The 50 Best Supernatural Mystery Shows, Ranked
- 1
Watch This Show If You Love: Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Grimm, The Winchesters, Constantine, Angel
Why Should I Stream? Dive into the thrilling world of Supernatural, a show that effortlessly combines horror, action, and comedy to create a truly addictive television experience. With its loyal fanbase and cult following, this long-running series has become an essential part of pop culture history. Don't miss out on the excitement and embrace the Winchester brothers' supernatural adventures across 15 captivating seasons.Two brothers battle evil forces.- Premiered: September 13, 2005
- Number of Episodes: 329
featured
subscription
paid
- 2
Watch This Show If You Love: Fringe, Twin Peaks, Night Stalker: The Hunt for a Serial Killer, Millennium, Kolchak: The Night Stalker
Why Should I Stream? As one of television's most iconic sci-fi shows, The X-Files offers viewers an immersive universe filled with government conspiracies, unexplained phenomena, and thrilling suspense. With a dynamic duo leading the charge—FBI agents Mulder and Scully—this groundbreaking series expertly blends science fiction, horror, mystery, and drama. It's no wonder The X-Files continues to captivate fans around the globe after nearly three decades.FBI special agents probe cases involving phenomena that defy conventional explanations.- Premiered: September 10, 1993
- Number of Episodes: 253
featured
subscription
paid
- 3
Watch This Show If You Love: Eerie, Indiana, Locke & Key, Dark, Wayward Pines, Tales from the Loop
Why Should I Stream? Stranger Things exploded onto screens in 2016 with its irresistible mix of nostalgia-inducing 80s aesthetics and spine-tingling supernatural thrills. This critically acclaimed Netflix original masterfully pays homage to classic genre films while also offering fresh storytelling that keeps viewers hooked season after season. Dive into Hawkins, Indiana's mysterious happenings for an exhilarating ride through parallel dimensions and teenage friendships.Mysteries unravel in a small Midwestern town involving supernatural forces.- Premiered: July 15, 2016
- Number of Episodes: 34
subscription
- 4
Watch This Show If You Love: Supernatural, Angel, Charmed, Teen Wolf, The Chilling Adventures of Sabrina
Why Should I Stream? Buffy the Vampire Slayer is more than just a teen drama with vampires; it's an influential series that reshaped television in the late 90s and early 2000s. Praised for its strong female characters, witty dialogue, and innovative storytelling techniques, this revolutionary show has transcended time to remain relevant today. Join Buffy Summers as she navigates high school while saving the world from supernatural threats—one stake at a time.Buffy Summers battles evil in the suburbs.- Premiered: March 10, 1997
- Number of Episodes: 148
featured
subscription
paid
- 5
Watch This Show If You Love: Supernatural, Sleepy Hollow, Once Upon a Time, Lost Girl, Warehouse 13
Why Should I Stream? Enter a world where fairy tales collide with modern-day crime-solving in Grimm—a must-watch show for fans of fantasy TV dramas mixed with police procedurals. This innovative take on classic folklore features an impressive ensemble cast and clever storytelling that creatively weaves legendary creatures into a thrilling supernatural universe. With six seasons to explore, Grimm provides viewers with ample opportunity to lose themselves in the show's enchanting lore.Nick, a warrior known as a Grimm, protects Portland from dangerous creatures known as Wesen.- Premiered: October 28, 2011
- Number of Episodes: 128
featured
subscription
free
paid
- 6
Watch This Show If You Love: Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Supernatural, Charmed, Grimm, True Blood
Why Should I Stream? Angel stands as a prime example of how a spin-off can achieve independent success by building upon its predecessor's strong foundation—Buffy the Vampire Slayer—while carving its own distinct path. Created by Joss Whedon, this darker, urban counterpart to Buffy offers rich character development and complex story arcs that delve deep into themes like redemption and self-discovery. Join vampire-turned-private-investigator Angel in his quest for atonement across five enthralling seasons.A vampire with a conscience saves lost souls in Los Angeles.- Premiered: October 5, 1999
- Number of Episodes: 110
featured
subscription
paid
- 7
Watch This Show If You Love: Lucifer, Supernatural, Hellblazer (Animated Series), Grimm, The Dresden Files
Why Should I Stream? Darkness meets wit in Constantine—a gritty yet humorous adaptation of DC Comics' Hellblazer series—that follows occult detective John Constantine as he battles supernatural threats using his vast knowledge of the paranormal and his unique magical abilities. While its run may have been short-lived, Constantine left an indelible mark on viewers with its compelling storytelling, intriguing characters, and memorable performances—particularly from Matt Ryan, who continues to reprise the role in various DC TV projects.A demon hunter and a girl with second sight travel the country fighting evil.- Premiered: October 24, 2014
- Number of Episodes: 14
featured
paid
- 8
Watch This Show If You Love: Supernatural, Angel, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Charmed, Constantine
Why Should I Stream? Get ready for a prequel to the hit series Supernatural with The Winchesters, which delves into the origins of the beloved monster-hunting family. By exploring the lives of John and Mary Winchester, this highly anticipated spin-off brings new depth to its parent show while also offering fresh and compelling storylines for both longtime fans and newcomers alike. Don't miss out on this exciting opportunity to uncover more secrets from the world of Supernatural.The story of how John Winchester met Mary Campbell and put it all on the line to save the world.- Premiered: October 11, 2022
- Number of Episodes: 13
featured
subscription
paid
- 9
Watch This Show If You Love: Constantine, Preacher, The Rook, Good Omens, Supernatural
Why Should I Stream? In Lucifer, viewers are treated to a devilishly entertaining blend of comedy, romance, crime-solving, and supernatural intrigue as they follow the Prince of Darkness himself in his unlikely career transition from Hell's ruler to Los Angeles nightclub owner—and eventually LAPD consultant. This wildly popular show boasts an irresistible mix of charismatic characters, witty banter, and thought-provoking drama that has captured fans' hearts worldwide. Give Lucifer a chance; it might just become your next binge-worthy obsession.The original fallen angel retires to Los Angeles, where he meets an intriguing homicide detective.- Premiered: January 25, 2016
- Number of Episodes: 96
featured
subscription
paid
- 10
Watch This Show If You Love: Fringe, Eureka, Haven, Alphas, The Librarian Series
Why Should I Stream? For those who crave a mix of adventure, humor, and supernatural mystery, look no further than Warehouse 13—a sci-fi show that follows two secret service agents tasked with locating strange artifacts imbued with mysterious powers. With an engaging cast of characters and a treasure trove of historical references to uncover, this fan-favorite series offers endless hours of entertainment for both casual viewers and die-hard fans alike.Two government agents search the country for supernatural objects.- Premiered: July 7, 2009
- Number of Episodes: 67
featured
subscription
free
paid
- 11
Watch This Show If You Love: Ghost Whisperer, Medium, Deadbeat, Paranormal Home Inspectors, A Haunting
Why Should I Stream? SurrealEstate takes the haunted house trope to new heights by exploring paranormal real estate—an unconventional yet highly entertaining concept for anyone who appreciates supernatural television dramas. With an engaging cast led by Tim Rozon (Wynonna Earp) and intriguing stories that blend spookiness with heart, viewers will quickly be drawn into this Syfy original's unique universe where ghostly encounters are just another day at the office.Real estate agent Luke Roman and his team specialize in clearing and closing haunted houses.- Premiered: July 16, 2021
- Number of Episodes: 28
subscription
- 12
Watch This Show If You Love: The Haunting of Hill House, Castle Rock, American Horror Story, Servant, Channel Zero
Why Should I Stream? Critically acclaimed filmmaker Mike Flanagan brings horror fans another chilling masterpiece with Midnight Mass—a Netflix original that expertly blends religious themes into a suspenseful narrative loaded with spine-tingling moments. If you're seeking an intelligent slow-burn thriller that dives deep into questions about faith, fanaticism, and fear—all wrapped up in haunting visuals—then this highly praised limited series should be next on your watch list.A charismatic priest brings miracles, mysteries and religious fervor to a dying town.- Premiered: September 24, 2021
- Number of Episodes: 8
subscription
- 13
Watch This Show If You Love: Warehouse 13, Eureka, Fringe, The Dead Zone, The InBetween
Why Should I Stream? Discover the hidden secrets of Haven—a picturesque Maine town filled with residents harboring supernatural abilities in this engrossing sci-fi drama loosely based on Stephen King's novel The Colorado Kid. As FBI agent Audrey Parker investigates strange occurrences within Haven's borders, she uncovers an intricate web of mysteries that will keep viewers hooked across five seasons of spellbinding storytelling and compelling character development.An FBI agent with a lost past arrives in the small town of Haven to solve the murder of an ex-con.- Premiered: 2010
- Number of Episodes: 78
featured
paid
- 14
Watch This Show If You Love: Preacher, Good Omens, Lost Girl, Sleepy Hollow, Carnival Row
Why Should I Stream? Enter a world where ancient gods walk among mortals in American Gods—an enthralling adaptation of Neil Gaiman's bestselling novel that blends fantasy with social commentary to create a captivating television experience like no other. Widely recognized for its stunning visuals and stellar cast—including Ian McShane as the enigmatic Mr. Wednesday—this ambitious Starz series challenges viewers to reconsider their understanding of mythology while being thoroughly entertained along the way.An ex-convict becomes the bodyguard of a powerful old deity looking to reclaim his lost glory.- Premiered: April 30, 2017
- Number of Episodes: 28
featured
paid
- 15
Watch This Show If You Love: Stranger Things, Gravity Falls, Goosebumps, Are You Afraid of the Dark?, So Weird
Why Should I Stream? Feeling nostalgic? Look no further than Eerie, Indiana—a cult classic TV show from the early 90s that delivers a perfect blend of spooky vibes and adolescent angst wrapped up in quirky humor. Follow young Marshall Teller as he navigates his new hometown—one filled with peculiar inhabitants and bizarre happenings—and uncovers hidden truths lurking beneath its seemingly ordinary facade.Eerie, Indiana is a cult classic series that centers on Marshall Teller, a teenager who moves to the small town of Eerie, which he soon discovers is the epicenter of weird and supernatural occurrences. Alongside his friend Simon, Marshall investigates the strange happenings, from residents who don't age to dogs that form a secret society. The show combines elements of horror, science fiction, and comedy as it explores themes of suburban life and the peculiar underbelly of American culture. Though it had a short run, Eerie, Indiana has since been praised for its creativity and ahead-of-its-time storytelling approach, and gaining a dedicated following.- Premiered: September 15, 1991
- Number of Episodes: 20
featured
free
paid
- 16
Watch This Show If You Love: Dead Like Me, Wonderfalls, Bryan Fuller's Hannibal, Chilling Adventures of Sabrina, Eli Stone
Why Should I Stream? Pushing Daisies is a whimsical dramedy that captivates viewers with its enchanting blend of romance, mystery, and fantastical elements—all wrapped up in vibrant colors and imaginative storytelling by creator Bryan Fuller (Hannibal). The show's quirky charm is undeniable, as it combines a unique premise with fantastic performances—particularly from Lee Pace in the lead role of Ned, a pie maker with the ability to bring the dead back to life (but only for a short time). Don't miss out on this delightful and visually stunning gem that captured both critics' acclaim and fans' hearts during its all-too-brief run.A man learns that he can resurrect people simply by touching them.- Premiered: October 3, 2007
- Number of Episodes: 22
featured
subscription
paid
- 17
Watch This Show If You Love: Stranger Things, The Chronicles of Narnia series, His Dark Materials, The Umbrella Academy, A Series of Unfortunate Events
Why Should I Stream? Based on Joe Hill's critically acclaimed graphic novel series, Locke & Key expertly combines supernatural thrills with family drama to create a hauntingly addictive television experience. This Netflix original transports viewers to the enchanted world of Keyhouse—an ancestral home filled with magical keys that unlock wondrous powers—and delivers a heart-pounding blend of mystery, suspense, and otherworldly enchantment that will leave audiences yearning for more.Following their father's murder, three siblings move into a house filled with reality-bending keys.- Premiered: February 7, 2020
- Number of Episodes: 28
subscription
- 18
Watch This Show If You Love: Supernatural (especially the "Scoobynatural" episode), Gravity Falls, Archie's Weird Mysteries, Buffy the Vampire Slayer (for a more mature audience), Trollhunters: Tales of Arcadia
Why Should I Stream? Fans of the beloved animated franchise can't afford to miss Scooby-Doo! Mystery Incorporated—a series widely regarded as one of its best iterations—which offers a fresh take on familiar characters while preserving what makes Scooby-Doo special: camaraderie, humor, and a love for mystery-solving. With an overarching plotline and darker themes, this updated version will intrigue longtime fans and newcomers alike as they join Scooby and the gang on their latest thrilling adventures.Scooby-Doo! Mystery Incorporated (Cartoon Network, 2010) is an American animated mystery comedy-drama television series and the eleventh incarnation of the Scooby-Doo mystery franchise created by Hanna-Barbera. The series takes a tongue-in-cheek approach to the classic Scooby-Doo formula, with increasingly outlandish technology, skills and scenarios, while also introducing two elements that have never been used in a Scooby-Doo series before: a serial format with an ongoing story arc featuring many dark plot elements that are treated with near-total seriousness, and ongoing relationship drama between the characters.- Premiered: 2010
- 19
Watch This Show If You Love: Twin Peaks, American Horror Story: Freak Show, Boardwalk Empire, Penny Dreadful, Deadwood
Why Should I Stream? Venture into the mysterious world of Carnivàle—a visually stunning HBO series set amidst the backdrop of the Great Depression—which weaves an intricate tale of good versus evil through both human and supernatural perspectives. Despite its limited run, this ambitious show garnered critical acclaim for its meticulously crafted narrative, top-notch performances, and striking visuals—making it a must-watch for anyone seeking an immersive viewing experience rich in history, magic, and intrigue.A carnival travels across the Oklahoma Dust Bowl of the 1930s.- Premiered: September 14, 2003
- Number of Episodes: 24
featured
subscription
paid
- 20
Watch This Show If You Love: Stranger Things, Dark, Channel Zero, Black Mirror, Twin Peaks
Why Should I Stream? Unravel a supernatural mystery in Archive 81—an upcoming Netflix original series inspired by the popular podcast of the same name—which centers around an archivist who discovers cryptic clues while restoring old videotapes related to a missing documentarian's investigation into a dangerous cult. With its rich narrative potential and strong source material—this highly anticipated show promises to captivate fans seeking an immersive viewing experience steeped in suspense and eerie intrigue.An archivist takes a job restoring videotapes and gets pulled into a mystery involving the director.- Premiered: January 14, 2022
- Number of Episodes: 10
subscription
- 21
Watch This Show If You Love: Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Angel, Supernatural, The Secret Circle, Witches of East End
Why Should I Stream? A trailblazer in the realm of female-led supernatural television dramas during its initial run from 1998-2006—the iconic series Charmed has left a lasting impact on pop culture thanks to its focus on powerful sisterhood bonds coupled with spellbinding storylines involving witches fighting against evil forces. Whether enjoying the original or exploring the recent reboot that pays homage while offering fresh perspectives—Charmed remains an essential watch for fans seeking strong female characters navigating love, loss, and magic throughout their lives.Three sisterly witches battle the supernatural.- Premiered: October 7, 1998
- Number of Episodes: 185
featured
subscription
free
paid
- 22
Watch This Show If You Love: Constantine, Supernatural, Grimm, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Angel
Why Should I Stream? Based on Jim Butcher's best-selling urban fantasy book series, The Dresden Files introduces viewers to Harry Dresden—a wizard private investigator who uses his arcane talents to solve Chicago's paranormal mysteries. Although short-lived—with only one season under its belt—this unique adaptation boasts an appealing mix of wit, suspenseful storytelling, and unforgettable characters that will leave you yearning for more adventures with the wise-cracking wizard detective.A wizard and private detective uses his powers to solve crimes.- Premiered: January 21, 2007
- Number of Episodes: 12
featured
free
paid
- 23
Watch This Show If You Love: Grimm, The Legend of Sleepy Hollow (any adaptation), Fringe, Once Upon a Time, American Gods
Why Should I Stream? Witness historical figures come to life in Sleepy Hollow—a genre-bending series that blends American folklore with modern-day crime-solving—as Ichabod Crane teams up with Lieutenant Abbie Mills to protect humanity from malevolent forces threatening their quaint town. With its superb cast chemistry and engaging mix of horror, action, humor, and mystery, this inventive show is an enthralling ride from start to finish.Ichabod Crane is resurrected and transported 250 years into the future to solve a mystery.- Premiered: September 16, 2013
- Number of Episodes: 65
featured
subscription
free
paid
- 24
Watch This Show If You Love: Veronica Mars, Pushing Daisies, Lucifer, Dead Like Me, Santa Clarita Diet
Why Should I Stream? Looking for a fresh take on zombie TV shows? Check out iZombie—a smartly written series that blends horror, comedy, crime procedural elements, and drama into one irresistible package as medical resident-turned-zombie Liv Moore utilizes her newfound ability to access murder victims' memories by consuming their brains in order to solve crimes. With five seasons packed with biting wit and unforgettable characters, iZombie is guaranteed to provide endless hours of binge-worthy entertainment.A newly turned zombie takes a job in a coroner's officer to get access to fresh brains.- Premiered: March 17, 2015
- Number of Episodes: 76
featured
subscription
paid
- 25
Watch This Show If You Love: Teen Wolf, Legacies, The Magicians, Shadowhunters, Chilling Adventures of Sabrina
Why Should I Stream? Dive into a secret society's magical underworld with Netflix's hit series The Order—which follows college student Jack Morton as he navigates his way through a hidden realm of werewolves, dark magic, and ancient conspiracies. With its engaging blend of horror, humor, drama, and fantasy elements, this highly bingeable show will undoubtedly captivate fans of supernatural television with its intricate world-building and dynamic characters.A student pledges a secret order and lands in a war between werewolves and dark magic practitioners.- Premiered: March 7, 2019
- Number of Episodes: 20
subscription
- 26
Watch This Show If You Love: Angel, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Moonlight, True Blood, Blood Ties
Why Should I Stream? Travel back in time with the cult classic Forever Knight—a Canadian TV series that combines elements of crime procedural and vampire lore—to follow Nick Knight, a 13th-century vampire turned police detective seeking redemption for his centuries-long bloodlust. This innovative twist on the traditional vampire tale offers viewers an intriguing exploration of guilt, morality, and humanity wrapped up in gripping episodic stories filled with supernatural intrigue.A vampire works as a detective while trying to find a cure for his curse.- Premiered: May 5, 1992
- Number of Episodes: 70
featured
paid
- 27
Twin Peaks
Kyle MacLachlan, Michael Ontkean, Mädchen AmickWatch This Show If You Love: The X-files, Fargo (TV series), Wayward Pines, Dark, American Gods
Why Should I Stream? Experience David Lynch's groundbreaking masterpiece Twin Peaks—an iconic TV series that defies categorization as it weaves together elements of mystery, horror, surrealism, comedy, and melodrama within its hauntingly beautiful Pacific Northwest setting. With an unforgettable cast featuring Kyle MacLachlan as FBI Agent Dale Cooper—and a cryptic storyline steeped in symbolism and layered meanings—Twin Peaks remains a cultural touchstone nearly three decades after its debut.An FBI agent investigates murders in a Pacific Northwest town.- Premiered: April 8, 1990
- Number of Episodes: 32
featured
subscription
paid
- 28
Watch This Show If You Love: Medium, Charmed, Supernatural, SurrealEstate, Tru Calling
Why Should I Stream? Seeking solace in heartwarming yet spine-tingling tales? Look no further than Ghost Whisperer—a long-running series starring Jennifer Love Hewitt as Melinda Gordon—who has the unique ability to communicate with spirits lingering between life and death. Through captivating episodic stories paired with compelling character arcs across five seasons, viewers can explore themes surrounding grief, redemption, and forgiveness within this eerie yet touching supernatural drama.A young woman communicates with earthbound spirits.- Premiered: September 23, 2005
- Number of Episodes: 109
featured
subscription
free
paid
- 29
Watch This Show If You Love: Manifest, Fringe, Extant, The Whispers, Lost
Why Should I Stream? Experience an intriguing mystery unfold in Emergence—a single-season ABC series that explores themes surrounding family bonds and artificial intelligence against a backdrop of compelling supernatural occurrences. With an engaging ensemble cast led by Allison Tolman (Fargo) as a police chief investigating a mysterious plane crash, this show offers viewers a brief but thrilling escape into the unknown.A police chief takes in a young child she finds near the site of a mysterious accident.- Premiered: September 24, 2019
- Number of Episodes: 13
featured
paid
- 30
Watch This Show If You Love: Grimm, True Blood, Supernatural, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Orphan Black
Why Should I Stream? Supernatural TV aficionados should not miss the opportunity to explore the enthralling world of Lost Girl—a Canadian series that follows Bo, a bisexual succubus who seeks to uncover her origins while maintaining allegiances with both light and dark fae factions. Praised for its compelling character development, engaging storylines, and refreshingly open approach to sexuality—this show offers fans a unique perspective on supernatural beings existing alongside humanity.A succubus feeds on the sexual energy of mortals.- Premiered: September 12, 2010
- Number of Episodes: 78
featured
free
paid
- 31
Watch This Show If You Love: The 4400 (2021 Reboot), Manifest, Fringe, Heroes, Continuum
Why Should I Stream? An intriguing blend of science fiction and supernatural thrills await viewers who delve into 4400—a captivating series that follows the sudden return of 4,400 individuals who mysteriously vanished over the past century. As they attempt to reintegrate into society while grappling with newfound abilities, both personal and global mysteries unfold in this thought-provoking drama that will keep audiences hooked from start to finish.At least 4,400 people who vanished over the past century are returned to Detroit in an instant.- Premiered: October 25, 2021
- Number of Episodes: 13
featured
paid
- 32
Watch This Show If You Love: The Returned (2015), Les Revenants (The Returned - French Version), Glitch, Resurrection, Being Human
Why Should I Stream? Immerse yourself in the chilling tale of Revenant—an upcoming Netflix original series created by Charlaine Harris (True Blood) which centers around Harper Connelly—a woman who can sense the final location of corpses after being struck by lightning—leading her to unravel buried secrets hidden within her small Arkansas town. Though details are scarce at this time—fans can eagerly anticipate another gripping supernatural drama from a master storyteller known for creating richly layered worlds filled with mystery and intrigue.Gu San-Yeong and Yeom Hae-Sang confront a demon about a series of mysterious deaths.- Premiered: June 23, 2023
- Number of Episodes: 9
subscription
- 33
Watch This Show If You Love: Heroes, Umbrella Academy, The Boys, Alphas, Legacies
Why Should I Stream? Embrace your inner antihero with Misfits—an edgy British television series that follows a group of young offenders who develop supernatural powers after being struck by lightning during community service. Praised for its dark humor, unparalleled performances (notably Robert Sheehan as Nathan), and innovative take on the superhero genre—Misfits stands as an unforgettable cult classic that pushes boundaries while delivering gut-busting laughs and thrilling suspense.A group of young offenders are struck by an electrical storm that leaves them with superpowers.- Premiered: November 12, 2009
- Number of Episodes: 37
featured
subscription
free
paid
- 34
The Lost Room
Peter Krause, Julianna Margulies, Kevin PollakWatch This Show If You Love: Locke & Key, Stranger Things, The Twilight Zone (2002), Fringe, The Booth at the End
Why Should I Stream? Explore a world beyond imagination with The Lost Room—a 2006 Syfy miniseries that follows detective Joe Miller as he investigates the mysterious disappearances surrounding a seemingly ordinary motel room key. With its unique premise and engrossing storylines, this underrated gem offers viewers an exhilarating journey filled with unexpected twists and unforgettable characters that will leave them wanting more.A police detective investigates a mysterious motel room.- Premiered: December 11, 2006
- Number of Episodes: 3
free
- 35
Watch This Show If You Love: Stranger Things, Enola Holmes, Penny Dreadful, Shadow and Bone, Miss Sherlock
Why Should I Stream? Embark on a thrilling journey into Victorian London with The Irregulars—a recent Netflix original series that reimagines Arthur Conan Doyle's iconic Sherlock Holmes stories by focusing on a group of street kids who assist Dr. Watson in solving supernatural crimes plaguing their city. With its inventive storytelling approach, diverse cast of characters, and engaging blend of mystery and horror elements—this show provides a fresh take on classic literature that fans won't want to miss.Set against the backdrop of Victorian London, The Irregulars is a thrilling supernatural crime drama that breathes new life into the classic tales of Sherlock Holmes. This gritty series showcases the exploits of a ragtag group of street-smart teenagers, led by the intrepid Bea (Thaddea Graham), as they assist the enigmatic Dr. John Watson (Royce Pierreson) in solving eerie mysteries. The Irregulars skillfully weaves together elements of horror, suspense, and adventure, resulting in a riveting viewing experience. With its complex characters and immersive storytelling, the series offers a brilliantly fresh take on Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's legendary detective stories.- Premiered: March 26, 2021
- Number of Episodes: 8
subscription
- 36
Watch This Show If You Love: Medium, Ghost Whisperer, Haven, Tru Calling, Sensing Murder
Why Should I Stream? Join psychic medium Cassie Bedford in The InBetween—a captivating series that follows her journey to help solve crimes and bring closure to those left behind while grappling with her own personal demons. This short-lived NBC drama offers fans an intriguing mix of crime procedural, supernatural phenomena, and heartfelt storytelling that will leave them longing for more adventures within the show's enigmatic universe.Medium Cassie Bedford helps Seattle police solve grisly crimes while helping the dead find peace.- Premiered: May 29, 2019
- Number of Episodes: 12
paid
- 37
Watch This Show If You Love: Grimm, Sleepy Hollow, Beauty and the Beast (2012), Merlin, Witches of East End
Why Should I Stream? Step into the mythical realm of Storybrooke in Once Upon a Time—a fantastical ABC series that brings beloved fairy tale characters to life in modern-day Maine while interweaving their past and present stories throughout its seven-season run. Praised for its inventive narrative structure, strong performances from its ensemble cast (including Ginnifer Goodwin, Jennifer Morrison, and Lana Parrilla), and enchanting visuals—this show captivates both young and old alike as it explores themes surrounding hope, redemption, love, and the power of storytelling.A bail bond collector must fight for the present-day world, in which fairy-tale characters now live.- Premiered: October 23, 2011
- Number of Episodes: 165
featured
subscription
free
paid
- 38
Watch This Show If You Love: American Gods, Lucifer, Constantine, Deadwood, The Boys
Why Should I Stream? Delve into the darkly humorous world of Preacher—a critically acclaimed AMC series based on the cult-favorite comic book by Garth Ennis and Steve Dillon—which follows Reverend Jesse Custer as he embarks on a quest to find God after being given immense power from a supernatural entity known as "Genesis." Praised for its bold storytelling, captivating visuals, and unforgettable performances (notably Dominic Cooper in the lead role)—this groundbreaking show caters to fans seeking an irreverent blend of supernatural thrills and dark comedy.Jesse Custer, a preacher from West Texas, teams up with his ex-girlfriend and an Irish vagabond.- Premiered: May 22, 2016
- Number of Episodes: 45
featured
subscription
paid
- 39
Watch This Show If You Love: Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Angel, Supernatural, Being Human (UK and US versions), Hemlock Grove
Why Should I Stream? Sink your teeth into the addictive universe of True Blood—a wildly popular HBO series based on Charlaine Harris' Sookie Stackhouse novels—which explores themes surrounding prejudice, love, and power as it follows telepathic waitress Sookie Stackhouse's tumultuous journey within Louisiana's supernatural community filled with vampires, werewolves, shape-shifters, and more. With its engaging storylines, unforgettable characters (including Anna Paquin as Sookie), and sultry Southern Gothic atmosphere—this critically acclaimed show is an essential addition to any supernatural drama enthusiast's watch list.Vampires walk the Earth using synthetic blood.- Premiered: September 7, 2008
- Number of Episodes: 82
featured
subscription
paid
- 40
Watch This Show If You Love: Brickleberry, Big Mouth, F is for Family, Disenchantment, BoJack Horseman
Why Should I Stream? Immerse yourself in paranormal intrigue with Paradise—an upcoming Netflix original series created by Joe Hill (Locke & Key) which centers around Nina Gillingsworth—a woman who inherits her estranged father's vast estate filled with uncanny secrets. While little information is currently available about the show, fans of Hill's previous works and supernatural TV dramas can eagerly anticipate this fresh addition to the genre.When three girls disappear, Javi, Quino, Álvaro, and Zeta discover something from another world.- Premiered: June 5, 2021
- Number of Episodes: 17
subscription
- 41
Watch This Show If You Love: Kolchak: The Night Stalker, Cold Case Files, Unsolved Mysteries (True Crime), Mindhunter, Forensic Files
Why Should I Stream? Dive into the chilling world of Night Stalker—a 2005 ABC series that serves as a reimagining of the classic 1970s TV show Kolchak: The Night Stalker—following investigative reporter Carl Kolchak as he uncovers supernatural mysteries hidden beneath Los Angeles' glitz and glamour. Though short-lived, this modern take on a cult classic offers viewers a thrilling blend of horror, mystery, and intrigue with its captivating episodic storytelling.Reporter Carl Kolchak investigates crimes with a supernatural bent.- Premiered: September 29, 2005
- Number of Episodes: 10
featured
paid
- 42
Watch This Show If You Love: Altered Carbon, Blade Runner series, Westworld, Ghost in the Shell (Anime & Live-Action), Sense8
Why Should I Stream? Plunge into an extraordinary universe with The Envoys—an upcoming Spanish Netflix series centered around two detectives investigating paranormal events while grappling with their own personal demons. As they uncover hidden secrets within Barcelona's underbelly, this highly anticipated show promises to captivate viewers through its combination of thrilling mysteries, supernatural occurrences, and complex character development.Two priests who understand medicine, science, and law investigate supposed miracles.- Premiered: December 11, 2021
- Number of Episodes: 16
featured
paid
- 43
Watch This Show If You Love: Desperate Housewives (with a supernatural twist), True Blood, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Teen Wolf, Lost Girl
Why Should I Stream? Venture into The Gates—a short-lived but engrossing ABC series that delves into the seemingly perfect suburban community hiding a myriad of dark secrets involving its supernatural inhabitants (including vampires, werewolves, witches). Providing viewers with an intriguing blend of family drama intertwined with paranormal elements—this underrated gem is worth checking out for fans seeking fresh perspectives within the supernatural TV genre.The Gates (ABC, 2010) is an American supernatural crime drama television series created by Richard Hatem and Grant Scharbo. A police officer (Frank Grillo) and his family move to a serene, upscale community where vampires, werewolves, witches, and other supernatural entities reside.- Premiered: 2010
- Number of Episodes: 13
- 44
Watch This Show If You Love: Ghost Whisperer, Psychic Investigators, Tru Calling, Cold Case, Sensing Murder
Why Should I Stream? Explore the extraordinary life of psychic medium Allison Dubois in Medium—a long-running drama series inspired by real-life events that follows her journey as she juggles family, career, and her unique ability to communicate with the dead and foresee future events. With six seasons filled with captivating episodic stories and engaging character development (led by Emmy-winning actress Patricia Arquette)—this beloved show offers a powerful blend of supernatural intrigue, heartfelt emotion, and thought-provoking storytelling.A young wife and mother uses her unusual gifts to help solve crimes.- Premiered: January 3, 2005
- Number of Episodes: 132
featured
subscription
free
paid
- 45
Watch This Show If You Love: The X-files, Supernatural, The Exorcist (TV Series), Lucifer, Millennium
Why Should I Stream? Examine the fine line between science and religion with Evil—a CBS series that expertly blends psychological horror, mystery, and character drama as it follows a team consisting of a forensic psychologist, priest-in-training, and skeptical tech expert investigating unexplained phenomena within the Catholic Church. With its thought-provoking approach to tackling themes surrounding faith, doubt, and morality—Evil offers viewers an enthralling television experience meant to be savored rather than binged.A psychologist joins a priest-in-training and a carpenter as they investigate unexplained mysteries.- Premiered: September 26, 2019
- Number of Episodes: 69
featured
subscription
paid
- 46
Watch This Show If You Love: Over the Garden Wall, Adventure Time, Rick and Morty (for a more mature audience), Steven Universe, Star vs. the Forces of Evil
Why Should I Stream? Delight in the animated adventures of Gravity Falls—a critically acclaimed Disney Channel series that follows siblings Dipper and Mabel Pines as they uncover a world of supernatural wonders hidden within their great-uncle's tourist trap in the enigmatic town of Gravity Falls, Oregon. Praised for its clever humor, engaging characters, and intricate mysteries tailored to both kids and adults alike—this charming show is an essential watch for fans seeking family-friendly entertainment with a supernatural twist.The adventures of 12-year old twin brother and sister Dipper and Mabel Pines.- Premiered: June 15, 2012
- Number of Episodes: 42
featured
subscription
free
paid
- 47
Watch This Show If You Love: Heroes, Utopia, Torchwood, The X-Men series (Movies & TV shows), Sense8
Why Should I Stream? Step into a world of espionage and supernatural powers with The Rook—a stylish Starz series based on Daniel O'Malley's best-selling novel—that follows Myfanwy Thomas as she navigates her way through Britain's covert paranormal agency while attempting to uncover who wiped her memory. Though short-lived, this intriguing show boasts a compelling narrative, strong performances from its ensemble cast (including Emma Greenwell), and an intriguing exploration of identity, power, and loyalty.A woman who has amnesia soon finds out she is part of a secret supernatural agency.- Premiered: June 30, 2019
- Number of Episodes: 8
featured
paid
- 48
Watch This Show If You Love: 12 Monkeys, Heroes, Continuum, Colony, Extinct
Why Should I Stream? Prepare for an epic journey filled with supernatural thrills in The Rising—an upcoming television adaptation of acclaimed author Tom Perrotta's novel about ordinary people grappling with extraordinary circumstances following "The Sudden Departure"—a global event that caused millions to mysteriously vanish without a trace. While information is limited regarding this highly anticipated project—viewers can look forward to exploring themes surrounding grief, faith, and the human condition within a captivating narrative that masterfully blends reality with otherworldly elements.When Neve Kelly discovers she has been murdered, she is determined to find her killer.- Premiered: March 11, 2022
- Number of Episodes: 12
featured
paid
- 49
Watch This Show If You Love: Scooby-Doo! Mystery Incorporated, Riverdale, Sabrina the Teenage Witch, Josie and the Pussycats, Beetleborgs
Why Should I Stream? Experience a slice of childhood nostalgia with Archie's Weird Mysteries—an animated series from the early 2000s based on the iconic comic book franchise—which follows Archie Andrews as he uncovers strange happenings within his hometown of Riverdale. Despite its age, this nostalgic gem still entertains with its delightful blend of mystery-solving adventures reminiscent of Scooby-Doo paired with familiar characters beloved by generations.Thrilling adventures await Archie, Jughead and the gang.- Premiered: October 2, 1999
- Number of Episodes: 40
featured
subscription
free
paid
- 50
Watch This Show If You Love: Dark, Twin Peaks, Les Revenants, Top of the Lake, Happy Valley
Why Should I Stream? Embark on a chilling journey into darkness with Moloch—an atmospheric French miniseries which explores themes surrounding fear and isolation as six people become inexplicably engulfed in flames while maintaining consciousness across varying locations throughout France. While details regarding this eerie thriller remain limited—it promises to deliver an unforgettable viewing experience steeped in haunting visuals and suspenseful storytelling for fans craving supernatural chills served up European-style.Moloch (Sundance Now, 2021) is a French crime drama mystery series created by Arnaud Malherbe. Set in an industrial seaside town, a young journalist, and a psychiatrist go to investigate crime scenes where strangers suddenly burst into flames for no reason.- Premiered: 2021
- 51Two teen ghosts work alongside a clairvoyant to solve mysteries for their supernatural clients.
- Premiered: April 25, 2024
- Number of Episodes: 8
subscription
- 52Community tensions come to a head when a mysterious black void arrives in the Abbotts' pasture.
- Premiered: April 15, 2022
- Number of Episodes: 15
featured
- 53A law clerk discovers his ability to communicate with the otherworld.
- Premiered: May 15, 2019
- Number of Episodes: 8
featured
free
- 54Sarah Fenn is a modern-day witch, but when a local teenager dies, murder accusations arise.
- Premiered: January 4, 2024
- Number of Episodes: 7
featured
subscription
paid
