Andrew Smith's Reviews > Reacher Said Nothing Lee Child & The Mak

Reacher Said Nothing Lee Child & The Mak by Andy Martin
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5885760
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: memoirs-biographies, non-fiction, on-writing

Lee Child’s latest Reacher novel is Make Me (Jack Reacher 20). It was released in September and I enjoyed it – maybe not as much as I had some in the series, but I’ve always admired the way these stories flow and I love the idiosyncratic hero. As a long-term fan of the series I’m on it like a dog on a turkey dinner as soon as each new episode is released. So the opportunity to retrospectively observe the author writing the book – of being a fly on the wall - was something I was not going to miss!

Andy Martin is an academic and an author: he lectures in French at Cambridge University and has written a number of books on such heavyweight subjects as the lives and writings of Jean-Paul Sartre and Albert Camus. He too is a long time fan of the Jack Reacher books and so having convinced Child of the merits of recording the metadata of the book’s creation he sets off to New York, where Child is based.

It seems that Child commences the writing of each new book on 1st September, the same date he started writing the first book in the series, Killing Floor. It’s fascinating to see how he lays down a sentence or two and gradually develops the story. At commencement, he has no idea what will happen in the rest of the tale – it will develop organically in the coming days, weeks and months. It’s hard to believe that there’s no starting structure, no sketched out plot, but it seems this is how he always does it.

Like Reacher, the author drinks a lot of coffee (up to twenty or so cups a day) and he smokes a good deal too – something Reacher gave up because he didn’t like carrying things around. There’s quite a bit of banter between author and shadow author, they seem to get on well. There’s also a good deal of discussion between the two on writing craft and grammar. In fact, I was surprised how technical the whole process was and just how much thought and care went into the detailed construction of the text. As an example of the level of discourse, the following is a response supplied by Martin to Child after the latter read out a short sentence he was particularly pleased with:

Nice parataxis, no subordination and the simile, of course. Oh yeah, and the sibilance… it was plain and simple yet it had an onomatopoeic feel to it.

And there’s lots of discussion like this.

Child himself has a phenomenal memory and he seems to store information, mostly trivia, that Reacher may or may not regurgitate at some point. He comes across as an open and charming guy, and the process of writing the book is as surprising and interesting as I hoped it’d be.

Whether you’re a Reacher fan or just interested in the craft of writing, there’s loads here to float your boat. I can’t wait for the next Reacher book and now I have knowledge of its rough path to completion I'm sure I’ll appreciate all the more!
45 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Reacher Said Nothing Lee Child & The Mak.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 12, 2015 – Shelved
December 12, 2015 – Shelved as: to-read
December 22, 2015 – Started Reading
December 22, 2015 – Shelved as: memoirs-biographies
December 23, 2015 –
40.0% "Loving this! It's great fly on the wall stuff. Lots of small bits of detail being picked up. I particularly liked that Child named one of the characters in his latest book after an Aston Villa midfielder. Tells me quite a bit about the man."
December 25, 2015 –
75.0% "I'd no idea so much effort and thought went into the construction of sentences. I had no knowledge of the science of writing. I now know, with certainty, I could never write a book."
December 26, 2015 – Shelved as: non-fiction
December 28, 2015 – Finished Reading
December 26, 2022 – Shelved as: on-writing

Comments Showing 1-11 of 11 (11 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

James Thane Nice review. I really liked this book too; it's a great companion to the series.


Andrew Smith James wrote: "Nice review. I really liked this book too; it's a great companion to the series."

Thanks, James. Yes, I think it's made me appreciate the books even more.


message 3: by Deanna (new)

Deanna Great review, Andrew!


Andrew Smith Deanna wrote: "Great review, Andrew!"

Thanks, Deanna :)


message 5: by Jaidee (new)

Jaidee This is fascinating Andrew.

I have not read any of this series. In a nutshell are you able to tell me the appeal this detective and series has for you? No pressure- I'm curious as all.

Wow that is a lot of coffee. I drink 3L of diet pepsi a day. I have nothing on the author :)


message 6: by Kenneth (new)

Kenneth Iltz Great review. What is your favorite Reacher book?


Andrew Smith Jaidee wrote: "This is fascinating Andrew.

I have not read any of this series. In a nutshell are you able to tell me the appeal this detective and series has for you? No pressure- I'm curious as all.

Wow that i..."


Jaidee, the books are straightforward and linear to read, it doesn't take much effort. They're quick reads too. And Reacher has these habits and traits that recur, so I feel at home very quickly when I pick up one of these books.
The stories are actually cleverly plotted and they keep me guessing - for instance in the latest book it wasn't actually clear what the crime was until very late on, the reader was just working on the principle that people were out to hurt Reacher so something bad must be happening. And there are always some good action scenes too. Reacher takes no prisoners and these sequences are always very well handled.
My preferred daily drink is tea and I probably have a dozen or more cups a day. But not up with Lee Child's intake, either!


Andrew Smith Kenneth wrote: "Great review. What is your favorite Reacher book?"

That's a tough one, Kenneth. I guess Killing Floor because it's the first or maybe One Shot ... or Without Fail. I'm not good at recalling plot lines but these three have stuck with me.


message 9: by Jaidee (new)

Jaidee Andrew wrote: "Jaidee wrote: "This is fascinating Andrew.

I have not read any of this series. In a nutshell are you able to tell me the appeal this detective and series has for you? No pressure- I'm curious as a..."


Thank you so much for the response Andrew. Lee Child has so many devoted fans but I don't know anybody personally that has read this series. I'm glad you love this series. Also, I love my Earl Grey tea but only one in the morning :)


message 10: by Jaline (new) - added it

Jaline I love your review, Andrew! This sounds so fascinating I had to add it! :)


Andrew Smith Jaline wrote: "I love your review, Andrew! This sounds so fascinating I had to add it! :)"

Thanks, Jaline. I really think that this is such an interesting book that's flown under the radar. The exchanges between the author and Lee Child are fascinating and I really enjoyed learning how Child goes about writing his books - it wasn't at all how I expected it was done.


back to top