DNH v. Edwards Complaint
DNH v. Edwards Complaint
Defendant.
INTRODUCTION
investigates doctors to ensure they meet the high standards of the profession.
Physicians serving on the Board are required to have been licensed for at least five
years and have resided in Louisiana for no less than six months. There is also one
consumer member that sits on the board. Outside of the bona fide qualifications that
the statute mandates for both Board positions, in appointing members to the Board,
the Governor must consider a factor entirely outside the control of the potential Board
members—their race.
1
Case 5:24-cv-00016 Document 1 Filed 01/04/24 Page 2 of 8 PageID #: 2
physicians as well as members who would qualify for appointment to the consumer
slot but for their race. It brings this lawsuit on behalf of itself and its members to
ensure that every doctor and qualifying public consumer in Louisiana has the equal
right to serve on the Board, and to ensure that the people of Louisiana are regulated
4. This action arises under the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States
Constitution and 42 U.S.C. § 1983. This Court has jurisdiction over these federal
claims under 28 U.S.C. § 1331 (federal question), and § 1343(a)(3) (redress for
U.S.C. § 1391(b)(2) because a substantial part of the events or omissions giving rise
PARTIES
public. Its mission is to protect healthcare from a radical, divisive, and discriminatory
licensed physicians actively engaged in the practice of medicine for at least five years,
2
Case 5:24-cv-00016 Document 1 Filed 01/04/24 Page 3 of 8 PageID #: 3
that have resided in Louisiana for at least six months, and which have not been placed
membership also includes one or more members that are at least eighteen years of
age, have never been convicted of a felony, have resided in Louisiana for more than a
year, have never been licensed by any of the licensing boards identified in La. Stat.
§ 36:259(A), and which do not have and have never had a material financial interest
Board of Medical Examiners and to consider the race of potential appointees when
making those appointments. La. Stat. § 37:1263(B). Governor Edwards is sued in his
official capacity.
FACTUAL ALLEGATIONS
9. The Board’s mission is to protect and improve the health, safety, and
welfare of the citizens of Louisiana, and it is responsible for licensing, regulating, and
disciplining physicians and allied health professionals in a manner that protects “the
3
Case 5:24-cv-00016 Document 1 Filed 01/04/24 Page 4 of 8 PageID #: 4
10. The Board is comprised of ten voting members appointed by the Governor
and subject to Senate approval. Of these ten seats, nine must be filled by physicians
11. All nine physician members of the Board must be residents of Louisiana
for at least six months, licensed and in good standing to engage in the practice of
convicted of a felony, not been placed on probation by the Board, and have had at
least five years of experience in the practice of medicine in Louisiana. La. Stat.
§ 37:1263(C).
12. In addition to these requirements, the nine physicians are also recruited
from varying backgrounds: (a) two must be appointed from a list of names submitted
by the Louisiana State Medical Society, with one of these members practicing in a
parish or municipality with a population of less than twenty thousand people (La.
Stat. § 37:1263(B)(1)); (b) one member appointed from a list of names submitted by
the Louisiana State University Health Sciences Center at New Orleans (La. Stat.
§ 37:1263(B)(2)); (c) one member appointed from a list submitted by the Louisiana
(d) one member appointed from a list of names submitted by Tulane Medical School
(La. Stat. 37:1263(B)(4)); (e) two members appointed from a list submitted by the
Louisiana Medical Association (La. Stat. § 37:1263(B)(5)); (f) one member from a list
4
Case 5:24-cv-00016 Document 1 Filed 01/04/24 Page 5 of 8 PageID #: 5
§ 37:1263(B)(6)); and (g) one member appointed from a list submitted by the
13. The consumer member of the board must be a citizen of the United
States, a resident of Louisiana for at least one year immediately prior to appointment,
have attained the age of majority, have never been licensed by any of the licensing
boards identified in La. Stat. § 36:259(A), not have a spouse that has ever been
licensed by a board identified in La. Stat. § 36:259(A), never been convicted of a felony,
and not have or ever had a material financial interest in the healthcare profession.
14. In 2018, the Louisiana legislature enacted legislation that directed the
Governor to also comply with a racial mandate when making appointments to the
15. Pursuant to this racial mandate, “at least every other member … shall
be a minority appointee” in regard to three of the physician seats as well as the public
statistics, or any other alleged governmental interest that formed the basis for the
Governor Edwards must ensure that “at least” two of the seats with a racial mandate
5
Case 5:24-cv-00016 Document 1 Filed 01/04/24 Page 6 of 8 PageID #: 6
18. Do No Harm has physician and consumer members who are qualified,
willing, and able to be appointed to the Board if the racial mandate is enjoined.
19. The racial mandate prevents these members from equal consideration for
Cause of Action
“[n]o State shall … deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of
22. La. Stat. § 37:1263(B) requires the Governor to consider and make
decisions on the basis of the race of potential board members when making
interest.
24. The racial mandate in La. Stat. § 37:1263(B) does not serve a compelling
governmental interest.
25. The racial mandate in La. Stat. § 37:1263(B) does not remediate any
6
Case 5:24-cv-00016 Document 1 Filed 01/04/24 Page 7 of 8 PageID #: 7
26. Even if the racial mandate in La. Stat. § 37:1263(B) served a compelling
discrimination.
the basis of race, treats all individuals of different races as fungible, mandates racial
quotas, requires racial balancing, has no “good faith exception,” and has no end date.
States Constitution;
7
Case 5:24-cv-00016 Document 1 Filed 01/04/24 Page 8 of 8 PageID #: 8
s/ James Baehr
James S. C. Baehr, La. Bar No. 35431
Local Counsel
BAEHR LAW
609 Metairie Rd, #8162
Metairie, LA 70005
Telephone: (504) 475-8407
Fax: (504) 828-3297
[email protected]