Coney's Cones

The ice cream was super tasty! I suggest going on a not so hot day because as soon as you got outside it was boiling hot and the ice cream melted in 2 seconds. The servers were very nice and did our order very fast, the scoops are hugeee! The shop can be particularly busy because it's so small but it is so worth it going to have this ice cream!

The staff was great and efficient. The atmosphere of the shop was also youthful and bright! The gelato is absolutely tasty, and if you're a fan of nutella, the hazelnut is at the top of my recommendations list.

While walking the boardwalk, we stopped in for some ice cream. You order and pay first and then proceed to the counter with your receipt to get your ice cream. It was a bit confusing because usually I like to see what flavors are offered in order to decide how many scoops I wanted to order.

I ended up getting a Double Scoop ($7.50) plus cone (+$0.50). For flavors, I got the Milano and Coconut. They did let me sample flavors, which was nice. It was busy too, so felt rushed trying to pick my flavor and go.

Nice spot to grab some ice cream to cool down while strolling the boardwalk. I wish they had some more flavors, but decent overall.

Decent gelato and the price was semi affordable. The lines were fast and the staff were diligent with multiple orders. Since I had a small group, just ordered all together gelato regular cones. Then we told the gelato handlers two flavors.
It's a small store with small variety of flavors and other options besides cones and cups. Make sure to grab napkins because it melts fast. The classic coneys cones are always a light option on a hot day on the boardwalk.

It's a good sweet treat when you're craving one on the boardwalk. You have gelato and sorbet and many to choose from. Use to come here a lot when I worked at Coney Island for their iced vanilla lattes and those lattes were absolutely delicious!! Feels good to come back and taste their gelato again. I got the kiddie scoop which is one scoop for about $5 which is on the steep side. I believe 2 scoops is almost $8 but for the amount it's alright not too crazy. It does melt ridiculously fast so for sure eat and enjoy quickly. No seating area so you just pay first place your order and walk and enjoy it. Service was quick no line when I went but I remember before when there would be lines there be hardly no wait either.

Was my affogato a little pricey? Yes, but that's what you have to expect from a popular tourist area. The espresso was good, and the ice cream was great - I got it with Milano cookie ice cream and I have no regrets

Shop set up is a little weird. You pay in advance and then give your receipt to an employee who actually fills your order. I'm used to ice cream shops where they fill your order first and then you pay. Can cause the line to back up if there's a big or slow group of people in front of you, but then again, that's any line. It all works out.

It's a quite nice establishment on the Coney Island boardwalk. Ordering system is kind of old school but totally fine by me. You pay for the scoops first, get a ticket and hand it to another person who will now scoop your flavors. Non-diary options are Strawberry and Mango FYI.

I got the Coney Island Custard, Milano Cookie and Pistachio. I normally avoid Pistachio flavored things because they're usually artifical and super neon green. The one here is more natural looking and it indeed tasted quite nice. Not into the Milano Cookie myself.

Also the gelato melts crazy fast: I know gelato melts faster than ice cream, but my gelato started melting already as soon as I stepped outside the shop. I'll stick with my usual ice cream.

Stopped in on a hot day for a little cold treat! The custard strawberry combo was delicious. It was about $8 for two scoops. They had some fun flavors. The strawberry tasted a little artificial but still tasty.

Stopped here yesterday on our day trip to Coney Island.

A lot of people were working which made the line go extremely fast. For $4.50, I received a kid's scoop of chocolate gelato with chocolate sprinkles. It was extremely pricy for the size I got, but the scoop was more than enough for me.

The gelato was fine but I've ate much creamier gelato in the past. The sprinkles had a weird taste which turned me off.

If you're on the boardwalk and in need of a sweet treat, check out Coney's Cones. Just don't get the chocolate sprinkles!

Yummy ice cream, and prices aren't terrible, but the set up where you order and get a ticket and then have to give it to a scooper is very disorganized and confusing to many. There was a woman who ordered 3 people before me who didnt realize what she had to do and was still waiting to pass off her ticket after I already got my ice cream, so just be aware of the fact that you have to tell someone your order!