La calidez de lo raro, la rareza de lo cálido.-
Género. Relatos.
Lo que nos cuenta. El libro Pasan cosas más extrañas (publicación original: Stranger Things Happen, 2001) es la primera recopilación de relatos, once en concreto, que publicó Kelly Link y que nos permiten conocer las actividades de una joven detective, diferentes relaciones entre personas y zapatos o entre personas y personas, cierta clase de turismo muy particular o, entre otros asuntos, a dos hermanas que juegan a estar muertas.
¿Quiere saber más de este libro, sin spoilers? Visite:
https://librosdeolethros.blogspot.com...
Género. Relatos.
Lo que nos cuenta. El libro Pasan cosas más extrañas (publicación original: Stranger Things Happen, 2001) es la primera recopilación de relatos, once en concreto, que publicó Kelly Link y que nos permiten conocer las actividades de una joven detective, diferentes relaciones entre personas y zapatos o entre personas y personas, cierta clase de turismo muy particular o, entre otros asuntos, a dos hermanas que juegan a estar muertas.
¿Quiere saber más de este libro, sin spoilers? Visite:
https://librosdeolethros.blogspot.com...
August 22, 2014
Carnation, Lily, Lily, Rose
The ghost(?) of a man stuck in a strange limbo tries fruitlessly to remember his wife's name. Through his monologue, a sad story gradually emerges.
Water Off a Black Dog's Back
A young librarian meets an attractive girl as she's returning a book in worse-than-dog-eared condition. A love affair quickly starts - but when she takes him home to meet the family, he's drawn straight into a Southern Gothic nightmare.
The Specialist's Hat
Previously read in Link's 'Pretty Monsters' collection, as well as in 'Crossroads: Tales of the Southern Literary Fantastic" and in a Year's Best collection. This is a well-anthologized story! It's also available free on Link's site: http://www.kellylink.net/fiction/link...
Creepy! Creepy, creepy, creeeeeepy! If you buy, and move into a haunted house, you PROBABLY should check the babysitter's references, and maybe her ID, too, before you leave your young children with her. Better yet, just get the hell out of that house before it's too late.
Flying Lessons
"Going to hell, instructions and advice..."
Fractured and reconstructed, a modern myth that follows a kleptomaniac innkeeper's daughter (well, actually, it's a British bed & breakfast catering to the tourist trade...) Weird connections, and more than a hint of Eurydice...
Travels with the Snow Queen
An adult retelling of Hans Christian Andersen's tale. Here, Link reimagines Gerda and Kay not as innocent children but as two contemporary adults in a dysfunctional relationship. A strong feminist message is the main takeaway, as Link turns the original story on its head.
Vanishing Act
Hildy has always envied her cousin, Jenny Rose, who gets to travel around the world with her missionary parents. But after Jenny Rose is sent to live with them, her feelings change. Jenny Rose is quiet, uncommunicative - the reader can tell, traumatized - but we see things only from the child Hildy's perspective. But Hildy is more perceptive than any of those around her, who gradually seem to stop noticing Jenny Rose at all...
Survivor's Ball, or, The Donner Party
Imagine the weird and unpleasant dream that you might have after watching a TV show about the Donner Party. Your relationship problems, random things from your day, problems with your teeth, and snippets of the TV show are all mixed together into somethings that's half nightmare and half just... interesting.
Shoe and Marriage
Really, this one is four separate short pieces on a similar theme.
The first is a feminist take-off on Cinderella. The second, a dream/nightmare inspired by televised beauty pageants. The third: What if Imelda Marcos (or someone like her) was actually sympathetic, once you understood her background? Fourth: An encounter with a fortune-teller.
Most of My Friends Are Two-Thirds Water
Have you ever noticed that there's a certain type of blonde woman? They all look alike. Maybe they're actually aliens.
Louise's Ghost
One Louise has the strange ghost of a naked man in her house. Her best friend, also Louise, likes to sleep with cellists. Her young daughter is obsessed with the color green.
The Girl Detective
Is the narrator the plucky girl detective? Or is she detecting the girl detective? Nancy Drew meets the Twelve Dancing Princesses, through a weird kaleidoscope.
The ghost(?) of a man stuck in a strange limbo tries fruitlessly to remember his wife's name. Through his monologue, a sad story gradually emerges.
Water Off a Black Dog's Back
A young librarian meets an attractive girl as she's returning a book in worse-than-dog-eared condition. A love affair quickly starts - but when she takes him home to meet the family, he's drawn straight into a Southern Gothic nightmare.
The Specialist's Hat
Previously read in Link's 'Pretty Monsters' collection, as well as in 'Crossroads: Tales of the Southern Literary Fantastic" and in a Year's Best collection. This is a well-anthologized story! It's also available free on Link's site: http://www.kellylink.net/fiction/link...
Creepy! Creepy, creepy, creeeeeepy! If you buy, and move into a haunted house, you PROBABLY should check the babysitter's references, and maybe her ID, too, before you leave your young children with her. Better yet, just get the hell out of that house before it's too late.
Flying Lessons
"Going to hell, instructions and advice..."
Fractured and reconstructed, a modern myth that follows a kleptomaniac innkeeper's daughter (well, actually, it's a British bed & breakfast catering to the tourist trade...) Weird connections, and more than a hint of Eurydice...
Travels with the Snow Queen
An adult retelling of Hans Christian Andersen's tale. Here, Link reimagines Gerda and Kay not as innocent children but as two contemporary adults in a dysfunctional relationship. A strong feminist message is the main takeaway, as Link turns the original story on its head.
Vanishing Act
Hildy has always envied her cousin, Jenny Rose, who gets to travel around the world with her missionary parents. But after Jenny Rose is sent to live with them, her feelings change. Jenny Rose is quiet, uncommunicative - the reader can tell, traumatized - but we see things only from the child Hildy's perspective. But Hildy is more perceptive than any of those around her, who gradually seem to stop noticing Jenny Rose at all...
Survivor's Ball, or, The Donner Party
Imagine the weird and unpleasant dream that you might have after watching a TV show about the Donner Party. Your relationship problems, random things from your day, problems with your teeth, and snippets of the TV show are all mixed together into somethings that's half nightmare and half just... interesting.
Shoe and Marriage
Really, this one is four separate short pieces on a similar theme.
The first is a feminist take-off on Cinderella. The second, a dream/nightmare inspired by televised beauty pageants. The third: What if Imelda Marcos (or someone like her) was actually sympathetic, once you understood her background? Fourth: An encounter with a fortune-teller.
Most of My Friends Are Two-Thirds Water
Have you ever noticed that there's a certain type of blonde woman? They all look alike. Maybe they're actually aliens.
Louise's Ghost
One Louise has the strange ghost of a naked man in her house. Her best friend, also Louise, likes to sleep with cellists. Her young daughter is obsessed with the color green.
The Girl Detective
Is the narrator the plucky girl detective? Or is she detecting the girl detective? Nancy Drew meets the Twelve Dancing Princesses, through a weird kaleidoscope.
Read
March 5, 2016Tuhaf Şeyler Oluyor, Kelly Link’in 2001’de yayımladığı ve geçtiğimiz sene Aylak Kitap tarafından dilimize kazandırılan bir öykü kitabı.
Hikâye üzerine düşünmeyi severim. Bazen çok deneysel öyküler gelir, bazen öyle postmoderndir(?) ki işler neden o şekilde gelişti, hiç anlamam. Alt metinler, üst metinler ve metinlerarasılık çarkları arasında çiğnenirken öyküyü yakalamaya çalışırım.
Bazen öykü hemen oradadır. Uzansanız yetişecek gibisinizdir. Üstü biraz puslu, etrafı biraz dağınık, kimlikler biraz evde kalmış gibidir. Gözlerinizi kısıp dikkatle bakmanız gerekir. Orada olduğunu bir kere sezmişsinizdir. Bir şekilde ona ulaşmayı başarırsanız kesinlikle memnun olacaksınızdır. Odaklanmanız gerekir.
21. yüzyılda birisinden odaklanmasını istemek iddialı bir taleptir. Boşa çıkarsa başınız yanar. Kelly Link ve öyküleri hakkında konuşmak biraz da bu yüzden zor. (Zor olduğundan bahsetmemiştim, ama siz yine de bir türlü konuşmaya giremeyen anlatıcınızın buhranından durumu çarçabuk yakaladınız.)
Kitabı okurken asla yeterince odaklanıp odaklanamadığımdan emin olamadım. Bir şeyleri sürekli kaçırıyor gibiydim. Büyük şeyler oluyordu o öykülerde. Resmin tamamına hakim değil gibiydim ve bu beni rahatsız ediyordu. Okuması değil, okuması kesinlikle müthiş keyifli bir kitaptı. Sadece hakkında birkaç söz edecek olduğumda, “Ben çok sevdim, ama biraz…” deyip duraklamama neden oluyordu.
Ama biraz neydi? Neden emin olamıyordum? Sonra bu yazının başına oturduğumda bir kez daha düşündüm. Kitabın ilk öyküsü “Karanfil, Zambak, Zambak, Gül” bu süreçte bana yardımcı oldu.
Bu kitap belirsizlikler hakkındaydı. İnsan huzurunun en büyük düşmanı, geceleri yastığın soğuk tarafını ararken içimize çöreklenen o illet his, işte somut bir şekilde önümüzdeydi! Hal böyle olunca kitabı okurken bütün resme hakim olamayışım beni susturamadı. Zaten hayatımızın büyük bir kesimi belirsizlik bulamacında kaybolup gidiyordu. Zaten gece yarısı ansızın içimize oturan ve kalkmayı da pek sevmeyen bu his, hayatımızın çok büyük bir parçasıydı.
Öyleyse belirsizliğin pusunu sapına kadar hissettiğimiz bu kitabın bana vermiş olduğu, “Ama…”ları rafa kaldırabilirdim.
Seda Çingay’ın çevirdiği Tuhaf Şeyler Oluyor’u, Özgür Arslan yayına hazırlamış. Çeviri hakkında yorum yapamam fakat, imla adına -özellikle sonlara doğru- biraz fazla hataya şahit olduk, üzücüydü. Bunun dışında, Aylak Kitap’a bu isabetli tercihlerinden ötürü teşekkür etmek isterim.
Damaklarda Karin Tidbeck’in “Zeplin”i tadı bırakacakken son anda çenenize bir yumruk sallayarak dilinizi ısırttıran bir kitap. Çünkü kendi adı ve kendi tadı var.
Odaklanmaktan çekinmeyen, sabırlı okurlar için!
- Onur SELAMET
İncelemenin tamamı için: http://www.kayiprihtim.org/portal/inc...
Hikâye üzerine düşünmeyi severim. Bazen çok deneysel öyküler gelir, bazen öyle postmoderndir(?) ki işler neden o şekilde gelişti, hiç anlamam. Alt metinler, üst metinler ve metinlerarasılık çarkları arasında çiğnenirken öyküyü yakalamaya çalışırım.
Bazen öykü hemen oradadır. Uzansanız yetişecek gibisinizdir. Üstü biraz puslu, etrafı biraz dağınık, kimlikler biraz evde kalmış gibidir. Gözlerinizi kısıp dikkatle bakmanız gerekir. Orada olduğunu bir kere sezmişsinizdir. Bir şekilde ona ulaşmayı başarırsanız kesinlikle memnun olacaksınızdır. Odaklanmanız gerekir.
21. yüzyılda birisinden odaklanmasını istemek iddialı bir taleptir. Boşa çıkarsa başınız yanar. Kelly Link ve öyküleri hakkında konuşmak biraz da bu yüzden zor. (Zor olduğundan bahsetmemiştim, ama siz yine de bir türlü konuşmaya giremeyen anlatıcınızın buhranından durumu çarçabuk yakaladınız.)
Kitabı okurken asla yeterince odaklanıp odaklanamadığımdan emin olamadım. Bir şeyleri sürekli kaçırıyor gibiydim. Büyük şeyler oluyordu o öykülerde. Resmin tamamına hakim değil gibiydim ve bu beni rahatsız ediyordu. Okuması değil, okuması kesinlikle müthiş keyifli bir kitaptı. Sadece hakkında birkaç söz edecek olduğumda, “Ben çok sevdim, ama biraz…” deyip duraklamama neden oluyordu.
Ama biraz neydi? Neden emin olamıyordum? Sonra bu yazının başına oturduğumda bir kez daha düşündüm. Kitabın ilk öyküsü “Karanfil, Zambak, Zambak, Gül” bu süreçte bana yardımcı oldu.
Bu kitap belirsizlikler hakkındaydı. İnsan huzurunun en büyük düşmanı, geceleri yastığın soğuk tarafını ararken içimize çöreklenen o illet his, işte somut bir şekilde önümüzdeydi! Hal böyle olunca kitabı okurken bütün resme hakim olamayışım beni susturamadı. Zaten hayatımızın büyük bir kesimi belirsizlik bulamacında kaybolup gidiyordu. Zaten gece yarısı ansızın içimize oturan ve kalkmayı da pek sevmeyen bu his, hayatımızın çok büyük bir parçasıydı.
Öyleyse belirsizliğin pusunu sapına kadar hissettiğimiz bu kitabın bana vermiş olduğu, “Ama…”ları rafa kaldırabilirdim.
Seda Çingay’ın çevirdiği Tuhaf Şeyler Oluyor’u, Özgür Arslan yayına hazırlamış. Çeviri hakkında yorum yapamam fakat, imla adına -özellikle sonlara doğru- biraz fazla hataya şahit olduk, üzücüydü. Bunun dışında, Aylak Kitap’a bu isabetli tercihlerinden ötürü teşekkür etmek isterim.
Damaklarda Karin Tidbeck’in “Zeplin”i tadı bırakacakken son anda çenenize bir yumruk sallayarak dilinizi ısırttıran bir kitap. Çünkü kendi adı ve kendi tadı var.
Odaklanmaktan çekinmeyen, sabırlı okurlar için!
- Onur SELAMET
İncelemenin tamamı için: http://www.kayiprihtim.org/portal/inc...
September 8, 2019
Valóban különb dolgok gyűjteménye ez. Kicsit még kóvályog a fejem, pedig lassan, hosszan olvastam a kötetet.
Sok novella szól a halálról. Főleg arról szólnak. Meg világok közötti átjárásról, átváltozásról és áttűnésekről, másmilyen létminőségekről, eltűnésről és elvesztésről, személyiséghatárokról vagy éppen határoknélküliségről. Mindez sok esetben meseátiratokba csomagolva – ha valakit vonzanak az ilyen megoldások, ínyencségre lel. Nekem hullámzó volt ezzel a viszonyom.
Nehéz megmondani, melyik volt a legzavarbaejtőbb és a legkényelmetlenebb darab – talán az, amelyiknek mindkét szereplőjét Louise-nak hívták, de még ez sem biztos. Meglátjuk, melyik visszhangzik tovább a fejemben.
Szinte egyiknek sem értettem a végét, ha volt nekik végük egyáltalán és meg kellett volna bármit érteni. Nem is szokott nagyon zavarni az ilyesmi, pont ellenkezőleg, de tagadhatatlanul van ennek egy olyan sajátos effektusa, hogy az ilyen történetek alattomosan a bőrünk alá kúsznak és nem távoznak az utolsó nyomtatott betűkkel. Egyszerre mindig csak egy novellát tudtam elolvasni, aztán szépen meg kellett várnom míg a hétköznapi ingerek kimossák őket a pórusaimból, vagy amíg az elhasznált levegővel lassan kilélegzem őket.
Sok novella szól a halálról. Főleg arról szólnak. Meg világok közötti átjárásról, átváltozásról és áttűnésekről, másmilyen létminőségekről, eltűnésről és elvesztésről, személyiséghatárokról vagy éppen határoknélküliségről. Mindez sok esetben meseátiratokba csomagolva – ha valakit vonzanak az ilyen megoldások, ínyencségre lel. Nekem hullámzó volt ezzel a viszonyom.
Nehéz megmondani, melyik volt a legzavarbaejtőbb és a legkényelmetlenebb darab – talán az, amelyiknek mindkét szereplőjét Louise-nak hívták, de még ez sem biztos. Meglátjuk, melyik visszhangzik tovább a fejemben.
Szinte egyiknek sem értettem a végét, ha volt nekik végük egyáltalán és meg kellett volna bármit érteni. Nem is szokott nagyon zavarni az ilyesmi, pont ellenkezőleg, de tagadhatatlanul van ennek egy olyan sajátos effektusa, hogy az ilyen történetek alattomosan a bőrünk alá kúsznak és nem távoznak az utolsó nyomtatott betűkkel. Egyszerre mindig csak egy novellát tudtam elolvasni, aztán szépen meg kellett várnom míg a hétköznapi ingerek kimossák őket a pórusaimból, vagy amíg az elhasznált levegővel lassan kilélegzem őket.
January 21, 2008
A book of surreal short stories that would vie with Hurakami for the strangest stories I’ve ever read. Unlike Hurakami, however, there is no Kafkaesque feeling of alienation; the odd people in these stories seem generally content with the craziness of their lives. What kind of stories are these? Here’s a list from the back cover: “The girl detective must go to the underworld to solve the case of the tap-dancing bank robbers. A librarian falls in love with a girl whose father collects artificial noses. A dead man posts letters home to his estranged wife. Two women named Louise begin a series of consecutive love affairs with a string of cellists….”
Sometimes, when I read odd stories like these, I get the feeling the author is just trying to be weird in order to be weird. I didn’t feel that way while reading this book. Reading the stories felt like the author was relating them exactly as he’d seen them in a vision or a dream.
I’d have to say that even though I read all the way to the end I’m not sure how much I took away from the book. I didn’t remember any of the details of the book until I looked over the story titles.
Sometimes, when I read odd stories like these, I get the feeling the author is just trying to be weird in order to be weird. I didn’t feel that way while reading this book. Reading the stories felt like the author was relating them exactly as he’d seen them in a vision or a dream.
I’d have to say that even though I read all the way to the end I’m not sure how much I took away from the book. I didn’t remember any of the details of the book until I looked over the story titles.
January 11, 2018
I'm obviously missing something, but Kelly Link stories read like this: " A man was walking on a black beach. A wave bit his finger off. He saw a purple cloud. The end. " Just don't get it. Too absurd for me.
January 6, 2013
Kelly Link is one of those authors that, if she wrote novel length fiction, I think would be held up alongside Neil Gaiman as one of the greatest living writers and inspire similarly devoted and obsessed fans.
But her wheelhouse is the short story, and this is no country for short story writers. Still, she has her own cult following of devoted fans, and their passionate recommendations drove me to picking up this collection.
I liked this collection a lot. There are a few duds, as in most short story collections, but even the duds have something interesting going on. For example, the first story, "Carnation, Lily, Lily, Rose", didn't grab me as others, but I still found her description of a dead man writing letters to his estranged wife, which he puts in a post box that empties into the sea, to be quite evocative.
Reading Link's stories is liberating. They are comfortable in their strangeness. There are no obsessive attempts to "world build" or explain how or why things are happening. They have dream logic: things happen because they are happening, and the goal is to go allow with the narrative and enjoy the sights. The writing is very good. It is dreamy, but tightly controlled. In Lousie's Ghost, which features two protagonists of the same name, Link alternates between clearly differentiating between the two Louises and blurring them together, which mirrors their independent personalities and codependent friendship.
What I really liked about the collection is that while the stories are detached from reality, they are not so light that they float away. They are tethered to the earth with a strange, precise personalness. Link doesn't give you the impression that she is writing weird stuff to be weird, but just because when she opens her mouth to tell a story, it comes out this way. Under all the strangness, there is a realness that resonates with readers. You may not have a frigging clue what is happening in a story, but you still feel pain, sadness, love, joy, fear, etc. An incredible accomplishment on Link's part.
My favorites were the very scary "The Specialist's Hat" & the feminist fairy tale "Travels with the Snow Queen."
But her wheelhouse is the short story, and this is no country for short story writers. Still, she has her own cult following of devoted fans, and their passionate recommendations drove me to picking up this collection.
I liked this collection a lot. There are a few duds, as in most short story collections, but even the duds have something interesting going on. For example, the first story, "Carnation, Lily, Lily, Rose", didn't grab me as others, but I still found her description of a dead man writing letters to his estranged wife, which he puts in a post box that empties into the sea, to be quite evocative.
Reading Link's stories is liberating. They are comfortable in their strangeness. There are no obsessive attempts to "world build" or explain how or why things are happening. They have dream logic: things happen because they are happening, and the goal is to go allow with the narrative and enjoy the sights. The writing is very good. It is dreamy, but tightly controlled. In Lousie's Ghost, which features two protagonists of the same name, Link alternates between clearly differentiating between the two Louises and blurring them together, which mirrors their independent personalities and codependent friendship.
What I really liked about the collection is that while the stories are detached from reality, they are not so light that they float away. They are tethered to the earth with a strange, precise personalness. Link doesn't give you the impression that she is writing weird stuff to be weird, but just because when she opens her mouth to tell a story, it comes out this way. Under all the strangness, there is a realness that resonates with readers. You may not have a frigging clue what is happening in a story, but you still feel pain, sadness, love, joy, fear, etc. An incredible accomplishment on Link's part.
My favorites were the very scary "The Specialist's Hat" & the feminist fairy tale "Travels with the Snow Queen."
August 2, 2011
2.5 stars. I was tempted to give this three stars, because a lot of my reaction wasn't that these stories were bad, just that they weren't for me. But boy, were they not for me.
My first exposure to Kelly Link's writing was through her YA collection Pretty Monsters: Stories. I loved it. "Magic for Beginners" is still one of my all-time favorite stories. So I was excited to read her two adult collections, this and Magic for Beginners. I started with this, her earlier collection, and proceeded to be extremely disappointed.
For the most part, these stories reminded me unpleasantly of my least favorite literature classes in college, the ones where all the pretentious English majors would say things like, "I loved how the diamond motif perfectly reflected the unyielding nature of the protagonist's attitude toward motherhood," and I would be all, "Uhh, I liked the bit with the dog. It was funny and sad at the same time, which is, you know, cool." Which is to say, these stories weren't fun to read. They were work, full of clever symbolism and literary styling, but not entertaining. And most of the time I felt like the stories were going right over my head, which is a pretty depressing reading experience.
There were a few stories I thought were okay, and one, "Vanishing Act," that I really liked a lot, but overall, I'll leave this one to the pretentious English majors.
This collection can be downloaded for free from the publisher's website here.
My first exposure to Kelly Link's writing was through her YA collection Pretty Monsters: Stories. I loved it. "Magic for Beginners" is still one of my all-time favorite stories. So I was excited to read her two adult collections, this and Magic for Beginners. I started with this, her earlier collection, and proceeded to be extremely disappointed.
For the most part, these stories reminded me unpleasantly of my least favorite literature classes in college, the ones where all the pretentious English majors would say things like, "I loved how the diamond motif perfectly reflected the unyielding nature of the protagonist's attitude toward motherhood," and I would be all, "Uhh, I liked the bit with the dog. It was funny and sad at the same time, which is, you know, cool." Which is to say, these stories weren't fun to read. They were work, full of clever symbolism and literary styling, but not entertaining. And most of the time I felt like the stories were going right over my head, which is a pretty depressing reading experience.
There were a few stories I thought were okay, and one, "Vanishing Act," that I really liked a lot, but overall, I'll leave this one to the pretentious English majors.
This collection can be downloaded for free from the publisher's website here.
April 11, 2007
I'm afraid there's a sameness to Link's writing. Grotesquerie, quirky refusal of all resolution. It's a delight for one story (especially when you encounter it somewhere like F&SF, surrounded by the trite and self-serious) but in a collection it quickly becomes annoying.
Favorite stories: "The Specialist's Hat," "The Girl Detective."
Favorite stories: "The Specialist's Hat," "The Girl Detective."
Currently reading
July 24, 2024i began reading this collection of stories in january, as i've been meaning to read kelly link's work for years! she's one of my brother's favorite writers, and i knew i would love her work too. i read the first half slowly, then put it on hold for a few months. now picking the book up again in july, it's time for me to keep track of all the stories here.
✧✧✧
CARNATION LILY LILY ROSE is a strong start to the collection. alternating italic third person narration and epistolary lost love letter is a very effective structure.
WATER OFF A BLACK DOG'S BACK drives home what my brother told me to expect from kelly link. there is deep joy in the telling of the story. the words are heavy with black beauty. there is deep sadness, and little intrigue after little intrigue. all of the misfortunes roll off the main character's back, because her is luckier than his love interest or her family. i love the eerie supernatural vibe from the enormous black dogs.
THE SPECIALIST'S HAT is wonderful because it puts the reader in a ten year old state of mind. a huge old house with eight chimneys, two lonely twins. deliciously dark, biting, spooky, sad. i really enjoyed this because it reminded me of books i read as a child, stories about ten year olds in big looming houses. at this point in the collection, i'm learning to expect things to remain mysterious.
✧✧✧
FLYING LESSONS is a story where the wind always seems to be gusting. there are aunties with a lemony snickety flavor that i adore. the reveals at the end are perplexing.
TRAVELS WITH THE SNOW QUEEN has a hugely pervasive second person POV. i adore the blend of lyrical fairytale imagery, dark gruesome reality, and absurdly sardonic dialogue, all finishing with a big beautiful breakup metaphor. the map can only be followed by slicing your feet open step by step. it is necessarily painful.
VANISHING ACT is delightfully supernatural, acute. it's firmly rooted in 1970s coming of age, and the odd realization that life is full of people leaving.
✧ this is where i took a break from the book for a few months. was i letting the previous stories sink in, or was i letting myself forget their details? ✧
SURVIVOR'S BALL, OR, THE DONNER PARTY consists of a strange journey by car, through a mountain by tunnel, and it consists of an arrival, at an isolated hotel where a raucous party is taking place. link really shines at creating a deep feeling of unease, of wrongness. but this coexists with the tender dreamlike qualities, and like in a dream, unbound by time, the characters have no control over the bizarre situation they're in.
✧✧✧
SHOE AND MARRIAGE challenged me. short stories are a challenging format for me in general, and this one has four vignettes within the story!! "the glass slipper" i wasn't sure about. "miss kansas on judgement day" is my favorite in this set. it's an account of two honeymooners watching a surreal miss america pageant on tv. snarky and strange. "the dictator's wife" is about two old women in a shoe museum, and the story of how they got there with all those dead people's shoes. and finally, "happy ending" is a sweet one, a fortune teller's message to a couple. aside from the finale, all of these lil vignettes feel half told, and i wish they were tied together more tightly.
MOST OF MY FRIENDS ARE TWO-THIRDS WATER caught me by surprise. i think as far as content, this is the most ~normal~ story in the collection so far. the strangeness comes in the telling. the narrator won't quite say that she's quietly in love with her friend jak, who is obsessed with blondes, but who has a theory that blondes are aliens with barbie crotches instead of vaginas. maybe it is strange after all. but it's also strikingly sad, to be in love with someone who is fixated on a whole different category of humans altogether.
LOUISE'S GHOST is a painful little one. it's about two friends named louise and louise, and at first i thought this might be confusing, as the narrative never distinguishes between them. but with time, as i got to know them as separate characters, i grew to be able to identify them by context. kelly link is so fucking clever! anyway. one louise has a naked ghost, and the other louise has a little girl who used to be a dog, who now will only wear and eat things that are green. i love taking oddities at face value, and only later being confronted with deeper meanings - green as the color of the supernatural world. music, smell, textures, eight cellists. the title itself has a double meaning - first it's about one louise's ghost, and then about the other louise's ghost.
THE GIRL DETECTIVE
✧✧✧
CARNATION LILY LILY ROSE is a strong start to the collection. alternating italic third person narration and epistolary lost love letter is a very effective structure.
WATER OFF A BLACK DOG'S BACK drives home what my brother told me to expect from kelly link. there is deep joy in the telling of the story. the words are heavy with black beauty. there is deep sadness, and little intrigue after little intrigue. all of the misfortunes roll off the main character's back, because her is luckier than his love interest or her family. i love the eerie supernatural vibe from the enormous black dogs.
THE SPECIALIST'S HAT is wonderful because it puts the reader in a ten year old state of mind. a huge old house with eight chimneys, two lonely twins. deliciously dark, biting, spooky, sad. i really enjoyed this because it reminded me of books i read as a child, stories about ten year olds in big looming houses. at this point in the collection, i'm learning to expect things to remain mysterious.
Claire's eyes are grey, like a cat's fur, he says, but Samantha's are gray, like the ocean when it has been raining.
✧✧✧
FLYING LESSONS is a story where the wind always seems to be gusting. there are aunties with a lemony snickety flavor that i adore. the reveals at the end are perplexing.
TRAVELS WITH THE SNOW QUEEN has a hugely pervasive second person POV. i adore the blend of lyrical fairytale imagery, dark gruesome reality, and absurdly sardonic dialogue, all finishing with a big beautiful breakup metaphor. the map can only be followed by slicing your feet open step by step. it is necessarily painful.
VANISHING ACT is delightfully supernatural, acute. it's firmly rooted in 1970s coming of age, and the odd realization that life is full of people leaving.
✧ this is where i took a break from the book for a few months. was i letting the previous stories sink in, or was i letting myself forget their details? ✧
SURVIVOR'S BALL, OR, THE DONNER PARTY consists of a strange journey by car, through a mountain by tunnel, and it consists of an arrival, at an isolated hotel where a raucous party is taking place. link really shines at creating a deep feeling of unease, of wrongness. but this coexists with the tender dreamlike qualities, and like in a dream, unbound by time, the characters have no control over the bizarre situation they're in.
What happens when you get to the end of the world? Sometimes you find a party. This party has been going on for a long time. There is music, lights, people drinking and dancing. Strange things happen at these parties. It is the end of the world, after all.
✧✧✧
SHOE AND MARRIAGE challenged me. short stories are a challenging format for me in general, and this one has four vignettes within the story!! "the glass slipper" i wasn't sure about. "miss kansas on judgement day" is my favorite in this set. it's an account of two honeymooners watching a surreal miss america pageant on tv. snarky and strange. "the dictator's wife" is about two old women in a shoe museum, and the story of how they got there with all those dead people's shoes. and finally, "happy ending" is a sweet one, a fortune teller's message to a couple. aside from the finale, all of these lil vignettes feel half told, and i wish they were tied together more tightly.
MOST OF MY FRIENDS ARE TWO-THIRDS WATER caught me by surprise. i think as far as content, this is the most ~normal~ story in the collection so far. the strangeness comes in the telling. the narrator won't quite say that she's quietly in love with her friend jak, who is obsessed with blondes, but who has a theory that blondes are aliens with barbie crotches instead of vaginas. maybe it is strange after all. but it's also strikingly sad, to be in love with someone who is fixated on a whole different category of humans altogether.
LOUISE'S GHOST is a painful little one. it's about two friends named louise and louise, and at first i thought this might be confusing, as the narrative never distinguishes between them. but with time, as i got to know them as separate characters, i grew to be able to identify them by context. kelly link is so fucking clever! anyway. one louise has a naked ghost, and the other louise has a little girl who used to be a dog, who now will only wear and eat things that are green. i love taking oddities at face value, and only later being confronted with deeper meanings - green as the color of the supernatural world. music, smell, textures, eight cellists. the title itself has a double meaning - first it's about one louise's ghost, and then about the other louise's ghost.
THE GIRL DETECTIVE
October 24, 2022
Oct 2010: It may sound strange but I love the twitchy ambiguities of October, and to wit, there are certain— whatever you call them— requirements, traditions— cravings?— I indulge from year to year. As soon as there are cinders and smoke in the air and the nights turn all crisp and inky, I stay up past midnight with the windows open out over the farm and read “Water Off A Black Dog’s Back.”
Like a kid who doesn’t believe in anything, ghost stories are the best.
________________
Sept 2009: If you ever wanted me to read a book, any book, you would promise me this: you would promise fairy tales and cautionary tales, dictators, extraterrestrials, amnesiacs, honeymooners, revenants and ghosts. You would promise to be seriously spooky and smart. You would also promise happy endings, bizarre and sad dreams, and somehow, Nancy Drew.
“Every story contains a secret prize,” promises the dust jacket. “Each story was written especially for you.”
Like a kid who doesn’t believe in anything, ghost stories are the best.
________________
Sept 2009: If you ever wanted me to read a book, any book, you would promise me this: you would promise fairy tales and cautionary tales, dictators, extraterrestrials, amnesiacs, honeymooners, revenants and ghosts. You would promise to be seriously spooky and smart. You would also promise happy endings, bizarre and sad dreams, and somehow, Nancy Drew.
“Every story contains a secret prize,” promises the dust jacket. “Each story was written especially for you.”
March 6, 2014
Jamie Quatro ruined me for ballsy contemporary short fiction, she set the bar with 'I Want To Show You More', and Miranda July is up there too.
I really wanted to love this, but it's just a tad too cute, light and just very detached. Props for mischief, enjoy some sass and comedy - but otherwise, meh. Just not my cup of milo.
I really wanted to love this, but it's just a tad too cute, light and just very detached. Props for mischief, enjoy some sass and comedy - but otherwise, meh. Just not my cup of milo.
June 3, 2016
Unabashedly girly, experimental, tender, genius. It took a few stories for me to get into Link but I think... I think I love her like I love Buffy the Vampire Slayer, and four day old tres leches cake with black coffee, all things sweet and sneaky and spooky.
August 1, 2021
Way to messed up for me. I gave it two stories and no. Just no. If you like messed up, you might enjoy this. Not my cup. 1, maybe when I was younger, stars.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Want to read
December 31, 2015"Stranger Things Happen" is accompanied by "Origin Stories" and is number 331 of 500 signed and numbered copies, signed by Kelly Link.
Table of Contents:
009 - "Carnation, Lily, Lily, Rose"
025 - "Water Off a Black Dog's Back"
047 - "The Specialist's Hat"
061 - "Flying Lessons"
085 - "Travels with the Snow Queen"
103 - "Vanishing Act"
123 - "Survivor's Ball, or, The Donner Party"
141 - "Shoe and Marriage"
161 - "Most of My Friends Are Two-Thirds Water"
173 - "Louise's Ghost
203 - "The Girl Detective"
Origin Stories (bonus volume)
07 - "Origin Story"
35 - "Secret Identity"
Table of Contents:
009 - "Carnation, Lily, Lily, Rose"
025 - "Water Off a Black Dog's Back"
047 - "The Specialist's Hat"
061 - "Flying Lessons"
085 - "Travels with the Snow Queen"
103 - "Vanishing Act"
123 - "Survivor's Ball, or, The Donner Party"
141 - "Shoe and Marriage"
161 - "Most of My Friends Are Two-Thirds Water"
173 - "Louise's Ghost
203 - "The Girl Detective"
Origin Stories (bonus volume)
07 - "Origin Story"
35 - "Secret Identity"
February 21, 2022
Do you enjoy listening to someone telling you the weird dream they had last night in excruciating details? Then this is just the book for you!
Stories about random characters in equally random situations with absolutely no resolution nor any explanation at the end.
Kelly Link writes beautifully and her later Pretty Monster was fantastic but this was such a bore.
Stories about random characters in equally random situations with absolutely no resolution nor any explanation at the end.
Kelly Link writes beautifully and her later Pretty Monster was fantastic but this was such a bore.
March 7, 2017
Sjajno, sjajno, sjajno. Iluzija hvala :D
November 2, 2010
I picked up this book because Amazon told me I would like it. Being that I trust their algorithm more than I trust most of my family members, I did it.
Kelly Link's collection of short stories ran the gamut between being successful and kind of pointless. While the concept is interesting: take folktales, fairy tales, ghost stories, etc. and smush with contemporary narrators or situations. Hijinks and fun imagery ensue.
The stories I found to be the most successful were those that had a more distinctive plot or took a quirky point of view toward death and evil (boy dates half daughter of Zeus who is persecuted by Hera, ghosts that like to live in cellos, girl who cases ex boyfriend to regain him from snow queen, dictators mummified wife talks about her shoes).
The least successful stories worked too hard to hint at some grander mystery or plot convergence but ended up being incoherent or incomplete. Maybe this is because I'm a lazy reader. Maybe because I was exhausted when I read this. Maybe because I don't equate being vague with being insightful.
Ultimately, it's an entertaining read but nothing earth shattering or thought provoking beyond idle curiosity.
Kelly Link's collection of short stories ran the gamut between being successful and kind of pointless. While the concept is interesting: take folktales, fairy tales, ghost stories, etc. and smush with contemporary narrators or situations. Hijinks and fun imagery ensue.
The stories I found to be the most successful were those that had a more distinctive plot or took a quirky point of view toward death and evil (boy dates half daughter of Zeus who is persecuted by Hera, ghosts that like to live in cellos, girl who cases ex boyfriend to regain him from snow queen, dictators mummified wife talks about her shoes).
The least successful stories worked too hard to hint at some grander mystery or plot convergence but ended up being incoherent or incomplete. Maybe this is because I'm a lazy reader. Maybe because I was exhausted when I read this. Maybe because I don't equate being vague with being insightful.
Ultimately, it's an entertaining read but nothing earth shattering or thought provoking beyond idle curiosity.
April 19, 2018
This was unlike anything I've read before. Kelly Link is a genre of her own. The stories collected here are more than mere narratives. They're like curious things found in a bottle. Oddities, deranged and delightful, magical and subversive. All woven skilfully with beautiful, direct prose. Unnerving at times & humorous and quirky at others but always entertaining & unpredictable in their phantasmagoric brilliance.
August 22, 2016
Good, but I loved Get in Trouble much more. Will try Magic for Beginners next to try to recapture that earlier buzz from great and weird stories.
January 26, 2021
Anyone who loves short stories has to pick up this book!! It is by far the most imaginative and witty collection I've ever read. I read this because two of my favorite writers, Carmen Maria Machado and Erin Morgenstern, both had "Stranger Things Happen" on their Strand bookshelves and it exceeded expectations. Enjoy!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 801 reviews