Lark Benobi's Reviews > The World and All That It Holds
The World and All That It Holds
by
by
Aleksandar Hemon gallops right up to the line dividing "perfect" from "overwritten" but he never steps over it. Every sentence is so lush and so rich. It took some getting used to. It was like falling in love when I didn't want to but in the end I had no choice. It's rococo writing. It's full of filigrees and flourishes. I fell in love with each wavy swirling sentence--the way each sentence always manage to fit in one more perfect clause before the period came along. I read this book in electronic ARC while also listening to the audiobook. I adored the narrator of the audiobook, Aleksandar Mikic--what a talent!--but I also loved reading the words on the page at the same time, so that I had a view of the hills and valleys of the sentences as they came along. I appreciated having both audio and print versions handy, as I read, where they could reflect and refract one another in my brain. This is rich writing. It required a few channels into my thoughts and feelings for me to fully engage with it.
There are so many specific scenes that took my breath away. So many varied moods. One aspect I particularly loved in the novel were the wrenchingly beautiful lovemaking scenes between men--scenes that are full of desire, but also, great gentleness. They were a little gauzy. There was a romantic sheen on the writing that fit the story so well and made me realize how rarely I've read scenes where two men get to be gentle and romantic with one another, vs having a more visceral physical experience on the page...and I thought it was great.
There are so many specific scenes that took my breath away. So many varied moods. One aspect I particularly loved in the novel were the wrenchingly beautiful lovemaking scenes between men--scenes that are full of desire, but also, great gentleness. They were a little gauzy. There was a romantic sheen on the writing that fit the story so well and made me realize how rarely I've read scenes where two men get to be gentle and romantic with one another, vs having a more visceral physical experience on the page...and I thought it was great.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The World and All That It Holds.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
December 21, 2022
–
Started Reading
December 21, 2022
– Shelved
December 24, 2022
– Shelved as:
2022
December 24, 2022
– Shelved as:
2023
December 24, 2022
– Shelved as:
male-identified-authors
December 24, 2022
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-12 of 12 (12 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Jodi
(new)
-
added it
Dec 25, 2022 02:42PM
Lovely review, Lark! Happy Christmas to you!
reply
|
flag
Interesting for me he leapt the fence and fell off on the other side. I agree re your last para and thought the opening WWI parts were strong but felt it completely lost it’s way after that - especially once the British major entered.
Gumble's Yard - Golden Reviewer wrote: "Interesting for me he leapt the fence and fell off on the other side..."
The book it reminded me of most was The Queen of the Night by Alexander Chee. Which I hated at the time I read it, and thought it was completely overdone.
I think maybe one needs to be in exactly the right mood (i.e. ready to indulge the author's many, possibly self-indulgent flourishes) when it comes to reading a lush postmodern-ish novel set in historic times.
The book it reminded me of most was The Queen of the Night by Alexander Chee. Which I hated at the time I read it, and thought it was completely overdone.
I think maybe one needs to be in exactly the right mood (i.e. ready to indulge the author's many, possibly self-indulgent flourishes) when it comes to reading a lush postmodern-ish novel set in historic times.
Jaidee wrote: "O my goodness you sold me times ten ! I am so glad I have a copy and am now shortlisting this."
Did you like The Queen of the Night? Now I'm going to check--
Did you like The Queen of the Night? Now I'm going to check--
Camelia Rose wrote: "Love this review."
It's a frothy dessert of a book! Like eating the entire tiramisu by yourself but I was here for it.
It's a frothy dessert of a book! Like eating the entire tiramisu by yourself but I was here for it.
Lark wrote: "Jaidee wrote: "O my goodness you sold me times ten ! I am so glad I have a copy and am now shortlisting this."
Did you like The Queen of the Night? Now I'm going to check--"
Ok I see you don't have Queen of the Night on your bookshelf, Jaidee. I think I recommend it? I def. need to read it again to be sure but this book did remind me of it
Did you like The Queen of the Night? Now I'm going to check--"
Ok I see you don't have Queen of the Night on your bookshelf, Jaidee. I think I recommend it? I def. need to read it again to be sure but this book did remind me of it
I started and felt it does cross into overwritten territory. I mean "damnable abandon in the tremulous pitch of his now unthudering voice" almost made me not finish it. I'll continue though.... ;-)
Yes I did have those feelings—“just how much of this ornamental flourishing can I take?”—but then I just gave up and decided to think of it as an ornate architectural style, maybe not the way I’d decorate, but valid. Basically I’m trying, when I can, to yield to the way an author wants to tell the story
Lark I feel as though you’re a much kinder reader than I am. I loved the writing but the story felt so choppy to my mind. I do appreciate how thoughtful your review is and how you describe the writing as holly and flowing, that it does.